Shout-out to Becky for being really good about explaining what her cards are doing instead of just playing a cards assuming th audience knows. As a newer magic player this helps soooo much.
I'm glad we get a second episode. I was under the impression you guys release once a month. I appreciate all your hard work and hopefully one day we can sit down a play a game
Relatable with my Tergrid or Toralf deck. When it goes well...it goes WELL. When I'm heavily targeted...it's a bummer (and honestly rightfully so to the heavily targeted in the decks I made with those commanders lol).
Despite the outcome, there's always a feeling in most episodes that Joe is just a little play away from winning. And of course, great episode! I love the fact that we get to see some game-ending combos in your show that many people might consider taboos. Ending the game like this does not mean that it was no fun.
Joe and Lynch are looking for a fun game and trying to win fairly but some of the guests are combo cedh players who such the fun out of a game. Not David of course, he's delightful.
It's true that gameplay-wise this show is the best, because it showcases real commander with sincerity. It's a love letter to the game itself really, without any other objectives.
@@IHateYourDeck I know I've definitely been caught up in table talk while resolving a fetch search and grabbed the wrong land and none of my opponents caught it either because we were all chatting. As you say, mistakes are easy.
"We have mistakes at I Hate Your Deck, [...] We make mistakes, it happens." I really appreciate you leaving this in the finished video, makes me feel better about all the mistakes I make. :P
It’s nice seeing Lynch just be happy to play the game. It reminds me that some edh play groups want you to check the spike mentality at the door and just have fun. Jo being salt with blue is funny but most of the time warranted..... 🤣 David got shut down before his engine started again and Beky was an awesome first time guest. Great episode guys keep up the grind
It'd be nice to see a battle of old school troll decks for an episode of I HATE YOUR DECK. We're talking like Urza's lands fueling a colorless grindstone/whetstone deck, thrashing wumpus + spirit link/curiosity/"whenever enchanted creature deals damage" shenanigans, your classic counterspell deck where you ask "what's it do?" nearly every time a player does anything since you can counter everything, land destruction, etc. etc. Maybe choose up to a certain old school block and anything prior to it is allowed, but no proxies still.
What I love about these videos is that they are fun and entertaining. You have a group of four individuals who jive well together but playing cEDH style decks in the most fun way possible. Is there possible salt? Sure, but who doesn't from time to time and its all in good fun. I can't help but notice that Lynch plays toxic shit like me, mill baby mill and torture style decks. But Joseph likes to play life gain decks a lot. But seeing different guests and seeing all the different decks and commanders is great. I played a similar match with Phenax as my opponent and I was playing Anowon. I ended up winning due to Phenax milling most of everyone and on the 1 on 1, I had enough damage with a ton of Nortoious Throng Boosted rogues to deal well over 40 damage but the opponent also had like 20ish cards in their deck lol So this video brought back a fond memory of a good match (shameless plug vid on my channel) Edit: David should have waited on activating brainstorm till either Bekys endstep or in case he had cards he wanted to recycle in case someone used a library reshuffle or wheel early on.
I really like the atmosphere to these videos and the games have a proper down to earth feel. Thanks for keeping the commanders different, the players this game were both great
I love David, he's so smooth and funny. You guys gotta have him more! Another thing that would be cool was showing the hands to the camera at the start of the game so we can see what you're paying with
This show really just is continually getting better over time. The guests are lovely, and it feels like you're just enjoying a casual game of Commander.
It's always nice when we do have judges on set. There actually was a judge on standby, but sometimes you are too far away to truly see it to stay off camera. But we def welcome judges to help monitor to help!
Meanwhile, opposite of Mind Crank: "Whenever you gain life, put that many cards from the bottom of your graveyard onto the bottom of your library in a random order".
I appreciate the chuckles about the play errors. We all make mistakes! Laughing at them and moving on is healthy and a great example for younger players watching.
Great Video! With 2 mill decks and a wheel deck I was surprised people didn't get milled out sooner. I love your content and I love the banter! We need more lighthearted channels like this. ❤️
Joe didn't seem as peppy as he usually does...hmmmm..."Maybe he was feeling blue"🤔. Beky was definitely piloting that deck smoothly. Lynch needs to start a school of threat assessment...haha. he is usually right. Mistakes and miss triggers...who cares! We're human. Great content! Keep up the great work. If you want someone's deck to hate I'm sure you can call up Josh Lee Kwai. Hahaha. He seems like a mean blue player. Maybe he can bring his Orvar deck...🤔. Just kidding Joe...hahaha.
Ok, great deck idea: Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle using a cedh style loop build. Despite being mono white, it's easily one of the strongest decks I use, and the perfect spikey list to pop off on this show!
I absolutely love this show. If you guys are taking deck suggestions, I would love to see a Ruric Thar list get played. He's a 6 mana 6/6 hatebear from hell. I love to mix him in with a bunch of ramp and some nasty creatures to keep other decks in check and win in the combat step
TLDR; Can't wait to see how this plays out. Funny I had versions of these 4 decks, Rielle being the quickest to zero out(and the most hated of the four) Akiri voltron is fun, Anowon Rouge tribal actually turned in to Phenax big tough mill power. Phenax is a bold choice considering how quick so of the decks are that have been on so far that gave good showings(specifically not looking at Ur-Dragon).
29:00 Echo of Eons won’t be put into your graveyard until after it’s finished resolving, which means it won’t be shuffled into your library as part of its own effect.
it was also cast with flashback, which means it would be exiled regardless. Lynch should have countered it, deal or not. If you have a narset into a wheel, all deals are off at that point
i just love this edh gameplay! i would love to see Magda, brazen outlaw and what you come up with her, maybe without the infinite treasure tokens (clock of omens).
Every izzet player on youtube: imma gonna put in Nivvy and a Curiosity and a Thassa cuz i got the colours for it. Somebody should build a staple tribal deck :D
I have a soft spot in my heart for Anowon since it was my first commander deck. I rarely win with it but if you get a chance to do what it does, its super fun
Quick note: Notion Thief is a static effect that affects all players at all times. Any draw an opponent takes beyond the one for their turn is stolen. This is NOT a MAY so it is important to keep track of the board state because it is possible to mill out a Notion Thief opponent with cards such as Consecrated Sphinx by infinitely drawing them out of the game.
Wached episode 1 ages ago, episode 3 yesterday, and episode 7 today. So many improvements in such a short time making the watch more accessible. Continue reading the cards for the audience and I'll continue tuning in! Good stuff. GG!
Love the pacing of this show! Even with production edits, the flow of the game and the banter stays so organic and engaging. Easily one of my favorite game shows atm.
Deep respect for playing mill decks in multiplayer edh, that is a bold strategy. Thank you for the content and I appreciate the production level that you maintain while keeping it a bit unpolished. Every game of edh has human error as a component, and that is without half the table being in charge of making everyone else look good with lighting and such. Excellent work, and thank you again. Have you considered doing meta-strategy versus play? What I mean is pick a competitive version of 4 strategies and pit them against each other?
@@michaeldlynch What would be most balanced? Graveyard recursion, life gain, token creation, and red deck wins (that may be balanced but grave love may be the favored). Also respect for how you all respond to your audience.
I have a feeling she powered down the cEDH level Rielle deck, so Thought Scour is used as a cantrip and to mill topdeck tutors like Vamp and Mystical Tutor
David saying “Dressing smart today because I’ve got a date with victory” was the smoothest thing I’ve ever heard 😂
David is super Smooth!
That and when he calls our magic “Causally Hard”!
@@michaeldlynch yeah that was super smooth too 😂 get him on again mate!
@@GatheringTheMagicYT oh we have filmed two more episodes with him. Don’t worry.
Yeah...how did that work for him. Kappa!
Love that Lynch says to David "you're still learning" but he's the one missing his own triggers lol
May not have been about Magic, but life. :D
Lynch is a relatively new player and he looks blazed all the time
Shout-out to Becky for being really good about explaining what her cards are doing instead of just playing a cards assuming th audience knows. As a newer magic player this helps soooo much.
Can we have a "Missed trigger counter" The number of sphinx's tutelage and mindcrank triggers missed is a lot.
Human error. Sorry. We’ll get better.
Yup first thing I noticed XD but it's easy for us since we are not playing vs Joe :P we can relax
@@michaeldlynch No worries! I like your content nevertheless. Keep going :)
@@michaeldlynch No worries, I can guarantee that even CEDH channels like the Spike Feeders have missed triggers/played stuff wrong before.
@@michaeldlynch I don't think they were asking to be better, but it would be funny in post to see that, unless the players are not fans of it.
It’s not only that Sphinx’s Tutelage triggers were missed, but the “repeat this process” triggers were also missed!
I love how polite David is.
Very good kid!
Let's see some God battles. Mix it up between Theros, Amonket and Kaldheim.
I like that the decks are starting to level out in their greatness and it's making the episodes longer
I'm glad we get a second episode. I was under the impression you guys release once a month.
I appreciate all your hard work and hopefully one day we can sit down a play a game
If you join the patreon, joe, lynch, and many of the other members of the discord play webcam magic almost everyday! :)
You can actively track Joseph's mood downward with how much he's being messed with.
So relatable.
Relatable with my Tergrid or Toralf deck. When it goes well...it goes WELL. When I'm heavily targeted...it's a bummer (and honestly rightfully so to the heavily targeted in the decks I made with those commanders lol).
Despite the outcome, there's always a feeling in most episodes that Joe is just a little play away from winning.
And of course, great episode! I love the fact that we get to see some game-ending combos in your show that many people might consider taboos. Ending the game like this does not mean that it was no fun.
Lynch = MVP. These episodes are soooo good. I love the fact that they are about PLAYING the game, not WINNING it.
Joe and Lynch are looking for a fun game and trying to win fairly but some of the guests are combo cedh players who such the fun out of a game. Not David of course, he's delightful.
@@blaze556922 No, none of the guests suck the fun out of the game. They are playing high power edh, combos are just a part of that.
This has quickly become the best EDH gameplay show on YT. Great job, guys!
Glad you enjoy it!!! We have great episodes coming all year!
It's true that gameplay-wise this show is the best, because it showcases real commander with sincerity. It's a love letter to the game itself really, without any other objectives.
@@nehebtheunwhorthy3313 we truly love the game. And as you put it we love sharing that love with others.
@@michaeldlynch I’m loving how often episodes are coming out. Keep up the good work man❤️
its because of me right?
I love when a Wooded Foothill can get an island
Mistakes are easy, but she did cast dockside, got treasures so it didn't affect the outcome.
Right? That part was weird...
@@IHateYourDeck I know I've definitely been caught up in table talk while resolving a fetch search and grabbed the wrong land and none of my opponents caught it either because we were all chatting. As you say, mistakes are easy.
This is just another reason why this series is so good. It doesn’t take itself too seriously. It feels real.
@@IHateYourDeck some of my decks are mistakes
David is honestly absolutely amazing
He’s a treasure! And he’s coming back!
We love David!
@@IHateYourDeck We do too!
@@michaeldlynch that’s great to hear. Great game
Why thank you!
Two mill players.
Thassa's Oracle and Laboratory Maniac have entered the chat.
Two mill players and a rielle who is psuedo mill with her wheel effects
"We have mistakes at I Hate Your Deck, [...] We make mistakes, it happens." I really appreciate you leaving this in the finished video, makes me feel better about all the mistakes I make. :P
We try to keep it real flaws and all. That happens at your lGS.
It’s nice seeing Lynch just be happy to play the game. It reminds me that some edh play groups want you to check the spike mentality at the door and just have fun. Jo being salt with blue is funny but most of the time warranted..... 🤣 David got shut down before his engine started again and Beky was an awesome first time guest. Great episode guys keep up the grind
Nice island off a wooded foothills love breaking fetches
Human mistake. It’s not easy playing under the lights.
@@michaeldlynch love the series just pointing it out, things happen, lots of triggers
Rielle is highly underplayed on CZcams! Appreciate it to see her :)
Wow, I think this is the first time the title was wrong, I didn't hate any of these decks haha
This show is the perfect balance of the production value of game knights but the realistic real time gameplay of commander vs. This is amazing
Narset playmat and sleeves... I knew who was gonna win by minute two! Great stuff! Looking forward to the next one.
I would love to see my boy Torbran aka angry dwarf burn the whole table down. Please make my dreams come true!
In my Phenax Deck I play the "Duskmantle Guildmage" as counterpart to "Mindcrank", so there is a counterpart.
OMG my girl Rielle finally gets the respect she deserves!!!!
It'd be nice to see a battle of old school troll decks for an episode of I HATE YOUR DECK. We're talking
like Urza's lands fueling a colorless grindstone/whetstone deck,
thrashing wumpus + spirit link/curiosity/"whenever enchanted creature deals damage" shenanigans, your classic counterspell deck where you
ask "what's it do?" nearly every time a player does anything since you
can counter everything, land destruction, etc. etc. Maybe choose up to a
certain old school block and anything prior to it is allowed, but no
proxies still.
Damn, Lynch had a counter but stuck to his deal when Beky wheeled with Narset out! No way in hell I would've been able to do that, mad respect
I’m a man of my word!
What I love about these videos is that they are fun and entertaining. You have a group of four individuals who jive well together but playing cEDH style decks in the most fun way possible. Is there possible salt? Sure, but who doesn't from time to time and its all in good fun. I can't help but notice that Lynch plays toxic shit like me, mill baby mill and torture style decks. But Joseph likes to play life gain decks a lot. But seeing different guests and seeing all the different decks and commanders is great. I played a similar match with Phenax as my opponent and I was playing Anowon. I ended up winning due to Phenax milling most of everyone and on the 1 on 1, I had enough damage with a ton of Nortoious Throng Boosted rogues to deal well over 40 damage but the opponent also had like 20ish cards in their deck lol
So this video brought back a fond memory of a good match (shameless plug vid on my channel)
Edit: David should have waited on activating brainstorm till either Bekys endstep or in case he had cards he wanted to recycle in case someone used a library reshuffle or wheel early on.
Sweet!!!!
10:30 wouldn't the opposite of Mind Crank be like Vilis, Broker of Blood?
I was thinking either bloodchiefs Ascension or duskmantle guildmage
Great content again. I like the random opponents, and even young David is growing on me. Keep it up! Thank you!
Oh man David is such a charismatic guy, love to see him on the show.
He's coming back in future episodes!
eventually ill take over the show, but for now I'm just a guest
I really like the atmosphere to these videos and the games have a proper down to earth feel. Thanks for keeping the commanders different, the players this game were both great
Come out with more stand-up please JOE
25:30 I was dead. Lynch throwing shade at Joe. "it's in the grave" 😂🤣
I was thinking of building a mill deck! I am glad I watched....I changed my mind.
I've recently discovered tihs channel and have been binging. I aspire to have Lynch's energy - just so chill and good vibes all around all the time.
I love David, he's so smooth and funny. You guys gotta have him more!
Another thing that would be cool was showing the hands to the camera at the start of the game so we can see what you're paying with
David will be coming back!!!
I wish I was as smooth as David when I was his age 😆
Right!! Super smooth.
I wish i was that smooth at my age. 🤷🏼♂️
Beky is a really cool player. You need to have her back again.
This show really just is continually getting better over time. The guests are lovely, and it feels like you're just enjoying a casual game of Commander.
So. Many. Missed. Triggers.
Joe, would you like me judge the next game (please)?
It's always nice when we do have judges on set. There actually was a judge on standby, but sometimes you are too far away to truly see it to stay off camera. But we def welcome judges to help monitor to help!
@@IHateYourDeck I'm so down to help. HMU next game.
Lynch, you need a consuming aberration in that deck. As well as tree of perdition.
Love your games! It's very similar to the group I play in. Much smack talk(politics), I love it! Please continue!
Beky: I don't see a lot of diplomacy on your show
Lynch: Because usually too many people are winning
Fun playgroup in a nutshell. LOL
16:29 - I wonder if he's flashbacking to Game Knights
Keep the awesome videos coming!
I'd love to see a krark the thumbless / sakashima storm deck in the future
You all rock..!! keep up the awesome content.. Appreciate you!
Meanwhile, opposite of Mind Crank:
"Whenever you gain life, put that many cards from the bottom of your graveyard onto the bottom of your library in a random order".
I appreciate the chuckles about the play errors. We all make mistakes! Laughing at them and moving on is healthy and a great example for younger players watching.
Great Video! With 2 mill decks and a wheel deck I was surprised people didn't get milled out sooner. I love your content and I love the banter! We need more lighthearted channels like this. ❤️
Appreciate that!!! We’ll keep them coming all year!!!
Its cool to see this group having fun playing MTG! A rarity these days, bring it back!
Would definitely love to see either chulane or tatyova as I pilot those and they are my favorite decks
Takesies backsies is funny. In my casual group, it’s “ I’m going back in time” lol
Best EDH show on CZcams hands down
Also I like to imagine Lynch is wearing a Tool shirt even when he isn’t.
Joe's mind is like "Aaah man, not blue again. Fuck this game."
suggestions for commanders(my favorite comrades): Ghave, Grand Arbitrer Augustin IV, Unesh, Elsha, Sevinne, Gavi, nest warden
that random Mishra's Workshop at 19:38
cash moneyyyy
I love how even though he isn't doing much Lynch is having a blast. and his reactions were just great.
Joe didn't seem as peppy as he usually does...hmmmm..."Maybe he was feeling blue"🤔. Beky was definitely piloting that deck smoothly. Lynch needs to start a school of threat assessment...haha. he is usually right. Mistakes and miss triggers...who cares! We're human. Great content! Keep up the great work. If you want someone's deck to hate I'm sure you can call up Josh Lee Kwai. Hahaha. He seems like a mean blue player. Maybe he can bring his Orvar deck...🤔. Just kidding Joe...hahaha.
David is the funniest guest you will ever have
Funniest lookin guest
Oooooh. New episode. Upvote. watch after the alcohol wears off. And then watch again once the alcohol has started again.
That was a great game. Thanks for sharing that.
Ok, great deck idea: Teshar, Ancestor's Apostle using a cedh style loop build. Despite being mono white, it's easily one of the strongest decks I use, and the perfect spikey list to pop off on this show!
Joe's allways going against David right? How can you attack someone with such a nice tee-shirt! Good game btw.
i know! Just leave me alone so I can win jeez
I absolutely love this show. If you guys are taking deck suggestions, I would love to see a Ruric Thar list get played. He's a 6 mana 6/6 hatebear from hell. I love to mix him in with a bunch of ramp and some nasty creatures to keep other decks in check and win in the combat step
How many sphinx mill triggers were missed? 😄 so much better audio quality. Compliments!!
Thanks for posting another game! Also can you do some turn counter on come corner of the screen? keep it up
I keep forgetting about that. Good point.
Joe, you need to run Blue and get Revenge :) Great Game
Could we see an omnath locus of rage deck anytime soon. Ragey boi is my bebeh and i wanna see him fully powered.
Yes bring in big daddy omnath
Do all the Omnaths! Locus of Mana vs Locus of Rage vs Locus of Creation vs Locus of the Roil 😂
@@SuperOwei The big daddy rumble
TLDR; Can't wait to see how this plays out.
Funny I had versions of these 4 decks, Rielle being the quickest to zero out(and the most hated of the four) Akiri voltron is fun, Anowon Rouge tribal actually turned in to Phenax big tough mill power. Phenax is a bold choice considering how quick so of the decks are that have been on so far that gave good showings(specifically not looking at Ur-Dragon).
29:00
Echo of Eons won’t be put into your graveyard until after it’s finished resolving, which means it won’t be shuffled into your library as part of its own effect.
it was also cast with flashback, which means it would be exiled regardless. Lynch should have countered it, deal or not. If you have a narset into a wheel, all deals are off at that point
@@skykur when I make deals. I’m
a man of my word.
@@skykur INDEED.
I'm wrong. I thought she casted it from her hand. You're right :).
@@michaeldlynch that’s fair, you gotta make better deals tho. Say I won’t counter your “next” spell :D can’t give people free reign like that
@@haldir1991 as soon as I saw she milled it, I knew something dirty was going to happen
i just love this edh gameplay!
i would love to see Magda, brazen outlaw and what you come up with her,
maybe without the infinite treasure tokens (clock of omens).
This the awesomest match I've watched in this channel of yours!
Starting watching the epi and can tell David will take this W home!
This series is my favourite magic CZcams content by a long shot. :) Rielle popping off made it even better!
Great show! I love having another fun EDH youtube to watch.
Every izzet player on youtube: imma gonna put in Nivvy and a Curiosity and a Thassa cuz i got the colours for it.
Somebody should build a staple tribal deck :D
Pouncing shore shark gets jammed in all the decks lmao
Lol hey, if that's what works, go with it lol.
Love the energy of the group on this game, commander games like this are the best
Missed tutelage triggers lynch
I know! Bummed I missed the triggers!
The best EDH series on CZcams
Finally another episode. One of my favorite commander series
Great decks! Love all the blinged out cards :)
I have a soft spot in my heart for Anowon since it was my first commander deck. I rarely win with it but if you get a chance to do what it does, its super fun
I'd love see Both Syr Gwyn & Elsha in the same episode. Me and my friend both use those as our commanders.
I love this! Lynch you were missing triggers for days haha now we need an infect deck on the show.. make it really nasty
I hate doing this... But wooded foothills into an island. Hopefully calling out errors helps you catch them in the future.
Human mistake. We all missed it. But yes we learn from these mistakes.
@@michaeldlynch yeah I noticed this too, love the content! Keep it up!
Quick note: Notion Thief is a static effect that affects all players at all times. Any draw an opponent takes beyond the one for their turn is stolen. This is NOT a MAY so it is important to keep track of the board state because it is possible to mill out a Notion Thief opponent with cards such as Consecrated Sphinx by infinitely drawing them out of the game.
Good note!!!! Appreciate the info.
Wached episode 1 ages ago, episode 3 yesterday, and episode 7 today. So many improvements in such a short time making the watch more accessible. Continue reading the cards for the audience and I'll continue tuning in! Good stuff. GG!
Wouldn't Sphinx Tutelage trigger at 13:38 when Lynch stole Becky's loot are Rielle trigger?
Fun game and great content on the channel - I binged through most of your games today. Keep it up guys!
"Wizards! Give us an opposite of Mindcrank! Get on that"
Bloodchief Ascension: Am I a joke to you?
I wanna build Rielle now. Beky looked like she was having a blast lol.
Love the pacing of this show! Even with production edits, the flow of the game and the banter stays so organic and engaging. Easily one of my favorite game shows atm.
Cool Beans :D
Glad to see the channel is doing well, loves son Commander play.
Deep respect for playing mill decks in multiplayer edh, that is a bold strategy. Thank you for the content and I appreciate the production level that you maintain while keeping it a bit unpolished. Every game of edh has human error as a component, and that is without half the table being in charge of making everyone else look good with lighting and such. Excellent work, and thank you again. Have you considered doing meta-strategy versus play? What I mean is pick a competitive version of 4 strategies and pit them against each other?
Interesting. What 4 would you want to see?
@@michaeldlynch What would be most balanced? Graveyard recursion, life gain, token creation, and red deck wins (that may be balanced but grave love may be the favored). Also respect for how you all respond to your audience.
I'm laughing right now. Joe didn't shuffle his graveyard into his library like everyone else did on the wheel lol
The blue deck on the opposite side of lynch has won how many games now 😂 at least half I think?
Anyone know why Thought Scour is in the Rielle deck? Is this some secret tech?
I have a feeling she powered down the cEDH level Rielle deck, so Thought Scour is used as a cantrip and to mill topdeck tutors like Vamp and Mystical Tutor
Lynch's exasperated "shiiiiit" is a whole mood, honestly.
I want Lynch in every game I play. Love the decks, love his attitude, and he genuinely seems to enjoy playing Magic.