HOW INDIAN POLITICS WORKS (I Think) Reaction! |

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
  • Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
    ____________________
    Intro music by DAVIS
    CZcams - bit.ly/30OK7RR
    Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
    iTunes: apple.co/2KnvgYN
    SoundCloud: / unofficialdavis
    Facebook: / unofficialdavis
    Twitter: / unofficialdavis
    Instagram: / unofficialdavis
    ___
    Jamazing Patrons of June: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Madhan, Riju Mahna, Pankaj Goel, Elisha Mittal and Gaurav Kolarkar!
    Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
    / jabykoay
    ___________________________________________________
    Original Upload Link:
    • How Indian Politics Wo...
    ___________________________________________________
    SOCIAL MEDIA:
    ~ACHARA KIRK~
    Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
    / achara
    ~JABY KOAY~
    CZcams, Twitter, Instagram: @jabykoay
    ~VEERENDRA CHOWDARY~
    Veerendra Chowdary created the opening animation.
    Twitter: @NameisVeeru
    ~MOOSA RAZA~
    Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
    Instagram: @syedraza7
    Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
    ___________________________________________________
    Jaby WEST:
    / getjaby
    Jaby ASIA:
    / jabytv
    JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
    • JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
    Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
    czcams.com/users/subscription_c...
    Thanks for watching!!!
    __________________________________________________
    Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
    Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
    creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
    Intro song: Hudson Stanton (looks more like Nick Jonas than me)
    CZcams: / hudson12311
    Insta: / hudsonstantonmusic
  • Komedie

Komentáře • 6K

  • @atharvagodambe5555
    @atharvagodambe5555 Před rokem +3769

    I don't have any hate against muslims but he mostly spoke from the Muslim perspective of India this is because the information he got from Western media cover largely of abhramic religions but it rarely covers non-abrahmic religions like Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, shintoism, etc

    • @vikata5499
      @vikata5499 Před rokem +283

      Rather leftist perspective.

    • @lavenyasharma
      @lavenyasharma Před rokem +91

      true

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +1

      Hindus and pagans lives don't matter ..I think

    • @Ishantyagiofficial
      @Ishantyagiofficial Před rokem

      yup he said we attack non hindus what !!!!
      when we attack sikh, christan, jew, parsi, buddh, jain ? Only muslims are who create tensions and every country is sick of muslims we saw roits in europe between christain and muslims, roits in israel between jews and muslims riots in china between CCP and muslims, in india non muslims vs muslims
      in their own islamic countries muslims ( shia ) vs muslims ( sunni )
      what's in common - MUSLIMS

    • @prabhatpandey5861
      @prabhatpandey5861 Před rokem +76

      Exactly

  • @raviahuja9287
    @raviahuja9287 Před rokem +1753

    Also fun fact the Gandhi family of the Congress are not related to Mahatma Gandhi in any way. They just share a common name.

    • @TusharSharma-gc4vs
      @TusharSharma-gc4vs Před rokem +4

      @@ronitmahawar5220 what? NO!!

    • @shivammehrotra8757
      @shivammehrotra8757 Před rokem +92

      For political benefit Nehru asked Mahatma Gandhi to adopt Indira and give her Gandhi as last name.
      Although India has been patriarchy but they kept Gandhi and not Khan

    • @sukshiths.m.4592
      @sukshiths.m.4592 Před rokem +56

      @@ronitmahawar5220 no.. they Belong to Ghandy Family (Feroze Gandhy, who changed his surname to Gandhi as he followed Mohandas Gandhi)
      Feroze Gandhi is the husband of Indira Gandhi.

    • @OGThorOdinson
      @OGThorOdinson Před rokem +17

      Noo When Indra Gandhi married a Muslim man so they got the Muslim surname and After the divorce Mahatma Gandhi said you can have my surname

    • @girdrache
      @girdrache Před rokem +3

      They didn't share the name they took the common name.

  • @Yeagerr9
    @Yeagerr9 Před rokem +555

    Little knowledge is very dangerous thing 😌

    • @abubakarrashid9109
      @abubakarrashid9109 Před 2 měsíci +6

      lekin wo sahi to bol raha hai

    • @BhuviJassal
      @BhuviJassal Před 2 měsíci +5

      ​@@abubakarrashid9109 puri baat ni btai 2002 me shuru kese huye
      kuii pehle pange lete ho baad me victim card khelte ho
      fir kehte ho julm hua

    • @abubakarrashid9109
      @abubakarrashid9109 Před 2 měsíci

      @@BhuviJassal abey jab hum pangey letey hai to pichey nahi hattey samjha
      aur agar tu police se badh kar hai to fir aamney samney aaja
      saza court deta na ki hindu terrorist
      aur waisey bhi tum logo ne kisi aur se badla liya

  • @romeoakbarwalter8630
    @romeoakbarwalter8630 Před 2 měsíci +18

    **Wrong info alert ** : BJP is a nationalist party and not a hindu party. There are muslim wings in BJP. JJ's research is half baked.

  • @thethirddoor5480
    @thethirddoor5480 Před rokem +658

    *The Gujrat violence*
    It happened when a train full of Hindu Devotees were burned down by Islamic mob. In result of that there happened a huge fight between hindu and muslim mobs. Many hindus and muslims got killed. Modi was cm of Gujrat at that time, opposition accuses modi that he didn't done anything to stop that violence.
    Later several terrorist attacks happened in Gujrat by Islamic terrorist mainly Pakistan originated to teach hindus a lesson. Famous temple of Gujrat also hijacked by terrorists and many hindus were killed. Recently 38 Islamic terrorist got death sentence 💀. It takes nearly 14 years to give justice to victims of terrorist bomb blasts.

    • @thelastline4583
      @thelastline4583 Před rokem +1

      Western Media to Muslims : Oh dear gorgeous.
      Western media to Hindus : You f'in donkey

    • @logophile9
      @logophile9 Před rokem +16

      Yes

    • @ronin0077
      @ronin0077 Před rokem

      Yes but west only follow liberal media which blames hindus for all the problems, ex - 26/11

    • @randomgoodvideos1569
      @randomgoodvideos1569 Před rokem +15

      thank you

    • @huh..4591
      @huh..4591 Před rokem +33

      And also kashmir, they already saw the movie and their was congress government then

  • @moviefan3785
    @moviefan3785 Před rokem +959

    This video is extremely biased.
    He didn't tell that The Godhra train burning occurred on the morning of 27 February 2002, in which Hindu pilgrims and karsevaks returning from Ayodhya, were killed in a fire inside the Sabarmati Express train by near the Godhra railway station in the Indian state of Gujarat.

    • @anondolphin71
      @anondolphin71 Před rokem

      ****killed by Muslims

    • @rajatjaiswal8355
      @rajatjaiswal8355 Před rokem +18

      Exactly

    • @pranav1256
      @pranav1256 Před rokem +25

      That is strictly religious though and not political. He was talking about Modi's involvement in it and not the actual incident. I think the video was pretty unbiased in covering the two major parties beliefs.

    • @reyaroy4236
      @reyaroy4236 Před rokem +57

      This guy who made this yt video did all his research on Al Jazeera propoganda channel. 😂

    • @sparks8087
      @sparks8087 Před rokem +2

      That incident could have been politicised too. For inciting the riots. There’s no evidence but there is possibility. We will never know what actually led to burning of the train.

  • @saga38
    @saga38 Před rokem +297

    I lived my entire life here in India but I don't know what is a cow belt is, i think the reference is to point out the major Hindi speaking belt, as we all know that Hindi is not very popular in south India and north east India, but the best part is that we all Indians connect to each other , either by Hindi or by English or by using both languages together, we Indians call such a language as "Hinglish" 😀

    • @Trash-hc5uk
      @Trash-hc5uk Před rokem

      Bcz you're ignorant... Hindi belt is also known as cow belt electorally bcz they worship cow in this region. People in South or NE region eat beef so not included in cow belt

    • @saga38
      @saga38 Před rokem +5

      @@Trash-hc5uk this is good info, but what makes you feel i am ignorant... The term "Cow belt" is not widely used, only a small niche community use this term and i am not among that, i suggest you should too stop assuming that only Hindi speaking people worships cow, this term Cow belt is too communal and it feels like targetting a particular community.

    • @Dwrksied
      @Dwrksied Před 3 měsíci +1

      Hindi is extremely popular in NE states though. Only our accent is a little different.

    • @nishthagupta1357
      @nishthagupta1357 Před 3 měsíci

      Exactly yess

    • @putridtrouble
      @putridtrouble Před 2 měsíci

      'cow belt' was an insulting term to use instead of 'hindi/urdu belt'

  • @Pennywise.18
    @Pennywise.18 Před rokem +75

    To understand Indian Politics you need to know Indian history otherwise things without context are just blown out of proportion 🥱
    Peace

  • @shauryapratapsingh6052
    @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +317

    Bjp made apj abdul kalam president of india ..which is even higher position than prime minister ..
    But these propaganda driven people call Modi as anti Muslim 😂😂

    • @Rajeev_Singh1
      @Rajeev_Singh1 Před rokem +18

      Yes

    • @thesouthindianpov4443
      @thesouthindianpov4443 Před rokem +34

      They dont consider APJ sir as a Muslim... because he used to read Bhagavad-Gita.... His funeral march only had a fraction of what terr#$t Yakub memon had.

    • @rajatjaiswal8355
      @rajatjaiswal8355 Před rokem +3

      Exactly

    • @arnavranka4510
      @arnavranka4510 Před rokem +29

      They call Modi as casteist, when he himself is from a backward caste.
      They call him a Hindi imposer, when Hindi isn't even his first language.

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem

      @@arnavranka4510 just some woke things ...less brains more gyaaaaaan

  • @totallyweird2794
    @totallyweird2794 Před rokem +320

    The video is like having half knowledge and sublimely propagate hindu phobia.
    There are many layers to it.

    • @sorenutpal6091
      @sorenutpal6091 Před rokem +2

      Yes

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Před rokem +1

      Chup chutiye , offend hona haii bass tum bhadwoo koo

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem

      india is secular because hindus are in majority...
      Hindus were forced to leave afganistan pakistan Bangladesh kashmir srilanka bhutan ..even after that hindus in india accepted every community.. before the word secularism was added in constitution during emergency by Indira Gandhi..

  • @repistmohammad9621
    @repistmohammad9621 Před rokem +65

    it is better to know nothing than having half knowledge. The video is a perfect example.

  • @rpb4865
    @rpb4865 Před rokem +46

    10:59 if this is being fair and unbiased then I don't know what to say 😂😂

  • @mendel_baba1784
    @mendel_baba1784 Před rokem +442

    The guy said that BJP is dominated by upper class hindus of the cow belt.....but actually he is wrong.....NAMO himself is an OBC (Other Backward Caste).....moreover there are many cabinet ministers who are from east, south and NE India

    • @nitishupadhyay3481
      @nitishupadhyay3481 Před rokem +32

      sc st and OBC vote share is pretty big

    • @Wiseenoughtobefoolish
      @Wiseenoughtobefoolish Před rokem

      The president ramnath Govind himself is a Dalit. This video as always is a typical liberal mindset explaination of acting like knowing everything when they dnt know anything 😂

    • @piyushmeher8369
      @piyushmeher8369 Před rokem +21

      NAMO Means "Na"rendra "Mo"di

    • @shashianandtoppo
      @shashianandtoppo Před rokem

      Only party which are led by upper caste brahmin lare winning in this country.modi is just a puppet. However I appreciate upper caste people to hv leadership quality which are not found in OBC/SC/at.

    • @aayushsharma6755
      @aayushsharma6755 Před rokem +16

      Also there biggest vote bank is OBC

  • @DrAshishPradhan
    @DrAshishPradhan Před rokem +755

    I am Hindu. My first language is Odia. We use Hindi as common language among various language speakers. That's it. But Hindi language is not an essential criteria to be an Indian or a Hindu.

  • @subrayhegde264
    @subrayhegde264 Před rokem +7

    Modi did not incite violence. Muslim extremists burned a train car filled with Hindu volunteers returning from Ayodhya. 57 innocent Hindu volunteers were burnt alive. It was the response from the public that resulted in targetted killing.

  • @mohanpatelbg8545
    @mohanpatelbg8545 Před rokem +25

    He was accused, but he got clean chit by court

  • @kinoobscura9946
    @kinoobscura9946 Před rokem +3722

    Yep exactly what we want , a Canadian to tell us how Indian politics works. Already we've an Italian doing it.

    • @wanderingsoul457
      @wanderingsoul457 Před rokem +140

      Good one😂

    • @leahhhh7981
      @leahhhh7981 Před rokem +60

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @nittynatsha4346
      @nittynatsha4346 Před rokem

      Y'all get proud when indian-origin politicians get elected outside India.. But when there are Italians in your country , you shame them for it. That's the difference.

    • @indian6455
      @indian6455 Před rokem

      Get some knowledge about Islam digusting teaching why Islam hate every other religion specially idol worshiper. Why their Allah hate non Muslims....spend some time to know Islam teaching by books or ex Muslims on youtube who read by Quran text with Islamic Sciptrues reference.. Islam is political militants ideology to conquer the world by violence ,genocide ,war, lies, Victimhood...

    • @nirajyadu
      @nirajyadu Před rokem +71

      That's gold

  • @rationalsamrat3247
    @rationalsamrat3247 Před rokem +1409

    the reason why hindi and Hindu sound similar is because both of them were given by foreigners based on Sindhu river , Persians Greeks and Roman's called us as Hindu or Indos(India also came from the same word) because our culture started from sindhu river .
    sindhu river is one of the sacred rivers of Hinduism, almost all major rivers in india are sacred to hindus as we consider them as mothers that sustain civilization.

    • @sorenutpal6091
      @sorenutpal6091 Před rokem +4

      Yes

    • @veerareddy9119
      @veerareddy9119 Před rokem +10

      Not like our culture only started from Sindhu river only at the population was spread across most of the India the only thing is that we don't because we did not explored, digged the rest of India for archeological survey.

    • @shailendrasingh6507
      @shailendrasingh6507 Před rokem

      That was totally wrong which is said by communist people and putting this lines on everyone's mouth

    • @rationalsamrat3247
      @rationalsamrat3247 Před rokem +4

      @@veerareddy9119 by start I meant geographically not historical.

    • @utkarshverma013
      @utkarshverma013 Před rokem +4

      No. It's a misconception that the word "Hindu" was given by foreigners. We can find it mentioned in various ancient scriptures like Bhavishya Puran, Kalika Puran, Shargandhar Paddhati, Brahspati Aagam, etc. However, I do agree that the term has geographical roots, rather than religious ones.

  • @gautamgoyal7397
    @gautamgoyal7397 Před měsícem +7

    Also, to mention that there is nothing like extreme hinduism bcz Hinduism allows everyone to question their religion and asks people for non violence. Which means A person with with strong belief in Hinduism would be against of taking life even if he/she is an athiest or belongs to any other religion.

  • @Drillcopter
    @Drillcopter Před rokem +18

    8:28 funfact hindu do not attack non hindu, but muslim attack non Muslim

  • @funnycountdown6739
    @funnycountdown6739 Před rokem +885

    Another fact I am a Hindu , my school was run by rss (in this video he said rss extremist hindu group). In my school they never taught me to hate Muslims or never be violent or anything else alarming. In fact they focus on education + teachings our Sanskriti like respecting your elders , they teach Sanskrit language also which is getting lost these days . They taught us mantras and little bit of our hindu culture also but never anything against any other religions.
    I am a qualified CA now, and my best friend is muslim so it is quite frustrating how propoganda some people are spreading around the World.

    • @nikhilreddy8550
      @nikhilreddy8550 Před rokem +142

      RSS has to be the most misunderstood organization.

    • @kaiwalyaghotkar832
      @kaiwalyaghotkar832 Před rokem

      But my friend is from RSS and really hates Muslims , even my relatives hate Muslims , and they call them by derogatory names .

    • @robustlion
      @robustlion Před rokem +99

      RSS has been backbone of India even before independence, and people and other western countries just try to portray it in a completely negetive way.

    • @kireeti93
      @kireeti93 Před rokem +73

      @@nikhilreddy8550 It is not misunderstood but misrepresented purposefully.

    • @nikhilreddy8550
      @nikhilreddy8550 Před rokem +13

      @@kaiwalyaghotkar832 What kind of logic is that?
      I can also your whacky logic. Chinese also ill treat muslims, so they are also from RSS.

  • @GodOfWar0379
    @GodOfWar0379 Před rokem +244

    First time heard of the "Cow Belt", and being from that region, it's hilarious. And if I start writing about the things which he assumed wrong, it will turn into an essay of 2500+ words which no one would like to read. So, Peace out.

    • @the_nitish_singh
      @the_nitish_singh Před rokem +4

      Absolutely

    • @offencebestdefence500
      @offencebestdefence500 Před rokem +9

      Couldn't even watch the full video
      So much trash

    • @anandjainishere
      @anandjainishere Před rokem +5

      In South India, UP and nearby states are usually called cow belt.

    • @offencebestdefence500
      @offencebestdefence500 Před rokem +10

      @@anandjainishere what a joke🤣🤣🤣🤣 ...I m from the south...and except for Marxist n jihadis n the News channels in bed with them no one call any one as cow belt
      🤣🤣🤣 this is funny

    • @Rahul-pz7xb
      @Rahul-pz7xb Před rokem +4

      @@anandjainishere yess its always called cow belt region

  • @jasonkadayat8168
    @jasonkadayat8168 Před rokem +17

    Stan means boobs 🤣🤣🤣 but staan means place in pronunciation.

  • @sire_99
    @sire_99 Před měsícem +4

    Half knowledge is more dangerous than not knowing something

  • @user-ob7jp1kz2o
    @user-ob7jp1kz2o Před rokem +646

    It is better to know nothing than having half knowledge. This video is a perfect example.

  • @globalaffairs8517
    @globalaffairs8517 Před rokem +537

    The problems stated, are largely present in the West. The fact that, the media is under Western control those issues are not publicly discussed.

    • @Shahbaz7771khan
      @Shahbaz7771khan Před rokem

      No indian media is godi they just praise government

    • @AstrobyAbhimanyu
      @AstrobyAbhimanyu Před rokem +53

      It's really funny how they make videos on India from the information available from the west 😂

    • @injustice5814
      @injustice5814 Před rokem +8

      oh c'mon they don't have volatile neighbors or population issues...

    • @TheRishijoesanu
      @TheRishijoesanu Před rokem +7

      I disagree. Poverty is a much bigger problem in India than in the West. Anyone who has lived in the West from India will attest

    • @sparks8087
      @sparks8087 Před rokem +3

      They have problems too, but they are much different from India. And poverty etc are bigger problems here. Standard of living is much higher .

  • @Oxygen846
    @Oxygen846 Před rokem +11

    I lived my entire life here in India but I don't know what is a cow belt

  • @subodhsingh7126
    @subodhsingh7126 Před rokem +12

    He sums the western media views of hindu and india

  • @The__Leo69
    @The__Leo69 Před rokem +129

    10:20 he told just half of it. Complete story is:
    The train boggey carrying Hindu karsevaks returning from Ayodhya was burned down. Many men, women and children were burnt alive. This incidence erupted riots, which killed many hindus and muslims. This guy told only muslim death toll, thanks to media.

    • @spilltea4241
      @spilltea4241 Před rokem +4

      It's not about what muslims and Hindus did, it's about what the Government and police did to maintain peace, thousands of innocent Hindus and muslims died and the government must take accountability

    • @greensloth5125
      @greensloth5125 Před rokem +3

      @@spilltea4241 exactly you have to hold the government accountable for whatever happens

    • @swatisuman2835
      @swatisuman2835 Před rokem +6

      @@spilltea4241 but who said modi was behind all that...u should check the report on Godhra kand submitted by the detective agency in which modi was proved innocent.
      We can discuss about things but can't blame anyone for anything just based on the rumours.
      And In the J J's video all the things were half told and only based on their perspective about India...the international perspective.
      They don't show the reason behind violence or who's doing that, they just show "Hindus oppressing Muslims".
      Also they only talk about those violences in Hindus(in most cases started by Muslims, u can check) were involved not the one in which only Muslims were involved such as: Delhi Violence over CAA, Kashmiri genocide, Nupur Sharma controversy...the stone pelting etc.

    • @santhoshd1833
      @santhoshd1833 Před rokem +6

      @@spilltea4241 then why dont anybody condemn or talked about hindus pilgrimage train burnt alive...isn't Islamic terrorism? and why don't anybody talked about verdict of court saying that modi is innocent? why? because those facts don't suit for congress & muslims parties appeasement politics...

  • @rishavjain1867
    @rishavjain1867 Před rokem +558

    One of the reasons of Congress' decline was the inaction over the cruel violence of Muslim mobs against non-muslims. THey preached secularism and did victim-blaming saying how can majority be victim and whatnot which basically sowed the seed of absolute hatred against the party.
    Also, corruption of ungodly levels

    • @mdqumar3170
      @mdqumar3170 Před rokem +14

      now india is at lowest employment rate
      worst economic condition
      highest inflation
      most unsafe place for women
      last rank in eas of doing bussiness envornment etc etc
      yess this is very godly gold... ant it

    • @rishavjain1867
      @rishavjain1867 Před rokem

      @@mdqumar3170 lmfao I just mentioned Congress' true faultlines and somehow I have to listen about bjp's failures?
      You're just blinded by utmost hatred for thre present regime but I'll still pick them as the lesser of 2 evils. I'd rather buy costly petrol than live in constant fear of being killed by maulvi's whims and constant bomb blasts all across the place whilst getting blamed for them while the govt. is selling away the country to china.
      Jaa azaan padh apne papa Raga ki jeet ki

    • @DhruvaL-3000
      @DhruvaL-3000 Před rokem +41

      @@mdqumar3170 you people are always crying
      Bhai if you are indian and so much affect with these problems then stop complaining and try to do something about it Hardships are there but it's our job to make our country great and prosperous become a businessman or start a startup give unemployed people job earn lots of money and help people in need stop blaming BJP
      BJP is in power because Congress fail to understand emotions and feelings of Indian people
      No matter what you do Modi will be the PM of India for another 10 years

    • @Rashisy81i5
      @Rashisy81i5 Před rokem +19

      @@mdqumar3170 lo bhaya Bidwa Bilap suru ho gaya ...

    • @mysteriousperson9808
      @mysteriousperson9808 Před rokem +22

      @@mdqumar3170 really? Wow..... Firstly educate yourself as a Indian not as BJP opposition. Do not make yourself a laugh for others.🤣

  • @kishorchaudhari7897
    @kishorchaudhari7897 Před rokem +5

    JJ... One week is not enough to digest a sip of indian political ocean

  • @vishalambule1856
    @vishalambule1856 Před měsícem +3

    Okay, Now a Canadian tells us how Indian politics works. Lol 😆

  • @yashraj_official6009
    @yashraj_official6009 Před rokem +677

    JJ totally missed the JP Movement and Emergency era of Indian Politics in 1979, which was the reason for the rise of different Political Parties including Jan Sangh which later called BJP and other regional Parties specially in the so called "Cow Belt" and the fall for congress's monopoly in Indian politics.
    Also Bihar is also considered under "cow Belt" what he missed in the map.

    • @shreshth6841
      @shreshth6841 Před rokem +3

      Ummm not really Bihar doesn't have a religious politics Bihar has high level of cast politics and corruption election in Bihar is mostly about who will provide govt jobs better and making roads better with a 90% chunk of caste favourism. Politics in Bihar is very different that UP or madhyapradesh because Bihar has quite a few muslims, it's like sometime it is extreme right wing sometimes extreme left wing so the politics in Bihar is very volatile and fickle minded plus you know a bit of forced voting indirectly. Like every rule about election has once been broken in bihar

    • @bbaworld4942
      @bbaworld4942 Před rokem +46

      He was just focusing on propaganda
      Against india and hindu

    • @spilltea4241
      @spilltea4241 Před rokem +3

      Bihar isn't part of cow belt

    • @arunodaysetu5062
      @arunodaysetu5062 Před rokem +4

      All those bullshits that happening in UP and madhyapradesh between religious grps are definitely not happening or happened in bihar. There is caste politics here but definitely not the religion involvement of any kind till now. So your comment on cow belt is pure false.

    • @priyanshagrl1721
      @priyanshagrl1721 Před rokem

      To your comment on how he missed somethings, even you and everybody else will agree when I say that the Indian Political System is too complex and complicated to be covered in a single youtube video, and if one tries it'll become boring and wouldn't get much engagement on video.......
      What he can do is make it episodic (like in Parts) to "try" to cover entirety of politics....!

  • @halleyscomet2672
    @halleyscomet2672 Před rokem +378

    The other day I watching news with my family and it was showing that the members of "peaceful community" involved in Nupur Sharma stone pelting were getting punished i.e their property was being destroyed. And the first thing that left my mouth was "this is something they will show on international media. But they will never show the reasons for this on international media" and just by reading comments, I know how right I was.

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +2

      What they show is hindus are terrorist ..and muslims are victims ..
      Even after kashmiri hindu genocide , pakistan Bangladesh afganistan srilanka bhutan hindu genocide

    • @gagan77100
      @gagan77100 Před rokem +4

      Agniveer protest 700 crore worth property burnt stone pelting but no bulldozer no arrest.

    • @iash0ksingh1794
      @iash0ksingh1794 Před rokem +13

      @@gagan77100 the uttar pradesh government is already started the process...

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +4

      @@gagan77100you are unaware of news ..

    • @halleyscomet2672
      @halleyscomet2672 Před rokem +2

      @@gagan77100 if i m not mistaken only UP govt has taken action.

  • @Rahul-pz7xb
    @Rahul-pz7xb Před rokem +11

    Politics symbols were always funny since my childhood 🤣🤣🤣😂

  • @arvind9405
    @arvind9405 Před rokem +3

    6:20 I'm from south of India
    Hindi is not Hinduism
    sanskrit is Hinduism and almost every language in India as sanskrit words , unfortunately no one speak sanskrit

  • @drdripransom342
    @drdripransom342 Před rokem +369

    Indian Politics is soooo complex that you can't compress it in a 20 minute video
    Indians haven't able to understand the system itself, people dedicate 10 or 20 years of their lives for studying politics in India
    Also Hindus are the followers of Hinduism and Hindi is a language, they sound the same but are not related in the sense that you need to be hindu to speak hindi or anything
    I have seen some Americans say "Do you speak Hindu" so nope Hindi is the language

  • @YoshitaASharma
    @YoshitaASharma Před rokem +1613

    Every day as I hear some Westener sharing their wisdom on India, the more I realize that how much the West hates Hindus, which is so unfortunate. Also, the Gujarat incident, left thousands of Hindus dead as well. The Godhra train where the Hindu pilgrims were seated was burnt by a Muslim group. That part is conveniently ignored to propagate the victim narrative of minorities.
    And yes, Mughal invaders were muslims. They were responsible for converting thousands of Hindus into Muslims by raping women, and by forceful conversion. The West loves to propagate the minority hatred narrative because they are threatened by the idea of India becoming a superpower. The Hindus are the most inclusive people. History has shown that how respectful and inclusive we have been to people who fled other countries because of Ismalic invasion.
    Addition: For Jaby and Achara and others. Read about the Sanatana culture which was the foundation of the Indus valley civilization. Unfortunately in today's climate, if someone talks about reviving the Santana culture is termed as far right and minority hater, which is again, so unfortunate.

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +1

      india is secular because hindus are in majority...
      Hindus were forced to leave afganistan pakistan Bangladesh kashmir srilanka bhutan ..even after that hindus in india accepted every community.. before the word secularism was added in constitution during emergency by Indira Gandhi..

    • @b18harshsinha83
      @b18harshsinha83 Před rokem +107

      Millions not thousands , india never had muslims

    • @jatinsingh5426
      @jatinsingh5426 Před rokem +17

      When reality hits a brainwashed minf

    • @jatinsingh5426
      @jatinsingh5426 Před rokem +2

      When reality hits a brainwashed minf

    • @AakashChaudhary565
      @AakashChaudhary565 Před rokem +7

      True

  • @proudconservative23
    @proudconservative23 Před rokem +2

    I think someone invisible is grabbing his hair and moving his head.....he cant stop using his neck muscles to talk 🤣🤣

  • @prashantkatwankar9902

    Nice shirt Jaby. Loved it! 💯

  • @ojasvisingh7020
    @ojasvisingh7020 Před rokem +342

    being an Indian i can definitely confirm that this video is super biased towards one perspective . It is not fair at all . This man needs to get his facts right

    • @nanameanduku671
      @nanameanduku671 Před rokem +2

      yeah

    • @IronMan-dp8gv
      @IronMan-dp8gv Před rokem +3

      Well let them decide for themselves..and have them hear from both sides of the india..

    • @dsodragon8152
      @dsodragon8152 Před rokem +3

      and which side was he biased towards.... it more seemed like a neutral perspective of Indian Politics...

    • @laba3423
      @laba3423 Před 9 měsíci +1

      to understand you need to go through british times because thats what defined political control till late 1970s and then new parties begin to emerge after rise of janta party alliance which is a separate period so overall I guess it will take atleast 2 hours video to have a fair view of indian politics

    • @karneshthakur2212
      @karneshthakur2212 Před 7 měsíci

      Yes

  • @dharmashah100
    @dharmashah100 Před rokem +80

    10:21 He was acquitted by the Supreme Court regarding this case and also given a clean chit on his involvement in this case.
    Yet people tend to comprehend him in it.

    • @ghazalrehsi5953
      @ghazalrehsi5953 Před rokem +3

      But even though he was given a clean chit doesn't mean that not doing anything to stop the situation from escalating was the right thing to do especially if you have power. Not doing anything and letting things get out of hand , letting people kill each other while he just sits back and watches isn't a very good step to take as a leader. He doesn't care at all if people just kill each other as long as his position isn't compromised seems like it. That's not a good leader for the nation at all. He's divided india so much during his tenure. I don't get how people don't see that. Having said that he has acted rationally in a few policy matters.. not that it matters much when everyone is just gonna kill each other since that seems to be the main motto right now...

    • @mysteriousperson9808
      @mysteriousperson9808 Před rokem +4

      @@ghazalrehsi5953 it's for all political parties. Even in religious preachers. Hypocrisy should be under limits.

    • @Abhishek-hk3ql
      @Abhishek-hk3ql Před rokem +8

      ​@@ghazalrehsi5953 you are very ignorant, you have literally zero knowledge about the verdict. Modi government did the the best that they can, he also asked the central government for additional forces but they didn't sent them at all. You should read the verdict. Also there was firing in the second and third day to control riots, hindus were shot dead, "more than Muslims".muslims are always victim, do you also go by that opinion.

    • @Hinduism_94
      @Hinduism_94 Před rokem +2

      @@ghazalrehsi5953 MUSLIM DETECTED OPINION REJECTED

  • @harshitaprusty6640
    @harshitaprusty6640 Před rokem +4

    Yeah Modi became Prime Minister of Gujarat in 2001.
    My fellow indians, how many PMs do we have?? 1 or 30🤣🤣

  • @comicalhawkwatch2995
    @comicalhawkwatch2995 Před rokem +2

    The people of ancient INDIAN civilization were called 'Hindus ' by the invaders from the north western side of the country as to enter the ancient India they needed to cross the Hindukush mountains which stood as a barrier from foreign invasion. So , during those time they called us " Hindus, those who are protected by the Hindukush mountains"

  • @dakshtiwari3027
    @dakshtiwari3027 Před rokem +137

    Didn't you remember the Kashmir files, the large scale violence against Hindus, nearly 90k killed and 500k left their homes and at that time the government was of Congress, they didn't do anything and in fact the PM of India between 2008-2013 was from Congress and he gave one of the highest honour of India to him i.e. to the person who initiated the whole violence, and everything has proof, those families who migrated from Kashmir has described the whole incident,etc and everything I said has facts

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem

      india is secular because hindus are in majority...
      Hindus were forced to leave afganistan pakistan Bangladesh kashmir srilanka bhutan ..even after that hindus in india accepted every community.. before the word secularism was added in constitution during emergency by Indira Gandhi..

    • @user-om5sg8sq9q
      @user-om5sg8sq9q Před rokem +1

      But what about the fact that more kashmiri pandits are leaving kashmir now because of poor decisions taken by the current government which has created bad environment for karshmiri pandits why govt isn't helping them now

    • @dakshtiwari3027
      @dakshtiwari3027 Před rokem +5

      @@user-om5sg8sq9q bro everything needs time,. It's not a movie, give some time to everything, all will be good

    • @user-om5sg8sq9q
      @user-om5sg8sq9q Před rokem +3

      @@dakshtiwari3027 8 years is enough time, now it is time to take back our country from this self serving party

    • @dakshtiwari3027
      @dakshtiwari3027 Před rokem +1

      @@user-om5sg8sq9q but the article 370 was removed 3/4 years ago not 8 years ago and removing the article 370 was a really really big decision, you see there has been a great decrease in the terrorist attacks in India after Modi government, economy increased by 10 times in 8 years compared to last 65 years, our millitary is becoming strong day by day, India first time sold it's very own weapon to another country, Pakistan is in a terrible state in un from a very long time due to our strong stance in un by this government, surgical strike, neutral stance on Russia Ukraine in un, oil and coal deal in midst of sanctions, showing the hypocracy of US and Europe by our EAM, good international relations and many more things all these took only 8 years so just stay positive, and keep patience as anything doesn't happen in a snap

  • @FlashFromDC
    @FlashFromDC Před rokem +301

    This video is so one sided and full of incomplete information which is what makes it factually wrong. When he talks about tensions between Hindus and Muslims he actually mentions just the Hindu side. I mean, seeing the current developments in the country it can be easily inferred that Hindus should be able to take a joke on their religion in the name of liberalisation and modernity but when it comes to Islam it simply is Blasphemous and something which can lead to stone pelting.
    BJP has always been a conservative party which believes in the concept of restoring the past glory of a place which holds a significant value. Some people find it problematic linking it to wastage of administrative funds which is understandable and valid but there are some people who simply deny the obvious history of the Nation. The Kashmir Genocide, Islamic invasion etc are some of the few examples which are not taught in our textbooks.
    South India's history has always been kept at a hand's distance from students but the truth is there were some great dynasties in the Southern part of the country and their rich cultural heritage can be very well seen in their architecture. However it's really sad that those icons of our history have always been neglected but there's hope of embracing them yet again.

    • @Wiseenoughtobefoolish
      @Wiseenoughtobefoolish Před rokem

      It’s simply the abrahamic privilege. They never get tired of playing the victim card making others look bad. While Muslims protested against let’s say hijab in schools in India and burnt down public property etc and the whole world was tweeting against Hindus at the time like headless chickens, they cldnt protest against the same exact law in Muslim
      Countries itself. The west constantly tries to undermine India in every way just because it doesn’t obey their template of right and wrong 😂

    • @jamoon9341
      @jamoon9341 Před rokem +4

      trueeeeee

    • @vineetsrivastava5515
      @vineetsrivastava5515 Před rokem +2

      +1

    • @SuperKing604
      @SuperKing604 Před rokem

      There was no kashmir genocide stop playing the victim all the time 80 of india is hindu

  • @jkmaurya868
    @jkmaurya868 Před 2 měsíci +1

    He didn't mentioned that supreme court of India find him innocent after a long lasting prosiding

  • @arvindp9112
    @arvindp9112 Před rokem

    @16:00...the logos are for independent candidates who are not a part of any parties. In the Indian Elections, one can contest in a particular part of the city if you do not belong to any party, which is referred as ward/zone/sub zone(as I am from Mumbai we refer it as ward...not referring to the child in school but the area is bifurcated in wards where only a male or female candidate can contest based on the Election Commissions directive). The logos are chosen by the Election Commission to avoid confusion. Example: An person can have various issues like eyesight, or any problem. All are allowed to vote. Even if you are 100+ years old.. You Know what I mean...

  • @thyzacx8597
    @thyzacx8597 Před rokem +85

    Most of the religious statements said by him are wrong. He clearly has a very biased view.

  • @Bridge_2702
    @Bridge_2702 Před rokem +170

    The video talks from an extremely left wing perspective. Can't blame him coz he's from Canada💀💀
    All the rioting or fighting is never so one sided in India as these videos like to present. It's not difficult for anyone to understand that religious radicalism is gonna be an issue in developing & under developed countries. But why does everyone have a hard time understanding that this phenomenon would happen not just to one religion, but to others as well. *"Religious radicalism"* is the issue, not *"just"* hindu radicalism. Other religions also have such behaviours in India, but that's not talked about for some reason. This further triggers these right wingers. I'm not even a righty, but look at this comment itself. The perception is so deep in the matrix that even saying such a simple thing makes me come across like a righty lmao.

    • @narendranarendra5143
      @narendranarendra5143 Před rokem +13

      @@redpanda2204 because he accused of Hindus being extremists

    • @amazingfeed9975
      @amazingfeed9975 Před rokem +5

      @@bibhasdmusic not only andha but deaf too

    • @rakeshpanda8772
      @rakeshpanda8772 Před rokem +1

      @@redpanda2204 see 5+ mins in the video. Good luck

    • @albertjoseph4604
      @albertjoseph4604 Před rokem +1

      He is famous conservative political commentator in news before he started CZcams.

    • @rakeshpanda8772
      @rakeshpanda8772 Před rokem +4

      @@albertjoseph4604 that gives him no right to say anything does it? He should stick with Canadian politics only then

  • @ElectrooKing
    @ElectrooKing Před rokem +1

    Hinduism was originally called Sanathana Dharma, which means righteousness forever. The Persians, who invaded India in the sixth century BC, gave Hinduism its name from the root word Indus.
    The birthplace of Hinduism is Indus River Valley which runs through northwest India into Pakistan. The Indus Valley civilization, or "Harappan civilization" originated sometime around 4,500-5,000 B.C.E. and reached its zenith between 2300 to 2000 BC.

  • @Uditro
    @Uditro Před rokem +1

    I can tell you the reason how hindi got its name , as in the earier centuries the region below 'Himalayas' in map is called hind region that's why 'hindi' is name of language spoken by people living in hind region and that's the same tah 'India' is also called 'Hindustan' .

  • @Bruh-we8kl
    @Bruh-we8kl Před rokem +226

    This is ridiculous how people talk about hindu on Muslim violence but totally forget stuff like the godhara kand, kashmir genocide, palghar lynching, delhi riots, etc. It's just that violence on Muslims attracts lot of marketing and attention from media but look at the statistics across the indian subcontinent and the picture will be crystal clear.

    • @gagan77100
      @gagan77100 Před rokem

      Coz muslim dont have political power compare to Hindus in india i.e minority.Its just like killing a black by white will highlight more than vice versa.

    • @GorrIndica
      @GorrIndica Před rokem +2

      Right

    • @sharadroy1445
      @sharadroy1445 Před rokem +1

      All those provoked by bjp though

    • @kgCode658
      @kgCode658 Před rokem

      ​@@sharadroy1445 if someone provoked you. then u will burn the country and kill peoples of other religion. then what is difference between u and terrorists

    • @omkarpandey4643
      @omkarpandey4643 Před rokem +1

      @@sharadroy1445 Wow all those provoked by Bjp

  • @Aaryavartah
    @Aaryavartah Před rokem +119

    8:15 Ohh we love Taj Mahal dude, the thing is, surprisingly majority of these mughal era architechures(Mosques , Tombs, Muslim Shrines and Pillars) were built after turning Hindu temples into dust, and they built these achitechures on top of these hindu temple ruins. Thats the problem right there !! It's not that India was so over-populated in the ~1600CE that they could not have found a piece of plain land to built there shrines.
    They intentionally splintered most of our temples and left a small piece of wall/idol/painting undisturbed so that our generations could see and remember the atrocities that were carried upon us !! That's the pain, and then to add fuel in the pain, they mock us by asking what did native indians we build before the mughals ??Like really !?? the audacity dude !!!

    • @manish1606
      @manish1606 Před rokem +2

      But ASI which is under bjp government says something different on taj mahal, qutub minar and other monuments

    • @alliswell79
      @alliswell79 Před rokem +3

      @@manish1606 qutub minar has proofs but since it is not a place of religious worship for any of the religion currently, the status will remain the same.

    • @ghazalrehsi5953
      @ghazalrehsi5953 Před rokem +2

      @Sagar Khatri This is the argument I don't get at all. Everyone wants to destroy all monuments and religious places because there MIGHT be religious monuments under them from a different religion. So once you destroy everything and build temples everywhere.. you'll be happy. But you would have destroyed all the places that people in the PRESENT era have come to love and feel happy about. Because some thousand years ago your happy places were destroyed. And repeating what was done soo many years ago to other people who aren't even a part of this stupid ego battle..seems like a good move... 👏👏

    • @Aaryavartah
      @Aaryavartah Před rokem +1

      ​@@ghazalrehsi5953 Yeah, explain that to the tyrant maniacs who destroyed, looted our 1000-3000 year old temples to built there mosques in the first place !
      Or if you can't go in the past, then explain this to the Hydrabadi brothers who openly threatens to cleanse hindus from the face of this country in 15 minutes, if the POLICE is put on hold.
      And yes, this is not an ego battle, this is the battle of our survival, because isl@mic religion does not tolerate it's co-existance with other religions, they have to convert poeple , spread attacks, terrorize the majority of the country into submission to isl@m. You can take any number of examples in the history of this religion. They came in as refugees and in a matter of 2-5 decades, converted the country's ethos into isl@m by birthrate explosions,forced conversions, terror, rapes, vandalisation of other religion's godly figures. You need examples for that study history, I'm giving you some countries to start upon :- Tajikistan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Maldives, Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei.
      So Now here you are wanting our submission to your atrocities which went on for 1000 years ?
      And until recently India and pakistan were one country...but the isl@mist terror groups under the jinna doctrine layed atrocities on the eastern India to force Gandhi into submission of a new country based on the Isl@m as thier state religion for the mu$lims.
      Also when terr0rist organisation Taliban took over Afghanistan on 15th August 2021, who were the people in India who were celebrating the afghanistan coup ? they all were mu$lims celebrating thier religious win in afghanistan and pakistan.
      Whether you accept it or not ,whether you like it or not, your community leaders are perpetrating hatred and attacks towards non-mu$lims. And your religion may have preached to be at peace with everyone around you, your community leaders have a doctrine to set unrest,convert and take-over any country they step in.
      Peace out 👍

    • @VSM101
      @VSM101 Před rokem +2

      @ABHRA TALUKDER Why to glorify tryrants dude no one in the world keeps monuments of invaders did the Spanish keep Muslim monuments after they took back Spain No they didn't did the Greeks keep Ottoman monuments when they freed themselves from the Ottomans.

  • @Mayank-Pawar
    @Mayank-Pawar Před 7 měsíci

    Hindi is just a language of link of diverse groups speaking different languages. I know Gujrat Incident was actually very important which completely changed Indian Politics and only Indians will understand, this guys did very good job with this video explaining political scenario.

  • @rajdubey1183
    @rajdubey1183 Před rokem

    In love with Jaby's shirt and Achara!

  • @prigee
    @prigee Před rokem +132

    Just a few small things.
    1. Cow belt is used as a derogatory term for Hindi belt or what is better known as heartland regions.
    2. Congress is not being hated for their closeness to Muslims but for their appeasement politics at the cost of majority which is inherently divisive in nature.
    3. Before 2014 election, where BJP managed to secure a easy majority, people were more divided on caste, religious, cultural and social issues. BJP managed to secure the win only by gaping the divide not furthering it. So, point is, BJP can be accused of polarisation but not of division.

    • @himanshumeenaarts5308
      @himanshumeenaarts5308 Před 6 měsíci +1

      You are 💯 correct, i think he already know many things and he just trying to defame by soft influence. Like say some write, some debatable, and with all this give some wrong information.

  • @nickpartha8643
    @nickpartha8643 Před rokem +152

    Fact for jaby n achara- When whole system is left centric narattive then it is very difficult to live as a majority because whole world gonna point out on u even if u r not wrong and fighting for ur own existence .

    • @shivamshrivastava970
      @shivamshrivastava970 Před rokem

      Bro whose existence they are fighting. They just use people like us to win election there is no fight between religion it's just politicians using people for there agenda of election

    • @singhabhi.16e
      @singhabhi.16e Před rokem +6

      true 🔥👍

    • @shefk7325
      @shefk7325 Před rokem +7

      "Difficult to live as a majority" is hilarious considering the current political climate we live in. You are giving them majoritarian narrative instead. Nice🤣

    • @jatinsingh5426
      @jatinsingh5426 Před rokem

      Look at minority aka muslims

    • @t.s.p1864
      @t.s.p1864 Před rokem

      @@jatinsingh5426 what to look,

  • @777maddox
    @777maddox Před rokem +1

    Relationship between English and christianity is the relationship between Hindi and hinduism.

  • @danbruh33
    @danbruh33 Před 3 měsíci +1

    This is what you get when you go on to make a video on a very complicated subject which Indians also struggle with without full knowledge. Half knowledge is very dangerous.

  • @shauryapratapsingh6052
    @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +134

    Modi won with more margin than 2014 in 2019 😂😂
    These elite western journalist who don't have any connection with ground politics don't know anything

    • @anewtrader7368
      @anewtrader7368 Před rokem +1

      Yes they are too much occupied in their delusional world that they don't want to see the reality

    • @debangansamanta
      @debangansamanta Před rokem +4

      I think u don't understand. This guy is just presenting the information he got

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +1

      @@debangansamanta I know this video is older ..but I am talking in general..not pointing out him

    • @lodalega9674
      @lodalega9674 Před rokem +11

      @@debangansamanta Yeah yeah we didn't the fact that he mentioned 2002 but not Godhra,2002 but not 1984,yeah we got him.

    • @anewtrader7368
      @anewtrader7368 Před rokem +6

      @@debangansamanta yes the biased information he got!
      Or maybe he is biased?
      Did he provide any proofs in this video?
      He showed 2 clips, 1 against English language in schools, 1 against Taj Mahal & then concluded Hindu nationalists are fanatics?
      Tomorrow he might say Indians are the aggressors and bichara paxistan is a victim because India is bigger than paxistan!
      Just because someone is in majority doesn't mean he is the oppressor!

  • @truthbetold8885
    @truthbetold8885 Před rokem +180

    A investigation was done by the Supreme Court of India in the case of Narendra Modi and no connections were found that he had any hand in the violence. Its amazing how these narrators forget to talk about half of the thngs.

    • @jai_yogi
      @jai_yogi Před rokem +12

      Right

    • @Ishantyagiofficial
      @Ishantyagiofficial Před rokem +24

      And he only. Tell that Hindus did violence on non Hindus what a lie
      Pta nhi kha se dekh kar aaya tha video vala

    • @ExtreMe-uk4lm
      @ExtreMe-uk4lm Před rokem +18

      The video was actually pretty biased.

    • @jai_yogi
      @jai_yogi Před rokem +13

      Ppl get attention going 'anti majority'/ultra feminism/minority appeasing

    • @anewtrader7368
      @anewtrader7368 Před rokem +1

      What else would u expect from a western population??
      They still believe that India is killing Kashmiris!
      All this is left western propoganda!
      Better report!

  • @NKR200
    @NKR200 Před rokem +1

    RSS is literally the most misunderstood organization. It never was an anti muslim organization. Its main ideology is the NATION FIRST. It is pro Hinduism but not anti muslim or any other religion. RSS full form is Rashtriya (Nation) Seva (Aid) Sang (Untity), it preaches the indian flag in the main office not any hindu god. Basically, saying things like they are anti muslim are just for belittling them for political reasons by the Congress mainly. Can you tell a single thing that it did which can be seen against Muslims?

  • @historyandmore9555
    @historyandmore9555 Před rokem +1

    This guy's source of making this video was information from a guy named ayaan, yeah that explains a lot

  • @amithmurikinati9013
    @amithmurikinati9013 Před rokem +570

    For sure, he wasn't at all covering just one side of things that happened and painting a picture of just Muslims being oppressed and Hindu s oppressing them and other non Hindus always. It's a very broad minded video and it's crazy that jaby and Achara didn't notice how he didn't mention about kashmir genocide but he was more than ready to talk about stuff that happened just with Hindus and also misrepresenting the reason behind why bjp won in the first place over congress s tyranny for decades. Wow 👌

    • @kanishkkumar5431
      @kanishkkumar5431 Před rokem +17

      I noticed that too....

    • @utkarshsharma8826
      @utkarshsharma8826 Před rokem +1

      All the load of secularism in this country is on the shoulders of Hindus. It's time we standup for ourselves.

    • @onedash1901
      @onedash1901 Před rokem +47

      He also didn't mentioned, why Gujarat riots happened? He is such a one sided person.... ☹

    • @captain_sourav_10
      @captain_sourav_10 Před rokem +13

      IKR I noticed it too

    • @spilltea4241
      @spilltea4241 Před rokem +10

      It's a 20mins video on 75 years of Indian politics by a Canadian who learnt about it within a week. Give it a break
      This 20mins video has more information than 10+12 curriculum in Indian schools

  • @AkshatGoelMAITMAE
    @AkshatGoelMAITMAE Před rokem +211

    A person from another country can never know how another country's political system works until and unless he/sje has spent some time there.

    • @himaanshusharma8469
      @himaanshusharma8469 Před rokem +10

      True brother
      Apart from General facts about elections n political party , everything about riots , congress and Hindu Muslim relationship in India (as shown in this video) does not show the actual complete picture therefore completely changes its meaning.

    • @kunalsoni3329
      @kunalsoni3329 Před rokem +3

      that is what I feel, people just being nice in saying that he is accurate but is not really very close to the reality

    • @linkbombchu168
      @linkbombchu168 Před rokem +1

      The least he could do is portray it as it is. And not talk from one narrative.

    • @Azx12345
      @Azx12345 Před rokem +1

      Even some people from India also don't understand politics that well even after living here how will someone from another country would understand Indian politics that is true

  • @incrediblemind9288
    @incrediblemind9288 Před rokem

    There was another party named Janata Party in the 90s. It was the first party to be in majority in parliament after Congress.

  • @gthm7
    @gthm7 Před 7 měsíci

    @jaby and @achara, I was impressed by your pronunciation

  • @lavenyasharma
    @lavenyasharma Před rokem +221

    How do you guys think that he was trying his best to be fair. He is clearly speaking from only one perspective .

  • @utkarshverma013
    @utkarshverma013 Před rokem +149

    Most of the interpretations used in the video and terms like "Cow Belt" have been coined by left-leaning, anti-BJP political analysts and journalists who are either from the west or have their intellect and perception conditioned according to western political systems (notice how every screenshot of news articles shown in the video are from western media houses). These people then try to see India through that western point of view, which when mixed with anti-BJP bias, results in a lot of factually incorrect and misleading narratives. For example, in the video, JJ tells that Modi was accused of being complicit in the Gujarat riots of 2002. But he does not tell that no such evidence was found against Modi and after 10 years of investigation he was given clean chit by the special committee formed by the Supreme Court of India, that too in a period when Congress was ruling the country. I would like to believe that his is probably because JJ would not have found this fact in any of his research sources. For another instance, that pyramid shown at 7:10 was actually of "Varna System" but it is claimed to be of "Caste System", a concept which is not native to India or Hinduism. The Varna System was based on knowledge and skills of individuals and was meant to efficiently manage the society, not to create any "divide" among people.
    The concept of Left Wing and Right Wing are western concepts which are relevant in countries with binary political discourse. It doesn't completely apply in India, because here a single ideology could be multipolar. The BJP can be considered a "non-left" party, but by no means it is a "Right Wing" party. The term "Hindu Nationalism" is nowhere same as Christian nationalism that we see in Europe or Islamic Nationalism that we see in pretty much every Islamic nation. That's because Hinduism is not a rigid ideology which is based on fixed set of commandments and classifies people into believers and infidels. It is an inherently inclusive ideology based on the idea of "The world is one family". Even atheists can be considered Hindu as the term Hindu is a geographical and cultural identity rather than a religious one. So even if India officially becomes a Hindu nation, it won't be like people of other faiths would lose their rights and become 2nd class citizens.
    Do you know that 26 seats in the House of Lords of the British Parliament are reserved for Bishops of the Church of England. No "Hindu nationalist" has ever proposed any such idea to reserve seats for representatives of Hindu Temples/Mathas in the Indian Parliament. Yet, those who keep defaming India with out of context interpretations of "Hindu Nationalism" never question Britain's secularism!

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +11

      Very well and deep analysis ..

    • @thereisnospoon123
      @thereisnospoon123 Před rokem +11

      Well said 👏!
      Profound!

    • @rajatjaiswal8355
      @rajatjaiswal8355 Před rokem +8

      Exactly

    • @dnshet5998
      @dnshet5998 Před rokem

      I don't think we should really care about what people in the West think about us. Their politics is more fucked up than ours- at least nobody is banning abortions or giving free pass to gun violence in this third world country.

    • @Trash-hc5uk
      @Trash-hc5uk Před rokem

      I'm sorry but cow belt is a widely used term in electorally area, because these regions worship cow. Where southern or NE people eat beef so not included in Cowbelt. There are elements of language too. UP Bihar, jharkhand MP share the same language origin.

  • @MariikhoNingshen
    @MariikhoNingshen Před 3 měsíci

    9:24 the office he was elected to was that of the Chief Minister not Prime Minister. Chief Minister is the executive Head of the government at the state level, elected during the time of the state legislative assembly elections. Whilst Prime Minister is the executive head of government elected during the country's general elections.

  • @thedriver492
    @thedriver492 Před rokem +2

    You saw Kashmir file you forgot it while listening this

  • @lightfantasy566
    @lightfantasy566 Před rokem +437

    Hindi language and Hinduism are not basically derived from each other but "hind" refers to India so the most spoken language has its name as hindi. Also Tamil Nadu and South India as a whole have their own linguistic culture which are tamil, telugu, kannada, malayalam but they equally practice Hinduism🕉️.

    • @SG-xx8um
      @SG-xx8um Před rokem +37

      Yes you are right. Infact shankaracharya the greatest revivalist of hinduism known to us was from kerala of South India. He and his disciples revived hinduism not only in South India but in the whole of India .

    • @Xcvbn3355
      @Xcvbn3355 Před rokem +21

      South India proudly practice hinduism and their cultures but also allows others to practice theirs.

    • @randomchess7044
      @randomchess7044 Před rokem +8

      @@Xcvbn3355 That's why population of hindus in South India are completely falling due to a high amount of forced conversions....

    • @Xcvbn3355
      @Xcvbn3355 Před rokem +10

      @@randomchess7044 conversions happened a lot due to the caste system among hindus. Especially in my state Kerala. Many lower caste hindus find Christianity a way to represent themselves. Now i dont think much of a hell like caste discrimination is still here in kerala as it was in old times.
      And here hindu population is not at all shrinking.. Tbh most of the old hindu traditional stuffs which are not that seen in other states of india are still here in south.
      Harmony is the only way to move forward. Maybe it's hard to accept but if you accepted it and tried to get an exposure then you will see people are not that different as we thought

    • @thiluthilu7785
      @thiluthilu7785 Před rokem +3

      Originally South India practiced atheism , but in the early stages involved in sun worship.

  • @shrivastavapraveen
    @shrivastavapraveen Před rokem +158

    It's like I can exactly tell how your family system works by just making watch over few American families videos in CZcams 😂😂😂

    • @wolfiesingh7093
      @wolfiesingh7093 Před rokem +5

      Yeah ,we cannot make assumptions
      Talking about this videos, this guy has been using bbc and Washington post for research on Indian politics XD

    • @deepeshchandra2802
      @deepeshchandra2802 Před rokem +1

      Totally correct

  • @thedeepakreddy7
    @thedeepakreddy7 Před 7 dny

    Yes, you pronounced so perfect jaby❤

  • @ak-pn4ze
    @ak-pn4ze Před rokem +1

    rss- Hindu extremists group ❌
    congress- secular party ❌
    bjp- hindu nationalist party ❌
    modi responsible for 2002 riots ❌(high court and supreme court verdict)
    cow belt- ❌ never heard (ask any Indians)
    so on..
    i mean how baised a foreigner can make a video on India WITHOUT PROPER KNOWLEDGE
    JJ- yes

  • @anuragsinghrana9221
    @anuragsinghrana9221 Před rokem +72

    I would say that what JJ missed is one pivotal moment that turned fortunes for the BJP.
    Shah Bano was a Muslim woman who had an alimony dispute. The Supreme Court ruled in her favour granting her right to the alimony. Hardliner Muslims saw this as interference in Islam.
    Congress government at the time went overboard and passed a law in parliament to overturn the court decision, creating a separate law for Muslim women and rights after divorce.
    This was the last nail in the coffin, of the several such "Muslim appeasement" moves that Congress had been doing. Even though this appeasement only made hardliner Muslims happy with no actual benefit, this was seen as discrimination by many Hindus.
    This paved the way for BJP to pitch in as a voice for Hindus and raise their issues. And I would say even though BJP had such beginnings, being in power for 8 years now, they are toned down and do talk about inclusiveness. However since their core voters still expect them to be a voice of Hindus, they can only go so far.

  • @utkarshbengani6560
    @utkarshbengani6560 Před rokem +265

    10:45 No @Jaby, JJ has not done his best. He out right said that Hindus were terrorist and attacked Muslims. The audacity to say this is bonkers. Even after 1000s of ethnic cleansing, religious murder, rapes and butchering of Hindus, specially in Kashmir... the audacity to call Hindus, terrorist is just not fair. What does west want to Hindus do? Sit there quietly and see our mothers, daughters and wives getting raped and butchered and forcefully converted?

    • @sumitadhikari5126
      @sumitadhikari5126 Před rokem

      The thing that he only read about India for 1 week says it all
      First of all in 2002 riots both Hindu and Muslim were affected
      There is both loss on life on both side
      The court has given the verdict of Modi of not being involved in riots
      Moreover he just skipped how much corruption and scam took place in UPA regime and also the Emergency and Economy collapse
      So just for some views JJ f*cked the whole thing up when it's already messy in India with religious scenario
      What a masterstroke these creators are becoming nowadays especially the western ones

    • @manyadixit6685
      @manyadixit6685 Před rokem +12

      *BHAKT INCOMING*

    • @sumitadhikari5126
      @sumitadhikari5126 Před rokem

      @@manyadixit6685 for the reason Congress supporters trying to deny the facts and findings and calling bhakts is the epitome of comedy in the self rotting party
      No supports no votes only blame game
      You'll had good 50 years to rule but only scam took place 2G scam, Bofors Scam, Agusta Westland scam, Tatra Truck scam, CWG Scam, IPL Scam, Coal Scam
      People are fed up of dynastical party system
      Just cry in a corner for atleast 30 years

    • @nagabhatta2715
      @nagabhatta2715 Před rokem +50

      @@manyadixit6685 L u d fakir outgoing.

    • @greensloth5125
      @greensloth5125 Před rokem +11

      Nobody can generalize one religion as "terrorists". But it's not like Hindus don't spread terror (example-mob lynching)
      (Same goes for Muslims)

  • @rakeshcherry3955
    @rakeshcherry3955 Před rokem

    5:29 even jaby don't know his native language grammar rules, here in India we are struggling to learn grammar in schools and in college.

  • @naresh_biswas239
    @naresh_biswas239 Před rokem

    Which song you are taking about??

  • @shivanichavan8363
    @shivanichavan8363 Před rokem +152

    He is not stating facts but his point of view. We do not need someone with no knowledge of Indian politics telling Indians how Indian politics work. 😂

  • @debojyotikundu224
    @debojyotikundu224 Před rokem +1382

    JJ has totally represented a biased view here bcz it's really impossible for an outsider to understand our political system.

    • @azeemali8462
      @azeemali8462 Před rokem

      Why can't you admit that India is a run by a fascist Government who are like the Nazis

    • @mdqumar3170
      @mdqumar3170 Před rokem +30

      thats what an avarage person see bro ... they will not go through upsc syllabus

    • @rachitsomani4690
      @rachitsomani4690 Před rokem +35

      What was biased in this? Seems pretty neutral to me!

    • @Nova8739
      @Nova8739 Před rokem +39

      @@rachitsomani4690 he is actually talking about india atleast 10 years behind , the castle system i mean except for some very backward areas the castle system doesnt even exist anymore , no one f cares if you r a brahmin

    • @TheForgottenVoter
      @TheForgottenVoter Před rokem +11

      Very immature CZcamsr.Pls read Indian Supreme Court rulings on Gujarat case 🙏🙏🙏

  • @manishbhatt360
    @manishbhatt360 Před 3 měsíci

    Yeah ..I should read one book on the US and describe Politics there as if I understand everything that too without bias. Makes complete sense !

  • @awnindra
    @awnindra Před rokem

    Taj mahal was known as Tajo mahal earlier. According to some archeological survey, it was built over a Lord shiva temple. This has been one of the greatest challenges that Hindus have faced during the mughal era. Mughal's have either converted or bulldozed many of the temples to a mosque. the fight for getting all those places are still on

  • @ritamdebnath5728
    @ritamdebnath5728 Před rokem +222

    What he actually tried to portray leaves in other foreigners' minds, who would prefer watching his videos over reading about Indian history and politics, an image denigrating the Hindus as the savage butchers, which is absolutely wrong and mostly prevalent in leftist mindset from time immemorial, and another image of Muslims being the victims always who are living at the Hindus' mercy, which is again ludicrous, and you tend to develop this kind of idea when you read one or two books written by propagandists who are so eager to omit the parts of history or of the series of events that don't fit into their agenda, thus resulting in an off-kilter and manipulative narrative.

    • @nittynatsha4346
      @nittynatsha4346 Před rokem +1

      The majority always feels that they have been misrepresented or their pov isn't accurate.

    • @indian6455
      @indian6455 Před rokem

      Get some knowledge about Islam digusting teaching why Islam hate every other religion specially idol worshiper. Why their Allah hate non Muslims....spend some time to know Islam teaching by books or ex Muslims on youtube who read by Quran text with Islamic Sciptrues reference.. Islam is political militants ideology to conquer the world by violence ,genocide ,war, lies, Victimhood...

    • @cringekiller348
      @cringekiller348 Před rokem +1

      My bro
      Only in your mullah dreams

    • @cringekiller348
      @cringekiller348 Před rokem +7

      Nitty
      Natsha
      The minority always feels violated, despite exploiting the majority

    • @nittynatsha4346
      @nittynatsha4346 Před rokem +1

      @@cringekiller348 Don't make baseless comments unless you have proof.

  • @RishabhKumarenetuser
    @RishabhKumarenetuser Před rokem +154

    There is a serious need to mention Godhra incident in the comment section. I don't know why no one is mentioning it. But it is stupid to talk about Gujarat violence when you ignore the root cause for the same. Even JJ failed miserably at this argument.
    I wish I could explain you what pro-muslim parties do to be called pro-muslims.
    I wish I could explain you how BJP has become the only party to be a pro-hindu party.
    I wish I could explain you how nepotism and corruption played major role in banishing Congress from the Government.
    I wish I could explain you how 2019 elections established BJP an undisputed winner.
    I wish I could explain you why people vote for Modi?
    I wish I could explain you history of Indian politics.
    I wish I could explain you everything.
    But I guess, that is too grand voyage which I am unwilling to board.

    • @Pooja-rq3ow
      @Pooja-rq3ow Před rokem +6

      I was also thinking the same..

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +2

      They are not gonna come and vote here ..so no problem ..
      Just one problem is that how media spreads Hinduphobia ..even after Hindus have went through worst of ever genocides

    • @rajatjaiswal8355
      @rajatjaiswal8355 Před rokem +3

      Exactly

    • @RishabhKumarenetuser
      @RishabhKumarenetuser Před rokem +9

      @@shauryapratapsingh6052 Yes, it has always bothered me. The world is a place where some people can portray donkey as a horse and an environment is created where no-one can see the truth at all. Bizzare it is.

    • @pranav1256
      @pranav1256 Před rokem +4

      I guess he didn't mention the godhra incident cause he was talking about Modi's background and not the entire incident itself. Modi was not connected to Godhra incident directly.

  • @vipinthapliyal1567
    @vipinthapliyal1567 Před rokem

    Lipi in which Hindi is written derived from Sanskrit so you can say it has a Hindu or sanatani aspect also

  • @GreenAstro-if2fi
    @GreenAstro-if2fi Před rokem +2

    Hindu is a way of life, Hindi is from Sanskrit, Hindu religion have many languages includes Hindi(Sanskrit based) and and Dravidian languages.

  • @a.d.7888
    @a.d.7888 Před rokem +52

    You need to understand the difference
    1. In islamic countries everyone who is not Muslim is discriminated and killed
    2. In India only Muslims are hated. Rest all Relegion have come out of Hinduism only and are very close to each other, not a single fight between any Sikh Hindu budhist parsi Jain in 1000 years....

  • @mr.G1100
    @mr.G1100 Před rokem +26

    FUN FACT:1. Jaby search for etymology of caste. check for its origins and learn Portuguese roles in it.
    we don't have caste system but Jaati and Varna system.
    2. modi was exculpated of all charges by the supreme court of India.

  • @chandlerhbk08
    @chandlerhbk08 Před rokem

    Indian national Congress was founded by British Civil Servant AO Hume
    In the first ever congress session, one of its founding members WC Bonerji said, "formation of Indian National Congress is the work of British Civil Servant Marquess of Dufferin, with the queen's blessing"
    Congress was nothing more than a local franchise of the British government.

  • @abhimanyunegi8396
    @abhimanyunegi8396 Před rokem

    I think he got it very correct on macro level you can't expect everyone to know everything. Video is quite factual

  • @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk
    @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk Před rokem +103

    Wanted to add few things
    *Cow belt refers to primarily Hindi speaking states
    *Modi has been given a clean chit regarding the 2001 clash by the court
    * The Taj Mahal thing is a court case it's not backlash against Muslims it's to factcheck if the Taj Mahal is built on a temple

    • @sharadroy1445
      @sharadroy1445 Před rokem +4

      *Source : Godi media

    • @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk
      @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk Před rokem

      @@sharadroy1445 bhai pehle 2 fact hai aur tesra court me filed pil thi theek
      Aur tu jo godi media bol raha hai usse tera prejudice pata chalta hai aur ki tu kitna judgemental hai

    • @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk
      @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk Před rokem

      @ABHRA TALUKDER bhai woh mene video ke reference mein bola tha

    • @sharadroy1445
      @sharadroy1445 Před rokem +2

      @@AbhishekSingh-lf6wk din me gobar khate aur raat me godi media dekhne aaj kal jada udne lg rahe h

    • @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk
      @AbhishekSingh-lf6wk Před rokem +4

      @@sharadroy1445 not backed by facts
      Using lines that wouldn't be considered a comeback by a toddler 🤣
      And even took weeks to come up with this
      I have nothing but just empathy for you
      Hope you grow some wits

  • @funnycountdown6739
    @funnycountdown6739 Před rokem +74

    There is also caste system among Muslims, my friend is a muslim he told me this fact and I was completely unaware of this fact.

    • @Parv_Not_Perv
      @Parv_Not_Perv Před rokem +21

      It's a whole new Pandora's box bro.... First there is the ideological divide between Muslims. There are Shias and Sunnis. Then there is class divide in muslims... The upper class are called Ashraafs and the lower class is called Pasmanda. Ashraafs are the one who draw the strings. Then there are sects among them too. And all sects have given fatwas against each other. To name some of them - Barailvi, Deobandi, Ehel-e-hadees, Ehel-e-Quran. These are sects of Sunnis. Shias have their own sects - Agha khani, Bihari/Bohra, Ismaili Bohris etc....

    • @Trilok_world
      @Trilok_world Před rokem +3

      @@Parv_Not_Perv really thanks bro I don't know about that.

    • @anisulislam1
      @anisulislam1 Před rokem +2

      @@Parv_Not_Perv but as Muslim other than Shia and Sunni rest is not important coz in Islam it's told that no one is superior over other and if any one believe such things like he is bigger than other just because he is Arab or his last name then he is not following the teaching of prophet Muhammad. The whole cast thing is started after British colonial.

    • @abhisehkpandey9230
      @abhisehkpandey9230 Před rokem +11

      In Indian caste system u may observe only wealth disparity while in Islam its a whole different level of hyperbole where sunnis are after shias life literally galloping aggressively for beheading them and destroying shias worship places the same way they destroyed our holy temples.

    • @Parv_Not_Perv
      @Parv_Not_Perv Před rokem +8

      @@anisulislam1 If it is like that only then why are there fatwas against every sect by the other sects?
      Dekho Barailviyo ke nazar mein deobandi gustakh hain... Aur ehel-e-hadees ki nazar mein Barailvi aur Deobandi dono gustakh hain. This is religious ideological divide. There are 73 sects of Islam. Aur according to a hadith (Sorry mujhe abhi number yaad nahi hai hadees ka) only 1 out of those 73 sects will go to jannat aur baki sab jahannumi honge. Ab ye to aapke Islamic text me bhi likha hai. Aur simple si baat hai apne firqe ko sahi batane ke liye dusre ko galat batana padega aur isiliye sabne ek dusre ke khilaf fatwe nikale huye hain. Which means aapka Islamic text hi aapko divide karne ko keh raha hai.

  • @aryanvardhan1161
    @aryanvardhan1161 Před rokem +1

    We never hate non hindus......we even don't hate Muslims but what they done in 1947 we never forget! PARTITION 😭

  • @Croonycruise
    @Croonycruise Před rokem +1

    The video depicted the correct picture of Indian politics, kudos for highlighting the hatred towards anything related to muslims legacy even a tourist place like Taj Mahal

  • @anujdhakad8426
    @anujdhakad8426 Před rokem +383

    My teacher once said , "having no knowledge is much better than having half knowledge" now i realise why he said so.
    This video shows complete opposite of actual religious situation in india. he hasn't talked about the other parties or muslim group which often try to disturb the peace in the name of freedom of speech

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +50

      True
      india is secular because hindus are in majority...
      Hindus were forced to leave afganistan pakistan Bangladesh kashmir srilanka bhutan ..even after that hindus in india accepted every community.. before the word secularism was added in constitution during emergency by Indira Gandhi..

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Před rokem

      Tum chutiyo koo hamasha offend hona haii , FIR bhii kardey chutiye

    • @sorenutpal6091
      @sorenutpal6091 Před rokem +4

      Yes

    • @manishgoyal7677
      @manishgoyal7677 Před rokem +17

      @@shauryapratapsingh6052 adding the word 'Secularism' to the constitution actually made India less secular.

    • @shauryapratapsingh6052
      @shauryapratapsingh6052 Před rokem +10

      @@manishgoyal7677 so true..
      Even there is time now..if india wants to be in peace with all religions living peacefully ..
      India needs to embrace it's dharmic roots
      Like no jews no Israel
      No Hindus no india.

  • @tusharvashisht2286
    @tusharvashisht2286 Před rokem +332

    Hey Jaby and Achara. BIG FAN of you both. But just wanted to clarify that the references this guy is using are from the newspapers that always spread lies against hindus. Regarding Taj Mahal there are a lot of things that you won't understand right now buy these papers spread hate across hindus all over the world whereas Hindus are the most peaceloving community of India. Our gods are made fun of but we take it lightly on the other hand if even the texts written in holy books of other religions are quoted then the people of that religion are like BEHEAD THIS PERSON. I request you both, do not believe in everything that is shown in a video . THANKS. LOVE YOU GUYS 😁

    • @kesardogra5529
      @kesardogra5529 Před rokem +32

      That is Abrahamic privilege.

    • @brucewayne6238
      @brucewayne6238 Před rokem

      Say a little thing about isl@m and beheaded threats starts coming

    • @gauravmishra7158
      @gauravmishra7158 Před rokem +1

      Agree. So many mosques and islamic structures were build by demolishing temples on same land to set an example. Even muslims are proud of such acts

    • @vyzxyz6477
      @vyzxyz6477 Před rokem

      the video is too biased against hindus , each and every hindu muslims riots were initiated by radical muslims .
      read the islamic scriptures they are completely biased and contradictory.

    • @tusharvashisht2286
      @tusharvashisht2286 Před rokem +18

      And JJ must have not studied the reason behind the Riots in Gujrat. Otherwise he wouldn't have brought up this riots point

  • @kyaw5454
    @kyaw5454 Před 10 měsíci

    Yay😊 welcome to India

  • @NiranjanPandey__
    @NiranjanPandey__ Před rokem +1

    Modi was in no way responsible for Gujarat violence. It was an incident which he tried to control with great responsibility.