Classical & Jazz Musicians React: MOONBYUL 'Eclipse'
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 01. 2021
- 🎉 Thank you Skillshare for sponsoring us! The first 1000 people to use the link will get a free trial of Skillshare Premium Membership: skl.sh/reacttothek01211
For the 25th reaction video of Season 5 of this series, classical musicians react to MOONBYUL's 'Eclipse' MV! We are continuing to practice social distancing during our film sessions, so if you see 2 people sit next to each other with their masks off, they're roommates/have been quarantining together. Please stay safe and healthy everyone!
▶️ Watch Eclipse MV here: • [MV] Moon Byul(문별) _ E...
❤️ If you'd like to support ReacttotheK and help us grow, support us on Patreon and get early access to videos and to a bunch of exclusive content: / reacttothek
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
C&JMR Reaction Release Schedule (and list of Patreon exclusive videos): docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
Songs that are currently being voted on or waiting to be voted on by our musician voting panel (or votes are tied akjnfsakjdfn):
• Not so sure list
Will not react to list:
docs.google.com/document/d/1b...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
~Channel IG: / reacttothek_official
~Channel Twitter: / reacttothek
~Channel Tumblr: / reacttothek
~Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
~Join our discord! discordapp.com/invite/d7zU26X
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video filmed and edited by Umu
Script written by Erin Peters (Twitter: @eireaine)
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
Thumbnail by Nozomi Murayama (IG: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow the ReacttotheK squad and keep up-to-date with our lives:
🎵 Umu:
Twitter: / umucado
IG: / umucado
Personal YT: / @umucado
🎵 Kevin:
Twitter: / nerdymusicks
CZcams: / @nerdymusicks5381
IG: nerdymusick...
🎵Owen: N/A (he doesn't have any social media accounts)
🎵 Henry:
IG: / henrythedean
🎵 Charlotte:
IG: / charmander_97
🎵 Stephen:
/ stephenmorrisdrums
🎵 Brianna:
/ brianna239
🎵 Cloud:
/ life_as_a_cloud
🎵 Jason:
/ jason_gluck
🎵 Ju Young:
/ claryinet
🎵 Raffi:
/ raffiwright
🎵 Sam:
/ sam_yuh
🎵 Josh:
/ joshuaachiron
🎵 Steve:
/ stephen_parisi_music
🎵 Rafael:
/ rafaelenciso_
🎵 Jamal:
/ jamaldamien.music
🎵 Stephanie:
/ saxy_stephy
🎵 Leon:
/ leonhsuin123 - Zábava
WOOO The first 1000 people to use the link will get a free trial of Skillshare Premium Membership: skl.sh/reacttothek01211
➡️ Reaction Release Schedule + list of all our Patreon-exclusive videos: docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/edit?usp=sharing
➡️ Songs that are currently being voted on or waiting to be voted on by our musician voting panel for C&JMR:
czcams.com/play/PLFw_XZtkCVMMt3F3O3jvbeYlUyGo8v2nX.html
➡️ Will not react to list for the CJ&MR series & why songs may not be reacted to:
docs.google.com/document/d/1b5aQLWbYgUCm30Pj5-AalSjwMaq8gm5jOyrcbAlMu6c/edit?usp=sharing
Mamamoo’s Killing Voice is amazing!!!!
They have some of the best vocalists in the industry!
can you guys react to mamamoo "killin voice on dingo" amazing display of only vocals on this platform
they do display vocals only their top hits..love ur insights vocally
I know it's a bit rude to somehow mention this in this video, but can you please react to nct u's from home (rearranged version)? Pleaseeee
please react to dinngo "killing voice" of Mamamoo
Just admit it, Moonbyul is cooler than we will ever be.
👁💧👄💧👁
That’s on periodttt ✨✨
Can't avoid a fact :")
Cool is not enough to describe her
I feel like Moonbyul took all the sounds of a 'boy group song', pulled it off 100%, and thereby showed that this style is not confined to boy groups.
And I have mad respect for that.
Now to see a guy do a girl concept MV
Moonbyul, trained as vocalist but debuted as a rapper. That's why she can rap fast and so good, and she sings those high notes beautifully!
She not only singout high note, but she also screams 'em out
@@noneyabiz1513 No, she didn't. It was their CEO/producer who asked Moonbyul to. At the time, she was the least strong, vocally speaking, and it was fashionable to have a rapper in the group to succeed (it still is, somehow).
@@SadicMoutExt12 mkay
@@noneyabiz1513 lol. You're giving a wrong info, I correct you, that's it.
@@SadicMoutExt12 okie
Here is a question for you, if a "sub-vocalist" is that good in the group how good does the rest of Mamamoo have to be?
Answer : VERY.
Answer: YES
True but worth pointing out that they had very loosely defined roles early on and dropped them almost entirely after their rookie years. They're three vocalists and a rapper (Moonbyul often introduces herself as being in charge of rapping and performance but that's the only variation) and you will never catch any of them saying they're "main/lead/sub vocals".
Also, the only reason there's a gap between Moonbyul and the other three as vocalists is because they continued receiving vocal training and she learned how to rap. She was never a rapper prior to the group forming and she was accepted into RBW as a vocal trainee. If Mamamoo was meant to be purely vocals, she would have no doubt been one. The group was actually meant to be five strong but she was picked to rap before the fifth member departed so they were always meant to have that rapping part to them. The fifth member was rumored to be a stronger singer than Hwasa but Hwasa was seen as initially more talented in rap than Moonbyul (Moonbyul credits Hwasa with teaching her how to rap) which is why when the group was young, Hwasa was often split between raps and vocals, which is why we got stuff like "Dab Dab" and once Moonbyul fully came into her own they backed Hwasa off the rap stuff and put her entirely on vocals. Also, that fifth member was the eldest of them all which most likely would have made her the leader which is why, for Moo Moos who know, that Solar struggled as leader early on because it was thrust upon her and she had no idea how to act like the eldest (she is the baby of her family). And just FWIW they're still quite close with that lost member, I believe she and Hwasa are super close.
Mamamoo history lesson over lol.
@@el_kabong Ya weird looking back to first 2~3 year stuff and they have traditional "roles" assigned to them.
@@el_kabong the eldest isn't always made the leader. The most mature as determined by the company and group is chosen as leader
She was originally going to be a lead, but her rap skills are outstanding so they positioned her as the Rapper of the group. Her voice is really excellent.
To the poeple watching this and commenting, if you actually listen to more kpop you'd know that the "this sounds like a boy group song" isn't supposed to discredit and offend Moonbyul's work, it's just the fact that this type of industrial sounding instrumentals and musical elements are pretty popular and trendy among boy groups recently and it's actually undeniable cause everyone's doing it, it's just about musical styles and trends, not gender and there's no reason to get butthurt! She's actually breaking the stereotypes by doing it, we should stop getting offended by everything!
yep lol
Honestly part of why I love Dreamcatcher since they also are more “dark and edgy” which is not typical GG style. Music is awesome for its variety.
Moonbyul basically thought to herself "hmm I wonder what type of song would sound good for EXO" and then did the whole thing herself lolol
The choreographer is also exo choreographer in some of their song, what why simillair
Honestly, I like EXO but come on, this is better than any EXO song. And j think the biggest difference is the lyrics. They're beautiful lyrics and the powerful voice, oof!
@@simransimran9339 preach!!! 💜💀
@@simransimran9339 not all exo songs that's over. And im a moomoo so that's not me hating or smthg
@@fatimakaoukab2385 maybe. I haven't really heard much of exp after...war I think.
Moonbyul is the most underrated idol ever.. her style is very unique but it doesnt fit the stereotype so people just sleep on her work. she's also very talented she writes and composes as well. check her and mamamoo out they are insanely talented..
This channel had reacted to Mamamoo from a looong time ago
Love how Charlotte is talking about the traditional male-associated style of her clothing, her moves, her everything and that she's always been one to break from the traditional female associations, the comments on the song overall sounding more like what we're used to from male groups is the first step to get those hard lines softened in my opinion. Btw Rafael and Jamal were a mood the whole time.
I’m so glad I watched this, I haven’t listened to her album in a couple of months and now I want to listen to it all again. As always I hear things that I didn’t before now that musicians pointed things out. The thing that I can’t believe I didn’t notice was that the male voice did the backing in that part.
Oneus member did the backing for her
@@jjy31 It was Yonghoon actually, the lead vocalist of Onewe
Omg Moonbyul is cool.. she is trying a new genres and styles in her solos.. i respect her as soloist 👍🏼
"All you guys do is poop" I just died xDDD
Moonbyul talked about wanting to do music, and that there should be no boundaries between male and female artists in kpop, saying its a boy group song reduced its impact
I think fan reactions saying "oh this sounds like a boy group song" is part of the transition to getting rid of boundaries! First it's shocking, since there's such a big difference between sounds, but the more boy groups and girl groups blend sounds, then the boundaries will finally fall? Those are just my thoughts...what do you think?
@@ReacttotheK i am glad that it started this conversation, i am longing for a concepts in kpop where there is no typical gender norms restrictions, Like she said, by doing this, she is bridging the gap between the lines dividing "feminine" & "masculine" music
I think it's less "this sounds like a boy group song" and more "this sounds like songs by [instert boy group here]". The distinction is that Moonbyul is obviously not a boy group. And she did a great job, nobody would say it's not her song. So now we're starting to build a base of music that sounds like [instert boy group here] that is by female artists, pushing us away from boundaries between male and female artists in kpop.
maybe getting rid of the boundaries between the norm of what music a boy group should make and what a girl group should, aka girl group songs should be generalised to just this, and same with boy group songs?
@@JazzIsAwesomeMG well said
I think the reactors would enjoy her b-side "ILJIDO". Another interesting instrumental, smooth and free vocals, and a vibe on par with songs like "Candy" by Baekhyun,
When Moonbyul puts on the suit, there's nobody who can look more handsome than she does.
Btw, I hope you guys will react to other songs from Moonbyul's Dark Side of the Moon album, like Iljido and Mirror.
"That's why you go and watch the dance practice video"... Umu has trained them so well
MOONBYUL OUR TALENTED GIRL WITH LIKE 70+ song credits a QUEEN!!
Eclipse is a masterpiece. I love this song. She can rap abs sing at the highest level. Queen. “Absence”, “love & hate/worthless”, “mirror”, “Iljibo”, “moon movie, “snow” , “in my room” and her new song that she released around her birthday. “Selfish” that she did with Sulgie is also good. While I like Selfish, the tracks from Moon and Darkside of the Moon are more Moonbyul to me while still showing her versatility.
Some of the male vocals in the background are Seoho from Oneus and Yonghoon from Onewe.
Which girl soloist in kpop does things like this? I dare u to find one..its just moonbyul.
If they ever give Dami a solo, I would expect something very similar in tone and theme to "Eclipse". She's the only other one I can think of, though.
@@el_kabong style wise they are different though
@@el_kabong Dreamcatcher/MMM is the combination I dream of that will probably never happen...
@@viraoktaviani8290 f(X) was late 2nd gen, MMM is early 3rd gen. 4th gen is like G(I-DLE), aespa, ITZY, etc.
And hard disagree on Amber, she was just a tomboy, she and Moonbyul are very different artists. Go check out Amber's solo stuff and imagine Moonbyul ever doing them, they're in two different worlds.
@@el_kabong Agreed on Amber, her solo stuff is very lyrical-pop and not as "edgy" as Moonbyul's work is.
THIS WAS UNEXPECTED
8:30 “They never focused on her for more than 2 seconds” IS SO MY FEELINGS ON THIS MV. I love the quality of Mamamoo’s music videos in general (they’re shot very well), but their editors always go and chop them all up to the point that I’m left confused and disoriented by the end. RBW seriously needs hire better editors because they always ruin Mamamoo’s videos with amateur editing.
"Dal dal mosendal" "moon moon which moon" is actually a children lullaby... and she made it into this .... and the fact this song represents her the best in all of it's aspects.....
Wow this is actually the first time I'm hearing Moonbyul's position being called as a sub-vocalist lol. From all I know the only position Mamamoo has are only Leader, Vocalist, Rapper, Performer, and Maknae. This is interesting tho, if Moonbyul indeed is a sub-vocalist just like what you said (*which is in terms of rank, sub being the lowest tier, while main vocalist being the highest) then imagine how good their main vocalist are.
You're right that they don't have any sub/main/lead distinction, that's something that spread from kpop fandom, not MMM themselves. She *could* be considered a sub-vocalist, especially now that she's getting more vocal parts in MMM songs, but it isn't anything official.
I don't know if you're aware of this or not, but I just wanted to clarify that vocalist = sub vocalist, and yes it's the lowest vocal position....The second highest vocal position being lead vocalist and then main vocalist...I wanted to say this because many people confuse vocalist and sub vocalist positions while they're the same. Mamamoo now has ditched the lead, main titles and are only categorised as vocalist, performer and rapper.
@@aradhyasaraf_ True, but in most groups those categories are set in stone. For Mamamoo it only means to indicate things they are strongest in because when push comes to shove... they can all dance, rap and sing.
If one looks at how Moonstar up to now has been used vocally, then however yes sub vocalist comes to mind because when actual singing (not rapping) wise she gets the least solo bars but provides harmonizing support where needed.
Little bit of info, Moon album sold over 100,000 copies which made her the top selling female soloist.
I wonder if you will do a reaction for "Absence' since it has more isntrumental and i think is totally different to Eclipse, will you??
Yes to this!
oh yes please !!
Yeeesss
yes pls omg that song is everything!!
yayyy. Moonbyul Eclipse is a bop. her whole album(the repackaged ver) just slaps.
now on hoping that y'all react to her other song, Absence
Eclipse is off of her album, Dark Side of the Moon. ILJIDO is one of my favorite tracks from the album. You can watch her performance video of it on her group MAMAMOO ‘s homepage
Mamamoo are vocals Queen's as group or everyone of them as soloist ...I would be happy if you react more to them ..and I don't known if you guys do reaction to live but for me if you want to enjoy their full power beautiful vocals then you must watch their lives like :immortal songs medley.... Or mamamoo killing voices
Successful by the way.
@@cherissetillman8973 I know I m fan of them ❤❤❤ ..still ..I think they need more recognition in international level....
Errmmm.... Umu is one of the earliest Mamamoo reactors. I honestly found Mamamoo from one of her reaction video 3 years-ish ago.
The backup vocals are Oneus and Onewe members (Seoho and Yonghoon)!
❗️💜Just to add, in the background you can hear 2 male vocalists, and they are actually Seoho from Oneus, and Yonghoon Onewe’s leader💜❗️
I love how Moonbyul took a risk with going with the kind of music and concept she wants and more comfortable with, despite it wouldn't be general public friendly. At 4:50, that's actually ONEWE's main vocalist Yonghoon and some of the other backup vocals are ONEUS Seoho's too.
"Moon Movie" is my favorite Moonbyul song😭
AH! I NEVER CLICKED SO FAST!
I was just rewatching this MV an hour earlier with no idea that this was gonna be released today 😭
I'm waiting for this videoooooo
thankyou so much
agreed
THANK YOU SO MUCH THIS IS ALL THAT I WANTED
I was waiting for this since yesterday but I realized that PH is 12hrs ahead US 🤣🤣 thank you for this reaction video! 💖
Parehas po tayo. Hahahaha
Moonbyul rap so very very fast she queen of rapper....!!!!!!
Moonbyul just proves that Music has no Gender. ❤️
Yessss from an artistic standpoint truly breaking those societal gender standards!!
Thank you so much for reacting to Byul's Eclipse!!! I loved to hear how the musicians pointed out the more technical side of the track, I dont know music theory but they managed to explain things pretty well. Thank you for also remarking on the concept, how it tied to the music, and visuals of the MV.
Moonbyul's Dark Side Of The Moon really shows her versatility combining hard-hitting tracks like Eclipse and Moon Movie, with slower, emotionally-driven songs like Mirror and Snow (and later on Absence in Moon repackage), there's also ILJIDO and Weird Day as a couple of chill, easy-listening tracks. These all speak about various facets of Byul at this point in her life, I definitely recommend giving it a listen if you're interested in her solo music!
Moonbyul is named by South Korean people and media as the ULTIMATE GIRL CRUSH OF KPOP 😊😉
Moonbyul's eclipse really was my favorite solo
An amazing fact about Moonbyul that sets her apart from the rest of the K-Pop world is that she helps compose a number of her groups pieces alongside writing all of her own raps. She is the most credited female idol in the genre. True artist overall!!! It's funny that on Mamamoo's comebacks one of the Universes she is depicted as a producer....Real talk, I would pay serious money to experience any artist, group or band produces!
Good point about the contrast. The chorus could have hit harder.
Let's give love to our Moonstar ❤❤
Great reaction! Moonbyul is so underappreciated. Eclipse is so powerful and the world was not ready for it. I just wish the world could have experienced it at least once to realize how fucking amazing not only Eclipse (the main track) but the entire album was artistically and lyrically speaking
Everyone already know that Moonbyul can do anything :
SING
RAP
DANCE
VISUAL
what else...
She also have good personality and very kind
I love you imbue :)
Looking forward to Moonbyul's 2021 comeback and what she's gonna come up with this time! but before that we're getting Wheein solo soon...looks like we're getting well fed this year as well
Is really awesome to see people appreciating Moonbuyl's song and all the effort that she put it on more in an musical perspective. I hope more fans could see this and support her as mucha as they support the other members. Thanks for this and always ¡Moonbuyl FIGHTING! 🥰🥰
PS: she told that she wanted to make a song like this trying to do more like a boy group song performed by females just to proof she can do it too. So she made it. ¡QUEEN!
Moonbyul has a particular talent of being able to flow from a rapping set easily into a melodic line. That’s why (in my opinion) her solo album was so good even though she’s slated as the “rapper”. And most moomoos know she went to RBW to sing not rap, but they had auditioned enough singers so our Byulie rapped and history was made.
EDIT: Guys, it makes me so sad they’re so surprised by her range. She’s a singer and a rapper. I’m so glad she got this solo because she was able to shine. The b-sides are fantastic.
Wowwww I wasn’t expecting this reaction almost a year after the release! I really enjoyed the breakdown of this track! It was composed by so many people, and I always wanted to hear the musical breakdown of it.
I actually would have expected a reaction to “Absence” by Moonbyul since it’s more recent and probably shows off her vocals better. But on second thought, Eclipse might be more interesting if I set aside the vocals. I’ve always appreciated this track for trying to break down gender stereotypes in kpop. Thanks for reacting to it!
I cannot get over how good the editing is now. It really brings out everything in the reactors 😭
Moonbyul always try to break standard since day 1. Love that for her
YESSssss our talented hardworking Queen moonbyul
If this was a boy group’s song, it probably would’ve been more successful. It deserves so much more because she killed it.
I've always loved Moonbyul's vibe and voice. She can literally pull off any kind of sound. How can one be so perfect? How bizarre... 🤔
moonbyul is legendary
Moonbyul!!! 🥰 Can't wait for her next album
it's CRIMINAL that eclipse went by so unnoticed, and not many people outside the fandom even know the song. kpop was not ready for this song, i feel like if it was released today, it would have gotten a lot more fanfare! i love that moonbyul is trying out different concepts now with her solo and showing her versatility, but this one suited her the best!
i really hope she'll come back to this concept sometime because it showcased her agenda perfectly. she has always been more on the androgynous/masculine side and this song shows exactly how well she can pull off a boy group esque concept, without making it a higher pitch or more girly. of course, there's nothing wrong with either of those things, i just want to see more songs like this from girl groups or female idols. even the more “girl crush” or “badass” groups like blackpink, everglow, etc are still not truly breaking any boundaries in terms of gender presentation and stereotypes.
I knew there was a reason Moonbyul caught my eye
Please react to Purple Kiss pre-debut single ‘My Heart Skip a Beat’ they’re a new girl group under RBW! They’re going to debut this year.
Could you react to krock band Onewe? They’re with RBW (Mamamoo) and they’re the brother group of kpop idol group Oneus. You heard right, she was supported by male vocalists Seoho (Oneus) and Yonghoon (Onewe). You can hear Yonghoon clearly from 4:41- 4:52. I think you would really like them from a musical and vocal perspective. Some suggestions from them: Regulus, Reminisce About All, A Book In Memory, End Of Spring, Parting etc. And like Mamamoo, they are phenomenal live.
Yeeees, so happy to see people reacting to our talented Byul 🖤
I love how she helps write her songs! She's my favorite and I wish I could be her friend
I'm really glad she continue to train her vocal lately 👍👍👍 she shouldn't stop at the first place..
"When the moon covers the sun" - I think she added that line to troll her bandmate Solar. Since she is the Moon and her BFF is the Sun. HAHA
i really love how you introduce moonbyul to them!!!
She is the kind of person I want to be.Thank you for your react.
MoonByul is so talented and strong that she managed to sing, and dance to a song that an entire boy group could but she did it all by herself if this isnt talent I dont know what it is .
I hate how many people look down on MoonByul because she doesnt sing that much when it comes to MAMAMOO so they say MoonByul doesnt sing but I am SOOO glad she proved them SOOO wrong with this song .
That background add lips and high notes was seoho from oneus the young brothers to mamamoo
I WAS LITERALLY WAITING FOR THIS AHHHHHH
I've been waiting for this!!!! Thanks guys
I was sooo happy for this!
YES! I've been eagerly waiting for this one!
Girl in the peach shirt/highlight hair passed the Moonbyul vibe check 😌
Thank you for reacting I'm rlly learning a lot from you all. I'm a moomoo(MAMAMOO stan) and this makes us proud of her.
The choreographer her song is also one of choreographer some of exo songs
OMG the last 10 seconds 😂 "All you guys do is poop!" 😂😂😂
i wanna be like Moonbyul. .
Thank you for doing this video. It’s my number 1 favourite song right now because of its rock undertones and Moonbyul.. just her lol
Would you ever do a reaction to Gain - Paradise Lost??
its so cool to see moonbyul being appreciated :)
also yall should react to mamamoo's killing voice
Woohoo thankyou for the video!
I love Yonghoon's adlib towards the end
Please react to Moon Byul's other solo songs. Among Moonbyul's solo songs, I want to introduce C.I.T.T and G999 first. Because I want to show Moon Byul playing better than anyone else on stage with a bright and exciting song that's the opposite of Eclipse. C.I.T.T definitely recommends the stage version.
C.I.T.T
G999
Absence
intro : SYNOPSIS
ddu ddu ddu
It comes FINALLY!!!!
Really enjoyed this video especially with the explanation and song break down in the second half
MOONBYUL 💘😭 i love how they pointed out that she owned a usually bg kind of sound and her artistry 🤧
Even if the music kinda has a taste of a usual boy group sound, she pulled it perfectly and made it her own. I love the sound
I WAITED FOR THISSSSSSSSS
Moon is known for her deep voice. And i love that he said it was really put together. Love it because that is Mamamoo all together. They know who they are and what they want.
Moonbyul is so cool
Unrelated, but I REALLY HOPE THE CHANNEL REACHES 1 MIL IN 2021! Y'all be putting out some great stuff for years
Wooo... Waiting for this!!!!
ITS HEREEEEEEE YESSSSS FINALLLYYYY
Thank you for the 🌙🌟 react!!
Woahh! Thank you so much for bringing this reaction to life, Umu and the gang. I hope moonbyul sees this video somehow. ❤️
Super love it when music experts appreciate our moonbyul ❤️❤️❤️❤️
YES MOONBYUL ❤️
I HAVE WAITED FOR THIS
that guy read my mind about the chorus!! i wish it had built up more or a little less so the chorus would be very explosive huhuhu nonetheless i love eclipse, it doesn't get old and how much it means to byul, like,, she fought for that concept and she owns it! despite getting a lot of hate (from sk men lol). i just wish for her to do whatever she want with her music (and let her produce!! bcs she already can and she needs to have more control abt the songs) :(♡