It's the old ridiculous notion of just dealing with it. It's the same nonsense like "maintain frame." Feminism is in full swing by 1907. So I'm sure he's really suffering because now they're is more consequences by law for NOT suffering. Poor guy. He needs a patriarchal society. Then he wouldn't have these problems. John and Arthur are in the wrong thinking that you shouldn't control your woman. Also, John married a whore. Which makes Abigail worse than anything John did in his past.
i think all these videos of npc reaction that was unexpected, or interesting.. is what makes people try different routes thru the game(i.e.- being "low" honor arthur, and then trying again as "high-honor arthur" @@murkyturkey5238
Rdr4 he gonna be mad about his advice Rdr5 old 50 old dude mad about jack marston jr advice Rdr6 probably the begging of gta he gonna be made about the advice that jack marston gave him on his deathbed since you can see in gta that jack marston became an author and wrote books giving bad advice about marriage
@@stanleybochenek1862That shouldn’t be an excuse for R* abandoning this game like they did in the first place. They should have a certain category of employees for different games, like one group for GTA V, another group for Red Dead Redemption II and Red dead Online, and etc… they could be a very well organized company, but choose not to because, they are very lazy.
@SergeantRip_ They used to be like that and got nowhere. They now merged the whole team, and everyone is now working on just 1 project. So, every next game will be something special when it finally comes out. Also, I don't see how they abandoned this game? I see regular events on online version or RDR.. i don't play it because both GTA Online and RDR Online are bullshit with 0 RP and awful community. I prefer private servers on RageMP, FiveM, and RedM.
Arthur’s advice is good. He’s just too good for most women, and even he knows true love better than Mary. Arthur’s advice worked because that lady said yes to the kid. But it’s not Arthur’s fault that the woman was bad.
He earned it. He should have just been respectful and taken "no" for an answer instead of coercing and pestering her, but no, his ego couldn't handle it. And now he's suffering the consequences of his actions. He's earned this miserable life. Men need to learn to take "no" for an answer.
Rdr1 ends right before ww1, I wonder if they will ever make a story around ww1. Else I think they will make a story based on the young arthur, dutch and hosea.
That should be a lesson to all desperate people to just be patient. Especially towards men, I've known so many guys desperate to date/marry someone they barely knew.
Damn hahaha that's some cold blooded shit! I love it. Too bad you were unable to follow thru, R* usually really good at making things like that possible. They are usually so dope with the NPC's and their environment & immersion, but I believe they dropped the ball this time... whelp, can't win em all!
either way his life is ruined, if you motivate him to talk to his girl you'll get this scene. But if you provoke or leave him alone he'll just be upset how shes played hard to get but never gave him a chance.
That's actually not funny , it just shows how a multimillion-dollar company has a lazy approach to designing a game ( blame the player at all times) This game has so many restrictions in it I do not know why it's called a free roam game 😂
@@moosemussolini1429 What? Honestly man, I don't get how this is lazy. In any other game an interaction chain like this probably wouldn't even exist. Still one of, if not the most immersive single player game out there. Can you give me a better example of intricate game mechanics?
Why give out advice that you ain't going to take yourself perfect example here you said if you don't like it don't play so I should respond to you with.... if you don't like what I say then stop reading it and don't comment on it we shouldn't go any further you obviously mentally believe the simulated video game is reality.. so we should deal with that first before we get into being a hypocrite
To. Francis813.... You said you don't get it ? you don't get what? you don't get how my opinion is different from your opinion.... how do you not get or understand that You do understand it but you're playing dumb for a cover-up to hide your true emotions of you not liking that I spoke negatively about a game you're obsessed with... And to prove you're Obsession Read below 👇 why would you negatively try to discredit my opinion with your opinion? this means that you mentally believe you're above other people you talk to, but let's make it clearer you're doing this over a video game ...A video game.... a fictional simulated false form of reality🤔 maybe you and the other guy should stop playing this for a while because it's clearly distorting your head Mainly both of you shall understand please seek help
If Arthur give them good advice it turns out the girl gave the kid some disease and that's what he goes on yapping about when you play as John and if Arthur gives the kid a bad advice then the kid forgets all about the girl
no instead he'll just be upset that he wasted his whole life trying to get her and she showed no interest in him. either way his life is ruined and he partly blames Arthur for it.
@@ianloeb1672 that is as Arthur…🤦♂️ edit if you greet him he'll marry her but he's miserable with her and if you antagonize him he wont have the courage to ask her so then he's just miserable because he didnt ask her out and she showed no interest in him.
@@ianloeb1672 either way he’s going to have resentment towards her. I agree with you but then he also doesn’t know what kind of woman she is and thinks he’s missing out on an angel but in reality she’s not the person he really loves. Which do you think would be harder? Marrying someone that you thought you loved but ended up being in a toxic relationship or spending your whole life miserable wishing that person would just show you some interest? I personally probably think getting to know her and hating her is better then spending your whole life wrapped up in being in love with someone you think you love. Both seem like a lose lose though.
There is a message carved in a tree near that river with Lillie-May’s name crossed out and “thanks for the clap” inscribed under it. I can only assume it’s the same lady that this guy married.
“There ain’t so many good men in the world, make yourself one of the good ones. She’ll come around.” That’s literally all he said to the guy. How is this Arthur’s fault? 😂
You say doing low honor? What do you mean ... The whole game your a dishonorable person.. So why do you say it like you HAVE A CHOICE..you don't We all played it before and there is unforgivable things you have to do in game ...so how did you have a choice again? Ohh I get it...your insane and act like your in control when that is not the fact 😂
Literally today I was riding my horse and I was just looking a way for a moment and I accidentally rode into this guy… I recognised him from playing as Arthur so thanks for this😂😂😂
Dude took a strangers advice, got what he wanted, and when it turned out to not be all sunshine and roses blamed the guy who helped him. Seems like a man who won't ever be happy. 🙄
Ngl the ones that hurt the most playing as John were meeting the lady at the homestead Arthur helped survive and seeing rainsfall at the station on the way to Canada
LOL careful what you wish for! The crushes and romance in the beginning are the best, but marriage is like a gator getting closer as I skip pebbles on a pond XD.
Bro blamed the guy he talked to one time for the choice he made 💀
Well he was the one who said to go forward.
When i saw this guy again i just killed him😂
Well he clearly hate marriage, and is miserable.
It's the old ridiculous notion of just dealing with it.
It's the same nonsense like "maintain frame."
Feminism is in full swing by 1907. So I'm sure he's really suffering because now they're is more consequences by law for NOT suffering.
Poor guy. He needs a patriarchal society. Then he wouldn't have these problems.
John and Arthur are in the wrong thinking that you shouldn't control your woman.
Also, John married a whore. Which makes Abigail worse than anything John did in his past.
@@earnem4175 It was his choice to marry
@@henryworks9089 Blinded by Jealousy and love is the reason
If you kill him. John says, "There fixed your problem" 😂
💀💀💀
Its messed up that you know that 😂
i think all these videos of npc reaction that was unexpected, or interesting.. is what makes people try different routes thru the game(i.e.- being "low" honor arthur, and then trying again as "high-honor arthur" @@murkyturkey5238
Bro did not let the insult to arthur slide💀
Sounds like something he’d say
Did bro just call Authur a basturd
Yes
@cosmicsatanas I'll probably kill i kinda beat the game once soo if I find him again as John I'll kill him
I listened to the whole thing, than shot him in the back of the head. Nobody talks about Arthur like that.
@@marcuslehman4458 fr
He deserves to die for that
Imagine in rdr3 you play as like Jack or something and you find this dude again and he’s mad at john about the advice☠️
Three generations of Van DER Linde men ruining marriages lmao
LMFAO
Rdr4 he gonna be mad about his advice
Rdr5 old 50 old dude mad about jack marston jr advice
Rdr6 probably the begging of gta he gonna be made about the advice that jack marston gave him on his deathbed since you can see in gta that jack marston became an author and wrote books giving bad advice about marriage
3 will be another prequel
@@elmizzoxNothing is confirmed.
Hell yeah it’s insane how much detail and effort they put into this game.
Yeah
Rockstar really does care
They just milk gta 5 cause it’s best selling game to make more AMAZING games
@@stanleybochenek1862Best video games company imo.
@@stanleybochenek1862That shouldn’t be an excuse for R* abandoning this game like they did in the first place. They should have a certain category of employees for different games, like one group for GTA V, another group for Red Dead Redemption II and Red dead Online, and etc… they could be a very well organized company, but choose not to because, they are very lazy.
@SergeantRip_ They used to be like that and got nowhere. They now merged the whole team, and everyone is now working on just 1 project. So, every next game will be something special when it finally comes out. Also, I don't see how they abandoned this game? I see regular events on online version or RDR.. i don't play it because both GTA Online and RDR Online are bullshit with 0 RP and awful community. I prefer private servers on RageMP, FiveM, and RedM.
Asking Arthur for a Love Advice is like having John as your Swimming Teacher...
True.
😅😂
Or Micah as your dog sitter.
Excuse me?
Arthur’s advice is good. He’s just too good for most women, and even he knows true love better than Mary.
Arthur’s advice worked because that lady said yes to the kid. But it’s not Arthur’s fault that the woman was bad.
*Morgan Freeman voice* "John then went on to ruin this young man's life even more with his advice."
he already did tell the man to go home 😢
He earned it. He should have just been respectful and taken "no" for an answer instead of coercing and pestering her, but no, his ego couldn't handle it. And now he's suffering the consequences of his actions.
He's earned this miserable life. Men need to learn to take "no" for an answer.
@@fawnieeebro getting mad and making social commemtary over a video game character💀
@fawnieee women also need to learn no, too. It's not just a gender issue as hard as that might be for your neanderthal brain to understand
@@fawnieeebro never heard yes.😂
Arthur may have spent 15 minutes running him over with a horse and pushing him into the river, so I might understand the dislike for Arthur.
That literally what I did🤣🤣🤣
And that's why he call Arthur is bastard.
Well, Arthur may robbed the poor boy at gun point and thrw him tied in the river sooo… justified anger😂
😂😂😂😂
What you did rii
😂😂
It's not Arthur's fault. Sometimes, advice just doesn't work. Arthur didn't ruin his life. Kid just has accelerated anger.
In this case, the advice worked. The problem is that the guy chose the wrong woman.
Arthur ruined his life.
@@scrappy93no he ruined his own Arthur had no idea who he was after
@nazeem214 woman ruins man's life
it's simple case close
@@Dutchy4564Moral of the story: Never listen to mf named Callahan😅
Imagine this kid in Rdr3 being old and talking about John💀
And jack gives him the same advice☠️
Rdr1 ends right before ww1, I wonder if they will ever make a story around ww1. Else I think they will make a story based on the young arthur, dutch and hosea.
@@levvz6113I'd like that, where you can play as those 3 and stuff That'd be peak
i love how almost everyone just shot him after he insulted arthur
"Bastard ruined m-"
*Loads Colt Single Action Army*
“Bastard ruined my life” 😂😂😂
I shot him right then and there 😂
@@zeewaawoowaa2449 thank you for your service
That part cracked me too
@@zeewaawoowaa2449 You did him a favor there and ended his suffer
*aims*
When he called arthur a bastard when I was playing I shot him in his face
You solved his problem, he won't have wife issues anymore
@@mr.goatperson lol
good.... good
Well he was factual.
That makes John the bastard then.
That should be a lesson to all desperate people to just be patient. Especially towards men, I've known so many guys desperate to date/marry someone they barely knew.
Arthur had so much main character energy that he attributes his mistake to the moment he talked to arthur
His little “know what’ll happen” was so realistic
Man did I beat the crap out of him the moment he called Arthur a bastard...
I never do anything evil with John but that time...my hands were itchy.
Arthur actually didnt do anything wrong. This stupid bastard wanted the girl and Arthur only tried to help him.
Still a bastard
Arthur did help em get her, now he's mad that he got her 😂
Did he just call Arthur a bastard? Bro is a gonna be at the bottom of the river like those stones are
Head shorted him when he called Arthur a bastard
“It’s better if you stick to it” poor dudes gonna follow some more bad advice 💀
I tried to follow him home. I was going to off him in front of the Mrs. but he walked around in circles. Don’t you dare talk bad about Arthur! 😂
Lmfaoooooo
Damn hahaha that's some cold blooded shit! I love it. Too bad you were unable to follow thru, R* usually really good at making things like that possible. They are usually so dope with the NPC's and their environment & immersion, but I believe they dropped the ball this time... whelp, can't win em all!
When he said Arthur was bastard my dead eye was full my guns was ready and the crocodiles was hungry
Then Jacks gonna see him crying about how he should've divorced
either way his life is ruined, if you motivate him to talk to his girl you'll get this scene. But if you provoke or leave him alone he'll just be upset how shes played hard to get but never gave him a chance.
This isn’t red dead redemption this is read dead depression
Blew his head off with a double barrel after he talked like that about arthur
For telling the truth? Lol
@@scrappy93what truth? Arthur may be a bastard, but this guy sure as shit doesn’t know that. This guy is just a loser playing the blame game.
@@scrappy93no for lying about a good man
@@Dutchy4564 depends on the playthrough
You turned his cranium into pink mist?
When he called arthur bastard, i filled him with lead.
Hahaha, he's so mad at Arthur, but he was actually trying to help for once. Poor Arthur just can't get it right 😂
That's actually not funny ,
it just shows how a multimillion-dollar company has a lazy approach to designing a game ( blame the player at all times)
This game has so many restrictions in it I do not know why it's called a free roam game 😂
@@moosemussolini1429 What? Honestly man, I don't get how this is lazy. In any other game an interaction chain like this probably wouldn't even exist. Still one of, if not the most immersive single player game out there. Can you give me a better example of intricate game mechanics?
@@moosemussolini1429 lmao I don't think so dude, you're just cranky. This game is a fricken masterpiece. Don't like it, don't play. Easy fix 👍
Why give out advice that you ain't going to take yourself perfect example here you said if you don't like it don't play
so I should respond to you with....
if you don't like what I say then stop reading it and don't comment on it we shouldn't go any further you obviously mentally believe the simulated video game is reality..
so we should deal with that first before we get into being a hypocrite
To. Francis813....
You said you don't get it ?
you don't get what?
you don't get how my opinion is different from your opinion....
how do you not get or understand that
You do understand it but you're playing dumb for a cover-up to hide your true emotions of you not liking that I spoke negatively about a game you're obsessed with...
And to prove you're Obsession
Read below 👇
why would you negatively try to discredit my opinion with your opinion?
this means that you mentally believe you're above other people you talk to, but let's make it clearer you're doing this over a video game ...A video game....
a fictional simulated false form of reality🤔
maybe you and the other guy should stop playing this for a while because it's clearly distorting your head
Mainly both of you shall understand please seek help
*"You remind me of a feller I used to know"*
I stopped talking to him once he called Arthur a Bastard.
He also stopped talking as well because i threw a Molotov at his ass
I put a tomahawk in his loaf and John said at least you've no more problems now 😂
If Arthur give them good advice it turns out the girl gave the kid some disease and that's what he goes on yapping about when you play as John and if Arthur gives the kid a bad advice then the kid forgets all about the girl
Bastard ruin my live😂. He blame Arthur
I like how John is chasing/stalking the guy at the end. 😂
Bruh bout to start over just to come across him again and tell him to kick rocks
What if you antagonize him as Arthur? Will he have a better life in the future?
no instead he'll just be upset that he wasted his whole life trying to get her and she showed no interest in him. either way his life is ruined and he partly blames Arthur for it.
@@georgejones1262they asked what does he do if you antagonize the boy as ARTHUR not JOHN
@@ianloeb1672 that is as Arthur…🤦♂️
edit if you greet him he'll marry her but he's miserable with her and if you antagonize him he wont have the courage to ask her so then he's just miserable because he didnt ask her out and she showed no interest in him.
@@georgejones1262 well you should antagonize him so he doesn’t ask her out so he doesn’t wind up stuck in a miserable marriage
@@ianloeb1672 either way he’s going to have resentment towards her. I agree with you but then he also doesn’t know what kind of woman she is and thinks he’s missing out on an angel but in reality she’s not the person he really loves. Which do you think would be harder? Marrying someone that you thought you loved but ended up being in a toxic relationship or spending your whole life miserable wishing that person would just show you some interest? I personally probably think getting to know her and hating her is better then spending your whole life wrapped up in being in love with someone you think you love. Both seem like a lose lose though.
I can't believe if you put this kid out of his misery you lose honor.
After the nice heart to heart "seeya mister"
"BASTARD RUINED MY LIFE!"
*Quick draw*
I love that Leon Kennedy had to be the voice for this as well lol
@frostverseyt7814 yup apparently
Soon as he talked smack on Arthur I threw hands
There is a message carved in a tree near that river with Lillie-May’s name crossed out and “thanks for the clap” inscribed under it. I can only assume it’s the same lady that this guy married.
Feed to crocodiles for calling Arthur a bastard
His voice when he yells makes me think of Scotty the mechanic
THATS THE KID WHO WATCHED MY HORSE PLUMMET OFF OF A CLIFF AND WATCH ME DROWN AS JOHN!!!!!!
Imagine skipping stones down by the river and then you turn and watch as a grown ass man comes jump skip and hopping out of the forest.
“There ain’t so many good men in the world, make yourself one of the good ones. She’ll come around.” That’s literally all he said to the guy. How is this Arthur’s fault? 😂
The second he said that Arthur is a basturd i drowned him in that river
“Your a good man Arthur Morgan….. your a good man”
I fed him to a gator after he called the GOAT a bastard
Fun fact: This NPC is dubbed by Arthur's voice actor. He's doing a different voice, of course. But it's the same guy.
Anyone else bully this kid as Arthur the first time they met?
On my second playthrough doing low honor when it first came out i clipped him after his remark about Arthur. 😂😂😂
Why in first place you didn't clipped him when played Arthur?)
You say doing low honor?
What do you mean ...
The whole game your a dishonorable person..
So why do you say it like you HAVE A CHOICE..you don't
We all played it before and there is unforgivable things you have to do in game ...so how did you have a choice again?
Ohh I get it...your insane and act like your in control when that is not the fact 😂
@@moosemussolini1429What's wrong with you? Who hurt you? 🤨
@@moosemussolini1429 who let the moron out of the asylum
And then when you come back as jack in rdr3 it turns out johns advice made it worse
Bro I shot that kid as Arthur when I first played 😂
Only game I ever actually listened to NPC’s 😂
Literally today I was riding my horse and I was just looking a way for a moment and I accidentally rode into this guy… I recognised him from playing as Arthur so thanks for this😂😂😂
Arthur told him to be a good man, not a simp
bro would drop to the group exactly 0,5 milliseconds after he called Arthur a bastard
in rdr3 he’ll have a villain arc where he kills her
Life made him smarter
bro had been mad for 8 years💀
Bro jump over there like bugs bunny 💀
Dude took a strangers advice, got what he wanted, and when it turned out to not be all sunshine and roses blamed the guy who helped him.
Seems like a man who won't ever be happy. 🙄
Damn, I'm gonna miss this little detail cause I actually listened to the kid and left him alone like he requested
This channel is a dice roll
The way NPC look downward while they walk amuse me 😅
This the greatest game ever made
I specifically remember this incident when I started replaying the game, I visited him just a few days back
Lmao this was great. I didn't kill him he spoke the truth.
Ohhhh that I could only have John say “aw shoot, Arthur thought he was helpin’. You know that.”
The amount of random hidden jewels in this game is amazing. The fact that people are STILL discovering stuff in 2023 is crazy
"Women problems huh?"
-John Marston
I always tell that kid to give up and laugh at him because I know secretly that’s the start of the good guy play through
Thanks to the random guy i talk to who persuaded me into being a good man ruined my marriage
He didnt react that way with me , was less hostile and more friendly bout it
he really just spoils it without hesitation no warning no nothing
I wonder what he says if arthur never talked to him
This game just keeps surprising me
He never returned to his wife. I followed him around and he just kept walking. I think his story is what inspired Forrest Gump to just keep running.
If you shoot him John will say ,,Just solved your problems''
Things aren't as bad as is looks sometimes. I have to talk to my wife like she's my friend alot of the times in order to get my point across
It also depends on what arthur says if you choose antagonise instead, the boy will later complain about never giving her a shot
Welcome to the club brother.
Jack seeing the same man in 1911 while pasisng by: 🗿
I swear this kid is in the game called The Quarry 😂
Surprised Arthur didn’t step up and skip a rock for Mary lol
Arthur, ruining life cycles, ending lifes prematurely and just being a good man!
Dude has a serious chip on his shoulder. He needs to sort himself out.
its like arthur was the only one he spoke to
I haven’t played much of 2. But it’s weird to hear John just talking and not yelling every single sentence practically 😂
This guy sounds like a goofy charater you would here on spongebob.
These red dead shorts made me buy the game today
Lily may is the one the bartender talks about in valentine. He says “ how many guys asked her to marry her today “
Realized halfway in Arthur's story hes basically everyones dad. I fs funded that camp for any upgrades
Ngl the ones that hurt the most playing as John were meeting the lady at the homestead Arthur helped survive and seeing rainsfall at the station on the way to Canada
I tossed dinomite at the fools feet as soon as he started to talk..
LOL careful what you wish for! The crushes and romance in the beginning are the best, but marriage is like a gator getting closer as I skip pebbles on a pond XD.