Netaji Bose vs Gandhi | The Left & Right Wing of Congress Party | Dhruv Rathee
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- Dr. Subhash Chandra Bose, or Netaji is known as one of the most prominent freedom fighters of our Country. But there was an infamous tussle between Netaji and Mahatma Gandhi. Even though both of them had the same goal of making India independent, their ways and ideologies were different. While Gandhi was seen to be on the Non - Violence side, Netaji was seen on the opposite side. But what was the exact problem? What problem did this difference cause within the Congress party? Did it affect the Independence Struggle? I talk about all these things in this video.
0:00 Introduction
0:49 Early Life of Bose
4:47 Bose's Return to India
7:26 Left Wing vs Right Wing
10:35 Bose wins 1939 election
12:16 The Shocking Resignation
13:51 Leftists Group Forms
15:06 Gandhi vs Bose
---------------------------------------------------
JOIN MY COURSE:
The CZcams Blueprint Course: academy.dhruvrathee.com/youtube
✏️ Time Management and Productivity Course : academy.dhruvrathee.com
Learn how to manage time and maximize productivity in my specialised online course.
🤖 Master ChatGPT - Full Course : academy.dhruvrathee.com/chatgpt
Learn to harness the power of ChatGPT effectively and transform your life!
Use GET20 for a straight up 20% discount!
---------------------------------------------------
LISTEN TO MY PODCAST:
🎧 My Spotify exclusive podcast. Learn about how India works, only on Maha Bharat with Dhruv Rathee: spoti.fi/3IhBW51
FOLLOW ME ON:
▶️ Main Channel: / dhruvrathee
🎦 Vlog Channel: / dhruvratheevlogs
🩳 Shorts Channel: / @drshorts
📸 Instagram: / dhruvrathee
🐦 Twitter: / dhruv_rathee
MY VIDEO TOPICS:
🗺 Geopolitics: • Geopolitics
📘 History: • History Education
🔬 Science: • Science
☠️ Mystery: • Mystery Videos
💰Finance: • Financial Education
🇮🇳 Indian Current Affairs: • Current Affairs (India)
🌍 International Current Affairs: • Current Affairs (World)
DOWNLOAD MY APP:
📱Android app: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
📱iOS App: apps.apple.com/ie/app/dhruv-r...
----------------------------------------------------
Which other historical topics would you like to see videos on?
Link to KukuFM- kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/1ocn/9n2s
Coupon code - INDIA for 50% discount
Much needed video thanks man !
"It is our duty to pay for our liberty with our own blood. The freedom that we shall win through our sacrifice and exertions, we shall be able to preserve with our own strength." ~ Subhas Chandra Bose
About partition
Pls make video about collapse of USSR
Make a video on Maharana Pratap
If gandhiji is father of nation
Then Subhash Chandra Bose is godfather of the nation
@@Sir_AV that's why I used IF😁
@@Sir_AV i think no one should be called father of nation .
All greats are protectors and saviours of our sacred land ..
But yeah BOSE sir is totally in a different league ... The greatest freedom fighters of all time 😁
@@Sir_AV are u idiot netaji himself called him father off nation
@@Sir_AV Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose agar nehi raheta to phir India azad na hota
Gandhi was given title father of nation by the British, read more on Gandhi's truth and his role in Indian partition 👍
*Freedom is not given - it is taken.*
*~ Subhash Chandra Bose*
And we want from jihadis
@@siddhanth124 like you jihadii
@@siddhanth124 teri profile dekhne ke bad kuch ironical nhi lga
@@siddhanth124 pehle bhi tum jaise logon ki wajah se partition huaa,
@@siddhanth124 muslims ne tumhe kaha gulam banaya hai wo toh 200 saal phele tha ab thodi hai ab kis se azadi chahiye
Netaji was the only legend as a lovely person no one can beat him, we love Netaji
Nonsense. He was just a Japanese sub-unit.
@@uj00uj26 and you are just a stupid kid
@@rounakpaul no thanks Sanghi
@@uj00uj26 McDonald's 🤯
@@uj00uj26Madarsa spotted, opinion rejected.
*"Give me Blood and I will give you freedom"*
- Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose 🔥
I always respect Netaji. The greatest freedom fighter India has ever produced.His ideology is really effective.
His ideology was socialism. If you want to see how effective that was look at the Soviet union. He was a brave person who we should respect for his valour and sacrifice but his ideology was quite flawed.
@@hrishabkumarsharma1355
Our constitution says...
We the people of India..... Sovereign, "Socialist", Secular....
The word "socialist and secular" was added by Respected Indra Gandhi ji of Respected INC...
But Hrisab kumar Sharma acording to you which ideology was free from flaw?and which one was the best?
The moderate ideology was not effective. Because of them only India participated in the first world war. After the world war British Government did not keep their promise they deceived India. So that only I think the ideology of Netaji was the best one for that particular time.
@@dristikone3182 free market capitalism is the best way to improve standard of living. From china to the US to Singapore to Norway just open up your markets and wealth will follow.
"One individual may die for an idea, but that idea will after his death, incarnate itself in a thousand lives." - Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose
Oohhh...
A man who collaborated with Hitler who killed 6 million innocent people, burnt them in gas chamber.Hitler believed Aryan race are superior and Jews not. How can such a man be great?
@@jbharat6977 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Arrey , Waah !!! Yeh Huyi Naa Baat ! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Kya Hain Ki Hum Log Toh Paydaishi Desh Bhakt Hain , Humare Agey Yeh Netaji Naam Ka Admi Kis Khet Ki Muli Hain !!!!!
Kyun Sahi Kaha Na ! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@jbharat6977 tu pagal hai sale
@@jbharat6977 tum Pagal ho kya?
Proud to be an Indian ❤️
Proud to be an human
@@YT-GAMER-X Proud to be an Earthian
@@Nouhildsxhertz1 proud to be an what you are
Proud to be a fan of godse
@@praveenakolli9168 proud to be an proud
People like Netaji take birth in thousands of years and remain immortal in our hearts. He is like God in West Bengal. We are proud of our hero.
"Give me blood, I will give you freedom "
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ❤️
History is interesting if you don't have to prepare for exam
True
@@raghuveerprabhu 😂😂
😂😂
😅🤣
Right
Netaji, one of the leaders loved by both the liberals and conservatives, this shows how popular he was and still is, Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Mujhe dukh iss baat ka lagta h ki ek ko bhagwaan dikhaya jaata h, aur ek k baare me padhaya tak nahi jaata
Some people even say that Netaji could've been 1st in ICS. Just because he was Indian, they made him 4th. Not sure if this is true, but Netaji was just legendary. 🔥
It doesn't really matter at all its true or not
No I don't think so. The person who came 1st was also an indian. He became a very important diplomat in independent India. I don't remember the name, but yeah.
@@srirudra1008 Kumar Padmanabha Sankara Menon was the only Indian ever to top the ICS. But he appeared for it in 1921 unlike Netaji(1920).
Todays UPSC CSE .. is ICS exam of that time ... And our Pride .. just Prepared within 7 months 🤯🤯🤯😮😮😮😯😯 ... !!!
@@thequickwit8174 Bro how does it matter he came 3rd or 4th? He kicked the luxurious job of high salary for his country. If he would come 1st, than also he would have kicked the job. We know him bcz is the best and the biggest leader of our freedom struggle not bcz his rank in ICS
If history was taught like this in my school, I would have never hated history.
facts
If u thinks that i would recommend u a sst teacher named digraj singh rajput
Doesn't matter
History is my favourite subject jabki main science student hoon
@@parth8558 ya bro magnet brain and it's teacher doing great job
@@Syedfaizan67866 he left mb 😶
Fearless character is the key 🗝️ for success,i salute your decision give me blood, i will give you freedom 🙏
English interviewer said"I am seeing a monkey front of me" Netaji replied "yes,I am a mirror"-ICS exam.
😂😂😂savage
You can change history books, news media. But Netaji will never be erased from the hearts of ordinary people.
It is there in the books, read properly 😄, half knowledge is dangerous
Read your history books properly. You don't read and then accuse incorrectly.
@@newsjunkieish atleast Google it fool 😂
@@newsjunkieish I am from bengal....we dont read history......we make history......we dont need your artificial history
@@saivamsi8126 bro you have complete fool knowledge😂😂😂
"One individual may die for an idea, but that idea will, after his death, incarnate itself in a thousand lives." ~ Subhas Chandra Bose
Subscribe me
@Indra Devta: the King of Devas
# Dhritarashtra asks Yudhisthara how many of the soldiers are slain, and Yudhisthara replies 1.6 billion (1,660,020,000) soldiers have been slain and 24,165 are missing.
# The Kalinga War resulted in massive loss of life and property. 1,00,000 soldiers were killed in the battle and 1,50,000 soldiers from Kalinga were captured by King Asoka.
For the rest google the 'list of battles in ancient india'.
It will help you know the reality of peaceful indian people.
Provided the idea should be a right one.
The fight between evil & truth is from times immemorial.
That's the only truth rest are mere characters.
No one would be asked about other's karma but their own.
Choose your side wisely based on truth and justice not by the accidental birth Identity of caste, community, country, colour and language.
Life is a one-time opportunity for each one of us.
Let's not ruin it for immoral leaders.
Also Ambedkar said Gandhi is no Mahatma
@Indra Devta: the King of Devas
Gobar thoda aur kha lo poora ilaaj ho jayega aap ka 🙏🙏🤣🤣🤣🤣
Sabhi freedom fighter jihone hmare liye apna jeevan diya sabhi ko sat sat naman.....jai hind ..
As a Bengali and Bangladeshi i always respect Netaji Bose and Chittaranjan dutt ❤️
Coz Bangladesh Was Never Different it was a Integral Part Of Bengal But Unfortunately Some Idiots Made Us Divided!
@@KalpanaDas-lb2linot by some idiot yeh log Muslim the toh yeh log apni dilse Pakistan ko join kiya tha... and later Pakistan ke log jab Muslim hoke muslim ko marne laga tab.. yeh log bole hum Pakistan ke sath nhi rahina..
@@KalpanaDas-lb2li🤬
@@AllSong681 you have little bit of wrong information
Netaji Subhash was pure GOLD 🪙🪙🪙
He was a fire 🔥
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is the reason behind independent India and he is the greatest son of mother India 🙏🙏🙏
Correct
Right
Thick
Yesss..
Correct
Proud of be a Bengali 🇮🇳👏
Maturity is when u realise two were legends and respect each other.
The main reason of freedom was Netaji. He was the backbone of our country.
I think you didn't read history,u get knowledge from CZcams only
@@ranjan9842 i studied and i think Bose had more less success than Gandhi but Gandhi also had failures like he stopped non cooperation movement after chori chora kand , like he didn't ask Irvin to free bhagat singh and titled him a terrorist , like he adopted Bose ' s path and said Karo ya maro , like he was killed by godse and there are a lot of people who respect godse 🤣🙏🤣
@@adiityakumar yes he stoped non cooperation movement because the movement had become violent and the biggest point of the movement was non violence yes it dosnt seem like a big deal to us but still when one of the biggest thing on which a movement is started become invalid then the movement it self becomes hollow also 2nd point is total lie ypu can watch dhurv vedio on "did gandhi try to save bhagat singh" and can literally see how many time gandhi tried to cancel the hanging of bhagat singh he never called him terrorist this is a misconception but gandhi always tried for cancelling bhagat singhs hanging also rrs or hindu mahasabha and muslim league were the one who were total silent on the issue of bhagat singh which godse was part of
@@adiityakumar So that's why you kill a freedom fighter for not doing as much as far your expectations did you appoint him on salary to work for the country??? What about your godse what was he doing to get the country free? It is just like modi didn't give 2 crores job let's kill him and become God, see I know gandhi had some flaws but he did according to the situation of that era , people were unaware about independence there's no TV no internet despite gandhi United different parts of the country only violence and only non violence doesn't work World war 2 did a major job also , Gandhiji had everything he was successful despite he made himself like one of us yes that was the true India if you see gandhi ji dress code and he worked for 33 years in India going jail several times was he employed was he getting any money for that? He worked day and night unconditionally and with uncertainty people like you complain 10 hours of work in office that too getting paid highly,and neither he demanded him to respect or give any titles that was the netaji who give him,so if you are a true indian then respect every freedom fighter and don't fall for CZcams narrative read spectrum and don't celebrate terrorism
@@ranjan9842 exactly you read history first 😂
Spinning charaka raping minor wont give anyone freedom 🤣🤣
I am from West Bengal and we all Bengalis think that Netaji is our Real Hero of our Nation.... because iswar ka janam hota hai , mirtu nahi hota....as like Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.... ❤️❤️❤️
Bhai Netaji odisha se hei
Pehele rusgulla ko lene ke liye jhagadte ho
Aur abhi netaji WB ka batate ho
Tum WB log bhi Pakistan se mangne wala skim shik liya kya🤣🤣
@@venomdhamaka7595 no wonder why divide and rule policy worked successuly in india, coz of ppl like u
@@venomdhamaka7595 just bcoz someone was born in cuttack that dsnt mean that he is from Odisha... ancestors,family, culture, education everything is from bengal....
no offense but i had been to cuttack and asked autowala to take me to that place where Netaji spend his most of his time during his childhood but to my surprise none of them are aware of this..... so sad...
Odisha mein paida huye the...netaji🥰🥰
@@explore_life8960 are bhai sher jungle main rahe ya fir zoo main log sher ko Jungle ki raja kahte he wese subash ch bose bengal mein rahe ya fir jahan b rahe woh to odisha ki sher he 🔥🔥
My greatest respect to netaji subhash chandra bose. He will remain in our hearts for generations to come.
দেশনায়ক নেতাজি সুভাষচন্দ্র বসু তোমারে সেলাম🙏🙂❤
জয় হিন্দ✊
As a Bangladeshi, I always knew that he was a great leader and I feel proud of him because he is a Bengali too. But I never knew that he was such a great leader who could challenge Gandhiji . Great video. Respect for both.
NETAJI was way bigger than Gandhi.
@@saswatabhattacharya9759 they never competed don't worry
@@saswatabhattacharya9759 comparison ??why ??
তোমরা আমাকে রক্ত দাও আমি তোমাদের স্বাধীনতা দিবো।।।।।।।
আসলে জাপানের সমর্থনে বৃটিশের বিরুদ্ধে যুদ্ধ করায় অবাঙালি ভারতীয়রা নেতাজী কে সঠিক সম্মান দিতে ভয় পেতো। এখন ধীরে ধীরে দিচ্ছে।
he was born in odisha .
*"Freedom is Love"*
-Netaji
That's a man's word who don't understand 'AHINSA'
@@harshbagchi9296 Ahinsa se hamesha kaam nhi chalta. Mahabharata parh ke dekh lo
@@ayushkumar5950 guess "Ahinsa" also can be used to stop wars and conflicts in middle east, Afghanistan, Europe and other parts of the world too? Lol! its our param dharma to do ahinsa but for the saving dharma one must do every possible way which includes hinsa too..
@@harshbagchi9296 tu jajur gujurati hoga isliye baat ko badal mat Jo such hai yohi bolrahe hai
@@crazy440voltkajhatka9 I am Bengali
Both are great,jai Hind Jai Bharat ❤
Love and respect to both Gandhi ji and netaji subhash chandra bose. We got the freedom from Britishers but the sad reality is we are still slave as democracy is dying day by day. Our leaders sacrificed their lives to attain real freedom but only 40 percent work is done and 60 percent is still due.
Netaji is a man who doesn't die in the hearts of True INDIANS
Today is Netaji's birthday, mine too!!
I'm exactly 101 years younger than him! Lots of love and respect to this amazing man!!💖💖
Every day 67,385 babies are born in India.
@@togetservi4342 i am waiting for 67,384 other comments
Happy Birthday and you are lucky to be born on this auspicious day
@@nikhilchadokar here Iam, born in the same day and Idolize netaji from the core
@@soothsayer8500 read that comment again
different route for same destination. Respect for both.. Our freedom leader thought us both ways.. how to fight and how to respect. Great Video.
Superb. Very logical and knowledgeable. Presented with zero prejudice. Thanks a lot Rathee ji
A Hero that is forgotten why???we got freedom because of Subhash ji salute to you sir . Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
U r right ❤️
Mai bhi chahta hu aage chal kar ,dhruv sir ke jaisa banna
My channel name is,. One page media ma'am
There were many having no name now we should respect all and not align with a few only.
Every sacrifice matters
he is not forgotten dude
I want to share something here..... One of my grandfather's friend he was classmate of Netaji and he used to say that Prof. Oaten was insulting India during history class and Netaji could not tolerate that (quite obvious) and he started beating him and then rest joined him.... I don't know how others believe but we know that grandpa so we trust on this evidence..... Nice video
Oh my god.....really....😇
Yes it is a true story
It's true...it's a legend in Presidency college/ university.
According to some historical accounts, it was his friends who started abusing him first, but the fact that Netaji started beating too is not very sure.
Ya this story is famous in bengal.
this is one of your best videos. beautifully verbalized the ideas of violence and non violence and opened up the eyes to see a grey area between the two.
सर सुभाष चंद्र बोस हमेशा हमारे दिलो में रहेंगे
वंदे मातरम् 🙏🙏🙏
जय हिन्द 🙏🙏🙏
भारत भारत कि जय 🙏🙏🙏
Freedom is not given.
It is taken.
:-Netaji 🇮🇳🙏
We should all take it same for happiness in life
Wo azadi nehi thaa bhikh thaa., :- kangkana ranaut
@@johirulislam9426 yes becz agr aap jaante honge thoda bhi pdha hoga toh world war 2 mai gandhi ne netaji ko mna kr diya tha ,aur hmare soldier bheje WW2 mai india ke sath kahi aur desh like indonesia aur 6 other countries aajad hue becz america signed a deal with britain ki hum tbhi WW2 participate karenge agr tum sbko aazad karoge and that's why we get it under transfer of power
World War 2 ki wajah se
@@johirulislam9426 " I work in puncture shop, But my dream is boycotting France " - A random South Asian ABDUL.
Gandhi is in our wallet, Netaji is in our ♥ heart
❤❤best comment
and BJP IN YOUR BRAIN
@@devdiv05 😂 sahi kaha yaar 😆
Andh bhakt peoples
@@devdiv05 and what do u like Raga or owasi
@@atanudholay1184 kejriwal
Ek Mahan sanatani hamare neta ji ❤❤
😂😂 netaji was leftist bro! he was pro secular 😂
@@prajyotbachewar9538 he respect every religion and culture. His army full with different religion and different people
Gandhi ji preached nonviolence which is of minimum importance .Netaji is the Hero of India .
Why Nelson Mandela, Dr Marti Luther King followed his path. Why Einstein or Leo Tolstoy respect Gandhi.
@@manmohanrout3083they can't understand the greatness of Mahatma Gandhi❤
Freedom isn't given, It's taken 😮🇮🇳🔥
- Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
It was Taken Actually
But British Showed That They Gave Us like a Parent or Supreme Authority.....
Their Present Generation Too Thinks that British Rule Was Good For India .......
😑😑😑😑
Looking at the circumstances of that time...
It is more obvious to say that the freedom was given us.
@@vedikapapita kangana ka influence lag rha hai
@@vedikapapita it was never given , it was taken
our freedom fighters sacrificed their blood to give us this country
@@vedikapapita quit india movement pde ho?
Are tum to tweets pde ho whatsapp pade ho , kya kare .....
"Taste can be different,but everyone eats to fight hunger."
Thank you Dhruv for imparting true knowledge of our modern history among people.Gandhi ji & Netaji both of them fought for us,for India against British ❤🙏🏽
but neta ji is best
@@healthcare5622 perception matters
@@arghadipsaha9206 and some just bark for no reason
@@healthcare5622
Father is always best.
Also Ambedkar said Gandhi is no Mahatma
Very nice. Excellent, unbiased, rational and middle of the road presentation. Keep up the good work. This professor is an admirer of your work.
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ❤️🙏🙏❤️🙏❤️🙏🙏❤️❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Maturity is when you respect every freedom fighter.
@@raghuveerprabhu they weren't radical..
@@raghuveerprabhu may be you didn't studied about the ideology of Mahatma Gandhi, if people had supported Gandhi then we would had got independence in 1920.
Which later S.C. Bose understood and gave the title the father of nation to Gandhi ji.
@@raghuveerprabhu This is why I say learn more and talk less. Study about Bhagat Singh and Netaji more to know them well. Don't just go with the flow
Ok
@@raghuveerprabhu maturity is when u realise great leaders like subase chander bose , Bhagat singh etc also respect the other leaders like Gandhi ji and Nehru ji 😀
I Respect Gandhi jii but More Respet to Netaji and trying to Follow his principles..Hero of India Jai Hind🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Respect but laga ke nhi ki jati hai
@@knowledgewithadarshjha8942 @knowledge with adarsh The tilt is subtle but exists and depends on the ideology one adheres to. Common sense, easy to understand this, unless you have a negative tilt when a Bengali person respects/prides Netaji.
@@knowledgewithadarshjha8942 yeah agreed Respect is respect you either do or not there aint any more or less in it
My Grand father & grand Uncle both were follower of CR Das. But my father was a follower of Gandhi, Netaji & Nehru. There was no difference between Gandhi & Netaji.
Look at his language jindegi pura set tha.
Its reflecting his mum mindset
FOR SUBHASH NATION IS ABOVE ALL.
JAY HIND
Not Gandhi only Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose my ❤️ our love❤
Real Father of Nation…Netaji🙏🏻💐🤗
गांधी और बोस हमें सिखाते हैं कि मतभेद भले हो जाए, लेकिन मन भेद नही होना चाहिए।
किसी से असहमत होने से वह हमारा दुश्मन नही बन जाता ये आज के दौर में समझना जरूरी है। 🙏🙏
But if discrimination can change your country future then it matter a lot.
like jinaah and gandhi.
aapne sahi kha but :( radical extremists ye ni samjhte han wo bus apne blind faith ko he subse ucha samjhte han aur iski vajah se he terror and hate spread karte han world main he not only in India.
The fight between evil & truth is from times immemorial.
That's the only truth rest are mere characters.
No one would be asked about other's karma but their own.
Choose your side wisely based on truth and justice not by the accidental birth Identity of caste, community, country, colour and language.
Life is a one-time opportunity for each one of us. Don't ruin it for immoral leaders.
Right 👍👍
@@adarshpatel055 आप पोगो देखो या कुछ नॉलेज लेकर आए
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ji ko koti koti nomon
When the British Prime Minister Clement Atlee had returned to India after India's independence ,
He was asked , " What was the contribution of Mahatma Gandhi in India's independence? "
Clement Atlee answered,
" *Minimal* "
If you don't believe , go see there's a video proof of it
Our greatest leader Netaji... We never forget him and his service for the nation. I salute him from my ❤.
I'm Grandson of late Captain Govindrao Kirde who was in Azad Hind sena... He used to tell us Stories about his time❤️
Tum Muze khun Do mai tumhe aazadi Dunga❤️
You will unite the nation on all terms it seems to me. Good job, keep it up🙏
Beautifully explained 🙏🏼👌🏽
Subhas Babu was a world class Leader ✊ It's our Bad Luck that we lost him when we really needed his Support
Just think about it if he became the pm of india in 1947 then the whole scenario of india should have been different today 🙂
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
We did not loose him
Some seculars of this nation hided his existence
Watch Anuj dhar videos
Well nehru ji also did great.
@@toaa4734 lehru. 😂😂
@@rrrabad1234 sorryworker 🤣
@CosmoSapien no never he was alive with a different identity gun nam baba
India got independence because of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose❤💐...Not because of Gandhi..
--Dr. Ambedkar🇮🇳
And netaji was inspired by Gandhi 😂
@@saifilias7736exactly. 😂.
Also a staunch believer in inter religious harmony.
@@saifilias7736Netaji was not inspired by Gandhi . In 1927 they had a disagreement in the Calcutta session and since then their path of works became fully different. And Netaji was inspired by Swami Vivekananda and Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Das.
Ooo inspired gandhi se nahi the konsi state mai rahoto ho mai nehi janta hoon...but west Bengal Porte to desh ki Asli history jan pate tum log..desh ke 90% mahapurush Bengal se belong se nikalta hai...isliye iyha history details main pora hai jata hai......tumari answer hai. Chiranjan das..OK his inspire
@@AkashJana-xh2zh you can Google, "Who were Netaji's inspiration?". You can easily find the result. I belong to W.B. too and I also know a little bit about him. Don't argue with that silly things on social media... Ok?
Sir this video and all of your video is informative, I salut your hard work and knowledge.
Also request you to make another video of netaji life about gumnami baba.
Proud of neta ji Subhas Chandra bhos 🇮🇳🇮🇳🫡🫡🫡
Netaji is the pride of India. A jewel!!
Subhash Bose biggest mistake was he tried to get the support of Germany's Nazi leader Hitler for India's freedom
Hitler was an fascist, dictator Hitler killed more than 60 lakhs people
This was not needed
@@sharankumar4396 his biggest mistake was that he did not lick the boot of British who carried out Jaliwanwala bagh. Also allied force dropped atom bomb on Nagasaki and Hiroshima killing millions which is no less heinous than Hitler. His biggest mistake was he did not spend scandalous time with Lady Mountbatten. Greats are Jawaharlal and Jinnah.
@@rohitbannerji2756 What about Nanjing massacre of Japan? What about Andaman massacre?
@@prakhardubey2356 what about the massacre of Kauravas in Mahabharata. What about massacre of Lanka in Ramayana? I hope you got the point. The point is for the right cause enemies’ enemy is a friend. In this case the cause was independence.
@@rohitbannerji2756 “allied force dropped atom bomb on Nagasaki and Hiroshima killing millions"
This is why half knowledge is dangerous. The combined death of those two is 130000, which is a lot less than Hitler's 6 million jew massacre,also go read about the horrific war crimes Japan committed and come back if you don't feel disgusted by it.
*The dark politics still being the biggest obstacle in solving of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose 's mystery...*
*~literally he is our forgotten hero from the forgotten history ...*
*All Indians should protest for creating the pressure upon the Govt. to solve the mystery and declassified the top secret hidden files of Netaji...plz🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🥺🥺🥺🇮🇳🇮🇳*
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ji was never forgotten....and will never be forgotten...
In my childhood, On every Independence day and R-Day celebrations I have seen Netaji's role, heard his famous lines...
We all read about him in our school days....How can people forget????
as "He is the Prince of all the Patriots"
Yes , we want all files related to Netaji be disclosed .
Enjoyed the video. Very informative.
16:55 -
The regiments in Azad hind fauz were :-
1) Gandhi Brigade
2) Subhash Brigade
3) Lakshmi Brigade (after Rani Lakshmi Bai)
4) Nehru Brigade
5) Azad Brigade ( after Maulana Abul Kalam Azad)
Jai hind
@Time Machine
Which poem?I would also like to know about that poem
@Time Machine savarkar main idea was 2 nation theory , he always wanted it divided , go learn history andhbhakth
@@abeyjoy7
Bro don't call him andhbhakt,ppl can have ideological difference one should not stigmitize (video by dhruv says the same)
We can counter each other by points and you are right sarvakar's hindutav idealogy (definition given himself) - divided the indics into hindu vs (muslim+Christians)
@Time Machine savarkar was a real terrorist
@@jafardahodwala6477 Who wrote 1857 war of Independence? Whose book's third edition was published by Bhagat Singh? You are the real one
Netaji subhas chandra bose is a great national hero. And real Hero of india🇮🇳❤🇮🇳
Bilkul
Jab first world war me India ne angrezo ka saath Diya tha uske badle me unhe kya Mila jaliyawala bagh iske baad bhi Gandhi samajh rha tha ki non voilence se angrez bhagh jayenge isliye netaji ka rasta hi shi tha Jai Subhash Chandra bose Jai hind
Sir my question is why does we never know subash chander Bose 's death date
Big brother, your efforts are greatly appreciated. Today's people have separated Mahatma Gandhi and Subhash Chandra Bose as if both were arch enemies of each other.
Netaji was not but Gandhi was enemy of Netaji. Why Gandhi tried to get rid of Netaji from the position. Of the president otherwise.
@@somnathchakrabarti1870 true
@@somnathchakrabarti1870 Who told you that ?
@@rahulgeorge1963 I dnt need to be told, there are numerous books and documentaries. Plz make an effort to read them. Dnt have time to spoon feed you.
@@somnathchakrabarti1870 please give the real facts
What you know about the real history?
Is the books and documentaries you read is genuine?
If he was alive in 47, Bengal would never be parted into two countries
I do not understand, why for the sake of partition, India was divided into 3 instead of 2 demographic regions - why West and East Pakistan, instead of (West) Pakistan alone ??! 😔
@@souraday1133 why not 3 part?? Yes, partition via religion is stupid but was somewhat necessary to avoid riot. So, could make muslim Pakistan, hindu India and secular Bengal (WB, BD and 7s)
@@souraday1133 Because 1That part of Bengal Was Muslim majority
If he was alive in 47 Pakistan Would never exist
They had different ideology but they never forgot their ultimate aim i.e. the independence of our Nation. Proud of both of them :)
Moral of the story -
To achive something great
(mat bhed acha h bas man bhed nhi hona chaiye) Diffrence in opinions is good but there should be no differences in hearts.
Both freedom fighter were above the greatness. I have read about both. I respact both from depth of my heart. They may live forever in hearts of the people.
The spelling of respect is wrong...
Can you share the name of the books. I want to learn that
Godse knew the truth
Gandhi, freedom fighter. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. Koi ek gal par mare, to usko dusri gal badado. Is it a characteristics of a fighter...??
Gandhi is a politician. He dose every things only for his family.
@@nirupamghosh3511 fact is he never said that and you still stick to it and believing it 😂😂 keep it up 😂😂
Both Gandhi ji and Bose ji were gems of modern India. But people spread misconceptions about both and it deeply hurts me.
Both were true patriot and admirer of freedom.
Jai hind jai Bharat
Not Gandhi 🤢
@@techboy4769 Bhagat singh was the son of nation
Sardar patel was iron man of india
Gandhi is father of nation
S.C. Bose was the true patriot who is Prince of patriots.
@@vortexunofficial1397 LIKE SERIOUSLY gandhi when the british used to arrest him he used to chill in the jail there are many sons of Bharat desh who were brutality tourted in cellular jail . they were the real heros .
@@techboy4769 There were Thousands of freedom fighters whose names we don't even know and maybe S.C. Bose impact in freedom struggle was the most but that doesn't give us right to criticize Gandhi.
Savarkar asked for mercy petetion but that doesn't mean he wasn't freedom Fighter at one point of time.
Bal gangadhar tilak(Father of india unrest)- Against women education.
Mahatma gandhi(Father of nation)- Against Untouchability but supported varna system.
Dr. Br. Ambedkar (Father of constitution)- Wanted separate Constituencies for dalit which might have lead to seprate nation and criticise Islam and Hinduism.
Veer savarkar (Founder of hindutva) - Supported eating Beef and was against Islam and Christianity .
Every one had some defects in them but as people who lives in independent india It's our responsibility to respect them.
@@vortexunofficial1397 100% correct
Without Gandhi we cannot think about Bose
Both are imp both are our gems
Both are respected
Thanks for giving me an independent country
You should maintain the birth place (Odisha)of the great Bose!!
"A wise man always appreciate the Wisdom of Another wise man"
Unlike certain extremists from *both* sides in modern times.
सभी देश वासियों को सुभाष चंद्र बोस जयंती की हार्दिक शुभकामनाएँ
Thanks brother 🙏
Netaji didn't cause any hindrence towards Gandhiji's Quit India Movement, but Gandhiji and his team did cause hindrence towards Netaji's actions. Even after forcefully declaring Netaji dead, it is heard that investigation was carried on him and his family.
Gandhiji never had any respect for Netaji. He stated those respected words after the so called myth of plane crash.
Gandhi is the father of nation ❤️
Subhash Chandra bose is our Netaji ❤️
Gandhi called Subash Netaji
Subhash called Gandhi father of the nation
Both had huge respect and love towards eachother.
Your respect for Gandhiji makes my soul realise that there are still some people who respect gandhiji....your comment is a gem.
🙏
@@IamLookingforWoody_________786lol no body likes gandhiji now😂😂..
Even I don't admire him at all ,fan of Bhagat Singh and netaji here but yeah we gotta give Gandhi the respect he deserves .smh
@@IamLookingforWoody_________786 we respect him whole world respect him he has his statue in usa and many more countries he deserves this
@@IamLookingforWoody_________786 Me too bruh.
I also respect both
I am really amazed by the way Gandhiji and subash chandra bose dealt with differences in ideologies.
Dhruv, can you create an episode on the evolution of Indian politics and the way different political parties deal with ideological differences in present India?
your ending music is just awasome.....❤
Proud to be my heart ❤️ BHARAT❤❤❤❤❤
Such balanced view of two of the greatest sons of India is absolutely important in today's US vs them world view..two men respecting each other though following different ( but not opposite ) paths ..lesson for today's youth who will become tomorrow's social drivers .
What a lovely explanation of facts. History in schools should be taught in this manner. Unfortunately most of teachers in schools never do any kind of research before coming to class. They just read the content of textbook. Very knowledge enriching content in this video.
Sir research adhuri hai. I suggest dhruv to read parallel life ( Nehru vs shubash chapter 7 ).
HE IS A FRAUD DONT BELIEVE HIS NONSENSE HE LIES ABOUT EVERYTHING
Instead of blaming teachers, blame the education system as a whole, why the textbooks are not updated since years? If the system is not amended frequently, how can you blame teachers to not teach outside of textbooks. If the system and examination system by boards in the country don't support practical learning, but rote learning and memorization, then the teachers are probably going to make you memorize so that you can score better, they only want good for you, except some bad teachers which are not most of them. Also if the textbooks are made in this detail especially history which is already filled with only dates, names, and events to memorize, this will add more syllabus only to have more burden on students to memorize this for exams. However I agree in subjects like science, more practical learning should be promoted, in English more speaking skills and grammar should be taught than Literature, and textbooks should be moderated frequently to be up to date, rather than teaching the students same thing which were taught 30-40 years ago.
@@Coronavirus-dk7mq NCERT books are well written. Problem is teachers are unable to create interest and at the same time parents also don't promote non science subjects
@@mr.nikogaming2511 Fraud? I too don't like him but would u mind telling how he's a fraud
Always Netaji..❤❤a true patriot can't hate him..most of the people don’t know him & Don't want to remind him..But We Indian as well as Bengal people know his contribution to get freedom of India❤..He is called The Great National Hero/ leader.❤
2:58 Bro Plane crash occurred in 1945 not 1943.. That too is still a mystery whether it occurred or not...
"आजादी मिली नहीं छीनी गई है"🔥🔥🔥
- नेताजी सुभाष चंद्र बोस
Whatsapp University
@@ranjan9842it's true Netaji quoted this line "Freedom is not given , it is taken" and u may be from facebook University or peaceful community... don't mind it. it's fact bro
@@godkumardas3147 yes Sir . Dominion status is given , Freedom is not given in 1947 .
It’s unbelievable that certain political parties are trying to hijack these legends
right bro
No Political parties "hijacks" the legends, they just glorify the lost legends...
@@anmolpandey9670 no they don't, they gaslight and misguide the public, fills hatred for one another. Never in his life did Sir Subhas Chandra Bose wanted hate between religious community in India. He wanted a. India where every person despite of his caste, state or religion can feel proud calling themselves Indian
@@idontcare3147 true
@@idontcare3147 Then why are you saying "hijack" the legends?? Is erecting the statue of Bose in National war memorial "hijacking" of the Bose?? And can you specify which Political parties are "hijacking" these legends??
There is no comparison between a patriot and a slimy traitor..
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is the ultimate legend
Netaji's every words are gold.
Jai hind
Father of nation
Dilli chalo
@@raghuveerprabhu 😆😆
Mahatma Ji was a gem
Unke bina aazadi Aaj nahi hoti
I m bengali and i m proud of HIM.. Jay Hind.. 🔥🔥
Joy hind joy bangla
Every Indian is proud of Him
Bengal was the hub of Nationalism
Whole india is proud of him...
@@PriyankaYadav-lb9jd aj bengoli der jonno des sadhin kintu tomra amader opor hundi bolte badho korao
বাঙালির জয় হো!!
Love from cuttack Odisha the birth place of the legend Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose..❤️❤️
Netaji was a symbol of strength and pride. Happy birthday sir
This is what we called a awesome video ....I myself a history teacher and know how much hardwork is required for creating a video on such a controversial topic . commendable dhruv 👏
Only netaji subhash chandra bose
Since you are a history teacher, I've got a few questions for you.
First of all let us be clear that the Governmental bodies decide what ideas are stocked on the shelves at schools through standardized curricula and standardized exams. Even charter schools and home schools are not immune from this control of ideas because students are still required to learn the information on standardized exams.
Now, My questions are :
Why were we taught to hate our heritage and glorify the invaders ? (Delhi Sultanate, Mughal Empire etc)
Why is it called 'Indian Rebellion of 1857' and 'Sepoy Mutiny' instead of 'First War of Indian Independence'?
Why is it that Gandhi and Nehru were glorified and many other freedom fighters were ignored or was mentioned just as a side note(paragraph) with small pictures while Gandhi had a whole chapter to himself?
Why are so many places, streets, grounds, stadiums, awards, statues, Indian currency notes, are all associated with Gandhi-Nehru dynasty and completely ignoring other freedom fighters?
We have National holiday on OCT 2 and Children's day on Nov 14 , what about so many other freedom fighters?(why not a national holiday at least on 23rd March)
Why was our history distorted in our text books?
Our History text books just revolves around these topics(at least during 70's to 90's):
1)Indus Valley Civilization
2)Delhi Sultanate
3)Mughal Sultanate
4)Independence Movement
In addition to the above four topics, the Guptas and Mauryas are mentioned for one chapter each. Gonds and Ahoms are vaguely described in one chapter. Sikhs, Marathas and some South Indian kingdoms like Cholas, Cheras, Pandyas , Vijayanagara empire get a paragraph each.
This is mere brainwashing to show Gandhi as a good figure. Gandhi treated Bose horribly. If not for Mr.Gandhi, India would have been independent 10 years earlier!
Absolutely