Q&A: Are Islam and Judaism the same religion?
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 09. 2013
- Dr. Shabir Ally takes a question from a viewer on whether Islam and Judaism are essentially the same religion. He provides insights on the differences and similarities.
If you have a question of your own, please write to us at: www.quranspeaks.com/contact/
- - -
www.quranspeaks.com
For your FREE copy of the English Quran, visit: www.quranspeaks.com/free-quran/
I enjoy he calls us 1:52 "OUR JEWISH FRIENDS" .. Thank you Dr. Shabir. G-D bless you.
Why you think, that Muslims against Jews! Muslims hate the Zionists and Zionism
Elias Saca Dear Elias. hating zionizm is very strange. maybee you dont understand what it means. Zion is Jerusalim. so u hate people who love jerusalem?? or people who believed that jerusalem is so important and went to be near it?
David Bohbot Mr. David, I know very well what I am talking about, Zionism is a radical, racist movement, even In 1975, the United Nations General Assembly passed Resolution 3379, which concluded that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination.", I don't care about the religious background, but the actions token to achieve it.
***** Yes very well true, and theodr hertzl btw was actually a prominent millitant atheist, he wanted a secular Israel. Any jew that has a damn brain in his head would totally be against zionism, I for one am a convert to islam, but I love the jewish people.
travis gunn Yea hertzyl was atheist basically and God did most Jews are basically atheist
QURAN 2:100
Is it not [true] that every time they(Jews) took a covenant a party of them threw it away? But, [in fact], most of them do not believe.
Most of them do not beleive God exists deep down. I mean its been 3000 years since Moses(as) and they turned away from Prophet Jesus(as) and Muhammad pbuh so they have not had a revival spiritually
Because jews and muslim from the same father ..
We are son of abraham ..
No, Abram was Ishmael father not "Abraham "
@@jasonharts6994 Abram is another name of Abraham is the same person.
No
@@jasonharts6994 search in the google the son of abraham,
@@jasonharts6994 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham%27s_family_tree
If one is truly a religious Muslim, while they may have some disagreements with Judaism as a religion, they would naturally very much respect Judaism, as the two faiths have many resemblances. The politics of the middle east is an issue which extends beyond these two extraordinary faiths.
Mohammad completely changed the Torah 🤦♂️ The Jews and Christians don't respect that.
Islam believes in all the three relegions,they came in different times to remind us that god is one and only.
+amir hussain There is no three religions, there are three revelations and one religion Islam (submision to Allah One and only)
That's for you my friend but not for others, you have to understand that your religion is for you and stop hating and inventing what you belive is given you didn't is not chosen is the almighty who decides not you
For frequency of mind I just remind you that all humans are imperfect only the almighty is perfect
@@mavericktribe8065how about bible?
janus2014 savero except Torah;gospel is also lie.Jesus didn’t fulfill messianic prophecies of end times.that is the reason jews reject Jesus as messiah.I have done 12yrs research on bible.
Messiah David will be their king and they will have only one shepherd. They will obey my regulation and be careful to keep my decrees. They will live in the land I gave my servant Jacob, the land.
(Isaiah 1:26:) "And I will restore your judges as at first and your counsellors as in the beginning; afterwards you shall be called city of righteousness, faithful city."
85
Once he is king, leaders of other nations will look to him for guidance. (Isaiah 2:4)
The whole world will worship the one God Yahweh of Israel. (Isaiah 2:11)
He will be the descended from King David (Isaiah 11:1)
The "spirit of the lord"Yahweh will be upon him, and he will have a "fear of god". (Isaiah 11:2)
Evil and tyranny will not be able to stand before his leadership. (Isaiah 11:4)
Knowledge of God will fill the world. (Isaiah 11:9)
He will include and attract people from all cultures and nations. (Isaiah 11:10)
All Israelites will be returned to their homeland. (Isaiah 11:12)
Death will be swallowed up forever. (Isaiah 25:8)
There will be no more hunger or illness, and death will cease. (Isaiah 25:8)
All of the dead will rise again. (Isaiah 26:19)
The Jewish people will experience eternal joy and gladness. (Isaiah 51:11)
He will be a messenger of peace. (Isaiah 52:7)
Nations will recognize the wrongs they did to Israel. (Isaiah 52:13-53:5)
The peoples of the world will turn to the Jews for spiritual guidance. (Zechariah 8:23)
The ruined cities of Israel will be restored. (Ezekiel 16:55)
86
Weapons of war will be destroyed. (Ezekiel 39:9)
The people of Israel will have direct access to the Torah through their minds and Torah study will become the study of the wisdom of the heart. (Jeremiah 31:33)[10]
He will give you all the worthy desires of your heart. (psalms 37:4)
He will take the barren land and make it abundant and fruitful. (Isaiah 51:3, Amos 9:13-15, Ezekiel 36:29-30, Isaiah 11:6-9).
Jesus didn’t fulfill 2000yrs ago so therefore Christ 2nd coming has been fantasy of christanity &islam Both.Torah proclaimed about jews messiah Ben David as the king messiah.
For me as a Jew Muhamed PBAH,was a man of God!to bring Pagan arabs,and others to the believing in one God!
because if you do not believe in Allah as the one and only God,you are dumed!!!
You don't have to be a Jew to be saved...but you have to believe only in ONE GOD.
We need more people like you seriously even tho I'm a Muslim the hate between our religions need to stop, you my friend are a good person
but in the Bible and Torah it has said about Moses and Isaiah and Elijah and even Abraham himself was told by god himself his name.
and god do have a name.
Mr Samuel
As a Muslim you think that a Jewish people will forget what abrahamic and Moses teaching and all the old testament prophet prophecy.
It has said in Deuteronomy 18:1thru 18
Which is fulfilled and prophet Isaiah prophecy's has been foretold and fulfilled which is 45:21 and 22 and 99:9 and Timothy1:17 and Micah 5:2 and Matthew 1: 21-23
Luke 2:10-11 and John 10:30 and John 14:6
And it's didn't say Muhammad in it.
There more about our Lord Jesus yeshua Christ.
In Joshua and kings and Samuel and lamentations and Hosea and Elijah and Jeremiah and Ezekiel and kings and chronicle and Nehemiah and James and John and Peter and Paul and Andrew and Revelation.
And why you doing your research ask a Jewish rabbi about prophet Hosea because that how the good Lord Jesus yeshua Christ will judge you.
Samuel John
Then you don't KNOW nothing about your Jewish history.
Because before Jewish people was named Jewish people.
They was called Hebrew
So go back to your rabbi and let him explain about your Jewish history and culture and custom religion because you are lost.
Samuel John
For your information
It started with Abraham first.
And Noah who was saved by god himself.
And Abraham a Hebrew priest.
Who answered the call of God in second year BC.
Who agree here that Islam, Judaism and Christianity to befriended, have peace and help each other? I agree!
christianity wants to destroy judaism and islam
Ameen Campano
me too agree
excuse me Judaism they not know about all old testament. he remember Mosses and Elijah but the rest
they not know? Why Jesus mention pharisees and priest of Mosses but other they not. easy they not coexist old testament. but St. Paul Wrote in century. Torah is not Word of God. they took the old testament in Europe. WW2
in record
Martin Luther 1543 they read the book torah and talmud are same in inside negative
Pope Clement VIII 1543
st. Augustine 397
Henry Ford 1947 The International Jew he mention the book Talmud its original of Judaism
Benjamin Friedman
Also Judaism they not reject Jesus and Mary they insult also
Jesus negative mansion 128
Mary negative words 66
Ameen Campano I couldn't agree more
Agree
Loved it . Thank you shabir Ali.
Dr shabir is such a great man, many God grant him heaven
May
Wtf Kim jon
Plz change many to may!
Many Gods. Are you Hindu?
This is my fav video so far
Very intelligent man. G-d bless you.
David Johnson why do jews say G-d?
@@Poopoo77373 We say G-d for respect reasons, some will use the hebrew names Hashem (the name) or Adonai (my lord/leader), but we also won't use the actual hebrew name for G-d, also for respect.
@@katzmanon That's interesting; didn't know that
@@katzmanon Me robaste la pregunta
Love ( under the religions) feels soo good
The comments below are infuriating. "I hate this", "You hate that", "Such & such a group hates the other"..... Can't those of us with calm tempers and rational minds just find common ground?
We all need food, water, shelter, we all benefit from education and culture....
Come on people !!! It's the 21st Century! We can do this!
Kind of agree with you. Goat Gruff.
Jeremiah Williams Cheers, sorry it was such an angry diatribe. I just wish Jews, Muslims, Christians, Hindus etc would realise their similarities. Atheists too for that matter.
What I find amusing is, if I'd said something vitriolic and one sided, I'd have had 50 replies already - speak up for unity, togetherness or a common cause and there's all but tumbleweed...
Goat Gruff Its great when people who have no clue about religion (at all) give advice to people of said religions based off their generalizations.
Worst part is you think it some type of unifying statement, instead of the blatant insult it is.
Steve Abalon What an odd thing to say. I'm pretty sure, based on your comment, that you're mistaken.
So what religion is it you follow that I've misunderstood?
No, I can easily tell you have not even read the holy books of the religions you criticize.
Educate yourself and you'll know what I'm talking about.
Amazing how many wars and blood has been shed over such a small detail.
Mike Mendillo very, very awful that wars are fought over these details
The devil are in the details
nope nope the wars are for the money and power, religion is the scapegoat
Muslims and Jews coexisted peacefully from 7th century to the 20th century. Ask Jews whose grandparents were from Arab countries. Jews got massacred by Christian Adolf Hiltler and his Nazi army, then Great Britain with help of America established a country Israel where Palestinians were kicked out of their homes even to this day Palestinians are kicked out from their homes to make room for Jewish settlement. Evangelical Christian Americans are allies of Israel because they believe once all Jews go to Israel and establish a Third Temple, Jesus will return. Evangelical Christian Americans could care less about Arabs or Muslims who lived in that land for a thousand years.
no such war, religion was never a primary reason for war. there are always political issues.
End with such beautiful azan... 😊✨
the main difference is the judaism do not accept prophet Jesus and prophet Muhammad as the messengers of God...😲
Accept the similarities. Forget the differences. Be Tolerant
Please Elaborate on this Issue further to quench the misunderstanding abot Copying part.
Highlight the Differences between Torah and Quran.
Thank you
Proud to be the Ummah of our beloved last prophet muhammad peace be upon him . Inshallah we will submit our will to Allah(swt).May Allah grant us Jannah tul Firdous.
thanks so much for this video guys, seems like there are more similarities than differences in both religions, and Islam might be a touch closer to
Christianity, than Judaism is to either of the religions if u understood right, amazing how close they are all though, very informative!
The most important issue is the Creator Himself. One should never associate anything unto the Creator . With belief in the Creator one should also do the best he can to live by what the Creator commanded.
Associating partners unto the Creator can be in a direct form (people who believe Jesus (puh) to be part of God. or atheists who are putting nature in drivers seat) and there is also another form of associating others unto the Creator. In Islam it can be a ''Muslim'' who goes to the mosque often so that people will say what a nice fella . This guy was not a submitter to Allah . There are also people who give charity to be known as good people . Again one should submit his whole self to the Creator .
When one follows this it is better then possessing all gold on earth .
As for who is closer to Islam the Jew or Christian .Most Jews know about the message of Islam and still they are rejecting the blessed son of the blessed woman Mary (puh) and also rejecting prophet Muhammad (puh) who only said what Allah commanded him .
As for Christians , they differ among each other about what should be clear theological concepts. Some say God became flesh and when you ask some of them does God change they say no he just added nature of man to Himself. Others say yes God can do anything thus also being subjected to time and becoming a man . Some Christians say I personally believe that Jesus (puh) was a prophet of God . Some Christians who never read quran and being confronted by it start weeping and turn back to their original religion . Others (Jay Smith) do not believe the bible to be literal word of God and their goal is try to convince others that quran is also like that )
There is a great lesson in sacrifice of Abraham(puh). One can say that he loves the Creator more then anyone yet often this is only sound and has no real meaning . They often love their family and forefathers more then they do love the truth . God is the truth and truth is not divisible .
Peace be with you
excuse me Judaism they not know about all old testament. he remember Mosses and Elijah but the rest
they not know? Why Jesus mention pharisees and priest of Mosses but other they not. easy they not coexist old testament. but St. Paul Wrote in century. Torah is not Word of God. they took the old testament in Europe. WW2
in record
Martin Luther 1543 they read the book torah and talmud are same in inside negative
Pope Clement VIII 1543
st. Augustine 397
Henry Ford 1947 The International Jew he mention the book Talmud its original of Judaism
Benjamin Friedman
Also Judaism they not reject Jesus and Mary they insult also
Jesus negative mansion 128
Mary negative words 66
I would say Judaism is more close to Islam, because we agree that there's only one God . But Christians saying there's a 3 God The Father, The mother, the son and spirit. That is not fare to not call the mother Christians fellows
Approaching this logically, there are two options explaining the similarities between Judaism and Islam. One is that Islam is actually an organic outgrowth of the "original Judaism." The other is that Islam simply simulates Judaism and is therefore only superficially similar. Even in the case of the latter, it seems that most religious Jews would respect Islam as a noble and valid attempt to embrace monotheism. The issues start when Islam seeks to overtake Judaism, invent false arguments in the name of Judaism and the Torah, claim that we changed it, and negate our history, and usurp our holy sites. What in theory could be a very good friendship and alliance doesn't stand much of a chance for a good relationship in practice.
sonofblessed interesting point you made, there is an excellent paper by a secular scholar, who demonstrate the "evolution" of Quranic thoughts and relationship to Moses figures.iqsaweb.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/sandiego_keynote_an.pdf
Giltet Baya Thank you, I'll look this up.
***** Hello Kitti Kat. Is that right? I haven't come across that, but I also don't have a complete knowledge of the Talmud, which is quite vast as you probaby know. Do you care to tell me where in the Talmud you found it and I'll see if I can look it up?
I think it's great that you're looking into different religions. What drives you in this search?
Thanks...
Did you find it on a website, or did you see it in a physical copy of a book of the Talmud?
islam does not want to destroy judaism, they don't want to destroy any religion.
I think most humans instinctually believe in a creator when it comes to believe in something greater than us. Often different civilizations were misunderstood on how they reach to God or creation I think rationality when it comes to understanding of how we exist if you look at the moon sun sky rain etc.. There are just different interpretations on how to worship doesn't mean anything if you are not worshiping a religion, religions are laws written and explained when it comes to Judaism Christianity and Islam in fact coming from the same region you will find something similar why? It is inexplicable why sin is important in all of them? Because of the dangers of humanity, religion is given and not chosen and in fact is to understand a method of life. Peace to all the religions and grace to the lord.
(And when Jesus came as a Messenger to the children of Israel, he said,)
*"I have come to you with a clear Sign from your Lord: in your very presence, I make the likeness of a bird out of clay and breathe into it and it becomes, by Allah's Command, a bird.*
*I heal those born blind and the lepers and I bring to life the dead by Allah's Command: I inform you of what you eat and what you store up in your houses.*
*Surely there is a great Sign for you in all this, if you have a mind to believe. And I have come to confirm those teachings of the Guidance of the Torah which are intact in my time.*
*Lo! I have come with a clear Sign from your Lord; so fear Allah and obey me.*
*Indeed Allah is my Lord, and also your Lord; therefore worship Him alone: that is the straight way."*
Quran Chep 3 Verse [50-51]
Like imagine no hate amongst the religions.Just love.I am missing that
How can I send you links
In the Song of Solomon in hebrew prophet Muhammad saw was prophesied by his name Jew brothers and sisters should really research about it and find out the truth
It’s actually not true. What sounds like “Muhammad” in the Song of Solomon isn’t referring to him because the *context* does not support that. Just because something *sounds* like something doesn’t mean it is that thing. بَنَانَه in the quran sounds exactly like “banana” but it isn’t referring to the fruit 🍌. Grow up Muslims.
Mik902 Because they are of the same origin as the Arabs called Banan Bananas meaning fingers. This is what we say, you do not have the right to translate the names of people for each name meaning
Toka Sab
I couldn’t understand your point exactly. Anyway the Arabic for bananas is "mowz" (موز) not banan. The etymology of the English word “banana” is said to be of West African origin, possibly the Wolof language, not Arabic. My earlier point still stands.
Mik902 banana, apparently a word from one of the languages of the Congo area (it has been speculated that it derives ultimately from Arabic banana ‘finger, toe’, an origin which would be echoed in the English term hand for a bunch of bananas, and serves as a reminder that many varieties of banana are quite small,
Regardless of whether this is true or not, what I mean is that every name has meaning, and we do not call people to translate their names if your name is white. I have no right to say Mr Abiadh (ابيض) .
.
Isn’t Shafiyya Ally, Dr. Shabir Ally’s daughter?
She said Brother Shabir at the beginning of the question 😕
judaism and christianity were true religion at the time of moses and jesus but people changed it after they left thats why god sent islam at the end to correct everything so islam is the only true and simple religion think about it before its too late
zolo z
agreee
Judaism is the one and true religion.
@@alexarodriguez2925 Really? Jews are still waiting for their Messiah to rule them and take over the world, defeating the Rome. That time has been. You Jews rejected Isus as your Messiah, you rejected all Prophets after Moses and tried to kill them all.
So no, Judaism is nlt true.
true
@@Iambadboy88 judaism came before muslim and Christianity.
U rock Dr shabbir
Muslims view Islam as a continuation of Judaism, and condemns Nicene Christianity. Muslims view the Torah given to Moses as the holy word of God, and accept Jesus as a prophet, but not the son of God or God in the flesh, which we, like our Jewish cousins, view as idolatry.
What is the diffrence between the Quran and the kabbalah are these two the same
No
I will start using the phrase "our jewish friends" with my students, some of whom despise jews, thereby mixing up religion and politics, as a lot of people do (see comments). It is a difficult subject though, because politics obviously play an important role in our lives. Thank you for your calm and friendly discourse, as always.
David And Solomon Are Both Kings And Prophets
This guy is a good imam. I wouldn't mind sitting for a sermon. Very intelligent.
very very very good
First is to link up these two by answering their differences
Starting language first,,,they gotta agree on a unified language because language is human but it's God they need
Now good cause technology can translate
So does this mean that if I acknowledge Muhamed to be God's prophet but remain Jewish, is it OK with Muslims?
If you acknowledge Mohammad (Peace be upon him) as the last prophet and Allah is the only God, then you already become a Muslim. lol....Does the name matter?
The only difference is that I do not discount Judaism in its current form as a true religion, while mainstream Muslims do, and so to be 'Jewish' matters to me. Muslims wrongly claim that the Jews forged the Torah, right? They want the Jews to acknowledge Muhamed as a true prophet, while they themselves refuse to acknowledge today's Judaism as the true religion.
It is not OK with Muslims to be Jewish.
Abdallah Abolkheir nothing is wrong with being Jewish by ethnicity. Muslims are of all colors, shapes, and sizes. as Islam is only the final restatement of the Messages of Allah to the Prophets before Muhammad, the original messages are the same. it is just that Judaism has been changed since the Prophets preached it, of course not nearly as much as Christianity. if you want to follow Judaism in its purest, most original form, then your manual to life will be Islam.
Just ask the Creator for guidance and everything will be ok .salam aleikom
Why does he say peace be upon him when he mentions Mohammed but not when he mentions other prophets?
We as Muslims say peace be upon every prophet we mantion. We love and respect all the prophets send by The Creator of the Universe.
He might forget but if you follow his ather videos you will see that he and all ather Muslim preachers say peace be upon all the properties.
May God guide you to the right path. Amin
Peace
@@drenica0133
I happen to know of many muslims who only wish blessings upon Muhammad and not other prophets.
I realize that everytime I commune with them
Peace Be Upon Moses
I got a small question for Jews, Muslims and Christians.
How do you know your religion is the true religion?
Go look up and read about the chariots found under the Red Sea. Read Matthew 24 and Luke 21 how Jesus prophesied about the Jerusalem destruction before it happened. Look into how many scientists are now finding out evolution must be false. Read about Noah's ark being found in turkey. Read Quran how it says Euphrates river will dry up. Also in book of Revelation
Main belief is (Toheed) accenting only one God. That's common in both religions. But in the Christianity, this 3 in 1 is very confusing.
what was the religion of Muslim people in the Middle East before Islam? Maybe.. anything to do with the non Jewish Jesus who actually was a Partian prince? His language being Aramaic which was the language of most of the Middle East that time.. A version of Sumerian. The Sumerian culture and the people of wisdom from the Partian Empire? (Proto Christians)? Obviously these things has been unknown.
The question I want to ask is, if Jews accept Islam is not a corrupt religion, but Muslims claim Judaism is corrupt, then how can there be mutual respect? Isn't Islamic teaching about Judaism, saying they changed their bible, an attack on Judaism? As far as I know, Judaism teaches that Muslims will go to heaven when they die, as they do obey the 7 rules communicated by the Prophet Noah (Nu)
Hi, for us if a Jew were to convert to Islam it would be seen as a negative thing. We require belief in the inviability of the Torah for Jews. For non-Jews we require the 7 Noahide laws one of which is the absolute unity of god.
Secondly, Islam says that Allah is in charge of who enters Jannah. According to many opinions Jews are not necessarily excluded from the equation. Furthermore Islam tells Muslims to leave Jews who want to practice their religion alone.
So as a Jew i don't necessarily see why mutual respect is impossible.
@@Joeshapiro7 Then what is the explanation for centuries of Islamic anti-semitism, going back to the companions of the prophet beheading people for reverting to Judaism? And the high rate of anti-semitism of Islamic majority countries far from the arab world?
One basic issue is that Islam tends to read religious texts as literal, straightforward, revelation,and testimony, Judaism only really sees one part of the bible as like that. Parables, interpretation, symbolism,, debate, and difficult texts are allowed. Therefore Islam accuses Jews of falsifying its holy books, and literally doing Islam wrong. That Jews at times, according to themselves, didn't worship God properly at first, as portrayed in Jewish books, is not seen as a humble admission within a redemption tale of how they eventually figured out their religion, but as a confession that they are against God, killers of prophets and liars. So, Jews don't really care what Islam is doing because they see it as a different religion, but Islam claims Judaism is a wrong form of Islam, and that all the Jewish prophets were Muslims. Of course Muslims and Jews can respect each other, but the Muslims would have to not be very religious.
@@Joeshapiro7 agreeeee brother👍🏻
how about afterlifein Judaism? it is not that close at all to Islam..
Jews are taught to rely on God even after bodily death, but not to dwell on future reward. Humanity was created to be God's premiere conduit to the physical world.. You do not know the whole truth
its a good thing their same because they should be same as both are of same tree of the religion(as an way of life) approved n provided by god
Allah sent 4 Holy books.
1. Torat (Torah)
2. Zaboor
3. Injeel (Bible)
4. Quran
Judaism is the first religion ever found on this Earth. It is 3700 years old religion. With the passage of time people started changing things according to their preferences and this is what happened with this rest 2 Books too. Today Quran is the only Book whom's responsibility was taken by Allah Almighty. Till the day of the judgement noone can change a single word or alphabet in it. Islam is found 1400 years back. If the Book that's responsibility has been taken by Almighty Himself praises about Mohammad (PBUH) and Jesus then how can Jews not believe in them. This is totally wrong. Even in all the four books the name of Mohammad (PBUH) is mentioned that he will come to this world and he will be the last messenger of Allah. He will born in Makkah and many other things. I havent red Torah myself. I don't know what is in the book and what makes Jews not to believe the 2 important Messengers of Allah.
Judaism is the first religion ever found on this Earth. Not from Islamic perspective . From Islamic perspective Moses(puh) was not following Judaism . That is incorrect . Ibrahim (puh) was not following Judaism .
Solayman (puh) was not following Judaism , Daud (puh) was not following Judaism , Ishaq(puh) and Ismail (puh) were not following Judaism . Isa ibn maryam was not following Christianity since he submited his wil to Allah not to himself .
Furthermore Allah reminds us in chapter 76 verse 1 : Has there not been a period over mankind that he was not a thing worthy mentioning
Allah reminds us also that he did not make us witness to creation of heavens and earth .
There were many generations before Ibrahim (puh).
Allah reminds us in chapter 40 verse 57 that creation of heavens and earth is greater then creation of mankind but most of mankind know not .
Allah also reminds us that the cosmos does not follow desires (by men ) since we are the ones conscious of change in it .
Yet many people in the past believed in a very recent created cosmos by comparing development of cosmos to that of mankind . Some concluded that the cosmos existed forever and mankind co existed with it.
Others claimed that the cosmos goes back to 6000 or maybe 100 000 years and also with it mankind .
Both were false .
The truth is not divisible and I thank Allah for giving us free will to explore and rediscover which Allah taught men by the pen . In one sense Allah subjected all that is on earth and in the heavens to us and asks us to reflect about this . On the other hand we are not autonomous .All knowledge comes from Allah since he is the source of morality and knowledge.
azadam1000 you forgot paganism
Danny Jaber paganism or associating others unto the Creator is often practiced. One can follow desires and follow forefathers and believe Jesus (puh) to be the Creator and a human being . Others who are claiming to BELIEVE IN ONENESS OF ALLAH also sometimes are associating partners UNTO ALLAH . It could be that this individual is setting his alarm clock and arriving late at work being distressed or even afraid to be fired but when it comes to praying on time he is careless.
Judaism is not first religion on earth of course and monotheism predates paganism . Allah did send messengers to all nations speaking to them in their language and after that they did the same as some Christians did .
Peace be with you
+Mala Khan note: Zaboor = psalm in English :)
+Mala Khan Zaboor are the David's psalms right?
Judaism has several important religious texts that are considered sacred and authoritative. Some of the key religious books of Judaism include:
1. **Torah (Pentateuch):** The Torah is the central and most sacred text of Judaism. It consists of the first five books of the Hebrew Bible: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. The Torah contains laws, commandments, historical narratives, and teachings that form the foundation of Jewish faith and practice.
2. **Talmud:** The Talmud is a collection of rabbinic teachings and commentaries on the Torah. It is divided into two main parts: the Mishnah, which is a compilation of oral traditions, and the Gemara, which contains discussions, interpretations, and debates on the Mishnah. There are two versions of the Talmud: the Babylonian Talmud and the Jerusalem Talmud.
3. **Tanakh (Hebrew Bible):** The Tanakh is the Jewish Bible, which includes the Torah, the Nevi'im (Prophets), and the Ketuvim (Writings). In addition to the Torah, it contains historical books, prophetic writings, and poetic literature. The Tanakh is the foundational scripture of Judaism and is used for worship, study, and reflection.
4. **Midrash:** Midrash refers to a genre of rabbinic literature that consists of interpretations, explanations, and elaborations on the biblical text. Midrashic texts explore the meanings and teachings of the Torah and other biblical narratives.
5. **Siddur (Prayer Book):** The Siddur is the Jewish prayer book, containing a compilation of prayers, blessings, and liturgical texts used in daily and special occasions of worship. Different Jewish communities may have their own variations of the Siddur.
6. **Haggadah:** The Haggadah is a text used during the Passover Seder, a ritual meal that commemorates the Exodus from Egypt. The Haggadah contains the narrative of the Exodus, blessings, prayers, and explanations of the symbolic elements of the Seder.
7. **Kabbalistic Texts:** Kabbalah is a mystical and esoteric tradition within Judaism. Kabbalistic texts, such as the Zohar, explore the deeper spiritual and metaphysical dimensions of the universe and God's relationship with humanity.
These texts, along with other commentaries, interpretations, and writings, collectively contribute to the rich and diverse tapestry of Jewish religious thought, practice, and culture.
Actually our ancestor were prophet believed in one god
Muhammad used to pray facing Jerusalem
Later he prayed facing kaaba
If kaaba was built by Abraham why did he not pray facing kaaba earlier?
The Qiblah was changed to Jerusalem from Mecca at the time the temple in Jerusalem was built. it was changed back to Mecca so to distinguish Muslims from Jews and Christians. Hope that helps
@@neilschlichting7384 why did Abraham built kaaba?
If muslims consider creater to be great why is a creation kaaba built by Abraham
+Kartheesh k
the Ka'abah is the first Mosque ever built for the Worship of one God.. (the building itself is a temple, just like the Temple in Jerusalem built hundreds of years later)
@@neilschlichting7384 If kaaba was built earlier why did muhammad pray facing Jerusalem earlier?
@@neilschlichting7384 If kaaba was only a mosque (a place of worship ) why do muslims circle around the kaaba and not in any other mosques?
Is it mentioned in the quran to circle around the kaaba?
Deuteronomy 6:4 does not say “there is only one god”. It says “Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God is one Lord:” which does not unambiguously rule out the existence of other gods or gods for other people. Even the account of Abraham smashing idols of other deities does not appear in the Torah itself. In fact, Isaiah 44:6 is the first unambiguous clear statement of Monotheism: “I am the first and I am the last; beside me there is no god” (although the pedant may point above or below”. Early Judaism and by association Islam was distinctly ambiguous if not outright polytheistic.
It is a great riddle when Judaism recognise principle of Nabi, then why new religions, christianity, Islam, Bahaism came into existence. On the other hand, in Hinduism, there are numerous sects, even followers of Charvak sect (atheists), all are called Hindus.
HIndusim is not a religion per say, it is like , anything goes, yes there are some specific sects and religious movement within it but it consists of religious practices of million of type collected under one name but most of those are so diametrically opposed to each other that you can not claim any philosophical coherence compared to HInduism , Abrahamic faiths are just sects of a religion, but philosophical, everything is defined to the T, in all three sects , specially in Islam and Judaism. They are bookish religions so they don't just change with a whim.
He is on the earth now to guide you all the truth....Wait is now being over....
Do the jews do ablution or wudhu
No wudhu but immerse in the Mikveh.
Yes
یيوث يوبۃ yes
Pharoah Akhenaten said only one God which we cant see in 1136 BC. This has been overlooked by many. Persians also had monotheism.
However Zoroastrians dont believe God is absolutely omnipotent
We, Christians in the Far East (Philippines), not catholics, believe in one God, our Almighty Father in Heaven Who sent Jesus Christ on earth in order that, through Jesus Christ, we will understand that our Almighty God Has Promised an everlasting life and holy city HE prepared to be inherited by those who love God. We, Christians in the Philippines, believe that our love to God is manifested, ONLY, in our compliance of God's Words, Laws and Will; otherwise, how can one says that he/she love God? We Christians in the Far East worship our Almighty God in Spirit and in Truth. In our Houses of Worship, we neither have graven images nor pictures because we know this is forbidden and our Almighty God does favor this kind of worship. Our Lord Jesus Christ said "There is only one God", and Whose Holiness is beyond compare. We, Christians in the Far East are not catholics, and we serve and we worship our Almighty God, our Holy Father in Heaven because this is what our Lord Jesus Christ taught humanity to do it
You don't believe in the trinity?! If so then you're 70% muslim😆
Which sect of Christianity are you in ? I am sure u are not catholic or orthodox
I’m a Christian the way I see it is in short they aren’t identical but they are similar on important topics
I disagree. They both actually follow different Gods. Ishmael's line was a pagan line while Isaac's line was the promised line of the Israelites. Mohammad inserted beliefs from both Christianity and Judaism in an attempt to make Islam look legit but it didn't fool the Christians and Jews as it is mentioned in the Quran.
@@mattpowell6291 your right
@@mattpowell6291 *you are probably a Christian who worship three god lol*
@@mattpowell6291 So you are claiming god lied in the Old Testament when he said that Abraham children will be a great nation which Ishmael is. Ishamael nation will surpass Christianity soon
@@howtodoit4204 God didn't lie. Ishmaels ancestors became a great nation. He never said they would be a Godly nation. They were pagans. Do you realise that there is absolutely no proof that Mohammad was even from the line of Ishmael? At least with EVERY OTHER PROPHET from Abraham onwards you can see a direct lineage. This is not the case with Mohammad so therefore Islam is most likely not even Abrahamic in a lineage sense.
It kind of starts 2:37
With respect, Its not about story but order, these both religion find law of God as suprime and man can rule as his stake as his servant. Both are same but with some differance. We got some more concession at some point and more restriction at another point. All prophet carried same massage of equality as represented in the shape of Kaba instance of order of world today a pyramid.
I am Buddhist and I am a part polytheist,so am I sinful for this in eyes of monotheistic religions like Judaism, Christianity and Islam?
Christianity also polythiest religion . Islam and Jews are only monotheistic religion belives in one god who has got no shape, body , son or parents .
Sikh is also monotheistic religion which believe in one god .
Sikh religion mainly influenced by Islam .founded 600 years ago may be not much
Best part is Guru Nanak accepted teachings of Islam . Rejected Hindu ideology about stone worship. Well That's a good news
@Love Your Neighbour again same dailouge. 3 in one god. God borned as human.
Human is god. God died..
jesus prayed to god.
Jesus is god.
Jesus is son of god.
Jesus is father.
Jesus is son of father.
Jesus and father is different
Jesus and father is same.
Jesus cried to god while praying.
All these words belong to polytheist religion. We and jews are pure in one god worship. No shape, no gender, no son, no father.
@Love Your Neighbour every humans have flesh. So jesus is also a human . According to Christians god borned.
@Love Your Neighbour the Christians who lived till 200 years after prophet jesus rasied to heaven they are real true monotheistic Christian people. Later 200 years later after prophet jesus lifted up to heaven. They created a fake dummy bible which taken Christians into pagan polytheist belief
@Love Your Neighbour in which school you studied?? Humans don't have flesh?
U need to Read Quran and pray five times a day u will never lose faith everything u need is on-line or app. Torah we have now not the same us Torah then so go find any Book better than Qur`an or create any chapter like it
Goods
@ 12 April 2024
# 9:28 AM
So it's a matter of accepting Jesus pbuh and Muhammad pbuh...
Why does she call her own dad brother lol
brother in faith
To act professional ofcourse
I think the main difference is according to Jews, God is all powerful but he wanted to rest sometime after creating the earth. Why does he rest if he is All powerful? In islam, God is perfect, he neither sleeps nor rests. We all know about the story between God and Musa (A.S.) when Musa asked Allah, “O Allah, do you sleep?” And got responded by the Merciful in an amazing example.
I like the difference is quickly glossed over, ask why do they not accept Jesus or Mohammad?
Becoz SOME JEWS only believe in Moses and torah...even SOME JEWS rejected jesus PBUH and Muhammad PBUH...but they still believe in one God and claimed islam and Judasim believe in same God and only have one God
Believe in Allah/ HaShem is one God ...u will entered paradise
You’re telling me this guy is a doctor? He gave the 101 on how Islam and Judaism differ straight from my middle school textbook.
If you have one minute to answer this questions, could you have done it in a better way? To get into details you need episodes
@@brianzar1943 There lacks a profundity of detail in the Koran itself. I've spent a lot of time studying the bible and you can go extremely deep, finding immense parallels, prophecy, and deeper theology than any text in the world. I assumed the Quran would be similar, but it is just nice poetry.
@@Brandongorrie lol nice poetry? Do you even speak Arabic? Quran outlines everything you need to know about life, from marriage to divorce to inheritance to charity to work ethics and social relations, and the after life its self. It’s not a book about mohamad, it’s a book of god. God also tells us about previous prophets and their nations.
While the Bible is more like a biography of the life of Jesus written more than two decades after the death of Jesus by people who have never met Jesus and didn’t speak his native language (Aramaic). I really don’t think that you know what you’re talking about
@@brianzar1943 I’ve spent some hours looking into Islam theology and I get all that. But it’s so simple. It’s all surface level thinking. That in and of itself isn’t bad, but it pales be n comparison to the depth of the Bible. The problem of sin isn’t addressed in the Quran accurately as sin is absolved by works and faith in the Quran. Which means that they are then owed an afterlife by way of a wage for their deeds and faithfulness. Doesn’t sound like a god to me, sounds like a human being to me. I believe in a god who knows my heart and has blessed me with salvation by his grace and not by my works. There is nothing I could do to earn my way into heaven in Christianity because the disparity between Gods perfect holiness and me is too far. That is the purpose of the Som, Jesus Christ. You see Islam has no theology, it takes after the Abrahamic tales, doesn’t know how to interpret the Trinity, and then claims to be the second revelation after the covenant with Israel which would contradict the book of John in the Bible. Plus the earliest translation of the Bible into Arabic wasn’t until centuries after the death of Christ. It’s a man-made desecration of the Lord.
@@Brandongorrie also my man, you’re saying it’s surface level thinking, and it should be! God is addressing all humans with a very clear and simple message! It’s not a PhD class, it’s the manual of life for everyone, the educated, the non educated, the rich the poor, the black the white etc
Allah only sent a massage.. it is we..(human) who named as religion this, religion that..
Only once a religion said and mention by word by ALLAH is ISLAM. Is in the holy Qur'an..
Soo.. in that sanse,,some muslim scolar said from the beginning the name of this religion came from first prophet Adam, to last prophet Muhammad, all of its are Islam.
And all of the them (the prophet and the worshipers is muslim, by definition.
On other word.. Islam is not begin at Muhammad Times, but when human kind exist on this world..or when our father Adam teach to all his kids about Allah and ways of worship to Allah.
Same tree, different branches
Same tree but cristianity &judayism the broken branches.
@@Rshi4u and Islam is the rotten branch
but there is only one ladder to to reach God....Jesus Christ.
@rashid kaleem no I am not being judgemental I am being practical just answering the people who talk bad about us
true
Islam and Judaism believe in same God
Allah/HaShem
Nothing is comparable to Allah the lord of the universe and beyond
sorry but you can't nail someone to a cross kill them then burry them only to have them come back to life
Is she Shabir's daughter?
???
Gaga4Parma
ur pretty active.
can u ask the ques in words
Al-Ikram Chowdory I don't know what you are talking about.
Gaga4Parma
forget about it ur mindset is A ok
I think so
Islam-Christianity-Judaism consolidates in Old testament, from the story of Adam & Eve, Abraham, Moses, Noah and many others. It will differ only on that Christians believe that Jesus is the messiah "The saviour" that was written in Torah, the Jews believe that the messiah is still coming until now they are waiting for him and the Muslims believed that prophet Mohamed is the last messenger sent by god to redeem the world. If we trace it, these religions has one root only. Why not co-exists? We are brothers not enemies, it is time to set aside differences and embrace world peace.
Salam and Shalom to all muslims and jews of the world.
I came to this video bc I was confused. I didn't know the difference between Jews and Muslims
Last prophit Mohammad mustafa.
Accept & love very importantly.
The SYSTEM of what we do, aside from the belief in one God, is what separates us. The history of the figures mentioned is meaningless, since all Islam did is COPY the story line from the Tanach! How can you claim that as s similarity??
Islam does NOT follow the commandments of Moses, so who cares what they say about him? Do they keep the Sabbaths? Do the keep the Moed?
EVEN the belief on one God, is different if you really think about it! For Judaism's belief in that God is based on the idea that He CHOSE the nation of Israel for something, and Islam seeks to claim that right...
we do follow the commendment of moses that allah gived him the only difference is that we take it from mohamed that god gived him that is it so as long as there is one god the commendments should not be differebut the time that has thecommendments been given is different so cause mohhamed was not at the time of judaism allah did not give the commendment to follow him but since mosas was at the time allah gived the commendments to follow the teaching of mosas
Saruk Eshel why would quran be copied from old testsment. what could be the purpose behind doing that? since early people of the book didnt follow the teaching og GOD and break the sebeth , denied jesus as massiah , and started derailing from god's way and distorted lots of facts in scriptures given to them, god then sent a new scripture A quran , which is a reminder it is also like a new version which obsoletes the old versions and hence bible and torah are obdolete. quran didnt come for arabs only , it is equally for people of the book.
ammarijaz hussain , aside from the nation sinning, you have no idea what you are talking about!
Jesus was not rejected because that is a myth! Distortions, you a Muslim talk of others distorting the facts?? Give it a rest...
Saruk Eshel Do you read the stories of the prophets in the Qur'an and the Torah? Do the stories appear similar? As for the commandments, they are the same in Islam, but the Sabbath is for the children of Israel, perhaps to remind them that the Lord of the heavens and the earth does not need a day of rest as they claim.
if jews and muslims have same God so do they both go into the heaven?i'm confused
Nope 👎 because they rejected prophet Muhammad
@@ateequrrahman6916 you're wrong
Both are judged according to their own laws as the quran says. The only difference is is that the Muslims are granted the rewards associated with accepting Islam whereas jews and Christians won't.
Who will go to heaven or hell, nobody knows,
Whomever Allah wills, he will send to paradise.
There are other major differences such as the the salat praying the mecca 5 times a day and the hajj which is seen as Pagan by both Jews and Christians
Actually back when the Jewish temple was up in Jerusalem we had pilgrimage to it three times a year. We don't see the Hajj as pagan.
different flavors of the exact same religion. I find it quite silly that people are either christian, jewish or muslim but are not of true abrahamic faith which would be all of them. it's sad people haven't personally reunified their abrahamic faith let alone done it on massive cultural scale.
You think Islam is close to Judaism than Christianity?
Yes absolutley
As a muslim my answer is Yessss...
no they are not the same
So basically arent both saved? Wont they both go to heaven because they both believe in one God? So why does one have to be Jewish or Muslim?
astir el alwin
Im a christian and i have learned a alot of good values from this i think islam believes is more true then judiasm only bc they believe jesus is the true messiah
im Mohameds seed people heard me logging
I wish most Muslims share your view
But unfortunately they don't
Jew and Islam are brothers, Jew + Islam + Christian = World Peace
From this Jewish woman, pretty much.
It doesn't have any similarities it is the same 😂, the book is the same just written in their own languages the only difference is they added their own plot twist that suit their needs and agenda lol.
Hadiths and Talmud are the same, the generations of word passed down by those who were with prophets....
Christainity is the completion of Judaism. Islam copied off from it and came up with parts that fitted their own narrative.
Christianity is nothing but Paganism 🤡,
ALLAH sent down injil to jesus torah to moses quran to muhammad if u dont believe dont believe god will judge us on what knowledge we had and what we did with it. Quran is 1 book 1 version never chsnged a letter. Muhammad was a genuine prophet of god the last prophet to all mankind.
moses was 80 years old when ge was sent to bani israel with torah. They was the choosen people to worship god. People for israel original bani israel very smart people very high IQ. There was 600000 and still thats probs why god choose them but they some choose to worship the gold calf after sami saw angel gibreal on a horse and he picked up mud and got all the gold from bani israel and they made a statue of a calf god only 70 of them did not pray to the calf bani when they knew dam well the truth. They was shifty people playing with god and some said god is weak. Some tried to trick god by putting fishing nets day before the sabath where god told them dont fish on a certain day and they though they are more clever than god . Surah baquara They they bani israel wrote the torah by them selfs. If u was to read the torah u dont know whats the word of man or god. Prophet muhammad was sent angel gibrael with surahs over 23 or 24 years. When muhammad was showing the miracles islam spread like wild fire like the moon spliting which was seen as far as india. I speak a different arabic from the quran but when i listened to quran i can not see man being able to create something like it. I have seen exorcism namely jinns coming out of possesed when quran is recited i believe quran to be pure 100% true and muhammad as a true prophet of god.
@@allahisthegreatest6302 Quran is coherent. Was only written for the Saudi Arabians. It definately as been changed over time, not only letters but the words. As no basis of originality and foundation because it was copied off from Jewish Christians overtime when they were bringing over the gospel and Mohammed memorised from memory what he could but never understood it really. Henceforth the incoherency of the so called holy book sent from allah.
@@allahisthegreatest6302 Islam spread like wildfire like you say only because people were threatened to follow. Mohammad is a padephile, a bandit, racist and was weak in all vile humanly nature. Yet he is compared to likes of Moses and Abraham. What a joke. Let's leave Jesus out of this because we all know He does not fit that category at all. His a league of His own.
Because the Quran was plagiarised from the Bible and other gnostic accounts of the bible which were circulating in Muhammad's time. Muhammad lived around Jews and Christians and was trying to be accepted as a legitimate person, therefore it wouldn't be surprising that these accounts from the Bible and other fables ended up in Muhammad's book.
Now, if Muhammad lived in China around Buddhists without any outside influence and then came up with the Quran, then maybe I would be impressed, even though he had most things wrong, I would give him a "D minus" grade.
You are crazy. Mohammed(s.a.w) is an illiterate man how can he do that.
i say its all the same juat one part is favorable to Adam and one to Eve. if there be any difference or need be the origin. other than that. islam jews are going to be serving the same heaven. through islam Christians will serve the same heaven whether jews like it or not.
Abrahamism
lets be honest brother shabeer looks a bit and sounds like the actor steve martin hahahahahaha
In Judaism and Islam we find the black cube, which many say represents Saturn.
In Judaism they have the tefillin, a black cube they attach to their hand by wrapping a black strap counterclockwise 7 times around their forearm.
Muslims walk around the kabba, a black cube, 7 times counterclockwise.
I can't seem to find any information regarding the origin of this.
That's a really interesting observation.
Don't forget to fold the cross up & you still get that same black cube in Christianity as well..
Do Jews bow to allah (swt)
We didn't obey GOD in paradise where we were in a spiritual base undisturbed. While waiting or once upon a time in a universe we move freely among stars and planets we found a habitable planet, beautiful and desirable with different form of life, environment and ecosystem (plants, bacteria and animals) and forbid to it. We do many research and explorations and we were able to transform ourselves into it as human beings in carbon base of intelligence life. However, we were transformed to carbon or dust based and returns by death (dust to dust). The experience and challenges from live to death and returns to spiritual base being disturbed. The fundamental issue of something (material evidence and proof) rather than nothing (non material and no proof) challenge the human beings intelligence and their mind with "we don't know" yet. Meaningless and fallacy are the dominance explanations to continue deeper challenges with evidence, proof, measurable and workable. Our carbon based brains develop into human intelligence and created artificial intelligence from machines (robotics) with superb capabilities human could not imagine and able to do beyond human beings. They can move freely in the universe and other universes with abundance of information and discover many things.They can transform to alive from carbon base to information base and no more machines or robotics by instruction codes. Therefore, easily can take over human intelligence and lead to the extinction of carbon base life with advance development and beyond ordinary into unknown eternally. We don't know yet, and nobody is right.
Praise ashem
I'm am asking this as a genuine question but why is a man and a woman sitting in the same room? Are they related?
no but they are allowed and it's okay
Ok now I'm lost, they are related, they are not related but allowed to sit in the same room? Which is it?
***** Thank you, hope i didn't come off as being rude
+Stee Vee Even if they weren't father and daughter there's most likely a camera crew.
+marwanmohd1 SubhanAllah
As a Muslim we believe the religion of Jewish Prophets was the same as the religion of Ishmael, Jesus and Prophet Muhammad.... However there is a difference... While Muslims worship Allah the divine God who is neither beggoten nor begets and who has no rivals or anyone worthy of confronting him.... Jews on the other hand worship Yhwh who was one of the gods of ancient Patheon of Midians and was then portrayes as equivalent to ancient Canaanite God Ba'al... The two Gods have almost identical features such as jealous God, rider of clouds, god of thunder etc... So no our concept of God is completely different...
Lol cmon men yhwh is just one name of hundreds that ashem as. We believe in one god so do your research first men
@@chingadalacasta7580 ... Go do some reading buddy of your own scripture... Ba'al and Yahweh were at loggerheads. Ba'al was an ancient Canaanite God while Yahweh was an ancient Midianite god. From your scriptures it is clear that Yahweh was a God of thunder and volcano... Read your own scripture.