Hindi imposition and north-Indian bias
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 06. 2023
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @vimohlive
Support the show at / vimoh
Make a one-time donation at vimoh.stck.me/profile
Please read these rules before commenting. Follow them to the best of your ability. The rules are meant to keep the comment space clean and a safe space for anyone who wishes to participate in good faith.
1. No advocating violence of any kind against anyone for any reason. People doing so will get banned from the channel.
2. No praising or abusing any religion for any reason. Proselytising is not appreciated, nor is making generalised statements about the followers of any religion. People doing so will get banned.
3. No casteism, racism, or sexism. Discriminatory language will get you banned too.
4. Trolling, spamming, use of fake accounts to deceive people about your identity, will also get you banned.
In India, Hindi poses a bigger threat to the Regional languages than English, and the Threat to The Languages related to Hindi is even Greater.
I am giving you an Example from my personal experience.
One day our Professor of Linguistics said to everybody in our Class to write our names and mother tongues.
Many of my Classmates wrote Hindi, instead of Their Original Mother tongues which were Khortha, Sadri, Magahi, etc.
Plus , in my semester exam, when I wrote an essay Critical to Hindi in Hindi on the Topic "Rastrabhasha Hindi ke bina Bharat Gunga hai", I was awarded least marks in the Paper despite of presenting Facts and Information.
Then under the 'NEP', Hindi has been forced as a compulsory subject over all students, even those who don't Know H of Hindi have to study it.
Nobody Demands for Hindi even in India, even I will appear for an Interview, the Questions will be asked in English only.
Then why should I learn Hindi, it's nither close to me like my Mother tongue, nor Useful as English.
Hindi is just Overrated
All Indian languages are feudal languages. Opt for English
True
True, even in South when I am in Chennai, if I go to a local restaurant they speak Tamil or if you go to little hifi restaurant they speak Tamil or English, but when I go to a restaurant in Hyderabad, most of them speak's Hindi.
It's like if you are coming to Tamilnadu and want to run a restaurant, you need to learn Tamil, but that's not the same in Hyderabad or Mumbai.
It might look like an advantage but forcing people to learn the local language is what keeps the language alive.
China is a good example for this, many dialects in China are almost extinct because of Mandarin.
2:30 "kyu lord ganesh
Wo British aristocrat the kya?"😂😂
Ye meme template ban sakta.
We Bengalis never accept any hindi imposition never ever.
Where hindi is impose
জাতীয় ভাষা হিন্দি ঠিক আছে, আমাদের সবার জানা,বোঝা এবং বলতে পারা উচিত কিন্তু তাই বলে নিজের মাতৃভাষা বাংলা কে কখনই ত্যাগ করা তো উচিত নয়ই, বরং আমরা অন্য কোনো ভাষার আধিপত্য মেনে নেবো না, তা সে হিন্দি হোক বা ইংরেজী। একথা ভুলে গেলে চলবে না যে বাংলাও ভারতের একুশটি রাষ্ট্রভাষার মধ্যে একটি।
😂 but you want to get imposed by a foreign language.... 😂...
speak and read bengali only
@@manurazgoit yeps
English usefulness>>>>Hindi usefulness
Got any problem?
@@saptarsi7868 if you talk about usefulness then... in all practical sense there is no use regional languages like... bengali, kannada, tamil....
use english only🤣
Respected journalist from wire tweet about how she felt after hearing तुम instead of आप while traveling in Mumbai. She critisized Mumbaikar for their flawed Hindi. But she chose not to speak in Marathi in Maharashtra.
Tamils want others to speak Tamil in TN but when they come to Mumbai or Maharashtra, they complain about having to learn Marathi (I've read these complaints online)
There's a lot of hypocrisy on both sides
@@CW-rx2js That's true we Maharashtrians get sandwiched between north and south. South Indians think we don't have our own language and we speak Hindi. And North Indians impose hindi on us. It's high time other Indians understand we have our own language 'Marathi'.
Link in description??
Language is a tool. I think saving our culture is important but we should balance it out with decentralisation of power structure of that opposite culture, not to be any culture should not be destroyed or gain supreme power on other cultures. Tell me where i am wrong.
Check the book
Indian culture: What is it exactly?
Awesome
It's easy to tell which languages are in danger and which are not. The languages which are used officially by states are no way in danger of extinction. I find south indian extremism against hindi total bs since their languages can never be in danger as long as it is used. The languages which are in danger of extinction are the once which are barely used like marwadi, magadhi, awadhi, garhwali, kumaoni etc. But then north indians don't really care about their own languages so can't say they need help with that or not.
"South Indian extremism" is a very crass way to describe decades of social agitation which LED to these languages become official languages in India. The difference between tamil and marwadi is that the Tamil people protested and protected their culture and the Marwadi people were crushed by the national hegemony.
@@mrinalganash4725 It's not called being "crushed" when they don't really care about it. Also I describe it very well. The language extremism in south is like no other non hindi states. I say this after seeing the kind of hilarious controversies because of Hindi in south. Tamil and other 4 south languages are privileged that they have their own state and those languages are used there but still they are way too insecure for it's extinction. It's just like religious extremism in north.
Bhai maine to kabhi bollywood ki wahaj se hindi nhi shikhi, main to bachpan se hii hindi bol rha hu, par hollywood dhek english main intermediate ban gya
Sir What about English imposition
@@Abhiraj_Jana Have you ever wondered why your language does not give us a good life and good salary?
English connects us to the world, we need English to be the connecting language because that will also put Hindi speakers at the same disadvantage as Malayalis, Tamilians or Bengalis. English has also helped preserve many non Hindi cultures by protecting the South and the northeast by adopting Hindi language.
@@sml4813 I am talking about imposing English, not the English language.
@@sml4813 You can tell how English protects South Indian culture and languages.
@@sid.7146 English is mainly used at work place, but Hindi could be brought into homes, which could possibly destroy the fabrics of culture. Even though I speak English at work and with friends, when I come back home I still speak to my family in Tamil or Kannada. Where as most of my friends who have learnt Hindi do not speak their mother tongue once they go home as their own parents have encouraged speaking Hindi at home. If Hindi becomes more important than English, then our jobs will be at stake, the jobs that helps sustain us. Is the government imposing English on us? No they aren’t, it’s only been Hindi. Congress and the bjp have done that repeatedly. Do you think if we foreign investors come to India or Indian investors go abroad they can speak Hindi? No they can’t, the cultural identity of India will become Hindi and not its variety of other languages that make India as India
For the difference between history and itihasa is “Dharma-artha-kama-mokshanam-upadesa samanvitham.
Poorva-vrutta-kathayuktham-itihasam prachakshate”
*Itihasam is a historical narrative that instructs (one) on Dharma, Artha, Kama, and Moksha (the Purusharthas).
So itihasa is not just history with dates and events. It’s more than that. And Ramayana and Mahabharata are the only two two itihasas claimed by the Santana dharma
This is just sharing info coz you asked for it. I don’t impose anyone to have my views I am skeptic myself but my journey of understanding our faith and culture are reviling the truths of human life and their evolution.
So basically, stories with morals?
I wonder, how can flying Monkeys, People Digging Ocean with hands, A Person from Lanka with ten heads, his oversized brother, floating stone bridge, etc can be history
@@vimohlive Stories that are already happened and provide teachings for becoming better man / human
@@basantprasadsgarden8365 Well it is for us to find out. If a claim is made then we must do archeological studies and examine those sites mentioned in those epics to debunk.
As I said I am a skeptic myself, I do not believe 100% exactly how it must have happened. There can be and most probably over exaggeration of the certain characters to paint a picture for their strengths and capabillities. Which are being added or got distorted in a way coming down from ancient times. Imagine you telling a story to one person and then that person telling to next, until it reaches hundredth person there can be many additions and substraction to the stories. something similar can happen to these stories too. And to just being clear two itihasas are 'Valmiki Ramayan' and 'Vedvyas Mahabharat' only. if you stick to these two most of the supernatural stuff is not even a part of it.
And well thats the beauty of sanatana dharma you can question and challenge everything that is said or claimed. Try doing that for another religions you would be lucky to keep your head attached to your body.
@@TheAbhishekJadhav The "happened" part is in dispute obviously. And without that, we just have stories with morals. So it's mostly just fiction with lessons. That'as not itihasa. That's children's fables.
कल्प वीगर्ह नाम से एक मूर्ति है जिस पर दावा किया जाता की ये 30000 साल पूरानी और यह विष्णु की हैं । कृप्या इस पर बताइये।🇮🇳 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙🙏🇮🇳
what about voilent imposition of kannada..even to MNCs
It's not imposition when you go to and stay in a state you speak the language of that state. Not completely atleast some words. Eg if you go to Japan atleast Know some words so that you can speak to the locals.
There's Hindi imposition happening nn Karnataka that's why kannadigas want people to talk to atleast auto drivers bus drivers in kannada
@@sharipn8348 bro you are taking example of an another nation.... and even in other nations i have been into none fight with me to speak their language, like in russia, france... nowhere...
if i face difficulty in my day to day work... i will eventually learn a local language of that place... but no one has right to force anyone to speak language they want...
you just speak in kannada and let others suffer if they don't....
Dada look at our mile stones, carefully removed English, replaced intelligently with local and hindi.... English is language of commerce there is no way around. We have the service sector as a major contributor to the Indian economy which literally runs on English!!!!! Comparing Hindi imposition with English is stupid!!!!