Hornby's New Build P2 | Unboxing, Review & Railroad Version Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 06. 2024
- Get A Hornby P2: bit.ly/45cG4Pw (Affiliate)
Become a Sam'sTrains engineer here: / @samstrains
Get your Sam'sTrains merch: teespring.com/stores/bullmane...
Thanks for watching!
Email: samstrains@outlook.com
Instagram: / samstrainsofficial
Facebook: / samstrains
Twitter: / samstrains
0:00 Intro
4:25 Unboxing
7:58 Prototype Info
9:20 Railroad vs Railways: Weight
10:39 Railroad vs Railways: Detail
18:27 Mechanism
22:16 Performance
25:08 Haulage
31:49 Ratings
35:05 Conclusion - Auta a dopravní prostředky
I overall prefer this one to the streamlined P2. It just looks better for me with the unstreamlined front end. I can’t wait to see the smoke working on one of these.
Yeah I think in terms of the outline/looks alone, I prefer this version of the P2 as well... it's just a bit different from the A4 style end, which we've seen a lot already what with the Hush Hush and soon the B17!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
Hornby have done a great job on both versions. I have an old Railways version, which looks great, but these two are definitely a step forward in both looks and mechanism.
Your reviews are excellent, Sam. But I think I'd have been a touch more generous than you and squeezed this loco into the Grade A category!
Let's hope Hornby do as good a job on all their future releases as they've done on the P2's.
One of the most beautiful locos you've ever reviewed, Sam! Never would have guessed that Hornby would be able to do it after so many years of complacency.
I agree - it's great to see them build something that looks this good, even if they are beyond other manufacturers on price now!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
In all my years of knowing about model railroading i have never heard of a model being completed before the prototype
'Classic OG P2' - probably the first time those words have ever been used together and I'm here for it
This version of the P2 Mikado from Hornby is slightly better than the streamlined version because it has a bit more detail and it has a die cast running board which makes it a bit heavier. Even if this version of the P2s' valve gear assembly and the whistle are made out of plastic along with the detail part on the right-side of the model using the same part in the front but they are just small nitpicks. Overall, it is a very nice looking model. I would definitely buy both the original and streamlined versions of the Hornby P2 Mikados Sam.
Yeah that's right - it is better in a few ways, and it's certainly more complex. I could totally recommend both on balance
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
Great video thanks. I have the Hornby Railways P" and have the steam version of Prince of Wales on order, I also sponsor the team building the new P2 2007 Prince of Wales, so it will be great to own the model - thanks for the 'preview' of what I may receive.
I used the extra connections on the drawbar to wire the firebox glow to the decoder. I also fitted lamps to the front. Quite easy to do if a little bit fiddly due to the small size of the solder tabs. It’s also a lot neater than using visible wires.
These are lovely models, but at over £200 way out of my price range. I’m so happy with my latest eBay purchases - Hornby Dublo Bristol Castle, Duchess of Atholl, 2-6-4T, N2 0-6-2T. At 70 years old Bristol Castle still holds its own, and as for weight, Bristol Castle and tender weigh in at 614g, and Duchess of Atholl and tender are 625g. Even though the detail is crude by modern standards, they capture the feel of the real locomotives and after nearly 70yrs they still run beautifully with a little maintenance. Will the Hornby P2 still be running in the 2090’s? I doubt it, but I wouldn’t be at all surprised if 7013 and 6233 are still going strong…
and they cost under £40 each !
I love this one a lot more than the streamlined P2. It has the unique front smoke box and wind deflectors, which look amazing. The only shame is the plastic valve gear and the small bits of glue here and there, but aside from that, I would say it's all I could have hoped for. Near perfect performance, finally a die-cast running plate and the stunning finish. I'm not sure if I will go for this or the sound/steam version of it. I got my old Railways P2 and not only does it have very simple detail for a railways model, it runs very poorly after all these years the crappy 3-pole motor and lack of bearings really make it struggle on third radius with four coaches on a flat layout. I didn't think you would buy another P2 so shorty after the streamlined one, but man, does this one look good. I think performance could be 4.5, but I think it's forgivable as the crawl is literally perfect for the size of the loco. Great review, Sam 👍👍
Agree with you, jeanne, about the 2014 Railways P2. I purchased one and was so disappointed that I went four years without buying any Hornby products. Looks like they've finally done it right, but do they really deserve a second chance from those who purchased the original?
You're right, it's much more unique looking isn't it? If you can overlook the price, it certainly is everything we could have asked for... more or less...
Yeah the old version really doesn't run that well - and it is mainly because of the naff motor and bearings as you say. Huge improvement here on mechanism!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
This is a very interesting and useful review. Great stuff 🎉
I received my P2, Earl Marischal, yesterday, and my god it is near perfect. Being a Walscherts geared loco instead of rotory cams, it doesn't have those odd cylinders on the running board, so that's a negative remark remived. It runs and looks amazing, and the only problem I had with it was fitting the front screw link coupling 😂
I'm so happy I pre-ordered it, and for *£190 from Hattons*, it was an absolute bargain.
Still not a fan of the plastic whistle, but from a distance it's not noticeable.
Amazing video today Sam what a beautiful modle I might try and get the one with smoke
An overall good video here Sam, thinking of getting 2002 myself as well as maybe getting 2003, these new P2s from hornby are excellent looking models, it wil be very interesting and exciting when 2007 is finally finished and running in real life.
Ahh sounds great - and they sure are interesting! I can't wait to see the real thing :D
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
Great review Sam! The non-streamlined P2 is one of my favourite steam engines along with the A4.
Also, would you ever consider reviewing a Hornby Dublo model?
Ah, Hornby Dublo! Now you’re talking 😂
Another forensic and entertaining review, Sam. I think I'd have squeezed it into the ""A" category though!
Both versions are a big step up over my current Railways model.
Let's hope Hornby can maintain this standard for their future releases. This hobby needs high quality models from Hornby.
Hi Sam I just got the railroad p2 love your videos
I love the macro shots!
I enjoyed seeing Bullman in the closing shot!
Another excellent review Sam.
I picked up one of the old full detail versions of Cock O' The North just this month. Just for the record the weight is identical at 487g. This is definitely an upgrade though. In particular:
1) The satin finish.
2) The fantastic mechanism. Hornby mechanisms tend to be pretty good in my experience, but this one looks exceptional.
3) A closer and more realistic loco to tender connection.
4) Vastly improved cab detail.
5) Better detail overall
All that said my older P2 only cost me £84 inc P&P on Ebay. If I see one of the new ones going for a sensible price on the secondhand market in the future then I'll get it, but not at the current price.
Awesome video Sam's trains
I really love this model Sam, I'll probably get one of these for sure.
Cheers Jasper & Willow
That sounds great - hope you enjoy :D
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
The only thing I do notice is that when you start loco from one direction to the other, the geared wheels will move before the other wheels until the play is taken up. For me, small detail, maybe...maybe not worth noting.
Great channel Sam. Well done. Best wishes to Chloe.
Lovely loco and great to see Hornby hopefully back on form. Crazy price though and I will definitely be sticking to my well-loved Railroad P2.
I agree - I think now their models are up to scratch with the competition, they need to start matching them on price. They probably won't want to cut any prices though, given their situation at the moment,
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
I believe the A1 trust announced recently in their new workshop opening ceremony that it's looking more like 2026 until its finished now.
Hi, great honest review, i hope the new 21pin Hush Hush W1 in dark grey comes out as good as this, looking forward to it hitting the retailers, thanks for sharing.
Being from the US.
That is probably my favorite British locomotive
Lovely engine, and another fantastic review. I can’t wait to see the prototype in person.
Thank you! I agree, I can't wait :D
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
Great review. The odd one out is the thompson a2
The "etched" plates are just painted flat brass that just shows through the lettering.
The weight difference will be due to the Prince of Wales model having a cutout in the chassis in the smoke box area to allow for the smoke generator fitted models.
It would be nigh on impossible to get accurate working rotary valve gear with all the proper joints.
Ah, I think I've heard of this one. We've got a similar project here Stateside where a group of enthusiasts are trying to build a brand-new Pennsylvania Railroad Class T1, one of their heaviest locomotives and with a rather unique design even by streamliner standards. I believe they're shooting for a finish date some time during the latter half of this decade.
Yup the T1 Trust found inspiration from the A1 locomotive Trust i believe 😊
Such a cool model, when hornby does get it right they get it right, hopefully we see more of this for future models
Absolutely - fingers crossed their next locos are of this standard!!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
Yes, the Accurascale Class 37 did traverse the corner better, and yes it is heavier, but that's probably because the ability to traverse sight curves has absolutely nothing to do with weight and everything to do with wheelbase!
True… but I have a Hornby 9F that can traverse that curve with no issues, and the original Railroad P2, while a poorer crawler, also did no slowing down around there.
I have the sir Nigel gresely high gloss version of the p2 and love it, due to youre reviews I’ve ordered a streamlined p2… interestingly the hornby collectors club version is £50 off… be interesting to compare to your review when it arrives
Awesome vid Sam, I'd choose the full fat one tbh! Also the first of my two Manors arrived yesterday, delighted with it. However performance around corners and crawl a little lackluster, but I think you'll love it, I'd say it definitely is better than dapols!!
Ahh that's great to hear - pity about the performance though - can't wait to try mine!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
I can’t wait to order this one on Friday.
Being built in my hometown, and now in a brand new building by the museum!
Fabulous loco Sam and well done review again. The P2 are absolutely glorious. Well, as avid Märklinists we are used to high pricing and we think that H have nailed it with both versions of the P2; your earlier review of the streamlined one and this example. Hopefully H have finally found a route to up to the mark quality of their products and consistency in all areas concerned. We'd have her on a layout but of course that would be wishful since it can't run on 3-rails. However, we can admire their splendor here from a distance. She's breathtaking 💓 Cheerio.
Both Märklin and (Mini)trix (also owned by Märklin,) use "metal impregnated plastic" for some of their locomotive bodies although as far as I can see only for the smaller scales like N & Z. Interesting to know what difference this makes to the weight and how the surface finish and level of detail that can be moulded compares to regular plastic.
@@vijeolookAn interesting development indeed. Such composites should in theory be well injection mouldable since the metal molecules will conduct heat and add to specific thermodynamic qualities but it will depend very much on the exact formula of course.
I like the idea of metal impregnated plastic - wonder what the density of that is, and what the advantage is over die-casting?? Interesting stuff!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
@@SamsTrainsChecked this with my other half yesterday (chief chemist). He said it potentially has several advantages, e.g. weight, conductivity, better heat resistance, less prone to cracking and deformation, less degenerative, improved molecular symmetry for certain plastics, finer mouldable than die-cast to name a few. Downside is cost though. All evidently depending on the formula as well as density.
I want a P2 myself too! But I think I am gonna have to purchase a railroad range one as I am on a budget, so… yeah. Awesome review Sam. You know, you keep buying so many cool and awesome steam locomotives, that I just can’t seem to have the patience to save my money for these lovely machines!!!
Yeah the Railroad one is certainly good value if you get it from the retailers - good luck!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
I am getting the Earl Marischal on Friday and she'll be my second P2 loco but i intend to get the others in the future
Should have gone for 2002 'Earl Marischal', semi-streamlined front end but walschearts gear and a lovely curve to the running plate! Love mine to bits! Shame they didn't offer 2002 with the 'double deflectors'.
Also: was the Thompson rebuild (A2/2) the odd one out? Or was it the W1 for not being a P2 derivitive?
Ahh yeah that would have been interesting - though I did want to see how their rotary cam valve gear looked... and basically it's no better than the Railroad one. It was indeed the Thompson A2/2, as all others were Gresley designed!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
I was put off straight away by the excessive play in the valve gear, two of the four wheels moved before the others. I like the P2 and I would like one for my layout, but I think it would be the Streamlined version. Another great video as usual. Martin. (Thailand)
It’s the Thomson A2
Hi Sam. I have the TT sound version cock-o- the north and is fully lined and is much nicer than the railroad model and I am very happy with it as well. I have since bought the the lord President loco after seeing your review and that wonderful too. great video thanks sam.
Do you mean TTS sound because there is no TT120 model yet of a P2 ?
seriously can't wait for the new release with the steam effects.
Well done Sam very good camera work as usual as always what is your next loco going to be. Take care. Best wishes Philip xx
Finally a p2 was sprung buffers!!
The odd one out is the Thompson A2/2 Cock o the North
As per usual, great video Sam!
Sam, nice review of an interesting locomotive. Regarding the operation of both P2 locomotives on second radius curves, it sounds like the same issues that the real ones had running in Scotland on their curves.
Also, regarding weighing the models, I think that it would be interesting and useful to weigh the models with and without the tenders (weighing the tenders separately as well). The difference in weight between the Railway and Railroad versions may be affected by the weight of the tenders. They may end up weighing closer together, or perhaps further apart.
Thanks Stuart - generally I weigh with the tenders to be consistent, as it's not always possible/easy to remove the tenders. In this case, the Railroad tender has far less hardware on board: no pickups, no DCC socket, blanking plug etc, so I'd expect this Railways one to be the heaviest, making the difference between the locos even larger!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
Hi Sam I'm new to the channel, mainly for the great videos you do. I've no models, no track, no real knowledge of locos, apart from that which I picked up in the late 70s to mid 80s, when I did quite a bit of photography on various station platforms, mainly Leeds.
I mainly got into deisal electrics, such as class 31s class 37s and Deltics, oh and 03 shunters. I did have a really good train set when I was 8 or 9 years old, which my mum bought second hand way back in the 60s at great expense. You've fired my interest again, though I've no room for a lay out. May just become a collector, not the same I know.
Regards Rob.
I'm pretty sure the original Hornby Dublo did bring a model out before the real prototype one was completed. It was the Deltic diesel.
The cab seats on the railroad P2 are correct, they are the older type fitted to the first two locomotives from new. The streamlined engines were fitted with bucket seats, which also necessitated reducing the depth of the cab cutout, and 2001/2 were later brought into line
I think the loss of speed on tight curves is because of the very long driving wheelbase of these locomotives as well as having flanges on all the drivers as the front drivers are trying to climb over the outer rail. I believe that this was a problem with the prototypes and this was one of the reasons why they were rebuilt.
Indeed you are right - it is ridiculous to compare a 2-8-2 slowing on 2nd radius curves with a Type 37 diesel which has two tiny wheelbase pivoting bogies - the fixed wheelbase on the P2 is enormous and putting it on 2nd radius looks stupid anyway. Woof!
In my view, as you mentioned, a good compromise is the original R3207 "Railways" version, which has better detailing and decoration compared to its sister Railroad version of the same 2014 era. Having said that, this new version clearly has better slow speed running.
I believe unrebuilt P2s had Caprotti valve gear, which although I'm not certain you can't see move. The plastic kind of makes sense, as it was a black mechanism, and black plastic would be easier to produce over painted metal.
None of the P2s had Caprotti valve gear. Cock of the North had Lentz Rotary Valve Gear, which went through various modifications.
Prince of Wales is a different engine altogether. The A1 steam trust goes into a lot of detail as to what is different, but basically it has a different design of boiler, different valve gear (based on later implementation of Lentz Valve Gear) a completely new design of Pony truck and Roller Bearings on all axles
@@racgordon I stand corrected sir.
Not a point about the model per se, but I really wish the loco it is based on would follow the original classes Scottish naming conventions and be named Duke of Rothesay (the Scottish equivalent title to Prince of Wales)
I believe the A1 trust stated ages ago that 2007 will carry a different name (Think it will actually be Duke of Rothsay) when it is doing work in Scotland. Wish people would drop this silly debate tbh
@@18EStudios I'd not heard that - although I struggled to find a definite statement to that effect there were a few search results about it - and will be happy to stand corrected if such a compromise is indeed the case.
Having a name that respects the traditions of the original class, which in turn celebrates the customs of Scotland, is important and it's not surprising that it has been raised previously (and by people new to the issue, like myself).
Reviews are great but, how about doing a review on layout design software. Ease of use, available track and other icons, cost or free. Part of railway modelling is having a layout so this might be a very interesting sojourn.
Cheers
Ashley
I found the odd one out is the Thompson A2/2 cock of the north and love the new p2 loco model Sam’s trains
The frictional loss from the long wheelbase drivetrain on R2 must be up three with the 9F. Anyone done any calculations?
Hey Sam, will Hornby sell the smoke generator needed for the P2 so you can install it yourself?
Hornby also did a full decoration example of the original railroad model, (same tooling mind).
The original Hornby P2 was a design clever model unfortunately. That's why it was in both railroad and main ranges
How many more times will Hornby reissue this model.? Why not manufacture a loco that hasnt been done before, such as a 'Claughton' ?
The LNER P2, greasley's plaything
Thinking out loud… having the old p2 in the high gloss… would the old body fit on the new chassis?
The other year I had a go at Simon Kohler that I hoped he would get this particular model fully detailed and appropriately painted. This was because the streamlined Hush Hush was more Railroad in its paint application, and I had to give it many hours of work to get it to look fabulous. I told him I wanted to see wood and brass rimed cab windows where appropriate as Bachmann had done to their new V2. It doesn't look like they have 😢
Also, why is that plastic valve gear black and not a steel metal colour ?
We'll have to wait for the real 2007 to be completed, so to see which detail is what colour.
I'd love to see you do a review of a Trix locomotive
That looks an awesome model. The paint looks so much better than the A2/3! Little disaponted that they could not do a metal rotary shaft for the valve gear. esp for the price.
Not sure Im going to be buying though for that price. I really stopped buying when list went over 150, Alreay have the gloss Gresley special edition which while not as good detail wise looks awesome!.
Question - can you retrofit that motor in the old version?
Now that I think of it, I don't recall seeing Sam doing an unboxing of a train on a table.
I don't believe I ever have!
Odd one is the w1
I was hoping that you compare this to the previous P2 but not the Railroad version.
What G scale starter said, would you recommend from Bachmann?
Hi Sam, I need your help.
I am planning to buy two hm7000 sound decoders for my dublo flying sctosman and p2 locos.
Which pin do you recommend is the best for these?
Are you getting the one with a steam generator?
I really love locos with 8 driving wheels
Always amazing to be early to a sams trains video, will you ever review a broadway limited loco? They’re pricey but amazing
And they come with dc\dcc with sound
very nice looking model....love it...always wanted one...but probably won't now......to many locos already......
The odd one out is the A2/2, it is a Thompson rebuild
Looks and runs well....
Well Sam, it looks like the glue monster left the factory. Lol
Cheers Jasper & Willow
haha yeah - not quite as tidy as the other one was it??
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
I've always been intrigued by Hornby having a "Railroad" range. That's a U.S. term for "railway" (as used in the English-speaking world :P ).
Unless i'm mistaken the black, plastic rods dont seem to be present on the Earl Marischal version. This being the case i'd prefer that version.
That is because both models have different valve gear, 2002 has the Walschaerts valve gear which it had when it was originally built back in 1935 and 2007 has the Lentz poppet valve gear which the real locomotive will have when it is complete.
Is the odd one out the Thompson A1
Sam I've been trying to find a Battlespace G10 Q car. It's a oo scale train wagon that opens up a fires a rocket. No one has one . Do you know who would have the plans for one so I can get it 3D printed. Many thanks Darran
I am surprised it took Hornby so long to put a smoke generator in their steam locomotives. Most new HO scale steam locomotives in America (even some diesels) do come with a smoke unit pre-fitted which can be turned on and off. I personally think smoke units in model locomotives look best on O scale or larger.
I thought they already made a new P2?
29:10 the odd one out is a
Spoilers:
A2/2 or A2/3 in BR green i think
i would guess that prototype models tend to exist before real thing.
but in this case shall i assume there is a real life locomotive being built as replica of some olden dessign that never gotten into production?
Yes... The real-life 2007 is being built in Darlington, however I believe it's more accurate to call it a new-build, as they have updated the loco for modern conditions. I wonder if it'll be turned out as a Darlington loco...? 😜
Sam, would it be practical to rename, and re-number this model as P2 Cock o' the North, as to all intents and purposes it is identical, or maybe Hornby could save us the trouble by issuing it as such?
Bit odd that the plates say 2023 on the new one (even if that’s accurate that’s not it’s completion year)
I think I’ll stick with the railroad one for now
I want to paint one in Br Blue and I think I could make one for less than £250!
Even though the railroad one is slightly dated I still am pleased with my railroad p2. Too bad it soon be replaced by prince of wales
Yeah absolutely - it's still a very cool looking model!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
That's amazing review sam
Thanks Justin! :D
nice
Can you confirm that the firebox glow, on dcc, only comes on when the motor is powered up? My A1, Knight of the Thistle glows only when the motor receives power from the decoder, but my Hornby Princess stays on all the time.
This has power all the time - the LED system is connected directly to the loco pickups… I filmed the shot of it working without the tender attached!
Damn-it, I watch the wrong Review first these Green LNER locos look the same Sam. It's nice that they come with an all metal wheel set that can be changed out for the rubber tired/tyred wheel set.
I wouldn't want a tired wheelset...they just wouldn't perform well, wanting to rest all the time 🤣
The odd one out is the A2/2. Easy spot for a guy that is reading up on Thompson at the moment.
I really don't think marking it down on performance is fair, that is largely down to the gigantic wheelbase. I have a few American engines with a similarly sized wheelbase, and those struggle on 2nd radius too, despite passing every other test. I do agree on marking it down on detail for the plastic, immobile valve gear. Disappointing for such an expensive model in that regard. I will be picking this up as soon as I can afford it.
Now they need to redo Duke of Gloucester. Give us the Duke with a metal running plate and valve gear bits, decorated/glowing cab, and sprung buffers!
Iiiis the Odd one out the Hush Hush?... idk for sure, heh
wait, i found it, its the A2, NVM ^^
Is the projected smoke the distilled water version or the old oil type.
I understand the new Hornby system will use water!
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
@@SamsTrains great news, I wish that would become standard here in North America.
Ugh my phone was packed up so I missed the Sam'sTrains new video alarm, yes I actually set alarms for your uploads, that's how I always comment that fast. 😆
Ahh sorry to hear that - glad you got here in the end! :D
Thanks for watching - Sam :)
My model shop near me stocked the railroad p2s as well as the 2023 wagon and some other things, also will you review bachmann annie and clarabel or grumpy diesel, i think you need to so thomas has the right coaches
What about the railway version? I was looking forward to seeing it in the comparison as well as I have a sound fitted version which I'm considering upgrading. The railroad version isn't a worthy comparison in my mind as they're different markets. Still enjoyed the review though.
Yeah the two are just the same modes - the railways version just has some extra painted parts and tender pickups… that’s all!
A Very Lovely looking Model Sam 🙂🚂🚂🚂
What a bizarre choice to have half the linkage be static plastic, i wonder why that is