Ups & Downs From Star Trek: Discovery 5.9 - Lagrange Point

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
  • GOLD XL Enterprise-D Giveaway: masterreplicas.com - join the newsletter (at the bottom of the page) for a chance to win!
    Read the article here: whatculture.com/trekculture/7...
    Listen to The TrekCulture Podcast - Tuesdays on;
    Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/1wrqDG8...
    Apple: podcasts.apple.com/ph/podcast...
    Acast: play.acast.com/s/trekculture/
    For more awesome content: whatculture.com/topic/star-trek
    Follow TrekCulture on Twitter: / trekculture
    Follow us on Instagram: / trekcultureyt
    #StarTrek #StarTrekDiscovery #Breen
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 797

  • @sparquisdesade
    @sparquisdesade Před 27 dny +153

    Jonathan Frake's directing is responsible for more starship destruction than Wolf 359

    • @withershin
      @withershin Před 27 dny +15

      I was honestly thinking just park the Disco in to that huge hanger. Frakes knows what the nerds crave.

    • @sparquisdesade
      @sparquisdesade Před 27 dny +18

      @@withershin We are a simple to please people. We love 3 things in life. Starship design porn, stuff blowin up and/or crashing into other stuff and cold beer on a warm day while cookin a pizza

    • @brookatkins8111
      @brookatkins8111 Před 27 dny

      @@sparquisdesadespot on mate

    • @withershin
      @withershin Před 27 dny +7

      @@sparquisdesade you know doing a 180 in a Crossfield class A-10 style in a Breen carrier is unique right?

    • @sparquisdesade
      @sparquisdesade Před 27 dny +2

      @@withershin I was jus tryin to make a funny about how for the most part, cool spaceship designs an ship battles are all it takes to make me happy most of the time. lol

  • @BernardManansala
    @BernardManansala Před 27 dny +62

    The scene with the crew lined up in Breen armour I couldn't help but think...
    "Aren't you a little short to be Breen?"

    • @tronicman1
      @tronicman1 Před 25 dny +3

      What? I'm Luke Skywalker, I'm here to save you... - oops, wrong franchise!

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 25 dny +2

      Adira is so adorable in the breen suit they’re so smoll

  • @michelleholleywood
    @michelleholleywood Před 27 dny +61

    E10: Finally! Tech that can bring back Trip.

  • @LePedant
    @LePedant Před 27 dny +140

    The progenitors capsule was blown into space with the door unlocked and the portal activated. I could see how those two things could compromised the integrity of the capsule.

    • @Bubblesthewitch
      @Bubblesthewitch Před 27 dny +31

      Also it was balanced at the Laronge point before. The stress on the object would be way stronger when it got jettisoned.

    • @woogha
      @woogha Před 27 dny +2

      I thought it was being shot out from inside.

    • @thomaslarson459
      @thomaslarson459 Před 27 dny +8

      Not to mention being pelted with debris as it was blasted out into space. Duranium is impressive, but not indestructible.

    • @jamesmatthew2236
      @jamesmatthew2236 Před 27 dny +7

      Not to mention that at the edges of the event horizon there are insane amounts of radiation, super heated plasma and cuncks of matter zipping around at ludicrous speeds. The capsule without Sheila's or deflectors would have zero protection from any of this.

    • @robertandersen9886
      @robertandersen9886 Před 27 dny +4

      It was open when it was blown into an unstable orbit...

  • @robpittman3132
    @robpittman3132 Před 27 dny +65

    On the subject of Doug Jones being incredible....it never jumped out to me before, but the way Jones acts with his eyes IN ALL THAT PROTHESIS is amazing. The emotional range that he is somehow able to convey without saying a word is just masterful.

    • @petertrudelljr
      @petertrudelljr Před 27 dny +9

      Dude went through MIME training. He knows how to act with his body and eyes. I'm sure that's why he got so many bits in prosthetics (and the fact he's TALL).

    • @JohnDlugosz
      @JohnDlugosz Před 26 dny +2

      @@petertrudelljr Not just tall, but oddly proportioned. In silhouette he already looks alien.

    • @andywellsglobaldomination
      @andywellsglobaldomination Před 26 dny +2

      I'm sure Jones wishes he could work without being swallowed up in makeup... but I'm sure he gets paid very very very well to do so because he owns it every time. Still remember him from HELLBOY!

    • @withershin
      @withershin Před 24 dny

      I see him on the boardwalk - good dude. I don't nerd out. It's Toronto.

  • @sjprdude
    @sjprdude Před 26 dny +22

    I think Raynor doing the “Picard maneuver” (pulling his top when sitting) should have been mentioned in Cetaceans Observations.

    • @susanscott8653
      @susanscott8653 Před 26 dny +2

      And when he clapped his hands like a teacher, on the bridge. 😅

    • @janemcdonald5372
      @janemcdonald5372 Před 21 dnem +1

      If you watch to the latest episode of The Ready Room, Frakes tells Will Wheaton that he suggested The Picard Maneuver to Rennie when Rennie asked him for advice for the first time sitting in the Captain's chair. The arm rest double bang was all Rennie.

    • @Mazvec
      @Mazvec Před 17 dny

      And then he uses a version of the Riker maneuver against the breen fighters later

  • @danboyle7165
    @danboyle7165 Před 28 dny +70

    My prediction: Progenitor tech used on the Kwejian worldroot cutting to restore the planet or at least a child of the planet.

    • @kadosho02
      @kadosho02 Před 27 dny +9

      So it would be a Genesis like device

    • @chazmania3644
      @chazmania3644 Před 27 dny +28

      The Breen kill Saru, but the Progenitor Tech brings him back and also revives L'ak. The series ends with T'rina and Saru's wedding on the newly recreated Kwejian home world.
      Hidden in the crowd of wedding guests is a resurrected Trip Tucker!

    • @petepanteraman
      @petepanteraman Před 27 dny +4

      Yes that works with the mild emphasis last episode 👍👍
      🙏 For kwejein

    • @ArtistryBranson
      @ArtistryBranson Před 27 dny +2

      I said much the same thing on a previous video, but you put it more eloquently than I did. Well said!

    • @ArtistryBranson
      @ArtistryBranson Před 27 dny +1

      ​@@chazmania3644🤣

  • @hazel7296
    @hazel7296 Před 27 dny +43

    A portable transporter buffer is a perfect battlefield tool. Freezes an injured ally in time until they can be brought out in a med bay, can freeze an enemy to bring home for interrogation. Allows hidden carrying of heavy ordinance. All around useful machine. Basicslly a fantasy "inventory" system

    • @esumiwa5583
      @esumiwa5583 Před 27 dny +1

      They used it in SNW: the buffers only have a finite amount of room befoer you have to let someone's pattern go

    • @sparquisdesade
      @sparquisdesade Před 27 dny +1

      @@esumiwa5583 Eh, I'm sure it would only be a matter of time before some kooky terran mad scientist would have been able to develop a way to choose certain parts of someone's pattern to edit/delete so you can make more room to carry guns.
      Like... I mean... do the prisoners need to be anything more than a brain in a jar to interrogate them once we get back? I really wanted to try out the new gravametic-chainsaw the dr cooked up.

    • @mastere6115
      @mastere6115 Před 27 dny +3

      ​@@esumiwa5583there is a big difference between a relatively small pattern buffer on a 23rd century starship, and a handheld 32nd century pattern buffer... Where with the latter, they have literal bigger on the inside technology

    • @brookatkins8111
      @brookatkins8111 Před 27 dny +1

      @@esumiwa5583from TNG about 25 years ago

    • @georgegrennan6328
      @georgegrennan6328 Před 26 dny +4

      A Bag of Holding 🙂

  • @OmegablueWolf
    @OmegablueWolf Před 27 dny +18

    I like when captains get to use their pre-Captain skills Pike and Archer flying things, Janeway, Picard and Burnham scienceing, Sisko dealing with Engineering stuff....its just very nice.

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny +4

      Agreed! Burnham’s anthropology skills have come in hand massively this season and it’s a good treat

  • @medleystudios72
    @medleystudios72 Před 27 dny +34

    Adding to your wish for a reaction shot of Burnam at the end, imagine the Treksphere implosion if we'd heard Avery Brooks' unmistakable voice say, "The Burnam is here. Welcome."

    • @RotalHenricsson
      @RotalHenricsson Před 27 dny +8

      "Computer, end program."

    • @rigues
      @rigues Před 27 dny +5

      I would have fainted.

    • @KaygeeAllah
      @KaygeeAllah Před 24 dny +1

      Just the one word: “Welcome.”
      His voice is absolutely unmistakable.

    • @grumpus_hominidae
      @grumpus_hominidae Před 24 dny

      OMG, if she and Mal (Moll? Mall? Moll?) end up with the "Wormhole Aliens", that would just be AMAZING, and if SISKO greets them... Pbbffttt! That's the sound my head would make as it explodes.... 🤯

  • @wesleyehowell
    @wesleyehowell Před 27 dny +24

    I like Saru being back, but I have to say, MY latinum up would be Raynor all the way through, but especially in the last scene when he took the captains chair.

  • @RL-gl8qg
    @RL-gl8qg Před 27 dny +15

    I don't think it's a Pringles can. It's a Barrel of Monkeys game. Can't win until all the primates hold hands...

  • @lovipoekimo176
    @lovipoekimo176 Před 28 dny +153

    If they kill off Saru, we riot

    • @michaelarulanantham8833
      @michaelarulanantham8833 Před 27 dny +11

      I have a bad feeling about that!

    • @AvesPasseri-Jinysvet
      @AvesPasseri-Jinysvet Před 27 dny

      If they had planned that, they changed it the moment they realized it's the last season.​@@michaelarulanantham8833

    • @brayundia
      @brayundia Před 27 dny

      @@michaelarulanantham8833 : I do too !!

    • @jaykay845
      @jaykay845 Před 27 dny +14

      Saruicide

    • @KenjiWardenclyffe
      @KenjiWardenclyffe Před 27 dny +1

      I'm so scared they will since it's the last episode 😭 it feels like they're setting it up to happen, but I hope thats just misdirection

  • @PassivesAbseits
    @PassivesAbseits Před 27 dny +22

    No up for that short "I have an idea, it might be risky" "Just do it" interaction between Rayner and Burnham?
    It is so short, but so good, since it a) shows how far the trust between Burnham and Rayner has come.
    and B) means that mister "62 % is good, we take that risk" actually at least thinks about it by now.
    In episode 1, they would have argued about a call like that and ended up on different points. In episoe 9, Burnham trust him to make the right move blindly.

  • @mrfluffyhedgehog
    @mrfluffyhedgehog Před 27 dny +36

    the case imploding as it flew out of the shuttlebay is not a plot hole.
    it makes sense that it impleded as it was exposed to violent gravitational forces.
    originally it had been stationed in the lagrange point where gravity is in equilibrium between opposing forces, cancelling one another out. a box of (duranium) tissues would be fine there.

    • @chuckintexas
      @chuckintexas Před 27 dny +2

      NONE of that is _how_ gravity _WORKS_ .

    • @HermanVonPetri
      @HermanVonPetri Před 27 dny +6

      @@chuckintexas Hah! I've seen this explanation repeated here in the comments, but...
      Any object in free fall experiences NO sensation of stress from gravity except for:
      (1) when it is being accelerated by physical contact with something pushing it.
      (2) when it is being stretched by strong tidal forces over a short span of space
      Option 1 is out since the canister is not in physical contact with anything pushing on it. So that wouldn't do it.
      However, 2, it _is_ in proximity to two large black holes which can create the types of tidal forces that could rip apart something in orbit. Except for three problems with that. One, seemingly paradoxically, the bigger the black hole is the gentler the forces are outside of the event horizon. Two, the further you are from the black hole, the gentler the forces are. And three, the smaller the object is the gentler the forces are because the gravity has to be significantly stronger on one end of the object than the other to rip it apart. That's more likely for a large object like Discovery or the Breen ship than a car sized canister.
      Counterpoint: The structural integrity fields of the ships could (in a sci-fi way) be enough to hold the ships together if I suppose the canister didn't have one.

  • @Tuskin38
    @Tuskin38 Před 28 dny +64

    The Star Trek game Voyager Elite Force had a portable transporter buffer to explain how your character can carry so many weapons at once

    • @cjt217
      @cjt217 Před 27 dny +5

      Dang, went here to make this comment myself. Regardless, +1

    • @QuintusAntonious
      @QuintusAntonious Před 27 dny +6

      Also theirs was the size of a briefcase so having it small enough to fit on Moll's wrist 1000 years later makes perfect sense too.

    • @sparquisdesade
      @sparquisdesade Před 27 dny +2

      my god.... those crazy bastards at Section 31 tactical RnD found a way to use the transporters to literally make "bugs bunny hammer space" for their arsenals

    • @JohnDlugosz
      @JohnDlugosz Před 26 dny +2

      We've seen in Discovery already how tools materialize in their hands on away missions.

    • @TheAdam159
      @TheAdam159 Před 21 dnem +1

      Love that game!

  • @KyleWitten
    @KyleWitten Před 27 dny +49

    The Pringles Can blowing up doesn't bother me. The episode title explains it.
    A Lagrange Point is a region of gravitational stability because competing gravitational forces cancel each other out. A real world example from today is the James Webb Space Telescope. It is located at a Lagrange Point.
    So, not only was it damaged from the collision, unless it was jettisoned back into the Lagrange Point, it would have been subjected to extreme gravitational forces for the first time ever.
    They got the science right on this one.

    • @jeffs6090
      @jeffs6090 Před 27 dny +5

      But not the time dilation that they should be experiencing from them being so close to a black hole. A few hours for them there would be years for everyone not near it.

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny +2

      @@jeffs6090dramatic television conceits, it would derail the story if they tried to do that part right

    • @jamesmatthew2236
      @jamesmatthew2236 Před 27 dny +5

      Not to mention that at the edges of the event horizon there are insane amounts of radiation, super heated plasma and cuncks of matter zipping around at ludicrous speeds. The capsule without shields or deflectors would have zero protection from any of this.

    • @QuintusAntonious
      @QuintusAntonious Před 27 dny +3

      @@jeffs6090 Now that'd have been an interesting twist--the cost of getting the tech is that you'll lose years to it.

    • @KyleWitten
      @KyleWitten Před 27 dny +2

      @@jeffs6090 Star Trek magic physics. The inertial dampeners compensate for relativistic time dilation.

  • @shanchat
    @shanchat Před 27 dny +16

    Burnham says the mission is time critical but she decides in the middle of the mission, to have a heart to heart with Book. if they hadn't done that, they'd have succeeded.

    • @archmage_of_the_aether
      @archmage_of_the_aether Před 25 dny +3

      Yes, so stupid, especially from show often criticized for being ongoing group therapy sessions.

  • @WilliamDeLong-ky3zi
    @WilliamDeLong-ky3zi Před 27 dny +17

    You said you wanted some ideas as to what we think we'll see on the other side of the portal. 1) Dr. Kovich. He started Disco on this journey. I think he's the sixth scientist who "died" (Jinaal's word), but really he mastered the Progenitor's tech. Either he's a human who is now immortal b/c of the Progenitor's tech or a Lanthanite. 2) Based on the musical cue from TMP in Epi. 9 of this season, we'll see the race of beings that created the machines that sent V'Ger home, or maybe the life-form from the end of the movie that was the amalgamation of Decker/Ilia (list them as missing), or both. 3) We'll see many of the ancient races of the galaxy there, a la the end of Babylon 5, who were testing the younger races. Perhaps we'll see Q, Iconians, the race that created the androids in the TOS episode "What Are Little Girls Made Of?" and, perhaps, a cameo from Salome Jens reprising her role (she's 89 years old now!).

    • @darylmullins4369
      @darylmullins4369 Před 25 dny +1

      Naaaah...I think Wesley Crusher - with or without "the traveller" - will be on the other side. Either that, or Jodie Foster's dad! Or as a third option, Rick Sanches will be waiting for them with a case of beer.

  • @SarahConsalvey
    @SarahConsalvey Před 28 dny +36

    I love Jeffery combs ❤❤

    • @funkygerbil2530
      @funkygerbil2530 Před 28 dny +8

      I was really looking forward to where his character and Archer were going in Enterprise. Oh well.

    • @HighSierra1500
      @HighSierra1500 Před 27 dny +2

      @@funkygerbil2530 I always loved it when Shran called Archer, Pink Skin.

  • @kristineglass704
    @kristineglass704 Před 27 dny +12

    Rayner did the Picard maneuver when he sat in the captains chair

  • @Bubblesthewitch
    @Bubblesthewitch Před 27 dny +14

    Cloaking Technology has always caused distortions. I agree that they could have made the effect more subtle but it’s kinda needed for the establishing shots to work. Also the capsule was balanced at the Lagrange point between the black holes for years. It breaking apart when jettisoned, door wide-open, and not equally balanced between two black holes makes perfect sense.

    • @RogbodgeVideo
      @RogbodgeVideo Před 26 dny

      In addition, there are a lot of gravimetric fluctuations caused by the black holes, which would interfere with the cloaking field.

  • @DWPLANCE
    @DWPLANCE Před 26 dny +3

    That Tilley smile and scene was perfect!

  • @mattspeer3516
    @mattspeer3516 Před 28 dny +12

    Trek Culture After Dark.....take an up.

  • @jesseszymcik3026
    @jesseszymcik3026 Před 27 dny +10

    Find Jeffery Combs is the loudest laugh you’ve given me. It hurt my ears!

  • @Vyan00
    @Vyan00 Před 27 dny +15

    Can we talk a moment to recognize that Commander Jemison is obviously a nod to NASA Astronaut Mae Jemison who appeared years ago on TNG?

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny +1

      I clocked it while watching the episode, very cool nod

    • @petertrudelljr
      @petertrudelljr Před 27 dny +5

      NK Jemison is a stellar sci-fi author that could also be a reference.

  • @samfisher6606
    @samfisher6606 Před 27 dny +5

    Can't believe Seán missed Rayner's Picard Tug when he sits in the chair.

  • @CRanapia
    @CRanapia Před 27 dny +59

    Breen are now canonically poly-amorous hot oil jaccuzi swingers - at least on holidays and high holy days. Along with Saru and T'rina being utterly adorable, and Tilly and Rayner being work flirts, I'm here for horniness in a crisis.

    • @glenncrider2566
      @glenncrider2566 Před 27 dny +9

      This is now canon.

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny +7

      Need more Book with a Breen boyfriend

    • @petertrudelljr
      @petertrudelljr Před 27 dny +3

      still not as horny as the Cerritos.

    • @withershin
      @withershin Před 27 dny +4

      Omg Tilly was flirting with Raynor? I didn't get a moment of that thought. I got eff off kid and Tilly was like okay fine you win. It was all a set up for the chair sit. Simple comedic/dramatic framing. I skip over the lovey-dovey parts. Oh crap you might be right but that means we'll get Callum Keith Rennie on Academy. It's fine.

    • @chazmania3644
      @chazmania3644 Před 27 dny +6

      Babylon 5 fans know that Breen taste like Swedish Meatballs

  • @oladeji15
    @oladeji15 Před 27 dny +22

    Great points made on Owosekun & Detmer’s absence. My dream scenario is that they are brought into Starfleet Academy in a way that PROPERLY builds out their character arcs.

    • @philopharynx7910
      @philopharynx7910 Před 27 dny +3

      And Saru has to do some guest lectures as well.

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny +2

      @@philopharynx7910I would’ve love Saru awkwardly trying to get through a special guest lecture

    • @dannyayala3462
      @dannyayala3462 Před 27 dny +3

      My thoughts exactly

    • @alejandronopasanada5302
      @alejandronopasanada5302 Před 27 dny

      I watched it once, I thought they were trying to sell the “Definitely Not Character Who’s Name I Didn’t Know” as “Extra In need of Extra Money” a la Gabriel Union in DS9 “Sons and Daughters” or the 3 (Fing 3, only nerds know) Zeals.

  • @MrOhYeahRight
    @MrOhYeahRight Před 27 dny +14

    I know the perfect ending for the series.
    Pull a “Bob Newhart”.
    At the end, fade to white and show Williams Shatner waking up in bed saying “Damn! What the hell was that? No more chili fries before bed!”

  • @wesleyehowell
    @wesleyehowell Před 27 dny +10

    This episode, with Burnham going through the portal reminded me very much of Times Arrow part one.

    • @jackkenefick2696
      @jackkenefick2696 Před 27 dny

      Or Picard stepping through the Iconian gate onto the Romulan ship

  • @sbellis67
    @sbellis67 Před 27 dny +6

    So apparently the Breen are like tacos. You've got your hard shell ones, soft shell ones, and when they're in their uniforms, you've got the gorditas.

  • @SamriBliss
    @SamriBliss Před 26 dny +4

    14:30 - the outline of the cloak shows because of the 2 black holes sucking matter which hits the ship…

  • @cmgrafmc
    @cmgrafmc Před 24 dny +1

    Doug Jones’ portrayal of Saru is absolutely the MOST Star Trek part of the series. He’s hands-down my favorite Disco character and embodies the best and deepest aspects of what good sci-fi story telling can be. As others have pointed out, his ability to emote through all the prosthetics is impressive and even the way he walks seems “other worldly.” He’s really nailed the part.

  • @matthewkaess
    @matthewkaess Před 27 dny +3

    I am so glad you gave a down to the helmet views. I thought I was alone on that one.

  • @arrjay2410
    @arrjay2410 Před 24 dny +1

    "Pringles Can", Love it. 🤣Love the DS9 references too. As for episode #10, even though the series is ending; Discovery will go on.

  • @opsirusa
    @opsirusa Před 26 dny +4

    I’m calling it here. We will get a 32nd refit of the ISS Enterprise with Detmer and Owo, with the fleet, arriving just in time for a rescue.

    • @lwnasidh
      @lwnasidh Před 25 dny

      That would make it all worth it.

  • @phunkydroid
    @phunkydroid Před 27 dny +9

    You're wrong about that 5th down. The whole point of that location it was in (the lagrange point) is that it's a place where the gravity of the two black holes cancels out, making it "safe". The capsule being anywhere else outside that specific point is vastly different than the conditions it's spent the last 800 year in.

    • @Justjakelive
      @Justjakelive Před 27 dny +5

      Plus the key is in the canister now and hence it was open when it was blown out too.

  • @TheNewSam
    @TheNewSam Před 27 dny +5

    I'm just gonna say, the canister really reminds me of the Lego Mini-kit containers from the various Lego video games

  • @ryoukosan11
    @ryoukosan11 Před 27 dny +8

    First, I have a bit of a beef with giving a down to the destruction of the "Pringle Can". While in the Lagrange point between the 2 black holes, it was in equilibrium and in little danger. Once it was expelled from the ship, there was no indication that it was into the Lagrange point. Any unprotected object would be ripped apart by the forces of the black holes.
    Second, I think that Burnham will get everyone to work together, bring back Lok, get a few answers of the universe, then ultimate everyone decides that it's better if the tech is destroyed. They all end up coming back to normal space, Lok takes over as the leader of the Breen and brokers a deal with the Federation and everyone lives happily ever after.

    • @spilchsaysstuff1427
      @spilchsaysstuff1427 Před 27 dny +2

      Yeah, I think that sounds terrible too.

    • @EvanBly
      @EvanBly Před 26 dny

      I think rather than destroy it, Burnham pushes a new set of scientists to make a new set of clues to reset the riddle for somebody else in the future, which will suck as an ending.

  • @AndrewLakeUK
    @AndrewLakeUK Před 27 dny +5

    I'm not sure how the Breen suits magically knew what was banter between the Disco crew and what they wanted to say and translate for the Breen. I guess the microphones work on plot power. My guess is the small pringle tin blew up because instead of being at the LaGrange point avoiding gravity, as it was for centuries, it's traveling closer to one of the black holes, I can't remember them explaining what a LG point is though so it could be clearer.

  • @tonyperkins7644
    @tonyperkins7644 Před 27 dny +3

    Good grief you actually made me laugh with the "bring back Jeffry Combes" gag. Well done you said a funny.

  • @hammerman199374
    @hammerman199374 Před 27 dny +7

    Okay, Sean, here's your heat: I really like the "Ironman" helmet views we got of the away team, so... so there! I also liked the split screen moment when it showed three faces at once, which made it really feel like an old-fashioned 1960's heist film. But, on the other hand, I'll let this one "Down" you gave slide because your Jeffrey Combes joke literally made me laugh out loud.

    • @msromantini
      @msromantini Před 24 dny

      I think that split screen moment was a power rangers reference….

  • @KylieG328
    @KylieG328 Před 25 dny +1

    Sean your video closings are so beautiful. We need more peace and kindness in this world.

  • @Saifon2000
    @Saifon2000 Před 27 dny +9

    Gotta love Jonathan Frakes for directing this episode :).. much love..

  • @debunkosaurus8228
    @debunkosaurus8228 Před 27 dny +4

    Part of me wishes that, When Burnham entered the "wormhole", she should have said "My god, its full of stars".

  • @Freddles279
    @Freddles279 Před 27 dny +9

    Pringles can? I think it looks a lot more like one of those little rootbeer barrel candies.

  • @pangaeawriter8766
    @pangaeawriter8766 Před 27 dny +6

    The journey onto the Breen dreadnought strongly reminded me of Burnham and Prime Georgiou's ill-fated heist to the Klingon sarcophagus in "The Battle of the Binary Stars", but this time, it worked.

    • @dianenorton3316
      @dianenorton3316 Před 27 dny +1

      It's now the battle of the binary black hole's 😂 😂 ❤❤ ❤

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny +2

      @@dianenorton3316 its sort of like poetry they rhyme

  • @RonnyNussbaum
    @RonnyNussbaum Před 27 dny +5

    There was also a reference to COSID. An anagram of DISCO.

  • @marcelomartins8013
    @marcelomartins8013 Před 24 dny +1

    and Rayner felt comfortable and finaly sat on the chair

  • @mattgelfer
    @mattgelfer Před 27 dny +12

    Detmer and Owo's absence feels so conspicuous that I can't help but think they're gonna come back in at the end of episode 10, shooting surprise torpedos from the ISS Enterprise, Han Solo style.

    • @allancrocker4471
      @allancrocker4471 Před 27 dny +2

      Oh good, another Star Wars reference I can tag this on to: Was I the only one half-expecting someone to utter to Tal "aren't you a little short for Stormtrooper"?

    • @FreedomJo
      @FreedomJo Před 27 dny

      They have to yell "Yahoo!"

  • @sdoht
    @sdoht Před 26 dny +2

    That Jeffery Combs Joke made me actually Laugh out Loud. lolol

  • @IsiahBradley
    @IsiahBradley Před 28 dny +1

    THANKS for this, Sean and Co.!!!!!

  • @Hodor_70
    @Hodor_70 Před 28 dny +9

    Seán Ferrick IS Trek Culture!

    • @gerryh8367
      @gerryh8367 Před 27 dny +1

      But bring back Marcus and Adam
      That's a dream team

    • @drian1236
      @drian1236 Před 27 dny

      @@gerryh8367 yes plz

  • @bjorn00000
    @bjorn00000 Před 27 dny +4

    I'm betting that they'll figure out a way to make Calypso canon.

  • @Bluestar1079
    @Bluestar1079 Před 26 dny +1

    I recently rewatched strange new worlds and I'm seeing a lot of that in this season of discovering. Somebody was definitely taking notes

  • @leticiagarcia9025
    @leticiagarcia9025 Před 27 dny +7

    The oil bath made me laugh. I needed a good laugh. I fear that the finale will be a disappointment because of Moll’s stubbornness and the Breen’s nature. Michael stands alone. I will be delighted if I’m wrong. BTW where are the Klingons? I haven’t seen a Klingon in the 32 century. If I missed it please let me know.

    • @Cdr2002
      @Cdr2002 Před 27 dny

      We really need to see Moll in a different base emotional state that isn’t cocky/bitter for the finale to work

    • @RotalHenricsson
      @RotalHenricsson Před 27 dny +2

      After they yeeted everything bad from the show by going to the future i think it's safe to say whoever had the reigns for seasons 3 through 5 was smart enough to not ever touch the Klingons again in Discovery. Ever. At all.
      In-universe you can probably chalk it up to them poking the wrong bear and Quo'nos lies in shambles, Klingons are like 2 steps above Kazon on a good day.
      Anyway, where'd you hear that? We have any leaks already?

  • @scottjohnsoncet
    @scottjohnsoncet Před 10 dny

    Thanks to Kris again for the running “Oops-a-daisy” gag! I literally laughed out loud!

  • @musicloverme3993
    @musicloverme3993 Před 27 dny +4

    As soon as I saw Saru, I thought of you, Sean.

  • @mikemcguckin8596
    @mikemcguckin8596 Před 27 dny +7

    I think the casing collapsed in space because it was unlocked and open by then rather than sealed as it had been for 800 years.

  • @paulc9643
    @paulc9643 Před 25 dny +2

    The series began with a battle at a binary system (Binary Stars) and will technically end the same (Binary Black Holes)

  • @ninedragons99
    @ninedragons99 Před 26 dny +2

    The shuttle entering the dreadnaught through the exhaust port and almost getting melted in the process reminded me a lot of DS9 "One Little Ship" where the Rubicon is shrunk and also enters the Defiant through the plasma vent.

  • @rigues
    @rigues Před 27 dny +2

    "Pringles can", AMAZING. But actually, my first thought was "Whisky barrel" 😅

  • @ediedaley3701
    @ediedaley3701 Před 27 dny +3

    Lotta harsh comments tonight. Sheesh!
    Watched all the Trek shows (most 2x or more) & enjoyed them all. Let’s be less aggressive, people; that’s part of the future ethos of Trek.

  • @alasdairgardiner2313
    @alasdairgardiner2313 Před 27 dny +1

    The scenes of Discovery flying through the Breen ship reminded me of the scenes of Discovery flying through the Charon in the Mirror Universe.

  • @midago7332
    @midago7332 Před 27 dny +1

    I think I have to rewatch this one next week as a movie length finale 😊. Enjoyed it so much what a great season this has been. And great ups and downs too 🖖🏽

  • @bjbresulla
    @bjbresulla Před 27 dny +6

    I wonder if in the finale amongst the starfleet armada thats on the way we will see a 32nd century ISS Enterprise being piloted by Owosekun and Detmer and captained by admiral Vance

  • @jeremydoud4885
    @jeremydoud4885 Před 27 dny +2

    Disco gets the addition of Rayner (played by arguably one of the best Skin Job Cylon’s from BSG) and they decide to cancel it…wtf Paramount +!! Season 5 of Disco has been the best season since season 2! I hope we see more of Rayner…maybe he’ll pop up on Starfleet Academy? We can only hope!

  • @craigjackson4393
    @craigjackson4393 Před 26 dny +1

    I really thought as soon as the Breen started sending troops through, there's a shout out to the SG-1 episode 'Torment of Tantalus' - especially the one with the tether....

  • @charliemckellips
    @charliemckellips Před 27 dny +1

    Rayner might be one of my favorite characters on Discovery.

  • @willsanders1841
    @willsanders1841 Před 27 dny +1

    Saru is the "shape of the one between the many". A diplomat, and pragmatist who overcame existential fear to become something greater...Action Saru is about to have his moment I think.

  • @slayerdemin
    @slayerdemin Před 23 dny +1

    Sean, I love your message at the end of all the videos. Thank you for that.

  • @colemanjr
    @colemanjr Před 27 dny +2

    YES let's talk about that Oil Bath!!!

  • @MalikBarrow16
    @MalikBarrow16 Před 27 dny +4

    This ep was so fucking good had me hyped

  • @lamartherevenger
    @lamartherevenger Před 27 dny +2

    Seriously, the binary black holes reminded me of the Battle of the Binary Stars in the first 2 episodes of Discovery.

  • @preferredimage
    @preferredimage Před 27 dny +1

    I called it back in episode 1... I said Rayner was going to be this shows Shaw..... Looks like it was a good call.

  • @CaseyOntiveros
    @CaseyOntiveros Před 27 dny +2

    I would have loved to have heard the Breen who Book was hitting on asks, "So we're not going to the Feast together?"

  • @grahamcann1761
    @grahamcann1761 Před 27 dny +1

    "See you next week for the season finally." Sadly, also the series finally.
    As always thank you so very much all.

  • @aeternumiter2443
    @aeternumiter2443 Před 27 dny +4

    Sean: You can actually see book getting beamed out of the shuttlebay in the final sequence if you look closely

  • @BasaiDai
    @BasaiDai Před 27 dny +5

    Ok, so we are on the Breen ship, surrounded by enemy soldiers. It is very tense and a dangerous situation. Let's just grab five minutes to talk about or feelings shall we?

  • @nickjenkins9210
    @nickjenkins9210 Před 27 dny +1

    Ah! A re-run of the Jason Nesmith/Alexander Dane 'argument' to distract the guards and then knock them out.

  • @Cmdr1962
    @Cmdr1962 Před 27 dny +2

    Saru's part was modular in this episode, detached from the main plot and cast. Owo and Detmer are Lost in Space, I think. Feels like they could have been fit in. Look how much time we spent on four cast members in Iron Man suits. THAT can be done anywhere, anytime. They should have had Owo and Detmer phone home in front of a cheapie background. Also -- aren't Burnham and Adira a little short for a stormtrooper?

  • @cortezpaschal1913
    @cortezpaschal1913 Před 27 dny

    The Pringles Can???😂Sean, you had me dying laughing

  • @jamesfoster9613
    @jamesfoster9613 Před 27 dny +1

    Also potential additional Cetacean Observation: piloting a small ship through thin shields caused by impulse engine exhaust also happened in another Trek penultimate episode: TNG s7e24 "Preemptive Strike". Ro Laren used her advanced tactical training to pilot a Maquis raider between the Enterprise' nacelles :D

  • @glenncrider2566
    @glenncrider2566 Před 27 dny

    Love the t-shirt Sean.

  • @luisvaldivieso5217
    @luisvaldivieso5217 Před 28 dny +13

    I really haven't been missing Saru. I think he is a great character and great actor, but I like when characters move on. When we get to see their career progression.

  • @jcrichichi
    @jcrichichi Před 26 dny

    I agree with most of your ups and downs. As for the Finale, i'm eager to see what they come up with. The only thing I can think of is the great power may not be about creation but more about cooperation and unity. Also, one thing you could say was flying the shuttle into the unshielded exhaust port is a call back to 2 Star Trek episodes: DS9 One Little Ship where the tiny runabout entered the ship through the plasma vent, and TNG's Preemptive Strike where Ro navigates the Maquis raider through the Enterprise shields cause the impulse exhaust causes a weak point in the aft shield.

  • @T0ghar
    @T0ghar Před 26 dny +2

    The part with the casing is NOT a plot hole. We have no spacial awareness in this scene. The Pringles can was in a Lagrange Point, a stable orbit point, around the 2 black holes at the start, but now it was moving away from the shuttle bay thus not in a stable orbit anymore and probably now in a decaying orbit into an object with MASSIVE gravitational forces. It is similar to submarines being just above crushing depth or the scene in Babylon 5 with the white star and the shadow vessel flying into Jupiter. If you cross a certain point, depth, or height (as in decaying orbit), it is game over.

  • @nickgiovanniit5809
    @nickgiovanniit5809 Před 23 dny

    Nice closing message .

  • @eduardodanielrappaoppezzo1888

    Saludos desde Argentina.

  • @Capt.Marco-Hawk-L.L.A.P

    I enjoyed this episode... I was so happy to see Saru back,
    I was hoping to see more of 10c for the last season. Brimful Of Asha on the 45 lol...

  • @iidreddiipsn4720
    @iidreddiipsn4720 Před 28 dny +3

    Discoverys phaser sounds this episode were Next Generation Phaser sounds you missed that. Also season 3 finale their phaser sounds from from TOS.

  • @Stress-Free-K
    @Stress-Free-K Před 26 dny

    Well the outline of the Disco ship give me ... Wonder Woman invisible airplane vibes ... so I LOVE IT!

  • @MyogaSama
    @MyogaSama Před 27 dny +1

    So when that whoopsy daisy started. The first time I was laughed. The second time I was confused. The third time I felt like the Fry not sure if meme... and now I've circled back around to laughing

  • @lcflngn
    @lcflngn Před 26 dny

    Agree with everything, except it’s clearly an 800 yr old beer barrel.
    100% support your message of how peace is made. Hoping the last ep whops us on the head with that in a beautiful way. Also a great wedding.

  • @SSG1N571
    @SSG1N571 Před 27 dny +1

    Sorry but you’re wrong about the container. It was explained earlier in the episode that the container was put into a place between both black holes where it was in perfect equilibrium. That is why it didn’t come apart. Plus, the integrity of the container had been breached by it being opened.

  • @carolbriscoe9337
    @carolbriscoe9337 Před 18 dny

    Thanks for your weekly review of these episodes. Can't believe next week will be the finale of the series. I'm still betting Book's planet will be restored by the Profenitor's technology

  • @EGGmockradio
    @EGGmockradio Před 23 dny +1

    I realize I’m a few days late to the party but theory: Last we heard of Detmer and Owosekun, they were piloting the ISS Enterprise to Spacedock. Any chance they make a big return as bridge crew on a newly retrofitted ISS Enterprise in the final episode? More importantly, would that redeem their absence 🤔

  • @Alex_Meyer_1311
    @Alex_Meyer_1311 Před 28 dny +17

    In the next episode Q shows up and tells them, they do not need so much power, to make the universe a better place!
    Or Riker and Troi show up and say: „Computer, end program“
    (Again…. 🤦🏻)

    • @FosterTravis1071
      @FosterTravis1071 Před 27 dny +2

      Either way... the only thing left to figure out... is WHOSE TWISTED HOLODECK FANTASY IS THIS.

    • @rodneyjackson7147
      @rodneyjackson7147 Před 27 dny +2

      and this was directed by frakes...

    • @JohnThomWebb
      @JohnThomWebb Před 27 dny +1

      Both of those endings would be better than this trash, I guarantee.

    • @marcusjohansson668
      @marcusjohansson668 Před 27 dny +2

      Honestly, the "end program" would be better than ANYTHING THESE COMPLETE JOKE OF WRITERS came up with whatever it will be, I PROMISE you!

    • @JohnThomWebb
      @JohnThomWebb Před 27 dny +3

      @@marcusjohansson668 I really did not expect them to be able to do worse in the last season than any season before but they've really surprised me with how truly awful the writing can get. The acting got slightly better as the show went on so Burnham is not completely unwatchable anymore but the actual good actors on the show get too little screen time. It's rather unfortunate. I could not possibly have lower expectations for the series finale and yet, I'm sure they'll find a way to disappoint.

  • @gwilym1991
    @gwilym1991 Před 27 dny +1

    I'm amazed no one pointed out that provided they don't leave the area. Discovery started with Binary Stars and will end with Binary black holes/stars

    • @thewonderladie
      @thewonderladie Před 27 dny

      Yes! Thank you for bringing this up. I noticed that right away. Thematically, it's rather beautiful I think.