When you said you would give Jesse all your cheesecake I smiled a lot, this is the content I need in my life! my underrated ghost boy deserves respect!
omg the tavvy slander i could NEVER!! dont you remember the scene when he remembers the story about anabel blackthorn in his children's book that was so so adorable aww (but i get that he was also annoying in some other scenes!)
I think I would pick Julian as my favorite Blackthorn, even though many people didn't like him, to me he was very interesting to read. After Chain of Iron it may be Jesse though! I adore him. Love theses shadowhunters videos!!!
NOT the Livvy Blackthorn slander- I- she and Jules (and Dru) were my favourite characters in the series! Also... You: *takes Annabel Blacthorn out for lunch just to... talk* Annabel: *is served her food* why have I not got a fork? You: *steals (and eats) her cheesecake and reveals the fork you hid* hmmm, maybe it’s because you’re a
This was just *so* perfect!! I hate Mondays, and in my time zone your videos always come on Monday mornings, and my day just gets a whole lot better! I don't see many other BookTube channels who make videos like yours, and the little twist you put on your tags makes it a whole lot more interesting!! Also, about Grace-I went into the ChoG thinking I'd like her-maybe?-and then when we got to know about the Gracelet, I realised that the majority of Cassie Clare characters have more backstory, and moreover some sort of reason for doing what they do... Barely two days for ChoI and I can*not* be more hyped!!
Omg that’s the cutest thing ever I’m so happy they make your Monday mornings 🥺 yes I’m fully preparing Grace to surprise me in Chain of Iron, we’ll find out soon enough!
I feel like people are a bit excessive with their hatred of Grace and refusal of even considering a redemption arc for her 💀 like she's done some bad things but considering the trauma and abuse of being raised by Tatiana and being so isolated....it'd make anybody have a lack of better judgement. also there are many characters in tsc specifically tlh that are also Not Great (*cough* Matthew *cough*) and yet they get excused... 🤔 excuse my rant lol!! and just a disclaimer, I dont hate Matthew I just think his treatment of Alastair and anybody outside of his circle is ....tedious. 😅 ANYWAYS I loooooved this video! we agreed a bunch on the blackthorns, a family I dont have many favorites in (besides Mark, Jesse, Helen, Grace)
I totally agree about Grace! People were quick to shut her down when I think she’s an incredibly complex character. I’m not defending her actions but there is definitely reason behind them (growing up with Tatiana etc!)
My favorite Blackthorns; Jesse, Dru, Helen, Ty and Arthur. What familiar relationships would you have wanted to learn more about/interact more in the books? For me it’s Jace and Robert’s relationship and Aline and Patrick’s relationship.
Omg Jace and Robert’s relationship for sure!!! That would have been very interesting? Especially since it always seemed they were closer than Alec and Robert were... it would be interesting to see their dynamic, alas he’s dead now 😭😭😭
I am late to this, but as I literally finished Lord of Shadows I cannot accept that Livvy slander. Poor girl just died she deserves that piece of cake.
THANK YOU this is exactly we all need right now (and Mark’s gnome quote is top tier in itself). And I agree completely about Grace! I think there are a lot of things we don’t yet know about her. I always felt like I was the only one who didn’t hate her 😅
I agree with every ranking except for Julian, Dru and Tavvy. Julian, for me, would be higher. Dru and Tavvy too. But other than that, I feel the exact same thing about Grace as you do. I feel like she platonically cares about James, and wish that we get to know about her more in CoI
I would love it if u tier rank my shadowhunter family aka The Herondales. Preferably on a scale related to ducks😂 cannot wait for ur next videos omgggg
We all know Julian would share his entire cheesecake with his family. My man honestly desireves the entire world at this point. Been through some much.
The blackthorn family is my favorite shadowhunter family. I disagree with the list personally but I see your points and respect your opinion. Love your content though
@@MyYAFictionAddiction ok I’m done with chain of iron, so now Jesse is definitely top tier for me along with Ty, Julian and Dru. I like Mark but he’s not really my favorite. I especially loved him in lady midnight with his whole arc of coming back to his family but then he kinda sorta lost me. Livvy, Helen and Tavvy are fine but they are barely developed enough for me to judge them that much. I’ll say Livvy and tavvy are “I would offer them a slice” while Helen “I would let them eat the whole cheesecake”. Grace after reading chain of iron is definitely also in that category. The rest are just “I would not offer them a slice”. Wait TATIANA IS DEFINITELY BOTTOM TIER ALONG WITH ANABELLE.
Honestly I think I would put everyone of them on the top, I adore every single one of them (even Annabelle I felt sorry for her) Also Grace is the best character in every book ever
ok so it's not confirmed yet (even though cassandra has implicitly confirmed that lucie does marry jesse in tmi or tda) where would you put lucie as a possible blackthorn?👀
For Lucie, I would make her her own tier above Mark in the top: “I love them so much I would not only let them eat me instead, but I would come back from the afterlife just to bake her her own cheesecake as well”
@@MyYAFictionAddiction AHAHAHA YES I DID I AGREE WITH U ON MOST THINGS AND YS MY SURNAME IS BLACTHORN IN THIS COS I TOOK an ASSASIN name quiz and my name was asha blackthorn lmao
When you said you would give Jesse all your cheesecake I smiled a lot, this is the content I need in my life! my underrated ghost boy deserves respect!
Justice for Jesse xx
I agree!!
You’re so funny.
“Every time livvy was there I just wanted her to leave so Kit and Ty could talk.” Mood
Tell me you didn’t think it too!
And then she left at the end of LoS 😔
I'm honestly living for all of your Shadowhunter content. So hyped for Chain of Iron in a couple days!!
HELP ME I AM NOT PREPARED
I don't like Grace as a person, but I adore her as a villain, if that makes sense.
It makes TOTAL sense, don’t worry!
omg the tavvy slander i could NEVER!! dont you remember the scene when he remembers the story about anabel blackthorn in his children's book that was so so adorable aww (but i get that he was also annoying in some other scenes!)
Lmaoooo IM SORRY 💀 you’re right that was a hella cute scene and he was cute then BUT IN THE OTHER SCENES I WAS SO ANNOYED
Mark is also my favorite Blackthorn. Every single thing that he’s ever said or done is so iconic & funny!!!
Yes 100%!!!
I think I would pick Julian as my favorite Blackthorn, even though many people didn't like him, to me he was very interesting to read. After Chain of Iron it may be Jesse though! I adore him. Love theses shadowhunters videos!!!
Why do I feel like Jesse is gonna be everyone’s favourite Blackthorn after COI?? Honestly an underrated KING
My favorite is probably Mark
@@robertoleary5470 100%
Mark would want a cheesecake with strawberries!
WHY IS THIS ACCURATE
Ooh I'm so excited for the Herondale rankings - my favorite family
Maybe I'll use a different ranking system for them lmaooo
@@MyYAFictionAddiction might I suggest ‘how likely I would be to feed them to the ducks’
@@abbyhorton758 absolutely iconic idea
Same
YASSS Mark ❤️ His relationship with Kieran and Cristina gives me life!
KIEARKTINA FOR LIFE
mark getting the recognition he absolutely deserves 🥰🥰
My KING
julian is obviously the best character in all of shadowhunter chronicles
He is but I just think Mark is so funny he deserves that top spot 💀
@@MyYAFictionAddiction but i feel julian has gone through so much more i can't even imagine raising four kids at just 12
@@moonchildslay Mark was literally a pow who as tourhured for five years while being abandoned by his government.
“I’m not a regular booktuber, I’m a cool booktuber” one can only hope to be as cool as Tilly is 😩
Just call me Regina George x
NOT the Livvy Blackthorn slander- I- she and Jules (and Dru) were my favourite characters in the series! Also...
You: *takes Annabel Blacthorn out for lunch just to... talk*
Annabel: *is served her food* why have I not got a fork?
You: *steals (and eats) her cheesecake and reveals the fork you hid* hmmm, maybe it’s because you’re a
Hahaha IM SORRY I JUST DIDNT CONNECT TO LIVVY LIKE THE OTHERS!! And omg that’s absolutely iconic
@@MyYAFictionAddiction haha thank uuuu :)
This was just *so* perfect!! I hate Mondays, and in my time zone your videos always come on Monday mornings, and my day just gets a whole lot better! I don't see many other BookTube channels who make videos like yours, and the little twist you put on your tags makes it a whole lot more interesting!!
Also, about Grace-I went into the ChoG thinking I'd like her-maybe?-and then when we got to know about the Gracelet, I realised that the majority of Cassie Clare characters have more backstory, and moreover some sort of reason for doing what they do... Barely two days for ChoI and I can*not* be more hyped!!
Omg that’s the cutest thing ever I’m so happy they make your Monday mornings 🥺 yes I’m fully preparing Grace to surprise me in Chain of Iron, we’ll find out soon enough!
I feel like people are a bit excessive with their hatred of Grace and refusal of even considering a redemption arc for her 💀 like she's done some bad things but considering the trauma and abuse of being raised by Tatiana and being so isolated....it'd make anybody have a lack of better judgement. also there are many characters in tsc specifically tlh that are also Not Great (*cough* Matthew *cough*) and yet they get excused... 🤔 excuse my rant lol!! and just a disclaimer, I dont hate Matthew I just think his treatment of Alastair and anybody outside of his circle is ....tedious. 😅 ANYWAYS I loooooved this video! we agreed a bunch on the blackthorns, a family I dont have many favorites in (besides Mark, Jesse, Helen, Grace)
I totally agree about Grace! People were quick to shut her down when I think she’s an incredibly complex character. I’m not defending her actions but there is definitely reason behind them (growing up with Tatiana etc!)
My favorite Blackthorns; Jesse, Dru, Helen, Ty and Arthur.
What familiar relationships would you have wanted to learn more about/interact more in the books? For me it’s Jace and Robert’s relationship and Aline and Patrick’s relationship.
Omg Jace and Robert’s relationship for sure!!! That would have been very interesting? Especially since it always seemed they were closer than Alec and Robert were... it would be interesting to see their dynamic, alas he’s dead now 😭😭😭
I am late to this, but as I literally finished Lord of Shadows I cannot accept that Livvy slander. Poor girl just died she deserves that piece of cake.
My favorite blackthorn will always be Jesse
Underrated kings and queens xx
THANK YOU this is exactly we all need right now (and Mark’s gnome quote is top tier in itself). And I agree completely about Grace! I think there are a lot of things we don’t yet know about her. I always felt like I was the only one who didn’t hate her 😅
Mark’s gnome quote was better than the book itself change my mind x
I think you should rank the lightwoods next ❤️❤️
I agree with every ranking except for Julian, Dru and Tavvy. Julian, for me, would be higher. Dru and Tavvy too. But other than that, I feel the exact same thing about Grace as you do. I feel like she platonically cares about James, and wish that we get to know about her more in CoI
Honestly I’m excited for more Grace in COI? I know no one else else but I am!
So close to 1k!!! I'm excited!!!!
Ahhhh I love that you’re looking out for me it means so much 🥺🥺 BUT I CANT BELIEVE IT EITHER
I'm in love with your tiers, they are way too relatable😂
Honestly why did I choose cheesecake omg I’m a mess
Absolutely LOVE this idea!
Don’t worry I have an idea 🔥
Ooo! I have the same thoughts about Grace and Livvy! Sis I love your Shadowhunters content!! Also, can't wait for Herondales 💙
I shall get thinking about a Herondale worthy tier ❤️
I cannot put into words how much I loved this video
THANK YOU
so proud of how well your channel is doing tillz
RIGHT BACK AT YOU
I'm gonna be honest, this is the best ranking system I've ever seen!
Cheesecake is the only way to rank characters really
MARK AND JESSE ARE THE BEST BLACKTHORNS. I had to say it.
JUSTICE FOR MY CHILD MARK
I adore this!!! You should do the Carstairs fam next!!!!
Omg YES
I would love it if u tier rank my shadowhunter family aka The Herondales. Preferably on a scale related to ducks😂 cannot wait for ur next videos omgggg
I most certainly can!
@@MyYAFictionAddiction 😢😍
This is such a cool concept!
Thank you 🥺
damn cheesecake is hella specific.... great video tho:)
If it were socially acceptable I would eat cheesecake for starter main AND dessert
@@MyYAFictionAddiction 😀😊😂🤣
This is sooo cute
Cheesecake and Blackthorns! What more could you want?😍
Now that you've read chain of iron, would you still put grace and Jesse in the the same tiers?
Mark is the best 💖💖💖
I weirdly agree with your opinion on Tavvy.
I love Cassandra Clare but she's really bad at writing children 😐
I'm honestly like If you're a Blackthorn I love you
I totally get that
I love this girl and her videos
Oh my god this is the nicest comment ever
amazing video!❤️
Thank you 🥺
"because not everybody * whispers 'me'* is in a happy and committed relationship" same bruh
Honestly mood
We all know Julian would share his entire cheesecake with his family. My man honestly desireves the entire world at this point. Been through some much.
Sees the word Blackthorn on the title. Likes the video before even watching it.❤
Our BABIES
@@MyYAFictionAddiction YESS!
yesss i loved this!!
❤️❤️
The blackthorn family is my favorite shadowhunter family. I disagree with the list personally but I see your points and respect your opinion. Love your content though
I am SO intrigued to see where you would put them!! Please say you at least agree with Mark being a KING
@@MyYAFictionAddiction ok I’m done with chain of iron, so now Jesse is definitely top tier for me along with Ty, Julian and Dru. I like Mark but he’s not really my favorite. I especially loved him in lady midnight with his whole arc of coming back to his family but then he kinda sorta lost me. Livvy, Helen and Tavvy are fine but they are barely developed enough for me to judge them that much. I’ll say Livvy and tavvy are “I would offer them a slice” while Helen “I would let them eat the whole cheesecake”. Grace after reading chain of iron is definitely also in that category. The rest are just “I would not offer them a slice”. Wait TATIANA IS DEFINITELY BOTTOM TIER ALONG WITH ANABELLE.
This video was excellent
This comment was excellent
“The perfect video doesn’t exist” *sees this video*
Lmaooooo
I have a 7 year old child. Can confirm they are annoying.
I honestly hate Tatiana, but I hate Annabelle so much I could commit a crime
YES
Honestly I think I would put everyone of them on the top, I adore every single one of them (even Annabelle I felt sorry for her)
Also Grace is the best character in every book ever
I can’t believe you’re giving Anabelle precious cheesecake 💀
@@MyYAFictionAddiction I feel sorry for her, she went crazy, I think she needs cheesecake and therapy
@@gaspsatan5555 don’t we all need cheesecake and therapy 💀💀
ok so it's not confirmed yet (even though cassandra has implicitly confirmed that lucie does marry jesse in tmi or tda) where would you put lucie as a possible blackthorn?👀
For Lucie, I would make her her own tier above Mark in the top: “I love them so much I would not only let them eat me instead, but I would come back from the afterlife just to bake her her own cheesecake as well”
@@MyYAFictionAddiction love that for her💓
i feel kinda the same about grace
I’m excited to read more about her in COI!
@@MyYAFictionAddiction me toooo
also somehow I thought there were more blackthorns omg
There probably are more minor ones but I *think* I got the major ones??
when is chain of iron coming?
The book or my review?
@@MyYAFictionAddiction review
@@LuCiFeR-tf5yu I’m gonna start it today so maybe sometime next week... watch this space 👀
AHHH JUST 3 MORE SUBSCRIBERS TO 800!!!
Omg your surname is Blackthorn on here I HOPE YOU ENJOYED THE VID
@@MyYAFictionAddiction AHAHAHA YES I DID I AGREE WITH U ON MOST THINGS AND YS MY SURNAME IS BLACTHORN IN THIS COS I TOOK an ASSASIN name quiz and my name was asha blackthorn lmao
@@ashablackthorn1442 AN ASSASSIN NAME QUIZ WHAT?!!!
GAHH I CANT FIND IT BUT JUST SEARCH UP ASSASIN NAME QUIZ ON GOOGLE AND PLAY THE ONE BY RUM AND MONKEY . tell me which one u get ahhh ly
@@ashablackthorn1442 I had a brainwave yesterday while I was driving that I would like mine to be either, Katniss Carstairs, or Emma Everdeen ✨