BRUTAL: Bob Good Does Not Hold Back Grilling Education Sec. Cardona About Student Loan Forgiveness
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 05. 2024
- At today's House Education Committee hearing, Rep. Bob Good (R-VA) questioned Education Secretary Miguel Cardona about student loan forgiveness.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
If you take out a loan, you pay it back. Simple.
Bruh this country got 34 trillion in national debt. You preaching, but still ooooof
what do you do if the loans aren't being successfully paid back. What if, as a result, a large part of the population is stuck in repayment limbo because the institution and themselves did not make them automsatically successful. What if you actually implemented this plan (which this guy did not actually outline because he is a non-talking piece of political shit (Both sides guilty)) and it freed all of those people and actually unlocked them and they become more productive. In theory it works but thats a 750 billion dollar theory, kind of cheap based off the ludicrous spending these few admins have done, huge trump dax deductions expire 2025 americans. Next year is gonna fuckingg hurt. I hope someone reads this
@@tedvanduzen8867borrow money, pay it back. Simple principle, not rocket science. If you can’t afford college then don’t go
This is asking too much of people who can't tell the difference between men and women.
When will Israel pay USA back
What about Ukraine
What about all those PPP loans
Billions can be paid for Foreigners and corporations and forgiven
But not the citizens paying taxes
Please stop your unpatriotic thumbs from typing...thanks.
This whole non answering bs is infuriating
Every Time.!!!
They know we the people will not hold anyone accountable.
It should be considered contempt or perjury. They work for the people supposedly and shouldn't be allowed to dodge questions.
I mean I totally agree that we should not forgive student loans, but the guy didn't even let him answer. He's just giving a speech and this guy is his prop.
@@user-iz9td8zz6nHe did let him answer, but the questions weren't being answered. Get it? He wanted to explain why they're doing this, instead of answering very simple ques2, liiiike, is anyone ABOVE The Constitution? The literal law of the land? NO. Not even the aholes voted in.
The most unqualified worst administrative in US history
ANY person testifying before congress who refuses to answer a direct, simple question with a direct simple answer should be held in contempt and JAILED.
If students were defrauded then they should sue the colleges.
U mean the protected corporations that have more protections then citizens🤣🤣🤣ah you make me laugh
Why did the government allow these schools to defraud students? The money literally doesn’t touch the student’s hands it’s paid to the school.
@@missevie432Doesn't mean there isn't a loophole. Lawyers always find loopholes.
I've watched literally dozens of these congressional hearings lately, and I can't name a single one in which the person testifying actually answers the questions asked.
What's the penalty for it? NO THING this is entertainment to turn the USA eyes from the Holocaust taking place in Palestine. I LOVE FORBES SO INWATCH THEIR CONTENT but this is classic look over here not there trick.
That’s in the Democrats handbook
THEM THEY SMIRK KNOWING NOTHING WILL BEDONE.
I would have loved to go to law school, but I couldn't afford it. Why should I pay for someone else to go?
exactly, if im paying for an education it should be my education lol
I still have student loans. I agree with you 100%. This is despite the fact that all these student loans are predatory and since the government has become involved, costs have gone through the roof but wages aren’t there.
because biden wants to buy votes from these kids
I need relief and I paid for my education! So who’s going to pay off my mortgage?
But did Biden lie to his constituents saying he would cancel all mortgage debts or did he say he would cancel
STUDENT LOAN DEBTS?
right smarty U wrong...
Was there fraud associated with your mortgage?
Nope!, not mine but back in 2008, millions lost their home due to fraudulent loans under the Freddie Mac policies! No one rescued tjose homeowners! But are fraudulent lenders being charged and prosecuted?
@@so.many.obstacles Problem with your statement is, the student who took out the loan 1 graduated highschool and should have enough common sense to understand a loan
@@so.many.obstaclesYes. Banks defraud all the time
FYI if Biden paid off my student loan i still wouldn’t vote for him
I would only vote for Biden to step down and charged with crimes against humanity.
Same, just so you know, both Biden and pelosi are the ones that removed bankruptcy protection from student loans in the 70s. Plus they started the government to get involved for subsidizing college tuition, so the colleges raised their prices cause they figure the government would pay anyway and here we are. Their promises are bullshit to get votes. Trump 2024!
That’s the thing, he’s not paying for them. The taxpayers are.
Only Congress has the authority to appropriate how taxpayer money is spent…not cabinet secretaries or the President have authority to do this!
Joe Biden gives these alphabet agencies. Way too much power. They should not have it. We need to dismiss and get rid of some of these alphabet agencies. Because they're not doing a damn bit of good for the american people
So what can be done to stop this? He just does what he wants. What's to prevent him from making an executive order allowing anyone residing in the US (citizen or not) the right to vote???
Congress gave that authority to the Department ... if you don't want congress giving money to help people pay off student debt, tell your congressional leader to put forth a bill to rescind that power.
@@GaiusCaesar_Blah. Shouldn't effing have to. Bot
Hell ya!!! I don’t want my taxes to go to people who don’t want to pay their debt.
I mean, i don't want my taxes going to alot of things, including tax-free religious centers.
You don't get to decide how every dollar is spent, sorry you just don't.
I agree. I don’t want to pay for abortions and gender affirming care/surgeries.
what i like watching this is Bob Good's ability to hold someone to his question, giving zero room to try and waste his very limited time by rambling and dissembling. He has a question, he asks it, he immediately stops the answer when he realizes he's being played, and he asks it again.
If they were defrauded then those loan companies should take the loss not the American people.
There are no private companies the Obama administration banned private companies from making student loans. The banks were banned from making student loans. The only people make a student loan was the federal government learn
the federal government is the loan underwriters thx to Ozero so technically WE are those loan companies
The schools themselves, high school teachers and counselors and to some degree parents are the ones that talked them into it. The loan companies didn’t chase people down telling them to take out loans
They were defrauded,not by the loan companies, but instead by, the colleges/universities who gave out worthless degrees.🤔😡😡😡
Hey dopy....we people are footing the bill? How long do YOU put up with that biz model? Oh, wait.... you never ran a biz, lol
They're always fixing a "broken system," it's called job security.
A broken system THEY broke.
Systems aren't broken. They don't like the system or want to enforce the system.
Yep
Again if a student was defrauded the college sue the college not the taxpayers. 🖕
When gov appointees refuse to properly answer a question asked of them from congress, while they’re under oath, should be found in contempt and removed if it becomes egregious…
Wow, how dare he tell the congressman how his constituents would feel about college loan forgiveness. He can't speak for other people who's taxes are covering the loan forgiveness.
ABOLISH DEPT OF EDUCATION.
How about LOAN FORGIVENESS on my house mortgage
They'd just take your house and rent it back to you.
I’m a low income person on medical disability post leukemia, but I would not ask the government to pay for my mortgage.
Refusing to answer questions results in jail time.
Unfortunately that doesn't apply to the dumbocrates and their witnesses.
100% agree
Where on earth did you get this idiotic idea? “I plead the fifth” is specifically there because people in America have the constitutional right to refuse to answer questions so as to not incriminate themselves.
@@alexanderfrederick-preece9770 Pleading the 5th is not for public servants, who are not on trial. He was there to answer questions about unlawfully forgiving student loans.
@@alexanderfrederick-preece9770 I am not an attorney, or any expert on congressional testimony. That being said, as I understand it, in an oversight hearing, the witnesses are testifying under oath, which means, again, as I understand it, that lying under oath, is a felony, which would include ' Lying by Omission '. However, even if my understanding on that IS wrong, these Department Secretaries, in my opinion, be required to answer any questions they are asked, or , at the very least, be fired immediately. The reason I say this , is because, as the top person in these government departments, the decisions they make, affect all Americans, either for the good or for bad, so by their refusing to answer, they are telling we the people, mind your own business, or, in other words, f--k-off.
NO STUDENTS LOAN FORGIVENESS
FJB
do you acknowledge there is a problem though? what is your solution, if so, how would YOU implement it?
@@tedvanduzen8867 Don't borrow money if you can't repay it. Pretty simply....
@@tedvanduzen8867 most of the "education" being taught isn't really education but political activism as of late. Another thing is what's being taught such as Critical Race theory, Liberal Arts, Gender Studies, and psychology to boot.
Also a bit of a personal opinion but I'd recommend watching Yuri Bezmenov's 1984 interview before trying to defend student loan forgiveness.
This isn't forgiveness, it's loan reallocation. Put more accurately, it's vote buying.
BROKEN SYSTEM!!?? YOU TOOK A LOAN YOU PAY IT BACK HOW THE HELL IS THAT BROKEN!!!
I'm done with this illegal administration
And to think... we're paying for Mr. Cardonas salary. Another waste of taxpayer money.
Great questioning he doesn't have answers. He's skirting around the answers because he knows this is illegal
Liars never give a straight answer, period.
You can’t give them time because they go off on tangents intentionally avoiding the question. They only spout their talking points. Answer the darn questions
My signature is not on their loans, not my bill to pay.
Simple.
As long as Cardona is Sec., we should end student loans. I don't want to pay loans for a stranger. Period. And no protester loans will be paid by taxpayers. Another Mayorkas.
He doesn’t know what to say if he doesn’t stay on SCRIPT.
What is my incentive to pay anything back if I can just dish it off on taxpayers? Pure idiocy
So students are paying their loans back ! Well ? end of conversation then !
Easy illustration: This is Joe the plumber. Joe works hard, didn't go to college, and runs a small family business with 3 other plumbers to put food on the table for his wife and 2 kids.. Tell me why Joe should have to pay for Ivy League Annie's student loans. I'll wait.
The guy NEEDS to be FIRED NOW... he IS the problem, NOT the solutions!!!
He refuses to answer!
This guy is the WORST kind of public servant. Hopelessly partisan and unwilling to answer questions, he should be dismissed.
Masterclass on how stop a witness from filibustering
Masterclass on corruption misuse of citizens money how to lie cheat and steal and get away with it...American Home of the Corrupt Liars what a change from when Inwas growing up Home of the Brave Home of the FREE...WHO LET THE ANTIHEREOS INTO OFFICE SINCE 2000 BUD it shifted
If you are not smart enough to answer a question, you should lose your job.
The problem is the PRICE of higher education - the Universities are gouging everyone!
Zero accountability, communism and socialism is alive and well living in the USA.
This is ridiculous. Who is this guy to make that decision? Why is no one held accountable??
CARDONA SHOULD BE HELD IN CONTEMPT OF CONGRESS AND GO TO JAIL UNTIL HE ANSWERS THESE QUESTIONS!!!! WE THE PEOPLE ARE SICK OF THESE CORRUPT ELITES THAT THINK THEY DO NOT HAVE TO ANSWER TO THE AMERICAN CITIZENS!!!!
SOUNDS LIKE MYORKAS . JUST A DEM SPEAKING POINT OF WOOPS I GOT CAUGHT.
Boy you NAILDED it! Mayorkas all over again!!
Americans are so 100% over all this nonsense. #Trump2024
I love it when they complain that they're not allowed to answer, when every time they're given the chance they change the subject to what they'd rather be talking about.
Go after the loan companies not the taxpayer.
I’ll Give you The CONSTITUTION. And In CURSIVE WRITING AT THAT!
I’ll STAND GROUND IN USA!!!
Oh sorry, the loan forgiveness that the President does not have the right to.do with congressional approval.
It is a scheme. Unbelievable.
Cardona needs to be removed and jailed.
Great job of questioning him ! Too bad it never changes this democrat group
Officials who refuse to answer questions should be held in contempt and penalized.
EXACTLY.....Who gave the people constitutional authority?????
A BSer, take the loan, pay the loan.Go after the loan sharks at colleges, not Americans.
This guy is so ignorant... How is he in the Top spot of Education! Equity Hire
Take an oath to tell truth. Then avoid telling truth. Coward and liar. The answers - or lack of answers- fits the definition of propaganda 101. If Cardona is unaware of this, he may eventually learn it and look back and see his totally flagrant examples of propaganda.
Avoid....deflect.....avoid.....deflect.....shift blame......avoid......deflect......hmm reminds me of several other current administration government officials. 🤔
Why should I pay for other peoples loans. There are students and probably a large number classified as drop outs.
The government declared war on Petro products I lost my job. I lost my house I lost my family in all the process. Does the government owe me?
Bring back debtors prisons.
i sacrificed and saved and paid off my student loan❗❗❗❗do i get a refund? or how about just pay off my mortage loan??
Silly the rich never pay off loans
They claim bankruptcy and get it forgiven...Do you ever read 📚
Look at the corrupt corporations
ENRON did they pay anything
Silly goose
There is no constitutional authority for a US Dept of Education to begin with. Most of the Departments and Agencies have none. They should be shut down.
If all that’s going to happen is a scolding, “Shame on you” for flouting the law, the will of the people, and ignoring the Supreme Court, what a waste of time! How about suing the administration or filing an injunction against it?? Something that actually holds them accountable and provides consequences!!
Turn all outstanding student loan debt to the IRS.
Oh my hardship is my parents told me I have to move out of their basement!
Noone asked the taxpayers if they wanted to pay off college kids loans.😡😡😡
Try taking out a loan from the mafia and not paying it back. See how that works out for you.
Great line of questioning. Well done
Who the hell is this AH that is "not answering the questions regarding student loans"? He is not very smart. This is why we are in this mess.
if you don't answer the questions why be there, waste of time and money
My welder sons should not be paying anyone’s student loans. I worked all the way through a master program and paid my own tuition and student loans. There was no time for parties/protests but it can be done.
If they were defrauded then go after the defrauder.
I had a lady who had a loan for education in us she was proud making her loan payments
Take it out of his check he makes more than I do
It’s pretty simple. You borrow money as a loan. You pay back that loan yourself. I went to university. Worked a full time job at the same time at night. I did have time to protest. To go to my university’s football games. Participate in any school activities aside from going to class. At most, I had 2-3 hours of sleep a day. Took seasonal jobs in the summer to save up for next semester’s tuition, books, supplies, etc. Graduated with ZERO student debt. But aged far faster than those who took up loans. Eventually those same people complained that their art history degree got them zero employment. Their niche social studies degrees got them hired to work at the local coffeee shop. Music theory didn’t help them pay off they of their debt. Parties so much that they graduated at the bottom of the class and affected who hired them. Or more precisely why they weren’t hired.
Congress said no, the Supreme Court said no. Now stop flapping gums and send a referral for charges. Grow a back bone and do something
when i was in school i NEVER took loans because i know i would need to pay then back.. I always did extra shifts to cover my tuition.. This is FOCKn CRAZY
Stop giving them MONEY!
What's the point of these hearings if they won't let the secretary answer
Take the money out of these huge college endowments
he said colleges defrauded students?? then have the colleges pay the loans
TLDR;
They are complaining he is violating federal statutes. Giving evidence that he is violating federal statutes.
Instead of having him removed from his duties (which they have a right to ask for), they are instead just going to let him continue to do what he wants to do.
Now use your 🧠...Why?
Answer the question asked.
No, he doesn't know because he doesn't care.This is the biggest malaka i've ever seen
Why can't people just answer a question
Save us all money-no loans at all will save kids from going to these indoctrination centers.
I own a business. I collect state federal and local taxes and pay a CPA so I don’t get fined. In fact I match SSN & Medicare, by law, for my employees.
Without businesses collecting taxes and paying employees former students would have jobs unless they started a business.
If I had a loan on by business no bank has reduced my loan amount. I would still have to pay it back.
The Covid relief was based on how many employees I had, not for paying down their debt.
The House of Representatives and the Senate are designated branches of government per our Constitution. The Department of Education is NOT! I am so tired of the arrogance and obfuscation from this guy!
MCardona doesn't want to answer simple questions. Maybe we should get a five year old to answer.
I love this Senator.
So this dude answering the questions I’m guessing he’s the same person not keeping score and getting participation trophies
Students …pay what you owe
Students should have option of filing bankruptcy
I cannot believe this guy is the secretary of EDUCATION. He is not bright. At all.
My goodness! Can these people just answer the questions?!!!!!!!!!!!!
I dont understand why these are hard concepts for people to grasp. I went into college knowing I was going to have student loans and that I would be paying them back. I am on a income based plan as most not all but most coming out of college are not going to be making huge salariers. You take out any loan you're responbile to pay. Also, people with there loans being forgiven dont understand that they will also pay more in taxes in the long run. Nothing is free.
re-elect bob good
Omg I want you as my lawyer. Even though I never get into trouble.
Big question is why federal government took over student loans. Why the fukk would the least competent, WORST run bank, the federal reserve, take over this program that was run efficiently by private banks.
For just this reason! Every member of Congress, regardless of party, wants to get to the same place. The only difference is how fast!
Control.
when they took it off the ability to relieve it through bankruptcy and then assigned underwriting to the federal government the handwriting was on the wall
Senator let the man finish talking if he's going to answer your questions then you can talk it's the same way with Jim Jordan who shouldn't be questioning anyone he should be in jail for avoiding his Subpoena.