NSA Ajit Doval is Ambitious, Very Good at Sniffing Power and Being on the Right Side of it-AS Dulat

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 12. 2022
  • Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
    In an interview to The Wire, former head of the Research & Analysis Wing A.S. Dulat talks about his new memoir, A Life in the Shadows. The book covers Dulat’s interactions with multiple senior leaders and important members of India’s security establishment - including current NSA Ajit Doval. Doval’s ambition and drive, Dulat said, was clear from the very start.
    Join The Wire's CZcams Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews

Komentáře • 932

  • @oscardellarenta8070
    @oscardellarenta8070 Před rokem +232

    One thing Karan, allow the guest to complete what he has to say. Don't lead him to conclude what you wish to hear.
    That's malafide intent not an impartial interview.
    Example: Dulat trying to explain Mrs. Gandhi's graciousness in Goa and him about to relate another incident when you interrupted him to steer it in your way. That's not on.
    Do shut up and let the man speak.
    Unintended gems come out of such
    off the cuff remarks.
    Your friends in Doon did have it right that you interview yourself not an invited guest. Right Mr. Ram Jethmalani, where ever you may be, smirking at this false sense of intellectualism?

    • @amitinindia
      @amitinindia Před rokem +11

      Agree. It looks very evident sometimes and repetitive.

    • @jrelax8236
      @jrelax8236 Před rokem +5

      Absolutely correct...he interviews himself...

    • @sudhanshugupta1392
      @sudhanshugupta1392 Před rokem +8

      Exactly. In in initial part of interview he is just pushing that Ajit Doval is there because he was always on right side. Me Thapar , in order to be ‘there’ in any profession you have to always be on right side. I am sure you would have also sniffed power in you earlier days and thats why you are here.

    • @bannerfilms2786
      @bannerfilms2786 Před rokem +3

      You have rightly spoken. Karan Thapar wish to hear what he wants and intervenes inbetween the person whom he interviews

    • @kuldeeptalan6619
      @kuldeeptalan6619 Před rokem +1

      both karan and sardeep are habitual ...

  • @sunnyypatyou
    @sunnyypatyou Před rokem +70

    It is so plain- Thapar is pushing selected words( ambitious, sucker, turn coat, climber, unscrupulous...) infront of AS Dulat to pick and react. And 60% of time, Dulat adds other, more refined, assessments to those words - that Doval is efficient, gets results done, knows how to handle people....! And these are exactly the kind of qualities any Indian would want in a person who is the NSA or RAW chief.
    Thapar can never grow up. He will always be partial and prejudiced. Just that his partiality and prejudice are covered in shiny little English phrases. Not a good guy to be exalted as India's top interviewer, but that's ok- it shows the poor calibre of those opposing India's right wing push.

    • @neelumahendra4695
      @neelumahendra4695 Před rokem +8

      not so - he is only earning his livelyhood - using his strength in english - but english or hindi - languge only supplies words - not brains - we r free to think whatever we feel right - does not hv to do with reality

    • @NavinKumar-rh6qo
      @NavinKumar-rh6qo Před rokem +10

      In pure interviewing skill Karan Thapar is one of the worst. He has this stupid habit of forcing his takes on those he interviews. He ends up interrupting the flow with his unwanted takes.

    • @sbasu4748
      @sbasu4748 Před rokem

      Kindly watch: czcams.com/video/SkRFt_6SMrA/video.html
      Reality of BJP and Ajit Doval exposed with hard facts and electronic evidence.

    • @vimalrajkappil
      @vimalrajkappil Před rokem +1

      Who's the best journalist in india in your openion

    • @NavinKumar-rh6qo
      @NavinKumar-rh6qo Před rokem +3

      @@vimalrajkappil Priya Sehgal from NewsX Round Table. She is neutral and gets the best out of who she interviews.

  • @search4sprit
    @search4sprit Před rokem +16

    Doval sir is true son of soil his work from northeast to skim to Punjab is speaking today, he deserve Bharat Ratna and he is the first police officer who got kirti chakra which is only given to Army

  • @milindchampanerkar1111
    @milindchampanerkar1111 Před rokem +23

    This must be one of your best interviews, Karan. And Mr Dulat also willing to open up to the maximum extent.

  • @unmuktyatree8200
    @unmuktyatree8200 Před rokem +63

    Karan, has a bad habit of setting words in his guest’s mouth. Mr Daulat handles such attempts like a BOSS

    • @dennisthemenace4288
      @dennisthemenace4288 Před rokem +4

      He isn't setting anything, he is overly curious and has lots of thoughts running around, he try his best to use every bit of given time to extract as much info as possible. Then comes his personal assumption that he has for every scenario that he put as "is that the case" that may appear as he is putting his words but he does it with everyone i have ever seen. It is just how he behaves.

    • @jrelax8236
      @jrelax8236 Před rokem +4

      @@dennisthemenace4288 if he is so curious why he is repeating same things to get it out of guest's mouth..

    • @unmuktyatree8200
      @unmuktyatree8200 Před rokem

      Karan follows a typical criminal lawyer approach of interviewing (exception is his interview of Ravish) which over the decade has become controversial and at times tad disrespectful to guest

    • @arkscrew
      @arkscrew Před rokem

      @@jrelax8236 it is done to get to the crux of the statement. So that we the viewers get to know exactly what the person meant. Other wise he doesn't need to dissect and clarify time and again. He can simply put it in big flashing letters that he said such and such words like zee news 🤣🤣. The idea of "haranguing" an interviewee is to give the viewers as much as he can bring out. And rest, we all have our own brains to think with. He knows it pretty well.

    • @mr.surveillance8110
      @mr.surveillance8110 Před rokem

      ​@@dennisthemenace4288 he do that with everyone
      Watch his w
      All yhe interviews
      He has this nonsense habit

  • @naveenpuskur
    @naveenpuskur Před rokem +83

    He was IPS officer could have earned tons of money and protocol had he continued same but he was great patriot took risk to his life and went to Pakistan undercover.

    • @johnnydoe3603
      @johnnydoe3603 Před rokem +5

      It almost feels like a James Bond Novel.
      I am Sure his Fair Complexion and
      Punjabi Height Helped him blend into
      the Local Population Perfectly. 😊👍🏽

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před rokem

      no wonder he was known as AS(S) Dulat..in the intelligence circles...coz he liked them a lot..wink wink...lol

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Před rokem +4

      ghanta... kuch pata nahi hai tereko .... yeh aadmi compromise tha ....

    • @milindmatang
      @milindmatang Před rokem +2

      @@johnnydoe3603 🤣🤣🤣muppets will believe anything

    • @umeshjuyal5398
      @umeshjuyal5398 Před rokem

      Jinko Patta nhi ye AS Dault tha jo Kashmir Separatists Farooq Abdullah ke sath challa raha tha, Iske tha jo ISI ki wives of London mai Shoping karta tha.

  • @happybelly1204
    @happybelly1204 Před rokem +20

    Please add time stamps to these long interviews so that we can watch it in precise parts.

  • @aakhthuu
    @aakhthuu Před rokem +34

    it is a pleasure to listen to AS Dulat, however his interviews raise more questions than the answers he provides. I need to read his book. 🙏🏾

    • @nikusingh191
      @nikusingh191 Před rokem +4

      Dulat is known double agent.

    • @random.
      @random. Před rokem +5

      This exactly what he wanted

    • @ajayphadke1211
      @ajayphadke1211 Před rokem

      its not known whether AS Dulat has mentioned his Wife's, Families Rep. Shopping Trips in Dubai with ISI Chief in Company ? has got recorded in the book ?

    • @shrihari5011
      @shrihari5011 Před rokem +1

      @@nikusingh191 That was the exact intention borther

    • @shrihari5011
      @shrihari5011 Před rokem +2

      @@ajayphadke1211 Source of this,hearing first time????

  • @ambarishupadhyay921
    @ambarishupadhyay921 Před rokem +55

    Karan trying to fish out something negative on Doval was pretty painful to watch 😂😂😂😂

    • @atrikroy9160
      @atrikroy9160 Před rokem +6

      Just a power hungry individual, close to government this is doval 🤣

    • @johnnydoe3603
      @johnnydoe3603 Před rokem

      @@atrikroy9160 Pay a Journalist to Write
      a Legendary Story about your Exploits
      in foreign lands and Voila. 😊

    • @ambarishupadhyay921
      @ambarishupadhyay921 Před rokem +9

      @@atrikroy9160 I would appreciate some more facts w.r.t the allegations please. Thanks.

    • @dennisthemenace4288
      @dennisthemenace4288 Před rokem

      Ah trying to find out as much what he thinks about doval is trying to find out negative!? Maybe you would love sudhir sudhir chaudhary interview with modi.

    • @jrelax8236
      @jrelax8236 Před rokem +1

      Very true🤣🤣

  • @razorr1920
    @razorr1920 Před rokem +34

    Only Karan Thapar can have the courage and intellect to dig such kind or interview. Great honor for our times.

  • @ksrijith9482
    @ksrijith9482 Před rokem +1

    Loved watching the interview and appreciate the honesty of Mr. Dulat with his responses. Karan Thapar was as usual at his best and unlike his usual self was willing to let go Mr .Dulat so as not to make him uncomfortable.

  • @ramynair
    @ramynair Před rokem +10

    A S Dulat, an intelligence officer who has lot of 'I don't know's' than what he knows. He doesn't know what his subordinate does. Then how can this guy knows anything about the enemy country. And how can a senior intelligence officer contest elections for the Gymkhana Club.Even when he is out of his job. A socialite? Strange. This happens only in India.

  • @shubhajagannathan4782
    @shubhajagannathan4782 Před rokem +5

    Mr Karan... Thapar... your guest was crystal clear ...no ambiguity...

  • @loneranger1265
    @loneranger1265 Před rokem

    Mr. Dulat sir thank you for the most engrossing interview with Karan Thapar dealing on the Kashmir issue as well as what does behind the scenes in the NSA, also have to admit you are a very very sincere and straightforward person

  • @GG09876
    @GG09876 Před rokem +2

    The Wire, MOJO, Likes of these Karan Thapars, Barkha Dutts, Arfa Sherwanis are the BEST example of Godi Media. Been Sitting in Gandhi Families Godi since the start of their Careers.

  • @sananth1315
    @sananth1315 Před rokem +11

    Anyone can make out that, 1. KT always tries to put words into his interviewee to make his own point; 2. he has pre-conceived ideas of steering any interview into what he thinks is the bottom line. Hat's off to Sri Daulat for steering clear of KT's maneuvering and not falling into the trap. The expression on KTs face gives him away. At the end of the day, he has his own agenda to pursue rather than make the interview per-se meaningful for the viewers

  • @aki2785
    @aki2785 Před rokem +1

    I do disagree with so many policies of this government, but admire Ajit ji work a lot, people like him born in centuries, such marvelous spy we have

  • @amitwelde5356
    @amitwelde5356 Před rokem +3

    Half the interview on Doval. Dulat a big man called for an interview just to discuss Doval as if he has not done anything in career. He wrote a whole book and you discussed just Doval. How blind people can get with hate for someone.
    The wire, you fearless channel delete my comment.

  • @sushmatapariya8897
    @sushmatapariya8897 Před rokem +24

    We are great full for people like Ajit ji for there service to this country.

  • @abhaykrishna6724
    @abhaykrishna6724 Před rokem +8

    Mr Ajit Doval is incomparable. He deserves the best credit. He is the greatest asset of our Nation today as NSA

    • @nitin1947
      @nitin1947 Před 11 měsíci

      😂😂😂

    • @Blokes0
      @Blokes0 Před 10 měsíci

      @@nitin1947 what so funny about it bro

    • @Coffee8388
      @Coffee8388 Před 7 měsíci

      ​@@Blokes0Doval is great

    • @Blokes0
      @Blokes0 Před 7 měsíci

      @@Coffee8388 ok

  • @SR0792
    @SR0792 Před 8 měsíci

    Anantnag is just an example of his intelligent mindset..
    He said india intel in kashmir is zero because of art 370 ..he was damn right

  • @advapsingh4834
    @advapsingh4834 Před rokem +1

    This Man has wealth of 1st hand info, a good raconteur, wise, someone need to hear him more patiently. wish another interview with him

  • @sudiptadhar6554
    @sudiptadhar6554 Před rokem +4

    Daulat's own policy failure in Kasmir is monumental and yet he speaks as if he only knows, how to solve the Kashmir problem...

  • @indikhanna
    @indikhanna Před rokem +2

    What a beautifully candid and lovely interview.
    Thank you, both you gentlemen.
    Makes one wonder as to why all those shrill 'debates' in the Indian 'media' can't be conducted in the same civilized manner.

    • @beulahlad3576
      @beulahlad3576 Před rokem

      Very rightly spoken 🙏🏼🇮🇳👍🏼

  • @sundershetty2759
    @sundershetty2759 Před rokem +19

    However Mr Thapar wanted and pressing Mr
    Daulat to picture Mr. Ajit Dival as ambitious and opportunist he simply failed. No doubt your talking to IB guy. You should remember there are many people now days who can read Thapars personal agenda inbetween the lines. Big applause to Mr. Daulat for giving us insight and expanding our views. I will surely be reading your book

    • @johnnydoe3603
      @johnnydoe3603 Před rokem +1

      Doklam Gone
      Galwan Gone
      Pangong Gone
      Bhakt: I can’t Sense Satire 😂

    • @rationaloperator4165
      @rationaloperator4165 Před rokem +1

      @@johnnydoe3603 Genuinely curious, have we lost any land in any of those skirmishes?

    • @asdasdasdqwe123
      @asdasdasdqwe123 Před rokem

      @@rationaloperator4165 he is a porki. As the narrative he is spreading is same in Pakistan.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Před rokem

      @@johnnydoe3603 But we Bhakths vote Modi, BJP.

    • @fieldagent7170
      @fieldagent7170 Před rokem +1

      @@rationaloperator4165 Nope.
      this kid do not even know that Doklam plateau is actually in Bhutan. and since bhutan is our protectorate, we went to protect it when chinese intruded.
      Galwan is a small river, tributary of Shyok. it emerges in aksai chin (lost in 1950s over period of 12 years), and flows into shyok. We control areas west of Y junction or PP-15 and LaC cuts Galwan river at it.
      He is also unaware that Pangong Tso is in both India and China(tibet). and In fact its not Aksai chin, that is legally the international boundary. thr the difference between LaC and International boundary is narrowest at Pangong. about 10 km

  • @drvivekrana15
    @drvivekrana15 Před rokem +18

    Mr Daulat has nothing but admiration and respect for Mr Doval ..

    • @johnnydoe3603
      @johnnydoe3603 Před rokem +2

      Your grasp of English must be Strong 😂

    • @nup_pun
      @nup_pun Před rokem +2

      @@johnnydoe3603 Mr. Daulat himself admits that he admires Mr. Doval at 25:44

    • @dennisthemenace4288
      @dennisthemenace4288 Před rokem

      ​​​@@nup_pun he also said he doesn't like his every bit in the very next line.

    • @nup_pun
      @nup_pun Před rokem

      @@dennisthemenace4288 yes, no human is perfect.

    • @jrelax8236
      @jrelax8236 Před rokem +1

      @@dennisthemenace4288 Nobody can like everybit of anyone...not even who love each other except a mother...be pratical...they had different approaches to get things done...but Doval gave results everytime as Dulat said...

  • @akshattewari
    @akshattewari Před rokem +24

    If Dulat is a Macaulay-putra , then probably Thapar would be happy to be Macaulay's faithful dog, if given a chance... 😂😂😂

  • @kapilmaliwad1470
    @kapilmaliwad1470 Před rokem +12

    Whenever I see Karan sir , my mind clicks - DOSTI BANI RAHE

    • @karansuri1576
      @karansuri1576 Před rokem +2

      Ek prime minister ban gaya aur dusra bs apni khunnas mita ta raha

  • @raghvinderjoshi4667
    @raghvinderjoshi4667 Před rokem +37

    Karan Thapar can be seen to be really working hard in forcing words into Mr Dulat's mouth. Mr Dulat is the same guy who co-authored a book with the top man of ISI, Asad Durrani. What credentials!

    • @johnnydoe3603
      @johnnydoe3603 Před rokem +5

      As Fake Bond is the Patriot even after
      his Son is in Business Dealings with
      a Pakistani Businessman. 😊

    • @jrelax8236
      @jrelax8236 Před rokem +7

      @@johnnydoe3603 Don't you think bond is actually fake😂😂..but Doval is real..😑

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Před rokem

      @prakhar singh Wow!?

    • @sanjeetbachchan809
      @sanjeetbachchan809 Před rokem

      Yes Dulat co-authored but without revealing any secret he discovered secrets from durrani. It is competence.

    • @rksingh4016
      @rksingh4016 Před rokem

      The earlier book with Durrani appeared drab to me. So I was suspicious about this book too which turned out to be unputdownable.

  • @anildubey7764
    @anildubey7764 Před rokem +2

    One casual talk on parking lot was so important to describe a person for his whole career

  • @hasibahmad186
    @hasibahmad186 Před rokem +1

    Really wonderfully engaging .I started to watch it late in the night but could not afford to leave .

  • @nizamyt1234
    @nizamyt1234 Před rokem +3

    What an excellent conversation. We need people like you in journalism

  • @jrelax8236
    @jrelax8236 Před rokem +6

    Thapar concludes that Doval sucked up to his bosses to get power..if that was so he would have "sucked up" to Upa govt so much that he would have got some important position later on...but he didn't...why would he waste 9 years of his life...may be there is something more to him...which probably thapar didn't want to hear and didn't go that way...Dulat complimented Doval..thapar couldn't stand it...

  • @KAULAJAY
    @KAULAJAY Před rokem +1

    We stand by honest media.
    Keep rocking KT👍

  • @pawandhimanpawandhiman90

    Dil Ke Armaan Aansuon Mein Beh Gaye😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪

  • @xrayman001
    @xrayman001 Před rokem +3

    Within a minute of the interview I knew how this is going to go. Sour grapes.

  • @jess-qe5ed
    @jess-qe5ed Před rokem +9

    Doval is best NSA of India.

  • @AliAkbar-rn3zk
    @AliAkbar-rn3zk Před rokem

    Wonderful discussion. Dulat ji's knowledge & assessment are bang on!

  • @charuchandradiwan192
    @charuchandradiwan192 Před rokem

    Great conversation,hope nation will be benefitted.Many such is expected.Really great Mrs Margaret Thatcher and Mrs Indira Gandhi ex P.M. of UK and our great nation were super humans.A heart felt rememberance.Jai Hind.

  • @rishabh19862008
    @rishabh19862008 Před rokem +7

    Whole interview is obsessed with Doval "the legend"

  • @9455033288
    @9455033288 Před rokem +4

    The old man tested Karan Thapar's patience 😂😂 , hillarious seeing Mr. Thapar so much moved 😂😂

  • @chandrapatil2443
    @chandrapatil2443 Před rokem +16

    Modiji and Dovalji made for each other. Both together made for 🇮🇳.

    • @johnnydoe3603
      @johnnydoe3603 Před rokem +3

      No Wonder Chinese Troops still
      Occupy Doklam, Galwan and
      Entire Pangong Noth Bank. 🫤

    • @Anonymous-nt4sz
      @Anonymous-nt4sz Před rokem +1

      Made for each other in the negative for our country. Sad times.

    • @chandrapatil2443
      @chandrapatil2443 Před rokem +2

      @@johnnydoe3603 if you been to those places, please share some photographs otherwise stop your lies.

    • @chandrapatil2443
      @chandrapatil2443 Před rokem +2

      @@Anonymous-nt4sz you need to service your brain then learn to use brain in good way.

    • @Anonymous-nt4sz
      @Anonymous-nt4sz Před rokem

      @@chandrapatil2443
      So do you.

  • @sanjaysanj6688
    @sanjaysanj6688 Před rokem +1

    100% agreed , what an Interview .. 👍🤨👍

  • @KundaSandy2010
    @KundaSandy2010 Před rokem

    Great insights - AS Dulat had worked with many top politicians closely and narrates well too

  • @avalok9851
    @avalok9851 Před rokem +5

    Karan should make a video on how to read a book with a journalist mind and discuss some books we Indians must read

  • @zaffazad4040
    @zaffazad4040 Před rokem +10

    Mr. Thapar, you did a great job as always. I must appreciate Mr. Dulat's honesty and integrity to say things in the manner he managed to say.

  • @lovkhokhar
    @lovkhokhar Před rokem +1

    Mr. Dulat is a great actor, see how beautifully he projects (disguises) his team members as general kashmiri people, and shows concern of this elite coterie as concern of general public, Marvelous!!!
    Then, how beautifully he portrays communist /socialist forces as Bengali and South Indian people and fictionalise their agenda as humanitarian concern for kashmiriat, really beautiful, amazing formulation.

  • @gauravishu1
    @gauravishu1 Před rokem +2

    Phenomenal interview

  • @nuddin61
    @nuddin61 Před rokem +31

    Ah. Interview ended. I can listen to these two finest people all night. A big fan of Mr. Thapar and Mr. Dulat.

    • @pamtam1
      @pamtam1 Před rokem

      @@Adinar2110 😂 Was that Hindustani Musalmaan's Haqeeqat of Akhand Bharat and beyond? 😂🤣😂

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Před rokem +1

      45'-46' election result -------- mmosslim constituency ( bombay province 100% seat goes to m. league, madras province 100% seat goes to m. league, assam 91% , bengal 95%, central province 93% ...so on so on ......) still congress did not do any popul . xchange .......

    • @pamtam1
      @pamtam1 Před rokem

      @@FreddieMurphy746 How could one write so many wrongs in couple of sentences?😂
      So to begin with, what is the Ummah concept in your understanding? What does it mean to be popular or unpopular? How and what made you believe it is popular in the Subcontinent and somehow it is NOT popular in the rest of Muslims (please do elaborate the Mulsims around the world country wise, both in Muslim majority and non majority which is pretty much every country in the World)??
      What is the identity of the subcontinent Muslims? This will be very interesting 😂 What is the identity of the subcontinental Hindus? Based on your question, I am 100% sure you don't know a thing about Islam and Muslims and identity of people. But I believe you at least know what the identity of subcontinental Hindus is, in your understanding. What is this identity of the subcontinental Hindu?
      Based on your understanding of identity, how do you understand the inferiority or superiority concept of identity??? Who and how does one feel superior about one's identity? That can give some explanation about the subcontinental Muslims feeling inferior😂🤣

    • @pamtam1
      @pamtam1 Před rokem

      @@FreddieMurphy746 I can ask tons of more questions but the above should be enough for the time being. Now, there is NOTHING called Turkic Arabs. Turks are different people, Arabs are different people. Arabs too. Turks have hundreds of variations within them (as Turkic people and NOT just Turks) too spread across continents from today's Turkey to central Asia to Russia to the Indian subcontinent. The Arabs too are hundreds of variations from Morocco on the western Africa to entire North Africa, to the Arabian peninsula (Khaleeji) to the Baluchis to the different ones in Palestine and Shaamiyyin (The levantan Arabs from Syria/Lebanon/Jordan etc) Which identity are you talking about??? Since you know so much about the Turks/Arabs😂🤣 may be you know what are these identities that they DONT associate with each other😂🤣😂🤣

    • @pamtam1
      @pamtam1 Před rokem

      @@FreddieMurphy746 Who all are Persians apart from the people of Iran?? Where do they live?? What is the ethnicity of Indonesians???🤣😂🤣Are Malay same as the Indonesians? What about the Javanese and what about the Bali ethnicity?? What about the Singaporean Muslims? What is their ethnicity and identity? What about the Brunei ethnicity? What is their sense of securities vis-a-vis the Subcontinental Muslims ethnicity and identity??🤣😂🤣

  • @lchaimlchaim
    @lchaimlchaim Před rokem +8

    Very likely Professional jealousy!!!
    PS- Professional jealousy is very common among professionals. It can not be equated with enemity.

  • @indianpoliticalsystem1949

    Before 1947 in Kashmir it was Hindu and Muslims was in equal number.
    What is demographic change now and what we are speaking now.

  • @24by265
    @24by265 Před rokem

    I enjoyed the discussion. So many things, I learnt. Thanks Karan and Daulat.

  • @chainrupsharma7375
    @chainrupsharma7375 Před rokem +3

    What a great feast it was to watch this marvellous interview! Thanks to the Wire team.

  • @mincyabraham5233
    @mincyabraham5233 Před rokem +16

    Mr Thapar, I hv been watching all ur interviews. I love the way u conduct and dig out matters from them.
    However, I get a feeling tht u are anti Modi govt and u use your full potential to portray that through your interviewees..
    I have never seen any of your clients out right rejecting Hijab issues or Nupur issues except Governor Arif Khan.
    As an Indian I don’t feel comfortable and also worry about how my children are going to live here if Congress continue their soft stand on issues like Galwan, Tawang and Indo- Pak.
    Current government is atleast trying to make it safe for our future generation.
    So kindly stop pro congress operandi through them.
    Let us focus for INDIA 🇮🇳

    • @jollythomas3328
      @jollythomas3328 Před rokem

      .....Yo, you're barking up the wrong tree; Thapar is the son of that shameless General who lost to China in 1962

    • @haridasshenoy8334
      @haridasshenoy8334 Před rokem +2

      I read more of comments than his interviews.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Před rokem +1

      Found him anti Modi now only? To be accurate anti Hindu, pro muslim ( so even support Jihsdis but demonise RSS), pro Christian (so support conversions also). The wire, the Hindu and Newslaundry etc.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Před rokem

      You are 100% correct, sir. Already a real minority caste people are feeling jumping the country is the best thing. If BJP were to lost in 2024 (not going to happen any way) and Khangress etc grab power Hindus become 3rd class citizens after muslims and Christians. Get assured.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Před rokem

      Sir, this man wants this government go this second like jihadis, and conversion mafia. Now evaluate him.

  • @jatinjgajjar
    @jatinjgajjar Před rokem +1

    It comes that Dulat is envious of achievement’s of Agit Doval and his achivements

  • @rksingh4016
    @rksingh4016 Před rokem

    It was a wonderful interview and more so as I had just finished it yesterday.

  • @Wg.Cdr.Rajinder.Singh1157

    Interview in the shadows.Actually. However, intriguing as always.

  • @rohanaj15
    @rohanaj15 Před rokem +49

    Karan’s modi bias is a bit disappointing. Nothing good will come of trying to make your guest blame the current govt. These statements only serve to create distrust with those India negotiates. Those questions could be framed differently. Allow nuance especially with a spy.

    • @dennisthemenace4288
      @dennisthemenace4288 Před rokem

      What? He even asked how well did the congress did in kashmir issue.
      His questions were very relevant.

    • @urrasscal8380
      @urrasscal8380 Před rokem

      @@dennisthemenace4288 don't trust faar rright and don't trust this lleftist librandu chutiyas ......

    • @ritamalhotra7072
      @ritamalhotra7072 Před rokem +1

      Absolutely right.he does it all the time in almost every interview...sad but true

  • @shashi1274
    @shashi1274 Před rokem +2

    He can gain some popularity quoting name of Ajit Doval
    Fair enough everyone has right to earn

  • @Mohdkhan74484
    @Mohdkhan74484 Před rokem

    Great and very true program, liked by everybody in London.

  • @diva7892
    @diva7892 Před rokem +8

    Dulat sa'ab ..... Always a pleasure to listen to your perspective🙏

  • @rakeshbarman3486
    @rakeshbarman3486 Před rokem +3

    clearly daulat failed in kashmir ,his idea of giving 🥕 infact too much so it felt like appeasment resulted his kashmir policy failure ,thats where doval succeeded he is a man with stick but with adaptability

  • @THEVENGENCEGURU
    @THEVENGENCEGURU Před rokem

    This is simply excellent, thank you both.

  • @srikm2992
    @srikm2992 Před rokem +1

    There is no greater glory than love, nor any greater punishment than jealousy. The jealous are troublesome to others, but a torment to themselves :)

  • @h79guf
    @h79guf Před rokem +2

    Did he suggest his boss to say “Na koi wahan hamari seema mein ghus aaya hai…”. Jun-2020. Some legend he must be.

    • @AkshaySingh-iu5mm
      @AkshaySingh-iu5mm Před rokem +2

      1962 mein ghus toh aya tha sabke naam ka, fir 2020 mein kyon ata koi.

  • @anirbanguha1415
    @anirbanguha1415 Před rokem +7

    Mr Daults remark about empathetic consideration of kashmir issue by people of south india and bengal is a very good observation

    • @abhijitghosh5662
      @abhijitghosh5662 Před rokem +1

      A crude generalised view.... Any opinion poll carried out?

    • @jollythomas3328
      @jollythomas3328 Před rokem +3

      'Kashmiri = Kashmiri muslim' according to Dulat; there are Hindus and Buddhists too!

    • @abhijitghosh5662
      @abhijitghosh5662 Před rokem +2

      @@jollythomas3328 as a matter of fact a bengali made sure we don't need passport or visas to enter kashmir!

  • @vijaypatkar4482
    @vijaypatkar4482 Před rokem +2

    The situation is retrievable provided we have a truth and reconciliation like in South Africa. Nobody hounded,everyone speaks the truth, mass graves etc admitted.

    • @fieldagent7170
      @fieldagent7170 Před rokem

      situation is improving. You are asking for appeasement which was the reason in the first place for all the problems.
      psy ops and propaganda are too high.
      Stakes are too high.
      the truth is that Kashmir is a state of India.

  • @gkm202
    @gkm202 Před rokem +1

    Both Mrs Thatcher and Mrs Indira Gandhi were great leaders, great politicians and great human being.

  • @milindsovani1457
    @milindsovani1457 Před rokem +4

    Full interview is scripted. It's ok for Mr. Thapar saheb but what was pressure on Respected Mr. Daulat Sir.

  • @pmukherjee1237
    @pmukherjee1237 Před rokem +4

    Thanks

  • @staniststan6509
    @staniststan6509 Před rokem

    We are grateful to Mr Modi & company for exposing & showing their "True colours" even for the blindest of the blind.

  • @sentinel9293
    @sentinel9293 Před rokem +1

    Dhoval is the best NSA till date. Two Macaulay putra with British taste are uncomfortable with Indian NSA.

  • @SuryaPrakashBheri
    @SuryaPrakashBheri Před rokem +14

    Absolutely Fantastic. It is for people like Mr. AS Dulat India has survived . India is fortunate to have a son like Mr. AS Dulat. As always deep appreciation and thanks to Mr. Karan Thapar.

    • @sagaryadav1467
      @sagaryadav1467 Před rokem

      Anyone giving intervew to this Anti National Pig Thapar is doubtful to me

    • @tada2508
      @tada2508 Před rokem +6

      India doesn’t need Daulats to survive. It’s precisely because of men like Daulat that Army never had a clear mandate of how strongly to act with stone pellets and other youth espousing militant ideology. Your comments are borne out of simplifications.

    • @ravindrabhangaonkar6497
      @ravindrabhangaonkar6497 Před rokem

      ASD was on special mission to Kashmir. He had good relations with almost all leaders in Kashmir; still it was not as fruitful as it should have been...

    • @himanshubaghel3101
      @himanshubaghel3101 Před rokem +3

      India doesn't need crooks like Daulat to survive. Arti Tickoo exposed him rightly for his Pak fascination.

    • @Dynamic1794
      @Dynamic1794 Před rokem +3

      I don’t like this Dulat guy. You can never ever ever win hearts of Kashmiri Muslims. They are beyond it. Did the stone pelting stopped because of any political agreement?? No, never. I am all for winning hearts but not with these Kashmiri Muslims. Current policy must continue.

  • @cafewaves
    @cafewaves Před rokem +2

    We all do things to further our career...it says nothing about anyone.

  • @praseeshprabhu302
    @praseeshprabhu302 Před rokem +1

    AS Dulat who predicted Pralay in Kashmir if article 370 is removed.
    Advocated cozying up to political families of the valley and talking to the terrorists.
    He a dinausor of the past who should be in the museum.
    I am sure if AS Dulat was NSA during Pathankot, he would have advocated kadi ninda instead of kada danda in Pathankot.
    Ps. After giving warning to be respectful before giving comments Karan Thapar himself uses word sucking up. What hypocrites.
    Dulat and Karan can do their stuff.
    Doval Rocks!!!!!!!

  • @tadepalliprasad
    @tadepalliprasad Před rokem +3

    Ajit Doval is Rasputin of pre revolutionary Russia!

  • @harikc7584
    @harikc7584 Před rokem +9

    The only people who you have interviewed so far are people who are staunch BJP baiters. You have to only mention that. These interviews needs to be balanced and independent of any political interferences.

    • @neelumahendra4695
      @neelumahendra4695 Před rokem

      not so - being neutral in assesment is one thing - but never forget one is working For the Country - if someone puts hurdles in the country ‘s welfare n safety - that someone has to be pointed out - we the people hv stopped listening to such warnings - we r only focused on protecting our netas , instead of the nation -

  • @paramjeetsingh4125
    @paramjeetsingh4125 Před rokem

    Karan tried his best to get his words spoken thru the mouth of Mr Dulat. And as u expect, the directions in the interview duly characterized The Wire. BTW, nice effort.

  • @abhaykher9703
    @abhaykher9703 Před rokem +2

    Karan said there is one chapter in Dulat's book but almost whole interview on this chapter ..

  • @ezekielmalachi587
    @ezekielmalachi587 Před rokem +4

    As an Indian who has lived in Britain for the past 27 years I can confirm Mr Dulat's views on Brits. In India we are too status conscious to mix with lesser mortals or treat them as fellow human beings. Excellent interview.

  • @gurusastropalmistry2214
    @gurusastropalmistry2214 Před rokem +6

    Sour grapes...it is a proof that we have the best person at the helm of affairs in our security / intel establishment.

  • @pratapsinhrajput5879
    @pratapsinhrajput5879 Před rokem

    If one does not sniff the power then how would you implement the vision you hold ? Ambition, ability to acquire power and professionalism- yes , that is exactly what is needed . Ajit Doval is a god’s boon to India

  • @Fjwizn
    @Fjwizn Před rokem +1

    As a wiseman once said “ A friend to ALL is a friend to NONE “ this kind of people are ruthlessly unscrupulous who “ Kiss UP and Kick Down “

  • @jrs4090
    @jrs4090 Před rokem +4

    Dulat was an employee of India but serving the interests of Pakistan. Dulat was one who misled Vajpayee for a good will trip to Pakistan which resulted into stabbing in the back of Vajpayee in the form of Kargil war. Nation never forgave Vajpayee for his going to Pakistan, then involving in Kargil war and more so involving in talks with Parvez Musharaf. Misdeeds of Dulat were very much there in the loss of 2004 elections by Vajpayee.Dulat always played double games between Srinagar and New Delhi.

  • @sudrendranathkt6901
    @sudrendranathkt6901 Před rokem +4

    Please keep it up Karan Thaperji.

  • @RajshekharBanerjee
    @RajshekharBanerjee Před rokem

    1. Doval. Enhances reputation. In one's interest, nothing wrong to be ambitious etc.
    2. Kashmiri. Layers upon layer. History is the reason. Spot on!

  • @abirshee
    @abirshee Před rokem

    Mr Thapar
    Mrs Gandhi once travelled in a helicopter with Pranab Mukherjee, who was a junior congressman then. only one seat was available, they not only shared the seat but also used the same seat belt.

  • @mansoorahmed2338
    @mansoorahmed2338 Před rokem +3

    Great Interview

  • @sg337
    @sg337 Před rokem +4

    Just amazing and honest.
    I really appreciate karan

  • @prafullshinde2759
    @prafullshinde2759 Před rokem

    Sir with your bow you appear like
    Peter Lavel. And loving.

  • @shankarrajgopal5165
    @shankarrajgopal5165 Před rokem +2

    Mr Karan,
    Know this very clear. If you interfere & be abrupt with your guest, most people will NOT watch your show. It's exceedingly irritating to watch your show.

  • @satyajitchanda5864
    @satyajitchanda5864 Před rokem +5

    I remained glued to the entire interview !

    • @sbasu4748
      @sbasu4748 Před rokem

      Kindly watch: czcams.com/video/SkRFt_6SMrA/video.html
      Reality of BJP and Ajit Doval exposed with hard facts and electronic evidence.

    • @prakashramchiary2938
      @prakashramchiary2938 Před rokem +2

      Watch all the interviews n articles, slowly you will notice the biasness.

    • @vishaldora8803
      @vishaldora8803 Před rokem

      @@prakashramchiary2938 , Ohh please Modi bhakts stay away from this channel.

  • @rajibroychudhary2951
    @rajibroychudhary2951 Před rokem +4

    THE WIRE NEWS NETWORK 🙏❤🇮🇳

  • @ruchisharma3504
    @ruchisharma3504 Před rokem

    I am a Dogra, .stayed in Jammu. I fully agree with the analysis o this man. toooo goood

  • @pradeepchauhan7769
    @pradeepchauhan7769 Před rokem +2

    If a MASTER SPY is NOT GOOD at SNIFFING he is of no use.

  • @narkelnaru2710
    @narkelnaru2710 Před rokem +6

    Mr. Thapar's last 2 interviews have been wonderful. With Ravish Kumar and this one with Mr. Dulat.
    Re Mr. Dulat's praise for Mrs. Thatcher, I think it's a question of how Indians behave in power. We are less sure of it, even when we are supposedly secure in it. I'm _guessing_ that Mrs. Thatcher identified much more closely with Mr. Cawthorne than Mrs. Gandhi did with Mr. Dulat (or indeed others).
    It's anecdotal and speculative and "nice to hear" but it's not majorly important.

  • @riser9644
    @riser9644 Před rokem +5

    The first part of the interview is weird, any top bureaucrate can be described the same way

    • @jrelax8236
      @jrelax8236 Před rokem +2

      Any ambitious person that includes thapar himself can be described that way

  • @sureshbajaj6031
    @sureshbajaj6031 Před rokem

    One of the most appropriate effort being made by both the gentlemen to help the people of Kashmir who being battered in this interview.👍

  • @jrelax8236
    @jrelax8236 Před rokem +1

    Dulat in bharat jodo yatra...just cleared the air on his political agenda...

  • @AjitKumar-lo9yu
    @AjitKumar-lo9yu Před rokem +21

    Wow wire is so relentless in its pursuit to defame and discredit the Modi Govt.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Před rokem +1

      They do until Modi and BJP government go. Want it happens this second.

    • @rudrankpatel379
      @rudrankpatel379 Před rokem

      to 1953 aur nehru kyon hain iss discussion me chutiye, aur 1988 aur congress kyon hai