Meet The MOST HATED Judge On MasterChef..
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 11. 2023
- Today we are going over the MasterChef judge everyone absolutely hated. Did you like or dislike him and WHY? Let me know in the comments!
1. Most MEMORABLE Dishes on Hell’s Kitchen
• Most MEMORABLE Dishes ...
2. Times Gordon Ramsay got SICK on Kitchen Nightmares!
• Times Gordon Ramsay go...
BECOME A MEMBER HERE: / @filmtravelerr
Join my Discord server:
/ discord
My socials:
/ filmtravelerr
/ filmtravelerr
/ filmtravelerr
/ 100094459811328
For all business inquiries: thefuturetravelerbusiness@gmail.com - Zábava
If you enjoyed the video, make sure to become a member here:
www.youtube.com/@FilmTravelerr
just look at Ramsey's expression in the background, and also look at when he had his own mother on the show and how embarressed she was.
That person seems arrogant based on appearance, unlike Gordon Ramsay, who has proved a lot by showcasing his skills and taking on challenges from diverse cuisines like Japanese. Ramsay’s track record in the culinary world speaks volumes!
It's better to replace that chef.
'With his track record, it doesn't sound too crazy'
Doesn't mean they're true. Prove it
@@jimmyso1645 he's not a rea; chef right, he just own a restaurant from his family
Joe is qualified to hand you a menu and take you to your table. That's about it.
hes not even qualified to do that with his, attitude, he'd be the one to tell a Chinese family that *this restaurant doesn't serve cat*.
No, at most he qualifies to mop the floors with tape over his mouth just so he’d shut up, and he barely even qualifies for that
Damn, people had no standard of service nowadays?
I doubt that he would pass the interview, or even breakout of his ego and get a job to begin with...
Stil has more restaurants then you ever will have
The final straw that made me lose what little respect I had for Joe is when he said that in his restaurant, he would put Christine Huyen Tran Hà in the coat room because of her disability. It made Christine winning that season even greater. He’s an absolute pig and I’m glad to see someone make a video on even just the smallest part of it!
That would be an insult to pigs.
Wtf
Him calling Christine a liability in the kitchen while he’s an even bigger liability himself
And that’s fucked up she went on ahead and won making the impossible possible despite the fact that she’s blind
Cry harder. Any episode with Joe was the best ones
What joe said about the blind contestant was the nail in the coffin for me. Even my "everyone is so sensitive these days" dad gasped during that episode
Dont blame him. The guy is being a genuine ass. If you have very little regard that the person you're putting down is a human being without any critical thought or reasoning, it's not right.
i hate to admit it. but he does have a point about people being more sensitive......good lord i hate admitting that.
@@thanoseid2883 so you know its bad when the "everyone is sensitive these days" guy gasps at something
@@toniotrussardi8126 yep. big time.
That made my blood boil so much. Since i myself am blind/have limited low vision. Being told that people like us are a liability is extremely hurtful :(
I'm italian and I would point out that Joe became a sort of national meme because of his improbable pronunciations of italian words along with actual grammar errors. The fact that he wanted to correct someone about italian pronunciations is incredible.
Is the Graziella thing a pun or actually a name? Sounds like he's saying you should be called "Thanks woman"?
@@citizensnips2348 don't worry, Graziella is a normal italian name
I love Italian Food, though IK I've never had authentic ones due to it's rarity in Canada. Also, they usually have pork from my experience. But IK that Italy can be evenly divided into "North", "Central", and "South" + "Sicily" and "Sardinia". And each "state" has it's own culture.
For sure! Every italian I know laughs their ass of at fake italian Joe who knows about as much about Italy as a weeb knows about Japan.
@shadmanhasan4205 Italy has only existed as it is since 1946, the kingdom of Italy was late 1800s I think but that wasn't all of it today. It was composed of city states and independent kingdoms between the fall of Rome and then. Much of Europe was the same really, even say in France which has existed as a kingdom for millenia, you can still divide it into areas of different languages or dialects, which only relatively recently were combined into a single common language and identity. It's really fascinating. And so much good food to discover.
But yeah, northern and southern Italian food are completely different. Equally delicious, of course. Sorry, that was way longer than it needed to be.
Gordon is a very kind person, he’s only aggressive and harsh because he wants you to be amazing, he’s tough on you because he believes in you! Joe has no regard for any of the chefs and just likes bullying them, that’s why I can’t stand Joe!
This is description of Gordon is exactly why his meme exists (“Oh, dear! Oh gorgeous!” VS “YOU FUCKING DONKEY!”). He’s a tough teacher, but a teacher with pride. There is no hesitation on his part to help a kid who’s supposed to be the cream of the crop because he recognizes that even if they are the best, they are still learning and eager to receive praise. He comforts the kids, explains what they did wrong, and how they could do better and try again. That’s why in Gordon’s other shows, especially in Hell’s Kitchen, he’s much more aggressive. In some of these shows, he doesn’t coddle the new chefs, but he exercises a lot more patience compared to Hell’s Kitchen, who have had their time and experience to hone their skills, so he is inevitably angry when someone talks big and comes up short.
Gordon is like a father cause he only is agreesive and harsh on you because he cares for you. Joe is just that Step father that hates you.
Yeah, you can always tell that Gordon just wants chefs/cooks/contestants on his shows to succeed and be great based on how he shifts how he talks to them based on what they need. He's hard on the professional chefs with years of restaurant experience and huge egos but SO much softer and gentler with cooks who don't have that kind of training or who just lack confidence. Joe just seemed to delight in his role of being the 'mean judge' and trashing cooks, which really sucks because you know some of those contestants were really deeply hurt by what he said. Even if their dishes weren't good, there's a difference between constructive criticism meant to better an individual and just trying to tear someone down to make them cry on television.
Joe’s the perfect example of what happens when you make Gordon’s rage and language of insults your entire personality.
Gordon aint even mad at like amateur chefs. He gets very pissed at PROFESSIONAL chefs because he has high expectations for them because they are supposedly pros at this. For example hells kitchen
Gordon once said in an interview that the difference between hell's kitchen and masterchef is that in hell's kitchen those are supposed to be professionals while masterchef are cooks, home cooks, and other who just picked up cooking as hobby and he recognized that. Which is why he is less harsh and provides more feed back in masterchef compared to hell's kitchen
Yeah, that's kind of what drew me into this show at first, but then they do the Hell's Kitchen-like restaurant takeover challenges, and all of that goes out the window. These are home cooks who don't need to produce dishes in that environment and have likely never done so. Putting them in that situation and expecting the perfection level they seem to want really takes me out of it.
@@JRAndrachI mean, it's fine closer to finals, since people who get that far would most likely be scouted and could use job experience. But early on? Nah.
Yes, and Hell's Kitchen is his restaurant, his reputation is basically on the line letting the contestants cooking in it and serving customers.
I believe in the same interview he specifically stated that especially in HK he sees chefs who call themselves executive chefs and he is a lot more critical of them than those that just got out of school or have less experience.
Gordon is only strict in team challenges in MasterChef because they want the guests to eat their food delicately. If they fuck up even one mistake, he will be angry as hell.
9:23 "shes a liability, she cant even do it"
He says as she's literally right there in the kitchen, cooking no problem.
That made my blood boil so much. Since i myself am blind/have limited low vision. Being told that people like us are a liability is extremely hurtful :(
@@jackieec Its rude but its also true.
Its a team game and obviously Christine cant contribute much.
And it was Joe whos root to Christine from the very beginning of the season.
Hes still an asshole, but we are getting unfair here
@@sentryward8744 ok ableist
In reality and not controlled environment she would fail absolutely. Get to reality dmbss
@@sentryward8744 she is clearly capable .. she isn't a liability in any way at all. That comment was extremely rude and really demeaning . How can you even say that to a person ?
The fact that nobody knocked some of his teeth out is a freaking miracle
He has all of them in place
i would omg
@@TeoHyung i would force feed him pineapple on pizza
@toniotrussardi8126 Good 👍. Giving this douche NYC-style, Chicago-Style, even Margareta Style would just give him a blessing. Just get a cheap store-bought one + cover it entirely with Pineapple + Anchovies.
@@toniotrussardi8126Oh my god, I would pay to see someone force pineapple on pizza down his throat. Real talk though, it's not bad
Gordon and Graham: Criticize the food.
Joe: Criticizes the person.
That says everything you need to know about his credentials in the food industry and who he is as a person.
😂
nah bro it's not critcizing anymore, that's straight up bullying
its not even critic.
critic is constructive.
which is ironic considering that there's a LOT to criticize about Joe's "person" ... the call is clearly coming from inside the house
The problem with Joe is that he tries to emulate Gordon's criticism without being constructive.
Gordon is harsh, but when it comes down to it, he has heart.
That person seems arrogant based on appearance, unlike Gordon Ramsay, who has proved a lot by showcasing his skills and taking on challenges from diverse cuisines like Japanese. Ramsay’s track record in the culinary world speaks volumes!
Gordon is like the dad that's hard on his kids because he knows they can do better. Joe is just a professional asshole.
and gordon at the end of the day genuinely cares. he’s harsh, but it’s because he wants to push them to the next level, not to shut them down or be a bully. his criticism is always backed with actual feedback, encouragement, and action to support the person he’s criticizing. sometimes his harshness will hurt, but the difference between him and joe is that joe’s criticism begins and ends with being a dickhead. gordon will go the extra mile to work with you and genuinely help you improve, because he genuinely wants to see you improve. not only with feedback, either. there’s plenty of footage of him teaching chefs how to improve their cook, or if his criticism ends up hurting the chef, him talking them down and encouraging them. he does a LOT for the people he criticizes, because cooking is his passion. but joe just wants to be a cunt.
Gordon actually gives a fuck and wants you to be the best you can be
@@drumbolist3295 nice copy-pasta to many comments. Joe is just an ass-hat that deserves no spotlight.
He was literally the reason I didn't watch during the show.
Knowing that he also was sued for and settled out of a sexual harassment lawsuit is also unsurprising.
His associate was accused. That’s it
@@liminalcriminal_lol nah he was popping off at the mouth to Chinese spa workers in Italy with his small dick energy and lack of testosterone - hence the baldness and limp wrists. Man's got no shame and is a beta simp.
And you are judge with the people you are with
he straight up called christine ha a liability because of her disability 💀
Dude had no filter smh
And she won
Because it’s true, regardless of her winning, she’d be a liability in the kitchen.
The funniest thing is when the contestants always say “Yes chef….Yes chef…… Yes Joe” when receiving feedback from the 3 judges, cuz they always gotta remind Joe he’s not a real chef
cold
I would say it is deserved that he is not called a chef.
Lmao
That's actually funny. I've never paid attention to that but your comment made me laugh a bit
I love it 😂
I’m surprised Gordon, Graham, and Arron were able to put up with all of Joe's BS remarks on MC and how disrespectful he is IRL.
I’m surprised Gordon hasn’t blown up at Joe by now
Because the Joe we see is a reality TV character/persona and not the real Joe.
The same can be said for HK Gordon vs MC Jr Gordon. He takes on a totally different role/attitude depending on what he needs to do for his show. Even HK vs MC is different and he's a lot nicer and more forgiving on MC with home cooks.
Joe plays the heel so well on MC and he makes a great heel in general because he has a naturally abrasive personality.
Who cares, he was fun
@@matthewbest5421If Joe wasn't a trust fund baby helping keep the ratings up, Gordon probably would have snapped at him the way he snaps at every dickhead restaurant owner on Kitchen Nightmares.
That shows that even when Gordon Ramsay might be a little harsh at times he's a professional unlike joe and graham is a good guy
graham: disappointed mom
gordon: disappointed dad
Joe: abusive alcoholic stepdad
Joe is more like that one lonely angry alcoholic uncle no one likes.
I think you nailed everything wrong with Joe perfectly here. I was never the biggest masterchef fan, but I did watch quite a few episodes, and I always hated Joe. My biggest problem with him is the fact that, as you said, he almost NEVER comments on a persons dish, he is never happy, and he always personally insults the competitors. Gordon for example, is harsh too, he provides great entertainment value with how harsh he is, but at the very least he will actually tell you what is wrong with your dish and how to improve it. On the other hand, Joe is just like "Your food sucks, you are an embarrassment, I bet you got straight Fs in school, also your hairline sucks and your mom is fat, go home kid". It is just so pretentious, annoying, and just plain wrong.
I could never watch Masterchief USA because of Joe so I just watched Canada instead. Much better watch and not cringe at all.
This dude was never punched in the face, and it shows.
It's also pretty ironic that he accused someone of narcissism, when it's clear he is the narcissist.
That person seems arrogant based on appearance, unlike Gordon Ramsay, who has proved a lot by showcasing his skills and taking on challenges from diverse cuisines like Japanese. Ramsay’s track record in the culinary world speaks volumes!
It's better to replace that chef.
It's not ironic. It's what a narcissist does. Everyone is a narcissist except him, and if he is a narcissist, it was for a good reason.
That's the narcissist prayer
That's not what narcissism is, so no.
However him just throwing around a diagnosis is really dumb
@@OriginalSirSpeaksAlot
You beat me to it.
I had commented in another video about how Gordon truly loves "fighters" in these competitions. He personally talked several contestants out of quitting, because of their passion and talents in the kitchen. Tamar is another example of why I respect Ramsey. He is always on the hunt for individuals who are capable of being "molded" into proper chefs and knowing who the right allies were to help those individuals. Joe was just an a-hat, and I really hated him and his attitude to CHEF Christine
Joe was the best one
Dude is definitely annoying. But makes the show more enjoyable
@@FilmTravelerr i won't deny the show is enjoyable because of his attitude. However, I feel he should be the host of the show and allow actual trained Chefs to be the judges. It just feels like he hates the fact he has to judge home cooks, he rarely offers any actual feedback while the other judges actually explain why the dishes don't work, and it honestly feels like he could careless about anyone who has the talent and more for who is going to create the most drama. As a host, he could do that and the show would still be exciting.
@@yaang9258 he doesn't offer those things because he doesn't know how XD
@@jacksmith-vs4ct pretty much said that lol
Pretty sure he just inherited a wine brand instead of ever brewing wine
I believe so.
16:00 Actually, there IS such thing as garlic bread in Italy. Olive oil and garlic. There's no such thing as garlic CHEESE bread in Italy.
That's surprising, considering how much they love their cheese.
@@maxburrill6192very surprising actually
Being to Italy a few times in my life, this is surprisingly true for me. I rarely saw any of the Cheese Garlic bread variety. But usually for me it’s the basket of fresh warm bread, with a little dish of olive oil/garlic dip.
God if i was a judge there and i wasn't under contract, I'd turn to Joe and tell him that the contestants aren't trained chefs and deserve the courtesy of their food being tasted and their feedback being useful. Throwing away a dish without tasting it helps no one and makes him look like a child
100000% true. All the other judges give constructive criticism. I would say Gordon can sometimes give some comments that aren’t needed, but at least he tastes the food and gives actual criticism on top of that
I bet Joe would retaliate with something amongst the line of "This is master chef, not some training centre, we're looking for the best of the best." excuse/reason.
Trained chefs? They are home cooks, not chefs. And untrained?? Did you seriously think that they would pick inexperienced cooks and throw them into the biggest cooking competition in the world?
@@alberb I don’t think you’re reading the comment clearly, he said they *aren’t* trained chefs, he didn’t say they were chefs to begin with. And also in no part of the comment did they say they were untrained
they dont deserve "courtesy" its a tv show. Stop taking it so seriously, its top quality entertainment
Joe is someone who watched Gordon Ramsey and wanted to emulate that behavior without having a heart
I would say this sums him up to a T
More to the point, when Ramsay gets sharp it's out of growing frustration that words aren't working. When Joe does it there is no escalation. He comes at people on the attack.
@@FilmTravelerr
It’s like he fancies himself as the Simon Cowell of MasterChef but lacks Simon’s redeeming qualities that make the audience love him.
@eliasdailey3911 gordon himself emulate it from Marco Pierre White.
@DuongNguyen-kz2eq I feel MPW is WAY more savage. He's refused service over someone asking for salt. Could you imagine that in today's society?
He tried to be Gordon Ramsey
But Ramsey had intelligence and wanted other chefs to learn
That bold guy was just trash
That bald guy*
Chef cooks Chow Mein
Joe: Refuses to eat it
Also Joe: There's no such thing as Chow Mein in Italy
He's a nepo-baby gone wrong. It's as simple as that. His mother's cook books are fantastic, though. I learned a lot from her works.
Joe should probably take notes from her too
I'm so mad finding out who his mother is through this video I loved watching her cooking show with my mom. Now he just comes off as a momma's boy with the "my mommy cooks better than you I don't even need to try it nyeh!"
Too bad she seems like a terrible mother
After seeing all the shit joe has done, I wanna slap Lidia with a barbed wire glove.
What kind of shitty parent do you have to be to make a child like that?
Joe is an example of the spoiled kid that their parents never said no to
A spoiled child who piggybacks on his parent's success
Well it's true. His mum is apparently a pretty well-known author of Italian cookbooks
@@riatorex8722dont forget slave owner
@@riatorex8722Lidia is not just an author of cookbooks, i grew up watching her cooking show on the creative pbs station. She is an Italian home cook staple, and honestly i feel like she was a pretty harsh mother. You can kinda tell with joe's cooking ideals, they're not just because it's how his mom made it, he probably had his knuckles whipped for raw garlic.
A soiled child doesn’t necessarily mean bad parents, as long as they teach them right, if I had a child(prob never will no man loves me) I’d love to spoil them and have a good time with them but would still teach them about money and how it works
I'm not convinced he's ever actually cooked anything.
Lowkey seems that way lol
Also, notice how in every restaurant takeover, Gordon and Aaron/Ghram are in the kitchen while Joe strolls through the tables taking orders.💀💀
That’s the only thing he’s capable of since the most complicated dish he has ever done on MasterChef was a freaking risotto, that everyone can do at home lmao
Everyone knows that strange feeling when you see someone for the first time and instantly dont like him. He is a prime example for that. The arrogance is just jumping out of his face man
He just has a punchable face
@@FilmTravelerr for me its more like a punching bag with legs lol
@@FilmTravelerrhe looks like Andrew Tate
This comment hit me: my relatives and I used to watch MasterChef a good few years ago. I was little back then; I took a liking to Graham, took a liking to Gordon, but for some reason that my younger brain couldn’t figure out for the life of me, I liked Joe the least. Seems like I definitely experienced this with him. Glad I can get a bit more insight now as to why. :’)
Exactly
The sexual tention between him and that trash can is incredible
😂😂😂
Fr, like, make out already🙄
The way he pop opens that lid GOD DAMN😳😳😳
@@mypaldracunyan1223They should get married 😂
@@aether4068 IKR! I'll totally be at the wedding
Can we talk about how he trashed on one of the kid contestants who tried making homemade syrup? I remember watching that and my jaw being on the floor
Quick note about how food tasting works in Master Chef:
The contestants prepare the dishes twice. The first batch is prepared, the contestants leave to do the interviews and the judges taste the food alone while it's still warm.
The second batch is then filmed and the tasting is just for the camera, the opinions have already been made.
This is completely fine as each meal gets tasted fresh and warm.
When Ramsey says you’re going overboard. You should probably rethink your strategy
He’s probably the right guy to say that lol
Ramsey is harsh but never mean. He provides valid points and everything he says is reinforced by his experience. Joe Basandwich is an egomaniac narcissist who acts high and mighty to cosplay as a chef and hide what a small insignificant miserable man he is.
It's spelt Ramsay
Not Ramsey
@@saintpepsi8602 shut up nerd
@@saintpepsi8602 only joking
I never understood why he was a judge. I hated him because he wasn't a chef, and he picked apart dishes like he knew what he was talking about; and never gave any actual feedback on dishes.
Plenty of dishes that Ramsay loved got shot down by Joe. The biggest shit move from him was dissing the Sticky Toffee Pudding that was baked instead of steamed; which Gordon himself said was better than his own. But Joe didn't like it, and never even gave a reason why.
It was a blow to his ego thats why. The best chef in the world loved the dish and was honest when he thought it was better and he didn't like that.
Joe's like saying Gordon's pudding is even worse lmao
@@justaplayer_8392 I'd very much argue against Ramsey being the best chef in the world. Most recognized by non-chefs maybe, but not THE BEST. This isn't dissing Ramsey, mind you, he himself would say the exact same.
Well he does know how to cook and i think its partially a character as i saw the kids version and he was much kinder, but i must iterate that you dont need to go to culinary school to know how to cook.
Because it’s a reality tv show, not an actual competition. The underdog contestant is going to win over anyone even if their dishes are worse. If a contestant is a massive asshole that causes drama they’re going to stay on longer than they should. Joe is there to add tons of drama and zingers.
For whatever reason US reality tv show producers think that the audience is going to get bored if the show takes itself seriously so they have people like Bastianich on there to be extra mean for no reason.
Gordon: The dish is awful
Graham: The excecution was awful
Joe: *You are awful*
😂😂😂
The dumbest interaction I ever saw with him on MasterChef was when that one guy was auditioning and made a sausage roll and Joe tries it and goes “I don’t know, 5 minutes ago I didn’t even know what a sausage roll was so..” So what?! Do you like the food or not?!?!
How did this human being go his whole life without knowing what a SAUSAGE ROLL is? 😭 Spoiled rich kids don't eat "peasant food"
I love how the camera consistently switches back to Gordon trying not to break his jawline from cringe whenever Joe is judging, meanwhile Graham doesn't even have any other option but to stand in painful silence.
He almost broke character a couple times lol
@@FilmTravelerr Except not... that's literally just your subjective interpretation. If Gordon was upset with one of his judges he wouldn't constantly bring him back season after season.
You can all just admit you have no taste and move on... there's no need to collectively defend your garbage palette.
@@joshuakelly9390 Gordon Ramsay isn't even the one who hires the judges. He's just a judge himself. There's a reason why Joe hasn't been on the show in years. Just admit you have no taste in quality PEOPLE.
@@pieexplosion101 It's literally his show
You'd have to be a moron to say the things you're saying
@@joshuakelly9390get off Joe's meat Josh, u can stop now, bet this is the closest we've seen u socialise, get some friends okay
My favorite scene of him is from Masterchef Junior is when Joe is showing the kids how to cook a basic risotto. He explains it like it is the most difficult dish in the history of cooking and says what I believe was "It looks easy but it is not". Followed by Chef Gordon and Christina holding back laughter and looking at each other like they thought "This guy lmao".
Marco Pierre White's risotto is the best recipe I've seen. He makes it look easy
Garlic bread isn't a thing in Italy. - Joe the guy who got put judging food.
@@cd-zw2tt marco is a genius.
@@lynarisevershadeshadowfall1684 i nearly wanted to slap him when he said that.
I REMEMBER THAT EPISODE OMG AND NOW I REALIZE HOW EASY IT IS
Joe deserves jail time for disrespecting Christine like that.
I always found him amusing. Even just the way he'd taste the contestant's food. How he maintains eye contact with them the whole time to try and look tough and / or scare them. The guy's a joke, and I love watching him try and act like he's not.
My brother got to meet Ramsay when he went to England for a business trip back in 2017, he greeted and shook his hand and asked him if he could take a photo with him, Ramsay was with two of his kids and said he really couldn’t and that he was in a rush. My brother understood and then walked away thanking him, as he was walking he heard Ramsay shouting wait and he said 1 or 2 pictures is fine. That simple gesture of kindness made my brothers trip to London a memorable one. Ramsay is a genuine dude in person and the shouting and cursing he does on tv is almost entirely for show.
This is why I love Gordon. Such an awesome, selfless individual
Not enough people realize that Chef is actually super sweet and cares very deeply. Not just about his family but people in general. It's just that he hates bullshit and people being morons.
Which is 100% fair.
Gordon is a good guy.
@@sophieamandaleitontoomey9343 It's like that Grinch shirt that I keep seeing. "He didn't hate Christmas, but he hated people which same."
@@TheCbrown146 Exactly. lol
Joe is actually a very qualified chef. He has cooked under some of the greatest chefs in the world in several different countries all over the world...in his mind
He is, just not the best with people overall lol
had me in the first half ngl
I heard he had the audacity to say that he would give Gordon or Graham a run for their money if they ever do a cook off.
@@minhkhoaluong25 anecdotal evidence, but i agree thats some audacity if he really said that.
@@FilmTravelerr I think you missed the sarcasm lol Joe isn't a chef.
The difference between him and Gordon Ramsay is that Gordon has good intentions and with passion. Its tough love vs bullying
He must have been bullied in school, now that he has the littlest bit of power he abuses tf out of it. By taking his anger out on masterchef contestants whenever he sees an opportunity
You’re projecting. Your bullies still laugh at you.
He’s a pathetic waste of specimen lol a shell of a “man “
@@codymays9943you’re a jerk it’s probably you who’s projecting
What really made me lose all respect for him, was on master chef junior. there were times where Joe literally bullied the children, and said some really harmful things to them that could scar them for life. he doesn't understand that even though these kids are talented, they are still children trying to learn and grow under their guidance. Yet here is joe in the show, ripping apart the children and literally had remorse what so ever. i was happy when they replaced him with someone else in the master chef junior show.
He did take it a bit too far there
@@FilmTravelerr shut up bro.
@@FilmTravelerrA Bit?
That’s why I have so much respect for Gordon- yes he is extremely critical… But he knows when to pull it back and treat the person like a person
If you mean well and at least try Gordon sees that and will actually show that
like what?
Joe knows he messed up when Gordon Ramsay said we made our first genuine mistake 😢 but the cherry in the cake was when he called a blind contestant a liability just because of her disability like WTF joe? 🤦♂️
Ableist fucker, that's what Joe is. I love how he got clowned on by Christina(the blind chef in question) winning the whole thing and being a head chef, because it showed how bullshit his claims were lmao
NAHHHH 💀 THATS WILD 💀
yea and she has 1000x more talent than he could ever dream of.
Do you know what liability means? You realize that 99.999% of blind people, if put on a cooking line, would be a liability?
@@liminalcriminal_you know how people and their feelings are
Calling Joe a chef is like me calling myself a professional chef because I interned as a fry cook for 6 months. Frankly, I think even I have more experience than him.
Fun fact: when he said "theres no such thing as garlic bread in italy", i went to find a Lydia Bastianich video where she makes garlic bread.
I told her "make this for joe next time he comes over, he said it doesnt exist" and she liked the comment. To me, this is his own MOTHER acknowledging he's a douche.
Joe makes Gordon look like a angel and a saint lol.
Gordon: Your food can be better, but you need to focus and work hard to be better.
Joe: Your food is trash, why are you even here in this competition, get out.
Reminds me of the art classes I took in college and receiving critiques. Someone who genuinely cares about the craft can recognize passion and skill that might be rough around the edges and just needs some guidance and refinement. Someone who only cares about their ego and feels like they constantly need to prove themselves will just tear down everything for no reason, there will always be something wrong and it will always be irredeemable.
One is a chef and the other likes shiny things
Gordon actually earned his spot I really doubt Joe even knows how to boil water
No Joe is more: "Your dish is trash, no wonder your wife cheated on you and your dad died in a car accident because how much of a disgrace you are"
He's so full of himself and it's crazy the way he's allowed to treat people , how on earth were they meant to learn from their mistakes or take criticism with the way he just verbally abuses them and refuses to try the food, I'm surprised no one ever snapped at him.
I care. Being Italian is important. He has an incredible eye for Italian talent and can qualify Italian dishes from a mile away. He really has a talent for this.
@@joshuakelly9390 L take + ratio
@@joshuakelly9390just Italian dishes on master chef? That’s like 10% of the dishes
@@kmsb1573 lol. Good job deleting your comment
@@kmsb1573 yuppers
He's a nepotism baby. He only got the gig as a judge as his mother is a world famous television chef.
Lydia Bastianich is so lovely, it seems Joe was intentionally being very critical to make a name for himself or reputation for being tough like Ramsay
The big difference between Hell’s Kitchen and Masterchef is that one is trying to improve their skill in cooking, and the other is trying to become an executive chef at one of Ramsay’s restaurants
Graham: Shows the most kindness and explains why the dishes are good.
Gordon: Harsh, but fair criticism, seeing the potential in the chef.
Joe: *The perfect merge between Low Tier God and Andrew Tate*
Hahaha
You should throw your food out NOW!!!
That's hilarious 😂
that's an insult to those two people, he's the worst of the worst, embodying the worst qualities of human 💀
@@betterboiyour dish has no purpose
Ya know its bad when even Gordon looks pissed and annoyed
Forreal!!
"Ughh here we go😒"
He’s never annoyed
@@makinyoumad9498nah he’s 💯% done with joes bs
11:00 Bro looks like a rip off andrew tate
I remember as a younger kid and teen I thought Gordon was just a colossal jerk and quickly realized now that I'm in my mid 20s that Gordon is beyond reasonable most of the time and even gives more leeway than he probably should for some. Joe not only is a colossal hygienic product that I cant type out on here, but likely cant cook himself. He was always that bad and likely embarrasses his mom who is a professional. The type of complex he has is mind numbing.
Joe blew my mind when he told a contestant that they should be ashamed for using onion powder, as allegedly "real chefs" don't use that garbage, yet it's boldly displayed on the spice rack in the back of Hell's Kitchen.
Which makes everything feel way much better when Gordon himself says “you are such a fucking snob” when he tries to mock a dish for having garlic bread since he doesn’t like it.
@@JugularJohni think I remember that. Before Gordon called him a F snob didn't Joe also insult Gordon and Aaron's restaurants like "what kind of restaurants are you guys running?" when the 2 said that there's nothing wrong with garlic bread or something.
@@INCOGNITO-iq4qy he just comes across as a Gordon Ramsey wannabe without any of the charm, or the limits of criticism, or the heart
He’s actually right. That’s a spice that ghetto black people use. The type of people who call white food “unseasoned” if it isn’t doused in a pound of dollar store onion and garlic powder.
Canned foods are in HK too. Just about everything is.
During the Chinese quinine challenge Joe was probably expecting chicken balls, Spring roles, and a fortune cookie
Spring rolls is not even Chinese food
@@rency1803 i mean they r but ok
@@alessandrohu1576they aren’t. They are Vietnamese
@@lysfranc8782 ive seen many theories, this is the dumbest one
@@lysfranc8782 Yeah idk what weird theories about food you guys are getting. If anything fortune cookies are from Japan
Imagine going on a cooking show and hoping to get critiqued by the likes of Ramsay, Graham Elliot or Marco Pierre White, and instead you have a random bald dwarf telling you that your food sucks.
7:05 he probably realized that someone who didn't make their decision based on facts wasn't going to change their mind based on facts
I feel like there wouldn't have been a problem if he criticized the food from a non-culinary perspective, but from a customer perspective. But instead, he acted like he was the smartest judge in the show.
Judging it from a customer perspective would've been smart.
Sadly, it seems he didn't get that memo.
@@mackenziewoloschuk7375 He also didn't understand that the other judges even taste or had their own opinions on the matter. When you critique a food, you would want every form of criticism. But Joe acted like his "critique" was enough and spoke for everyone. Even Gordon looked uncomfortable and looked upset when Joe threw food out or insulted the chefs during those scenes where Joe rips into them
He IS well versed in how restaurants work and what sells so that would make sense but that's not what he does. He's power tripping the whole time.
That’s a good idea.. the judges not all being chefs but one representing a chef, one representing a customer, and maybe on representing a foodie or food connoisseur maybe? Idk I feel like the diff perspectives would be cool!
@@MilkyisDead that would be perfect, an onterestong take, and HAS been done before by other shows and had worked for those too!
It could totally work here!
Essentially "A physical disability is a liability in the kitchen."
Ramsay: "Let me introduce you to someone."
Dave enters the room.
Joe: Why do I hear boss music?
Dave would give Joe an Aneurysm
I’m sorry but who is Dave? I’m trying to see if something is clicking in my mind but I have no clue 🥹
@@koyasworld4156 He's from Hell's Kitchen season 6. He actually broke his arm early in the competition (Think one of the first few days) and won the season with one arm.
Ramsay called him the "One-Armed Bandit". People commented that he was able to do the job of 3 cooks with one hand.
He impressed Ramsay so much that a couple seasons later, he was referenced by him to a contestant on the show who was whining about something minor. He became a legend in Hell's Kitchen.
@@Keiji555Ya got a link of that clip? I genuinely wanna see it, sounds really dope lmao
@rivy-lurk-869 pretty sure you can just find the entire season on youtube
Here’s the ironic thing.
Joe believed that Howard was going to win MasterChef during his audition where he made a basic cobbler, and was so confident he went out and told everyone he believed Howard could win. But once Howard was in the MasterChef kitchen he naturally underperformed, and every time that happened, Joe would bully and berate him because it shows joe’s own incompetence. As untalented as Howard is, it’s not his fault that he failed entirely, it’s also Joe’s fault. There’s a reason why auditions exist, to seperate the good from the bad, if Joe was any good, he wouldn’t have given Howard an apron, let alone go out and tell everyone Howard would win.
On the other hand, Joe completely underestimated Christina purely because of her disability, and yet she excels throughout the whole series, proves everyone wrong and wins. Funny that.
THANK YOU! This guy has erked me for years. I prayed when I watched a random episode of MasterChef that he wasn’t in it. And how he disrespects the chef by throwing their whole plate away, even Gordon doesn’t do that often. And he never gives any real constructive criticism, it’s just douchey criticism.
Joe was just a man child that happened to get his life in order and owned a couple restaurants. He bullied others and just flat out threw dishes away for his own self esteem and ego
He didn't get his life in order. His family did. He didn't own restaurants, he got it handed by inheritance.
Man is Devon Weston irl
@@krlost4405 Stop trying to strip a man of his accomplishments. That’s so fucked up. Shit like this is why I genuinely fucking hate people. If you’re was born into wealth, people will always attribute your success to it no matter what. Have some fucking empathu
This guy exudes "my dad owns Club Penguin" energy and it shows.
Why Club Penguin?! 😂😂😂
@@FilmTravelerr he just seems that childish and generally unimportant
LMAO
He has also been in the hotel space. I heard he owned Habbo Hotel for a while. 😅
I hope this guy gets put into a cooking competition, and then the judges just throw away his dish and insult him for 30 minutes.
You can see he's holding the tears building up in his his eyes 4:28
Yeah poor guy 😢
Joe is the reason I never auditioned for Masterchef, honestly. He's so hostile and egotistical, and I'm just not the kind of person who can sit back and take that kind of treatment. I'd either snap back at him and get booted off, or break down and get booted off.
fr, like im not the type to get hurt over every little thing. But if you barley eat the food and proceed to fucking insult me and give NO constructive criticism on my dish on live television, shits gonna get violent.
Hostile and egoistical ..like...most of customers?
@@mana_bananaYou're there to serve customers. Joe isn't serving anything aside his own ego.
@@Baelfyre I apologize in advance for my bad English. I understand the essence of the complaints, but people are used to idealizing things, highlighting them and pushing them to the maximum of expectations. Reality says that people like Joe are an integral part of almost any activity related to serving people. No matter what you think about them, no matter how unfair it is to you and your abilities - 1 person can decide your fate with a pedigree in stock. There are a huge number of them and you don’t even need to be rich to behave like Joe, you may simply not be in the mood and this will affect the person’s future career.
People like Joe personify a certain layer of people that you need to go through, you need to serve, you need to understand his desires and his approach to assessment. This is social engineering, which can affect both your professional destiny and your personal view of previously hidden things. I hope I expressed myself the way I wanted
@@mana_bananaThe problem is I don't figure MasterChef is about meeting the customers. It's about the food. It's about the cooking. So why do I care that the consumer is a shitty asshole? That's not the goal of this show, and he's not helping anyone.
Graham: Tries to find what you did well in the dish.
Gordon: Explains to you why the dish doesn’t work.
Joe: YOU’RE A DISGRACE TO LIFE AND YOUR PARENTS SHOULD’VE GAVE YA AWAY WHEN THEY HAD THE CHANCE!
😂😂😂
Graham: this isnt good because Y
Gordon: it the X could be done better with Y
Joe: your hand doesnt work
Graham: this is good but I think you could add a little more to it
Gordon: You did well, but there needs to be a little more, but otherwise a good dish
Joe: you're a shameful nobody who does not respect the culinary arts. Your mother should've gave birth to you on the toliet bowl and flushed
@@ripnob
Graham and Gordon: criticizes, *gives advice* , gives hope
Joe: DISHONOR ON YOUR FAMILY, DISHONOR ON YOU, DISHONOR ON YOUR COW
Graham is the best, he is too good for the show.
Bro has the guts to call Christine a liability when he is a liability on the contest. At least put someone like Alvin Leung in his place he may be angry but when he likes a dish he smiles and compliments. Joe just acts like a rich kid who values nothing.
God watching him talk to those women in the nail salon make me feel very ill.
Bullying chefs are ridiculous. I would have taught them both a lesson in respect
No you wouldn't 😂😂
Cry harder
Lol how long have you worked in a kitchen as head chef?
Joe yeah but Gordon nah 😂
@@AlmaWadeCrymsm as long as Joe has
I feel sorry for his mother. If I was her, I'd be ashamed of how my son turned out.
You should look up his mother before you comment on this....
He is the reason mother's eat their young in the animal universe.
Bastianich: *"There's no such thing as garlick bread in Italy"*
me: *laughing in bruschetta* 🇮🇹
Bruschetta Is not garlic bread Bro
You put garlic in bruschetta but Is not garlic bread , garlic bread Is garlic and bread
@dossisimone3366 Bro sounding like Joe. He must be your mentor
@@dossisimone3366 bruschetta is toasted bread topped with whatever cheese, meats, and or veggies you want and olive oil. If you put garlic on the toasted bread, it's garlic bread.
Bruschetta is not garlic bread cojone ignorante del cazz0
i think the another problem is when you only eat fancy food you also kinda lose touch what normal people consider good food and forget that some of the best dishes are quite simple to make and there's nothing wrong with that
"perfection is lots of little things done well" - Marco Pierre
The show improved so much when Christina Tosi joined, in my opinion. She was knowledgeable and knew how to provide constructive criticism. It was nice to have three judges who were articulate and polite while still being tough and opinionated.
Never actively watched any season after 5 but it's not difficult at all to improve the show when replacing this cringe spoiled know-it-all.
Plus I imagine finally having a female judge makes things generally more enjoyable just cause it's good to go mixed and not all male or all female.
She would get into it with the judges all the time😂 she would constantly judge worse than Joe…. There was a time she was butting heads with Ramsey on an entree and she was brought in for desserts
His culinary knowledge is also limited, there was one time a contestant called A-ran who was Asian and she told Joe she was going to make a savoury cake and he expressed disbelief, never mind the fact that savoury cakes (kueh) are pretty common in Southeast Asian cuisine.
As a man who is currently in the process of destroying a bag of kueh i can say that hes missing out.
fun thing is that savory cakes are also a thing in italy 😭 don't even know how they got him as a judge in masterchef italy, he's so embarrassing
@@cosmiclulu His ass is not italian. He pretends to be italian in the american version, then comes here and pretends to be the "american" in the italian version. Glad they got rid of his lying, fake flat ass from the italian version some seasons ago lol
@@cosmiclulu They're a thing everywhere tbh. You can't take two steps in a french "appéritif" setting without eating a nice slice of cake salé (literally translates to savory cake, simple as). (usually crushed olives, ham, herbs and some sort of cheese. I prefer goat's cheese).
Oh it was season 5's ahran!
The savoury tiramisu! I believe it was episode 13?
The one where they were cooking with ingredients in a basket picked by Joe. Christian was given a choice between the baskets of the three judges and he picked Joe's.
He definitely mellowed out over the years. First 5 seasons he was on one unnecessarily. Probably why he was replaced by Chef Tosi for seasons 6-8. When he came back he wasn't as villainous as before. While I can say that he was definitely controversial, I liked that he was honest. Probably the ONLY thing I can respect.
Dude Joe is like the epitome of a big shot CEO always wearing a tux but has no idea about all the little bits that go on in his company. All he knows how to do is make crazy big calls like "that thing is bad, fire everyone working on it," or something outrageous like that. Dude doesn't even think the woman cooking food is a chef, he thinks she's a coat checker. Like huh? Does he know what a chef is?
Not to be that guy but I believe Gordon and Joe are prime examples of where the differences between a leader and a boss are. A leader shakes you because he spotted potential within you and wants it to come out, a boss just bullies you because he's insecure
“Not to be that guy” and then you proceed to spit the most correct take possible
You ARE that guy. W take.
@@SarahSoupster sorry to hate on Italians but Joe acts like a stereotypical Italian
The part I am most surprised about is how he stuck around, there must have been something in the contract requiring a dickhead judge and protecting him with how personal his attacks got and how little Ramsey stopped him.
Ramsey normally flips his lid when decent people are targeted by those in power, like when a owner of Kitchen or hotel nightmares mistreat the staff.
I would have expected more to come from the stick the blind girl in the coat room comment.
Then you get to the dish where he doesn't even do the job he was getting paid to do, you have to taste the damn food to judge it. There were atleast 1 or 2 times in Gordan's other shows were things were not pretty on the plate but were tasty, like mama cherri where he went back with a clean plate.
Yeah, there is probably something in their contract, and the producers want Joe to be an asshole, cause no matter what, in the US, they need some drama to keep people interested.
Two things
Taste it
And Critique it
And joe did not do one of those in most of his judgements
He stuck around because he’s the most integral part of the show and rakes in tons of money. I mean just look at views of his compilations of CZcams. Clearly he makes money. And yeah he makes the show more interesting
Gordon is very much they type of person that gives extremely tough love, he definitely amps up his personality for the camera but he’s extremely tough on you because he expects so much more from you, you have to be better and if you do better he will definitely be happy about it
Bastianich also was a judge for the Italian Masterchef for a period, so I am inclined to defend him a bit: the first, let's say, 2 season he acted just like you are describing him in this video.
Then, when he realized his act was getting old, he kinda mellowed out and especially his interactions with chef Cannavacciuolo were funny af.
So yeah, this is just a character he is supposed to play.
Just to draw a comparison: Chef Barbieri is the only judge that has always been part of the show since season one and has taken the role of the evil one, the most feared and the most aggressive in his criticism.
He also is the judge for another show named "4 Hotels", which has a completely different vibe since all the participants are professionals. In that show he's a completely different character, he is always cheerful, has a dorky personality and even in his complaints he always keeps it cool.
That's great! He's still an ableist asshole.
Chef Barbieri is a great entertainer, I don't know how, but his presence gives me joy.
Barbieri is Italy's Gordon Ramsay: An overrated chef that lives of past glories and nowadays is mostly clownish entertainer and restauranteur than chef.
I am 100% convinced Gordon Ramsay is just a few steps away from choke slamming Joe to the pavement XD
😂😂😂😂
@@FilmTravelerr "You F-ing donkey!" (As the infamous Ramsay saying goes hehe)
Joe is the reason why I prefer Masterchef Canada & Australia over the American version & why my favorite seasons are the ones without him. At least the other judges give constructive criticism & give them an opportunity to grow if they feel theres still potential . Joe just tells the contestants their dish sucks in such a dramatic way without any real pointers
I worked in the industry for 13 years, and people are shocked when they find out that I hate Masterchef. Joe is the single reason why I refuse to watch the show, and that's before I knew anything about him. It's the running shoes with the suit, I don't care who you are, what your credentials are, or how expensive the shoes are, you look ridiculous wearing brightly colored running shoes with nice dresswear, it's tacky and gaudy and just screams attention whore/douchebag
the canada one is great
the blue haired demon chef in Canada knows his stuff despite being a prick
Aussie Masterchef is 10× better and the chef actually say insightful things. Graham is the only saving grace for Masterchef America.
Agree... Australia is so opposite in my opinion the judges are positive and the feedbacks are constructive and helpful
Here in Italy at McDonald’s we have a series of hamburgers called My Selection, which apparently where made with Joe Bastianich in a collaboration with Mickey D’s.
His Italian is far from perfect and it’s not the first time he corrects other people’s Italian lol he did it to a Moroccan contestant too and once he tried to correct another contestant’s Italian but she was simply speaking a regional variant and he couldn’t understand her accent…
His ungrammatical remarks are quite popular in Italy and we use them as memes - “sono diluso”, “vuoi che muoro?”
As an American who now lives in Australia, I challenge Joe to come down here and give his comment about 'Australian chicks' in any local pub. He'll be cowering in a corner within 5 seconds. One thing he needs to know about Australian men is that they are willing to defend their women to the bitter end.
Sadly, while simultaneously being told by the media and society there they are all predatory, problematic, misogynistic PoS monsters... 😮💨
I would pay to see that after I heard he criticize a person for their disability.
yeah im an aussie and was thinking "damn what a cunt", but when i heard that, genuine rage came over me for a second
As a local Aussie, this is no joke. Especially me having a a few girl-friends who are forces to be reckoned with
In their own right. I’ve seen it first hand a couple of times, especially when they had to deal with clearly incompetent people.
Joe is that one coworker that everyone hates.
But never gets fired cuz his Mom or Dad is the boss
His last name is Bastianich? Should be more like Bastiabitch.
That may have sounded cringe, but it is what it is.
No my friend, keep cooking 🔥🔥
Garlic bread stems from bruschetta, which appeared in Italy around the 15th century, and can be traced back to Ancient Rome. Garlic bread originated in the United States and it is a typical Italian-American dish. It probably originated after Italian immigrants started to use butter as a substitute for olive oil, which was uncommon in the United States in the first half of the 20th century.
To say they dont use it in italy is ridiculous
@@isaiahmayle4706 Though maybe technically accurate - depending on your definition of garlic bread? Like, if you're really narrow minded and think all "garlic bread" must be exactly like America's.... then yeah, probably not so common in Italy.
But I only say that because I've seen people try to explain how noodles and pasta are actually totally different things -🤨- to excuse Judge Joe's racism and eurocentrism, particularly his comment about there not being "any pasta in China".
I don't think most reasonable people would normally split hairs like that unless they were being purposefully obnoxious or obstinate.
*For those who don't know.... his mom Lidia is an Actual, Celebrity, Real Chef. He rides on her coattails.*
It's actually wild to think that just because someone didn't pay money to go to a school that they're somehow not a chef. Self-teaching is a very real thing, even outside of the culinary world, in almost every aspect of life.
That said, it's also not the job of a judge to "give tips." Their job to judge, full stop. That's it. The fact that Ramsay sometimes (*sometimes*) goes a step further is just because he wants to, but by no means does he have to. And of the original trio, Ramsay isn't even the one who did that the most; Graham is.
nice try defending this bozo but even he himself has said he isnt a chef
I’m a trained chef, and my professors tell me I’ve got good skill at analyzing things but I’m not even confident in my own ability and to think someone without my kind of training is doing it is awful
Honestly....... hearing a lot of the shit he did off cameras. I'm surprised he isn't kicked off MC.
Wait what did he do
?
Joe’s presence as a critique is a reflection of the industry.
He’s the restauranteur who you could end up working under and he’s got a bigger mouth then he’s got any right to have regarding food.
All because his parents made the business.
Joe has no real culinary background and is a complete a$$hole. He has no business being a judge on that show. Alvin from Master Chef Canada can be a pretentious a$$hole at times but at least he has actual culinary background and is likeable most the time.
@@elrapido5150 Exactly: Joe is one of the prime examples of bad nepotism there is. If his mom wasn't a world famous chef, he'd have no career.
@@JeffKelly03I know his mother but not him
@@JeffKelly03bro kill your self he wouldn’t be on the show next to Randy if he wasn’t good enough
Hey, so between the end of the cooking and the tasting/judging part, an hour lunch break happens. The judges taste a second dish during lunch to full breakdown the dishes. The tasting we see is fully theatrics.
11:30 this whole part abt him being racist reminds me of a kid that used to go to my school. He claimed to be italian and when we asked him to speak italian he would say he cant cuz his dad told him he cant, even tho we were at school and his dad wasnt there. he brought up he was italian atleast 10 times in the 5 days of the week we saw him.