Mystery of Subash Chandra Bose's Death
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 06. 2024
- Get 30% OFF on Kukufm’s 1st Month subscription!!
Only at Rs 69 instead of Rs 99 🤑 🤑
Use my code MOHAK30
Click the link in description ⬇-
kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/bw9n/wwmx
📃Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1j...
📚📖Top five book recommendations:
amzn.to/3QH0MRB
amzn.to/3ISyKjX
amzn.to/3Xj3hvO
amzn.to/3Xf4Smt
amzn.to/3WjLGT4
📸💡Filming gear:
amzn.to/3ZDE295
amzn.to/3ZD5Me2
amzn.to/3H9Siza
amzn.to/3iIN1oU
amzn.to/3XB4zCc
amzn.to/3XBUOU8
amzn.to/3QKvNUv
******
🔍✍️Research:
Mohit Priyadarshi: / mohitprior
✂️🎛️Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
CharanTej: / mograph.charantej
Channel Manager :
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
🎨Thumbnail :
Aanchal verma: / aanchal_creates
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
Liked the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: bit.ly/3A7bUx7
******
🗳Support on Patreon: / sochyoutube
👾Discord: / discord
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's death has been one of the biggest mysteries of modern India. Nearly eight decades after his disappearance in 1945, people still don't agree about what happened to him. While initial government investigations concluded that Netaji died in a plane crash in present-day Taipei, many saw loopholes in this account and provided alternate theories. One theory states that he somehow managed to make his way to the Soviet Union, where he was captured by Joseph Stalin's forces. Yet another theory says that Netaji didn't die until much later and lived as an ascetic in various parts of India. What really happened and how do we solve this mystery? We examine the evidence available for each theory and reach our own conclusion.
******
Playlists
🇮🇳Indian Society: • Hijab: Ban Right or Wr...
🗺Geopolitics and Foreign Affairs: • Will China Invade Taiwan?
🧍🏽♀️Issues of a Young Indian: • Are Indian Girls Bad a...
💰Economy: • How Kerala Changed its...
🗳Indian Politics: • UP Elections: Why Are ...
🇮🇳 Discoveries of India: • How Goa Joined India
📈Money, Stocks, and Crypto: • Why Indian Youth is NO...
******
Creative commons:
Unsplash
Flaticon
Freepik
Videvo
******
Markers
00:00 Intro
03:42 The Plane Crash
10:25 The Shahnawaz Commission
15:58 The Russia Prison Theory
16:51 The Justice Khosla Commission
19:32 The Gumnaami Baba Theory
25:33 Conclusion
Get 30% OFF on Kukufm’s 1st Month subscription!!
Only at Rs 69 instead of Rs 99 🤑 🤑
Use my code MOHAK30
Click the link in description ⬇-
kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/bw9n/wwmx
Ok
Okay smjh gya
Okay smjh gya
🤑🤑😂😂
You didn't explained briefly not about Books??
"Freedom is not given, it is taken"
---- Subhash Chandra Bose
Yes he did nothing he was just enjoying in big houses and now their family is ruling India and control it's resources right ??
You fool WhatsApp kid both Bose and Gandhi was national hero they both have different views but end result was independence.
Study kid study.
Only thing I can agree is congress has misused this independence to spread their propaganda but Gandhi was not there at that time .
@@studentapoorv2616 bro Iam not a Gandhi hater, I myself admire him.He had a lot of contribution like non cooperation movement, Satyagraha Movement, Civil Disobedience Movement, Quit India Movement(1942). But ignoring the contribution of Azad Hind Fauj and Subhash Chandra Bose is also wrong.
@@studentapoorv2616 and I agree with your viewpoint that all Freedom Fighters had their contribution in India's Independence, Though they have different ideologies.
@@GurmeetSingh-wc7gi sorry brother I think you misunderstood that I was not replying to you 😅
@@harshrathod691 lockdown kid 😂
It doesn't matter if Bose dies in plane crash or not, but he still continues to live in our heart.
Bose is a hero of our nation and we respect him even after that many years.
Dil me rakh kar liya ukhad liya
Agr alive hote to acha hota
Absolutely, but don't believe in stupid conspiracy theories
@@limiteddestration Alive hote to bhi 2023 tak zinda naa hote..
Keeping in your heart is nothing great you are doing ....this man should be in our history book ...can you even imagine he was dead or not in 1945 is still mystery in 2023 ...keeping in your heart is not only the way ...so stop this .
He just said Netaji lives in his heart, why are you commenting negative even on this
Anuj Dhar is alive
he has written 2500+ pages on Netaji
Infact he has given the framework of the three theories that you discussed.
Since he is alive. Why dont you invite him?
Exactly...I am with you
As Anuj Dhar says,
This narrative is not sellable, in the current situation both left and right wing will not favour this.
It will create huge confusion and commotion in the country. 75 years of lies, can they(our innocent & emotional citizens) digest this?
On Mohak Mangal, i don't know what kind of person he is , i did watch many of his videos and came to know many new things and history that i didn't knew. But today you cannot blindly trust anyone. So called celebrities are hiding behind the masks.
I'm from Ayodhya and gumnami baba theory is very popular here and many people believe in it. Legends tell us that Gumnami baba was very fluent in English,German, Russian,Awadhi,Bengali, Hindi. A homeopathy doctor ( I've met him) in Ayodhya was his doctor. Even I don't want to believe in this theory but I'm not convinced that some random baba ji who is living in small room on the banks of Sarayu river in a small town like Ayodhya have so much knowledge about politics and languages.
May he find his peace in Sri Vishnu's Lotus feet. Om Shanti 🙏
So that automatically means that he was Netaji?
Everyone should watch the GUMNAMI Movie
For us Bengalis Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is the father of nation. I am grateful that i grew up studying about him. ❤✊
But it was Netaji himself who gave the title of 'Father Of Nation ' to Bapu.
@@MrNegi-ch6jgExactly
@@MrNegi-ch6jg Indeed, that doesn't mean the title can't be shared by Netaji. After all he was equally responsible for our independence if not more.
He is hero to all Indian . I wrote is because hero never die
No one can be the father of our nation as we have concept of mother nation.. Even Shree Ram was a son of this mother nation....
Every freedom fighter and revolutionary is son of this nation..
Due to heroes like Sri Subhash Chandra Bose the idea of India is still alive 💙
sadly this idea is in danger due to Anti India traitor Modi 😔😔
@@saintpixie2765 Absolutely nonsense, don't be extreme in any case, If there are some problems with BJP government so there are some good things too such as Foreign Policy, Infrastructure, Economic balance at World Economic Crisis, Long term goals.
@@saintpixie2765 This polarizing thought process has been the root cause of the current divide. Criticizing the government is totally fine but blind hatred discredits the thought process of a large chunk of voters who democratically elected Modi into power. Respect the sentiments of people and engage in sensible conversations otherwise there is no end to it.
@@SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi Let the current PM also respect the sentiments of people who previously democratically elected prime ministers in this country before that courtesy is extended to him.
@@saintpixie2765 LOL no anti India traitor Congress and Rahul gandhi
Doesn't matter where he died
He will always be in my ❤️
Your investigation was incomplete, please study more on gumnami baba theory.
Justice Mukherjee said on camera about it,
In report he mentioned due to not finding clinching evidence he cannot accept gumnami baba was Netaji.
Why gumnami baba remainings are still kept in museum in UP?
Who was he if not netaji?
Why so many people were mad thinking he was Netaji?
Letters found there of UP CM, Golwalkar, INA veterans, netaji close friends etc what about that?
Gumnami baba had so many items that netaji used... International handwriting expert claims both the writings belong to the same and identical person
you are absolutely correct.
@@anirban22maji even indian handwriting experts concluded that they were of same person but they all were private not government experts.
My Respect to Neta Subhas Chadra Bose : ♾️
Happy to see Netaji is no longer a hero of Bengal👍🏻whole India is accepting him now🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@Horizon429 Let's say if he tried doing something like that would he be abled to succeed. definitely not, just assuming shit is not a wise thing
@@Horizon429what's bad in that
@@Horizon429 still better than what your chacha had done
Mohandas Gandhi ☕👴🏻
For us (Bengalis), Netaji is an emotion. Every Bengalis respect him like their father from the childhood.
Our culture, history and even Indipendence can't be complete without him. He is one of the greatest freedom fighter of all time.
No matter, where he is right now!
"He was alive, still alive
and will live in our Hearts"
আমাদের প্রিয় নেতাজী,
আপনি আমাদের হৃদয়ে আজীবন বাস করবেন ❤❤❤
@@kuunalsm Yes, He is the National Hero for all Indians.
*পশ্চিমা বাঙালি. Bangladeshis are original Bangalis or just বাঙালি.
Subhash Chandra bose was from odisha
@@sudhanshu533 cry harder 😂😂
@@Shafi9234 oh really 😂😂 in which basis? U just forget the culture and claiming urself Bengali? Bose, das, Mukherjee this is Bengali surname not Khan, ali, muhammad 😂😂
I don’t know whether Netaji died or lived after 1945
But one thing will remain forever is his thoughts which cannot be destroyed
“Tum mujhe khoon do, me tumhe azadi dilaunga”
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
But we all should also be curious to know how he died. He was the no 1 reason British left India.
Not only for Bengali he is hero but for whole india
❤ From Himachal
You missed a few things about the gumnami baba theory-
1. Handwriting analysis of gumnami baba's letters
2. All documents related to netaji haven't been made public
3. Habibur rehman's testimony to mi6 where he changed his statement many times
4. All the people quoted in Anuj dhar's book Conundrum, including senior politicians of that time, a governor, netaji's sister, about senior police officers visiting him regularly
5. Why not sanctions? To the Allied powers Netaji was a war criminal, they would ask him to be extradited and Indians would massively protest
6. How the cia and the mi6 were searching for netaji even in the 1960s
Video suggestion- how IB was reporting to mi6 till 1970s, how the chiefs of Indian forces were British till late 60s, about Nehru's letters to the queen of England swearing loyalty to her in 1948.
Most of your points can easily be countered but I don't have the energy to write such a long para so yeah
Agree. @uttaran
@@yash1756 If they can be easily countered so come on, lets debate on this topic. Lets see who is a “contrarian” and who is a debater. Don’t be Skeptic
@@yash1756 I would like to hear your counter arguments ..
Oh ho ho ho more conspiracy theories, love it. Neuron activation
I wish to draw your attention to the fact that Anuj Dhar has provided several pieces of evidence in his research on the Gumnami Baba case that were not discussed in the video. One of the key proofs that he has presented is that when Gumnami Baba died in his house, several suitcases were discovered containing various items that shed light on his identity.
Among the items found were inland letters and telegrams written by and received from Dr. Pabitra Mohan Roy, a senior official of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's Indian National Army's intelligence wing. The inspection of these letters is ongoing, but they are believed to be of significant importance.
Additionally, binoculars used by the Azad Hind Fauj, a newspaper cutout that mentions Bose was still alive in 1978, and a hand-made map of Bangladesh were also discovered in the suitcases. Moreover, a handwriting expert was hired by Anuj Dhar, who compared the handwriting of Gumnami Baba's letters with that of Netaji's, and concluded that they were written by the same person.
Considering these vital pieces of evidence, I would suggest that you review Anuj Dhar's research in more detail to ensure that your analysis is comprehensive and accurate. It will also help to provide your audience with a complete understanding of the matter.
I will draw ur attention on a small point that makes it clear on everything actually two
1) If Bose was alive u actually think he wouldn't be active in the circuit like u do realise by saying he was alive and not active u r calling him a coward...and no there wouldn't be any sanctions on India as sanctions r levied on very different circumstances
2. Bose Daughter has always been eager to get her father's ashes and she is also ready for a DNA test and has always maintained that she never met her father again , u actually believe that a father would simply disappear from his only daughters life but oh well he will definitely keep meeting random people well in 70s when literally no one cared if Bose was alive or not in west
This sort of people will never do that because this channel very cleverly make you believe that they are unbiased or not ideologically inclined. But, you have to notice the patterns in his recent videos. Obviously, they will term person like Mr Anuj Dhar as a conspiracy theorist vicariously because that's what the left does everywhere.
A guy in above comments was saying, most of those evidences could be easily countered, but denies to counter any, i mean dudee c'mon those evidences literally obliterate any other theory, guess jio users are just as stupid as Bufffons
@@ishanharshvardhan6687 my guy talking about emotions, what an amazing argument about his, daughter, where you going with that smartass, mannn
@@ishanharshvardhan6687 handwriting is literally the same, had photos of Subhas Chandra Bose's Family, had uniform of INA, seriously you're saying someone would keep them as momentos or souvenirs
Go, read and study Book by Mr. Anuj Dhar sir, Conundrum.
I'm surprised that you didn't mention the photos, letters and personal items of netaji's family found in the house where Gumnanmi Baba used to live.
And, these things are submitted in the Allahabad High Court for years, still the judgement isn't given
It isn't about whether he was alive or not, it is about acknowledgement of his sacrifices, that must be taught in our schools.
Also, about him being alive and not coming out in public was because Nehruji signed a pact to hand him over to the allied forces as a War Criminal.
I strongly support your statement.,.
@@namnitweloveyou5550 Thanks Bro:)
@@atharwdwivedi3385 anuj dhar is not investigater 😂😂 I am sure that plane crash happen and netaji was dead gumnami baba was just show like he was real Netaji ..
And what about Netaji's Niece? According to you, she lied as well, right?
@@atharwdwivedi3385 some family members are support that netaji death and some accpt it he was dead .. it's just rumors . This foolish theory invented because his brother in 1950 at report submission time says this report is not true.. and Mukherjee commission without any proof says plane crash not happeb
Being a Bengali, there are many ifs and buts, but now in the end it does not matter any way. Because scientifically he is dead now as he was born in 1897. But the most important thing is that his vision of making India a super power cant be denied. So making our India prosperous and great again will be the ultimate commemoration of Netaji and that's how we can give him a respectful "shhradh".
" Being a Bengali"... what do you want to convey? Say being an Indian....
@@sukchak123They mean to say that they are from West Bengal, a state IN India.
As a odia and from Cuttack city where netaji was also from,is really mind-blowing and proud moment to being educate about this iconic mystery of our history...
Jay netaji subhash chandra bose ki jay🕉️
I always go to school by his birth place
He was not from cuttack 😂😂😂
@@boombs7232 bahaha, where else do u think he was born. Go on, lets hear ur theories
@@boombs7232lol u don’t even know where he was born
Speaks a poor tribal Ude....Netaji was is and will always a Bengali....when he was born at that Time ur so called poor state oriiisa whom none knows in India even now was a part of our Greater Bengal....so just don't blabber with false pride
For us Jspanese, the introduction of Indian curry was made by Bose. He taught his Japanese friends how to cook it. There, the now famous Japanese curry was invented.
Bruh, I think you’re missing the point
But there few things which I would like to point out.
1. There is a "samadhi" named Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose at "Guptar Ghat" in Ayodhya.
2. As per locals, Army did all the last rites, at night ( which is unusual in Hinduism). And effort was put in to make sure the privacy of this procedurs as roads were blocked with army trucks on both sides. Also after the rituals they made sure to collect every bit of remains.
3. Every year during Navratri, there used to be a celebration at his place and bengali people would visit him every now and then. They also bought him bengali newspaper.
4. He didn't come out and used to talk from behind a curtain, spoke english mostly and used to smoke a very expensive cigrette/cigar. Also he always had new currency notes, always. He read an english newspaper which was not readily available he used to get it next day.
5. After his death, Army took all of his belongings.
There is an interview on Lallantop (in hindi) of the owners of the house he used to live.
Please note, I'm not saying that Gumnami baba was SCB or not. I just told you what I know being a local.
I am from Ayodhya
For all the Indians Netaji's body was died but his soul is under our soul ❤Jay Azad Hind 🇮🇳
India's independence is incomplete without Netaji. A big salute to him and his legacy of bravery.
No not incomplete
It's impossible ❤
But you did not debunk the handwriting evidence, multiple letters of Gumnami Baba talking about that times current geopolitical stuff is 100% match with Subhash Chandra Bose..
It doesn't matter if Bose dies in plane crash or not, but he still continues to live in our heart.
It does matter if you know the politics behind the death of Netaji.
Exactly,such nonsense people are commenting @@digitalbackup2169
We celebrate his birthday not his death day..... Because legends never die.❤
Don't not make any sense
Sir, in the documentary Enemies of empire the doctor himself says that he was not aware of who that person was until he declared him dead, after the person's death the doctor was told that he was Bose.
And ultimately everyone will accept that he died in the plane crash but the doubt will always exist because we were never provided with solid evidences
Living with a feeling that once there was a person who went all over for forming an army for India in those times, roaming in disguise and then we don't know what was the situation of that person in his last days is just heartbreaking
And as per the goverment official they have not release all the files till now so still its not proven that netaji died in plane crash
Even an official from PMO office told they couldn't classify all the files or else there will be riots in all over India. Its make me curious what is there in those files that even full of majority and pro right wing based party are scared to do so!
It's clear that the diplomatic relations between Russia and USA will be affected if Netaji's death comes forward! But being a bengali I know how people deeply feel the contribution of our greatest leader Netaji. Mother India must be feel proud that the land got a fearless son!
If you repeat a lie often enough it becomes the truth.
Meanwhile NCERT gave all credit for Independence to only "Gandhi ji and Congress"
NCERT should also add contribution of such gems in details too.....
BTW good Video Mohak Bhaiya ❤️
Gandi ji 🤡
Netaji was dictator,
Maybe a communist and very hardcore
@@Majid_E4chess but all the chapters revolve around them . Only small paragraphs of 3 or 4 lines are written about other national heroes
People Forgotten also Lokmanya Tilak
No CBSE,only ICSE😌
Our real hero never dies 😌🤞🏻❤️
তিনি অমর হয়ে রয়েগেছেন আমাদের মাঝে।। আমাদের জন্য।।
মৃত্যু মানুষের হয় মহা মানবের নয়😌
नेता जी अमर रहें
जय हिन्द जय भारत
@@Yadavendra.
When I was a kid, my grandfather used to tell me that Netaji Bode lived in one of the villages in Nagaland for some time after the plane crash.
Before making Any comments on Anuj Dhar pls go and discuss with their findings unhone kitna research karke yeh sab baat boli hai
People like Subhash Chandra Bose, Sardar Vallabhai Patel, Bhagat Singh, APJ Abdul Kalam should be on our currency notes
Right👍
Comeout from this kidish dream
@@user-qh8zx5my5j its not kidish its logical
@@user-qh8zx5my5j Mahatma Gandhi was never on the currency note from the beginning. He was put on the currency in 1980s. You're the clown here if you think more people can't be added on the currency in 2023 & onwards. Nowhere it's written only one person will have monopoly on the currency notes. Bookmark this video & come back to cry when this will actually happen someday
@@rupam8432 do you think world will accept us by changing the picture on note
We bangladeshi love Netaji So much , my grandfather Used to Explain His Legacy,
We have built many Colleges, Schools, Hospitals, Universitys in Netajis name in Bangladesh, We also believe He is alive
Leja apna West Bengal ko
@@weingkham4033 West Bengal has true Bangla culture. Unlike BD where they corrupted it with Arabic and Persian.
For Maharashtrians, if there is anyone after King Shivaji then it is Netaji 🚩
Chhatrpati shivaji maharaj bolo bahi
Chhatrpati shivaji maharaj bolo
"তোমরা আমাকে রক্ত দাও আমি তোমাদের স্বাধীনতা দেবো"
Goosebumps ❤️❤️❤️
Proud to be Bengali 🖤
Proud to be Indian 🖤
As an Indian we can proudly say that there was, is & will be only one neta for us & no one can take his place🙏
Anuj dhar’s investigation was also hard, just like all the previous investigations. So netaji was alive as baba
He was definitely the most deserving leader to become the 1st Prime Minister of India 😔😔
During emergency tym my grandfather also arrested as he was a leader of "Amra bangali" Sanghatan ,a bengali nationalist party . He also shared a story with me that in 1980 era he saw one day suddenly 6 person team came in his gurus ( Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar founder of Ananda Marga) house, in Lake gardens Kolkata. They stayed for 1 hour and leave. Later he came to know from a monk , that Ex INA Leaders they were. After few month ,Guruji suddenly told among devotees that Netaji Still Alive but he never will come in front of society bcz he stepped towards a spiritual journey and leds to a yogi purush like Rishi Aravind.
A lot of Conspiracy theories still now floating and majority of bengali firmly believe Netaji didn't died of plane crash
“Silence is a lie that screams at the light.” ― Shannon Alder.
Thank you for the nice, comprehensive research and accumulating all of 'em in a single video.
Loved the content. 💖
One of the Most Truest Leader was Our Subhash Chandra Bose...i respect him ❤
Proud to be a Indian bengali🇮🇳🇮🇳whenever I go to Netaji's house in Elgin Road Kolkata I get goosebumps 🔥🔥
Netaji was born in cuttack odisha(bengal province as per that time)...though he was a bengali
😂❤❤❤❤❤❤😅😮😢🎉😂❤
Gods never die ,I being a Bengali as well as an Indian consider Subhas Chandra Bose god ,and gods don't have any death day ...vande matram 🇮🇳
After watching this again and again it gives goosebump but also a little bit tears.. which can't be describe by text
Proud to say that I live in his birth place, Odisha
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose indeed the father of our nation..who truly dedicated himself to serve the nation... unfortunately he has to sacrifice his life due to conspiracy and betrayed by his own nation people for the hunger of their Power...but he will always remain in our ❤️ heart...jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Calling him father of our nation is little far don't u think....I mean sure he did struggle a lot but results....hmm
@@ishanharshvardhan6687
WhatsApp waale h yeh log.Ignore kro.
@@ishanharshvardhan6687 Bhai ne history nahi padhi shayad apne desh ki
@@ishanharshvardhan6687he would have suceeded if japan and hitler won the ww2 but then world would have been very different if that happened
Netaji,we salute you.
I read classic life story of Netaji in 'महानायक' by विश्वास पाटील. It is interesting if anyone enjoy reading as a novel. I am truly inspired by grand life of Netaji 🙌
Now do read "The Conundrum" the life after death of netaji by Anuj Dhar. With all facts and proofs.
I met Anuj Dhar today in IIT mamdi, he delivered a talk on Netaji's Death.
He has give many proofs to support his theory of Gumnami Baba, anyone can look after his investigation and form a opinion.
Hey Mohak, I love your content and the way you go in deep into each and every topic! Just to answer the question of "Why The Allied forces would have imposed sanctions on India after knowing Netaji is alive and well in India?", Since Netaji had association with the Axis powers they probably would have argued that he too was a proponent of Nazi ideology (as bizarre as this may sound) and would have outrightly repudiated the atrocities of Churchill and the British if we tried to argue against their sanctions
সুভাষকে বোঝা শক্ত , সুভাষকে বোঝা শক্ত , স্বাধীনতা আনে রক্ত ❤❤❤ lots of love to netaji ❤❤
Had Netaji been our first leader after independence, India would have been better off than it is under these "bhure sahabs" of INC and BJP who are all rhetoric and no work. A lot of thirst positionist leaders like him don't get enough credit for their work. All hail the Third Position ✊ Jai Hind! 🇮🇳
As long as you remember that Netaji had been a staunch communist
Not quite, apparently he had more socialist views than Nehru and even believed India needed dictatorship for the first few years which is obviously a bad idea.
@@shreyanshyadav8655 I understand your pain as you people refer netaji to Mulayam Singh Yadav...so this kind of argument is quite obvious from you
@@shreyanshyadav8655 He thought this because he knew that there would be mess just after independence....and you see it was occurred.......the refugee problem, the food crisis, the lack of industrialization in the starting years of India....everything was under a mess....and there was always a high probability that India may go to under a military rule......and so he wanted that for first few years there was dictatorship and then gradually democracy should proliferate .....This idea even I think first came to his mind to see the early years of development of the then soviet union from 1920s to1930s / 1935...rapid industrialization......
lol keep dreaming he was communist/socialist. Enough said
Subhash Chandra Bose would definitely change India if he would have been the prime minister....he is tge true Father of nation ❤
As indians if you are follower of nethaji we should understand one thing. We know ability of nethaji who continuously keeps misguiding British and come up with new surprise everytime. If he was alive he would have sure come in front of indian ppl and address them with surprise which is no big deal to nethaji... nethaji is immortal in the hearts of every indian. He has no death...
Do the DNA analysis of the ash in Renkoji. Ask the Russian government to give a statement that they don't have anything to do with Netaji's death. These will ensure that we have satisfactory proof which can be final. PM Vajpayee went to the temple but didn't get the ash back. It is said that Russian couldn't find any files they never said they don't have.
Gov did it and declared that that was Netaji's ash but didn't hand over the electromagnetic blueprint of DNA. Only gov knows why. On the other side Anuj Dhar did the DNA fingerprinting of that ash by a non gov organisation from outside of India and they said that's not Netaji's ash but ash one of the other persons boarding on that plane.
@SK S yea first time I dont satisfied with his research. He also ignored bose family's allegations over nehru as nehru engaged many spies for several years after Netaji's death was declared to monitor bose family's movement. And we all know why.
The Real Hero Behind India's Independence
Very important video for our coming generations....
So much detailed analysis...
Must watch for every Indian....
Jai Hind Jai Bharat
In our Uttar Pradesh peoples believes that Netaji hide himself as Jai Gurudev Baba who died in 2012 at the age of 116 years.
Srijit Mukharji's film 'Gumnaami Baba' is really a well made film. Even though it created few controversies. But the film is totally worth watching.
Hmm
A very well researched video as always. Bose is the true reason behind independence. Even then British PM Atlee admitted that Gandhi did not cause as much damage, but it eas Nejati who inspired the British Indian soldiers to be disobedient, which shook the British government. He should have become the first PM of India.
One man, alone convinced people like Hitler and Tojo to give him an army. He was a legend.
I've watched the podcast of Anuj Dhar where he was talking about Bose..and he was very much into Gumnami Baba theory and he's got points to support..and in that podcast all he was trying to say was that there should be a proper investigation DNA samples should be collected and check with the remains of what is to be known as the ashes of Subhas Bose at Renkozi temple..and about the Gumnami Baba theory..proper evidences with proof should be research upon..
M soo happy to see the comments that our generation is getting to know ablut who was the actual freedom fighter. I really hope that our currency notes will also be changed to bose in the future netaji was the real hero for our generation ❤
As a Bengali , we will always miss Netaji and love him ❤❤
As an indian
By every rights, if Netaji was present during Independence he never would've let the Partition [🇧🇩/🇵🇰/🇳🇵/🇮🇳] occur and we may have achieved somewhat *Akhand Bharat* !
Nepal was not part of British India
@@edwardkenway7139 Nepal was part of the gorkha empire for around 200-300 years before the British rule , the Empire was an empire emerged in uttarakhand
@@Nediooo yess one who startrd kingdom of nepal or gorkha empire he his from : Uttar Pradesh or uttarakhand states of Bharath or india - 😁🙏🇮🇳👍🚩
Nepal wasn’t part of Bharat
Now why wld u include Nepal
The legend and the great leader netaji subhash chandra bose 🙏🙏lots of respect towards to him ❤️
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
There are still some few old people who saw Netaji in a remote village located 60km away from the capital of Nagaland. Not sure how long he stayed there but the story came to light through his photo on the frying oil.
He has an extraordinary respect especially in the heart of us Bengal people. A true visionary leader, Mr Bose was and will always be a true hero for us❤️ .
Please don't divide
He is in the heart of every Indian(✿ ♥‿♥)
Netaji SC Bose =True Indian hero 🇮🇳❤️. Good video.. very informative and debunking myths and mysteries..
In the end of video you brought up death of Sushant Singh Rajput.. I live in Mumbai and have family who are friends with IPS/CBI officers involved in his investigation.. and they belive it was a political murder and not a suicide.. Thanks to Indian media who made a circus of his death and made the topic irrelevant.. May he get Justice. RIP. 💐🙏
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose inspire generations for his contribution in achieving complete independence and is remembered for his unwavering courage , leadership qualities, international diplomacy and his resilience shows the importance of perseverance in the face of adversity
🇮🇳🇮🇳
WOW! the best detailed analysis of the topic right here...kudos and thanks to you Mohak. This topic is finally cleared for me, no more conspiracy theories and possible timelines.
It is the worst analysis, in the topic according to you and the mohak we should all believe the one sided conspire analysis theory which not even got investigated
Netaji is the lion and pride of Bengal. To us Bengalis, he is the real Father of the Nation. His contribution to make our country free stands unparalleled. Jai Hind!
*tiger
Netaji is the lion and pride for entire India. The real father of the nation indeed. Great respect for Bengal for giving just the fiercest of revolutionaries.
Netaji born from odisha ki Cuttack not Bengal
@rkanhathehunted9903 I think OP meant he was a bengali by culture which is true. Though born in Cuttack he was not odia.
@@Rama-fi3cl, NETAJI is not a Bengali Revolutionery neither an Odia Revolutionery . NETAJI IS AN INDIAN REVOLUTIONERY , who is respected by Freedom loving people of the World !!!
Very versely explained...
Informative.
Thanks!
Amra Achi Netaji, tumi eguye jao
But acc. to Anuj dhar gumnami baba ki handwriting match ho gayi thi Subhash Chandra Bose ki handwriting ke sath and Kolkata high court mai govt. lawyer ne khud admit Kiya hai ki plane crash nahi hua tha
Aur ek sawal aur ki aapne maximum 6 months research Kara hoga Bose topic par aur Anuj dhar pichle 10 -15 years se research kar rahe hai tau kiski baat ko jyada importance di jaye aur wo apni har baat ko proof ke sath bhi bolte hai..
No hate to anyone but i want to know what is truth .😐
Anuj Dhar makes solid case
Tum muje khoon do , mai tumhe Azaadi dunga !
Sir Netaji's pivotal contribution will be remembered forever . Jai hind!
I agree with you my friend 💪
Underrated comment, needs likes and support
Netaji, we are forever indebted to you 🙏🏻❤️ Royal Indian Navy Mutiny of 1946, should be given a well deserved place in our History Textbooks.
I urge people to read The Forgotten Army and 1946 Royal Indian Navy Mutiny: Last War of Independence, for knowing more about INA and the Royal Indian Navy Mutiny 🙌🏼
It's already there in NCERT. Go and read again 😌😌
@@harshit3980 1&1/2 page ? Is that enough for you ?
@@thedarkknightwillrise23 NCERT are for giving basic understanding of the events.Don't expect Phd level of knowledge in them.
And history itself is very vast . That's why everything is in breif
If you are so interested in history, there are plenty of books available, and no one is stopping you to read them.
@@harshit3980 12th ki NCERT is for Basic Understanding ? Haha ! And what about History Textbooks recommended for preparation of prestigious examinations like Civil Services ? 3 &1/2 pages in Bipin Chandra and 1& 1/2 pages in spectrum ! And no one stopped me from reading other history books that's why I read the books that i recommend and asked everyone to read them.
@@thedarkknightwillrise23 😆😆you are kid. You can't clear Upsc just by reading Ncert.
Ncert is recommended so that the aspirants can have a basic knowledge of the subject, because Ncert is written in simple language and builts a base.
You have to read the standard books after ncert😌😌
I am preparing for UPSC so I know 😁
And yes, all school books gives a basic knowledge of every subject. After school, the student choose the subject in which he wants to make career and then read only that subject, to become expert in that.
School books will not make you expert😄 they will give you basic knowledge only
As an odia we love netaji❤ and we miss him
In 2023, after 78 years of his disappearance, it doesn't matter whether Netaji died due to the plane crash in Taiwan or later under captivity in the USSR or disguised as Gumnami Baba in India. We should move on and stop discussion on this topic as the more we discuss the more the conspiracy theorists thrive. Let's close this topic. Netaji will always remain immortal for us as a great freedom fighter 🙏🏼
What you said is right but what if it has some base?? Amaku seita taa janiba darkar naa... gote mahan byakti kn mrutyu re jadi kichi daga achi hele seita clear haba zaruri..
It not about any conspiracy theory! he was the leader of independent India, if it not for him than we would have been a dominion country of The so called great Britain. The country he loved so much, what this country has done for him till now???
Of all the theories surrounding Netaji's death. You forgot the Tashkent man theory. A man with facial features similar to Bose had been seen in a photograph taken during the signing of the Tashkent treaty. Almost all the officials and individuals in that photo including minor Soviet servants had been identified too, except for that man. What perplexes me more, is the death of PM Lal Bahadur Shastri, which occurred just after the signing of the security pact. The Government of India refused to launch an official investigation into his death, his cadaver had appeared to be bluish-black on the day of his death, which many suspected to be a result of poisoning, even the Soviet Republic which hosted him had offered to start an investigation, but the Congress party-led government refused once again.
Yes.! I was waiting for the Lal Bahadur Shashtri angle!
Can u plz tell me about this incident regarding Lal Bahadur Shastri’s death?
@@vansh-malik type the Tashkent man. You'll find everything ya need to know.
@@sks5972 I agree, as always there was an attempt to silently push a narrative through this video.
Even in 2015 Shastri's son told them that after signing the agreement in Tashkent, he talked to them on call on that night nd told him that he's going to reveal something big about the Bose nd eventually he had been killed that night. No postmortem had been done after the death of PM, everything becomes very clear
As a bengali I respect and am so proud so netaji , I grew up respecting him and his amazing mindset of a leader.
नेता जी अमर है नेता जी हमारे दिल में आज भी ज़िंदा है और ज़िंदा ❤🙏
We respect Netaji more than other leaders of that Time... He tried his best to gain independence from Britishers but unfortunately he died in a plane crash.... 2 out of 3 major Investigations agree on his death in a plane crash. Therefore what majority says.. we have to agree on that .
We have to agree where evidence is there and evidence points to bhagwanji theory.
In a jungle Tiger stay along and rest of others stay together but still tiger stays in top of the food chain.
There was a time when catholic churches beleive that earth is the center of our universe and rest of others solar bodies rotating our planet, only Galilo point out the actual fact but catholic churche put him in a jail.
Lies have to stay together but truth doesn't have to.
Nope
Search Gumnami baba
However, the most recent and comprehensive one does not agree.
Lal bahadur shastri is also one such gem we lost ..
Thanks to bringing all information in this one video....
Log unhe bahat pasand karte hain isiliye unki mat asani nehi le pate log dil me hai subash chander bos
you missed a very important part that government keep tracks every post letter personally by pm of india after the netaji's death because government is still worried about bose.
Ha bhai tu hi shi h
Chl khush reh👍👌
What a life he could live. What a LIFE he chose❤️🔥. It's people like him who got us rid of the British . Netaji in our hearts always 🙏
Gud Job Broooo.. keep coming up with more interesting videos like this.. 😀👍
i can't Believe Bose is died He is alive in our heart ❤ True Freedom Fighter ❤ Jai Hind Jai Bharat Jai Shree Ram
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, Rabindranath Tagore and Swami Vivekananda are the some of the greatest Indians of all time. Proud to be a bengali and obviously as an Indian❤
In Bengali "NETAJI" means leader. We Bengali believe that Subhash is the only leader of India who have capability to understand the international game.
In Hindi, "Neta ji" means leader. We Indians believe that Subhash ji was on the few leaders of India who had the capability to understand the geopolitical game.
One thing you have missed... The core of INA was basically formed by Rasbehari Bose and captain Mohan Singh... Which was handed to Netaji
Thanks for this information 😊
Every children have to know all these stories
It's sad that we're mostly taught about Gandhiji & some specific freedom fighters
when other freedom fighters sacrificed so much & they get so less credit & attention
absolutely true bro
Freedom fighters didn't fight for getting attention and validation in the future. So it doesn't matter.
@@godson200 They absolutely didn't
but won't it will anger you seeing only some leaders getting glorified like the 'father of the nation' & a prime minister who actually supported British
@@ItsAryax that's how societies function sadly
@@godson200 priviledged arguement
Jinnah once said,"If Netaji becomes the prime minister of India then he has no problem to join with India".😔😔
Clement Atlee visited after our independence to Kolkata he said to the chief minister of Bengal that Gandhi had minimum effect on our independence.😔😔
I understand your feelings but for me jinnah don't have any credibility over his statements, he is dogla kind off a person.
Kuch bhi .Both these statements are wrong.
Clement Atlee never said that and Bose himself offered Jinnah the PM position.
@@qwerty008 may be Jinnah is a dogla but he is better than bullshit Gandhi and Nehru.😴😴
@@subhadeepghosh3961 Not Bose but Gandhi offered the pm position to Gandhi.
@@tanjimabbas5012 Bose too offered Jinnah PM position on the grounds that the country does not split.
For indian public Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is the father of the nation ❤️❤️❤️
why it feels like Mohak is trying to rush towards the conclusion so hard🤔
Video still didn't solve so many doubts
I am so grateful that I was born and grew up in the city where Netaji was born and grew up "Cuttack". Jai Bharat Jai Netaji
Just curious if you're an Odia ଓଡିଆ, how do you understand Hindi हिन्दी in the video? (assuming you studied English as your additional language at school)
@@AchyutChaudhary the belt between Orissa and Karnataka had a variant of the language called Dakhini due to the Nizams. There is some familiarity with the language due to trade and local muslim populations. In addition to schools, we get our practice with this language due to this factor.
@@AchyutChaudhary Kyunki nation wide hindi bola jata hai toh hindi bhi zaruri hai.. btw most of the people can understand hindi just that some of them can't say it frequently..
Odisha is a state where people have least knowledge.. We have all types of terrains starting from beaches, lakes(We have Chillika Lake, Asia's biggest lake after Vembanad lake), mountains.. We have many districts which give Mussoorie that is Koraput, Mayurbhanj, Malkangiri, Kalahandi.. which are Odisha's paradise.. They are famous of poverty but actually they are majorly rural based and has massive nature beauty..
You must visit Odisha once.. Its best kept secret.. You will love it..
@@AchyutChaudhary simply odia is very similar to hindi, just like gujrati and Assamese. But not like South Indian languages
@@AchyutChaudhary Odia is somehow similar to Hindi. It's not totally different like south languages.
+ In Odisha, Most of the schools have Hindi has a mandatory language till class 8th, this is the reason why many can understand Hindi
Netaji fought for whole India, but we can see some people see him for their state only😢, why can't we say he is our true Indian hero