Joe didn’t like Ryan’s performance in this demo, so he fired him from the band and locked him in a pit of letters, forced to read letters from fans all day.
woah i never noticed this. i always played this on shuffle in a playlist without bothering to check what's playing lol. just realized when i tried looking up this specific demo
for some reason the whole song made me laugh SO HARD 'there was a lot of water.' 'i like the way it feels upon my brain'. 'the garage was flooded.' 'blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah.' 'what do you think??' 'when you die.' 'blah blah blah. blah blah bla-' like it sounds like a dude telling his whole life story then just singing 'blah blah blah' for a full minute.
All 3 different Mr. Moon responses: Incomplete demo: “See all these stars? When you die, you become a star.” Demo: “well it seems to be tricky to tell, whether ever a heaven or hell, play pretend, my friend and loose yourself in the rain.” Final: “well I think you return to obscure, or wherever you were, before you were, but I won’t let you loose yourself in the rain.”
The intro gave me an eargasm. I love hearing the way their songs connected in their history. It's the same with the mind electric and labyrinth from Hawaii part II
Lyrics from Genius [Intro] Mmhmm, mmhmm... Mmhmm, mmhmm... [RYAN SCOTT, spoken] Sometimes, I like to walk Outside In the rain (CANTOR: Blah, blah-blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...) I like the way it feels Upon my brain The rain One day, my family and I Went away For a little while When we came back The garage was flooded The rain had come inside And there was a lot of water Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah... Blah-blah, blah [CANTOR] Mr. Moon? [SCOTT] Yeah? [CANTOR] Tell us about the sky [SCOTT] The sky, deep and dark and blue, and very high [ALL, sung] Many people think that's where you go when you die [CANTOR, spoken] What do you think? [SCOTT] See all these stars? When you die You become a star [CANTOR, sung] You're a star You're a star You're a star You're a star You're a star Yes, you are You're a star Yes, you are Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah You're a star Yes, you are Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...
This song feels like a slow embracing march towards death, just slowly becoming more incomprehensible. Plus mr. moon says that when you die you become a star, then joe says that you're a star, doesn't feel like an accident to me. Mr. moon can also be interpreted as some type of god, or grim reaper figure. Anyway thats just me overanalyzing some goofy demo
I love admittedly incomplete demos so much, it’s just the way you can hear the hesitation in Ryan and Joes voices when they’re singing this it’s just so charming to me.
[Intro] Mmhmm, mmhmm... Mmhmm, mmhmm... [RYAN SCOTT, spoken] Sometimes, I like to walk Outside In the rain (CANTOR: Blah, blah-blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...) I like the way it feels Upon my brain The rain One day, my family and I Went away For a little while When we came back The garage was flooded The rain had come inside And there was a lot of water Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah... Blah-blah, blah [CANTOR] Mr. Moon? [SCOTT] Yeah? [CANTOR] Tell us about the sky [SCOTT] The sky, deep and dark and blue, and very high [ALL, sung] Many people think that's where you go when you die [CANTOR, spoken] What do you think? [SCOTT] See all these stars? When you die You become a star [CANTOR, sung] You're a star You're a star You're a star You're a star You're a star Yes, you are You're a star Yes, you are Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah You're a star Yes, you are Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah, blah Blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...
Oh I get, The only way to become a star is by being died and because the lyrics are saying " your a star" that means we the listener are dead and became a star
I'm sorry, but where do people find all these super early demos? Did Tally Hall just upload them someplace at some point and then delete them or something? Where did all these weird demos come from?
i love the latest version from MMMM and this was... mid not bad some parts were okay it just sounded like talking over music at parts and it sounded depressing with the delivery
Joe didn’t like Ryan’s performance in this demo, so he fired him from the band and locked him in a pit of letters, forced to read letters from fans all day.
thats not what happened
@@LunarDoor yes it is dude you just dont know your tally lore
@@LunarDoor it happened I saw it
Same
SO THAT's WHY AND WHO IS IN T.H.I.S
So the intro to the Bidding was originally for spring and a storm? Interesting.
That was a surprise for me, I thought the title was wrong for a moment.
woah i never noticed this. i always played this on shuffle in a playlist without bothering to check what's playing lol. just realized when i tried looking up this specific demo
for some reason the whole song made me laugh SO HARD
'there was a lot of water.'
'i like the way it feels upon my brain'.
'the garage was flooded.'
'blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah.'
'what do you think??'
'when you die.'
'blah blah blah. blah blah bla-'
like it sounds like a dude telling his whole life story then just singing 'blah blah blah' for a full minute.
"mR mOoN"
- Zubin Sedghi and Rob Cantor
"when yew die, ya become a star"
really makes me think if their garage actually flooded and inspired this song lol
Hahaha I'm crying laughing
"Sometimes, i like to walk"
"i have nostalgia for things that never happened" kinda song
I agree with you, but how do you plead?
@@timeforamunch2616 insane
@@residentsimon9921 condemn him to the infirmary
@@residentsimon9921 you ought to be ashamed of yourself *YOU OUGHT TO BE*
Somewhat similar to county good you know, in the nostalgic feeling of non existing memories
All 3 different Mr. Moon responses:
Incomplete demo: “See all these stars? When you die, you become a star.”
Demo: “well it seems to be tricky to tell, whether ever a heaven or hell, play pretend, my friend and loose yourself in the rain.”
Final: “well I think you return to obscure, or wherever you were, before you were, but I won’t let you loose yourself in the rain.”
hes changed his opinion over the years
@@weegeeetime843 just like twitter
I respect the hell outta this demo, but I am _very_ glad they revisited it to fully form it into the official version
wish they'd do that with all their other demos
im looking at u sea cucumber and at least a day >:)
this demo version sounds so much better imo: czcams.com/video/ewzMqZ3pGhA/video.html
dare i say, better than the final song tbh
song that might play when you decompose
YES
love the use of the word decompose
Should've called this "Spring and a Bidding" with that intro
The intro gave me an eargasm. I love hearing the way their songs connected in their history. It's the same with the mind electric and labyrinth from Hawaii part II
Very true
Eargasm??? Hold up
EARGASM??
@@TalllyHalll *I said what i said*
Honestly, it sounds like a song that doesn't get started until the last fourth.
Absolutely no one
Joe hawley: *BLAH*
im hysterical THOSE KID VOICES THO
MISTA MOON?!
the bidding who
RYAN AS IN THE TALLY MAIL DUDE? OH WOW
HE ESCAPED HIS PRISON OF PAPER.
HIS TYRANY SHALL NOW KNOW NO BOUNDS
how does ryan walk outside if he's in the mailbox
I love how some demos from tally hall ( and miracle musical ) just sing giberish
me tooo
@@marxistplierBro forgot it was his own comment 😅
@@estebson Fr 😭
Bro, that melody change at "The garage was flooded" is amazing
69 likes
there was a lot of water.
Lyrics from Genius
[Intro]
Mmhmm, mmhmm...
Mmhmm, mmhmm...
[RYAN SCOTT, spoken]
Sometimes, I like to walk
Outside
In the rain (CANTOR: Blah, blah-blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...)
I like the way it feels
Upon my brain
The rain
One day, my family and I
Went away
For a little while
When we came back
The garage was flooded
The rain had come inside
And there was a lot of water
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...
Blah-blah, blah
[CANTOR]
Mr. Moon?
[SCOTT]
Yeah?
[CANTOR]
Tell us about the sky
[SCOTT]
The sky, deep and dark and blue, and very high
[ALL, sung]
Many people think that's where you go when you die
[CANTOR, spoken]
What do you think?
[SCOTT]
See all these stars?
When you die
You become a star
[CANTOR, sung]
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
Yes, you are
You're a star
Yes, you are
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah
You're a star
Yes, you are
Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...
I don’t think it’s rob singing youre a star it sounds like joe
pretty sure its joe not rob
There is no way that is Rob, I’m sorry, but no way.
I feel like the further back you go with Spring and a Storm demos the more emphasis is put on the blahs.
Spring and a storm speed run with hidden Easter egg in the beginning
This song feels like a slow embracing march towards death, just slowly becoming more incomprehensible. Plus mr. moon says that when you die you become a star, then joe says that you're a star, doesn't feel like an accident to me. Mr. moon can also be interpreted as some type of god, or grim reaper figure. Anyway thats just me overanalyzing some goofy demo
Ooh, I love this interpretation!
thank you Ryan from Tally Mail, but how'd you escape the pit of letters? (also this whole recording sounds like a joke and I love it)
I imagine they tied the microphone to a string and lowered it into the pile and this was the result
“The sky… deep and dark, and blue… and very high” 😭 why haven’t I seen this
I love admittedly incomplete demos so much, it’s just the way you can hear the hesitation in Ryan and Joes voices when they’re singing this it’s just so charming to me.
Love the mellow guitar vibes though
Ngl I definitely prefer the official version
offical? you calling this a cover?
@@catfree this is technically unofficial because it’s a demo made before the original project
@@RandySaturn ...what? its a demo for the official
@@candlewick7328 makes sense now, my common sense sucked at that time
@@RandySaturn ah yes all those decades of learned wizdom, gained in a week
this is literally just the meaning of the song; this just breaking down the albums version loo
[Intro]
Mmhmm, mmhmm...
Mmhmm, mmhmm...
[RYAN SCOTT, spoken]
Sometimes, I like to walk
Outside
In the rain (CANTOR: Blah, blah-blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...)
I like the way it feels
Upon my brain
The rain
One day, my family and I
Went away
For a little while
When we came back
The garage was flooded
The rain had come inside
And there was a lot of water
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...
Blah-blah, blah
[CANTOR]
Mr. Moon?
[SCOTT]
Yeah?
[CANTOR]
Tell us about the sky
[SCOTT]
The sky, deep and dark and blue, and very high
[ALL, sung]
Many people think that's where you go when you die
[CANTOR, spoken]
What do you think?
[SCOTT]
See all these stars?
When you die
You become a star
[CANTOR, sung]
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
Yes, you are
You're a star
Yes, you are
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah-blah
You're a star
Yes, you are
Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah, blah-blah, blah, blah
Blah, blah, blah-blah, blah...
Mmmmm
The intro is unironically my favorite part of spring and a storm
Honestly this song unnerves the hell outta me
This calms me
OK, I ADMIT IT THE DEMO IS BETTER THAN THE FINAL VERSION
This is the time they were referring to in the final song.
spoken poetry
"Mr mooon?"
why is this funny to me-
Hmm, I’m curious, what tie would Ryan wear? Would it be black since that’s what he wears in Tally Mail?
no that's Casey's I think he would have light blue
@@siriusylee pink
@@maty5591 the Tree-Town Sound guy already claimed the pink tie. Also I disagree with my past self.
@@maty5591 also nice pfp
@@siriusylee thx
When your martial arts teacher in a music video
there needs to be a "Where Are They Now?" for Tally Hall showcasing his martial arts career
@@captromancer I know where he is. Hes at a martial arts dojo in California
@@alibolink0719 I've heard, I know a friend who goes there!!
@@captromancer Who are they?
Whaaat, who??
ur a star
Yes you are
no UR a star
An early demo of the track that would later be included on Tally Hall’s album “Marvin’s Marvelous Mechanical Museum”.
you get on my nerves
Yes very good good job
Why does Mr. Moon sound like a slightly deeper Bob Ross to me?
y o u d i d n t n e e d t o s a y t h a t
rob cantor and ross federman
I know a powerful Bob
@@woahhello9167 VARIATIONS ON A CLOUD
@@woahhello9167 does he eulogize you for being geocentric?
Yally Hall
Hally Tall
Yllat Hah
Yally tall
Lally Aall
llaytyall
phenomenal
unpopular opinion: the beginning is wayy worse than the official but the end SLAPS
The intro is great on the Bidding
thank you for reuploading this!
I like that the final version references the demo “one time i tried to sing about spring and a storm” he was talking about the original demo.
the bidding jumpscare
IVE BEEN SLEEPING IN A CARDBOARD BOX
spending every dollar at the liquor shop.
well i mean technically we are made from stars so they arent wrong
tally mail guy?
I only have my left earbud in
ill admit, this is pretty incomplete
Wet
So, the one listening to this Song is dead huh
what
@@catfree tahw
@@m7mdisenm866 waht
@@goopyhead wtah
Oh I get, The only way to become a star is by being died and because the lyrics are saying " your a star" that means we the listener are dead and became a star
imagine if this is how they released this song LMAO
the and a bidding
I'm sorry, but where do people find all these super early demos? Did Tally Hall just upload them someplace at some point and then delete them or something? Where did all these weird demos come from?
all of the demo albums are in bandcamp! this one was released in 2015 (i think)
THEY TOOK RYAN OUT OF THE GOSH DARN MAIL!!!!!
I want to animate this
I don't know how to animate
@@MrMilky-ou7ph Duality of man
@@MrMilky-ou7ph Duality of man
@@alvhawk4461 Duality of Man
@@MrMilky-ou7ph Duality of Man
Funny mail guy
i didnt know that the bidding was in spring and a storm
Fun version
I really like the sound at 1:48
I’m guessing this was taken place during the spring?
i love the latest version from MMMM and this was... mid
not bad some parts were okay it just sounded like talking over music at parts and it sounded depressing with the delivery
mIStEr MOoN
YeAh?
@@MinaWalker.
.
.
.
.
.
TeLL Us aBouT tHE SkY
@@could_possiblybe_thane07echook
The sky is deep and dark and eternally high, many people think that’s where you go when you die
WHATS THIS
Wehn u die u because a star
This just sounds…. Wrong