Bigger Picture Denver: How Gender Ideology has been Embedded within America with Leor Sapir
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 11. 2023
- Leor Sapir is a fellow at the Manhattan Institute (MI). In his work at the MI, Dr. Sapir applies his research and academic experience to policy matters, concentrating on issues of gender identity and transgenderism. His inaugural essay in City Journal (Winter 2022) explores a series of recent court rulings on transgenderism, demonstrating how bad ideas translate from fringe academic theory into law and policy. Previous pieces for City Journal explored evolving athletic guidelines and media coverage surrounding transgender issues.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please subscribe, comment, like and share!
Support our work: genspect.org/donate/
Follow us on Social Media:
Twitter: / genspect
Facebook: / genspect
Instagram: / genspectinternational
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@realgenspect?...
CZcams: / @genspect
Rumble: rumble.com/user/Genspect
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#beyondwapth #genspectbiggerpicture #timesupwpath #genspectdenver #leorsapir
Thank you, Genspect! I come back to this video often. “We must treat it as a medical and mental health issue with civil rights implications.” Bravo, Leo Sapir! 👏🏻 👏🏻 👏🏻
Leor Sapir is one of my favorite people to listen to on this topic
Mr. Spair needed more time. A most interesting talk. Thank you.
Thank you. This was very informative. One piece of the puzzle. Culture matters.
The other piece of the puzzle is money. Who profits. After all, this is America. Culture matters.
This process reminds me of James Lindsay and Peter Boghosian describing what they call "idea laundering".
Very informative talk in a (maybe too) short time from Mr Sapir!
Sapir has given quite a few more in depth talks and interviews available on CZcams. Highly recommend watching all of them. I’ve learned so much from him.
@@NorCalMom thanks!☺️
Thinking about whether we might also get somewhere with an ad absurdum approach: e.g., anti-woke students "identifying as" dogs, cats, or airplanes, demanding to be housed in kennels or hangars and to be called "whosa good boy" and "vrooom", etc. The civil rights establishment would either recognize it as satire, and be enraged (but effectively lampooned) or....they'd embrace it and life would get even crazier.
I didn’t embrace Centura Health determining my gender for me. As male!!!!
You would be laughed out because you all have been trying that tactic for twenty years now.
It's the first thing any Transphobe does: it replace all jokes in their head and destroy the part of their brain capable of making new jokes and replaces it with "I identify as an Attack Helicopter."
Your argument wasn't persuasive when it first popped up on 4chan around 2006, it's still not compelling now.
12:39 - in other words, politicians caved in to the trans lobby activists, and took the easy way out, instead of actually creating guide lines based on some sort of actual regulation such as say 'third spaces' for trans people (such as bathrooms, locker rooms, prison or sports leagues) and/or some sort of gate keeping as to who can pass in a convincing and believable way, no, they preferred writing vague legislation full of loopholes where they simply washed there hands. And they did so while simultaneously virtue signal to their woke base, and letting the door open to all kinds of absurd opportunists who could exploit this issue, while also throwing women under the bus in the process.
Exactly, all too hard, let the trans activists have their way.
It's because it's a men's right movement and there are transwomen in positions of power.
@@9395gbEXACTLY
The gate keeping needs to be based on biological facts, and there should be zero consideration given to whether a female impersonator passes or not. Zero consideration should also be given to how much effort has been given. None of this matters. A person born with a penis can NEVER be or become a woman under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES WHATSOFUCKINGEVER, and NO person born with a penis should EVER be referred to as she or her, or EVER be allowed into female only spaces or sports, under ANY circumstances whatsoever. NO EXCEPTIONS. To allow ANY of this evil insanity to occur, is to disregard the rights and needs of women and girls, and is incredibly misogynistic and harmful and hateful toward women and girls. It almost seems that women and girls don't matter at all to these people. It is like they are flipping us the bird...AT BEST. It is obvious that these people in support of these policies DETEST ALL females and children.
And you should talk about Obama care which mandated gender care must be part of what insurance pays for, that was the biggest green light there was
And yet, people can't get real life saving treatment they need.
Researching the Evidence Based Medicine movement and how it handled addiction red pilled me to this stuff.
It’s going to need a strong government to not only pass legislation to stop this but fund challenges by organisations like ACLU.
They also need to fund those damaged by ACLU and similar for pushing affirmative care in suing them. Go for their funds.
A Libertarian would object on this.
This information makes me so sick. This is a war on our children and to destory parent/child relationships
I am not sorry i listened. I'm just so shocked
I'm curious why you got to this conclusion..can't wait to listen to it as soon as I can
Like my university Political Science professor once said to our class: "In the Soclaist worldview, your child is the exclusive property of the Federal Government." He was so very right. That does not mean that makes it right, especially since he did not think his own two kids should be the exclusive property of the Federal Government.
I became trans and the relationship I have with my parents became better.
Accepting trans folks heals parent/child relationships. Whatever you're doing is getting placed in a nursing home as far away from your kids as they can get you.
@@mht5875Your political science teacher needs his license revoked.
How should clinicians cause change in the wording on the DSM -4 back to acknowledging biological sex?
Very illuminating presentation by Leor. Bravo!
It seems that heavy lawfare will need to be undertaken to mitigate the terrible policies which have been created to appease those that have an extremely vested interest in being seen as they wish to be seen in society. Even though their wishes destroy the very fabric of society by forcing the rest of us to uphold the most egregious of lies.
What would you suggest imprisonment or death penalty for all transgender people?
"their wishes destroy the very fabric of society by forcing the rest of us to uphold the most egregious of lies" - Exactly this. Well said.
@@biancawilloughby9980 😂 you're funny
@@joce11ever heard of michael shelenburger solution to san francisco drug addiction
@@joce11the regulation by proxy seems mind blowing to me since even if the far left revolutionary are not in political power, they are still able to make a big effect since thay are in institutional power of institutions that will be looked later by judges who are generalists for that reason will just immediately trust the peered reviewed sources & not having a spectrum of sources is a bad idea.
How did the gender ideology movement advance so fast? By standing on the shoulders of all the other movements you cited. And by using the intimidation tactics of our time; fear of being canceled and ostracized, fear of being considered backward, fear of being branded a bigot, and fear of being accused of discrimination and sued.
The basic problem is having a legal definition of "gender identity" when it is so subjective (as with self-id, even by a minor). The "performativities" of Judith Butler more or less correspond to gender identities as claimed. but so do the "polarities" of Paul Rosenfels (from the Ninth Street Center in NYC in the 1970s), who intended this concept to be used by individuals for personal growth only, not for (publicly) classifying and "labeling" (or "pronouning") people for political rights. Rosenfels is less well known (than Butler)but his ideas have essentially been codified as "gender identity" which is not what he wanted.
The Scottish Parliament passed the Gender Recognition Reform Act while neither the Scottish Government, nor the Parliament, nor the text of the Act, had any definition of what "gender" is. It's completely insane.
@@XKenny77u know social reproduction theory?
u know social reproduction theory?
I can't work out any application where gender identity needs legislation and we want to make any tangible effect.
I can think of a thousand ways sex needs protecting in law. In tons of countries we apparently never bothered to put in the basic effort to clearly define terms and prevent loopholes.
The best I can come up with for gender identity is that you can change your name and title on government documents. But that's basically pandering. Otherwise I can't think of any practical applications or needs for gender identity protection. Everything else I run up against the issue that you're requiring ppl to treat some different based on gender identity. That's basically legalizing and enforcing sexism.
There was a time when I thought maybe we'd be able to make some concessions for a tiny group of gender dysphoric post-op trans ppl but I don't actually see any evidence to say they shouldn't be treated like anyone else according to their sex legally.
@@robertmarshall2502drag queens acording to MARXSISTS instill to children that gender is performative
Home of the Brave,
To rewrite a famous quote, “Evil is allowed to persist when good and decent people behave as if they’re cowards.” For now, they have fierce shunning tactics. Speak up and be brave BEFORE laws of punishment are made. All mammals are dimorphic. Period. Stand up for truth. Be like Galileo. Be brave. I know you have a kind heart, use logic and don’t let them gaslight you anymore.
The issue with the takeaways at the end is that regardless of getting these changes, even if that were possible, the people who are in power, examples like school administrators and teachers, will fight against this and continue along the path that meets their beliefs no matter what the law states as we've already seen with things like Affirmative Action where the administrators and teachers found and announced workarounds.
Fascinating thank you
Great talk.
There are only 5.6 million people in Finland, just for an example there are 3.2 million people in Orange county, CA alone, this really is comparing Apples to Oranges. Imagine all of Europe having one agency, that would be more like it.
Sapir is not putting all European countries into one box disregarding all of their differences. He’s putting them in one box with regard to one factor only: Healthcare is paid for by the taxpayers and hence everybody is covered. You don’t need health insurance, calling an ambulance won’t cost the individual in need a single dime - it’s totally free. The same goes for seeing your general practitioner, a specialist in e.g. skin diseases or psychiatry and going to the hospital. You may have to spend two days or two weeks in hospital but you’ll never see a bill. However, in order to justify this freedom all kinds of treatment *must* be evidence based. In the US treatment is based on your wealth and whatever you feel you have a right to get - including scam treatments that are harmless and unnecessary at best and harmful at worst.
So the recent Supreme Court ruling that 2nd amendment people are talking about nullifying many of the ATF regulations.
If I said I was a witch and could see ghosts ......... I'd be accepted by Liberals.
Time to trespass the trans right out the door.
Solution: abolish the regulators. Allow the locals to govern themselves.
Money, power,, legal and political intimidation. Apparently not so strange bedfellows.
Leor Sapir is incredible.
It’s incredibly unfortunate that Phil Illy and his paraphilia has overshadowed all of the great messages brought by Genspect.
You should have known better. It is not Phil’s fault. There is no reason he shouldn’t have been at the conference.
Genspect never should have platformed his book. MAJOR mistake. Rookie mistake, and that makes people not trust you. Please learn from this.
I have to agree, sadly.
And you're helping to keep this "overshadowing" alive by randomly bringing it up in the comments on a great talk that had nothing to do with any of that. Thanks for your service.
No he has'nt, Stay on topic it's too important
It's not just Phil Illy. They link with active transsexuals & support the idea of 'true' transsexuality
@@treesart6914 Nothing was ever gained by sweeping mistakes under the rug and not owning up to them.
Disgusting subject. What happened to our country?
Democrats radicalized so far Left into Marxism, and their blind, loyal voters voted them into governmental power over us and our institutions.
Democrat leaders, that's what happened.
8-10 years ago this wasn’t even a thing now everyone has to subscribe to this nonsense?
Look up "Trans people in the Old West."