“If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”-- Malcolm X
Yes exactly! Palestinian Christians go all the way back to the time of Jesus! Christianity basically started in Palestine, and Jesus's birthplace, Bethlehem is in the West Bank! Jesus was a Palestinian Jew.
@ca8944 palestine, jordon,Iran,Syria,Lebanon,Iraq basically every Arab country has Christians didn't you see israel bombed a church in Lebanon this week. And they've bombed churches in PALESTINE!
There are 10 could be true i still need to read up a bit more about that but 20% of the Israeli population is arab and 18% of the Israeli population is Muslim ☪️, that's a fact ,Israel I think is the only country in the middle east that shares some what of the same western values and standards
Regardless of your view on the topic, I think it's safe to say - school's choose what they teach you. If you're ever wondering "why wasn't I ever taught this" when hearing about things which are referred to as "common knowledge", this is a good place to start asking why public education wouldn't tell you about it.
Because it's pretty much all about religious beliefs and religion isn't taught in public schools. This conflict is one of the main reasons I won't ever practice any religion.
Thank you! I was thinking it's actually crazy how much Americans in general, it seems like, don't really know much about the outside world, I don't think it's because Americans are 'stupider' or more 'ignorant' than the rest of the world, I think the problem comes down to the public education system, I'm not sure about education in the US but here in Australia, if you go to a public school theres a pretty good chance your education isn't up to the requirement you need to be a successful and productive member of society
@@kmojo8396As a US teacher, and someone who has traveled internationally a lot, I can confirm that we have one of the worst public education systems. Schools teach little to nothing about anything in the world unless it directly involves the US (so for ex., we learn about the world wars but mostly in the context of how we were involved, so something like how WWII impacted the middle east or Africa or anywhere else would not be included. Until adulthood, I literally had NO idea that anyone else was affected outside of the US and the European countries directly involved in the fighting - including this Palestine issue.) Most Americans don't know even the most basic amount of geography or world knowledge. We are also not allowed to talk about politics or religion in school, even from a purely educational standpoint, which is ridiculous. Even our own history is very sanitized and white washed. Much is glossed over and left out, which tells a pretty biased view of things. Plus, depending on what state ur in and what area, not only does the quality of education differ dramatically but even the CONTENT of what ur learning is a bit different and biased towards the beliefs and political leanings of that state. Anyway, I could go on and on but suffice it to say that I've been to 3rd world countries where the ppl are far more educated than Americans are in all subject matters. Even if they can't go to school due to poverty or war, they still learn about the world bc the news, TV shows, movies, etc. in other countries are far more international. They're watching content from all over the world. Sometimes my family across the world would hear about news of things happening here BEFORE we would. When I travel, I would find people abroad more knowledgeable about what's going on in American politics than a lot of Americans. They also know more about American geography than a lot of Americans. Many Americans wouldn't even be able to LIST all 50 states, let alone find them on a map (this is literally a joke on Friends where they try to list all the states.) Americans mostly only consume American content and watch American news. Most Americans don't even own a passport and have never been outside the country or region. They have such an isolated American exceptionalist view of the world and don't see where they have been fed narratives that are inaccurate bc they aren't exposed to other worldviews. This shows up in some of the reasonings these young gentlemen express. For example, many Americans think of the entire middle east as an overall hostile and dangerous part of the world. I once overheard a young man telling a young woman that he was traveling to Dubai, after which the girl expressed concern about whether he'd be safe there. I wanted to laugh and be like clearly u know NOTHING about Dubai if u have to ask that. The UAE is in the Gulf - one of the wealthiest parts of the world. Many seem to think the entire middle east is just a war zone or something bc the only time we ever hear about the middle east is in the context of war and islamophobia. And we never learn about how our country gets involved in all these wars and why, so people act like everyone there must just be barbaric ppl who enjoy war and dictators or something. Or that they're backwards ppl who live in the desert and ride camels. Or just a lot of ridiculous misconceptions. We also don't learn all the ways our government secretly props up all sorts of dictators around the world to suit their political interests. But alas, as noted, it all goes back to a terrible education system, coupled with a lack of diversity in media, that leaves the overall population completely ignorant to so many things they really should know, both about our own country and about the rest of the world whose policies and lives we have far too much control over...
𝐀𝐁𝐒𝐎𝐅'𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐋𝐔𝐓𝐄𝐋𝐘, w/the American public school system. Today, History class has now been taken over by gender studies🤦♀️ And why do ppl think we’re screwed as a country..
You would think us people would do the right thing knowing history or not lol. Me being a white male shouldn’t need any history lesson on why I shouldn’t own a black person lol. I’m just being sarcastic your right
Not all Jews are religious; Jews are also an ethnic group and a nation. Examples of non-religious Jews include Albert Einstein, Sigmund Freud, Karl Marx and Theodor Herzl. One third of Israeli citizens are non-religious Jews ("Hilonim").
That's the thing. This has been going on for THOUSANDS of years. This is simply one more chapter. The crazy part of it is the way people are reacting in our country. It's terrifying. The difference now is we have the internet, so we get to see it all in real time. Fact is most don't truly know the whole picture/history. Thanks for informing people. Great vid guys. Thank you. ❤️
To clarify - The Arabs didn’t largely colonize Palestine, they mainly used the land for military purposes as well the collection of Jizya taxes for protecting the non-Muslim inhabitants. The Palestinians are mostly descendants of the remaining Israelites as well as Canaanites. They converted to Christianity when Christianity was born, and most of them converted to Islam between the 9th and 13th century (mostly between the 11th-13th century).
Actually the DNA study found Jews were more closely related to the Bedouin’s and the Druze. They are most likely the people of Canaanite. The Palestine’s are more closely related to the people of Jordan/syria. Which makes sense since they came to Israel 1000 years later.
Yes!! Props to the Cartier Family for trying to educate themselves on all the various issues before forming a conclusion or taking a side!!! God Bless you all! ❤
Syria and Lebanon and Iraq don’t have peace deals with Israel. It’s not a genocide, just ethic cleansing because they want the land that’s the whole reason the expulsion happened in 1948 and 1967 and why Egypt and Jordan won’t agree to take refugees. Not because “Israel” is standing on business.
The Arabs were offered a 2 state solution on 6 separate occasions, and rejected all offers, including the one that gave them 96 percent of the land they were asking for.
This video didn’t mention that Israel had the weaponry and the air-force of UK, France and USA all of the time while Arabs doesn’t have as advanced capabilities. It didn’t mention that UK, France and Israel launched a war on Egypt. The west has always have been involved in these wars. Israel was not alone
Yeah that's how wars work just because one side isn't as advanced as another, doesn't mean they should be given a win or something. Think about the Native Americans. Not as advanced and got their land taken from them. War is evil but that's just how it is. Should Israel be giving Palestine weapons to fight them. Doesn't make sense. But again, war is evil. Trust in God, Amen
I recommend you guys watching a CZcams video called ''فلسطين..حكاية الأرض'' which translates to ''Palestine..the tale of land''. It is presented by an Egyptian called Al Dahih who throughout the video tells the story of Palestine and stresses that he used Israeli resources in the making of the video. The video is an Arabic, but if you open the captions, you will find English translation.
No, almost everything that comes from the Muslim side is cherry-picked anti-Jewish & anti-Israeli propaganda. Not that this vid was too well-made either.
fellas just want to give y'all props for being curious and trying to learn about stuff like this. keep on keepin' on! the world is interesting and we gotta lot time here....might as well learn where we've been, where we are, where we're going
I love watching them learn, but I wish I was in the room with them to answer questions and clear up confusion 😂 Also to say the things that are missing from this video, or overly simplified.
Also, the majority of that 750,000 were told by the Arab armies to leave! They said, "Leave for 2 weeks and once we drive all the Jews into the sea, you can come back." Only a few thousand were driven out by the Israeli army. And 150,000 chose to stay! They now number 2 million Arab Israelis!
Fun fact; When the Ottoman Empire invaded the palestine region, there were jews living there, and some of them converted into Islam that's why you will find historians say that Arabs that are currently living in palestine (not all) have Jewish blood line as well but they're not religiously Jewish cause the word Jewish can refer to athnicity and religion
They mostly were, they converted to save on heavy taxes and others fled. The jews that returned though were not arab they were european. Abraham was a Iraqi man that had son called issac ,Isaac son was called Jacob that formed the 12 tribes of Israel.
@@abedmansour93 there's Christian and Jewish Arabs would be the correct way of putting that. Islam is a belief structure. Those that follow Muslim teaching are Islamic.
We are canaanites and all descendants of the prophets baxk then and all of them were jews then came christianity and islam. It was not a problem ever before european. White people who happened to be some are jews decided to have politcal movement called zionism to take over palestine as they believe it is their promised land
@@thetntgirlanimation I did and read the history as well. Believe me, the last thing I would do is believe a biased source that doesn't distinguish between the origin of the language and religion. And the source did not mention that the Arabs were present in Palestine before the Prophet Abraham, and they were not a minority as this biased source mentioned.
@@thetntgirlanimation It is an Arab land for Arab Muslims, Arab Christians, and Arab Jews, and not the land of those expelled from Europe. However, everyone has the right to live in it, but under the banner of the State of Palestine, only Palestine. And of course not by occupation.
@@Mo99f10 hey man as much as I'm trying to come from a neutral perspective.. I'm from Israel and I do think we have rights to defend ourselves cuz if not we will simply not be.
Ask Thomas Sowell, you know he will tell the truth as it is. This is a complicated situation, with lots of emotion on both sides. Sowell always breaks things down and gives balanced explanations.
another thing to note is Palestine doesnt actually have an army they only reason israel was able to defend itself against all those countries was because the US was funding it
ofc it was America who else would it be? imagine those jews that were KICKED OUT OF EUROPE, arrived with no clothes, how do you think they would have any power to fight against 3 arab nation? AMERICA IS THE ANSWER
If they had an army, they would win. So dont think when those kids whos parents have been killed by bombs over the years that they will not keep fighting. If you are saying the truth you know that its not ok to put kids at 3 years old in jail? Because they are palestinian. And if they were so mighty than they would not have to bomb that little strip.
It is not college that failed on the basics - it is the primary/secondary school curriculums that have changed and are failing. I admire what you guys are doing, so no offense, but I am amazed at things you guys have not been taught and do not know about that I was taught in basic primary and secondary school.
💯 🗣🗣 I'm guessing you and I went to school in a different time than these youngsters 😅 I came up with Ireland/UK conflict and a MUCH broader understanding of world politics and basic history/facts.
as an egyptian the fact that you guys are willing to learn and keep learning is always appreciated cuz most americans aren't even aware of their own country involvement in other countries bad or good which is tough considering the news or the media covers jackshit so probs to you guys
Why is the wall between Egypt and Gaza more impenetrable than the one's between Israel and Gaza? It's almost like no one wants to deal with that death cult
One question. So it’s truth that Israel won against 4 Arab countries that’s crazy… and all that sinai land Israel took and gave back ? Why it gave back so much?
_”Why did you take MY land?”_ *”How is this YOUR land?”* _”My father gave it to me.”_ *”How did he get it?”* _”His father gave it to him.”_ *”How did he get it?”* _”He fought for it.”_ *”Ok, fight me for it.”*
They build the mosque in jerusalem on top of the site that used to be the temple of solomon. Basically to assert their dominance and disrespect the previous ocupants after they conquered the area.
@@FloridaMango They did not colonize Israel. Various groups "conquered" and governed the area but did not have permanent colonies. Every population (except for Christians) left the area with the subsequent "conqueror" EXCEPT for the Jewish people, who never completely left. Ever. There has been a Jewish population consistently (proven fact by genetics, historical records, and archeology) in both regions (Israel vs Palestine) for thousands of years. Jews have lived and settled the land the entire time (just with fluctuating populations), not just since WW2 like social media tries to claim.
Abraham was married to sarah and she thought she couldn't have a baby so she let him have baby with a servant. Sarah ended up having a son and then she made the servant and her child leave and Sarah's child recieved everything even though he was not the first born son of Abraham. The servant girl was from Egypt. That is where it all started.
Fun Fact: Abraham was not a jew! Because Judaism and Jews came from Judah. That wasn't established at the time of Abraham. Another Fun Fact: Abraham was an Iraqi Arab, who also travelled to Saudi Arabia. Another Fun Fact: Canaanites were also Arabs. Another Fun Fact: Muslims did not displace the population of Palestine but liberated it's people and brought, jews and the "wrong" kind of Christians back to Palestine. Another Fun Fact: The Crusades, were some of the most brutal massacres ever committed, killing Jews, Christians and Muslims alike. Another Fun Fact: Muslims never forced anyone to become Muslim, the population converted over the centuries and the Arabic language of Palestine has deep connections to ancient Hebrew, and Aramaic because Jesus was an ancestor of the Palestinians. Another Fun Fact: Not all Jews in the world are originating from Palestine. There is such a thing as Jewish conversion and it was a lot more common than you might think! Sorry... I'm just frustrated that Israels disinformation is successful! Have a nice day and may Allah lead you to the truth. -.-
I wish the documentary spoke on that because yes that is where all this started. Although you could even take it back a little further with King Saul, his prophet Samuel told Saul that he was supposed to kill every man women and child in Canaan and he went against Gods will and God said they will always be a thorn in their sides. The profit and strong man Samson had the first conflicts with them
@@shaheempashua6924 yes, that is true, but just like Isaac and Esau, the first, born right is a man-made selfish right. Firstborn privilege has been the start of so many problems in this world.
@@RichardTavilla The Palestinians, do not care about any of this. It's life under occupation and opression plain and simple.... We don't even care about Israelis being jewish as most Palestinians are decendents from jews... we also habe nothing against Judaism, it actually might be the one thing we can agree on for the most part!
For correct : The Al-Aqsa House was already built before the Roman invasion. And they rebuilt it when Islam spread and turned it into a mosque and then built the Dome of the Rock and supervised it by a Christian and a Muslim
i knew about all this stuff since i was in elementary school. thats what they mean by school standards. we learned about history from all around the world and conflicts.
GUYS U MISSED THE PART IN THE VERY BEGINNING WHERE THEY SAID THAT THAT THE JEWS CAME TO “CANAAN”!!!! This is important because Palestinians ancestry can be traced to Canaanites who converted to Judaism later to Christianity then islam even after the jews dispersed. Just cuz they changed their religion to islam doesn’t mean their DNA changes they’re still Canaanites when muslims came they said convert or pay taxes so they converted BUT THEYRE STILL CANAANITES changing religion doesn’t change DNA
In recent decades, several studies have been published in the field of genetics of populations that dealt with the genetic connection between Jews and Palestinians, In a study published in 2010 that dealt with the "total genome structure of the Jewish people", the Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudis. This genetic affinity, according to the researchers, is consistent with the theory that these groups "have a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula". Another study published in the same year demonstrated that the Palestinians, along with the Bedouins, Druze and Southern European groups, are the closest genetic neighbors to most of the Jewish populations. Additional genetic studies published in recent decades demonstrated that at the paternal level there is a clear genetic link between Ashkenazi, Sephardic and Mizrahi Jews and the Palestinians; The same studies showed that Jews from these tribes are genetically closer to the Arabs of the Land of Israel than to their non-Jewish neighbors in the Diaspora. These findings are consistent with the explanation that some or most of the Muslim Arabs in the Land of Israel are the descendants of local residents, mainly Christians and Jews, who converted to Islam after the Arab conquest in the seventh century. Some Muslims arrived in Israel during migration from North Africa and Turkmenistan and even Bosnian Muslims. surnames of many of the Palestinians indicate that their origin is outside the Land of Israel Although the Jewish population shrank dramatically throughout the periods of Roman, Byzantine, Crusader, and Islamic rule, a Jewish presence continued to survive in the region
Canaanites were literally nomads and DNA points to Jews and what we call Palestinians sharing common ancestry. It's a war between people separated by faith, but not origin. The only political constant in this region is conquest, but if you want to be a jerk about who came first with religion then Islam and the Muslims have no claim as Islam was invented last. Hell, even the Quran cites the per-existence of Jews and Christians and cites the importance of Jerusalem to the Jews. Nobody can claim sole ownership "From The River To The Sea"... not at all.
@@max_coast Jews settled in CANAAN (self explanatory they mingled with a few of the Canaanites) giving them a small % of Canaanite DNA, that doesn’t make them the original Canaanites (unlike the Palestinian) nor does it make jews a close ancestors to them . Palestinians genetics have been studied by using human leukocyte antigen (HLA) gene variability and haplotypes. That prove they’re Canaanites. Closest ancestry to Canaanites if u look at a gentic profile is the Palestinians & Samaritans pbs.twimg.com/media/F9OSisEbMAI06x9.jpg. Don’t project jewish belief on Palestinians no Palestinians in the world claimed they own the land because islam said so they claim the land because thats were they were since the beginning of time and since before the jews came in 1250bce since before the jews, greek, roman, ottomans came. Plus not all Palestinians r muslims u idiot. This is about indigeneity to the land not religion.
That is simply not true and a ridiculous attempt at revisionism of history for political gain!!! The ancient Hebrews were a Canaanite tribe! The Canaanites were consisted of various tribes, most of them disappeared from that land over the centuries, leading the path for the Hebrews/Jews to establish the monarchy of Israel and Judea! Vast majority of Palestinians today are mostly Arabs who invaded the land of Israel in the 7th century onward. Some of them are indeed descendants of Jews who were forced to convert to Islam, but they are tiny percentage!
The fact that ANYONE would criticize you guys is horrible!!!! You are putting yourselves out there and wanting to learn!! I find y’all so refreshing!!! And inspiring! Y’all let’s fill the comments with praise for these guys!!!
I hate to say it, but they're not retaining information...you have to be able to do that to learn. They remind me of conversations with pot heads--unfocused and repetitive. This was very frustrating to watch, but I guess we can give them credit for trying.
@@countreekiddyou don't hate to say it. they are retaining information just fine. You want them to be scholars already in this area? there's so much information to grasp now in a short time than in the 70s give them a break.
Try historical fiction Caribbean by micheaner, Hope and Glory about founding of Israel, Exodus by Uris, wilbur smith about the Belgium Congo slavery horrors, Tai Pei by Clavell, my favorite as an introduction, King Rat
One thing I wanted to say, Arabs have always lived in Palestine since the time of Isaac and Ishmael the sons of Abraham. The Jewish lineage stems from Isaac and the Arab lineage stems from Ishmael. They’re literally cousins from 2 brothers. Also the Arab-Israeli war with multiple countries was won due to Britain and other European countries putting embargo’s on all the Arab countries, basically leaving them with limited weapons while at the same times flooding Israel with weapons. They couldn't have won without Europes support. Britain is literally the source of this issue, from the moment they gave Palestine to the Jewish people against the wishes of the indigenous Arab Palestinians. Lastly, before the 1980’s no “extremism” groups existed. These Arab countries have been bombed none stop for the last 20-30yrs. It’s hard for the neighboring Muslim countries to do anything when their own country is falling apart. Since the fall of the Ottoman Empire 100yrs ago, there has been active ongoing colonization in Arab lands until this day, Israel being the modern example. These were a few things that were missing from the context. Thank you guys for reacting to this video and learning more!
Ja richtig aber richtige juden nicht Zionisten Israel ja die juden glauben nicht an Islam weil ibrahim sein frau hajar putz frau war Ibrahim sein erste Sohn Ismael war von ihn stammt an ende profet mohamed freiden und segen sei mit ihn
There were no arabs in the state of israel when King David founded the kingdom 3000 years ago. On 683 ad the Arab muslim invaded israel and that's how the Arab got place in israel. You are making your own history defending muslim that exist late 600ad
And that is your problem right there. You deny the existence of indigenous Jews who deserve to also have their own land and country since the jews have been treated by powerful Arab conquerors like subhumans throughout history. Just because a majority of people disagree with something, It doesn't mean it shouldn't have been done, otherwise a lot of good things that happened in history wouldn't have happened if consensus was a necessity especially when the British gave the Arab muslims Palestine AND Jordan. The jews having their own land and country is a sensible and necessary thing and the Arab Palestinians having their own land and country is also a sensible and necessary thing, but the thing is, Arab muslims from the Palestinian side don't and will never accep the existence a Jewish State and that is right there. . The Arab Palestinians thinks they have the sole right to whole of Israel and Palestine and the jews are just immigrants and settlers which is not true. The. Jews have always lived in Israel, they have about as much claim to the holy Land as much as the Palestinians, if not more so. Much of the Palestine population came from surrounding Arab nations just as much the jews migrated from Europe to the holy land to escape persecution and genocide. The hatred and dislike that Palestinian muslims have for the jews is deeply entrenched and religiously motivated. Any religion that says the end of days will not come until they fight a rival religious group cannot co-exist with that group. Its deluded of us to think otherwise. I guess Israel and Palestine are locked in an eternal war since Palestinian Muslims will never accept the existence of a Jewish state and jews will never relinquished the right to their ancient holy land.
Guys ...ur initial conversation exemplified why the American education system is so flawed 😂😂😂😂 but...I am very impressed n proud of ALL of you for expanding your knowledge base👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 #Trump/Ramaswammy2024
At least when we went to shool, HS and College actually had a very good education. History was my favorite, bar none. "If we forget history, we are doomed to repeat it again". And it hasn't been taught much in modern days.
The problem today is nit just what's not being taught. It's what is being taught alongside what isnt and moreso it's that the willfully ignorant won't listen even if you were to teach
when the video their reacting to is 10 minutes and your video is almost an hour really shows how committed y'all are. I appreciate you guys reacting to this cause this is a very sensitive topic for me and my family.
He got it right. People are being made to hate Israel but are made to feel sorry for Palestinians. It belongs to Israel as far as im concerned. Arabs have enough states. Israel should be able to have one.
Imagine your holy temple, where King Solomon built the literal house of God, being taken over by your enemy and being told they have a right to it even though it was under Jewish law for hundreds of years first.
The temple was destroyed by Romans in 70ad. Although it was still a consecrated site and significant to the Jewish religion when the Al Aqsa Mosque was built. However-the large majority of todays Israeli population is secular. So, is it really about religion for the majority of Israelis? Besides all that-think about who was “occupying” the United States in the seventh-ninth centuries….. should we give our homes/land back to native Americans because our ancestors treated them horribly and drove them out of what was rightfully theirs? By your logic, we should. And Europeans drove our native Americans hundreds of years after the Ottoman Empire conquered What is now Israel/Palestine.
@@av2827 The native americans weren't given their land by God. In this scenario, I am saying that anyone has the right to the land it is the Israelis. If I could choose, Jerusalem and all other lands would be Christian, but I am inclined to support the Jews because Jesus was Jewish and not Muslim. Plus, I don't recall a Jewish terrorist organization doing much terrorism in, say, New York city. I would like for there to be a great Crusade to win back the Holy Land, but right now keeping it out of the muslim's hands is the next best option.
@@orionmobile6545 I am genuinely confused at this incoherent statement. The Prophets weren't muslims, they were Jews. The pharisees and the Jews were in fact mostly ignorant when Christ came and regarding the prophets prophesizing about Jesus, but they weren't muslims.
How could we know? School taught us lies and never talked about foreign conflicts except minimal world War 1 and 2. We're just finding out now about all of the lies they've told us. And I think you guys are great. You're not dumb because you don't know every little thing ❤❤
As an Israeli It's nice to see you trying to learn about the conflict. One thing that bother me as an Iraqi descent Jew, About 45% of the Jews in Israel are descent from Arab countries, not European. Jews were ethnicity cleanse from ALL Arabic countries in the area at around 1948 and had all of their land, property and possession stolen in that act. When we say we have no place else to go to, we mean it.
Many Arab countries didn't even get independent and autonomy 1948 stop lying and use sympathy, The Algerian Jews even fought with the french against the demands of independence, Jews where they go they aligned with the powerful entitie, they did so even with the Muslims in way back so people can't trust you anymore. If the Jews didn't had any place to go why Palestine and Arabs why they didn't stay or migrated to the West, the West seems welcoming beside the good life, instead the West weaponise you and you keep ethnic cleansing the area, I don't know how that is better for you that's f* up.
Thank you guys for seeking knowledge I would just like to say that Arab doesn’t mean Muslim. That why you have Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Muslims
Preach this the part that was aliasing me off that they think it’s just a Muslim vs Jew thing. When there’s Christian’s and Jews that were already living there as Palestinians.
The historical program you are watching falsifies history. The Jews came from Egypt to the land Of (The Arabs) Canaanites, not the Canaanites only, and there were people living there whose name was the Canaanite Arabs.The one who produced the documentary program that you are watching is also a Zionist. The land of Palestine is not the land of the Jews as they claim. So why is there in the books of the Jews that they do not settle any land until When Jesus returns and establishes their promised kingdom for them !!??
Islam was created in 550 AD Israel in 1800 BC approx Correction : Judaism... The religion was created 1800 BC... And all the ppl in the region(s) have been inter-marrying since before Islam was even a (heretical) thing
In recent decades, several studies have been published in the field of genetics of populations that dealt with the genetic connection between Jews and Palestinians, In a study published in 2010 that dealt with the "total genome structure of the Jewish people", the Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudis. This genetic affinity, according to the researchers, is consistent with the theory that these groups "have a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula". Another study published in the same year demonstrated that the Palestinians, along with the Bedouins, Druze and Southern European groups, are the closest genetic neighbors to most of the Jewish populations. Additional genetic studies published in recent decades demonstrated that at the paternal level there is a clear genetic link between Ashkenazi, Sephardic and Mizrahi Jews and the Palestinians; The same studies showed that Jews from these tribes are genetically closer to the Arabs of the Land of Israel than to their non-Jewish neighbors in the Diaspora. These findings are consistent with the explanation that some or most of the Muslim Arabs in the Land of Israel are the descendants of local residents, mainly Christians and Jews, who converted to Islam after the Arab conquest in the seventh century. Some Muslims arrived in Israel during migration from North Africa and Turkmenistan and even Bosnian Muslims. surnames of many of the Palestinians indicate that their origin is outside the Land of Israel Although the Jewish population shrank dramatically throughout the periods of Roman, Byzantine, Crusader, and Islamic rule, a Jewish presence continued to survive in the region
I think you'll find from studies that the European groups are closer to you guessed it... Europeans. The Palestinians are native people who converted to Christianity and Islam. Nothing justifies the killings and displacing 750,000 indigenous Palestinians to create a racist ethnoreligious state that continues to occupy and oppress. @@romt-qr2ik
Israel came based on a text in the Bible, and in this same book there is a text that disproves their claim and explains who the first people of the earth were. Genesis 12: 6 Abram traveled through the land as far as the site of the great tree of Moreh at Shechem. At that time the Canaanites were in the land.
I'm a Master Social worker and never learned this history either. I'm 50 and they never taught this in school so those haters are just haters. I love how you guys are real and honest and intelligent young men with tons of promise. Never stop sharing because you make such a difference in lives everywhere. Love coming from Texas!!
If you want a video that goes really back in history with details and trusted sources about this that has an answer for almost every question, You should watch " Palestine, the tale of the land" by New Media Academy life, it uses various sources and a lot of people worked on the research, it has english subtitles but m pretty sure there is a dubbed version. Whatever you like
Friends, be careful. There is a lot of missing information in this video and a lot of wrong information. In order for the story to deviate from the true perspective, I advise you to watch the story from all sides, and the judgment is yours in the end.
considering the video doesnt mention the jews being exiled from muslim nations as well and not just europe id say it doesnt get all the info from one side either
Really? Funny how you people are never able to prove or show any examples of that being true... Otherwise give me at least 5 things the video gets wrong. And I mean 5 actual things. Not timeline errors. Mistakes happen. Obviously.
@@shakedben22considering the video doesn’t mention that before Saul Isaac Abraham there were people living there which they were “Palestinians” ! The Jewish people were exiled from that land by a foreign king who came from now we know as Iraq and he took them and made them slaves in his kingdom! On the other side centuries later the Muslims saved the Jews from Christians in Spain and they asked the Muslims to take them to Morocco with them! The Israelite kingdom he mentioned in the video for how much time did it last? 80 years maybe! So!? Does this give them the right to call it there land when there was already people living in that land!! Go educate yourself
Worth mentioning that some of the neighbouring countries stopped supporting radical ismalic groups as egypt president made it clear that hammas is now perceived as a terrorist group
I have a Lincoln Library book of Essential Info from 1955. It defined Semites as “A dark-skinned branch of the Caucasian race. It includes the Jews and the Arabians among modern peoples and, among ancient nations, the Assyrians and the Phœnicians. The name is so applied because of the traditional belief, without historical foundation, that this race was descended from Noah's son Shem.” Which means that this conflict is between two branches of Semitic people. Interestingly, Ethiopians are Semites as well, who’s ancestors came from southern Arabia. Semitism is determined by ancestry, not religion.
The term "Semite" wasn't created until the 1800s, and it is becoming frowned upon by historians because it isn't helpful in any way, being based on a set of languages, not a race. From Britannica: "Semite, name given in the 19th century to a member of any people who speak one of the Semitic languages, a family of languages spoken primarily in parts of western Asia and Africa. The term therefore came to include Arabs, Akkadians, Canaanites, Hebrews, some Ethiopians (including the Amhara and the Tigrayans), and Aramaean tribes. Although Mesopotamia, the western coast of the Mediterranean, the Arabian Peninsula, and the Horn of Africa have all been proposed as possible sites for the prehistoric origins of Semitic-speaking populations, there remains no archaeological or scientific evidence of a common Semitic people. Because Semitic-speaking peoples do not share any traits aside from language, use of the term “Semite” to refer to the broad range of Semitic-speaking peoples has fallen out of favour. For this reason, some critics even encourage the removal of the hyphen in the term anti-Semitism to help dispel any pseudoscientific notions of a "Semitic race." They advocate instead for the use of antisemitism to describe the hostility toward or discrimination against Jews as a religious or racial group. In fact, by 2500 BCE Semitic-speaking peoples had already become widely dispersed throughout western Asia. In Phoenicia they became seafarers. In Mesopotamia they blended with the civilization of Sumer. The Hebrews settled with other Semitic-speaking peoples in Palestine."
Jews are notoriously suck at two things: sports. and genocide. at 1947 there were 500,000 Muslims (they did NOT identify themselves as "Palestinians" till the mid 60's with the creation of the P.l.o - the world first terror organization). Today there are over 7 MILLION Muslims , including 2 million in Israel. How does a one ethnic/religion group grows from half million to 7 million in 75 years facing a genocide? See, WITHOUT LIES ISLAM DIES!!!
Go listen to Professor Finkelstein, or Rabbi Shapiro. Rabbi Shapiro explains that Israel was not created to protect Jews, but to destroy judaism and make Judaism a race not a religion!! Rabbi Shapiro states after reading historical documents that Zionism was created to destroy Judaism! The Zionists of that time, actually hated Jews, and wanted to change them!! The majority of Zionists that went to Palestine in 1948 were atheist or secular Jews just as they are today & not actual ultra orthodox Jews who believe there should be no Jewish state! Professor Finkelstein gives the entire history of the Palestine Israel conflict after 40 years of research and is an excellent resource!!!
something that is not pointed out enough is although Jews were offered more of the land it was less useable. It was mostly a swamp area (which is why many Jews died of malaria because of the mosquitoes) or a desert in the south where it was hard to practice agriculture. One of the biggest miracles of Israel is how it managed to create new technology and techniques to overcome those issues. those innovations are now used globally.
There is true information, and its widely available, you just have to do some basic efforts. One of my favourite videos of all time about this conflict, is a video by the name - حكاية الأرض الدحيح فلسطينon the "new media" channel. That video is so wild on so many levels because the creator "الدحيح" (daheeh) used actually verified israeli ressources to make the entire video and showcase the truth about the origin of this conflict. The cideo is like an hour long, but boy oh boy the quality is top fucking notch ( its in arabic but subbed in english). You can watch on ur own time and you will know the truth (according to israeli ressources)
I’m from Europe, but have lived in the US for a while. Unfortunately most people in the US are very uninformed and uncultured about others countries. This is basic knowledge, but the American standard education system is very subpar compared to Europe.
The historical program you are watching falsifies history. The Jews came from Egypt to the land Of (The Arabs) Canaanites, not the Canaanites only, and there were people living there whose name was the Canaanite Arabs.The one who produced the documentary program that you are watching is also a Zionist. The land of Palestine is not the land of the Jews as they claim. So why is there in the books of the Jews that they do not settle any land until When Jesus returns and establishes their promised kingdom for them !!??
Jewish is an ethnoreligion - both a race (Hebrew) and a religion (Judaism). After the fall of the second Temple in 70AD, Jews were expelled from the land of Judea and Israel, and into Africa, Europe, and Southeast Asia. This exodus created distinct racial groups (Ashkenazi, Semitic, Persian-Sephardic, Ethiopian, etc) of Jews, united by both religion and maternal line. The result of this over the last 2,000 years is several distinct racial groups who are all Jewish by either birth, religion, or both.
@@BouncySlim1 over time, this has changed to a matrilineal line, due to children being kidnapped and women being stolen into sex slavery. National Israel accepts both patrilineal and matrilineal Jewishness in claims for citizenship. Basically as long as one of your parents is a Jew, you're ethnically Jewish, regardless of whether your ethnicity is Hebrew/Semitic or not.
I asked my daughter if she was taught significant historical topics that I was taught in the 70s and 80s. Sadly she'd never heard of so many. So it's not that it wasn't taught, it's that it currently isn't being taught. Easier to mislead people if they don't know history.
One thing to take note of, during the Ottoman Empire rule, the Jews that were still in Palestine where to persecuted and where allowed to establish there own community.
@@kingdra-winston3500 sure you can. God says that he will bless the people that bless Israel. It has been their holy land since Abraham was promised from God. Also, I promise you the good guys never kill innocent men women and children.
The Arabs also received the bigger part of the British Mandate, which is Jordan! It's not fair to say that the Jews received the bigger piece of the land, because they received just tiny piece of their historic native homeland and they still agreed to it! It's the Arabs who were greedy and wanted everything for themselves, and that's why they started wars and lost everything as a result! They gotta take responsibility for their actions for once and stop playing the victims!
If you understand the logic of Palestinian supporters they say Israel is occupying their lands,yet they will say the Ottoman Empire liberated Israel. You can't have it both ways,if you believe Israelis are occupiers then you have to admit the Ottoman Empire was occupiers of Jewish lands centuries ago.
I just wanted to take a moment to express my gratitude for your dedication and commitment in addressing the complex and sensitive topic of the conflict. Recently, I came across an incredibly impactful documentary on CZcams called "Palestine: A Tale of Land," which has garnered 13 million views in just a week. This documentary is a gripping narrative backed by factual insights from Israeli authorities and historians. Your commentary, coupled with the powerful storytelling of the documentary, could offer your audience a deeper understanding of the complexities involved. I recommend turning on the subtitles to fully grasp the nuances presented in the documentary.
They were not expelled by Israel, if you look at the founding Israel documents they ask for the Palestinians to stay and be apart of Israel. The Palestinian rulers told them to leave!
At the time of the Muslims' entry into Palestine, no Jew or Christian was killed, but as for the Muslims, they allowed Jews and Christians to remain under their protection and had the right to practice their religion.
@@ENDAION THERE WAS MANY MASSACRE AGAINST THE JEWS IN 1920'S IN ''PALESTINE''. YALL DIDNT WANT JEWS SETTLING ON THEIR RIGHTFUL HOMELAND OF JUDEA. LOOK UP PALESTINIAN PRESIDENT ALLIANCE WITH HITLER. MANY ARAB COUNTRIES FOUGHT ALONGSIDE THE NAZIS.. look it up. Your statement is ridiculous. Historically, so many christians and jews were persecuted in your so valled countries
Notoriusly, ISIS was NOT opposed to isrel because in their version of the apocalypse, the jews fall last. these were opposed to nationalist groups who felt were fighting for secular "land aims" they wer enemies of the al quaeda
Please watch "Conflict in Israel and Palestine through 2015: Crash Course World History #223" by Hank Green. It gives more context to the conflict on both sides.
Another thing funny how everything radical is Muslim or Islamic 😂. But the Jewish militia when they first started attacking the Palestinians and taking their land and kick the British out were not terrorist but a militia 😒 I would say if one is going to be labeled a terrorist keep the same energy and use those same standards to label the other side a terrorist. By the way, any attack carried out in the name of Islam is not a representation of Islam. In our religion, our rules of war does not condone the killing of innocent men women or children. Even nature is not meant to be harmed. Only military personnel is supposed to fight other military personnel.
Then what is ziziya tax for non muslims isn't it hypocracy to collect tax just because they do not believe in your forced religion? For what protection? From who , islamic invaders😂
Islam was invented in 600AD far after Christianity and Judaism. The Christians recognize Jesus was a Jew so Judaism is older and Islam even mentions Jerusalem as home to the Jews (before calling them liars and saying they should be killed). The British only took control because the Ottoman Turks who controlled Palestine sided with Germany in WWI. Germany promised them stolen Russian land when they won... but sure, be upset that the people who were attacked, the British, won and flipped the script and took THEIR land. Karma. Meanwhile, Palestine, Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Iraq invade Israel in 1948 not even ONE DAY after the British hand over the keys and then get upset when the lose and lose land in the process. Had they won, would they have given Israel back to anyone and not kicked out all the Jews as they promised? Nah. The only constant in this land (besides Islam being new with no claim) is conflict. To the victors go the spoils.
Also to mention, at the time of the Ottoman Empire the three different religions lived peacefully for the most part. Religions were given the ability to rule their communities according to their religious guidelines. Christians and Jews under Islamic law had lower taxes to pay compared to Muslims. Muslims paid more taxes. Muslims paid 2.5 % of their wealth every year and non-Muslims paid a lesser tax and those how could not afford it were exempt. So there was peace between three religions
This is what I love about you guys. You research, you ask questions and you learn. This episode was soooooo interesting watching you bounce thoughts and interpretations off of one another. And this topic is indeed very deep and complicated for us to even begin to comprehend as this was and is not our history. you guys make a great team. Don't stop!
Their "research" is misguided and absolutely irresponsible. They're causing more harm than good, intentional or unintentional, with the spreading of misleading information to other viewers like yourself who have no understanding of the matter whatsoever.
@@tawfifee It's misguided to you because it goes against your beliefs of the situation. Maybe you should take a step back and not be blinded by hate and biasism and do some research as they're doing.
@@BigBoss1R I don't think nukes on Japan were justified. But, that's what I like about this channel, I don't agree with everything they say but I respect that they think for themselves.
@@BigBoss1R I'm biased because I'm American. As an American, I've learned that the Japanese did not surrender before the nukes. If you can prove me wrong with legit sources then I would love that but I doubt you can. Hirochito did not want Japan to surrender from what I understand and would not surrender unless something like the nukes happened. Maybe you're forgetting that Japan was under a dictatorship? That being said, I still don't think that justifies America using nukes on Japan. I believe there could've been other solutions to show the strength of the nukes without it affecting civilian lives. And last point, I never pointed fingers, I think all research is good and we should all be open minded and look at all sides.
@@ash__117 It's misguided because it leaves out huge chunks of information, twists narratives, changes facts, and is presented in a way to put Israel in the light of the victim. It's quite frustrating to watch. Not only did they blindly believe everything this propaganda said, but they made their own conspiracy out of it, which was so far from the truth, that it hurt... Honestly, if they are not willing to read and learn from actual historians, and from actual documents or talk to people from both sides, they won't ever understand this. And yes they will be responsible for Israel's Propaganda to spread further and further... It's extremely hard to fight propaganda from Israel, because of their extensive PR-.Budget, and it's frustrating when people are so easily falling for it... common...
This is a completely distorted story, friends. I can ask a simple question: Why is the number of Palestinians killed during this occupation not mentioned in this video? There are many details that must be mentioned that will completely change your view of this conflict. The real story is about the massacres committed against the Palestinian people from 1948 until this moment.
Have you lost your mind??? The Arabs have been massacring the native Jews in that land for CENTURIES before 1948, and long after 1948!!! The Arabs are NOT the innocent victims in this conflict. But nice try...
I hope you listen to the episode of an Egyptian influencer named Al-Daheh about the conflict. What is good is that he used Israeli sources that expose the entity.
He ignore so much, it's kinda trash. He accept Israeli data, but not the archaeological findings that put Judaism there before a modern, non nomadic city state. You can't say "I just take what Israel says" and then not take it all.
Just from your introduction discussion, I want to say that I learned about this in World History in high school, 1984-1988. I also took a foreign affairs and a current events class in high school and that was more advanced and intense history and its affects on current day events.
Just food for thought - you said (very correctly) in the video that the “nakba” was an event in which many Palestinians lost their home “due to the conflict”. If we follow Palestinians logic, all native Americans that lost their homes “due to the conflict” should get their land back. Throughout history many people lost their homes due to war and conflict (Jewish people as well, many times) but everyone moves on, they don’t. The reason behind it is not land, or wanting to return to their homes. Their reason is simply the hatred of Jews and the will to end them. And that’s the sad reality
As a christian Palestinian holding and Israeli passport living in Jerusalem. Would love to help explain the whole situation to you guys . This video is full of gaps.
Naa ..naming the land doesn't mean the people wasn't there .. palestanians are cannan ppl and the ancient hebrews who converted to christianity coz its jesus land then they became muslims .. zionest r europians who turned to judaism and never lived on palestain land or cannan land.about the temple there is no evidence they tried hard but no nothing.actually they found something in east africa only.they can go there @@queenelizabeth8253
One thing the video left out, is the Peel Commission was the first time a partition plan was offered in 1936. In that plan the Arabs were given the majority of the land and rejected it.
The Arabs are the oldest nation in history. Their origin goes back to their grandfather, Ya'arab bin Qahtan bin Sam. They were on the Arabian Peninsula, making up 30 of the Arabs of the ancient Middle East. Before Isaac, the father of the Jews, was born and lived on this planet, there were Canaanite Arabs, who were Semitic Arab peoples who migrated from Yemen after the demolition of the Ma'rib Dam. Provide history The Jews were mobile nomads who herded sheep and had no homeland. This is why they were called the Hebrews. If we assume that the presence of the Jews for a short period of time in this region on small lands gives them the right to that country, according to this logic, this means that Italy has right to the British Isles because they ruled it for a thousand years. A year and their traces are still there
It is important to note that the most of the land that the UN gave Israel was desert - the Negev Desert. The overwhelming part of the more livable land was awarded to the Arabs.
I would like to add… If you look at the biblical history of Israel and all the Wars and Occupiers throughout the years. Jews have always been in that land. Judaism came before Christianity and Islam. If you look into the modern day history of 1948 the day Israel earned its Independence from the British mandate of “Palestine” Immediately the following day they were attacked by Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Jordan/Iraq Those countries asked the “Palestinians” in the West-bank, Gaza, and within Israel’s borders to leave and promised them that they will win the fight for them. In 1948,1956,1967,1973 They technically displaced the “Palestinians” every time they lost. And created refugees in doing so. Israel never asked the “Palestinians” to leave. Ask any real non-biased historian. Unfortunately Israel always extends its hand for peace with land and the “Palestinians” (government) refuses. It’s called the 3 No’s no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel, and no peace with Israel. Israel is the only country that has given land back that they rightfully won in war in order to make peace. Israel is the only country that does strategic, surgical attacks on terrorist/terrorism with the least amount of casualties to be harmed or killed. Israel is the only country that has to defend itself from (world opinion) in order to defend itself from its enemies and the right to exist as a sovereign nation. Just look at what happened 10/7/23. Hamas is a terrorist group just like Isis “Palestinians” voted them in to power. They killed over 1200 people injured over 3000 and captured 240 hostages. They trade innocent hostages (240) for known terrorist criminals captured in Israeli jails
@@davidkash123 yeah, and if one were to say, what "religion" can claim ownership then Islam falls last. The preexistence of Christianity and Judaism is even in the Quran, which also notes the importance of Jerusalem to the Jews. Then of course it goes into the fun bits about hating Jews, calling them liars, and how to wage war on all non believers, lol. Still though, Islam is dead last in terms of the chicken and the egg dynamics.
Thank you for taking the time to create videos like this. I am Canadian and don't know much about the history of Israel-Palestine. Appreciate the content :)
Well let's take the story from a stupid children's cartoon Good job for a grown man 👏 Good plan for the Zionists Like the cartoon that Netanyahu showed about the hospital in Gaza 😂😂😂🥱🥱 Do you want realistic work? Watch the Jewish documentary... TantoraDo you want realistic work? Watch the Jewish documentary... Tantora
I'm sorry to inform you, that this video is complete propaganda! I don't know how much Israel paid for it, but they did a great job twisting history. Please forget and read history books... We can't let them manipulate people that easily
That’s a good non-biased video! If you take classes to be a religious figure or theology you’ll come across this topic. Jews do not believe Jesus is the Messiah , Christians do. I majored in communication and humanities. I am also a Christian and have studied a lot of these topics. I’m glad you guys are touching this subject.
“If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”-- Malcolm X
Bingo. He was a genius
facts!
He was talking about the white American liberal.
Aka, Liberals who are supporting Hamas.
💯
GUYS THERE ARE PALESTINIANS CHRISTIAN'S NOT JUST MUSLIMS!
Where?
Yes exactly! Palestinian Christians go all the way back to the time of Jesus! Christianity basically started in Palestine, and Jesus's birthplace, Bethlehem is in the West Bank! Jesus was a Palestinian Jew.
@ca8944 palestine, jordon,Iran,Syria,Lebanon,Iraq basically every Arab country has Christians didn't you see israel bombed a church in Lebanon this week. And they've bombed churches in PALESTINE!
There are 10 could be true i still need to read up a bit more about that but 20% of the Israeli population is arab and 18% of the Israeli population is Muslim ☪️, that's a fact ,Israel I think is the only country in the middle east that shares some what of the same western values and standards
@@MissnewsReporter where is Palestine? Who is the President of Palestine?
POV: When the history is written by an american 💀
“Amine”
Remember what Rebecca was told in the Bible about two nations struggling in her womb.
Regardless of your view on the topic, I think it's safe to say - school's choose what they teach you. If you're ever wondering "why wasn't I ever taught this" when hearing about things which are referred to as "common knowledge", this is a good place to start asking why public education wouldn't tell you about it.
Because it's pretty much all about religious beliefs and religion isn't taught in public schools. This conflict is one of the main reasons I won't ever practice any religion.
Thank you! I was thinking it's actually crazy how much Americans in general, it seems like, don't really know much about the outside world, I don't think it's because Americans are 'stupider' or more 'ignorant' than the rest of the world, I think the problem comes down to the public education system, I'm not sure about education in the US but here in Australia, if you go to a public school theres a pretty good chance your education isn't up to the requirement you need to be a successful and productive member of society
@@kmojo8396As a US teacher, and someone who has traveled internationally a lot, I can confirm that we have one of the worst public education systems. Schools teach little to nothing about anything in the world unless it directly involves the US (so for ex., we learn about the world wars but mostly in the context of how we were involved, so something like how WWII impacted the middle east or Africa or anywhere else would not be included. Until adulthood, I literally had NO idea that anyone else was affected outside of the US and the European countries directly involved in the fighting - including this Palestine issue.) Most Americans don't know even the most basic amount of geography or world knowledge. We are also not allowed to talk about politics or religion in school, even from a purely educational standpoint, which is ridiculous. Even our own history is very sanitized and white washed. Much is glossed over and left out, which tells a pretty biased view of things. Plus, depending on what state ur in and what area, not only does the quality of education differ dramatically but even the CONTENT of what ur learning is a bit different and biased towards the beliefs and political leanings of that state.
Anyway, I could go on and on but suffice it to say that I've been to 3rd world countries where the ppl are far more educated than Americans are in all subject matters. Even if they can't go to school due to poverty or war, they still learn about the world bc the news, TV shows, movies, etc. in other countries are far more international. They're watching content from all over the world. Sometimes my family across the world would hear about news of things happening here BEFORE we would. When I travel, I would find people abroad more knowledgeable about what's going on in American politics than a lot of Americans. They also know more about American geography than a lot of Americans. Many Americans wouldn't even be able to LIST all 50 states, let alone find them on a map (this is literally a joke on Friends where they try to list all the states.)
Americans mostly only consume American content and watch American news. Most Americans don't even own a passport and have never been outside the country or region. They have such an isolated American exceptionalist view of the world and don't see where they have been fed narratives that are inaccurate bc they aren't exposed to other worldviews. This shows up in some of the reasonings these young gentlemen express. For example, many Americans think of the entire middle east as an overall hostile and dangerous part of the world. I once overheard a young man telling a young woman that he was traveling to Dubai, after which the girl expressed concern about whether he'd be safe there. I wanted to laugh and be like clearly u know NOTHING about Dubai if u have to ask that. The UAE is in the Gulf - one of the wealthiest parts of the world. Many seem to think the entire middle east is just a war zone or something bc the only time we ever hear about the middle east is in the context of war and islamophobia. And we never learn about how our country gets involved in all these wars and why, so people act like everyone there must just be barbaric ppl who enjoy war and dictators or something. Or that they're backwards ppl who live in the desert and ride camels. Or just a lot of ridiculous misconceptions. We also don't learn all the ways our government secretly props up all sorts of dictators around the world to suit their political interests.
But alas, as noted, it all goes back to a terrible education system, coupled with a lack of diversity in media, that leaves the overall population completely ignorant to so many things they really should know, both about our own country and about the rest of the world whose policies and lives we have far too much control over...
@@lesterr4207World war 2 and the Ottoman Empire is non religious history
𝐀𝐁𝐒𝐎𝐅'𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐋𝐔𝐓𝐄𝐋𝐘, w/the American public school system. Today, History class has now been taken over by gender studies🤦♀️ And why do ppl think we’re screwed as a country..
“Those who don’t know history are doomed to repeat it”
-George Satayana
You would think us people would do the right thing knowing history or not lol. Me being a white male shouldn’t need any history lesson on why I shouldn’t own a black person lol. I’m just being sarcastic your right
Whose history point of view are we supposed to know?
czcams.com/video/6foH3Zc82ZQ/video.html&ab_channel=AJ%2B
Even worse when ppl know shit and still repeat it, pure evil.
@@RobRochon Prolly the one who was in deeper shit.
Not all Jews are religious; Jews are also an ethnic group and a nation. Examples of non-religious Jews include Albert Einstein, Sigmund Freud, Karl Marx and Theodor Herzl. One third of Israeli citizens are non-religious Jews ("Hilonim").
That's the thing. This has been going on for THOUSANDS of years. This is simply one more chapter. The crazy part of it is the way people are reacting in our country. It's terrifying. The difference now is we have the internet, so we get to see it all in real time. Fact is most don't truly know the whole picture/history. Thanks for informing people.
Great vid guys. Thank you. ❤️
To clarify - The Arabs didn’t largely colonize Palestine, they mainly used the land for military purposes as well the collection of Jizya taxes for protecting the non-Muslim inhabitants. The Palestinians are mostly descendants of the remaining Israelites as well as Canaanites. They converted to Christianity when Christianity was born, and most of them converted to Islam between the 9th and 13th century (mostly between the 11th-13th century).
Facts
Facts
Bingo
Tax for protection? 😂
Actually the DNA study found Jews were more closely related to the Bedouin’s and the Druze. They are most likely the people of Canaanite. The Palestine’s are more closely related to the people of Jordan/syria. Which makes sense since they came to Israel 1000 years later.
It's good to see people who are really trying to learn about the issue and not blindly picking sides❤
Yes!! Props to the Cartier Family for trying to educate themselves on all the various issues before forming a conclusion or taking a side!!! God Bless you all! ❤
😂😂😂 learn how Google 🤔 learn about slavery too much love
Syria and Lebanon and Iraq don’t have peace deals with Israel. It’s not a genocide, just ethic cleansing because they want the land that’s the whole reason the expulsion happened in 1948 and 1967 and why Egypt and Jordan won’t agree to take refugees. Not because “Israel” is standing on business.
The main issue is that they lack common sense.
@@user-lu1gr5ri4e You just say without explaining
The Arabs were offered a 2 state solution on 6 separate occasions, and rejected all offers, including the one that gave them 96 percent of the land they were asking for.
How cute!
Lies and propaganda
17:40 excellent. I love how you’re taking the time to learn this.
This video didn’t mention that Israel had the weaponry and the air-force of UK, France and USA all of the time while Arabs doesn’t have as advanced capabilities.
It didn’t mention that UK, France and Israel launched a war on Egypt. The west has always have been involved in these wars. Israel was not alone
Yes, its frustrating when they say its a miraculous victory for Israel when they were literally supported by great power nations
Also the jews were battle hardened from ww2
The ottomans didn’t give arabs basic technology
Yeah that's how wars work just because one side isn't as advanced as another, doesn't mean they should be given a win or something. Think about the Native Americans. Not as advanced and got their land taken from them. War is evil but that's just how it is. Should Israel be giving Palestine weapons to fight them. Doesn't make sense. But again, war is evil. Trust in God, Amen
As an Egyptian thats actaully true
I recommend you guys watching a CZcams video called ''فلسطين..حكاية الأرض'' which translates to ''Palestine..the tale of land''. It is presented by an Egyptian called Al Dahih who throughout the video tells the story of Palestine and stresses that he used Israeli resources in the making of the video. The video is an Arabic, but if you open the captions, you will find English translation.
No, almost everything that comes from the Muslim side is cherry-picked anti-Jewish & anti-Israeli propaganda. Not that this vid was too well-made either.
This one was perfect and could let u guys know more and more!👌🏻 I recommended as well
The best video to tell you 75+ years in one hour, and all the war crimes are from ISRAELI resources!!! just imagine the atrocities that were hidden.
great recommendation.
Great one I recommend it too
fellas just want to give y'all props for being curious and trying to learn about stuff like this. keep on keepin' on! the world is interesting and we gotta lot time here....might as well learn where we've been, where we are, where we're going
I love watching them learn, but I wish I was in the room with them to answer questions and clear up confusion 😂 Also to say the things that are missing from this video, or overly simplified.
Also, the majority of that 750,000 were told by the Arab armies to leave! They said, "Leave for 2 weeks and once we drive all the Jews into the sea, you can come back." Only a few thousand were driven out by the Israeli army. And 150,000 chose to stay! They now number 2 million Arab Israelis!
Such nonsense.
@@ccbutkus lol come to Israel and see for yourself there are arab doctors judges and even politicians where do you think they came from?
this is the nakba
Fun fact; When the Ottoman Empire invaded the palestine region, there were jews living there, and some of them converted into Islam that's why you will find historians say that Arabs that are currently living in palestine (not all) have Jewish blood line as well but they're not religiously Jewish cause the word Jewish can refer to athnicity and religion
There were islam christians and jews .. man watch kingdom of heaven if u want
They mostly were, they converted to save on heavy taxes and others fled. The jews that returned though were not arab they were european. Abraham was a Iraqi man that had son called issac ,Isaac son was called Jacob that formed the 12 tribes of Israel.
@@abedmansour93 there's Christian and Jewish Arabs would be the correct way of putting that. Islam is a belief structure. Those that follow Muslim teaching are Islamic.
Yep true most Israelis and Palestinians are genetically identical and are native to Israel and are rooted with the people in Canaan
We are canaanites and all descendants of the prophets baxk then and all of them were jews then came christianity and islam. It was not a problem ever before european. White people who happened to be some are jews decided to have politcal movement called zionism to take over palestine as they believe it is their promised land
Fam, that mosque was not built in 900 B.C., Islam was founded in 610 A.D.
It's NOT conflict, it's OCCUPATION
I guess you didn't watch the video ☠️
@@thetntgirlanimation I did and read the history as well. Believe me, the last thing I would do is believe a biased source that doesn't distinguish between the origin of the language and religion. And the source did not mention that the Arabs were present in Palestine before the Prophet Abraham, and they were not a minority as this biased source mentioned.
@@Mo99f10 I guess there is no real right or wrong to this conflict there's a whole levels of grey..
@@thetntgirlanimation It is an Arab land for Arab Muslims, Arab Christians, and Arab Jews, and not the land of those expelled from Europe. However, everyone has the right to live in it, but under the banner of the State of Palestine, only Palestine. And of course not by occupation.
@@Mo99f10 hey man as much as I'm trying to come from a neutral perspective.. I'm from Israel and I do think we have rights to defend ourselves cuz if not we will simply not be.
Ask Thomas Sowell, you know he will tell the truth as it is. This is a complicated situation, with lots of emotion on both sides. Sowell always breaks things down and gives balanced explanations.
another thing to note is Palestine doesnt actually have an army they only reason israel was able to defend itself against all those countries was because the US was funding it
ofc it was America who else would it be? imagine those jews that were KICKED OUT OF EUROPE, arrived with no clothes, how do you think they would have any power to fight against 3 arab nation? AMERICA IS THE ANSWER
calm down.
And so what ?
And?
If they had an army, they would win. So dont think when those kids whos parents have been killed by bombs over the years that they will not keep fighting. If you are saying the truth you know that its not ok to put kids at 3 years old in jail? Because they are palestinian. And if they were so mighty than they would not have to bomb that little strip.
It is not college that failed on the basics - it is the primary/secondary school curriculums that have changed and are failing. I admire what you guys are doing, so no offense, but I am amazed at things you guys have not been taught and do not know about that I was taught in basic primary and secondary school.
💯 🗣🗣 I'm guessing you and I went to school in a different time than these youngsters 😅 I came up with Ireland/UK conflict and a MUCH broader understanding of world politics and basic history/facts.
I had to learn all this shi myself💀. School only taught me about American revolution,ww 1 and 2,slavery,and some other wars.
Find Les Feldick for this is the Best Bible study for the Gentiles KJV Bible 🙏
@@gaeagaddy5099Find Les Feldick for this is the Best Bible study for the Gentiles KJV Bible 🙏 Saved by Grace plus Faith plus Nothing
same bro
@@Call_Me_Rio
United States need to stop throwing our hard earned dollars at these foreign wars😮
it's six day, not sixty and many jews considered the overwhelming victory a miracle and a signfrom god
as an egyptian the fact that you guys are willing to learn and keep learning is always appreciated cuz most americans aren't even aware of their own country involvement in other countries bad or good which is tough considering the news or the media covers jackshit so probs to you guys
Why is the wall between Egypt and Gaza more impenetrable than the one's between Israel and Gaza?
It's almost like no one wants to deal with that death cult
It’s worse; media actively misinforms if it serves the ruling class.
czcams.com/video/6foH3Zc82ZQ/video.html&ab_channel=AJ%2B
One question. So it’s truth that Israel won against 4 Arab countries that’s crazy… and all that sinai land Israel took and gave back ? Why it gave back so much?
I’m just trying to understand Im impressed that they conquered all that land and gave it back
_”Why did you take MY land?”_
*”How is this YOUR land?”*
_”My father gave it to me.”_
*”How did he get it?”*
_”His father gave it to him.”_
*”How did he get it?”*
_”He fought for it.”_
*”Ok, fight me for it.”*
This is how the world really works. People just don't want to admit it.
They watch Israeli documents hehehehe 😂
They build the mosque in jerusalem on top of the site that used to be the temple of solomon. Basically to assert their dominance and disrespect the previous ocupants after they conquered the area.
yeah... they had half of the continent but they build a mosque on top on the mount solomon.
The Roman’s named it “Syria Palestinia” over time the name was shorten to Palestine
Yeah but they’re not Syrian anymore after the Arab Muslims took and colonised Isreal and North Africa so calling it just Palestine makes sense
Palestine was a Roman derogatory term from "Philistine". It was an insult.
@@FloridaMango They did not colonize Israel. Various groups "conquered" and governed the area but did not have permanent colonies. Every population (except for Christians) left the area with the subsequent "conqueror" EXCEPT for the Jewish people, who never completely left. Ever. There has been a Jewish population consistently (proven fact by genetics, historical records, and archeology) in both regions (Israel vs Palestine) for thousands of years. Jews have lived and settled the land the entire time (just with fluctuating populations), not just since WW2 like social media tries to claim.
@@FloridaMango we palestinian Christians live in gaza to and Israel doesn't care they bomb our churchs to.
@@sivonni according to most historian we don't know that, That Roman named it or not let alone the reason.
Abraham was married to sarah and she thought she couldn't have a baby so she let him have baby with a servant. Sarah ended up having a son and then she made the servant and her child leave and Sarah's child recieved everything even though he was not the first born son of Abraham. The servant girl was from Egypt. That is where it all started.
Abraham married Hagar according to the old testament she wasn't just a slave girl she was his wife and Ishmael his firstborn son
Fun Fact: Abraham was not a jew! Because Judaism and Jews came from Judah. That wasn't established at the time of Abraham. Another Fun Fact: Abraham was an Iraqi Arab, who also travelled to Saudi Arabia.
Another Fun Fact: Canaanites were also Arabs.
Another Fun Fact: Muslims did not displace the population of Palestine but liberated it's people and brought, jews and the "wrong" kind of Christians back to Palestine.
Another Fun Fact: The Crusades, were some of the most brutal massacres ever committed, killing Jews, Christians and Muslims alike.
Another Fun Fact: Muslims never forced anyone to become Muslim, the population converted over the centuries and the Arabic language of Palestine has deep connections to ancient Hebrew, and Aramaic because Jesus was an ancestor of the Palestinians.
Another Fun Fact: Not all Jews in the world are originating from Palestine. There is such a thing as Jewish conversion and it was a lot more common than you might think!
Sorry... I'm just frustrated that Israels disinformation is successful! Have a nice day and may Allah lead you to the truth. -.-
I wish the documentary spoke on that because yes that is where all this started. Although you could even take it back a little further with King Saul, his prophet Samuel told Saul that he was supposed to kill every man women and child in Canaan and he went against Gods will and God said they will always be a thorn in their sides. The profit and strong man Samson had the first conflicts with them
@@shaheempashua6924 yes, that is true, but just like Isaac and Esau, the first, born right is a man-made selfish right. Firstborn privilege has been the start of so many problems in this world.
@@RichardTavilla The Palestinians, do not care about any of this. It's life under occupation and opression plain and simple....
We don't even care about Israelis being jewish as most Palestinians are decendents from jews... we also habe nothing against Judaism, it actually might be the one thing we can agree on for the most part!
For correct : The Al-Aqsa House was already built before the Roman invasion.
And they rebuilt it when Islam spread and turned it into a mosque and then built the Dome of the Rock and supervised it by a Christian and a Muslim
i knew about all this stuff since i was in elementary school. thats what they mean by school standards. we learned about history from all around the world and conflicts.
GUYS U MISSED THE PART IN THE VERY BEGINNING WHERE THEY SAID THAT THAT THE JEWS CAME TO “CANAAN”!!!! This is important because Palestinians ancestry can be traced to Canaanites who converted to Judaism later to Christianity then islam even after the jews dispersed. Just cuz they changed their religion to islam doesn’t mean their DNA changes they’re still Canaanites when muslims came they said convert or pay taxes so they converted BUT THEYRE STILL CANAANITES changing religion doesn’t change DNA
In recent decades, several studies have been published in the field of genetics of populations that dealt with the genetic connection between Jews and Palestinians, In a study published in 2010 that dealt with the "total genome structure of the Jewish people", the Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudis. This genetic affinity, according to the researchers, is consistent with the theory that these groups "have a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula". Another study published in the same year demonstrated that the Palestinians, along with the Bedouins, Druze and Southern European groups, are the closest genetic neighbors to most of the Jewish populations. Additional genetic studies published in recent decades demonstrated that at the paternal level there is a clear genetic link between Ashkenazi, Sephardic and Mizrahi Jews and the Palestinians; The same studies showed that Jews from these tribes are genetically closer to the Arabs of the Land of Israel than to their non-Jewish neighbors in the Diaspora. These findings are consistent with the explanation that some or most of the Muslim Arabs in the Land of Israel are the descendants of local residents, mainly Christians and Jews, who converted to Islam after the Arab conquest in the seventh century. Some Muslims arrived in Israel during migration from North Africa and Turkmenistan and even Bosnian Muslims. surnames of many of the Palestinians indicate that their origin is outside the Land of Israel
Although the Jewish population shrank dramatically throughout the periods of Roman, Byzantine, Crusader, and Islamic rule, a Jewish presence continued to survive in the region
There's no connection between canaanites and Palestinians. No biological, nor historical or cultural connections.
Canaanites were literally nomads and DNA points to Jews and what we call Palestinians sharing common ancestry. It's a war between people separated by faith, but not origin. The only political constant in this region is conquest, but if you want to be a jerk about who came first with religion then Islam and the Muslims have no claim as Islam was invented last. Hell, even the Quran cites the per-existence of Jews and Christians and cites the importance of Jerusalem to the Jews. Nobody can claim sole ownership "From The River To The Sea"... not at all.
@@max_coast Jews settled in CANAAN (self explanatory they mingled with a few of the Canaanites) giving them a small % of Canaanite DNA, that doesn’t make them the original Canaanites (unlike the Palestinian) nor does it make jews a close ancestors to them . Palestinians genetics have been studied by using human leukocyte antigen (HLA) gene variability and haplotypes. That prove they’re Canaanites. Closest ancestry to Canaanites if u look at a gentic profile is the Palestinians & Samaritans pbs.twimg.com/media/F9OSisEbMAI06x9.jpg. Don’t project jewish belief on Palestinians no Palestinians in the world claimed they own the land because islam said so they claim the land because thats were they were since the beginning of time and since before the jews came in 1250bce since before the jews, greek, roman, ottomans came. Plus not all Palestinians r muslims u idiot. This is about indigeneity to the land not religion.
That is simply not true and a ridiculous attempt at revisionism of history for political gain!!! The ancient Hebrews were a Canaanite tribe! The Canaanites were consisted of various tribes, most of them disappeared from that land over the centuries, leading the path for the Hebrews/Jews to establish the monarchy of Israel and Judea!
Vast majority of Palestinians today are mostly Arabs who invaded the land of Israel in the 7th century onward. Some of them are indeed descendants of Jews who were forced to convert to Islam, but they are tiny percentage!
The fact that ANYONE would criticize you guys is horrible!!!! You are putting yourselves out there and wanting to learn!! I find y’all so refreshing!!! And inspiring! Y’all let’s fill the comments with praise for these guys!!!
Nah let’s stop encouraging specials needs adults to get on CZcams n flex on how uneducated they r while being so grown 😂
Learning lies
I hate to say it, but they're not retaining information...you have to be able to do that to learn. They remind me of conversations with pot heads--unfocused and repetitive. This was very frustrating to watch, but I guess we can give them credit for trying.
@@countreekiddyou don't hate to say it. they are retaining information just fine. You want them to be scholars already in this area? there's so much information to grasp now in a short time than in the 70s give them a break.
@@taroute2376what in the HELL does the OP skin color have to do with ANYTHING??
Great that you put this on here ♥️😊
I love all you guys, you’re amazing
Love you guys. It’s great to investigate into historical aspects of different cultures. Good job on wanting to get more knowledge. Keep at it.
Try historical fiction Caribbean by micheaner, Hope and Glory about founding of Israel, Exodus by Uris, wilbur smith about the Belgium Congo slavery horrors, Tai Pei by Clavell, my favorite as an introduction, King Rat
Slavery is hardly unique to the American south,of blacks, 1700 to 1865
czcams.com/video/6foH3Zc82ZQ/video.html&ab_channel=AJ%2B
One thing I wanted to say, Arabs have always lived in Palestine since the time of Isaac and Ishmael the sons of Abraham. The Jewish lineage stems from Isaac and the Arab lineage stems from Ishmael. They’re literally cousins from 2 brothers. Also the Arab-Israeli war with multiple countries was won due to Britain and other European countries putting embargo’s on all the Arab countries, basically leaving them with limited weapons while at the same times flooding Israel with weapons. They couldn't have won without Europes support. Britain is literally the source of this issue, from the moment they gave Palestine to the Jewish people against the wishes of the indigenous Arab Palestinians. Lastly, before the 1980’s no “extremism” groups existed. These Arab countries have been bombed none stop for the last 20-30yrs. It’s hard for the neighboring Muslim countries to do anything when their own country is falling apart. Since the fall of the Ottoman Empire 100yrs ago, there has been active ongoing colonization in Arab lands until this day, Israel being the modern example. These were a few things that were missing from the context. Thank you guys for reacting to this video and learning more!
Buhahaha
Ja richtig aber richtige juden nicht Zionisten Israel ja die juden glauben nicht an Islam weil ibrahim sein frau hajar putz frau war Ibrahim sein erste Sohn Ismael war von ihn stammt an ende profet mohamed freiden und segen sei mit ihn
There were no arabs in the state of israel when King David founded the kingdom 3000 years ago.
On 683 ad the Arab muslim invaded israel and that's how the Arab got place in israel.
You are making your own history defending muslim that exist late 600ad
Thanks so much I was about to post this
And that is your problem right there. You deny the existence of indigenous Jews who deserve to also have their own land and country since the jews have been treated by powerful Arab conquerors like subhumans throughout history. Just because a majority of people disagree with something, It doesn't mean it shouldn't have been done, otherwise a lot of good things that happened in history wouldn't have happened if consensus was a necessity especially when the British gave the Arab muslims Palestine AND Jordan. The jews having their own land and country is a sensible and necessary thing and the Arab Palestinians having their own land and country is also a sensible and necessary thing, but the thing is, Arab muslims from the Palestinian side don't and will never accep the existence a Jewish State and that is right there. . The Arab Palestinians thinks they have the sole right to whole of Israel and Palestine and the jews are just immigrants and settlers which is not true. The. Jews have always lived in Israel, they have about as much claim to the holy Land as much as the Palestinians, if not more so. Much of the Palestine population came from surrounding Arab nations just as much the jews migrated from Europe to the holy land to escape persecution and genocide. The hatred and dislike that Palestinian muslims have for the jews is deeply entrenched and religiously motivated. Any religion that says the end of days will not come until they fight a rival religious group cannot co-exist with that group. Its deluded of us to think otherwise. I guess Israel and Palestine are locked in an eternal war since Palestinian Muslims will never accept the existence of a Jewish state and jews will never relinquished the right to their ancient holy land.
Bravo. Very intelligent dialogue in sorting out information.
Guys that's great that you all trying to find out about what going on in the world
Appreciate y’all for seeking knowledge on this ! It takes A LOT of courage to put yourself out there ! Much respect fr
Guys ...ur initial conversation exemplified why the American education system is so flawed 😂😂😂😂 but...I am very impressed n proud of ALL of you for expanding your knowledge base👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
#Trump/Ramaswammy2024
Lov that some(!) of you know history and you teach it to others(;
1947: the Israelis may have gotten more land but the land they got is utter desert
At least when we went to shool, HS and College actually had a very good education. History was my favorite, bar none. "If we forget history, we are doomed to repeat it again". And it hasn't been taught much in modern days.
The problem today is nit just what's not being taught. It's what is being taught alongside what isnt and moreso it's that the willfully ignorant won't listen even if you were to teach
when the video their reacting to is 10 minutes and your video is almost an hour really shows how committed y'all are. I appreciate you guys reacting to this cause this is a very sensitive topic for me and my family.
He got it right. People are being made to hate Israel but are made to feel sorry for Palestinians. It belongs to Israel as far as im concerned. Arabs have enough states. Israel should be able to have one.
You can just take it from the natives. Go give one of the 50 states to the Jews then.
Damn straight
@@Aaloshh Palestine. Under the British Mandate was supposed to be a Jewish state.
أيضا كان من ممكن أن تكون هناك دولة لليهود في أوروبا
Dope Channel, saying was up from Canada
Imagine your holy temple, where King Solomon built the literal house of God, being taken over by your enemy and being told they have a right to it even though it was under Jewish law for hundreds of years first.
Exactly. If anyone has a right to the land, it's the Israelis.
The temple was destroyed by Romans in 70ad. Although it was still a consecrated site and significant to the Jewish religion when the Al Aqsa Mosque was built. However-the large majority of todays Israeli population is secular. So, is it really about religion for the majority of Israelis?
Besides all that-think about who was “occupying” the United States in the seventh-ninth centuries….. should we give our homes/land back to native Americans because our ancestors treated them horribly and drove them out of what was rightfully theirs? By your logic, we should. And Europeans drove our native Americans hundreds of years after the Ottoman Empire conquered What is now Israel/Palestine.
@@cheesyfries7703 one thing u got it wrong the fact all the prophet was a muslim. The prophet told them but they didn't listen because their ignorant
@@av2827 The native americans weren't given their land by God. In this scenario, I am saying that anyone has the right to the land it is the Israelis. If I could choose, Jerusalem and all other lands would be Christian, but I am inclined to support the Jews because Jesus was Jewish and not Muslim. Plus, I don't recall a Jewish terrorist organization doing much terrorism in, say, New York city. I would like for there to be a great Crusade to win back the Holy Land, but right now keeping it out of the muslim's hands is the next best option.
@@orionmobile6545 I am genuinely confused at this incoherent statement. The Prophets weren't muslims, they were Jews. The pharisees and the Jews were in fact mostly ignorant when Christ came and regarding the prophets prophesizing about Jesus, but they weren't muslims.
How could we know? School taught us lies and never talked about foreign conflicts except minimal world War 1 and 2. We're just finding out now about all of the lies they've told us. And I think you guys are great. You're not dumb because you don't know every little thing ❤❤
You 100% never paid attention 😂
Guess world history is a joke 😂😆
These guys don't know when Jesus came, this is not "every little thing". This is plain ass illiteracy
As an Israeli It's nice to see you trying to learn about the conflict.
One thing that bother me as an Iraqi descent Jew,
About 45% of the Jews in Israel are descent from Arab countries, not European.
Jews were ethnicity cleanse from ALL Arabic countries in the area at around 1948 and had all of their land, property and possession stolen in that act.
When we say we have no place else to go to, we mean it.
Many Arab countries didn't even get independent and autonomy 1948 stop lying and use sympathy, The Algerian Jews even fought with the french against the demands of independence, Jews where they go they aligned with the powerful entitie, they did so even with the Muslims in way back so people can't trust you anymore. If the Jews didn't had any place to go why Palestine and Arabs why they didn't stay or migrated to the West, the West seems welcoming beside the good life, instead the West weaponise you and you keep ethnic cleansing the area, I don't know how that is better for you that's f* up.
#FreePalestine
ye so your solution was to do the samething towards other people solid
👏👏👏👏
@@AnimePlexerfrom the map
Growing up in the 80s we were taught the term "Jew" was inappropriate to say. It's weird how things change.
Thank you guys for seeking knowledge I would just like to say that Arab doesn’t mean Muslim. That why you have Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Muslims
And Palestinian Jews that get treated the same as other Palestinians
Preach this the part that was aliasing me off that they think it’s just a Muslim vs Jew thing. When there’s Christian’s and Jews that were already living there as Palestinians.
@@RocketGator05 There are no Palestinian jews. What a lie.
The historical program you are watching falsifies history. The Jews came from Egypt to the land Of (The Arabs) Canaanites, not the Canaanites only, and there were people living there whose name was the Canaanite Arabs.The one who produced the documentary program that you are watching is also a Zionist. The land of Palestine is not the land of the Jews as they claim. So why is there in the books of the Jews that they do not settle any land until When Jesus returns and establishes their promised kingdom for them !!??
Islam was created in 550 AD
Israel in 1800 BC approx
Correction : Judaism... The religion was created 1800 BC...
And all the ppl in the region(s) have been inter-marrying since before Islam was even a (heretical) thing
DNA says a lot 😂
In recent decades, several studies have been published in the field of genetics of populations that dealt with the genetic connection between Jews and Palestinians, In a study published in 2010 that dealt with the "total genome structure of the Jewish people", the Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudis. This genetic affinity, according to the researchers, is consistent with the theory that these groups "have a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula". Another study published in the same year demonstrated that the Palestinians, along with the Bedouins, Druze and Southern European groups, are the closest genetic neighbors to most of the Jewish populations. Additional genetic studies published in recent decades demonstrated that at the paternal level there is a clear genetic link between Ashkenazi, Sephardic and Mizrahi Jews and the Palestinians; The same studies showed that Jews from these tribes are genetically closer to the Arabs of the Land of Israel than to their non-Jewish neighbors in the Diaspora. These findings are consistent with the explanation that some or most of the Muslim Arabs in the Land of Israel are the descendants of local residents, mainly Christians and Jews, who converted to Islam after the Arab conquest in the seventh century. Some Muslims arrived in Israel during migration from North Africa and Turkmenistan and even Bosnian Muslims. surnames of many of the Palestinians indicate that their origin is outside the Land of Israel
Although the Jewish population shrank dramatically throughout the periods of Roman, Byzantine, Crusader, and Islamic rule, a Jewish presence continued to survive in the region
I think you'll find from studies that the European groups are closer to you guessed it... Europeans. The Palestinians are native people who converted to Christianity and Islam. Nothing justifies the killings and displacing 750,000 indigenous Palestinians to create a racist ethnoreligious state that continues to occupy and oppress. @@romt-qr2ik
Israel came based on a text in the Bible, and in this same book there is a text that disproves their claim and explains who the first people of the earth were.
Genesis 12:
6 Abram traveled through the land as far as the site of the great tree of Moreh at Shechem. At that time the Canaanites were in the land.
Since Israel was founded and long before that, the Arabs have always behaved in a horrible way towards the Israelis, we are not really to blame
the only people behaving in a horrible way is the jews, you stole their land so you're to be blamed
I appreciate the breakdown in this video. I also went and searched somethings up I was stuck on, and I learned a lot. Keep it up!
I'm a Master Social worker and never learned this history either. I'm 50 and they never taught this in school so those haters are just haters. I love how you guys are real and honest and intelligent young men with tons of promise. Never stop sharing because you make such a difference in lives everywhere. Love coming from Texas!!
Americans are just dumb. But the education system definitely takes most of the blame.
If you want a video that goes really back in history with details and trusted sources about this that has an answer for almost every question, You should watch " Palestine, the tale of the land" by New Media Academy life, it uses various sources and a lot of people worked on the research, it has english subtitles but m pretty sure there is a dubbed version. Whatever you like
I love your thirst for knowledge. Keep asking and seeking.
Friends, be careful. There is a lot of missing information in this video and a lot of wrong information. In order for the story to deviate from the true perspective, I advise you to watch the story from all sides, and the judgment is yours in the end.
I'm 65 and the conflict in the Middle East is not complicated. That is a lie that keeps being told by the is really side, but it is a lie
considering the video doesnt mention the jews being exiled from muslim nations as well and not just europe id say it doesnt get all the info from one side either
Really? Funny how you people are never able to prove or show any examples of that being true...
Otherwise give me at least 5 things the video gets wrong. And I mean 5 actual things. Not timeline errors. Mistakes happen. Obviously.
@@shakedben22considering the video doesn’t mention that before Saul Isaac Abraham there were people living there which they were “Palestinians” ! The Jewish people were exiled from that land by a foreign king who came from now we know as Iraq and he took them and made them slaves in his kingdom! On the other side centuries later the Muslims saved the Jews from Christians in Spain and they asked the Muslims to take them to Morocco with them! The Israelite kingdom he mentioned in the video for how much time did it last? 80 years maybe! So!? Does this give them the right to call it there land when there was already people living in that land!! Go educate yourself
I also thought that.
What you didn't realize is the mosque is built on the remains of the second Jewish Temple
Worth mentioning that some of the neighbouring countries stopped supporting radical ismalic groups as egypt president made it clear that hammas is now perceived as a terrorist group
The people who side with the G-d of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are the ones who are also on the side of truth.
“ god will bless those who bless Israel” ✝️
@@biagio9388 you 7th day?
so abraham had only isaac ? the one true god allah not your weak god who forgets and needs rainbow to remind himself or get beatten by jacob
I have a Lincoln Library book of Essential Info from 1955. It defined Semites as “A dark-skinned branch of the Caucasian race. It includes the Jews and the Arabians among modern peoples and, among ancient nations, the Assyrians and the Phœnicians. The name is so applied because of the traditional belief, without historical foundation, that this race was descended from Noah's son Shem.” Which means that this conflict is between two branches of Semitic people. Interestingly, Ethiopians are Semites as well, who’s ancestors came from southern Arabia. Semitism is determined by ancestry, not religion.
The term "Semite" wasn't created until the 1800s, and it is becoming frowned upon by historians because it isn't helpful in any way, being based on a set of languages, not a race.
From Britannica:
"Semite, name given in the 19th century to a member of any people who speak one of the Semitic languages, a family of languages spoken primarily in parts of western Asia and Africa. The term therefore came to include Arabs, Akkadians, Canaanites, Hebrews, some Ethiopians (including the Amhara and the Tigrayans), and Aramaean tribes. Although Mesopotamia, the western coast of the Mediterranean, the Arabian Peninsula, and the Horn of Africa have all been proposed as possible sites for the prehistoric origins of Semitic-speaking populations, there remains no archaeological or scientific evidence of a common Semitic people. Because Semitic-speaking peoples do not share any traits aside from language, use of the term “Semite” to refer to the broad range of Semitic-speaking peoples has fallen out of favour. For this reason, some critics even encourage the removal of the hyphen in the term anti-Semitism to help dispel any pseudoscientific notions of a "Semitic race." They advocate instead for the use of antisemitism to describe the hostility toward or discrimination against Jews as a religious or racial group.
In fact, by 2500 BCE Semitic-speaking peoples had already become widely dispersed throughout western Asia. In Phoenicia they became seafarers. In Mesopotamia they blended with the civilization of Sumer. The Hebrews settled with other Semitic-speaking peoples in Palestine."
Jews are notoriously suck at two things: sports. and genocide.
at 1947 there were 500,000 Muslims (they did NOT identify themselves as "Palestinians" till the mid 60's with the creation of the P.l.o - the world first terror organization). Today there are over 7 MILLION Muslims , including 2 million in Israel. How does a one ethnic/religion group grows from half million to 7 million in 75 years facing a genocide? See, WITHOUT LIES ISLAM DIES!!!
And yet Caucasian is not a RACE.
The European Jews went to Europe after Roman pushed them out, and all the wars. They are genetically come from Israel.
Go listen to Professor Finkelstein, or Rabbi Shapiro. Rabbi Shapiro explains that Israel was not created to protect Jews, but to destroy judaism and make Judaism a race not a religion!! Rabbi Shapiro states after reading historical documents that Zionism was created to destroy Judaism! The Zionists of that time, actually hated Jews, and wanted to change them!! The majority of Zionists that went to Palestine in 1948 were atheist or secular Jews just as they are today & not actual ultra orthodox Jews who believe there should be no Jewish state! Professor Finkelstein gives the entire history of the Palestine Israel conflict after 40 years of research and is an excellent resource!!!
I really appreciate you researching this and sharing it.
something that is not pointed out enough is although Jews were offered more of the land it was less useable. It was mostly a swamp area (which is why many Jews died of malaria because of the mosquitoes) or a desert in the south where it was hard to practice agriculture. One of the biggest miracles of Israel is how it managed to create new technology and techniques to overcome those issues. those innovations are now used globally.
There is true information, and its widely available, you just have to do some basic efforts. One of my favourite videos of all time about this conflict, is a video by the name - حكاية الأرض الدحيح فلسطينon the "new media" channel. That video is so wild on so many levels because the creator "الدحيح" (daheeh) used actually verified israeli ressources to make the entire video and showcase the truth about the origin of this conflict.
The cideo is like an hour long, but boy oh boy the quality is top fucking notch ( its in arabic but subbed in english).
You can watch on ur own time and you will know the truth (according to israeli ressources)
I’m from Europe, but have lived in the US for a while. Unfortunately most people in the US are very uninformed and uncultured about others countries. This is basic knowledge, but the American standard education system is very subpar compared to Europe.
I mean, how much do you know about South American countries not in your area of the world?
Yet, we get a cold and you get the flu.
The historical program you are watching falsifies history. The Jews came from Egypt to the land Of (The Arabs) Canaanites, not the Canaanites only, and there were people living there whose name was the Canaanite Arabs.The one who produced the documentary program that you are watching is also a Zionist. The land of Palestine is not the land of the Jews as they claim. So why is there in the books of the Jews that they do not settle any land until When Jesus returns and establishes their promised kingdom for them !!??
@@matthewjonesy3879 pretty sure Europeans know more about South America than people from the US do. Especially the Spaniards and the British 💀
Jewish is an ethnoreligion - both a race (Hebrew) and a religion (Judaism). After the fall of the second Temple in 70AD, Jews were expelled from the land of Judea and Israel, and into Africa, Europe, and Southeast Asia. This exodus created distinct racial groups (Ashkenazi, Semitic, Persian-Sephardic, Ethiopian, etc) of Jews, united by both religion and maternal line.
The result of this over the last 2,000 years is several distinct racial groups who are all Jewish by either birth, religion, or both.
Thank you! This is what I’ve been saying
Biblical history shows lineage through the patriarchal line............
@@BouncySlim1 over time, this has changed to a matrilineal line, due to children being kidnapped and women being stolen into sex slavery. National Israel accepts both patrilineal and matrilineal Jewishness in claims for citizenship. Basically as long as one of your parents is a Jew, you're ethnically Jewish, regardless of whether your ethnicity is Hebrew/Semitic or not.
The modern day Jews have been bred with Europeans so much that they aren’t even actually the Jews from back then 💀
I agree with you up to the Jewish being expelled. There were Jews that remained in small numbers. Some who've never left as proven through geneology.
I asked my daughter if she was taught significant historical topics that I was taught in the 70s and 80s. Sadly she'd never heard of so many. So it's not that it wasn't taught, it's that it currently isn't being taught. Easier to mislead people if they don't know history.
One thing to take note of, during the Ottoman Empire rule, the Jews that were still in Palestine where to persecuted and where allowed to establish there own community.
THANK you for putting this video out there! I'm so grateful for this video, to remind me of all the history I had forgotten! Much love guys!💜
No worries, most of it was twisted and untrue... Please forget and read history books! This is so dangerous and everybody is edging them on!
The Bible has the right information.
i am a christian and i believe you but you simply cannot use it to debate or form a strong opinion on this matter
What ? 😅
@@kingdra-winston3500 sure you can. God says that he will bless the people that bless Israel. It has been their holy land since Abraham was promised from God. Also, I promise you the good guys never kill innocent men women and children.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
The Arabs also received the bigger part of the British Mandate, which is Jordan! It's not fair to say that the Jews received the bigger piece of the land, because they received just tiny piece of their historic native homeland and they still agreed to it! It's the Arabs who were greedy and wanted everything for themselves, and that's why they started wars and lost everything as a result! They gotta take responsibility for their actions for once and stop playing the victims!
If you understand the logic of Palestinian supporters they say Israel is occupying their lands,yet they will say the Ottoman Empire liberated Israel. You can't have it both ways,if you believe Israelis are occupiers then you have to admit the Ottoman Empire was occupiers of Jewish lands centuries ago.
I just wanted to take a moment to express my gratitude for your dedication and commitment in addressing the complex and sensitive topic of the conflict. Recently, I came across an incredibly impactful documentary on CZcams called "Palestine: A Tale of Land," which has garnered 13 million views in just a week. This documentary is a gripping narrative backed by factual insights from Israeli authorities and historians. Your commentary, coupled with the powerful storytelling of the documentary, could offer your audience a deeper understanding of the complexities involved. I recommend turning on the subtitles to fully grasp the nuances presented in the documentary.
They were not expelled by Israel, if you look at the founding Israel documents they ask for the Palestinians to stay and be apart of Israel. The Palestinian rulers told them to leave!
Very true
At the time of the Muslims' entry into Palestine, no Jew or Christian was killed, but as for the Muslims, they allowed Jews and Christians to remain under their protection and had the right to practice their religion.
Why are you lying smh
@@Peaxxch I am not lying, this is the truth. You can search in history books about Saladin Al-Ayyubi
@@ENDAION THERE WAS MANY MASSACRE AGAINST THE JEWS IN 1920'S IN ''PALESTINE''. YALL DIDNT WANT JEWS SETTLING ON THEIR RIGHTFUL HOMELAND OF JUDEA. LOOK UP PALESTINIAN PRESIDENT ALLIANCE WITH HITLER. MANY ARAB COUNTRIES FOUGHT ALONGSIDE THE NAZIS.. look it up. Your statement is ridiculous. Historically, so many christians and jews were persecuted in your so valled countries
@@ENDAION nope there was many massacre against Jews. The Hebron massacre for exemple when there was antisemetism from Muslim comubitues
Notoriusly, ISIS was NOT opposed to isrel because in their version of the apocalypse, the jews fall last. these were opposed to nationalist groups who felt were fighting for secular "land aims" they wer enemies of the al quaeda
Please watch "Conflict in Israel and Palestine through 2015: Crash Course World History #223" by Hank Green. It gives more context to the conflict on both sides.
Another thing funny how everything radical is Muslim or Islamic 😂. But the Jewish militia when they first started attacking the Palestinians and taking their land and kick the British out were not terrorist but a militia 😒 I would say if one is going to be labeled a terrorist keep the same energy and use those same standards to label the other side a terrorist. By the way, any attack carried out in the name of Islam is not a representation of Islam. In our religion, our rules of war does not condone the killing of innocent men women or children. Even nature is not meant to be harmed. Only military personnel is supposed to fight other military personnel.
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Then what is ziziya tax for non muslims isn't it hypocracy to collect tax just because they do not believe in your forced religion? For what protection? From who , islamic invaders😂
Islam was invented in 600AD far after Christianity and Judaism. The Christians recognize Jesus was a Jew so Judaism is older and Islam even mentions Jerusalem as home to the Jews (before calling them liars and saying they should be killed).
The British only took control because the Ottoman Turks who controlled Palestine sided with Germany in WWI. Germany promised them stolen Russian land when they won... but sure, be upset that the people who were attacked, the British, won and flipped the script and took THEIR land. Karma.
Meanwhile, Palestine, Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Iraq invade Israel in 1948 not even ONE DAY after the British hand over the keys and then get upset when the lose and lose land in the process. Had they won, would they have given Israel back to anyone and not kicked out all the Jews as they promised? Nah.
The only constant in this land (besides Islam being new with no claim) is conflict. To the victors go the spoils.
Real-life lore is a really good channel if u want more info on the modern conflict
This is about Issac and Ishmael
Also to mention, at the time of the Ottoman Empire the three different religions lived peacefully for the most part. Religions were given the ability to rule their communities according to their religious guidelines. Christians and Jews under Islamic law had lower taxes to pay compared to Muslims. Muslims paid more taxes. Muslims paid 2.5 % of their wealth every year and non-Muslims paid a lesser tax and those how could not afford it were exempt. So there was peace between three religions
This is what I love about you guys. You research, you ask questions and you learn. This episode was soooooo interesting watching you bounce thoughts and interpretations off of one another. And this topic is indeed very deep and complicated for us to even begin to comprehend as this was and is not our history. you guys make a great team. Don't stop!
Their "research" is misguided and absolutely irresponsible. They're causing more harm than good, intentional or unintentional, with the spreading of misleading information to other viewers like yourself who have no understanding of the matter whatsoever.
@@tawfifee It's misguided to you because it goes against your beliefs of the situation. Maybe you should take a step back and not be blinded by hate and biasism and do some research as they're doing.
@@BigBoss1R I don't think nukes on Japan were justified. But, that's what I like about this channel, I don't agree with everything they say but I respect that they think for themselves.
@@BigBoss1R I'm biased because I'm American. As an American, I've learned that the Japanese did not surrender before the nukes. If you can prove me wrong with legit sources then I would love that but I doubt you can. Hirochito did not want Japan to surrender from what I understand and would not surrender unless something like the nukes happened. Maybe you're forgetting that Japan was under a dictatorship? That being said, I still don't think that justifies America using nukes on Japan. I believe there could've been other solutions to show the strength of the nukes without it affecting civilian lives. And last point, I never pointed fingers, I think all research is good and we should all be open minded and look at all sides.
@@ash__117 It's misguided because it leaves out huge chunks of information, twists narratives, changes facts, and is presented in a way to put Israel in the light of the victim. It's quite frustrating to watch. Not only did they blindly believe everything this propaganda said, but they made their own conspiracy out of it, which was so far from the truth, that it hurt... Honestly, if they are not willing to read and learn from actual historians, and from actual documents or talk to people from both sides, they won't ever understand this. And yes they will be responsible for Israel's Propaganda to spread further and further...
It's extremely hard to fight propaganda from Israel, because of their extensive PR-.Budget, and it's frustrating when people are so easily falling for it... common...
You should listen to the song “Rajeeeen” to learn the story of the Palestinian people and the beauty of the Arabic song
This is a completely distorted story, friends. I can ask a simple question: Why is the number of Palestinians killed during this occupation not mentioned in this video? There are many details that must be mentioned that will completely change your view of this conflict. The real story is about the massacres committed against the Palestinian people from 1948 until this moment.
Have you lost your mind??? The Arabs have been massacring the native Jews in that land for CENTURIES before 1948, and long after 1948!!! The Arabs are NOT the innocent victims in this conflict. But nice try...
I hope you listen to the episode of an Egyptian influencer named Al-Daheh about the conflict. What is good is that he used Israeli sources that expose the entity.
I hope they see your comment and watch it, the episode is titled “Palestine tale of land”
He ignore so much, it's kinda trash. He accept Israeli data, but not the archaeological findings that put Judaism there before a modern, non nomadic city state. You can't say "I just take what Israel says" and then not take it all.
The "entity"??? 😂😂😂😂 You really think people are as stupid as you are?
Just from your introduction discussion, I want to say that I learned about this in World History in high school, 1984-1988. I also took a foreign affairs and a current events class in high school and that was more advanced and intense history and its affects on current day events.
Good for you!
Just food for thought - you said (very correctly) in the video that the “nakba” was an event in which many Palestinians lost their home “due to the conflict”. If we follow Palestinians logic, all native Americans that lost their homes “due to the conflict” should get their land back. Throughout history many people lost their homes due to war and conflict (Jewish people as well, many times) but everyone moves on, they don’t. The reason behind it is not land, or wanting to return to their homes. Their reason is simply the hatred of Jews and the will to end them. And that’s the sad reality
Thank you for sharing facts.
As a christian Palestinian holding and Israeli passport living in Jerusalem. Would love to help explain the whole situation to you guys . This video is full of gaps.
وانا من مصر ياض الحق هيرجع لصحابو قريب و🤤🙏🇪🇬
nothing to exsplain palestine was made by rome its been a known fact documed in history sorry
Naa ..naming the land doesn't mean the people wasn't there .. palestanians are cannan ppl and the ancient hebrews who converted to christianity coz its jesus land then they became muslims .. zionest r europians who turned to judaism and never lived on palestain land or cannan land.about the temple there is no evidence they tried hard but no nothing.actually they found something in east africa only.they can go there @@queenelizabeth8253
Yes, true like Jacob and Esau, sons of Isaac and Rebecca.
Jacob become Israel
This is such a soft white washed version lol
I appreciate you guys I find y’all so inspiring! love from U.K
👍
One thing the video left out, is the Peel Commission was the first time a partition plan was offered in 1936. In that plan the Arabs were given the majority of the land and rejected it.
The Arabs are the oldest nation in history. Their origin goes back to their grandfather, Ya'arab bin Qahtan bin Sam. They were on the Arabian Peninsula, making up 30 of the Arabs of the ancient Middle East. Before Isaac, the father of the Jews, was born and lived on this planet, there were Canaanite Arabs, who were Semitic Arab peoples who migrated from Yemen after the demolition of the Ma'rib Dam. Provide history The Jews were mobile nomads who herded sheep and had no homeland. This is why they were called the Hebrews. If we assume that the presence of the Jews for a short period of time in this region on small lands gives them the right to that country, according to this logic, this means that Italy has right to the British Isles because they ruled it for a thousand years. A year and their traces are still there
It is important to note that the most of the land that the UN gave Israel was desert - the Negev Desert. The overwhelming part of the more livable land was awarded to the Arabs.
I would like to add…
If you look at the biblical history of Israel and all the Wars and Occupiers throughout the years. Jews have always been in that land.
Judaism came before Christianity and Islam.
If you look into the modern day history of
1948 the day Israel earned its Independence from the British mandate of “Palestine”
Immediately the following day they were attacked by Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Jordan/Iraq
Those countries asked the “Palestinians” in the West-bank, Gaza, and within Israel’s borders to leave and promised them that they will win the fight for them. In 1948,1956,1967,1973
They technically displaced the “Palestinians” every time they lost.
And created refugees in doing so.
Israel never asked the “Palestinians” to leave.
Ask any real non-biased historian.
Unfortunately Israel always extends its hand for peace with land and the “Palestinians” (government) refuses.
It’s called the 3 No’s
no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel, and no peace with Israel.
Israel is the only country that has given land back that they rightfully won in war in order to make peace. Israel is the only country that does strategic, surgical attacks on terrorist/terrorism with the least amount of casualties to be harmed or killed.
Israel is the only country that has to defend itself from (world opinion) in order to defend itself from its enemies and the right to exist as a sovereign nation.
Just look at what happened 10/7/23.
Hamas is a terrorist group just like Isis
“Palestinians” voted them in to power.
They killed over 1200 people injured over 3000 and captured 240 hostages.
They trade innocent hostages (240) for known terrorist criminals captured in Israeli jails
@@davidkash123 yeah, and if one were to say, what "religion" can claim ownership then Islam falls last.
The preexistence of Christianity and Judaism is even in the Quran, which also notes the importance of Jerusalem to the Jews. Then of course it goes into the fun bits about hating Jews, calling them liars, and how to wage war on all non believers, lol. Still though, Islam is dead last in terms of the chicken and the egg dynamics.
Thank you for taking the time to create videos like this. I am Canadian and don't know much about the history of Israel-Palestine. Appreciate the content :)
Well let's take the story from a stupid children's cartoon
Good job for a grown man 👏
Good plan for the Zionists
Like the cartoon that Netanyahu showed about the hospital in Gaza 😂😂😂🥱🥱
Do you want realistic work? Watch the Jewish documentary... TantoraDo you want realistic work? Watch the Jewish documentary... Tantora
I'm sorry to inform you, that this video is complete propaganda! I don't know how much Israel paid for it, but they did a great job twisting history. Please forget and read history books... We can't let them manipulate people that easily
Palestinian youth are Muslims and Christians, not just Muslims
That’s a good non-biased video! If you take classes to be a religious figure or theology you’ll come across this topic. Jews do not believe Jesus is the Messiah , Christians do. I majored in communication and humanities. I am also a Christian and have studied a lot of these topics. I’m glad you guys are touching this subject.
I disagree the first christians were jews