Trovato per caso. Per curiosità ho cercato questo pezzo cantato da altri tenori. Ascoltato quest’aria cantata da Florez e non c’è paragone. La differenza la sento pure io che non sono esperta di lirica.
@@oscarchavezliu Pavarotti lo canta mejor, su versión del 72 en el met es insuperable, el y su técnica impecable acompañado de la voz mas grande que jamas canto la hija del regimiento, además,Pavarotti es el único que tira los 9 C5 bien plenos, ni uno solo tirado atras
Pour mon âme quel destin! J'ai sa flamme, et j'ai sa main! Jour prospère! Me voici militaire militaire et mari! Militaire et mari! Pour mon âme quel destin! J'ai sa flamme, et j'ai sa main! J'en fais serment! Pour mon âme quel destin! J'ai sa flamme, et j'ai sa main! Jour prospère! Me voici militaire militaire et mari! Pour mon âme quel destin! J'ai sa flamme, et j'ai sa main! Me voici, me voici Militaire et mari! Me voici, me voici Militaire et mari! Militaire et mari! Militaire et mari! MILITAIRE
@@tancredisalina5602 a dire il vero Pavarotti e Kraus, così come molti altri, li ho ascoltati e studiati, però resto comunque dell'idea che sia bravissimo. Ovviamente non sto dicendo che gli altri siano da meno
So what you are saying is that his value to art is based on how many people he can get to come see him perform? I would suggest that his value as an artist is based on his contributions to the art form itself. Screaming something for sold-out audiences doesn't really strike me as benefiting art very much. And saying that they are two different things is a little like saying "well, I have chosen to mow my lawn with a blender rather than a lawnmower simply because the blender can also do it."
I laugh every time I hear people who say that he is one of the greatest tenors of all times. Those people probably never listened to Kraus, Pavarotti, Gigli or Corelli
Pavarotti (in the 1970s) I could agree. The other three however are far more unpleasant than Bocelli to listen to! Had you said Tamagno, De Lucia, Tauber, Patzak, Vaguet, Escalais, Pattiera, Melchior, Ershov, Sirota - I'd have fully agreed. Bocelli is just a small hoarse voice blown up by the microphone, like that slimy Roumanian midget Joseph Schmidt ninety years ago that the Swiss took good care of. But you don't make your point well by comparing him with other worthless mediocrities....
Bocelli un gran tenor por donde se le quiera ver, pero estoy de acuerdo con que en algunas arias no se le escucha como debiera, lo que admiro de el es su forma de resolver la musica, hay que tener cojones para hacer eso, para resolverla, aunque tu voz no suene igual para ciertas arias, viva bicelli
Bocelli piace molto nei paesi latino-americani. che evidentemente non conoscono le tecniche del canto, operistico, che Bocelli NON POSSIEDE! In quest'aria e assolutamente ridicolo!
I mean in 2012 he's voice is a bit pinched on the high C's and maybe he has less of a mix of chest voice on the high notes (he's improved since then), but I would still consider this performance "complete", it's no where near the word "disgusting".
bocelli may lack the power of the high c's that Pavarotti has, but he can still hit them. His voice is on the graceful, quiet side while other opera singers like Pavarotti pack the loud splendor and magnificence that make them better suited for high c's
@@flaze3 maybe pay attention to all the stuff BETWEEN the high notes. Its horrible, from his phrasing to the very basic diction of the french language.. its sloppy and lacking the fundamentals of artistry.
Great andrea fantastic WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from Roger Eklund 😍😍
Great andrea fantastic WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from Roger Eklund 😍😍😍Andrea
Great andrea fantastic WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from Roger Eklund 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Slightly less finesse than Juan Diego Florez, but very acceptable. Now would he be able to do this in a 3800 seat house like the Met and without a a mic?
@@eugeniogentili1048 questa è veramente una cattiveria gratuita ed agghiacciante .. Io mi vergognerei ... tra l altro non capisco cosa ci faccia qui , sotto un video di Bocelli , se per te avrebbe dovuto nascere muto ... sei qui solo per sparare acidità e offese ? Complimenti .. forse tu e chi fa come te vi credete spiritosi , ma lasciatevelo dire : non fate ridere .. facile poi fare i leoni da tastiera quando c'è un bello schermo che vi protegge ..
le falta potencia a bocelli, igual en los temas nessun dorma, y en otros temas iconos de la opera, por querer interptetar muchas arias sin ser buena en alguna en absoluto su voz ha decaído mucho.
Ok, cerchiamo di essere onesti in tutti e due i sensi. Bocelli non ha la voce per essere un grande dell'opera, e probabilmente non ha avuto i maestri giusti, per sviluppare una voce al meglio delle sue possibilità. Canta ingolato, l'appoggio non c'è, o meglio, sembra quello di qualcuno che imita la lirica. Detto ciò, da un punto di vista della professionalità e della creatività non gli si può dire molto: riesce a cantare un pezzo, con un'impostazione pseudo lirica, che molti cantanti lirici non riescono a tenere con naturalezza. Un fenomeno come Florez, negli ultimi anni deve stare attento a come prendere il brano. Per cui, che dire? Il problema non è del cantante, ma del circuito che lo spinge a cantare questo repertorio invece di restare sulla forma canzone.
Quindi? Cantasse le operette, in quelle se la pu cavare, ma che non siano lunghe ... regge i recital precostituiti... in scena serve davvero la voce... e si con fronta con veri cantanti !!!
For the love of god, stop parading this man through legitimate repertoire to sell tickets to armchair classical lovers ("I like classical music.....we had the theme from Ordinary People at our wedding...") when he has no ability to do it nor himself justice. Sing duets with Charlotte Church and Sarah Brightman, soar through the 7,456th (this week) rendition of the Schubert Ave Maria, and leave this repertoire to people that are properly trained and primed to perform it.
Usually I don't begin by going after someone's grammar, but really, we are passed the third grade and should know the difference between their, there, and they're. Don't you agree? On top of your poor grammar, you also decided to use faulty logic. Saying that someone is not allowed to critique art because they are not at the same level as the artist is absurd. Next time you have something to say, just don't say it. That way you won't look so dumb.
Agree with you, the only problem is he always tries some non apropiate repertory and it can damage his voice with that. I'm waiting for turandot but i dont have good spectatives of that recording.
He had the voice and the talent to become a nice lyric-leggiero tenor. He could've become a Pavarotti (same repertoire). He just lacks of a proper technique for that. It's a pitty, with such a beautiful voice and taste. I like Bocelli on pop, lyric-pop songs. But he kills opera arias, he should stop singing them for God's sake.
bocelli may lack the power of the high c's that Pavarotti has, but he can still hit them. His voice is on the graceful, quiet side while other opera singers like Pavarotti pack the loud splendor and magnificence that make them better suited for high c's
here is the difference between sounding like an opera singer and being one for real. draw your conclusion
Why?
Always Amazing Andrea.He can sing any song.I can not understand the words but I love his voice.🎶🎼🎵❤️🌹
We cannot deny that the voice of Andrea Bocelli is very beautiful because once he's start singing he can catch the heart of the Listener.
Bravo ! De Alma 💫 Para Alma 💫
APLAUSOS 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
🌹
Sei Grande , unica voce la tua
Qui, Pavarotti inarrivabile.
Who hurt him?
Bocelli nearly took the roof off with those high notes, blows my mind!
At least he tried, guys.
Trovato per caso. Per curiosità ho cercato questo pezzo cantato da altri tenori. Ascoltato quest’aria cantata da Florez e non c’è paragone. La differenza la sento pure io che non sono esperta di lirica.
Sembra un gallinaccio.
Se poi senti quella di un vero cantante lirico.... C'è ancora più differenza 😉
Florez is bad too
Bocelli at least has a manly high voice
Listen to the great Javier Camarena! Authentic Tonio!!!
Ángel Emmanuel Barbeyto Camarena excelente pero el mejor en esta aria será siempre Luciano.
@@alejo25081973 Nadie lo canta como Alfredo Kraus o Rockwell Blake.
@@oscarchavezliu Pavarotti lo canta mejor, su versión del 72 en el met es insuperable, el y su técnica impecable acompañado de la voz mas grande que jamas canto la hija del regimiento, además,Pavarotti es el único que tira los 9 C5 bien plenos, ni uno solo tirado atras
@@oscarchavezliu que asco Rockwell Blake jajajaj NTC cuestión de gustos supongo, a mí me gusta más con Diego Flórez y con Pavarotti xD
@@Un_Gordo_De_Derecha but rockwell blake is used to sings 11 do5 😁
It's good for a crossover Singer.
Did he really think he could actually manage this?
He managed it... Well or not, that's another thing 😂
Pour mon âme
quel destin!
J'ai sa flamme,
et j'ai sa main!
Jour prospère!
Me voici
militaire
militaire
et mari!
Militaire et mari!
Pour mon âme
quel destin!
J'ai sa flamme,
et j'ai sa main!
J'en fais serment!
Pour mon âme
quel destin!
J'ai sa flamme,
et j'ai sa main!
Jour prospère!
Me voici
militaire
militaire
et mari!
Pour mon âme
quel destin!
J'ai sa flamme,
et j'ai sa main!
Me voici, me voici
Militaire et mari!
Me voici, me voici
Militaire et mari!
Militaire et mari!
Militaire et mari!
MILITAIRE
Eu chego no do5
A great crossover singer, but live the serious stuff to serious opera singers.
Claudia De Sessa are you kidding me ? He is an opera singer . Get your facts right
@@laurent.9828 ._.
Lauren T. He is, but this aria was sung really badly.
@@MarkusBenedictly Bocelli is not an opera singer.
@@Martin-mc1wu well, being a singer, he actually sang operas in theaters a few times, so he is. Besides, if you ask me, I'm not a fan of Bocelli.
Immenso, bravissimo Maestro!
Ascolta Bocelli e poi ascolta Kraus o Pavarotti in quest'aria. È come leggere Fabio Volo e poi leggere Dante.
@@tancredisalina5602 a dire il vero Pavarotti e Kraus, così come molti altri, li ho ascoltati e studiati, però resto comunque dell'idea che sia bravissimo. Ovviamente non sto dicendo che gli altri siano da meno
Bravo Andrea!!!...
So what you are saying is that his value to art is based on how many people he can get to come see him perform? I would suggest that his value as an artist is based on his contributions to the art form itself. Screaming something for sold-out audiences doesn't really strike me as benefiting art very much. And saying that they are two different things is a little like saying "well, I have chosen to mow my lawn with a blender rather than a lawnmower simply because the blender can also do it."
HAHAHAHAHAHAJAHAHAHAHAHAHA
I laugh every time I hear people who say that he is one of the greatest tenors of all times.
Those people probably never listened to Kraus, Pavarotti, Gigli or Corelli
Juan Diego florez the Best
Sebastiano Verna they say it because it’s true . Just saying .
Luciano Pavarotti is definitely the best...
Pavarotti (in the 1970s) I could agree. The other three however are far more unpleasant than Bocelli to listen to! Had you said Tamagno, De Lucia, Tauber, Patzak, Vaguet, Escalais, Pattiera, Melchior, Ershov, Sirota - I'd have fully agreed. Bocelli is just a small hoarse voice blown up by the microphone, like that slimy Roumanian midget Joseph Schmidt ninety years ago that the Swiss took good care of. But you don't make your point well by comparing him with other worthless mediocrities....
Bravo
Ma é una cantilena...
Really good performance, as always! Great Andrea
Bocelli un gran tenor por donde se le quiera ver, pero estoy de acuerdo con que en algunas arias no se le escucha como debiera, lo que admiro de el es su forma de resolver la musica, hay que tener cojones para hacer eso, para resolverla, aunque tu voz no suene igual para ciertas arias, viva bicelli
Bocelli piace molto nei paesi latino-americani. che evidentemente non conoscono le tecniche del canto, operistico, che Bocelli NON POSSIEDE! In quest'aria e assolutamente ridicolo!
Why?.....
They can sing togheter...
actually the vibration on the c's is nice.
I mean in 2012 he's voice is a bit pinched on the high C's and maybe he has less of a mix of chest voice on the high notes (he's improved since then), but I would still consider this performance "complete", it's no where near the word "disgusting".
He really cn do it all.!!Dio mio!!
bocelli may lack the power of the high c's that Pavarotti has, but he can still hit them. His voice is on the graceful, quiet side while other opera singers like Pavarotti pack the loud splendor and magnificence that make them better suited for high c's
ALL FALSETTO and NOT FULL VOICE.
Would someone care to explain to me why this is being criticised so much? I genuinely don't understand.
Because it is absolutely HORRIBLE with his Falsetto bleating.
Because he's using a microphone and operatic elitists can't stand it.
@@flaze3 maybe pay attention to all the stuff BETWEEN the high notes. Its horrible, from his phrasing to the very basic diction of the french language.. its sloppy and lacking the fundamentals of artistry.
Did not think he had the high c'sbut he had them cleanly
ALL FALSETTO BLEATING
week
listen juan diego florez,, pavarotti, kraus!!!
Hurts my ears. JDF and Brownlee imo do this the best.
Have you heard Pavarotti or even Kraus?
Barone Vitellio Scarpia who sang this aria the best?
@@romanpears8442 big pav
@@Un_Gordo_De_Derecha dubito :-))
@@jackbigbug and kraus
In spite of all the criticism I like Bochelli!
You can’t even spell his name... there are singers infinitely more talented than this crossover sellout
Great andrea fantastic WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from Roger Eklund 😍😍
All high C's were FANTASTIC..
He certainly has good breath support.
Only the last one.
@@alinazang6651 true. my ears were different 9 years ago.
their is a difference when you just like and love two different things he might be awful but he sells tickets can you say the same ?
Great andrea fantastic WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from Roger Eklund 😍😍😍Andrea
Sutor, ne ultra crepidam! (Ciabattino, non [andare] oltre le scarpe!)
Great andrea fantastic WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from WONDERFUL beatiful excellent love from Roger Eklund 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Abbiamo capito che lei e la lirica sono cose separate...
Slightly less finesse than Juan Diego Florez, but very acceptable. Now would he be able to do this in a 3800 seat house like the Met and without a a mic?
Complimenti : manca appoggio, sostegno, legato, apertura della gola, timbro. Preferisco Aldo Fabrizi quando canta "Lulù".
Grazie sei il mio idolo qualcuno che dice le cose come stanno
C'è una squintalata di falsetto, la cecità copre tutto
Sono assolutamente d'accordo! Bocelli non è un cantante d'opera... roba da Sanreno e niente altro! Piace solo a chi non capisce nulla di canto!
@@xenialucich7608 Lui e Grigolo sono il nulla assoluto, assenza di tecnica e di voce
@@eugeniogentili1048 questa è veramente una cattiveria gratuita ed agghiacciante .. Io mi vergognerei ... tra l altro non capisco cosa ci faccia qui , sotto un video di Bocelli , se per te avrebbe dovuto nascere muto ... sei qui solo per sparare acidità e offese ? Complimenti .. forse tu e chi fa come te vi credete spiritosi , ma lasciatevelo dire : non fate ridere .. facile poi fare i leoni da tastiera quando c'è un bello schermo che vi protegge ..
Ma perché si lancia in queste cose palesemente al si sopra delle sue possibilità...?
Guarda non lo so io sono uno tenore è continuo a dire che quando prova a fare il do di petto mi sembra un cane in calore
Disgustoso quasi quanto Grigolo, na bella accoppiata sti due..heheheh
Soldi ! ... e mancanza di senso del buon gusto
Magnificent!
I have heard better.
You means you have heard all better than this ... :-))
le falta potencia a bocelli, igual en los temas nessun dorma, y en otros temas iconos de la opera, por querer interptetar muchas arias sin ser buena en alguna en absoluto su voz ha decaído mucho.
Dio santo che orrore.
E' sempre un grande
Quella sera Andrea era in uno stato di grazia.....
Figuriamoci le altre volte ...
Absolutely HORRIBLE falsetto shouting.
orrendo
Ok, cerchiamo di essere onesti in tutti e due i sensi.
Bocelli non ha la voce per essere un grande dell'opera, e probabilmente non ha avuto i maestri giusti, per sviluppare una voce al meglio delle sue possibilità.
Canta ingolato, l'appoggio non c'è, o meglio, sembra quello di qualcuno che imita la lirica.
Detto ciò, da un punto di vista della professionalità e della creatività non gli si può dire molto: riesce a cantare un pezzo, con un'impostazione pseudo lirica, che molti cantanti lirici non riescono a tenere con naturalezza.
Un fenomeno come Florez, negli ultimi anni deve stare attento a come prendere il brano.
Per cui, che dire? Il problema non è del cantante, ma del circuito che lo spinge a cantare questo repertorio invece di restare sulla forma canzone.
Quindi? Cantasse le operette, in quelle se la pu cavare, ma che non siano lunghe ... regge i recital precostituiti... in scena serve davvero la voce... e si con fronta con veri cantanti !!!
Bocelli va bene per i sordi. E ce ne sono a bizzeffe, basta leggere i commenti
For the love of god, stop parading this man through legitimate repertoire to sell tickets to armchair classical lovers ("I like classical music.....we had the theme from Ordinary People at our wedding...") when he has no ability to do it nor himself justice. Sing duets with Charlotte Church and Sarah Brightman, soar through the 7,456th (this week) rendition of the Schubert Ave Maria, and leave this repertoire to people that are properly trained and primed to perform it.
Usually I don't begin by going after someone's grammar, but really, we are passed the third grade and should know the difference between their, there, and they're. Don't you agree? On top of your poor grammar, you also decided to use faulty logic. Saying that someone is not allowed to critique art because they are not at the same level as the artist is absurd. Next time you have something to say, just don't say it. That way you won't look so dumb.
servusdei2032 Their and there, OK But what about passed and past?
Hahahaha! This is laughable!
Discusting, even worst that i do... share the same opinion beside, leave this repertoire to people that are properly trained and primed to perform it
Bocelli is not a Lyrical Leggero tenor, he is a lyrical. And here sounds horrible.
think he's better singing "Pourquoi me reveiller" From Wherter, but he sings very well to Mario Caravadossi
Agree with you, the only problem is he always tries some non apropiate repertory and it can damage his voice with that. I'm waiting for turandot but i dont have good spectatives of that recording.
he tries to sing like an spinto tenor, and doesnt do well :(
He had the voice and the talent to become a nice lyric-leggiero tenor. He could've become a Pavarotti (same repertoire). He just lacks of a proper technique for that. It's a pitty, with such a beautiful voice and taste. I like Bocelli on pop, lyric-pop songs. But he kills opera arias, he should stop singing them for God's sake.
I didn't know you could perform that poorly and sell tickets.
terrible singing.If he is not blind, he can't get money from singinf.
terrible ((((
Truly awful. The blind leading the deaf.
bocelli may lack the power of the high c's that Pavarotti has, but he can still hit them. His voice is on the graceful, quiet side while other opera singers like Pavarotti pack the loud splendor and magnificence that make them better suited for high c's