BMW M3 F80 vs Mercedes-AMG C63 S | evo DEADLY RIVALS

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 14. 06. 2015
  • The BMW M3 feels at home on track, but can it really beat Mercedes-Benz's substantially more powerful C63 S AMG? All is revealed in our latest Deadly Rivals video...
    Follow us:
    / evomagazine
    / evomagazine
    Subscribe to evo magazine: subscribe.evo.co.uk/
  • Auta a dopravní prostředky

Komentáře • 1,5K

  • @frankyleandri3592
    @frankyleandri3592 Před 9 lety +120

    Why is everybody hating on the M3? It's faster than the AMG around the track and cheaper too.

    • @hendradi3031
      @hendradi3031 Před 9 lety +16

      Franky Leandri i love both dude.
      BMW for sport (M3, M4, M6, M6 GC, & X5M)
      Mercedes for luxury (S Class. S Class coupe)

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 9 lety +20

      Franky Leandri Because AMG Fanboys and lexus fanboys joining them. lol

    • @blockthis08
      @blockthis08 Před 9 lety +5

      Franky Leandri Benz fans compensating.

    • @dollahdollah
      @dollahdollah Před 9 lety +4

      Franky Leandri i could care less about which is faster than the other. both cars are amazing. go for a test drive and see which youll feel more comfortable in than pick ...=D

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 9 lety +12

      dollahdollah agree, I picked the M3, COZ ITS SIMPLY a better drivers car.

  • @Sabrermk42
    @Sabrermk42 Před 9 lety +182

    I'm a BMW fan, I drive one, I generally prefer them to their competitors....but the way some of the fanboys below are talking about the C63 as if it's a Lada is ridiculous. Both great cars.

  • @curryops69
    @curryops69 Před 9 lety +130

    The m3 is a legend, Unlike Amg, M Dosent just put a huge amount of torque and horse power, they balance there cars out very well

    • @tysonmason4126
      @tysonmason4126 Před 9 lety +4

      Jay Singh yeah it`s just like apple products :D

    • @chrisbrown6759
      @chrisbrown6759 Před 9 lety +28

      Jay Singh AMG makes their cars for fun, not for track. That's why it oversteers so you can drift it easier, AMG has a tradition of making loud and fun cars, they are gonna change it for BMW. Mercedes has been around long before BMW so if they wanted to make a car to beat the M3 they definitley could. Anybody that argues with that is stupid.

    • @KokRiver
      @KokRiver Před 9 lety +14

      Chris Brown M has been around longer than AMG so shouldn't it be reversed?

    • @kennethmartin8124
      @kennethmartin8124 Před 9 lety +2

      Agreed BMW is the best

    • @danielmaia3559
      @danielmaia3559 Před 9 lety +1

      I would say that Mercedes does it on purpose, and that's why I can't say which is better because they are different cars with different driving dynamics for slightly different consumers

  • @NikoBell12
    @NikoBell12 Před 9 lety +480

    Nice review. I know some people are whining about it being boring but that's only because they want to see drifting 24/7 as opposed to actual driving.

    • @lenniegodber7805
      @lenniegodber7805 Před 9 lety +1

      Right, bcause I'm sure Top Gear would have been a more popular show in its time had the hosts just 'driven' those cars everywhere
      People want too see a fast car going sideways or rolling along at high speed because that's why they watch a car show

    • @NikoBell12
      @NikoBell12 Před 9 lety +31

      Lennie Godber
      *"because that's why they watch a car show"* That's not why I watch a car show. It's enjoyable when they go sideways but when they do it all of the time it's just overkill. Did I strike a nerve or something? Why are you coming off so defensive, lol?

    • @JonasRosenven
      @JonasRosenven Před 9 lety +24

      NikoBell12 I actually found it incredibly boring because it is so shallow. They put the cars on a track and BAM they are done. Instead of testing them on the road where they drive over 99% of the time.

    • @NikoBell12
      @NikoBell12 Před 9 lety +4

      Jonas Rosenven
      I actually agree. I personally love road reviews, they're usually scenic and easier to relate too.

    • @evo
      @evo  Před 9 lety +9

      Jonas Rosenven We've kept our full road test review exclusive to evo issue 211 (in UK stores from 17 June)

  • @leestyle1af
    @leestyle1af Před 9 lety +96

    I own a 2010 c63 and I'm crossing over to the 2016 M3. C63 didn't need more power, it needed to be lighter and more agile. Oversteer is cool on a track but when I'm driving on back mountain roads swinging that tail end out is too much. m3 is more what I am looking for, plus they offer a manual :)

    • @brandonchism6960
      @brandonchism6960 Před 9 lety +6

      You own a 2010 C63!? Reeeeeaaaalllllly???? Next you're gonna say you would get the M4 but your wife insists on 4 doors. And you plan to use it on "mountain roads" in California. Freakin poser, lol.

    • @brandonchism6960
      @brandonchism6960 Před 9 lety

      ***** dude i don't know you so i'll refrain from saying anything derogatory to you other than telling you to watch your mouth, i wasn't talking to you.

    • @brandonchism6960
      @brandonchism6960 Před 9 lety +2

      markeus lee aww c'mon. you laughed when you saw i wrote you, lol. congrats on the purchase though man!!!!

    • @leestyle1af
      @leestyle1af Před 9 lety

      @uzzyfuzzy tanzanite blue metallic

    • @harryward18
      @harryward18 Před 9 lety

      markeus lee fair enough, but you will miss the sound :) also why is it 2016 m3, do you mean you are buying a new one in 2016

  • @TheMpofu
    @TheMpofu Před 9 lety +263

    And there is still the competition package to come. Lol nice work bimmer

    • @jamescutter9868
      @jamescutter9868 Před 9 lety +5

      And possibly a CRT don't forget!

    • @Kaisuke971
      @Kaisuke971 Před 9 lety +1

      Kings mario Well the LCI is already here and no sign of a CP. The normal version is actually performant enough so... If they do it, then it's nice but i don't think they really need it.

    • @viktorlouzil7820
      @viktorlouzil7820 Před 9 lety +9

      Kings mario and there is the black series to come

    • @umaralikha
      @umaralikha Před 9 lety +1

      ***** There'd be an upgraded 507 which will probably be like 540hp and a few more such as the other editions which came out. This engine has much more capabilities.

    • @umaralikha
      @umaralikha Před 9 lety

      The normal coupe has been seen testing. There are more editions of the C63, which you know because Mercedes engineers have said this engine has capabilities of easily over 600hp, with tuners already going above that, which leaves headroom for more editions.

  • @metronemy
    @metronemy Před 9 lety +71

    BMW is faster and looks better too. I know which I would get.

    • @veemacks7255
      @veemacks7255 Před 9 lety +23

      metronemy The Mercedes?

    • @metronemy
      @metronemy Před 9 lety +15

      Alien Or Sutin yep

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 8 lety +3

      metronemy if u have sense u'd close ur eyes n buy the M3. LOL

    • @ItzMond123
      @ItzMond123 Před 8 lety

      Much better in person

  • @DallasCajun
    @DallasCajun Před 9 lety +340

    Nice track comparison...but I'd still take the C63 S...

    • @veemacks7255
      @veemacks7255 Před 9 lety +63

      Will Johnson Same here. Not because I have anything bad to say about M3's, just that I don't race people on tracks, and I don't need a 0.7 second advantage over another car. I'd get the C63 S AMG because I prefer the look, sound, comfort, and feel of it.

    • @DallasCajun
      @DallasCajun Před 9 lety +30

      Alien Or Sutin Exactly. I've owned an M3 and an E63 (yes, different classes), and loved both of them. Nothing bad to say about the M, the C just has such a better sound and feels a little more 'special'. They're both too fast to use that speed on daily use anyway...and if I'm going to track a car, it won't be a sedan.

    • @veemacks7255
      @veemacks7255 Před 9 lety

      Will Johnson How did you find ownership of the E63? I've considered getting one many times but it always comes down to the fact that it's too much power going through one axle. With my lead-lined right foot, I'd be buying a new set or rears every week (or every month if I'm optimistic). I like that they finally started doing a 4Matic version of the AMG's. Personally I went for an E500 4Matic, with 387bhp. Even in the wet it's a struggle to get the traction control light to come on, it just puts all the power down all the time. I can imagine myself picking up a used W212 E63 AMG 4Matic Estate in 2-3 years time.

    • @DallasCajun
      @DallasCajun Před 9 lety

      Alien Or Sutin I had a 2010 E63 for a relatively brief period (I couldn't get rid of my itch for another 911). Not a bad thing to say about it, other than at the time, MB's COMAND system was beginning to feel a bit dated. Having said that, I didn't get the car to surf the net or stream music anyway...I got it to go like hell. And that it did. Yes, it struggled with traction, especially in the wet. But in those conditions you still have to be careful with 400+ hp cars anyway. The new AWD versions are where it's at, it's amazing how those cars get off the line: E63 S, S7/RS7, Panamera GTS. I wouldn't buy a used one unless it's MB Certified, but finding a 2014+ one is the perfect car for me, ESPECIALLY the Estate. I'm in a S7 for now...GREAT car, but not an AMG or RS.

    • @veemacks7255
      @veemacks7255 Před 9 lety

      Will Johnson S7 sounds like a good choice. You have to wonder how often you really ever get to use those horses above 400 anyway. You might plant your foot to the floor and enjoy the ride to 60mph for example and think how having 500bhp is awesome, but not be actually using more than 400 of them a lot of the time. Apart from when I'm on the unrestricted Autobahns, I'm doubting I use more than 300bhp 99% of the time. I'll be sticking in the 300-400 range until those E63 4Matics get their ridiculous first 2-3 years of depreciation out of the way and then I'll pick one up :) Come on 2017, get a move on.

  • @Groagun
    @Groagun Před 9 lety +9

    This was easily one of Evos' best videos ever! Dan Prosser was excellent in his presentation and description of the driving experience and feel. The stop start feature in the side by side video was excellent and Evo should be commended on this simple but extremely effective application and 'show and tell' tool.

  • @HiddenWen
    @HiddenWen Před 5 lety +20

    Personally like the C63s more, but I respect the M3's capabilities. In the end, the C63s is really just a luxury mid size sedan with a monster engine, whereas the M3 was built for the track.

    • @gottliebdee263
      @gottliebdee263 Před 10 měsíci +1

      Don’t get fooled by videos like this. ‘Built for the track’, which track??? Monaco or Monza.
      That’s the trouble with CZcams videos, they need to be more comprehensive. It’s pretty crappy that an outfit as big as Evo couldn’t even get a car spec the same. Carbon brakes make a big difference even before you get as far as overheating.
      M3 probably is faster on a track but this was a cherry pick by the Mag.

  • @yitboy11
    @yitboy11 Před 9 lety +26

    What exactly makes the rivalry "DEADLY!!!!!"""""? Epic, historic, awesome, etc.. All good adjectives for what the rivalry is, but who died?

    • @MagicSkeleton
      @MagicSkeleton Před 9 lety +4

      yitboy11 It's just a cliche. No-one has to die for it to work!

    • @Tbland0930
      @Tbland0930 Před 9 lety +2

      yitboy11 Hyperbole.

    • @TheBlackdragon936
      @TheBlackdragon936 Před 9 lety +1

      The 80 hp more that the Benz had and the extra 110 lbs ft of torque. That is what died here lol.

    • @Robin-sf3gk
      @Robin-sf3gk Před 9 lety

      In germany are 3 fractions; the bavarians (BMW,Audi) swabia (Mercedes, Porsche) and Prussians(VW) and the bavarians hate all the others to death, so it is deadly.

  • @whoischxse
    @whoischxse Před 9 lety +96

    I'd have the c63 in my eyes it looks better and in the real world on the road is faster. How often really would you drive either cars on a track? Hardly ever

    • @valgehiir
      @valgehiir Před 9 lety +8

      chase lupex On track? never! Most of us don't have money to crash a $100 000 brand new car.

    • @harryward18
      @harryward18 Před 9 lety +3

      chase lupex The m3 would be more fun to drive probably, even on the road, speed and looks arent everything

    • @rajas2907
      @rajas2907 Před 9 lety +18

      Lol if an M3 is faster around the track, it will be fast on Road as well. Just get an M3

    • @whoischxse
      @whoischxse Před 9 lety +8

      Raja S the m3 i have no doubt is faster in the corners but in a straight is beaten out by the c63 most roads in america tend to be straight and not shaped like road courses.

    • @rajas2907
      @rajas2907 Před 9 lety +11

      my M4 beats my friends C63 s in straight / Corners/dry /wet any road, but not by a huge difference, it also depends upon the driver i guess. But u can't go wrong with either. Such amazing cars.

  • @mistreku
    @mistreku Před 8 lety +6

    Regardless of which one is your favorite, you just can't help giving the other the respect it deserves. Great cars, both!

  • @lobniklukas
    @lobniklukas Před 9 lety +78

    That C63 is so beautiful :O

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 9 lety +11

      ***** yes the old one is, the new c63 is so ugly.

    • @mriphone1000
      @mriphone1000 Před 9 lety +4

      ***** The older c63 models had character, the new one has really soft lines like a Bentley.

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 9 lety +1

      Easton McDonald yes true, but don't compare it to Bentleys LOL

    • @dollahdollah
      @dollahdollah Před 9 lety +2

      ***** they toned down the new c class exterior, not to say that it looks bad. it looks sleek. the previous model was awesomely aggressive, esp. the black series. =D

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 9 lety

      dollahdollah agree

  • @eddiefara
    @eddiefara Před 9 lety +7

    Nice work evo, informative, great video, no complaints.

  • @ryoc1
    @ryoc1 Před 9 lety +16

    Never have I heard the word slightly so much in my life. Very nice review.

  • @armoashxar
    @armoashxar Před 9 lety +15

    Slightly interesting video. I slightly noticed that this guy slightly uses the word "slightly" slightly too much

  • @elusivellama
    @elusivellama Před 9 lety +82

    That sudden oversteer on the Mercedes is ridiculously noticeable compared to the BMW's smooth, drama free corner exit..

    • @Hollyweed1
      @Hollyweed1 Před 9 lety +3

      BMW id Drivers car. It will do drama ONLY if you want it to.

    • @kristiannolasco8451
      @kristiannolasco8451 Před 8 lety +11

      Pedro Santos lmfao that amg idiot doesn't know anything about the cars he biased with BMW has been owning amg mercs since they were released theres a reason why BMW M is so iconic and older amg mercs were a lot worst back then this is their best one ever and still can't beat BMW

    • @umaralikha
      @umaralikha Před 8 lety +2

      Kristian Nolasco What'd you mean can't beat BMW? Have you seen Motortrends latest review?

    • @UrbanChaos20
      @UrbanChaos20 Před 8 lety +5

      +Pedro Santos Lol, the M3 beat the C63 around a short-ass circuit by 0.7 seconds. Hahahah. That's a fucking joke. Take the cars to a longer race track, and the M3 won't stand a chance. Also, everyone knows the C63 is the superior car to have on the road. The M3 drives likes crap on the road, and "especially when its wet" it's what every reviewer says.

    • @PedroTRamos1
      @PedroTRamos1 Před 8 lety +1

      Urban Chaos 2.0 "Take the cars to a longer race track, and the M3 won't stand a chance. ". I don´t think this deserves any comment

  • @pikachupowers
    @pikachupowers Před 9 lety +49

    BMW: 80hp less and still faster. same goes for the older m3 vs c63 amg. goes to show what good engineering and chassis tuning does to a car.

    • @rcybergaming
      @rcybergaming Před 5 lety +8

      The c63 is a basically a modern German muscle car. A m3 is a German track car for the masses. I personally want a m3 over a c63.

    • @BoomerZman77
      @BoomerZman77 Před 4 lety

      Street vs track?? What's the "real" story! Quick guys a-la track near by...be safe n get a M-CP. Daily + Merc will do! AMG Old Guy. P.S.: OG. Jr. Has the M-CP!

    • @jimwhite4270
      @jimwhite4270 Před 4 lety

      You're all tools. Watch real reviews and know AMG wins..

    • @pikachupowers
      @pikachupowers Před 4 lety +1

      @@jimwhite4270 You have to understand that different drivers will have their own preference as to what car does what better. In reality neither are better than one another. Then again judging by your white wash username cant really expect you to understand much about simple opinionated principles based on your white wash username.

    • @wasskhan3008
      @wasskhan3008 Před 3 lety

      Sababa Hummus thats just being ignorant. The M3 handles and puts the power down better than the mercedes. End of story.

  • @Fugue602
    @Fugue602 Před 7 lety +38

    I know this is irrelevant, but I hate the new 'tablet' mounted to the dash trend.

    • @bsg2621
      @bsg2621 Před 7 lety +1

      Yeah I'd have the company do it specially.

    • @hasanal-habbobi4018
      @hasanal-habbobi4018 Před 7 lety +3

      I have sat in it and in person its actually nice, not as bad as you think

  • @xkukubax
    @xkukubax Před 8 lety +30

    just the sheer fact that you compared m3's gearbox to ferrari's makes me think that bmw is doing something right.

    • @adrianp.3182
      @adrianp.3182 Před 7 lety +6

      BMW's DCT is amongst the best like Porsche and Ferrari , neither Audi and MB's gearbox is even close to the DCT of the BMW.I have been in a BMW with DCT and the gearshifts are instant.

    • @carlosmillan5451
      @carlosmillan5451 Před 7 lety

      +Drezdan stupid

  • @CledClassics
    @CledClassics Před 8 lety +23

    The noise an AMG makes is so fucking beautiful. That and the noise a GTR makes as it just whizzes past you. Put the two together and you have porn.

    • @CarswithB
      @CarswithB Před 8 lety

      +★ X I I I ★ Yes check my review for the C63 S amg bro

    • @dudz5825
      @dudz5825 Před 8 lety

      This models c63 is no where near as loud and fierce as the older 2010 models 😔

    • @CledClassics
      @CledClassics Před 8 lety +1

      +Dudz The new E63 models sound really good too. Like a more mature C63 (2012 or so)

    • @dudz5825
      @dudz5825 Před 8 lety

      yeah man you know it, its more of a ... posh mans car than a c63 ;)

    • @stretch90
      @stretch90 Před 7 lety

      AMGs always sound really nice. The M4 sounds completely different from the older generation m3s tho.

  • @youngdrug5927
    @youngdrug5927 Před 9 lety +15

    I worked for Mercedes and like them a lot. But over the c63 I would pick the m4 any day hands down.

    • @reynaldwilbert2245
      @reynaldwilbert2245 Před 8 lety

      Why?

    • @youngdrug5927
      @youngdrug5927 Před 8 lety

      Reynald Jackson because of the looks and driving dynamics

    • @VaunShiz
      @VaunShiz Před 8 lety +1

      Anish Ahuja the looks are subjective

    • @youngdrug5927
      @youngdrug5927 Před 8 lety +2

      matthew von yeah they're but the driving dynamics are not.

    • @mrkruger5108
      @mrkruger5108 Před 8 lety

      Anish Ahuja LOL great to see you're finally seeing the light!

  • @SaMaster18
    @SaMaster18 Před 9 lety +4

    Great video! I have a 2015 M3; just picked her up about a month ago. Definitely not a daily driver that is for everyone (I think the Benz wins there with more comfort and straight line speed), but the M3 just draws a smile every time I start her up! The exhaust also ins't that bad if you're used to it and its warmed up with valves fully open!

  • @MultiJugulator
    @MultiJugulator Před 8 lety +133

    Raw power is nothing. Balance is everything.

    • @sukhrajsahi9587
      @sukhrajsahi9587 Před 8 lety +2

      +Farid Magerramov real talk g

    • @bighands69
      @bighands69 Před 8 lety +8

      +Farid Magerramov
      And that is why Porsche make the best track cars.
      And Mercedes the best road cars.

    • @sukhrajsahi9587
      @sukhrajsahi9587 Před 8 lety

      look*

    • @Obi-WanKannabis
      @Obi-WanKannabis Před 8 lety +3

      porsche makes the best long beetles

    • @darthvidu8020
      @darthvidu8020 Před 8 lety +19

      Mercedes does more than just raw power. The C63 is a much better all-rounder. If you want a track car, the M3 is better, yes. But there are better track cars than it. It's all about compromise.

  • @thelarry383
    @thelarry383 Před 9 lety +26

    Good thing for mercedes fans, being faster on a race track is completely irrelevant in the real world where straight line performance is more relevant.

    • @lambosforusal
      @lambosforusal Před 9 lety +1

      Light Yagami indeed, you hear him talking in the beginning how everything in the BMW feels so much better on a flat racetrack than it did on the road. exactly something i do not want to hear if i am looking for a car! you can see the Mercedes being a bit more "wobbely" in the corners, showing it has a slightly longer spring rate and softer damping. i would definately choose the Mercedes over the BMW, as tracktimes do not interest me that much. Real world performance and usability do.

    • @thelarry383
      @thelarry383 Před 9 lety +1

      ***** not when you're doing things like overtaking

    • @mrkruger5108
      @mrkruger5108 Před 9 lety +12

      Light Yagami Didn't really see the c63 ahead on the straights now did we?

    • @thelarry383
      @thelarry383 Před 9 lety

      Mr Kruger Never heard of corner exit speed now have we?

    • @Dgannt
      @Dgannt Před 9 lety +9

      Light Yagami Actually M3 had faster corner exit speed thanks to less oversteer. Hence why M3 kept pulling away.

  • @NickR27
    @NickR27 Před 8 lety +40

    Can't wait to take delivery of my 16 M3.

    • @maxpayne8642
      @maxpayne8642 Před 8 lety +2

      +Najeem stop lying

    • @NickR27
      @NickR27 Před 8 lety

      +Max Payne No need to lie, already took delivery.

    • @kamika-zz6192
      @kamika-zz6192 Před 8 lety +1

      Have fun. I love the car, and put some vids online love to see more of the M3.

    • @DixaRSN
      @DixaRSN Před 8 lety

      +Najeem nice infinity mate l0l

    • @NickR27
      @NickR27 Před 8 lety

      +DixaRSN Thanks mate lol

  • @rajaehsin507
    @rajaehsin507 Před 9 lety +149

    Noo matter what I will still take the C63 AMG there's something about it..

  • @ricklp10
    @ricklp10 Před 9 lety +7

    The Mercedes doesn't use automated single clutch transmission. It uses a transmission more like a conventional automatic gear box with planetary gears. The different part about it is that it uses a multi disc clutch pack instead of a torque converter.

  • @vugar.askarov
    @vugar.askarov Před 7 lety +6

    This is still regular M3 without competition package. This C63 AMG S is same class with competition package of M3. Still can't beat. And competition package m3 also faster than Amg in straight line as well. 0-60 3,8 sec

    • @user-bs7ip5ic8r
      @user-bs7ip5ic8r Před 7 lety +1

      Vugar Askarov you right... the last m3 & m4 are true little beasts, even for new c63 amg...

    • @goga511
      @goga511 Před 7 lety +1

      nope in straight line is C63 faster

  • @TinkoMollov
    @TinkoMollov Před 9 lety

    really detailed inforamtion on his perception of the cars!! really professional oppinion! Thank you!

  • @MattUK36
    @MattUK36 Před 9 lety +9

    Slightly good review this one.

  • @slaWterCH
    @slaWterCH Před 9 lety +9

    Finally these two :) Personally, I prefer the AMG. Better sound and most likely a better all around road car. Still, I'm glad I ordered a Cayman GTS instead of a C63 S.

    • @GaryDownes
      @GaryDownes Před 5 lety

      Cayman is better than both the M3 and C63s. But if were to choose between the two, BMW has my money. Lighter, more agile and just better fun to drive.

  • @Osufootballfan100
    @Osufootballfan100 Před 9 lety +5

    I love my M4 it is the perfect everyday car for all uses. According to other owners dynos it puts out around 465-480 hp at crank. I would love to get the C63 S because of the V8 it is more of a cruiser.

  • @cybergreen874
    @cybergreen874 Před 9 lety +1

    Finally, a proper comparison between the M3 and the c63s that we wants.
    Thank you EVO !!

  • @oppanheimer
    @oppanheimer Před 9 lety

    Very good detailed informative performance review.
    Thank you.

  • @cicerobarbiero
    @cicerobarbiero Před 7 lety +4

    Well, i have to say that. As a BMW fan/Owner ( 130i Hatch, 265 BHP, 6l, etc ) for me a couple of seconds doesn't matter at all when you buy a car. A car is also made of emotions, the feeling, the sound, the power, etc. I love trM3, its a fantastic car, it's so precise and thight, a track machine!! But the c63s, ah its amazing!! Got the feeling, the sound, the power, and even a couple of second's slower, still an fantastic and emotional car. These are two completely different beasts, and two fantastic cars!! Stop this fight between Bmw and Mercedes!

  • @enricosundjojo8598
    @enricosundjojo8598 Před 9 lety +25

    C63 for days

  • @automirr
    @automirr Před 4 lety

    thank you for sharing!

  • @stoneeh
    @stoneeh Před 9 lety

    This guy knows his stuff. Refreshing seeing/hearing someone being really knowledgeable about the dynamics and technical aspects of driving.

  • @ibeunstoppable
    @ibeunstoppable Před 8 lety +66

    M3 all day baby.

    • @user-pr3eo8tq4d
      @user-pr3eo8tq4d Před 8 lety +5

      +sd Mercedes logic = put a big engine with lots of power in a road car and expect to be good on track.

    • @truuston3r220
      @truuston3r220 Před 8 lety

      +10482021 080253 if that was the case for the Mercedes that should be a complement ...... To JUST be 7/10's slower wouldn't be so bad after all

    • @nightfall9502
      @nightfall9502 Před 5 lety +1

      @Dodger says the guy who cant even spell....

    • @catalinxnecula
      @catalinxnecula Před 4 lety

      @@nightfall9502 his spelling it's just fine mate. he might say it wrong in urdu but nobody gives a shit about that

  • @branot89
    @branot89 Před 9 lety +14

    2% of owners is going to race them on track or drive them like a maniac on public roads. I would choose C63 (without S) because I found it to be more elegant, luxurious and I have better noise

  • @zdx197
    @zdx197 Před 8 lety +2

    I drove the C63S AMG yesterday and once you hear that brutal V8 roaring (AMG really did a good job making the 4.0 bi-turbo V8 sound as "full" as the older 6.2 version) you will soon forget about the fact the C63S is a bit heavier and a bit more slumpish than the M3. These cars are not made for solely tracking anyway. They are just sporty saloons made to have fun on your daily rides and have an occasional trackday if you like. Imo the C63S is the one who will give you the most thrills and the most "thumbs up" from other petrolheads simply because of its higher muscle/testosteron level.
    Ofcourse all this is from the perspective of a fast saloon where agility and handling are not the #1 prior thing, at least not in my opinion.

  • @Meezo7
    @Meezo7 Před 9 lety

    very thorough, great review!

  • @SaMaster18
    @SaMaster18 Před 9 lety +4

    Also, comparing price, wouldn't the non-S C63 be a better match up? Crazy to see the M3 (non competition package) edge out the S model!

  • @RAJohnson713
    @RAJohnson713 Před 9 lety +4

    I'd take either, both amazing

  • @MegaDan991
    @MegaDan991 Před 9 lety

    Excellent job on filming and depicting of the car's characteristics.

  • @vadymbrykalov8733
    @vadymbrykalov8733 Před 8 lety +2

    U should mention the weight comparison and weight distribution of the cars. Those two factors are extremely important when it comes down to putting the generated force to the ground.

  • @markoslider5953
    @markoslider5953 Před 8 lety +23

    ///M POWER BABY!!!

    • @tt-ln4mc
      @tt-ln4mc Před 8 lety +1

      hell yea

    • @dominicancash
      @dominicancash Před 8 lety

      So half a second faster, with less refinement, less technology, and definitely with a way better sound, how many times ppl takes this cars to the track? Most never do , how many get race on the street at a red light ? Lots of them and you know what that c63 will make you eat dust 100% of the time .

    • @tt-ln4mc
      @tt-ln4mc Před 8 lety +2

      dominicancash More technology, more beutiful, WAAAAY better around corners and at a street light the c63 would burn out its tires before it even starts. The C63 is trash and thats why the M3 won

    • @dominicancash
      @dominicancash Před 8 lety

      +Mitt Romney yo clearly don't know shit about cars c63 is AWD meaning no burning tires , the interior on the m3 looks like is from 1993 old as fuck super dated.

    • @tt-ln4mc
      @tt-ln4mc Před 8 lety

      dominicancash first of all, the F80 looks a lot niver interior than the C63. The C63 is rear wheel drive you idiot. You have to pay extra for all wheel drive.

  • @surewin1773
    @surewin1773 Před 9 lety +4

    I'm really impressed by the C63. The chassis seems much better behaved on track than its predecessor. The lap time margin between the E92 M3 and the older C63 was far greater. AMG is doing good work-

  • @ildjess
    @ildjess Před 9 lety

    excellent review top gear is nice and all but sometimes i prefer the info-LOADED reviews! great job lads.. u got a new subscriber :)

  • @000Haze
    @000Haze Před 9 lety

    Actual information in a review? Bravo EVO - great comparo.

  • @tyhutson6558
    @tyhutson6558 Před 9 lety +3

    Drinking game: every time this guy says "slightly" take a drink

  • @nightfly168
    @nightfly168 Před 8 lety +11

    6:37 "We've got a single clutch conventional auto in this car".
    No not exactly, actually it is called the AMG speedshift MCT. It i essentially the 7G-Tronic automatic transmission without a torque converter. Instead of a torque converter, it uses a compact wet startup clutch to launch the car from a stop, and also supports computer-controlled double declutching. The MCT (Multi-Clutch Technology) acronym refers to a planetary (automatic) transmission’s multiple clutches and bands for each gear.
    BMW's DCT is still much faster though, but to call the mercedes' transmission a conventional auto, is not right either.

  • @jonathanclarkewater
    @jonathanclarkewater Před 9 lety

    Great review. This guy knows his stuff!

  • @jch7807
    @jch7807 Před 9 lety

    I enjoyed the calm and poised demeanor of this video.

  • @TheShale187
    @TheShale187 Před 8 lety +4

    The M3 is a far better track day/fun car but as a daily driver I'd take the c63. Mercedes has the best comfort and luxury in that segment by far.

  • @warikplaya
    @warikplaya Před 7 lety +6

    Seems like a really small race track. A decent straight would allow the benz to close the gap nicely. Besides, c63 is more about being a luxury rocket rather than a track star.

  • @j.taveras8447
    @j.taveras8447 Před 8 lety

    There's no better comparison of these tow cars the internet, period. Amazing work. Love the footage.

  • @Semo11044
    @Semo11044 Před 9 lety +108

    God damn that Mercedes is ugly.

    • @Dashtea
      @Dashtea Před 9 lety +6

      Yeah I hate the froggy eyes on the c63.
      Ramadan kareem btw :)

    • @Semo11044
      @Semo11044 Před 9 lety +4

      Dashte Ramadan Kareem to you too man! I agree, the headlights are pretty ugly.

    • @barry810527
      @barry810527 Před 9 lety

      ***** Mercedes is ugly.
      BMW is fugly

    • @kennethmartin8124
      @kennethmartin8124 Před 9 lety +10

      Agree BMW m3 is better

    • @Semo11044
      @Semo11044 Před 9 lety +13

      The BMW looks sporty, the Mercedes just looks like a smaller version of a S-Classe. BMW wins again.

  • @JamesJDMoe
    @JamesJDMoe Před 9 lety +5

    The BMW is faster, looks better and cheaper. Clear choice to me. If only I could afford one :/ But both of these cars are awesome!

  • @jortepap
    @jortepap Před 9 lety +51

    M-POWER!!
    Both great cars but the M3 looks much better and it sounds better too imo. That twinturbo inline 6 engine is fantastic. Easy choise for me

    • @dagwinsabbe2676
      @dagwinsabbe2676 Před 6 lety

      superb

    • @ZenGamer97
      @ZenGamer97 Před 5 lety

      W205 sounds much better than the bimmer. Bimmer has it trumped everywhere else tho

  • @MusaZuma
    @MusaZuma Před 9 lety

    iv been waiting 4 dis :)

  • @G4ZZYP
    @G4ZZYP Před 8 lety +3

    They are both great cars but very different beasts. The M3 is awesome (I owned one) and is an easier drive as the car is very well balanced. I jacked in the M3 and got the C63 AMG S (which I currently still have) and I love it. The AMG is less forgiving and requires more "driving" which is what I love about it. I'm neither a Merc or BMW fanboy but more a driving fanboy. For me overall if you are looking to buy one of these the M3 would probably pip it for most but saying that I wouldn't swap my AMG back for the M3. You can't go wrong with either, it's just down to personal preference

  • @nemz87
    @nemz87 Před 8 lety +7

    why wasn't the c63s opted with ceramic breaks also?

    • @AsifLicious
      @AsifLicious Před 8 lety +3

      Then it would be $20,000 more expensive than the M3 lol

  • @Powaup
    @Powaup Před 9 lety

    Really enjoyed this review

  • @ZIPTRAVELS
    @ZIPTRAVELS Před 9 lety

    Nice review...would have liked to see a drag race between the two. Maybe next time?

  • @hansklostermann117
    @hansklostermann117 Před 8 lety +41

    Shouldn´t the M3 be compared to the regular C63 AMG instead of the C63 S ?

    • @kamika-zz6192
      @kamika-zz6192 Před 8 lety +3

      Yes, it is a 11000£ price difference.

    • @M3Conv
      @M3Conv Před 8 lety +31

      +Hans Klostermann The M3 would humiliate a standard C63 so i guess they were letting MB retain some dignity in the result being reasonably close

    • @konquistador1
      @konquistador1 Před 7 lety +5

      +M3Conv You obviously have no idea what the exact differences between c63 and c63s are. They both make roughly the same lap times and the acceleration from 0-100km/h is in the c63s about 0,1 seconds faster so what?
      Just btw: Compare some lap times at the Nürburgring or Hockenheimring and you'll see how ridiculous your comment is

    • @CarsnFood
      @CarsnFood Před 5 lety

      Still completely destroyed the almighty c63”S” model lol

    • @marwood9421
      @marwood9421 Před 5 lety +4

      Hans Klostermann M3 is faster than the C63 S. the M3 will make the standard c63 look like a C220d

  • @TuddecBMW
    @TuddecBMW Před 9 lety +3

    Normally I wouldn't care about lap times but this shows how the M3 is sharper and better on a track than the Merc. Both are awesome cars, and can be very fun drift monsters, but despite its extra power and torque, the Mercedes isn't faster 0-60 than the M3 (I know in the video it says the M3 does 0-60 in 4,3s but that's with the manual transmission, with the dual clutch they both do 4 seconds flat).
    I personally prefer the Bimmer, especially fo that masterpiece of a DCT (regular autos are good, but in a sports car I would either have a DCT or a manual).
    Also, the power they _really_ make is more important because BMW and Mercedes lie a lot about power in their cars. According to dynos, the MB has about 520hp (so Mercedes didn't lie that much this time), and the BMW has about 480 hp, so the difference isn't that big in real life (40 hp), but it is still considerable.

  • @Noposwowskis
    @Noposwowskis Před 8 lety

    Good review, Evo

  • @boringuserhandle
    @boringuserhandle Před 9 lety

    Getting better with every video

  • @clansman89
    @clansman89 Před 8 lety +14

    Please do M3 against Giulia QV as soon as possible

    • @teflondon4963
      @teflondon4963 Před 8 lety +2

      +clsman89 Theres nothing I want more than a giulia

    • @guigao28
      @guigao28 Před 7 lety

      motor trend channel did it

  • @johnsong4643
    @johnsong4643 Před 8 lety +4

    if you want sport driving and perfect balance , choose bmw
    if you want luxury and dont care balance , choose benz

    • @adrianp.3182
      @adrianp.3182 Před 7 lety

      So true , but internet trolls have to troll.

  • @Vgk36
    @Vgk36 Před 9 lety

    Sweet lord THIS is how you do a comparo bravo!!! please keep this format!!!

  • @LeeC_808
    @LeeC_808 Před 9 lety

    Great No-BS review. I love it!

  • @wishdj
    @wishdj Před 9 lety +17

    From the beginning of this video Evo seemed to be biased towards the BMW. The current generation M3 and M4 have been around for a while and likely the driver is more used to driving the M3 and M4. Pretty sure a different driver could put the extra 80hp into use and smoke the BMW.

    • @mrkruger5108
      @mrkruger5108 Před 9 lety +17

      wishdj LOL I smell a sour Mercedes cry baby

    • @BFD15i
      @BFD15i Před 9 lety +1

      wishdj Not so sure about that. The AMG-models always had way more power than the M-models but the AMGs always struggled to "convert" it into performance. Just take a look at the old M3 and the old C63. The C63 black edition had more than 90hp and 220Nm of torque more than the M3 and still the M3 was the better track-car.
      The AMGs are monsters on a straight line but they lack that last little bit of precision that the M-models deliver. Except the E63. That one beats the M5. Period. The current M5 is a disgrace for his heritage.
      However, I think that the average Joe won't recognize the differences so it's pretty much just a choice of your own flavour. All those cars are great.

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 Před 9 lety

      wishdj well u can say that about any review, BMW m3 won in this case.

    • @metallica5252
      @metallica5252 Před 9 lety +2

      BFD15i the M6 Gran Coupe (same engine, a bit more weight than M5) destroyed the E63 in a straight line drag, and the BMW had a shitty launch. Chris Harris was driving , search it next time before saying the M5 is a disgrace.

    • @BFD15i
      @BFD15i Před 9 lety

      Fredrik Kalgren
      Since you're talking about drag-racing you seem to completely misunderstand what I've written.
      Come on! Who cares about going a straight line?
      BMW M always stood for exceptional transverse dynamics while AMG always cared more for longitudinal dynamics.
      The current M5, however, can't stand a chance against the E63 on a track.
      The german magazine "SportAuto" had them tested on the Nürburgring Nordschleife and the E63 AMG S was 15(!) seconds faster than the M5.
      How about you do your researches the next time before posting irrelevant stuff on the interwebs..

  • @mikealanzo
    @mikealanzo Před 8 lety +9

    In all honesty, even if it differed 10-20 minutes I'd still go for the AMG!

  • @GunfightersINC
    @GunfightersINC Před 8 lety

    You are one of the best reviewers on youtube.. outstanding.

  • @hendradi3031
    @hendradi3031 Před 9 lety +5

    I love both,
    but in here, BMW still the king, Mercedes trying to catch up again & again.
    M3 & M4 is amazing, they're benchmark in this class.

  • @jamescutter9868
    @jamescutter9868 Před 9 lety +6

    These cars are just so good! Personally I'll need to try both but I think I might take the M3 just for looks.

  • @cadenguyen463
    @cadenguyen463 Před 9 lety +4

    awwwwwww shit I been waiting for this epic battle.

  • @KINGPerformance
    @KINGPerformance Před 9 lety

    Nice work, nice video ! Love the Bmw M3 F80...

  • @mgfmgtf
    @mgfmgtf Před 9 lety

    Very good, very detailed review! I like the presenter!

  • @Rascallucci
    @Rascallucci Před 9 lety +16

    Just typical Mercedes, oh well if the car is not good enough just give it more power with an "S" version, but still gets smoked by the BMW. Is just like when they couldn't beat the Audi RS6 Avant, what did they do? They threw the entire kitchen sink at them, they added the "S" version AND incorprated 4-Matic into the E Class Estate. Merc is probably the more expensive looking car, but that's about all it has got going for them and that applies pretty much across all their model range.

    • @Rascallucci
      @Rascallucci Před 9 lety +4

      Malc180s That's right, smoked!! Are you visually impaired? The Mercedes is up by what? 70 hp? And I haven't even mentioned the torque, yep the Merc got smoked alright. Little boy? I am in my 40s, if that qualifies me as a boy, hell I'll take it!! LOL.

    • @Malc180s
      @Malc180s Před 9 lety

      Alex Fu Ha! Off to bed grandad.

    • @Rascallucci
      @Rascallucci Před 9 lety +6

      Malc180s You must be one of those teenagers who doesn't even have a driver's licence. LOL.

    • @Amgbenz0
      @Amgbenz0 Před 9 lety +6

      Alex Fu Lol relax bud, it's not that serious. The fact that you care enough to shit on a car brand that doesn't force you to buy their product is alarming. If you want to be 0.7 seconds faster around a track then another car, then buy the BMW. If you want a faster straight line "muscle" car with a great sounding exhaust for a daily driver, then buy the AMG. Maybe you should wise up and realize that AMG and M have always had traits and characteristics to them for years that reflects in the differences in build and performance of these 2 competing models as they always have. AMG just likes building cars that are hooligans and have tons of torque and acceleration, M division likes building more track focused and precise cars.

    • @lambosforusal
      @lambosforusal Před 9 lety +2

      Alex Fu good luck the other 364 days of the year when you're not on a track. your superior cornering speed (which is probably only superior by 2/3mph) is not gonna help you one bit. comfort and torque is.

  • @irishtempah
    @irishtempah Před 8 lety +20

    Why is it still called a c63? If it has a 4.0 v8 it should be called a c40 no?

    • @clutched77
      @clutched77 Před 8 lety +1

      Marketing I guess it's more iconic

    • @mikgtc
      @mikgtc Před 8 lety

      +irishtempah bmw have Mpower as performance brand, that's why M before 3 (3-series).. Benz have AMG as performance brand, that's why AMG before c63 (class-c 63)

    • @GoldenEagle009
      @GoldenEagle009 Před 8 lety +7

      +irishtempah well if you're naming the car by engine size, then technically the C63 should be called the C62

    • @fahadalnafisa6121
      @fahadalnafisa6121 Před 8 lety +1

      +irishtempah It used to be 6.3

    • @SeanAlexanderJournalist
      @SeanAlexanderJournalist Před 8 lety +2

      No, it used to be 6.2, it was only named 63 and had 6.3 badges, but the engine actually was 6.2L.

  • @AlainCarAudioManiac
    @AlainCarAudioManiac Před 9 lety +1

    Excellent review.

  • @Nick-qx1vf
    @Nick-qx1vf Před 5 lety +1

    Dan is an ELITE car reviewer and doesn't get nearly enough screen time.

  • @reyrob
    @reyrob Před 9 lety +21

    And since 1986 the M3 remains king of the hill!

  • @23pyromaniac
    @23pyromaniac Před 8 lety +18

    Merc looks and sounds better and I'm pretty sure it'll be more reliable in the long run so I'd rather save up a little more and buy the C63.

    • @CarswithB
      @CarswithB Před 7 lety +13

      Not at all bro

    • @Taybrenn
      @Taybrenn Před 7 lety +7

      boo mercedes, breaks more and handles like shit.

    • @Notsure00700
      @Notsure00700 Před 5 lety

      Are u a grandpa?

    • @Motoscotty
      @Motoscotty Před 5 lety

      Mercedes reliability has went rather poor in the last 5 years. I’ve had 3 new ones in that time and switched to BMW. Mercedes full of electrical issues, BMW to date has been faultless!

  • @drifterx007
    @drifterx007 Před 9 lety

    excellent review!

  • @alej469
    @alej469 Před 9 lety

    Fantastically articulate review!

  • @pascalmpower7944
    @pascalmpower7944 Před 9 lety +3

    The AMG weight 63 kg more than the M3 but 0.7 second behind vs the M5 50 anniversary 600 hp but 360 kg heavier but the gap between M4 and 50 anniversary M5 is around 0.2 second.
    The M differential have better locking ability than AMG's, it means the rear have less grip than the front, gives a sharper steering. The AMG doesn't have it, the rear doesn't have as much locking as the M, it just gives closer traction ratio between rear and the front, for car weight that much, it'll just under steer. At corner exit, it got too much torque, 516 lb/ft, sure it'll over steer. At corner entry, it weight heavier, sure it'll over steer a bit into a corner too. Also at 8:53, the M3 locking ability brings some over steer but at the next corner, the weight transfer of the AMG will upset the dynamic.

  • @party_boy69
    @party_boy69 Před 8 lety +16

    lol at everyone saying a pro driver would drive the 63 quicker. Why does it matter? You're all pro shit talkers, not race car drivers...keep it real x

  • @michaellui74
    @michaellui74 Před 8 lety

    great review 😊😊

  • @michaellui74
    @michaellui74 Před 8 lety

    great reviewer. can you review 2015 r8 v8 last of v8 r8?? thanks

  • @SRT8ClassicDriver
    @SRT8ClassicDriver Před 9 lety +3

    which is more fun on the street? I don't care much about track & lap times

    • @mahmoudhakem7642
      @mahmoudhakem7642 Před 2 lety

      Obviously the beamer that merce is for driving elegant not particularly fun

  • @M3Conv
    @M3Conv Před 9 lety +3

    The M3 has always been better than the C63, it goes without saying

  • @TheJoeMB
    @TheJoeMB Před 9 lety +1

    Both are cracking cars, I'm an ardent M3 fan but the Benz is spectacular as well. Great video.

  • @tomscott88
    @tomscott88 Před 9 lety

    Great vid

  • @CaldeAilis
    @CaldeAilis Před 9 lety +4

    AMG is great at making muscle cars. Sports cars, not so much.