What have Iran and Israel accomplished in the last week? | LBC

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 04. 2024
  • James O'Brien questions the intangible consequences of the Israel versus Iran conflict as Israel reportedly launches retaliatory strikes.
    Iran's air defences were triggered early on Friday in response to reports of explosions near the city of Isfahan, the state-run IRNA news agency reported.
    Explosions were heard just after 5am local time in the central province of Isfahan, Iranian state media has said.
    Air defence intercepted three drones in the region, with no major damage sustained to buildings or facilities according to reports.
    Tensions between the two states were raised following Israel’s air strike on Iran’s consulate in Damascus on April 1 - a strike that killed 13 people, including two top Iranian generals.
    In response, Iran fired around 300 miles and drones at Israel on Saturday, the majority of which were shot down by Israeli air defences.
    A senior Iranian official has now said the country has no immediate plan for retaliation against Israel.
    There has been no confirmation of the strike from Israel following reports of the explosions.
    Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
    #jamesobrien #israel #iran #ukpolitics #LBC
    LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
    Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
    Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup

Komentáře • 821

  • @ChazFLA648
    @ChazFLA648 Před měsícem +315

    As an American, I hope to see my country independent from Israel one day.

    • @rogergrant9605
      @rogergrant9605 Před měsícem +24

      Why hope ? We should pressure them . We are a weak people driven by our own material needs.

    • @TheWolfe83
      @TheWolfe83 Před měsícem +34

      I hope to see the UK and Europe independent from the US

    • @raymondbooth3189
      @raymondbooth3189 Před měsícem

      No chance mate AIPAC run the your country. Your government gets it's order's from Bibi. The American taxpayer funds Israel but the Israelis walk all over you it's embarrassing really.

    • @Elisa-mg3rc
      @Elisa-mg3rc Před měsícem

      @@TheWolfe83 I guess at the end, both in Europe and in the US, we are all under the ruling of the same group of people. The most pernicious part, is that western people believe that they live in democracies.

    • @Titus9508
      @Titus9508 Před měsícem +5

      @@TheWolfe83 Yes.

  • @jituhanif
    @jituhanif Před měsícem +355

    History will remember this. US vetoing against ,and on the other side talking of two state solution. Real hipocrisy and sickening.

    • @kunaiflex491
      @kunaiflex491 Před měsícem

      Yep that was a real pos move by the us

    • @uttaradit2
      @uttaradit2 Před měsícem

      the us will no longer be the primary power by then it'll be a Chinese translation

    • @simonkapadia7582
      @simonkapadia7582 Před měsícem +17

      It has always done so, going back decades, and their rationale was it had to happen through a negotiated peace process, but of course, that only ever applied to the Palestinians. The US-pushed partition plan of 47 was supposed to create two states and an interstitial zone, albeit it gave most of the land to the Jewish minority, the bulk of whom were recent immigrants. It was a terrible plan on multiple levels, but it involved a two-state solution.
      Since then the two-state solution has been purely rhetorical. The US has continued to support Israel no matter what it does with only minor scolding now and again.

    • @shahidmiah7014
      @shahidmiah7014 Před měsícem

      American are alway supporting Israelis brutality against Palestine children

    • @susantranter7163
      @susantranter7163 Před 29 dny

      U.K. abstained! The country who illegally took away Palestinian land to give it to Zionists Europeans with no links to that place!

  • @fortytwo244
    @fortytwo244 Před měsícem +536

    Iran has the right to defend itself

    • @fortytwo244
      @fortytwo244 Před měsícem +45

      the Iranian people will defend Iran regardless of government, we might hate our government but we love our country and we love our people

    • @keirmitchell5560
      @keirmitchell5560 Před měsícem +7

      And so does Israel.

    • @jesusaguilar4585
      @jesusaguilar4585 Před měsícem +34

      ​@@keirmitchell5560Of course but if my American government were to not assist Israel, Israel would not do this again.

    • @HecticGlenn
      @HecticGlenn Před měsícem

      Maybe don't arm a bunch of proxies (Hezbollah, Hamas and the Houthi's) to orchestrate attacks against Israel to begin with?

    • @maneshipocrates2264
      @maneshipocrates2264 Před měsícem +4

      Israel too. Why use proxies to launch missiles to Israel before Israel acted terribly?

  • @thomasdolan2244
    @thomasdolan2244 Před měsícem +120

    Glaring hypocrisy of the west.

  • @celestesmith6060
    @celestesmith6060 Před měsícem +134

    Don't blame Iran. They have done nothing except defend themselves. Has Iran ever invaded another country?

    • @ne-ht4zx
      @ne-ht4zx Před měsícem +13

      They're behind various terrorist groups. Sounds like you could benefit from understanding more about current affairs.

    • @anneboyd7292
      @anneboyd7292 Před měsícem +8

      ​@@ne-ht4zxit depends on what your source is for current affairs 🤔

    • @Titus9508
      @Titus9508 Před měsícem +8

      @@ne-ht4zx Depends who is deciding on the definition of terrorists. Usually it's the accusation is screamed by the West at a country fighting invasion or occupation.

    • @Waseem_Amin
      @Waseem_Amin Před měsícem +2

      @@ne-ht4zx a lot of these groups are defending the right of the plasticines. just as the u.s founds people and group it feels shares its goal. how ever the difference is Iran is right here because they defending palistine and woulnt be tfreedom fighters

    • @abehorton7224
      @abehorton7224 Před měsícem +3

      @@calmingcrist4515I think it was the other way around

  • @charshill2978
    @charshill2978 Před měsícem +370

    Israel has been aggressive toward it's neighbors at the same time as calling itself a victim.

    • @Franki3683
      @Franki3683 Před měsícem +4

      Funny that.
      When your neighbours are launching rockets into your territory almost every nation would respond in the same manner.
      Israel is no different in their response, right or wrong.

    • @h2lo704
      @h2lo704 Před měsícem +43

      ​​@@Franki3683funny you made no mentioning of the oppression and killing of Palestinians as if, they are *not human being worthy of your concerns.

    • @hazaraudi7488
      @hazaraudi7488 Před měsícem +35

      ​@@Franki3683 funny how you didn't mention the occupation and the ongoing theft of land

    • @Franki3683
      @Franki3683 Před měsícem +2

      @@h2lo704 that's plain for all to see. Didn't think it needed mentioning. Calm down

    • @Occident.
      @Occident. Před měsícem +14

      They cry out in pain as they drone strike you.

  • @IanSmith2814
    @IanSmith2814 Před měsícem +259

    Israel needs to be taught a lesson

    • @karimfarangfromthejungle6027
      @karimfarangfromthejungle6027 Před měsícem

      And the only people who can do that is, the US and U.K. governments which prop it up. Which they have infiltrated and control….
      We have a rogue state who is sponsored and enabled by the decision makers. All of us in the world are less safe because of Israel…. At what point do the US and U.K. people point this out to their governments in a meaningful way?

    • @Occident.
      @Occident. Před měsícem +13

      🤞

    • @collettehartshorn581
      @collettehartshorn581 Před měsícem

      @@Occident. Israel and the Jews have been persecuted since Biblical times. Israel has every right to defend itself. The country was given back to the Jewish people in 1948, it's about time the Jewish people were left alone. If they had not responded to the Oct attacks from Hamas (and everyone seems to ignore this) goodness knows what else Hamas would have done.

    • @nazh9663
      @nazh9663 Před měsícem +7

      What do you do to mad dogs out of control.

    • @samf.s.7731
      @samf.s.7731 Před měsícem

      No, this escalation needs to stop.

  • @gerrybannon7394
    @gerrybannon7394 Před měsícem +204

    In our millions and our billions we are all Palestinian 🇵🇸🇮🇪

    • @Zimbly
      @Zimbly Před měsícem

      Meanwhile Indian Foreign affairs minister........."All you say is relevant. But having said all that you still do not know how to play cricket. India has best cricket team". 😊😊😊

    • @morasoussif4168
      @morasoussif4168 Před měsícem +2

      @@Zimbly elle joue avec les boules aussi

    • @davidgreen6490
      @davidgreen6490 Před měsícem

      Not for much longer. When Iran has been... errrr.... RESTRUCTURED, we will listen to your views on non existent nations..

    • @mohammedmir777
      @mohammedmir777 Před měsícem

      Indian foreign affairs minister represents extremists Hindutva or Hindu FANATICS party BJP.​@@morasoussif4168

    • @Tayloradrift
      @Tayloradrift Před měsícem +1

      No we're not!

  • @badomen9057
    @badomen9057 Před měsícem +304

    Iran achievement was that they have now changed the equation. They have now shown that they can directly attack Israel from their own country which probably is why America has gone out of its way to say it has nothing to do with this escalation

    • @ghas4151
      @ghas4151 Před měsícem

      If the US thought that Israel could win, there is no doubt that they would’ve invaded by now. This shows you that they’re terrified of Iran’s capability.

    • @davidgreen6490
      @davidgreen6490 Před měsícem

      We always knew Iran could attack Israel from their own country, they just proved that they cannot do it very well lol, 99% of the attack failed..

    • @comparecards5688
      @comparecards5688 Před měsícem

      They might attack America soon

    • @ne-ht4zx
      @ne-ht4zx Před měsícem +5

      Iran has proved it can launch over 300 missiles and drones and not even touch Israel. They have humiliated themselves militarily.

    • @tlhalefobriandlamini3817
      @tlhalefobriandlamini3817 Před měsícem +19

      @@ne-ht4zx OF THEOSE 300 HOW MANY WERE INTERCEPTED BY ISRAEL?

  • @imranali52
    @imranali52 Před měsícem +289

    *Palestine has a right to be defended* - even if by the likes of Iran!

    • @lisamills161
      @lisamills161 Před měsícem +5

      Yes agree but remember Iran is backed by Russia....not Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia has had years long war with Iran but conducted in the Yemen...just think a little more carefully

    • @ZED-PV
      @ZED-PV Před měsícem +6

      ​@@lisamills161if Russia were attacked they would have the right to defend themselves too. Same as Ukraine has the right to defend itself. Same as Palestine has the right to defen itself.
      What does it matter who's backing whom? How about don't attack sovereign countries?n

    • @lisamills161
      @lisamills161 Před měsícem

      @@thebeatcreeper Ummmm noooo. You need to look further into the relationship between SA and Iran, Fighting a proxy war in Yemen. Please do:) You may find it enlightening, Shia and Sunni.

    • @lisamills161
      @lisamills161 Před měsícem

      @@ZED-PV Oh dear. I think you are missing the point. Go read up and then we can discuss. Bests Lisa.

    • @Zimbly
      @Zimbly Před měsícem +7

      It should be announced globally that Palestine has a right to utilise it's rights like every human having intestine, has the rights. 👍👍👍

  • @beardedbloke2521
    @beardedbloke2521 Před měsícem +87

    I don't like Iran at all but their achievement is twofold.
    1. showing the double standards to the whole world how you can only act a certain way if you're 'with' certain countries
    2. Showing the hypocrisy that emanates from the above point when those certain countries give pathetic so-called answers to questions posed to them.

    • @khalidaser1430
      @khalidaser1430 Před měsícem

      It also showed the world that they are a major threat to Israel. Finally they changed the equation, or rules of engagement, to include massive attacks in retaliation by Iran.
      One thing I understand now is, every single inch in Israel is now in Iran's crosshair. That is a terrifying thought for a maniac like Natanyahu

    • @morasoussif4168
      @morasoussif4168 Před měsícem +1

      Si j'était un américain et j'aurais 2 énemi " *1/ israel 2/ Iran lequel ??????? j'attend vos réponses* "

    • @issiakasanogo3657
      @issiakasanogo3657 Před měsícem +1

      Israel et la France 😅

  • @luigifontana4164
    @luigifontana4164 Před měsícem +61

    this take that only Netanyahu is to blame in Israel is simply wrong... He's not the only problem in Israel, quite the opposite. It's a rouge state.

    • @Tayloradrift
      @Tayloradrift Před měsícem

      😂😂😂😂😂 Hamas?

    • @rabeebinnadeem8505
      @rabeebinnadeem8505 Před měsícem +4

      ​@@TayloradriftHamas = The right to resist under geneva convention, depending on how it is defined, can take the form of civil disobedience or armed resistance against a tyrannical government or foreign occupation a.k.a IsraHell.

  • @Nicolas-rg1zl
    @Nicolas-rg1zl Před měsícem +162

    Why did the UK abstain in the UN vote on recognising Palestine ?

    • @pamodoumanneh6134
      @pamodoumanneh6134 Před měsícem +43

      Better question is ‘why is the USA voting, the two states solution it claims to be in support for’ ?

    • @alexandrosparaschou246
      @alexandrosparaschou246 Před měsícem +36

      Because they where the ones who gave it away.

    • @mohsdef
      @mohsdef Před měsícem

      Supporting their US masters

    • @markeastlack4180
      @markeastlack4180 Před měsícem

      ​@pamodoumWe know why the US is vetoing Palestine, my country has more Zionists then Israel and the politicians who aren't Zionists are bought and paid for by AIPAC. Same goes for our media.
      However why won't the UK stand up to US is a legitimate question?anneh6134

    • @djmartin5240
      @djmartin5240 Před měsícem

      The uk and us are the countries that have caused this unrest by giving lands to the zionists since 1900s.
      Palestinians and israelis lived in peace up to the British empires claim of its lands.

  • @TazBo-wd2ig
    @TazBo-wd2ig Před měsícem +127

    Israel - Always the victim

    • @morasoussif4168
      @morasoussif4168 Před měsícem +2

      l'occident est habitué à dire oui

    • @collettehartshorn581
      @collettehartshorn581 Před měsícem +2

      Actually they ARE!! Read your history books.

    • @whatwentwrong4599
      @whatwentwrong4599 Před měsícem +8

      ​@collettehartshorn581 Laughable stuff. Don't start wars and cry when you lose, stating victim every time. What a embarrassing and pathetic outlook.

    • @Neo-ti2rz
      @Neo-ti2rz Před měsícem

      American history and slavery was way worse. Read more​@@collettehartshorn581

    • @jaferessop4412
      @jaferessop4412 Před měsícem

      Always the culprt​@@collettehartshorn581

  • @RichardSpain-lz9cf
    @RichardSpain-lz9cf Před měsícem +66

    I had a mate like Israel once, always starting fights expecting me to jump in,fool as I was… but one time I didn’t, we BOTH learned from the event.

    • @keirmitchell5560
      @keirmitchell5560 Před měsícem

      You don't have any mates.

    • @LunaK-pt3tz
      @LunaK-pt3tz Před měsícem +13

      @RichardSpain-lz9cf this is why I don't understand the UK public backing of Israel (maybe not all but alot), they're the occupying power and always in the wrong, the UK gets no benefit from them being an ally. People sit and wonder why the middle east and the alot of the world views the UK with hostility, you just have to look who the UKs best friends are (i.e the US and Isreal)

    • @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922
      @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922 Před měsícem +1

      ​@@keirmitchell5560Kermit the frog the baby killer

    • @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922
      @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922 Před měsícem +7

      ​@@LunaK-pt3tzScotland supports Palestine... Edinburgh is twinned with palestine

    • @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922
      @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922 Před měsícem

      ​@@LunaK-pt3tzScotland is colonized by Israel owned England

  • @_Damian_.
    @_Damian_. Před měsícem +21

    Completely avoids the attack on the Iranian embassy killing 14 or so people. This is why you're struggling to put this into context.

  • @Elisa-mg3rc
    @Elisa-mg3rc Před měsícem +121

    He "just" left out the fact that Iran's strike was in retaliation after Israel bombed Iranian embassy in Syria and killed 2 high Iranian officials plus 5 people.

    • @omarr6465
      @omarr6465 Před měsícem

      Western media only can remember certain things.

    • @celestesmith6060
      @celestesmith6060 Před měsícem +12

      13 people unless ordinary people don't count.

    • @alfredk471
      @alfredk471 Před měsícem

      He is owned the Zionists.

    • @ne-ht4zx
      @ne-ht4zx Před měsícem

      Iran are behind Hamas - this was Israel hitting back at Iran.

    • @hakanozaslan9571
      @hakanozaslan9571 Před měsícem +2

      are you surprised?

  • @user-em6ie2be7x
    @user-em6ie2be7x Před měsícem +53

    Iran has the right to defend itself from Israel's aggression.

  • @MichelMawon4982
    @MichelMawon4982 Před měsícem +34

    Israel should not have retaliated. I don’t think Iran acted childish, the complete opposite in fact.

    • @Titus9508
      @Titus9508 Před měsícem +5

      Iran is the only player here adhering to international law. They have outclassed the US and UK in this case.

    • @MichelMawon4982
      @MichelMawon4982 Před měsícem

      @@Titus9508 ohhh yes, yes indeed they have and we’re all super lucky they’re not what the west says they are.

    • @user-mz5qj8ic3z
      @user-mz5qj8ic3z Před měsícem

      Mr O'Brian didn't once mention that it was Israel that bombed the Iranian embassy provoking Iran with a possible WW3

    • @Blonde_Somnambulist
      @Blonde_Somnambulist Před měsícem +1

      💯

  • @kevinjewitt6347
    @kevinjewitt6347 Před měsícem +191

    Iran’s main objective was to show Israel what would happen if they overstepped the mark again.

    • @ne-ht4zx
      @ne-ht4zx Před měsícem +2

      Why, what would happen? Iran is weaker even than Russia. They won't dare to escalate the conflict now.

    • @kevinjewitt6347
      @kevinjewitt6347 Před měsícem

      @@ne-ht4zx The Iranians proved last weekend that they could strike any target in Israel and the missiles could get through any air defence.
      The damage to the airbases in northern Israel and the security facility in the Golan Heights was not shown on western media outlets.
      The Israelis and their allies lied, as usual, about the damage.

    • @Titus9508
      @Titus9508 Před měsícem +23

      @@ne-ht4zx Wow, that's a naive comment.

    • @1aatlas
      @1aatlas Před měsícem +6

      @@Titus9508 Indeed

    • @Lasquez111
      @Lasquez111 Před měsícem +1

      They sent 300 missiles! That nothing! What were they showing? What a tinpot army can do🤦🏼

  • @SourVodka
    @SourVodka Před měsícem +81

    Reporting from Iran
    Just a few mosquitos in the sky Iran bug spray very effective

  • @efdawahfan
    @efdawahfan Před měsícem +59

    the world says to Satanyahu dont do it...Satanyahu carries on...seriously this man is Histler 2.0.

    • @TheCuriuos
      @TheCuriuos Před měsícem +3

      2024 release, supported by US-UK service pack

    • @morasoussif4168
      @morasoussif4168 Před měsícem

      il plonge les juifs dans la merde pour longtemp mais il vont payer cher

    • @sofiabrinis8254
      @sofiabrinis8254 Před měsícem +1

      Satanyahu, you won the internet, mate 😂

  • @kevinjewitt6347
    @kevinjewitt6347 Před měsícem +66

    It’s funny how you don’t call the BBC the mouthpiece of the UK Government when discussing matters.

    • @MrSidkhan1
      @MrSidkhan1 Před měsícem

      Exactly. He tries to act all neutral, in real fact if u listen to him carefully he isn't at all, either he undercover supports israel etc OR afraid to call them out incase him and or the channel get cancelled. But he's a hypocrite which is their blatantly for the people to see. For the ones that can see that is.

    • @cowbanchalam9725
      @cowbanchalam9725 Před měsícem +11

      That crossed my mind, but why limit it to the BBC? All british media could justifiably be described as 'government'

    • @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922
      @britnatzaredemocracydenier5922 Před měsícem

      English brainwashing corporation..
      Britain just means England the colony masters

    • @kevinjewitt6347
      @kevinjewitt6347 Před měsícem +3

      I would agree but I would exclude a small number of independent media outlets.

    • @jonnydangerous2497
      @jonnydangerous2497 Před měsícem

      The BBC is state sponsored British propaganda. Everyone knows this, but O'Brien would never admit to it.

  • @ottoernst6707
    @ottoernst6707 Před měsícem +164

    While Iran is a horrific country this attack has shown the Israel regime to be a terrorist organization.

    • @joshuacampbell1625
      @joshuacampbell1625 Před měsícem

      Both are terroristic. The only difference now is that Iran launched an attack itself instead of through its proxies.

    • @abudujannah.
      @abudujannah. Před měsícem

      They have been shown to be a terrorist organisation for over 70 years. Both are.

    • @Cryosxify
      @Cryosxify Před měsícem +2

      what did they even target? and three drones only?

    • @andrewrobinson2565
      @andrewrobinson2565 Před měsícem

      Iran is not a horrific COUNTRY. Iran HAS a HORRIFIC ruling régime. Come on Otto...😮

    • @efdawahfan
      @efdawahfan Před měsícem

      Iran is a horrific country```who told you that ?? cnn and fox news or your government ??

  • @dachanne8631
    @dachanne8631 Před měsícem +33

    Again history begins with Israel's choosing. James talks about this current episode as Iran attacking Israel & Israel responding. Let's forget that Israel attacks Iran in Syria killing a number of people a couple of weeks ago.

  • @erselosman1380
    @erselosman1380 Před měsícem +21

    This man is not an honest broker, he talks for a whole 10 minutes on the issue without one mention of Israel's initial attack on the Iranian consulate in Damascus that kicked this all off.

    • @stormyweathers9887
      @stormyweathers9887 Před měsícem

      👏

    • @samf.s.7731
      @samf.s.7731 Před měsícem

      He did in a previous episode.
      But for those not knowing about what had happened, they're gonna not know at all what's been going on.

  • @CutiePie5183
    @CutiePie5183 Před měsícem +15

    How did you manage that into without mentioning the Israeli attack on the consulate?

  • @paulanderson2963
    @paulanderson2963 Před měsícem +17

    "We have billions to spend on posturing and escalation while millions of people who have been left with almost nothing are starving and dying."
    Sounds like all of human history.

    • @Jj-jg6pw
      @Jj-jg6pw Před měsícem

      Mostly european history. Almost all old empires and people were able to feed themselves and build a house.
      Europe is known for famines because they were always at war.

  • @mansari7310
    @mansari7310 Před měsícem +44

    😂😂😂😂What kind of face saving is that when Israel is too cowardly to even claim responsibility
    Iran attack hit 3 air base and 1 Mossad base in the Golan Heights openly and directly. Israel retaliated by paying some Iranian Jews to launch 2 quadcopters, which were intercepted.
    pathetic

    • @fortheregm1249
      @fortheregm1249 Před měsícem

      Bro, I grew up in Iran and there are so many Jews living here. Iran didn't expel them like many European countries. They are our country men and every bit iranian as we are. To assume Iran has problem with every Jew and vise versa is just a western/zionist agenda which has been pushed by the media. it was Probably some mosad agents or infiltrator from iraq which they paid off.

  • @motosashi6971
    @motosashi6971 Před měsícem +11

    Netanyahu needs to float to space and lose his helmet.

  • @sammy6877
    @sammy6877 Před měsícem +6

    What did the Iraq war accomplish by the UK and US??? No weapons of mass descructions were ever found

  • @corpocorrupt
    @corpocorrupt Před měsícem +13

    Well Israel has consistently been attacking Iran without retaliation. Surely Iran can’t be expected keep doing nothing.

    • @RajuAhmed-sy7ys
      @RajuAhmed-sy7ys Před měsícem

      Why not? Iran is a brown Muslim country that isn’t a puppet state of the west. How dare Iran claim to have rights to defend itself.

  • @alangravy27
    @alangravy27 Před měsícem +30

    What has been achieved is the focus and finance have been shifted away from Ukraine.

  • @naseemlatif3716
    @naseemlatif3716 Před měsícem +5

    "When a child is given toys regardless of their bad behavior, their behavior will eventually get worse as there is no reason for them to change. This is a prime example of Israel, as America will always support, protect, and provide weapons to them regardless of what they do."

  • @nathanu6759
    @nathanu6759 Před měsícem +12

    It’s risky to be the first to throw rocks when your house is made of glass.

  • @maqsh7239
    @maqsh7239 Před měsícem +10

    Isreal has all the right to do anything they want. Others have no right to defend themselves even when their Embassy is attacked. Double standards and hypocrisy for all to see

  • @taxpayer1040
    @taxpayer1040 Před měsícem +7

    Having spoken to three family members of Isfahan this morning they all seem somewhat unphased by what has supposedly happened. One says she slept through whatever it was. Another said the dogs did not make any noise which they would have expected and the last said that he was going on a demo today in support of Gaza but was not sure if the theme may change.
    Apparently children near the Nash-e Johan Square were playing with paper aeroplanes mimicking Israelis.
    As the mother of one said to me (89 on Sunday!) we were here before them and will be when they go.

  • @TravellingFreak991
    @TravellingFreak991 Před měsícem +12

    America are about a billion dollars down. That's what's been achieved.

    • @morasoussif4168
      @morasoussif4168 Před měsícem

      la prochaine envellope de 26 milliard de dollars pour israel c'est bon pour les ricains ils ont des machines planche à billets gratuite

  • @randomname3109
    @randomname3109 Před měsícem +16

    our people are going to die, for the sake of a foreign country... insane

    • @kirstyduncan408
      @kirstyduncan408 Před měsícem

      Ww1 and ww2 weren't british wars yet we sent millions to die fighting foreign wars and all theME ones since for the US and Israel.

  • @cealy76
    @cealy76 Před měsícem +20

    What's not to understand, Israel once again committed another war crime by attacking an embassy.
    Yet, you seem surprised Iran would retaliate.

    • @denisehusbands5751
      @denisehusbands5751 Před měsícem +1

      Right on. Thank you. James was so disingenuous. He knows the truth but diplomatically skirted around it.

  • @BehindTheCurtain_Truth
    @BehindTheCurtain_Truth Před měsícem +7

    He wants Iran to escalate first- to give him green light to use nukes.

  • @alrosano5786
    @alrosano5786 Před měsícem +21

    I know the answer, a insecure state that wants to remain top Dog 🐕 in the regional stage, bound to loose in the long term and they know that, that’s all folks !

  • @hansweissmann_xviii6754
    @hansweissmann_xviii6754 Před měsícem +13

    Who condemned Iran since last Friday? And who stands alone in UNSC protecting Israel?
    The achievements are plain in sight I would argue…..

    • @OldcastleElf
      @OldcastleElf Před měsícem

      Why does Israel need protecting in the UNSC? Really, it's everyone else in the region who need protecting from Israel.

    • @derekburke7831
      @derekburke7831 Před měsícem

      USA now stands alone with Israel even NATO allies won’t back them now when they turn and they will Israel will be history

  • @bucketlistreviews6593
    @bucketlistreviews6593 Před měsícem +15

    i care neither for Iran nor Israel but for the sake of not diverting attentiion from Gaza, Iran should not retaliate. This is exactly what Netanyahu wants. Gaslight the dire situation in Gaza, gain sympathy as the victim of "antisemitism" from Western nations and march on with the horrific Rafah Invasion that has just been greenlit by the US. The focus should be on Gaza now and let Israel be isolated further throughout the whole world

    • @xxxyzyz
      @xxxyzyz Před měsícem +2

      Then Israel will continue attacking Iran again and again. Then what?

    • @bucketlistreviews6593
      @bucketlistreviews6593 Před měsícem

      ​@@xxxyzyz If Israel attacks for the second time now, then Iran will have the global support. Even some EU countries will be forced to admit it. This war in Gaza is not going well for Israel and they want to distract the world with so-called "Iranian Aggression". israel cannot play the victim with the second consecutive strike on Iranian Soil

    • @samf.s.7731
      @samf.s.7731 Před měsícem

      Yeah they shouldn't.
      But here's the thing, if they don't...
      They'll seem like the bigger people than the Israelis..
      Israel will be worse than Iran in how it handled this.
      So, 1st world country?
      Pfffff more like a 3rd world rogue state who's been given weapons by Uncle Sam.
      So that's not likely gonna happen, Iran will retaliate.

    • @RevolutionaryVision-pc3gw
      @RevolutionaryVision-pc3gw Před 29 dny

      The US is saying not to go into Rafah still. Iran has the right to defence they should not have to take attacks because you don't want attention shared 😳d

  • @user-yv9ep4iu3b
    @user-yv9ep4iu3b Před měsícem +15

    Uk probably abstained, running away weak as usual 😅

  • @mr.t.2147
    @mr.t.2147 Před měsícem +10

    Iran is doing what the Arab states are not doing! May allah swt protect and bless Iran, signed by an Amazigh from North Africa.

  • @anthonyd4341
    @anthonyd4341 Před měsícem +12

    Be thankful for strange mercies. The loser is the US, Netanyahu's faithful janitor.

    • @MichaelDeHaven
      @MichaelDeHaven Před měsícem

      Worse yet, we(here in the US) have far too many religious zealots who want a war. They believe it'll bring about their little utopia. Even if it were true, they don't get to use other people's lives for their gain.

  • @rocketscience4516
    @rocketscience4516 Před měsícem +9

    Hey, Iran and Israel, grow up, the pair of you!

  • @johnwebster5005
    @johnwebster5005 Před měsícem +8

    It is absurd if - like James - you don't understand geopolitics and dismiss the Iranian regime as a bunch of 'headbangers'. This was about the USA NOT wanting a war in the Middle East because Ukraine is much more important to them and because we have an election year in the USA. Neither to the Iranians want a conflict - BUT Netanyahu DOES. The USA has given him a Green Flag to ATTACK RAFAH in exchange for not widening the war - EXACTLY WHAT HE WANTED. James ought to begin to realise this: WE IN THE WEST ARE THE PROBLEM.

    • @kirstyduncan408
      @kirstyduncan408 Před měsícem

      😂😂😂😂😂 ukraine is only US interst since 2014 Israels been US interwst from day one, ita their cobtrol of ME and resources. Give your head a wobble. Why else would US ignore sinking of USS LIBERTY deliberately by Israelis. 🤦‍♀️

    • @RevolutionaryVision-pc3gw
      @RevolutionaryVision-pc3gw Před 29 dny

      The USA are saying don't go into Rafah

  • @pearse9116
    @pearse9116 Před měsícem +2

    Iran achieved their goals - strain the US-Israel relations by costing the Iron Dome defence system $2B in a time when more Americans are questioning why so much US money is going to Israels defence and all it cost Iran was a few $100k

  • @nmchoudhary1512
    @nmchoudhary1512 Před měsícem +4

    Sorry to say majority of callers advocating for Netanyahu end up looking like foolish and ignorant.

  • @liamfarrell3281
    @liamfarrell3281 Před měsícem +2

    Iran has shown such strategic patience and now has totally rebalanced the Middle East. It was a shocking change of circumstances for the settler colony of Israel. Second passports have never been so readily available for the overly entitled European emigres.

  • @soniad3241
    @soniad3241 Před měsícem +3

    If you were kept in a prison and then condemned for using violence against mainly military targets and your jailors would you not do it James? I think I would!

  • @Abeda-be7tv
    @Abeda-be7tv Před měsícem +4

    James you don't talk about the first attack on by Israel on Iran killing several people. You don't talk about what happened prior to Oct 7 and you don't talk about the nakba but like to refer to the holocaust. Double standards

    • @pavloarmand4070
      @pavloarmand4070 Před měsícem

      James is scared of being described as 'antisemitic' as a lot of British people are. Why they allow 250,000 bellicose people out of 67 million to terrorise the truth is beyond the comprehension of many observers abroad. Fairness reaches a point where it becomes crass stupidity. Outside UK goldfish bowl there's less navel gazing and the reality isn't obfuscated by jaw-jaw ad nauseam by politicians and journalists whereby the meaning gets lost. It's a true British trait and extremely irritating.

  • @simonkapadia7582
    @simonkapadia7582 Před měsícem +4

    To be honest that trivialises it. Israel is the only nuclear state in the region, there is no symmetry, no mutually assured destruction. It has been trying to get the US involved in war against Iran for years. It recently struck an Iranian consulate in contravention of international law. People did die in that first attack. So no, cute names for it are not especially appropriate.
    Iran basically had to walk a fine line here. It's goal was to be able to say A) We've shown our capabilities (even if no real damage was done), B) We won't tolerate attacks on us, C) We don't want escalation with a nuclear power that genuinely might decide to use them with no real fear of consequences.
    Israel's retaliation against the retaliation was more in the emotional category, but Iran basically had no choice. Otherwise it would be sending the signal that when Israel attacks it, as Israel has done before this, it would just do nothing and let it happen.
    I would certainly ask whether your attitude if you were in Iran's place would be any different. There are after all two alternatives. You could do nothing after a number of your people were killed on your own de jure soil, or you could try to deal real damage and risk escalation. Which path would you choose?

    • @dech8220
      @dech8220 Před měsícem

      Exactly, I searched 'natanyahu UN' and found some 11 years ago clip with him saying 'how dangerous Iran is'. Middle East is NOT the problem, ISISrael is.

  • @robertovers1863
    @robertovers1863 Před měsícem +6

    two madmen in a cellar full of petrol both with a box of matches, trying to get the other one to strike a match fist

  • @mike798859
    @mike798859 Před měsícem +4

    My thoughts exactly James! "What on earth is going on?"

  • @shezaadkarim9123
    @shezaadkarim9123 Před měsícem +4

    How can the USA state they want a 2 state solution... but then veto the UN vote on recognising the Palestinian state?

    • @nazh9663
      @nazh9663 Před měsícem

      Hypocrisy is shouting

    • @nazh9663
      @nazh9663 Před měsícem

      They lied

    • @dech8220
      @dech8220 Před měsícem

      US wants 'my way or highway'

  • @andyhughes8433
    @andyhughes8433 Před měsícem +3

    Iran has shown its to be far more classier than Israel its allies. Their embassy was destroyed and 7 people killed. In response they showed Israel that they could respond and had that right, but avoided killing anyone.

  • @mansari7310
    @mansari7310 Před měsícem +4

    Iran never said that damage was minimum. there was 2 or 3 quadcopter that were intercepted and they releasd the footage .
    What kind of face saving is that when Israel is too cowardly to even claim responsibility

  • @Justlib543
    @Justlib543 Před měsícem +7

    James sitting on the fence as usual

  • @zahrais709
    @zahrais709 Před měsícem +4

    Face saving?! Does that disappoint u guys? Does your british hunger for destroying lives never lesson ?

  • @kimbirch1202
    @kimbirch1202 Před 29 dny +2

    The US has never forgiven Iran for nationalising its own oil, from American companies.

  • @steveblackman3606
    @steveblackman3606 Před měsícem +2

    Iran have shown themselves to be the strongest in that region and Israel now know they can get hit anywhere in israel

  • @phoenixh87
    @phoenixh87 Před měsícem +3

    Iran has been under sanctions for years and was probably irritated at the international response to Israel's stike on their diplomatic mission. Their strike was as much an economiconeas much as a military one. It cost zero lives but $1bn+ and that is a high cost no matter how you look at it. It probably cost Iran only tens of millions at the most.

  • @annwestman8354
    @annwestman8354 Před měsícem +3

    No tangible impact yet, but the longer this continues with retaliations on retaliations on retaliations ... something will go terribly wrong and then What?!

  • @andrewrobinson2565
    @andrewrobinson2565 Před měsícem +4

    No eyes for no eyes. No teeth for no teeth. 😮 33 eyes for one eye in Gaza (plus the injured 🤕 and amputees🦵 and the PTSDs on both sides). 🤔☮️❤

  • @Franki3683
    @Franki3683 Před měsícem +1

    The definition of statehood for UN council -
    The accepted criteria of statehood were laid down in the Montevideo Convention (1933), which provided that a state must possess a permanent population, a defined territory, a government, and the capacity to conduct international relations.

  • @juffjaff
    @juffjaff Před měsícem +4

    All of this over imaginary people in the sky.

  • @tobiashardy1620
    @tobiashardy1620 Před měsícem +1

    It’s a huge distraction from the moral loss and hopeless ‘situation’ in Gaza

  • @user-rm2to1sy1r
    @user-rm2to1sy1r Před měsícem

    Thank you for your excellent service,your support and your compassion you are the best ❤🩷😅we appreciate your support for the Palestinian people ❤❤the African community.

  • @Theo_Isaacs
    @Theo_Isaacs Před měsícem +2

    Israel attacked Iran numerous times until Iran retaliated with a strike of over 300 missiles. Iran achieved their objectives by now knowing the locations of their countermeasures. Iran also bled everyone financially because it cost Israel and her allies over a billion dollars to stop most of the missiles launched which only cost Iran 10’s of millions dollars in comparison. Iran notified the US in advance of launching missiles so that they could start the expensive task of stopping the missiles which were only launched to attack military airbases as opposed to Israel attacking civilian locations.

  • @kathyullah1619
    @kathyullah1619 Před měsícem +1

    Please no more war

  • @asone9797
    @asone9797 Před měsícem

    Mutual respect has been achieved. This way , the rest of the world can sleep in peace.

  • @bobmason1361
    @bobmason1361 Před měsícem

    James, you're bang on as usual.

  • @danmayberry1185
    @danmayberry1185 Před měsícem

    It's very much getting the last word. "Politics of the playground" is spot on.

  • @tombattisti8682
    @tombattisti8682 Před měsícem +1

    What’s changed is that the ground has shifted from shouting at each to a new status quo where actual attacks is now the norm

  • @paulhammond6978
    @paulhammond6978 Před měsícem

    It's basically expensive PR at this point - show that we have taken "action", but also not in such a way that it seriously escalates any tension. And everyone can see through how performative the action is.

  • @user-wq6sz7vt3w
    @user-wq6sz7vt3w Před měsícem +2

    Get it off your chest Mr Meldrew. You will sleep better tonight!

  • @swangelok
    @swangelok Před měsícem +3

    It is called posturing and saving face

  • @keithwilliams744
    @keithwilliams744 Před měsícem +1

    It’s a question that can only be answered when you include all the details without bias.
    The Israeli government is testing its boundaries both regionally and internationally this at a time when no nation is showing an appetite for war and testing its degree of opposition and support.

  • @mamunahmed1244
    @mamunahmed1244 Před měsícem +4

    Only it wasnt a twin attack though was it? Wasnt irans consulate hit with multiple deaths. Funny how we forget to mention certain attacks🤷‍♂️
    What we are certain about is if it were to be the other way around, we'd be obliged to repeat that attack in every sentence we utter

  • @Occident.
    @Occident. Před měsícem +2

    VIVA IRAN.🇮🇷

  • @Lea31706
    @Lea31706 Před měsícem +3

    I wonder who’s making all the money on weapons 🤔

  • @Naija4K
    @Naija4K Před měsícem +1

    IAEA said no facility was damaged and the missiles were destroyed in the air.

  • @teevee8944
    @teevee8944 Před měsícem +1

    Really Israel? 3 pizza delivery drones? That's it? We just watched Iran give you a drubbing, cleaned your clock wiped the floor with you. Pizza delivery mini drones??

  • @user-oo9tw1cb2c
    @user-oo9tw1cb2c Před měsícem

    Spot On

  • @michaelwalters3970
    @michaelwalters3970 Před měsícem +1

    This reminds me of an argument with a woman israel always has to have the last word.

  • @bas6628
    @bas6628 Před měsícem +1

    INSANE BOTH COUNTRIES

  • @josuter3808
    @josuter3808 Před měsícem

    Politicians know that true power lies with the people and the bluffing is a way to avoid getting overthrown.

  • @deehazsnow3178
    @deehazsnow3178 Před měsícem +1

    the scale of Iran's attack on Israel was unprecedented and unexpected. No other country has attacked isreal on such a scale in decades. The Isreali detterence is gone despite being a nuclear state.

  • @leavesinautumn5959
    @leavesinautumn5959 Před měsícem +1

    Israel attacked without warning (13 casualties), Iran responded after giving numerous warnings and details of incoming attack (no casualties), Israel attacked again (unknown number of casualties) .. its not really a "both parties are equally guilty" situation. To me at least, it's clear enough who's stoking tensions and who isn't.

  • @Dickie2702
    @Dickie2702 Před měsícem +1

    I listened to this show, and Mr O'Brien needs to look at himself in the mirror on two counts. Firstly, he made no mention whatsoever of Israels' attack on the Iranian Consulate in Damascus. The world needs to look at Iran and judge the country by the metric of how we viewed Irac in 2003, and we all know how wrong we were on that occasion. I speak as somebody who worked in the Middle East and has also been to the West Bank on several occasions.

  • @michaelmccarthy9411
    @michaelmccarthy9411 Před měsícem

    James, why on earth do you put an r in the middle of Kafkaesque?

  • @lynnellscott9079
    @lynnellscott9079 Před měsícem +1

    President Biden has stated on many occasions that the only way to end this conflict is to recognize Gaza’s statehood.

  • @traviscutler9912
    @traviscutler9912 Před měsícem +1

    O'Brien shows how much value he puts on Muslim life by ignoring the people murdered by Israel in Iranian Syrian Consulate when saying nobody was killed. What he meant to say was no Israeli lives were lost, the only ones of value.........

  • @ChelseaFCMario
    @ChelseaFCMario Před měsícem +1

    IRAN HAS A RIGHT TO DEFEND ITSELF

  • @inuwooddog3027
    @inuwooddog3027 Před měsícem

    Both regimes get to stay in power. Win-win cooperation.

  • @IOSALive
    @IOSALive Před měsícem +2

    LBC, This is fantastic! I subscribed because I love it!

  • @rayan76aa
    @rayan76aa Před měsícem +1

    Question is wrong.what has Palestinians achieved out of this theatre.