Your Boundary | Jake Roper | TEDxVienna
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- When does our real life become indistinguishable from our digital one? Is there a line between who we are, what we are, on social media versus who we are in reality? Is there still a distinction between the two? Jake Roper hosts, produces and writes Vsauce3 - a science CZcams channel with over 3.3 million subscribers, where he shares his excitement for the real-life science behind gaming, movies, comics, and more via ultra-cinematic explorations. To truly blend those worlds, Jake has been known to enlist the help of guests such as Bill Nye, Neil deGrasse Tyson, The Muppets, Paul Rudd, Jack Black, Steve Martin and Rihanna. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
I feel sad for him, the audience was so so unresponsive. I wonder how he felt while talking
Nah, I have been to couple of Vienna's TEDx talks and they are usually quiet. I think that it is caused by the culture. Austrians are learned not to interupt anybody, so they don't. Just a culture :)
i think it is also the environment. It is a very formal environment and it is harder to really 'react' when everyone else is formal and quiet. You don't really want to be that One Guy.
EdwardFlash Your Words Have Meaning Mr Hokage
He’s used to talking to a camera which also doesn’t clap or laugh.
But I also think that he said some things that wasnt in the script and when he did and the audience didnt say anything, I think he kind of felt awkward and moved on not so smoothly.
The audience though... no reaction
The mic didn't pick up anything from the audience, it's only streaming audio from Jake's stage mic
So it's not necessarily that there's no audience reaction, it's that we can't hear them if they did. Anyway, you can see some of them smiling and laughing in the B-roll cutaways.
I have already said it in another comment, but:
When I went to a Tedx talk, we were asked to keep quiet so the recording would be clean and the speaker wouldn't get interrupted
Jorvanius the reactions will be right HERE in the comments :) he was great
you can hear coughing from the audience
The problem is that people who would appreciate this humor dont go to TEDx. I ask my self if this people even anderstend english.
What is "Myself" - Vsauce music starts playing
And how much does it weigh?
And how much is it worth?
What color... is “myself”?
And how fast is it?
Does it work on the speed of light?
Is the audience dead Jesus, give Jake a hand clap...sometime
I think it's just muted, you can barely hear the laughing when it's there
bad luck for jake
I'm pretty sure the audience was incapable of digesting this type of humor/presentation.
Ater they laughed and smiled but the mic couldn't pick it up properly, you can still hear it fairly though.
audience was dead... but so was I. Full-body cringe during the whole talk. I was so embarassed for him
Wow, rough audience jake deserves more
The audience was probably mainly austrian and most of them probably just got really confused by the slides as their english skills might be a bit lacking
They were laughing tho, you just didn't hear them too much. The slides showed quite a bit of laughing
This audience doesn’t deserve Jake.
Melanie Anne Ahern Well, the humor was suspended on the slides.
Also in Vienna, so that may play into the reactions.
Pretty sure nobody laughed because Jake didn't expressly tell them to laugh; comedians, for instance, laugh a little bit during/after a joke, to signal to the audience that the joke was funny.
Jake only did that at the end, after everybody decided this wasn't worth laughing over and that he's a serious boi
It's so painful watching this guy trying to be funny :/ Sorry, but it's the truth. The jokes are really not funny.
I haven't watched the video yet but the audio at Ted is really good and the mics don't capture the audience sounds
Jake is such an amazing, talented person. I'm so happy he's done this talk
Tamira Clementi he dudes much better one earlier.
Tamira Clementi Yess
Loved the comedy. Hated the audience for not laughing lol.
it wasnt funny thats why. just cringy and awkward
I was there, there actually was quite a lot of laughter. The mics just didn't pick it up, or they cut it out.
This is like one of those awkward memes where someone edits out all the clapping and laughs... yikes
Sam Hansen TV u don't need to edit out anything. This crowd probably doesn't even know what a meme is.
Sam Hansen TV lol I had this idea
Some guy called DogBeef did it
Flunitrazepam yea. He made it even more awkward. If possible
He looks so nervous and the crowd isn't helping. This was really good though.
The audience are likedead inside, he's getting more and more nervous because no one is laughing.
Saunterblugget Hampterfuppinshire So you noticed his nervousness but not the fact that he used that for lack of content? I could barely watch the end.
jake makes me so riduclously happy. he always cheers me up and i'm so glad he exists
world needs more people like Jake
*Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term Bush deserves a third term*
That crowd was quiet af
Poor jake, he was talking to a bunch of unemotional robots
I'm an empty slide.
I'm an empty slide.
□
Such a cool talk! I really just love seeing Jake express himself
This talk is really well done, proud of you Jake!
ughhh..... such a tough crowd
poor jake
i still like the talk though
i wish the audience appreciated you more Jake, this was awesome!
@JakeRoper, I’ve been watching your videos for years (through cancer & FactSurgery) - and this video just reaffirmed my opinion that you are AWESOME.
You’re an artist and science/pop geek at the same time. You’re self-presentation is unbelievably non-typical male, and your expression feels deeply authentic - which is so rare in this medium and others. And you truly question everything when other content providers simply drone on to give people what they want.
And here, with one of the most difficult audiences I have ever seen, you communicate a message which is the most relevant in our changing world of social media. I wish more people could see this and understand how deeply it affects us all.
Thank you @Jake , for just being you!
This audience is deader than Vsauce2
Dewy Your grammar is more dead than the audience.
Your facts are more dead than your grammar. Vsauce2 still posts content.
Watching this before it blows up...
Aye, I'm here
It still hasn't and won't.
It's not a veitch talk
it wont
Sinom ayyyyy
Dino yep
None of them are Jake's Subscriber.
Always a joy to see Jake doing things outside youtube! This reminds me a lot of his video he made a while ago on the same topic.
And the way he jokes with the audience is quite entertaining. For all the comments upset at the audience, the mic does not pick up their reaction.
JAKE ! No matter what anybody comments, I personally think you're super cool.
I’m wondering if that audience speak English?
The audience wasn’t “dead” there was just no mic picking up the audience. You can hear faint laughter from Jake’s mic, and you can see the audience react at the b-roll shots.
this talk made me think about plato and his theory about forms, that there is an ideal version of a thing - the perfect version. Its that us, as persons, have different versions but can become collectively called as such. "persons". in which we all have different personalities, but not really, its more of a "thing" than a personality. Learned something from today
This was a good talk. Honest, raw, brave & funny. Nicely done, Jake!
What he's expressing opens apprehensions about starting on CZcams I haven't known how to put into words
Really liked it, very relatable... I haven’t posted anything on social media for years cause I don’t really think I’m in any way interesting enough for other people to care. In a way no one really is, no one is authentic on social media and that kinda bugs me that people try so hard. Anyway really interesting line of thought.
Ps. Your girlfriend has the cutest accent jake
This is now one of my favorite talks of all time. Great job, Jake.
I totally understand how jake feels on this topic. And it is so true. Thanks for the talk Jake, you helped out a lot!
I think his point here was primarily that the online representation of yourself is a part of you that you share online, because of validation or other reasons. You make "you" a company that other people see, and you want those that visit your "store" to enjoy themselves. If people don't like something, you "stop selling" it, the shallow reason is to "give them what they want", even though it may affect you in such a way you start to distance your true self from the company of "you". You end up becoming a character, one you really like (because it's nice to be liked) and one you don't let go of because it's nice to feel a sense of purpose when you might not really know.
I think here, in a sense, the idea is "all these social outlets are different and hold different pieces of me... I hope that I can encapsulate myself online in a way that becomes meaningful when you take these different pieces and bring them together, so that you might know the things I like the most about me, or who I am".
Another great point is that I (personally) think that there are too many people that can't differentiate their "business" and their "personal" self online. I can see the difficulty in basically operating a "business" like being a CZcamsr, while still trying to be honest with who you are and how you represent the company of "You". "I don't like myself very much" also says "I don't like myself but I'm attracted to the validation I get when I share a part of me online".
Just trying to make sense of things, and share my thoughts on this. I have followed Jake since before he got cancer, and love his videos.
Interesting talk, TEDx-Jake. I've had these kinds of thoughts pretty often as well, to be honest.
infinitesheldon because it's pretty cringy
infinitesheldon Thoughts about not posting about Apple products?
For the record, I loved Fact Hunt
“Nothing is real”...way to connect there Jake.
I mean I prefer to actually just live side by side with my friends and family so we can tell and show each other how we love them and express that which we need through speech or body language/actions taken to one another.
Judging by the audience's reaction.... he's not gonna do that again (if he follows what he had presented).
I personally loved the presentation and how down-to-earth he is (though entertainment is all an act).
and the applause at the end? and all the laughing and coughing you hear in all the other TED talk videos? Jake just ended up with a bad crowd man.
i like this version of jake
Thanks Jake for sharing about "yourself" :)
I kinda wish I was there, seeing as I live in Vienna. Jake was adorable and the fact that the audience rarely reacted to his jokes must‘ve been painful for him.
I love this. I appreciate his humour so much.
To everyone saying this audience is basically dead: there are no microphones pointed at the audience. Therefore, we can't actually gauge their reaction properly.
they're all mesmerized by his eyebrows...
He deserves another chance at TEDx.
I was there. You can not blame hundreds of audience that they did not laugh at the jokes. It was a nice talk anyway
Jakeee yes so proudddd
That talk is ingenious!
YEAH JAKE! awesome presentation !
Loved the talk❣️
He makes good points
We love you Jake
This was engrossing and deep!
Loved this one! The crowd is very still, typical for Vienna! Haha
Jake was fantastic
Dunno if jake's reading comments on here but he did a really brilliant and funny speech, yet that audience was so ungrateful for it. Remember always that most of the time your audience finds you, and these weren't your people. However, I'm still glad you did the talk because it was relayed to us here, your people. And I AM CLAPPING AND LAUGHING HERE! :D
Loved it. Cheers
Wish could attend to one of this talks of my fave one day
Is this for real? This guy was spot-on when he said "his 'idea' was not worth spreading". Watched till the end to see if he would have a point, he never did.
I get it, totally makes sense...thank you Jake!
I liked Roper, but that audience... Jeez.
"Jake doesn't condone nuclear war." That's some quality satire.
This was great.
Wow, such a quiet crowd. I'm here laughing at every joke, while this crows is quiet as frick :c
Cool video!
Wow that was amazing. This needs to see more people. Jake just take this and put it into a video. It is so good, awesome information and its interesting. I have not realized having "me" being separated into other types of "me". But it's so true and so cool and interesting. You have to make this on VSauce3
I enjoyed those stop motion videos
Wow this was awesome
I was literally flossing while he talked about flossing.
Everyone in the comments are so negative; feeling sorry for him ect. But I’m all honesty he did a good job and it was a well thought out idea
Y'all if you actually pay attention you can hear people laughing when appropriate. It's just very quiet (on purpose) so you can hear him clearly. They likely turn down the audio from the audience when they make too much noise so it doesn't overpower him.
Jake Roper is my effing Hero
I thought the slides were quite clever. Together with his physical presentation, they were a practical representation of his idea of him "self". Each slide was sparse, containing a little "content", that Jake wanted the audience to see. Accompanying each slide were notes, containing much more "content", that Jake did not want the audience to see. Similarly, the version of Jake represented on stage is a version of him "self" that he wants the audience/viewers to see.
It raises the question: does anyone ever see the real "self"? Or only a version of the self that you are comfortable sharing with people [in any given situation]? Which version of you is you?
I don't know if Jake Roper intended any of the above. I'm probably just reading too much into it.
I'm gonna go have an existential crisis now.
Jake... bro... calm down. You seem so nervous. You’re a great presenter. You have many ideas worth spreading.
yo, I love Jake soooooooo mUCH!
Pretend there's no audience. It's just a normal Vsauce3 video.
glad they got the audio right this time, his last talk had some of the lowest quality audio ever.
Seems like Jake wants/needs more genuine relationships. I hope more people are as done with/exasperated by social media. CZcams is the last thing I post on that's publicly accessible so I understand the frustration with the social media facade.
oh gosh I flinched so bad when there was no response
For some reason the entire audience isn't on the same wavelength as Jake
TEDx Talks
A Jake Roper Film
Not gonna lie, it’s a bit sad to see how vulnerable and awkward people you only know online are when stuck in front of a live audience or reality.
But I guess it’s important.
Still with everything else stripped out they always look sad and scared, and I worry about whether what they do makes them truly happy or not.
Jake’s a good kid, I like the him I see on here. I can say the same about Tristin, Jack, and Tim (the latter 2 whom I’m friends with on Facebook).
I just hope that the enthusiasm he seems to have for life is just as strong when he’s alone and the cameras and computer are off.
2:42 The audience is laughing, even at his more minor jokes. You just can't hear the audience
ayy
How come this video has only had 1.1K views so far?
Damn man. You are truly a human just like me and you are willing to express it... Really admire you man, would love to be your friend hahaha
bravo !
To the people criticizing the audience: Austrians are more reserved. I assure you they liked the talk, but you'll have to substitute the sensible chuckles with loud laughter.
This dude lives to others eyes.
Poor Jake. The crowd was dead silent even though he was great
So was this just Jakes awkward therapy session?
I'm sad to learn that Fact Surgery didn't do well. I really enjoyed those, but I did forget about them until he brought them back up. Maybe he will do a throw back to them someday in the future.
wow this audience sucks. Such a good talk about our digital selfs, Jake deserved a better crowd. Good on you Jake!!
Guys I think the mic just didn't pick up the sounds from the audience
Good music bro
Between this and his last video on vsauce 3, I've become worried.
They should have invited some of his CZcams subscribers to be in the audience. But I did watch Michael's talk in Vienna and his audience was much better
Sarcasm is the ultimate sword
The meaning and central premise of the talk slowly slipped away because of the extreme lack of interaction and reaction from the audience. The silence is certainly deafening.
Yeap, maybe that was not the best audience because they don't know the social media Jake. But I know some of the social media Jake and I love him. And I laughed at the jakes.
Jakes the frickin’ best
wow that's a tough crowd