Gun Review: Springfield TRP vs Remington R1 10mm Hunting Pistols
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 05. 2018
- What do you get when you have a pair of new 10mm longslide 1911-style pistols? A head-to-head, that’s what. There are far too many similarities in style, audience, features, and price not to consider the 6” Remington R1911 and Springfield TRP Operator arch enemies, not only in the tactical market, but the hunting pistol field as well. Which one do you choose when you walk into that gun shop with a pocket full of cash?
Visit Guns.com for the full article - Zábava
I really enjoyed this straight forward vs video. More often than not people want to spend more time trying to show off or be funny than actually picking a gun. Your shooting was short and to the point while showing accuracy and nice as well. You didn’t shoot off 50 rounds in video to tell us you have shot 500 with no issues, I appreciate that. Thumbs up.
Very informative no nonsense video. Videos like this really help people out.Thank you
Great review, the TRP with that Bull barrel looks NICE!!
Nice Job, buying the Springfield, have a Kimber I also like, but the Springfield looks like a tank and worth the money. New subscriber...
Great shooting and thanks for the video
I have a Remington 1911 r1 in 45 never had but one failure and it was a stove pipe. I have really enjoyed my Remington 1911 45, I would love to try the 10 mm. I would also like to try the Springfield.
Hi, love your video. I like your "pistols & reviews". Your clean and well spoken. My next pistol will be a Springfield. Could you do or have you made a ccw pistol of choice and why? Thank you .
I’d rather have a Ruger SR1911 in 10mm than that Rem
But, ruger doesn't make a long slide... YET
Outstanding review! Well done! Go2A!
A Remington handgun having a failure to feed? Never would've guessed, lol.
Some guns don't like some ammo. Plus shoot full power 10mm ammo like Underwood, Buffalo Bore, or Double Tap and neither including the Remington will have no issue. If you want to shoot watered down 10mm ammo than shoot a 40.
@@abcertweld you are accurate!
@@jamesanderson562 I've never had an issue with mine when I shoot full power ammo.
Thank you for justifying my purchase! Lol Glad this turned out like it did because that 1911 is on its way - ordered it a few days ago.
What is the tuning on the recoil springs ? Will they safely handle Buffalo Bore ammo ?
Wondering if a Wolfe spring kit would tune the timing.
I would have soaked the rem with silicone spray all over for the first 200 rounds. Then dried and tried. Nice video NTL.
Simple fix on the Remington. A Dremel and some polishing compound on the feed ramp should help out a lot. Get the mirror shine going. A high end magazine helps also. Typically running hollow points on a new pistol are the biggest culprits.
Would love getting the Springfield TRP
Look at 2:21 at how off the slide is on the rails of that Remington. The left side looks really wonky in comparison to the right. You see it multiple times throughout the video too. Unfortunately their QC leaves something to be desired.
Kevin B ... crazy, it doesn't seem to fit.
Kevin B I couldnt quit starring at it. Lol! Its like trying not to stare at someone with a huge zit in their face.
Damn, good eye on that!
Good catch.
Everything i see and hear the remington needs to be broken in with tight tolerances, ignorance is what kills a good gun nd its image
the thicker barrel of the Springfield was probably meant to handle the heat from firing more shots without losing accuracy.
thank you so much it`s so amazing
I love my STI Perfect 10.
Good video.
I have two Springfield's and when I saw one guy do a demo of the Springfield in 10mm the handle came off of it and for that price I would take the Remington although the Springfield shot better , many reviews that I have seen have said that the Remington 10mm is fine after about 50 rounds have gone through it , both Companies would have a Winner if these problems were not there . The Remington has a Match Grade Barrel , that was left out .
Personal preference? Do you want something works or does not?
Great video
Nice shooting.
Stay Vigilant.
Swap the magazines and run the test again.
I'd rather save a few more weeks and drop the extra 500$ on the Springfield. Starting to see them in the low 1000s. 1250ish
Some guns don't like some ammo. Plus shoot full power 10mm ammo like Underwood, Buffalo Bore, or Double Tap and neither including the Remington will have no issue. If you want to shoot watered down 10mm ammo than shoot a 40.
Springfield TRP!!!!!
Gir,l you rock!
Question at :54 for someone that basically knows little about guns: hand struggle with the slide on the Springfield. Is that because the gun is brand new, or could it use a little cleaning and gun oil???!!!! The narrators' hands look pretty strong to me.
The Springfield is my favorite. The TRP is built rugged.
Springfield TRP Operator !!
the TRP is one of the sexiest pistols I've ever seen
This is a classic example of "you get what you pay for". I also suspect that rumors about Remington QC may also have some truth to them. Shame.
Some guns don't like some ammo. Plus shoot full power 10mm ammo like Underwood, Buffalo Bore, or Double Tap and neither including the Remington will have no issue. If you want to shoot watered down 10mm ammo than shoot a 40.
@@abcertweld remmington has been having trouble for a while
That's me. Heavy 6in bull barrel.
What causes failure to feed for those that know ?
poverty and high food prices
It could be several reasons: dirty gun, some guns simply don’t shoot some ammunition well and are choosy of what they like. And of course, sometimes the gun itself just isn’t built to quality standards. Sometimes, some ammunition may be underpowered and not operate well in certain guns.
Comparing the Springfield to the Remington is like comparing a slice of cake to a crap sandwich.
One of these guns is much better than the other lol
Springfield simply makes a better gun
Failure Issues = Operator Error
for the price of the TRP, I'd get a Dan Wesson
Remington not as tight and blended slide to frame no checkering and not forged
I want trp
Or just save your money and buy the TRP
I will not buy the Remington if it has failure problems it's like buying a Hi-Point $100 type guns
The Remington probably has a long break in period
I have seen the Remingtons have lots of problems.
VERYGOOD VERYGOOD
I LOVE I WANT THE GUN
M.1911 45 ACP 10MM AND 38 SUPER MADE IN USA ALL BRAND
@THAILAND 26.3.2563.
my T-97 with a scope only cost me 1,500 Canadian... over priced guns. Glock 700 dollars ;)
Bull barrel for 1911 means shorter life span.
How so?
Failure to feed is just a break in... I know XDDDD
Springfield fTW
I heard the R1’s were crap...
At one point in time I had 12 1911's of various brands both 10 and 45, right now im down to 3. Two TRP Operators, one in 6 inch 10mm and a 5 inch 45. Then there is the Kimber stainless gold match which I don't shoot because its more of a "jazzed up" and accessorized, its beautiful and just for show at this point. But im going to get another TRP Operator 10mm in 5 inch, that bull barrel makes a huge difference, those springfields are just awesome. That being said I have a Sig p220 legion SAO I cant wait to sell, what a let down, I should of just bought the springfield with that money. I know the 220 is not exactly a 1911 but the concept is close.
no ear muff !!
I would rather shoot and but a high point 10mm than a remington hand gun. Love there rifles and shotguns, but there handguns absolutely suck. I would trust my life to a Jennings before I would a remington hand gun.
Some guns don't like some ammo. Plus shoot full power 10mm ammo like Underwood, Buffalo Bore, or Double Tap and neither including the Remington will have no issue. If you want to shoot watered down 10mm ammo than shoot a 40.
Save your money and get the TRP,Remington sucks
Remington is a dumpster fire now
Springfield TRP 10mm winner!, Remington R1 10mm loser!, Period!
Some guns don't like some ammo. Plus shoot full power 10mm ammo like Underwood, Buffalo Bore, or Double Tap and neither including the Remington will have no issue. If you want to shoot watered down 10mm ammo than shoot a 40.
OMG THIS LADIES VOICE IS LIKE NAILS ON A CHALK BOARD!! I AM SURE SHE IS A PERFECTLY FINE LADY, BUT REALLY HER VOICE IS HORRIBLE! I AM SORRY I AM A COMPLETE ASSHAT I KNOW, BUT ITS REALLY BOTHERING ME! I AM GOING TO HELL! I JUST HOPE THIS LADY GOES TO HEAVEN SO I WILL NEVER HAVE TO HEAR THAT AGAIN!
Jesus,,,, get your pantys out of your ass and just listen to her content.
It’s driving me nuts too lol
Almost as irritating as someone who screams in all caps with exclamation points....