How Walking Compares to Cardio
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- In this QUAH Sal, Adam, & Justin answer the question “Does walking count as cardio, or should I incorporate some steady-state cardio like running and/or HIIT? What will keep me healthy, while maintaining the most mass?”
If you would like to get your own question answered, follow us on Instagram where we post QUAH requests weekly.
/ mindpumpmedia
August Promotion: MAPS Performance ½ off!! *Promo code “GREEN50” at checkout*
www.mapsgreen.com/
New Program Launch: MAPS Suspension $20 off! *Promo code “SUSPENSION20” at checkout*
www.mapssuspens...
Maps Fitness Products
www.mindpumpme...
Free resources & guides on building muscle, fat loss, improving mobility, & more:
www.mindpumpme...
Check out the full episode 1359 here:
Video - • #1359: Physical and Me...
“How Walking Compares to Cardio“
LIKE this video if you learned something new!
COMMENT your thoughts on this topic.
SUBSCRIBE for more valuable fitness content!
#MindPump
CONNECT WITH US:
INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/mindpump...
TWITTER: bit.ly/2vN1qpE
FACEBOOK: bit.ly/2vq95cd
SHOP MIND PUMP:
bit.ly/2uvQY6b
PRIVATE FACEBOOK GROUP:
bit.ly/2vuntia
PODCAST:
iTUNES - apple.co/2vMEPcA
STITCHER - bit.ly/2hQSIAS
I was a runner for 30 years, and I have arthritis in both my knees, bone on bone, I’m 62, and now I walk 45 to 60 minutes 5 to 6 days a week, my knees feel so much better as well as my body in general, no more pounding on my body.
I used to run, do mini marathons, up until my right hip started giving me issues. Now I walk as well the last couple of years.
Absolutely
You got it. 💞💞❤
Sounds good dean im now 61 i think ill take your advice
How fast do you walk?
I'm astounded that people ask if walking is cardiovascular exercise. Seriously? People have been misled. A brisk 60-90 minute walk with hills and stairs included is fantastic cardiovascular exercise. Every runner I know has experienced chronic injuries to hips, knees, ankles, shins (me included). It's so hard on the body, yet so many people think they have to do it. I enjoy the topics you guys cover in the podcast. Thx and best regards
Sure but even that gets easy and then people want to know how to push themselves harder. Myself included. I walk all day at work and go for a leisurely walk after work to wind down. None of this pushes my body at all. Walking is great exercise for many, but not for those who are already doing physical activity all day, every day lol
Agreed. Knowing how to increase your heart rate and respiratory rate is key.
@@kodyramon That is an excellent point. In fact I have never heard anyone explain this more simply or clearly. Your point is that walking is very good for the body but if you are doing it every day it doesn't require anything special from the body because the body already adapted long ago. And if you want to see physique changes, you would need to add something different in.
@@hopefulforhumanity5625 If you live near mountains then hiking up and down steep trails or even going off trail can add a massive challenge even if you are walking slowly. The terrain differences and obstacles force you to think and to adapt and overcome
We live in this modern bullshit of no pain no gain cultural mentality.
I have tried many forms of exercise in my over 50 years of living..the one exercise I feel I will always need in my life is walking.
Walking has really worked for me. I've gone from 263 lbs. to 195 lbs. over the past three years (I am 6' 1"). I've increased my strength during this time as well. I can relate to what is being said; for me walking works because it is SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Timely).
did you lose muscle as well or did you just shed the extra fat
@@MAN9027 I maintained my strength by doing daily pushups.
How long do you walk for??
I’m 6’0 started at 295 now at 266 and counting just lifting and walking.
Having dogs has been such a blessing for not only a handful of other things but walking them everyday reaching 10k steps a day is effortless. Its a win win for both me and my dogs it keeps them happy and keeps me stronger .
I go for a short 5-10 min walk down the block every hour or so when I'm working at my desk. Doing this has been a game changer for my health, body comp and happiness. If you're sedentary all day you just feel like shit, and a long bout of exercise at the end of the day doesn't help much.
anytime someone gets to walk is good. not everyone has your schedule
Work out a few days a week and walk every day and you are set for life, for ever.....
FOR-EV-VER 🙌⚾️
Perfect that’s what I’ve been up to the past few months.
as simple as that.
3 years later and this is still the greatest fitness advice
Ive never been in as good shape in my life as i was when i was doing two 45 mins of a walk twice a day and lifting 5 time a week
Sounds good. You just have to manage your daily time properly to be able to do the things you mentioned.
Cardio is anything that raises your heart rate and respiratory rate. As long as the cardiopulmonary system is being improved its cardio. So each individual persons fitness level determines what is cardio. Over weight and new to exercise walking is cardio.
Beating yo meat raises your heart but that ain cardio
if you beat your meat for 30 minutes and you get up to 50-60% of your max heart rate, it's cardio brother@@SurfyStories
I've been doing interval incline walking and I've dropped pounds faster than when I was running. Also previously after my runs, I was ravenously hungry like a wild bear....after the walks, I was only thirsty.
So true ppl tend to think running is better because its more exhausting but walking is the absolute best
Walking is the way and the truth. Best exercise hands down
Exactly: goals must be obtainable but life changes must be sustainable!
I ran from early 30's to age 59 and I was burned out and sore. Ran 5k, 10k and 1/2 marathons and then it wasn't fun any more. I walked and eventually walking 3-5 miles. I found a gym and dumb bells and what a game changer! I also swim 2-3x a week and I'm loving it all at age 65.
"Walking is the best medicine" - Hippocrates
Did he say so ?
It’s laughter. And the bible say so. A merry heart do good like a medicine
Golf. Carry the bag. Walk for 6, 9, 15 or 18 holes among the trees surrounded by nature. Good cardio for your heart rate and for your mind.
I agree. I use to walk 6 days a week. I walked about 10 to 15 miles a week. I felt great and I looked healthy tone. I loss like 60lbs. It was definitely fat weight. I worked out 3 to 5 days a week. Anywhere from 30mins to 2 hours but it was light work outs. I'm working to get back to that lifestyle. Best feeling ever. Good luck to anyone who is wantin, lookingforward, and currently on that walking goals to making life better.
4 10 min walks after meals will help keep blood sugar low.
In what world is walking NOT considered cardio? If you walk fast enough, especially on hilly terrain, it will get your heart rate up just like running, stepping or classes. It absolutely is cardio.
Walking is a good start. Running needs preparation and time. Combining both is a blessing. Just don't overdo it
Yeap, I know a guy who said he could run for like 5 hours continuously but now he has knee issues. Another one I know has hip fractures. Running sux and people back in the pre agricultural age only did it if they had to.
I walk 2.5 miles a night at a fast im overweight cancer survivor and i pneumonia kinda wrecked my lungs so working out isn't easy as it use to be
Keep it up. And have faith in God my brother.
You got it bro! You’re already built different for being a cancer survivor! Just keep pushing and take it one day at time 💪🏾
God bless
Also 👉🏼 Eat LESS carbohydrates and MORE vegetables. 100% CHANGED my life for the better 💪🏼
@@sfrealestatedealmaker6001 vegetables are carbohydrates...
Mike Tyson said he would walk for hours a day in addition to his training emulating great Roman warriors of the past. 🥊🥊🥊
Really?
@@JavaughnJPorter yerp. 100%.
@@JavaughnJPorter the other example that comes to mind is all the damn golf Michael Jordan would play on top of his training. Like 18 holes a day sometimes.
I feel better walking because i get to appreciate the view and something i look forward to unlike running which i used to dread. i still insert some short burst of run from time to time but at least i dont feel pressured to do so. walking and resistance training i learned to love
Totally. I don't drive. I rarely use public transport because I incorporate my exercise into the daily tasks I have to do. I wall a few kilometers a week carrying groceries etc and this counts as lifting. I'm very fit.
Well, at least 10,000 steps everyday. Yes, do Strength Training, and even some HIIT or/and cardio. But I try to get those "steps" in if I can.
Back in college I walked everywhere with my 10lb backpack full of books. I was rucking and walking without even knowing it! And that was the best shape I was ever in.
If your lower back can handle it- rowing is also a great option for cardio I think a lot of people overlook
I love rowing! I call it the row row row your boats haha
yes i turn on an audio book and row very enjoyable
I'm unable to row slow enough for it to be steady state cardio. For whatever reason, idk.
If i do 2k after it I'm basically dead but a 5k or 10k row? Might as well just walk
@@TheInsaiyan rowing is a combination of stroke rate and leg drive. If you’re interested I would suggest just slowing down your recovery. Walking is great if you’re just trynna burn calories, but as a rower, it’s what I enjoy lol
@@TheInsaiyanTurn the drag factor handle on the side to 5, slow down the stroke rate to between 18 and 22 but drive harder with your legs, 70% of your power should come from legs don't arm row as you'll tire faster aim for a stroke rate of 20 and you'll be able to go for an hour
You can make walking intense by increasing incline. I do most of my zone 2 by walking.
💪
ive been doing some high intensity cardio for the bast 5 weeks or so and I am absolutely burned out of that crap, time to fall back to my daily steps and 3 times a week weight training 😤
Walking can definitely be cardio, especially if you make it a brisk walk with hills, your heart rate gets up there.
Mine used to get up there now I gotta like speed walk to get a heart rate I wonder if its needed or if I can still just walk
Started walking in Jan and do about 12-14 miles a day now. Was so out of shape that there was no other way to get started beside just MOVING. I've lost 45lbs since then by just keeping carbs low as well. It's been life changing. Problem is that it takes like 3-4 hours a day to walk that far, but I was sitting for that long either way before. I'm not going back!
Walking is cardiovascular exercise. I think some people feel that they have to walk longer distances and spend more time as it becomes easier, but you could also just walk faster pump your arms, hilly terrain, as long as your heart rate is where it’s supposed to be for moderate intensity activity you’re doing 150 minutes a week of that you’re doing pretty well for maintaining health. now weight loss is another story that might be more about calorie Restriction
Running is necessary if your overall energy expenditure is not high each day. Sure if you have time in the day to walk for an hour or two then fine, running isn't necessary. But if you don't have the time, walking isn't going to burn the calories necessary to make up your lack of activity.
For cardio, I do Tabata intervals 3 days a week but I walk for at least 40 minutes every day. I love the combination especially using walking as a cooldown for both Tabata and for lifting.
I love HIIT. best feeling ever
A hummer is up there too!
said no one ever
I am extremely lucky that cycling became my passion in the late 1980’s. I am 60 and ride my mountain bike 3-4 times a week. Low impact and so much fun.
Anytime your heart raises moving under your own steam is cardio.
I walk about an hour and a half a day I burn like 600 calories
As a trainer these guys are well in tune and just know their shit 💯💯💯
You say that yet they say walking does not count as carido, yet goes to say it keeps your cardio vascular system healthy.
I work at home depot, (so interesting right lol) my job consists of lifting a ton of products, push loads of carts, I often average 20K steps each shift. I didn't know how much I weighed beforehand, but I have lost quite a bit of weight. In my thighs, around my stomach. In April of this year, I got 600K steps just from working. I understand that that's not an ideal number to but for most people unless they're walking constantly like I am, but walking definitely helps.
That job is tough hang in there used to work there
@@aleco678 haha I'll try thanks, I have back problems every other week :(
Excellent comparison at the end "slow death"
Yup ... including the hamster comment. so true
Power walking is the VERY BEST!!!
Also looks gay as fu....
@@Wargwarn yeah I would be power walking early in the morning when it's dark and no one could see me there's no way in hell that I would power walk in public in front of other people.
I'm on this video because I pace around my yard like a full time job
i run for the runner's high
Me too! I like runners high. I get runners high at 20 mins lol
Hang on, I walk, on a 10 degree incline at 6kph for 30 minutes. I hit a heart rate of 170. I’m male, 62. That’s a workout, I’m drenched in sweat by the end of it. Not cardio?
People who can't run can do speed walking which gets your heart rate high like 160+. Try that and tell me it's not cardio.
Absolutely.
Walking is da bomb. We were designed to WALK!!
Not designed to run?
@@kamalahmed5057 Running is great too, if you have the right body and place for it. The beach and XC are da bomb for jogging!
@@stevewitt3697 I agree in that the surface is important, but for those of us that live in cities with only the road, can the choice of running shoe not make up for the lack of “softer more cushioned” surfaces to run on? Also Whats an XC?
@@kamalahmed5057 XC Stands for cross country. Like running in the woods or on dirt roads. I guess in the city a park might work? Good road shoes definitely help. Some folks jog on the track at their local high school.
walking can be cardio if it's done right. I walk briskly, 4 mph, and include hills. my HR is really up there, even though I'm fit. steadystate for 80 mins is a great workout. Iost 30 lbs of fat and I've got frog legs.
I don’t do cardio. If you can see the lining of your abs don’t do cardio just walk. Don’t destroy your bone density by running everyday.
Its not cardio but it keeps your cardiovascular system healthy...hmm that doesn't make sense
He didn't want to explicitly disagree with him as it could have been sort of disrespectful
@@adritrace88 they need to define cardio then
Exactly wtf🤣🤣
What about hiking because I am always climbing is it more of a workout ?
Works the same!
Does walking build stamina?
As a 64 fat lad who used to be very fit I started walking and it has been revelatory.
What about weighted walking, like with a heavy backpack? Is that more efficient/healthier/ does it make you stronger? Is it bad for your back/posture or good for it?
I wouldn't do it. I used to ruck march like that all the time in the army and it takes a toll on your back and shoulders and probably the spine. Walking without extra weight is enough, just walk fast for like 30 - 60 minutes without stopping. It makes you feel great.
I walk 3 hrs a day way better then running and injuring yourself 🤟🏿
I always was right when I used to go to the park with a group of people they start to run right away and when I see them running it's just ridiculous they way they were running all out of shape, me on the other hand I just started to walk.
Walking is cardio though? Low/medium intense cardio doesn’t decrease muscle mass at all. Running decrease muscle mass though
@@Adam-nu9gu Cross country runners? Sprinters only run 2 -3 times a week. They are mostly in the gym weight lifting. This is wrong
I'm doing 3 days of workout and 2 days of football (soccer), for me as a skinny guy it's enough
I enjoy cycling but I don’t enjoy weight lifting lol this is funny because how you’re talking about people and cardio is me and weightlifting. I’m strength training because I have to
Walking is Cardio medically speaking. If you walk at least 5-6 kph on hilly terrain. It keeps you healthy however isn’t suited for building up stamina
Keeps cardiovascular system healthy but isn't cardio? What is cardio short for again?
Walking is great!
I power walk on the treadmill for 1hr twice a week then do full body workouts thrice.
I tried to run 1.5miles every day 4-5 days a week for 2 months but my left heel started hurting on day 3-4 of each week. Now Im doing body strength training 3 times a week and running 1.5 miles twice a week
I’m training since I’m 13 now in 34yo 80kg I’m around 20% body fat 1,78 cms I started implementing cardio walking on inside treadmill at home fasted 7-8am and weight at 6-7 pm I’m leaner I lost around 4-6 kg but I also feel bigger bigger muscles , also my calves are growing ( I always split train twice a week legs ) both days I do calves but after I used treadmill this last two months I feel tigher calves and growing almost weekly I have been getting compliments lately 😅also upper body feels bigger it’s surprising for me due to my years training natural after 20+ years training you kinda stop gaining muscle that fast , compared to the first 5 years of training
What do you think about riding a bike? Does 10km a day do anything significant?
Its definitely beneficial
Better for the body than running thats for sure
It’s funny you say that about running because I have ran across this with clients they don’t know how to run . Doing track in high school I didn’t realize during warm ups these were the mechanics to running
10k in 45 minutes is at least jogging speed. That's like a 9 minute mile pace, normal people aren't walking that fast. 45 minutes of walking will net close to 4500-5000 steps, maybe a little more if your pace is faster, but definitely not 10k steps.
Is Doug wearing a U-Dub hat? Doug RULES!
I Walk 9 Miles A Day To Even Out Paul Saladino's Macros On My Caloric Load 🚶🏽 Testing If Metabolism Increases
How many miles are we talking for a daily walk? Pretty much described how I like to look with the “healthy, lean” remark. I like to get 2-3 miles in, should I increase or decrease.
I enjoy lifting weights and running. It tires me listening to strength trainers put down running like it’s bad. “We don’t grow up running” Bullshit, you didn’t play sports as a kid or run around the block with your friends? No we didn’t do long distance running. BUT, running is a skill, sound familiar? Trainers also like to preach about efficiency. Running is the most efficient form of cardio, not even debatable.
Yes, some of the points he is making are just plain ridiculous. Running has been a common form of aerobic activity for hundreds of thousands of years - evolutionarily our bodies are built in a way that allows us to run from dawn to dusk. And as you have mentioned earlier, as kids we can run effortlessly but when we grow up we tend to lead a sedentary lifestyle, develop severe muscle imbalances and simply forget what it means to be running. On top of that, modern running shoes exacerbate these problems allowing people to heel strike and internalize wrong movement patterns...
As for walking, the guy saying that walking is not cardio just doesn't seem to understand what cardio really is. Walking is the purest form of cardio. It's the best way to actually lose weight as bodyfat melts away at a fairely low heart rate (115-130bpm) which can be easily maintained while... well, while walking.
Sick of hearing these pseudo trend methods for weak folk always looking for an easy route. Everyone would be lean and in shape if they just had to walk.
I give!! If I buy the full boat Crossrope package will I stop seeing their continuous adds?!?!?
I think covid messed a lot of people up. Got them into the home workouts lile jumping rope and whatnot. Good exercise, yes, but no subsitute for walking! I cannot believe how micu better I feel since starting to walk more and more.
Walk backwards as well
Do we differentiate between walking and cardio as below or above the lactate threshold? So zone 2 training we put in the same category as walking here.
Walking is the best cardio - Sun Tzu, Art of War
I always belived in nature ... and nature made us to walk the plains of Africa for days tracking prey ... with small sprints. And humans evolved for millions of years doing this. So this is what i do.
Thoughts on HIIT for getting shredded? Before or after workouts for athletes that play baseball football and or basketball?
Diet. Can out train a bad diet.
I'm in my 40s and walk everyday and lift but still have a pot belly, despite watching my calories. When I used to run I was slim. I hate to say it but if you want to lose weight walking probably is not going to cut it. Maybe if you're really fat, but if you wanna lose that last 20 or 30 pounds you need to run. It's the only way. I wish it weren't because I HATE running.
I walk 7 miles daily for work. I can’t add cardio if I wanted to my legs can’t recover
For the love of Glob man! Millionaire hoy stretches, he's got 30 and 60 minute videos, at least once a week or you're going to murder your hips and lower back, plus leave the rest of your leg muscles unhealthily hard as rocks
Walking is cardio, because it’s a physical form of aerobic exercising.
I like to practice running so I can be more agile , nothing wrong with a little exercise
Is 5 miles a day too much. I’m overweight strength training 5 days a week
I'd recommend 3 but then again, I'm just some internet dude.
sounds like it if its higher intense cardio. Depends on what ur goals are mainly cardiovascular or strength. if u want to be stronger mainly weight train and focus on ur metabolism . Our metaboilsms are the furnace for fat burning. You will be able to eat more cause u burn more . (clean calories mostly ) . We all underestimate the importance of REST.... Its when we recuperate . The constant need to do more is actually the opposite of what we really need to do. Ran way too many years was up and down in weight for decades. Wasn't sustainable. Also so much cardio made me eat way more than I should have. Pay attention to your hunger signals . All I do now is walk everywhere and on weight training days with a slight incline 20 or so minutes and I've been able to keep my weight stable while getting stronger.
Intervals.
Doesn’t aerobics utilize all body parts?
.. I get down to 4% without cardio .. I just out-diet everyone and walk a lot on my job all day long .. I own a gym and have many PT clients .. I train with high intensity and minimum volume, getting PR's all the way to the very end before a show .. I do zero cardio, but a lot of moving and shaking .. Unless someone is in horrible physical shape, steady state cardio is surely not enough 'cardio' to contribute one iota to ones heart health or cardiovascular efficiency .. It would take a lot more than that .. A set of heavy high rep squats for instance?
When I first started walking my heart rate would be high now tht I'm lean i can walk forever without my heart rate going up. To lose body fat fat do u think I need to start moving faster? Or does it not matter for fat loss
@@tylerandleahcanadian3888 just lower your calories
@@Perryspowerhousefitness already eat only 1600 a day
@@Perryspowerhousefitness im losing weight tho I just am around the corner from abs and want to speed the process up I think im gna up my cardio a bit and maybe drop my cal to 1500 but I refuse to go lower then tht
@@Perryspowerhousefitness im a 155lb male
Totally true that most people run with poor form.
Walking doesn't get you to zone 5 and doesn't work on your VO2Max, which is #1 important factor in your longevity
So walking at 6km/h or cardio at 8.5 km/h better?
i tired running and then sprinting but i would break out in zits and pimples and i hated it. so i was like fk it and now i walk about 4 and a half to five miles everyday
How long should it take to walk 10k steps. I just started every morning and in 45min I'm at 6500. Guess I'm walking to slow?
It takes me about an hour and a half
0:44 everyone runs growing up no? Sports, school, play.
Any athlete trying to use walking for cardio is making a huge mistake. I tried this for six months, at 15,000 steps a day. My cardio went into the gutter.
GO DAWGS
the bro sience is big in this one.........
I walk minimum 10000 steps to 20000
I walk more than an hour from home to the gym
The meathead who says walking isn't cardio is lumping all walking together. When I do 45-60 minutes at 3 MPH on a 5-degree incline, my heartrate and sweat let me know it's cardio. It's much more intense than the walking I do throughout the day.
I love walking I do 30,000 - 40,000 steps a day. My recovery from training is so much better than people around me. Walking alone would never get me fit for martial arts etc though.