Was Race A Factor in Supermarket Stabbing of Boy in Shopping Cart? | Bionca Ellis Case Analysis
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 06. 2024
- This video answers the question: Can I analyze case of Bionca Ellis?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
The judge that turned her loose needs to be disbarred
Even judges have to follow the law. The judge said he had no legal grounds to hold her longer.
She is still in jail. The judge set a very high bond that she has no hope of posting.
We just heard the judge LIED to cover his own ass and did not get her mental help 😡
@@teddy2577 What timestamp was that? I must have zoned out.
I heard him say that the judge had to release her because it would be unjust to keep her there on such a small offence.
@@azrobbins01With HER record?? NO GODDAM WAY!!!
She is NOT insane. She is EVIL.
She looks possessed.
She is black
@@B-I-G-N-A-S-T-Y Totally is. You can see. I'd be interested to know what she's dabbled in. Unfortunately we don't always hear about the other stuff people do because people don't connect it but some people are doing dark things and they are truly possessed and this is often the result. Disgusting.
I don't think she is evil at all. She seems to be doing the only thing that makes sense in lieu of society today. Her actions make sense and they have a valid explanation. They make as much sense as all the attacks on Israel by Palestinians. If you know you are right, and the other people are born sin wrecking the world, stopping them the only way you know how makes absolute sense. Shouldn't we start to pay attention to the world we live in, the way it is now, without making up excuses for it?
She's not evil at all, not by modern progressives standards. Why don't more defense attorneys say the truth, that since all media is absolutely anti-white, anti-white male; their actions are absolutely understandable, as we see these kinds of race attacks happen all the time. There is a reasonable explanation for it, and it starts in schools, then on tv, in movies, in the new, like WaPo, CNN, New York Times and multiple other progressive media. Woke means anti-white, anti-white man, because white men are to blame for everything from black crime to climate change. It is a valid reason, not an excuse for someone's behaviors like this. She probably feels like a hero doing the only reasonable thing she could do to stem the horrors of white men.
Race was a factor both in the murder and the judge's decision to set her free
Prove it...🤡
@@TomikaKelly as doctor grande always says, it's just a theory, my opinion, if you allow us to have an opinion that is.
There is absolutely no racism in America “anymore”…
The judge who released her has that little boy's blood on his hands.
that little boy clearly started it, if he didn't call her a fat n word he would still b here
But at least they can’t call him a wassist… priorities
@@jamesm3471 A "wassist"??? That's a new one to me.
Judges get guidance. Who gave the guidance?
@@LucyKelly-of6cuGeorge Soros
If the races were swapped with this crime, the media wouldn't stop talking about how race was the main motivation.
@@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTimethat’s fact so stfu
There is baiting
There is speaking truth
When the truth is shut down, all that's left is baiting.
@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTime it's not bait, it's reality. Look at the recent cases in New York, LA, Illinois, Washington, etc where they get turned loose
@@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTime
Doesn’t make it untrue
This woman is clearly has mental issues. She should have been being treated INSIDE a facility. What's sad, since you're bringing up race, is that people like that don't recieve the needed treatment because of their race. It's partially because it is viewed is nornal behavior for that race. Unfortunately, she probably chose this poor little boy because she knew that his race would increase the possiblity of a long stint in jail.
I worked as a nurse in a state mental hospital in the 70s. We were told, “ Don’t fear the patients who are in this hospital & on medication; fear those who should be here, but are not.” Now most of those state psychiatric hospitals are closed. Sadly, we now all must fear those who truly should be confined to a mental institution.
Thank GWBUSH and Rick Scott
@@texasrefugee7888 It was the Reagan Administration.
Margolucas No truer words have ever been spoken.
Thank Ronald Reagan for that. He closed down all mental hospitals and single handedly created the homeless problem in the US. Shame.
Thank Ronald Reagan for closing all mental hospitals. He single handedly created the homeless problem in the US.
That judge is a POS. He should be disbarred and then charged with negligence. He doesn't even sound sorry. Excrement.
No doubt.
We don’t know what information he had. I doubt he knew all of the different things that she had been arrested for over the years.
All he have is that she was in jail for an arrest warrant stemming from a prior shoplifting charge.
There was nothing to suggest that she was going to do what she did. Magistrate thinking that she needs an evaluation is not enough to justify holding her. The only legal justification for holding someone is if they are thought to be a danger to themselves for others.
The judges are useless not all of them but you get more for lower crimes than you do actions like this?? The sentence should fit the crime.
she is out?
@@chrhadden No lol. She’s got a $5M bond. No way she gets out.
100% racially profiled her victim. Judge is vile and also responsible.
A baby stabbed IN THE FACE!
Incomprehensible.
The terror and pain of this child.
I bet the mother has lost the will to live.
My brother died when he was 15 and my parents went through a dark period of emotional estrangement for about 5 years, and the light of joy in their eyes didn't return until my daughter (their granddaughter) was born 17 years later. This couple has a rough journey ahead.
I'm praying for the parents, The pain of their loss must be unimaginable and unbearable. Breaks my heart.
Yes I agree
And in his back! 😡 The mother has two other children for whom to live, but the pain has been devastating. The father’s appearance in court was gut-wrenching. 😢
@@zyrrhosso sorry to hear this. Must have been so so hard to see your parents in that way for so long😢 My cousin died same age 5 years ago and that dark cloud still hasn’t lifted 😢
Waste of space, waste of air, waste of time, waste of resources...
You should pray for resources - if there was the appropriate medical mental health intervention this tragedy would not have occured !
Sadly, prayers will come too late and will end up helping neither the victims, nor the perpetrator. The victim lives with the loss the rest of their lives, the perpetrator loses…their freedom? Their ability to recuperate? I have little sympathy for the perpetrator
and sorry to say but most people can't be helped. We can't even find good care for our elderly or children at daycare. sick individuals everywhere. u have to take care of your own because Noone else will.
@@wookiedude21 you said "waste of resources" when actually it is the deficit of resources that was the problem!
Obviously a waste of a wheelchair too
I am not the person who first brought up race. It was BIONCA ELLIS when she said "I killed a WHITE bartender".
I think she is responding to her environment that raised her. I don't know why more defense attorneys don't use this defense in court: She has been taught to believe in every single institution in the USA that white men are the cause of all evil in the entire world, including climate change. It is a valid defense, because she is taught who is evil in schools, universities, media, movies, television, New York Time, CNN, Washington Post. Salon and multiple other sources, and it is a valid REASON why she must cringe in fear thinking that this white boy might just grow up to terrorize the world. I'd place a bet that millions of Americans are silently happy or outwardly happy she did what she did.
so you are racist too?
you just mentioned WHITE.
it is a description of the person she claimed she killed
agreed,the little boy ended it, called her a fat n word begged for murder & she gave in
So? White people always refer to black people as “a black person”
Just did it right here case in point
Why can’t the police give her the same treatment? 😢
In the face? She stabbed that poor baby in the face!!? 😡 The terror they all must have felt really hurts my heart. The loss of a baby in such a senseless, violent way must be unbearable. Prayers for his mom and family.
My heart breaks for this one. His poor parents and siblings. They did nothing wrong. I'm also in NE Ohio and shop at a Giant Eagle. It hits so close to home.
I live in this community and this is very hard.
it was also the fatal wound as the knife penetrated the nasal and sinus cavities into the boy's brain.
Don't live where people like Bianca live
@kenw2225 dumb comment. How would anyone know how Bianca was if they didn't know her at all. Crazy people lives everywhere and travel everywhere! It's disrespectful to the family for you to say that as if the mom purposely allowed her son to be in a dangerous area. For all we know, you might have mental health issues and snap just like this crazy lady did! It isn't safe anywhere is the best thing to tell people instead of blaming them for being at the wrong place at the wrong time.
My father had taught me always to take the child out of the shopping cart and put him or her in the car before unloading the groceries, but that was because of the possibility of the cart rolling away. One of his colleagues in the trucking industry was just cruising along and a shopping cart that a woman had left her child in went rolling down to the end of the parking lot and tumbled down an embankment and landed in the highway right in front of the truck. So I never left my kids in the shopping cart because of the fear that the cart might roll away. One thing that had never occurred to me to fear was that a random person would just come up and stab my kid while I was unloading groceries.
I always used to worry about my children being snatched so they would always go in their car seats first. They are the precious cargo, not the groceries. Not blaming the mom, at all just I think this is a good safety precaution to take.
I always put my kids in their carseats before loading the car with groceries. I'm not sure that would have saved this child. She targeted him and followed them to their car. She would have found a way to get to him.
@@edelweiss2.076 The whole thing is just so horrible and totally unpredictable.
I don't shop where people like Bianca shop.
Remember kids
Monsters are real
I’m 64. When I was a kid it was the boogeyman. In the closet or under the bed. I’ve since learned they are very real. And out from under the bed. Pulling strings.
No one called the police on someone just walking with a knife? Rest in love, Julian. Sending healing to the mother.
no men were shopping at the time.
Didn't wanna be accused of being r@cist
i’m guessing nobody noticed? i live here and people definitely would’ve called the police if they saw.
It's called political correctness
Horrible! What I find equally concerning is the fact that she was able to walk around the store for a while with a large blade in her hand unnoticed by anyone! Know your surroundings!!!
Around blacks never relax
They noticed. Protected classes have the upper hand if one has concerns and brings them to the attention of responsible parties. Our local Giant Eagle has private security at the entrance.
Can't understand security missing this or at least another shopper would notice and raise a red flag
This happened in Oceanside California. Some dude wanted to return to prison so he killed a grandma out in the open where everyone could see.
Confronting a black carrying a knife is considered wayciss. What people need to learn from this is whites are being hunted by blacks. Avoid them at all costs. If one is approaching you, be prepared to go all the way. Because they are and as you can see here, they think it's funny
It kills me seeing the pics of these child victims on the thumbnails. I can’t help but think of my boy. What a tragedy 😞
As a mom of a toddler, dear God! I can't even imagine the pain the mother is going through. 💔 The poor baby I can't even go there mentally Gosh! Evil is real
@@jeanedarcwhy do you have to bring the conversation to your toddler. Talk about wanting all the attention on yourself
@@567Seviper Please keep your negative energy to yourself. I hope you heal from whatever is bothering you.
In Poland, we had a similar case when an unemployed man with financial difficulties left the employment agency feeling upset. He grabbed an axe from the closest store and suddenly struck a ten-year-old girl who was walking by with her mother. It was during the middle of the day on a busy street. His goal was to go to jail or prison. The girl didn't survive the attack. It's crazy.
Ahhhhh 😢that's horrible.
There are other ways to go to prison without murdering children ffs.
It is a societal wrong that people have so little money that jail is seen as a solution to homelessness.
@robinantonio8870 actually, you have to try really hard to end up on the streets in Poland, or any other EU country. There're no excuses for that murderer. He and his family was on welfare for years and he felt entitled to get money from the government for nothing. One of the suspected motives was the fact that he recently lost the unemployment benefit.
Was it a black on white attack situation? It happens in Philadelphia PA USA.
This UNBELIEVABLE. The number of times this woman vocalized she needed to be incarcerated and the fact that she walked around with a massive knife in hand and not a soul noticed. I don't even know what to say. That poor, poor child. I hope his mother and the rest of his family can somehow find peace again one day.
she vocalized she need mental health help. big difference and now it's too late.
99% of people (exaggerated but probably not far off) walk around with their head so far up their ass
no people noticed, they are just all cowards afraid to be "racist" or something like that
They all do.
It’s amazing the lack of coverage this is getting.
I live less than 30 miles from where this happened. I never heard anything till 3 days after the 3 year old died.
This is so heartbreaking.
Why report it? There are no riots, fires, or protests.
@@sharonpowell3656 why??
Because a young boy lost his life. Because parents had to bury a child. Because siblings will now grow up without their brother.
This mom was doing something that most people do everyday. And that was shopping.
Should have never happened. Never!!
It is heart breaking- but the MSM is under strict orders to downplay crimes committed by diverse persons.
If it was the other way around the president of the United States would be talking about it...
@@sharonpowell3656So is your point that white people need to start acting more like the blacks?
This makes me furious. The system failed that family. This woman was clearly very ill. She was not safe to be around innocent people. I can't imagine the devastation this has wrought upon the child's family. I'm disgusted with everyone that played a part in letting this woman walk free into an unsuspecting community.
The great excuse in the 21st century! NOT every evil murderer is "mentally ill!" Did you watch her sentencing? SHE was self aware.
A true tragedy with too many missteps!
I agree. She was basically telling people she was going to do something to get herself in jail. Anyone could see that. They just did not want to deal with her and kept passing the buck.
@@nise5281 it's not an excuse. It's the truth. And more importantly, if she had either been treated or permanently admitted, this would NEVER have happened. Mental illness is NOT a get out of jail free card. If a person is sick, and becoming increasingly dangerous, it's on society to deal with that, not just ignore them until they kill someone. How about we try to prevent the fire before it burns the fucking building down?
@@SueP-jg9vxyou literally can’t imprison people for being “mentally ill”.
Judge did nothing wrong 🤷♀️
She and only she is responsible for this. Period.
Ugh, I hate seeing her face. I hope they are giving her hell in jail and they better not put her in isolation. Let her get everything that's coming to her.
😈
It's usa not russia. She is treated to 3 free meals a day, free water, shelter, shower, medical, clothing, TV, sometime even free PlayStation. If it was russia, she would be beaten, feed rats, hose down during shower time, lock isolate from any contact.
I have to look away from the screen when her face comes up. It's revolting.
Because she is a human being, but not a person, you can't "give her hell in jail" because she has no idea what that might mean. In fact is she is beaten to death I think she would simply accept that experience.
Regardless of how one feels about Bionca Ellis, it seems clear to me that she is highly dangerous and resourceful. The other inmates deserve to be protected from her.
I agree that she did the crime to be incarcerated. She probably wants to be taken care of and have her needs met without doing anything productive. Her smirk is repulsive. That little boy didn't have a chance against her evil nature. She will probably hurt people in prison after she finds out how tedious it must be. She is a predatory creature.
cctv footage shows the mom being attacked 7 uses the boy to block the knife strikes smart move or she might have died 2
hurt people in prison? lol its the prison, and those who reside their that hold all the cards, not her.
Yeah, she seems like she had the mental capacity to think that far ahead lol
@@JasenFromBostonthis is nonsense
She gave clear warnings of what she will do in order to be held in jail and she did it. She is not crazy and should be held accountable. Ohio is a DP state and this one might qualify due to the cold and calculated targeting of her victim.
So she wanted to go to jail for legitimate crimes, and they didn't incarcerate her because it's what she asked for. They were like, "Yeah, you might be dangerous, but we wont give you jail time if you like jail." She repeatedly tried to commit crimes to go to jail and DID NOT. I am not surprised at all that she would resort to something they couldn't ignore. An innocent child died due to the pathetic judge who wanted to be contrary. She could have been in jail for nonviolent offenses. But no. Let's CHALLENGE insane people. That definitely won't have any bad repercussions.
Imagine the level of cruelty to knive a happy friendly 3 year old kid to death. I dont care for her issues. Nothing excuses such an act of pure evil. I also think race played most likely a role because she would probably have had a harder time killing a black kid.
Anyone who would kill a random kid doesn't care about anything period so I doubt the race had anything to do w it. That kinda evil has no preferences
So what? The boy is dead. It really doesn’t matter now. What matters is how to prevent this sort of thing in future.
@@ausarbyrd4778.... I disagree I think this was racially motivated. There were a thousand different crimes she could have committed that did not involve killing a little white boy. She selected him because he was a little white boy
She did it for shock value and I believe she hates white people
@@ausarbyrd4778 she most likely targeted them because they were white. Plain and simple.
So she was a walking nightmare. And the judge knew it and let her go.
Woodchipper 🤷🏻♂️
2 quick
@@jamesfrench7299 Feet first.
That footage honestly looks like something right out of a real life horror movie 😢what a terrible tragic experience for that mother to lose her son like that 💔
Imagine the rioting if the races were reversed
Why would they riot if the suspect was actually ARRESTED AND TREATED LIKE A CRIMINAL?
Well, Dylan Roof killed 10 black people that actually prayed with him before HIS rampage, and there were no riots. So, there probably wouldn't be any if the races were reversed. This woman is just insane.
Black on white crime will never be called for what it is. Oh no, let's not go there. Oh but if a white woman targeted a black child... God forbid!!
Like in the earlier days with the lynchings, Dogs biting, fire hoses and Mobs of angry.....citiens.....and other unspeakable acts?.....Yeah I can only Imagine......
One day, race won't matter.
No!!!!!! Why won't people call for what it is... A freaking hate crime!!!! Im sick of pandering because of race....
But you get upset when black people jump to the same conclusions
As long as black people get the same pandering when it's an actual hate crime, I agree with you.
She may hate white people BUT I think first and for most the racial factors was strategic for her- she already claimed her goal was to be put behind bars and so due to common media discussion about white victims cases being taken more seriously she seems to have taken that into consideration to get the cops/courts/ media attention
@@stevenleonard1493no, the comment is pointing out those people’s hypocrisy in doing so
@@willnill7946 what people? Who is not calling this a hate crime and pandering because of race? Be specific?
Regardless of her level of culpability, how could she have made it any clearer to the authorities that she was seriously mentally ill and/or posed a significant danger?
If someone falsely confesses to murder in a neutral setting (e.g. not when being interrogated or to gain prestige with gang members), they obviously need immediate evaluation.
Gosh ! That creepy, evil smirk. But how could people just ignore a person wondering around wielding a knife in public??? 😢
To avoid being accused of racism.
@@NJards-zt4fp better being called a racist than to risk innocent lives, don't you think? That poor child and his mom!😥
@@NJards-zt4fp better to be called a racist than to risk innocent lives, don't you think? That poor child and his mom! So sad. So senseless.😥
Not that it excuses it, but she was only in the store for 90 seconds.
It has to be. If the races were swapped you would be hearing about this for the next 25 years.
And you will be denying it for the next 25 years
@@mr.denzelsausageton9719 there is no denying the savagery of this morbidly obese thing.
Exactly, and literally nobody would be asking if it played a role... This country has lost its damn mind.
@@mr.denzelsausageton9719Denying what?
@@AvidiaNirvana it is like this in England. Every day our own are getting slaughtered and the msm are still talking about a murder in the 90s.
I think it was a mixture of race & he was little & couldnt fight back. I hope the other prisoners make her stay in prison miserable.
There's a lot of women in prison who are mothers. There are also a lot of mothers in there that have had similar circumstances where their kid was killed.....
I don't think it had anything to do with race. I think she just wanted to do something that was guaranteed to keep her in prison... which she did. But why did she have to do that to a child? Why not punch a cop in his face and keep getting herself in trouble in prison so they never let her out?
But then again, what kind of sane person _wants_ to go to prison? We need a better mental health system in this country. We need to recognize the difference between the judicial system and mental health systems. That judge wasn't qualified to understand the importance mental health plays in public safety.
@@sirdopaminesjournal3292good insight.
@@sirdopaminesjournal3292This is the 2nd time I'm hearing that someone wants to be in prison. There's a woman from my town who said she was overwhelmed by work and life in general, so she considered becoming a nun but that felt like too much work as well so she got herself a gun, robbed a taxi driver at gun point and stayed with him until the cops arrived, which got her a few years.
(She is now an anti CPS activist claiming they took her kids for no reason other than being a single Mum. And the taxi driver has ptsd and cant work anymore)
Or they make her stay a very short one. If you know what I mean.
Just cause someone is mentally ill doesn’t mean they can’t also be evil. They are not mutually exclusive.
The last judge involved with releasing her should be held criminally and civilly liable for her actions.
YOUR explanation of WHY she committed this horrific crime, PROVES 100%, she's NOT CRAZY!!!! She KNEW EXACTLY what she was doing, why she was doing it and when she would do it!!! STEALING the knife, WAS premedition! ABSOLUTELY NOT A PSYCHOTIC BREAK! Smirking at camera in court is a ploy to make ya'll think she's insane!!! SHE'S PLAYED THE SYSTEM LONG ENOUGH!!!
💯
I think she is a sociopath, which makes her "crazy."
This was the comment I was scrolling down to read..... I'm not the only one who thinks this. As of now you got 2 comments and 16 likes when it's the top comment imo!
Well obviously she knew what she was doing. She wanted to be in prison. The system is the whole problem.
Not a psychotic break, just a certifiably crazy person. She made statements to that effect
Of all the crimes to commit, she chose the worst one imaginable. So tragic. I’m glad that you covered this outrageous story. This case highlights a need for change
What changes do you propose?
Actually given the child was white she may get off
@@FaxanaduJohn Mass Incarceration Plus XXL Mega Edition
Bring back insane asylums!!
@@FaxanaduJohn Confinement of engroes in koncentrationsläger
Can’t get arrested, can’t get incarcerated. She thought: I’ll show them!
What a tragedy.😪There was simular case in Newcastle , Australia where man came to local police station asking to be imprisoned or put in mental hospital as he has" thoughts of killing "...policemen laughed at him and after 7 days hi did kill somebody...
Thank you Dr Grande
100% yes. End of question
@@summrflowers7253That’s the problem with this country. Minorities are organized and make a ton of noise until they get what they want. The rest of us, or the majority who are law abiding citizens and working taxpayers are basically told to sit down and shut up!
They told us they would behave if they got this and that!
Gays get to marry, have disgusting parades and their month of recognition. This month!
I think Christians should organize a big parade in a big city and see how that goes! Traditional families encouraged to attend! Please come armed!
Mental health services are a year waiting list and doctors cant prescribe psych medication anymore. I live in the area and this is the reality.
@@summrflowers7253almost like it's not true. These brainlets just want to stir up racist bs.
@@hollyfabianiShhh you’re supposed to let them think this, it’s all they have.
Can you imagine the outrage if the roles were reversed? Of course it was racially motivated.
@@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTime yes because outrage over this would also be unwarranted, the only true outrage here is the failure of the judicial system.
@@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTime - you all? Racist much?
@@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTimeyou’re a warped fantasist.
@NobodyHasToAgreeAllTheTime so if they start acting up and rioting due to this you will agree it's warranted and justified? What a crock of b.s. Listen here it wasn't warranted then in 2020 and it shouldn't be warranted now. Evil is evil regardless of it's color.
@@RamseyUnit I’m sorry, I don’t know the protocol. Was I supposed to racebait first like original commenter?
Wow she really walked through the Walmart with a knife out… don’t ever come at me about racial prejudice. All these people let this person walk around freely with a knife in her hand.
Maybe the other shoppers were staying clear of her and not confronting her for obvious reasons - nothing to do with race.
@@camellia8625 No, I think they know better than to call 911 on a black person.
It was a Giant Eagle supermarket. In most places they don't have even a security guard although it depends on the neighborhood. North Olmstead is mostly white and it could have been her motivation.
Yes, racial prejudice doesn't exist because a woman walked around with a knife in a store that sells knives for 90 seconds....🤡🤡🤡
@@TomikaKelly lol ok Tomika. It’s obvious the backs of your hands don’t match your palms
I am so sickened and saddened by this that U-tube would ban me for life for saying what I am thinking right now.
Switch letters with numbers.
Huwhite peps are cowardly and weak.
Just claim you want to do it to white people and youtube will allow it
Likely the same things I've said about the two "men" that targeted the poor child Emmit till in Money Mississippi
@@edj2045Yeah you should look up Emmett till's dad...
Idk about race..but these people who randomly attack are scary as hell..imagine just trying to get your shopping and you NEVER come back home...that poor baby boy..horrific monstrous unimaginable
Imagine watching someone carrying a knife in their hand through a store & no one says anything!?! The whole damn place was insane!
@@jessieyork4508 yeah that was nuts.
Never relax.
@@jessieyork4508See something, Say nothing culture
Severe mental illness is color blind.
Have a happy father's day Dr. Grande.
She was maximizing her chances of getting the jail tenure she so desperately wanted. And the poor child and his mother? Jurisprudence and the justice system failed them woefully. This is a pure tragedy.
agreed free biance ellis! free bianca ellis!
Poor little sweetheart 😢
When I was ten my mom and I were on our way up north to meet my pop… it would be my first time meeting him. There was a black woman sitting behind us talking about how she wanted to (CZcams won’t let me say it) the little white boy (me) sitting in front of her and it scared my mom into leaving the bus. That was almost 40 years ago. I wasn’t aware that it was happening… my mom told me why she was so upset after we got off the greyhound. When she was pregnant with me a back woman tried stabbing her in the belly with a pair of scissors in the laundry mat over a dryer in Philly and my mom wound up taking it in the hand. When she was a little girl she had long blonde hair that went past her backside and a black woman with short hair lured her and shaved it off. In high school after being repeatedly jumped by a group of black girls she wound up always keeping her back against a wall. Even after all that I never heard her use the N word or express even the slightest bit of animosity towards anyone. We used to stand in those welfare lines and she told me in the car (a car given to us by a local church we didn’t even go to) we may be poor but love makes us rich. I’ve never seen a stronger woman than her. She is beautiful beyond words. My old man sued her for custody and won after that but I’m glad I had the opportunity to remember her as she was.
Exactly there are many blacks & whites who preach they want equality.
But they do nothing to make it happen.
As for me & mine we do make it happen & always have.
Sad so many others don't 💔💔💔
These are the same type of things I grew up with involving blaq women. So I know its not all blaq folks but a hell of a lot of them. So I understand how you feel.
@@beverlyamarantes9775 There are billions of black women around the world so how would you know its a hell of a lot of them? You people are so racist you dont even realise it.
@@beverlyamarantes9775 a complete account poses an existential threat to those with the means to control the narrative.
@@beverlyamarantes9775 a complete account poses an existential t to those with the means to control the narrative. To admit someone else may be reasonable is to concede. For those that have to see to believe it’s all about image
I didn't realize he passed away, my heart broke hearing that 😭 💔
How could you not know that?
I hear a lot of people say "lack of resources". There are ABUNDANT resources. A lack of willingness to abide by some of the rules that come along with assistance and aid lies squarely in the hands of the person receiving those resources. The resources we as a society are lacking are the asylums that were erroneously closed. People like this should not have free access to interactions with the public at large, and they are everywhere.
Your argument is not logical. You say there are abundant resources and then you talk about the closed asylums. Asylums are a resource; one of the ones which is not available; one of the ones which is desperately needed.
I’m sure what you meant by resources was food stamps, Medicare, mental health help, child protective services, etc. Those are abundant.
She obviously had enough resources to travel from Ohio, to California, to Ohio, to Florida and Ohio again. I make good money and can’t afford to travel like that.
@@juilenechilton544 She clearly hitchhiked.
@juilenechilton544 Hitchhiking and exchanging services for money or a ride exists. Some people can get anywhere without a single coin inside of their pocket.
I completely agree with Dr. Grande--Bionca Ellis is an example of what the immortal bard Maya Angelou said: ""When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time." I don't think her actions were racially motivated, I think she wanted to go to jail and she repeatedly figured out ways to make it happen. She kept upping the ante until she figured out a way to make it permanent.
"immortal bard?" Please! One of the most selfish, overrated women ever. She was a terrible mother and person, her own son couldn't stand her. Her writing is nonsense disguised as sage wisdom.
It was racial! She would never have picked a black child to murder! She went for the one that would inflict the most pain on the public knowing it would be all over the TV! Get real! She went for his face! She hates white people!
@@slypork5030 whoever composed Beowulf may have been the sorriest sumbitch of his time--but his work survives and still has power. Caravaggio was a murderer and (probably) alcoholic but his paintings are still considered masterpieces today. Richard Feynman had a long record of sexual harassment of women but his work in physics still stands. The list goes on endlessly of flawed humans who produced great works of art, literature, science, etc. Maya Angelou is in good company.
@@GrainneDhub-ll6vw Not the same, she wasn't a doctor or a physicist who was a bad mother. She was a woman that pretended to be maternal and styled herself as some kind of mother goddess when she was anything but - that is just called lying. Her writing is tripe that was fitting for its time but is now redundant.
@slypork5030
Sounds like Alice Walker--another mediocre "artist" who used her platform to pontificate about her superior wisdom and nurturing qualities. Her daughter bore the brunt of her toxic narcissism and no longer speaks to her
Strange how this isnt getting national attention like other similar crimes have.....
This leads me to speculate that for some institutions MONEY is more valuable than life.
In the UK we used to have residential mental institutions for such people.
They were closed in favour of ' care in the community '
Saving money had absolutely nothing to do with it, absolutely nothing, not a thing.
I suspect you're right.
Mental hospitals in the US will hold you longer if insurance is paying even though you're stable, but kick you out if you're still struggling and the money is gone.
I understand they're businesses, but it leads to some wonky outcomes. I guess it keeps lawyers busy too!
In the UK she would likely be sentenced to a hospital order rather than a custodial sentence as the rules are less stringent here. Once it could be established that she was mentally unwell at the time of committing the crime it would be more likely that she would be given a hospital order. In the US it’s more difficult to plead insanity and she will end up in jail.
A man that lived a few miles from me, was let out of a mental health facility, the next day, he killed his wife and child. He said the devil made him so it. I struggled to drive past their house for a long time after hearing about the details.
Death sentence.
Getting mental health services anywhere within a 30 mile radius of Cleveland is a YEAR waiting list. I live about 15 min away from there and this has been my experience. Its only 3% black per census bureau in that area. Cleveland and surrounding areas seem to use self segregation. You're better off walking to Mexico for Healthcare than waiting around in Cleveland.
Bring mental asylums back! As well as forceful admittance to these institutions, not voluntary admissions
Did you even watch the video? She's not criminally insane, she belonged in jail not a hospital. Also, mental hospitals do exist. Comments like this are really bizarre.
@@WevilShortcrest
For extreme cases and they are a kind of jail.
There were a lot more mental institutions 40 years ago and it was better, and they could still be better.
@pebblepod30 It was not better at all. They were even more abusive back then than they are now, and even more perfectly sane and innocent people were forced into them too. Nelly Bly exposed one of the worst examples in a famous report.
Both. Obviously Bionca wanted to be admitted somewhere and wasn’t able to make that happen. Let people voluntarily admit themselves and let people be forcefully admitted, if necessary.
Two things can be true at the same time: historically people were abused in asylums, AND there is a legitimate need for asylums to care for those who cannot function in society.
This woman was simply to lazy to work and looked at jail as free room and board.
100%
Also too lazy to walk
'Content of their character'
SMH
Or maybe this woman was completely insane.
There's countless lazy people, that doesn't mean they're going to go out and kill someone on purpose to go to jail. Get real.
Don't see how race could be a factor - as you said, she was only in the store about 90 seconds and latched on to the helpless baby in a trolley the moment his mother crossed her path. She wasn't there long enough to look around and select a victim out of a wide range.
FINALLY! Someone who saw the cam footage, too! YES! This was not random. But, it also wasn't about the child's race. Maximum bang for her buck... they weren't sending her to prison for lessor offenses, after all. Killing babies is what it takes these days!
Imagine the savagery that would go on if the races were reversed.
Everybody in this country would know her name and the victim's name... Instead, crickets
The only savagery in history has come from THEM! Get real!
Ohio would be burnt to the ground by now, film stars celebrities rock stars talking heads, taking the knee, whites renouncing their own race.
Imagine the denial that would go on if the races were reversed....🤡
@@AvidiaNirvana Who is stopping YOU from spreading this story?
This is disgusting. I couldn't help but start crying when I thought of the mother and what she must be going through. I have a 2-year-old and I don't even want to think about the turmoil my mind would be in. I do appreciate how well you cover each one of your cases! Too bad the media doesn't have your brave take on things! ❤
She doesn’t LOOK right. The judge who released her sans mental health evaluation screwed up very badly
Do any of them?
You can't hold someone off of looks.
@@TomikaKelly Tell that to the dead 3yo's mother...
Race was 100% the deciding factor in her choice for victims.
Utter nonsense
I agree with Scott Adams.
@@aeris2001 I think she is responding to her environment that raised her. I don't know why more defense attorneys don't use this defense in court: She has been taught to believe in every single institution in the USA that white men are the cause of all evil in the entire world, including climate change. It is a valid defense, because she is taught who is evil in schools, universities, media, movies, television, New York Time, CNN, Washington Post. Salon and multiple other sources, and it is a valid REASON why she must cringe in fear thinking that this white boy might just grow up to terrorize the world. I'd place a bet that millions of Americans are silently happy or outwardly happy she did what she did.
It wasn't
Stop playing the race card please
Why are the rights of a handful of mentally unwell individuals, more important than the safety of the community at large!?!
Very levelheaded analysis as always. What an awful crime on someone so young. I can only hope for the mother and father of that sweet boy to get some kind of peace.
Of course race was a factor.
I think she was specifically looking for a child.
I don't see any reason to assume that. She could simply be just fucking crazy.
@@Ipetamdoubt she would have gone for a future suspect
100%
I think she’s insane.
You analyze this case accurately and your analysis is correct! This young woman was an inconvenience to law enforcement and the court system which is why she was allowed to be released back into the public several times. It is beyond comprehension a person can be walking around with a grocery store with a knife and NO one notices or says anything! My condolences to this family for their loss. It’s just a sad case of invisibility as you so well pointed out. I agree with the statement from the mother of Bionca that the system failed her daughter. As result an innocent life was taken which could have been avoided!
What happened to Julian was truly horrific. Rest in peace little guy, I'm sorry that society failed so massively to protect you
Seeing her follow so closely just gives me the chills. Don't ever let someone get that close to you! Make sure they don't know you are on to them. One time I was being followed on the sidewalk and I did an about face and went the opposite direction on a dime. I then lost myself in a crowd.
Well if the races were reversed the question wouldn’t have to be asked
One day, race won't matter.
What question would be asked?
It wouldn't be asked at all unless the perp was a cop.
And if it was a woman, she'd still get off lightly despite race. All these poor kids getting graped or offed by mothers, teachers, aides, and other female guardians makes me sick.
@@Lilboozibert I think she was a woman. At least she's claiming to be one
@@dekev7503It would be a statement.
They shouldn’t be able to disregard another judges orders for a mental health evaluation and release them . This case has been so hard for me to listen to because my son is 4 years old. It makes you scared to leave the house. I honestly don’t know if I would survive something like that. Seeing her following them in and out of the store made me feel sick. My heart goes out to the family especially mom. I’m so so sorry.
One more thing that proves she's not crazy! When the judge questioned her, she knew exactly what was being asked and answered appropriately! She just WANTS everyone to think she's crazy and unfortunately she'll get her way AGAIN!!! People! She stabbed a 3 year old to death!!!
She's not going to get out on insanity... unless they REALLY don't want her!
I feel terrible for the mother.
A family member has had mental issues and refuses meds but hasn’t made threats to the public. She did threaten the court. She has now been locked up for 2 months and recently deemed unfit for trial. She is in a no bond state but the judge is holding her bc she threatened members of the court. It just depends on who you threaten.
so true. wow
Nice job, in stating all the facts! Adding that she was invisible in society brought an eerie aspect to the story. Very effective
Race was a factor.
Sorry... instructions unclear. I started diagnosing straight away.
I bet you did! It wasn’t about race. This woman wanted to be in jail or prison because she can’t make it out there because of her mental illness. I’ve seen people like her before she is not that smart, but I think she wants to state to take care of her so she committed to any type of crime she wanted to go to prison.
Dr.Grande , with the high percentage of Blacks in greater Cleveland , WHY did Ellis CHOOSE a little White boy to be her victim ??
I think it’s race
Considering she mentioned the race of the fake bartender she killed (being white).. I think it's at least partially race motivated.
I doubt she would have killed a 3 year old black boy.
Shhh stop noticing
How would he know?
@@midheaven_mimi This is about his opinion -- that is what they are asking is his opinion. No one asked him to KNOW.
Unfathomable... May the Wood family heal despite their heavy loss. Rip sweet baby.... I am sorry...
Can't even go out in public without this, unreal.
What a sad case again. The justice system failed to detain or care about her behaviors. Great analysis again. Thanks Dr G😊💞💞
We desperately need mental institutions to be reopened. Protect the innocent public!!
how dare you reopen those institutions ! They are racist !
That's not even the problem: it's not being able to afford such things. Who will finance them? And if there are people who would finance them, why didn’t they finance actual proper care for those with mental conditions?
@@everlynevins State funded mental institutions/asylums were not uncommon before the 90s. However, through the insistence of the contemporary liberal, grifters, politicians and their ideologue masses they were shut down as places of cruelty and overall unpleasantness.
That's only the solution for extreme cases anyway. A solution to avoid putting an unstable/pitiable person in prison where they essentially belong anyway.
Instead of funding the government machine it seems more sensible that we, as a society straighten up and start raising better kids instead of obsessing over entertainment, ideology, laziness and self pleasure. These are the kind of children these types of people produce.
The problem with humanity is humanity and all any government of any type has ever done and ever will do is make it worse.
@@everlynevins Clearly the cost of NOT having Asylums is greater in the long run.
What's the old saying: 'An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure'
Whether the justice system does too much or too little it too often does the WRONG thing!
'justice' = 'disgustice' .
This had EVERYTHING to do with race, those who say different are willfully ignorant at this point
Absolutely. I'm kind of glad this is one of the first few videos of Grande's that I've seen. It reveals early that he cannot assemble a comprehensive personality profile to see the spiritual dimension. He is limited, as that deplorable judge was, to nothing more than the cold, clinical evidence. For him to understand that race was a factor there would have to have been two mothers in that store: one black, one white, each with their own 3 yr old boy, at the same time, side by side and then if the white boy was attacked race "might" be a factor.
This inability to see the real dynamics at work such that only the superficial "facts" can be considered is a huge problem in the justice system and society as a whole.
Thank you for your analysis on this case, Dr. Grande. I appreciate the time and research you put into every video you post.
The problem is that the judicial system isn't set up, nor does it understand how someone's mental health can affect public safety. From a criminal justice standpoint, what the judge did makes sense. There was no "legal" reason to keep her incarcerated for so long for such a petty crime. *HOWEVER,* if the magistrate suggests a mental health evaluation, then just do it because if it turns out that this person really _is_ disturbed, not only is this person in need of help, but helping this person can also potential protect the public. Instead, we deny coverage and just let let crazy people who can't afford insurance just roam the streets and only after they cause someone harm is when we wonder what we could do to prevent this.
She seems well organized in everything. Coherent. I think she wanted to be in prison to be looked after her needs. That poor little boy, so horrific.
She uncovered how these people are dealt with now…
Yes, this very clearly mentally disturbed person was coherent...
@@TomikaKelly being mentally disturbed does not necessarily equal being unaware of one's actions and being unaccountable.
*unauthorized use of property*--One of the most creative euphemisms for attempted theft--EVER.
Such a horrible horrible crime!!! That poor baby & Mom!!!! No words for this situation- 💔
Ironic that her name means "white".
Yes it was 100% charge her/it with a hate crime
Prove it.
@@TomikaKelly nice name
I really hope this case isn’t over shadowed by race (I know it will be). What’s more important here is that Bianca showed very blatant signs of mental illness, she confessed a desire to harm others, she even requested to be arrested and placed in jail. There was no reason for it to get to this point. Mental Health is not taken seriously enough in this country and we will always be at risk for these incidents.
I see you support her, if it was reversed you would be screaming it’s about race
@@willnill7946 No I wouldn’t because I’m not a puppet, if this was a white woman who killed a black baby after repeatedly requesting incarceration, after repeatedly admitting to homicidal thoughts, I would blame the state for not taking action. And no, I don’t support her or her actions. She killed a baby, regardless of his race that baby didn’t deserve that.
@@willnill7946 Quit playing the race card. 😂🤡
Agreed. Mental health is not a priority in this country.
This is beyond horrific. I can't even imagine this happening. That beast wanted to be in jail. That is where she should have been. Since no one would lock her up she made sure that whatever she did next would give her her wish.
I’m willing to bet in her state of mind and the reaction she had that it probably was race motivated
Her state of mind is so insane i don't know how there'd be that much logic behind her actions. She's clearly extremely mentally ill.
Quit playing the race card. 😂🤡
She was homeless & wanted shelter … what a COWARD .
I know what you say is sarcasm
But she murdered a child to get what she wanted
Shouldn’t she be called a coward?
She could’ve found a job before doing that
She obviously had a family that was concerned for her did she use that option
She is a coward and worse. Homeless-ness does not equal virtuous
@@schultzannie sir , nothing I said was sarcasm . She was homeless & wanted shelter .
SHES A COWARD amongst other things … but this is CZcams’s .
Pay attention
@@Venise7777 than I completely agree
Yes! Same type of trash that get pregnant multiple times just to stay in Section 8 housing and on food stamps. It's disgusting. Absolutely no regard for life. And we wonder why today's children are turning out to be selfish and entitled. Because of the selfish parents who brought them into this world for their own benefit.
another point is that she really wanted to be in jail, shows that she was looking for an institution to stay in, i live in NYC and there are mentally ill people all over the place, it is dangerous, the leaders in our country don't take care of our welfare, How does this mother feel???
Just because race may have been a factor in her choice of victim it was not the reason for her crime. It wasn't a racially motivated murder, it wasn't a "hate crime". If she'd murdered a black child the same way it wouldn't have provoked such a shocked national response.
Her goal was incarceration anywhere at public expense and she needed public attention to get it. She's smiling so much because she's achieved her goal.
Racism
I was waiting on this analysis
What a shame , this is tragic on so many levels. Thank you for your insight into this situation Dr.Grande!
The authorities massively failed this little boy. If they'd have done their job Bianca would have been committed a long time ago and a life would not have been lost. I agree, I don't think race played a role I think age and defenselessness was why he was selected. Very tragic occurrance 😓