Sunni & Shia - What is (really) the difference?
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 01. 2020
- I see many videos talking about the differences between the Sunni and Shia, but most of them present a simplified version. In this video, I try to give you a more comprehensive overview.
For more detailed overviews, check out my other videos:
What is Shia Islam?: • What is Shia Islam? - ...
The Isma'ilis: • What is Shia Islam? - ...
What is Sufism? (Mostly Sunni): • What is Sufism?
What is Salafism?: • What is Salafism?
Support Let's Talk Religion on Patreon:
/ letstalkreligion
Or through a one-time donation:
www.paypal.com/paypalme/letst...
Also check out the Let's Talk Religion Podcast: open.spotify.com/show/0ih4sqt...
Music by:
Filip Holm
Most of my music can be found here:
Filip Holm: open.spotify.com/artist/2O7FL...
Zini: open.spotify.com/artist/0jy5K...
For more detailed overviews, check out my other videos:
Shia Islam (Twelvers): czcams.com/video/kXWADQ7HivM/video.html&pp=ygUSd2hhdCBpcyBzaGlhIGlzbGFt
The Isma'ilis: czcams.com/video/CFm03oac9es/video.html&pp=ygUSd2hhdCBpcyBzaGlhIGlzbGFt
Sufism (Mostly Sunni): czcams.com/video/Yc9k9nvIHOU/video.html&pp=ygUGc3VmaXNt
Salafism: czcams.com/video/8so2h21Mznk/video.html&pp=ygUIc2FsYWZpc20%3D
Support Let's Talk Religion on Patreon:
www.patreon.com/letstalkreligion
Or through a one-time donation:
www.paypal.com/paypalme/letstalkreligion
Also check out the Let's Talk Religion Podcast: open.spotify.com/show/0ih4sqtWv0wRIhS6HFgerb?si=95b07d83d0254b
Music by:
Filip Holm
Most of my music can be found here:
Filip Holm: open.spotify.com/artist/2O7FLjTvLWdWHDBgog9MPG?si=wLyeCLaoS4il7XLhhMgntQ
Zini: open.spotify.com/artist/0jy5KbYexv9k3zx2KWxXYQ?si=LMbsxxvjT-uI6bWwUxkPIw
Again ... Love your public education outreach work here. I've learned so much already on topics that are way outside my research area. (Especially laying sick in bed for a week.)
A possible future topic? What's the religious studies take on the social control theory of "religious cults / new religious movements"? The most often cited text seems to be Combatting Cult Mind Control. It's very much in the field of social psychology.
What I find interesting? The BITE model proposed in it could be used to, effectively place all new religious movements, but also all religious sects on a sliding scale between "high control "cult"" and low control sect. So, say, the branch Branch Davidians would be at the top and, say, Australian Aboriginal "dreamtime" rituals or other folk religions would be at the bottom.
Your interest in Islam might make you a good person to address this, given the fairly strict practices of religious law in Sunni, Salafi and Ibadi Islam.
I am a 61 year old Muslim. All my life, especially at young age, I have attended various Islamic events and travelled to places related to my belief. All these years, I never knew this much that you presented in this video. Maybe I wasn't informed, or simply, I didn't ask. What an excellent presentation that deserves all the credit. I feel ashamed of myself, Thank you.
Never feel ashamed of learning brother.
We all live and learn regardless of religious beliefs. I learn everyday glad others do as well!
Every day you learn something new is a good day.
I'm a 50 year old man. Raised Lutheran but as life went on ,I realized religion is here to control us. One day,hopefully, the world will realize religion is an imaginary boundary. We live we die and everything in between is a waste if we can't get along. Christians don't like muslims, muslims don't like Christians, how does either have peace after death if hate is all both know?
I have given up believing in God , I hope the world realizes how ignorant both sides have been. We'll never go anywhere with hate.
Lchaim from Jacova born March 11th in a Bethlehem. My covenant with God aka Elohim Adonai Hashem is to make Israel One. It means to bring peace and reconciliation between Jew, Christian, Muslim, cousins by Abraham. One of the things God told me I am is Evergreen. My middle name is Sue. When the Evergreen freighter Evergiven blocked the Suez Canal right before Passover, Easter and Ramadan I laughed with God and the entire angel team in Heaven above. For I knew. My Hebrew name Jacova is the female form of Jacob. In Aramaic Thomas means Twin. I am Rain. I am Anchor. I am The Ali Wickstrom. I am what God told and showed me I am.
I am Shi’a, my daughter in law is Sunni, we have excellent relations. We are all Muslims, and united under the prophethood of Muhammad peace be upon him.
Then y r u still calling urself shia what's that
Nowhere in quran r8?
Consider n introduce urself as Muslim❤️
Stop being taqiyya
@@farisaiman8537 Stop being a dumb hater!
We are not afraid nor will ever be from you, it's quite the opposite you guys fear us for no reason.
In my country, Malaysia, the Shia Islam is outlawed. Shia Islam is considered ajaran sesat/deviant teaching. The followers of Shia Islam usually get arrested and prosecuted.
@Secosia there are bunch of people who are extremists who do this, like they are sunnis who curse on Ahlul bayt!
Does all sunnis curse on Ahlul bayt?
The answer is no! But your extremist imams Always will show you those shia extremist minority and will tell you look at shia muslim and will start to stuff your brains with all the lies like that we don't worship god or that we have another Qur'an or that we consider Ali as prophet not Mohammad pbuh or that we curse the prophet wives or that we don't pray 5 times a day or that we never existed in the times of rashidons or that we don't do hajj...
We are used to all your scholar's lies :)
I’m not religious or interested in adopting a religion but I’m very interested in learning about religion as it relates to history, philosophy and the state of the world today. I really appreciate your detailed and balanced presentations. Thank you for all your hard work.
Same. I'm either agnostic or atheist(I dont think it matters), but religion has shaped so much of our culture and how events play out that one basically has to understand the history of religion to understand why many groups act the way they do. Understanding many geopolitical and humanitarian actions is greatly enhanced by knowing the religious context.
Same
Faerie folklore 🧚♀️
Yes,,, after learning more and more... I found Islam is worst in all of them
To sum things up. Religion is a scary cult that can lead people to both good and evil. But it's scary how you can make good people do evil things with it.
We should be working to get rid of it.
I am a Christian ✝️ but I'm interested in learning about Islam ☪️ to learn a better understanding about the world.
You should
Easy . Read the Qur'an book with translation.
I am also Sushi! My father was Sunni and my mother was Shia
@Muhhahha what do you mean cousins? My parents? NO!! Father's family is Pashtun and Mother's side is Balooch
@@safiagha8002 he is a troll, his username is Muahaha (laughter)
If you're Sushi you must taste nice.
@@jabujolly9020 I am ordering you some water for this... thirsty comment! *wink* *wink*
@@Dasnanortion Hey! I was hoping for some saki!
As a sunni who studied both suna and shia, this is extremely well put and subtle. Good job
Quran Verse (6:159) 👆
Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah ; then He will inform them about what they used to do.
People who divide the religion of Islam will be answerable to Allah. There is no Shia and Sunni in the Holy Quran, we are all Muslims.
I am a 12er shia, and i love my Suni brothers. ❤❤
Do u believe that 12 imams are saint?
We don't love you for the sake for the sake of Allah.
They were determined by allah@@lan8346
@@Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad.yeah me neither may Allah curse the nawasib
@@Allahuma.sali.ala.muhammad. If you read Sunni books, you will understand the truth of Imam Ali's caliphate
Such stoic objectivity on Islam and Muslim is rare in today's hyperpolarized world, especially in social media. Kudos to you for keeping it nuanced.
I love how articulate he ius when pronouncing peoples languages. It shows appreciation, respect and care towards anothers culture. wishing you good luck and fortune from South Florida
He is indeed very articulate and pronounces the foreign names very well. This is the first time I have watched any videos by this contributor, and I am intrigued by his accent; I'm 95% convinced he's Swedish.
@@CaptainQuark9 yes, he at least have a Swedish first and last name: Filip Holm, studied and works in Sweden and according to LinkedIn speak Swedish at a fluent or native level, and he sounds Swedish, so it seems quite likely that he's Swedish. :)
Yes, I really appreciate that with every video, not that he would be less relevant if he didn't it just shows an additional effort that I appreciate alot!
kalki avatar (beast of the earth) (christ on the white horse) (son of man on clouds) is the biggest enemy of dajjal/antichrist/kali 😏
Kalki Avatar (Murtaza) cousin of Moula mahdhi a.s. (muhammad) 😎
Moula mahdhi is raja shashidhuvj (the mighty one) 😎
Prophet Moula Isa a.s. will kill dajjal cause dajjal is going to kill Kalki Avatar 😏
Kalki Avatar will follow orders from 2 religious king Moula mahdhi a.s. and Moula Isa a.s. 😎
Kalki Avatar going to have 2 swords and ring of moula sulaiman a.s. and staff of moula musa a.s. (iron rod) Staff of moula musa a.s. is like omintrix can transform into anything and can transform others into anything And stone in the ring of moula sulaiman a.s. is also known as kastav mani and it's more powerful than all 6 infinite stones combined 😇
This staff will transforms into white horses with wings,weapons,iron-man,cloud etc or can do imagination into reality 😎
*Ratn sru sword of lord shiva (miri)😇
*Ratn varu (zulfakar) sword of Moula Ali (piri) 😇
miri piri 😇
Satyug (sunrise from West) 01.aug.38 😏
Sambal is hospital 😏
Gzwa e hind 2029 😎
Shiva uses Trishul and his son
Murugan, a Vel
Its amazing how a video from a YT channel with 2.2k subscribers teaches me better than a college level course on the same subjuct. Cheers bro, subbed
That is kind of amazing, and a little sad that some education is not delivering. But glad I could provide a counter to that :)
@Teal Seal i cannot agree more. this video had me subscribing within 5 mins lol. when you know, you know.
and hold up! he's on 200k subs already wtf.
Well that’s cause college is a scam.
then christian prince on you tube must be wrong
495k subscribers now 🤣🤣
As a Muslim myself, this cleared a lot for me. I had just been told "We aren't Sunni or Shia, we are just Muslims" whenever I asked them. Thank you for making such a concise video!
there a huge different in belief between these two group. So choose wisely which one you feels more in line with the Quran as the source and Hadith/sunnah.
Aka jewish haters 😂
@@mcbatetens Why would I hate Jewish people?
Lol
There is no just-Muslim person. How do you rate it?
Do you think that Abu Bakr (may God curse him) was the first caliph or Ali, peace be upon him?
Or how do you pray your prayers if you only call yourself a Muslim?
@@47952how do you feel cursing the first sahabi of Prophet Mohammed pbuh?
Your clear-mindedness is a welcome addition to the often hysterical discussions about religion. Thank you.
This Christian (Quaker) thanks you very much for this. I learned a great deal and unlearned even more.
I love this ♥️
We need more people like you
Quak
A Quaker! Such a sane, soothing religion.
Well put.
Your unbiased narratives and summation deserve more appreciation than many of the so-called Islamic scholars who incite promote enmity against each other(Shia and Sunni). Those who do not like your video, obviously miss the point that you presented a factual account of the differences and the origins of the divisions between Shia and Sunni and most of these people did not know themselves. Thanks, from a Sunni Muslim.
So true brother i ageee with you. They are dividing the ummah. When we divide we are weak, together we are stronger.
@@user-eh2pv4sc7hmy brother in Christ, repent and accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour so you shall have eternal Life ❤
I am a non-Muslim and found this video to be tremendously valuable to my understanding of the history and relationship of these two Muslim groups. Thank you.
just remember both sides, like all abrahamic religions, are cringe
@@glupshitto5019whatever makes you sleep at night
I have been asking this question for many years, and this is the first resource that bothered to actually answer the question. I thank you.
I am an Indian and a Hindu and I often wondered what is the difference between these two groups; thank you so much dude for coming up with this video. It really helped me to understand the details and the roots of Shia and Sunni. Even I had a thinking that random two groups are just against each other to show superiority over another. I appreciate your reading and research you did to make this video. You made it easier for millions to understand this difference. Cheers to you and keep sharing knowledge. Love from India.
After the death of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his family), there were two options to seek guidance from. a) The ahlulbayt (the holy household) of the Holy Prophet. b) Others.
The ahlulbayt are those family members of the Holy Prophet who grew up in his blessed lap. They are the people in whose house Islam, Qur'an and the sharia'h was revealed. They are the ones upon whom Muslims are obligated to send blessings in their namaz/Salat/Daily Prayers. Ahlulbayt are those family members of the Holy Prophet about whom Allah testifies to their purity, infallibility and sinlessness in the holy Qur'an. They are the ones who the Holy Prophet left behind him with the holy Qur'an. The Ahlulbayt loved the Holy Prophet the most and he loved them the most. Amongst the ahlulbayt you have people like hazrat Ali who is the gateway to to the city of the knowledge of the Holy Prophet, hazrat Fatimah Zahra who is the chief of the women of the paradise. Imam Hasan and Husain, the two leaders of the youths of paradise. They are the heirs of the knowledge and wisdom of the Holy Prophet.
Who can understand Islam, Qur'an, sharia'h, the sunnah of the Holy Prophet and so on better than the people of the house?
Therefore, after the Holy Prophet Muhammad, the Shi'as seek guidance from the Holy Household of the Holy Prophet.
As regards to the others, we are not sure of the state of their iman, their source of knowledge, information and understanding of Islam.
Muslims in general and the reverts/converts/new Muslims in particular need to study the history of Islam (not of the Muslims). Carry out your own independent and unbiased research on the personalities like the Holy Prophet Muhammad, his beloved daughter Fatimah and their sons Hasan and Husain (peace and blessings of Allah be upon them all).
Explore the school of the ahlulbayt and discover its beauty.
Do not be a victim of prejudice, brainwashing, ignorance and misconceptions about the school of the ahlulbayt.
www.al-islam.org
whoishussain.org
www.aoislam.com
www.imamali.net/?id=2390
www.ahlulbayt.tv
@@Gulamqambar too big to read.... gn
@@Gulamqambar why we need to seek knowledge from prophet's (pbuh) family or others when knowledge was already given in holy quran?
Regarding Hadith we can easily confirm them from quran. If hadith is in harmony with quran then we shall accept it and if it isn't then we will reject it.
Stop your shia sunni stupidity. We had already suffered so much from this divide.
@Hadi Asadullah And...? Are you trying to scapegoat or something?
@Hadi Asadullah I'm not a Christian tho? And that's a double-scapegoat now. Why do you keep doing it?
As a Shia, you've definitely done a great job bringing light into the Imams after Ali A.S, furthere more you've taught me aswell in relation to some of the branches, well done!!
Seeking aid from other than the almighty is not allowed
@@mountainleopard5370 Yet you have some authentic hadiths in your books that say Ya Mohammed and not Ya Allah. We aren't seeking help from them we just ask Gods best creation to get our message through to him, just like how you go to see a doctor before the specialist.
@@fabiology6439 we don’t ask the prophet Muhammad phub for help do you ever see us chanting YAAA MUHAMMAD MADADD? Btw the doctor is Alive to help you, Ali (ra) cannot hear you let alone help you
@@fabiology6439 Claiming that the Imam has power over creation and has all-knowledge to interpret and change islamic rulings to his liking is no different than Shirk.
@@mountainleopard5370 Allah has made this life in a way where we seek a means to attain our goals. For example going to the doctor before the specialist (which is called a metaphor/example in case your uneducated mind didn't understand). This is something very natural and accepted. Even those who believe in God seek help through others, it doesn’t mean that we don’t believe in God if we go to a doctor.
When we say Ya Ali or Ya Hussayn we are seeking help from the Ahlulbayt knowing and believing that whatever help they give us is through and by the permission of God.
There are several verses in the Quran which encourage people to seek a means to reach their goal or even get closer to God.
وَ ما أَرْسَلْنا مِنْ رَسُولٍ إِلاَّ لِيُطاعَ بِإِذْنِ اللَّهِ وَ لَوْ أَنَّهُمْ إِذْ ظَلَمُوا أَنْفُسَهُمْ جاؤُكَ فَاسْتَغْفَرُوا اللَّهَ وَ اسْتَغْفَرَ لَهُمُ الرَّسُولُ لَوَجَدُوا اللَّهَ تَوَّاباً رَحِيماً
Nisaa 64
This verse tells believers who are seeking repentance to repent through RasulAllah, basically encouraging people to call upon RasulAllah.
يا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا اتَّقُوا اللَّهَ وَ ابْتَغُوا إِلَيْهِ الْوَسِيلَةَ وَ جاهِدُوا فِي سَبِيلِهِ لَعَلَّكُمْ تُفْلِحُونَ
Ma’ida 25
Encourages people to seek a means to reach God.
When we call upon the Ahlulbayt a.s. we are seeking a legitimate means that God has appointed for us.
Saying Ya Ali is not only halal, it is also encouraged because the Ahlulbayt are the means that God uses to connect with us, we use them to connect with God. Also Ya Mohammed s.a.w.s. is in your books but you've just never read them. Plus saying that these people are "dead" and cannot hear us is a pure contradiction with what the Quran says.
Suratul Baqarah: Verses 153 − 157
(١٥٣) يَـٰأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُواْ ٱستَعِينُواْ بِٱلصَّبرِ وَٱلصَّلَوٰةِۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ مَعَ ٱلصَّـٰبِرِينَ
(١٥٤) وَلَا تَقُولُواْ لِمَن يُقتَلُ فِى سَبِيلِ ٱللَّهِ أَموَٲتُۢۚ بَلۡ أَحيَآءٌ۬ وَلَـٰكِن لَّا تَشعُرُونَ
(١٥٥) وَلَنَبلُوَنَّكُم بِشَىۡءٍ۬ مِّنَ ٱلخَوۡفِ وَٱلجُوعِ وَنَقصٍ۬ مِّنَ ٱلأَموَٲلِ وَٱلأَنفُسِ وَٱلثَّمَرَٲتِۗ وَبَشِّرِ ٱلصَّـٰبِرِينَ
(١٥٦) ٱلَّذِينَ إِذَآ أَصَـٰبَتهُم مُّصِيبَةٌ۬ قَالُوٓاْ إِنَّا لِلَّهِ وَإِنَّآ إِلَيهِ رَٲجِعُونَ
(١٥٧) أُوْلَـٰئكَ عَلَيهِمۡ صَلَوَٲتٌ۬ مِّن رَّبِّهِمۡ وَرَحمَةٌ۬ۖ وَأُوْلَـئِكَ هُمُ ٱلمُهتَدُونَ
O you who believe! seek assistance through patience and prayer; surely Allah is with the patient ones (153).
And do not speak of those who are slain in Allah's way as dead; nay, (they are) alive, but you do not perceive (154).
And We will most certainly try you with somewhat of fear and hunger and loss of property and lives and fruits; and give good news to the patient ones (155),
who, when a misfortune befalls them, say: “Surely we are Allah's and to Him we shall surely return” (156).
Those are they on whom are blessings and mercy from their Lord, and those are the followers of the right course (157).
I’m sunni muslim who studied abrahamic religion. For me, it doesn’t matter which path you use to follows because we all worship the same entity which is one God (Allah s.w.t), just put your trust in Allah & never arguing about others people view. We all deserve to live in peacefully.
Ameen
Absolutely ❤️
Do you consider your children as "other" people and adhere to the idea of letting them lead their life with their religious choice or no religion at all?
It’s a big thing to put down Shia Muslims. Especially on CZcams “big Muslim CZcamsrs” I won’t mention names, love to do this, and they get love from the Sunni community it’s not right especially because Sunnis are a majority. So I come from family with both because I’m Iranian and I have both Kurdish and Azerbaijani and it offends me, but even my Shia side of the family they are jus Muslims. They pray everyday and to Allah (swt) everything Sunnis says about Shia is rubbish
So it does not matter if u consider the prphet's companions kafirs
Dont forget the +10% morale of armies and the +10% shock damage
Only goes to show who really is on the right path
.
🏟️ Besiege every Mecca to kill every idol, but keep its Gold like a Black Stone, to be kissed and touched to forgive your faults...
💰 LOVE OF MONEY is ONE GREAT god! ☝️
It is the endless fight for POWER, camouflaged as religion;
The more it grows, the more division...
So, Lets Praise THE ARMIES OF JIHAD for heading to Self Destruction, like a Babel Tower collapsing over its poor foundation... ⚖️
wgt
@@williamgarayua5878 tf u talking bout?
Dear "@@vigosfilm4809" :
Im more than happy to explain it to you, if asked, but not because mocking at others;
Maybe you are very good about percentages, but still need to improve about what is morale or Armies of JIHAD disguised as religion or Ottoman Empire...
Wars need to be ended, and not perpetuated by praising it... 🌐🕊️
wgt
I'm a Christian (Catholic) just here for education.
I see similarities between us and the Protestants who are also Christians but who have many differences to us and our Orthodox Christian brothers.
The peace of the one God be with you all.
I'm Jewish Orthodox and like you, here to learn.
Respect.
Jews, Christians and Muslims have the same one God, the God of Abraham, you guys just have different interpretations and practices.
Real Christians worship Jesus Christ not Mary.
heck, what happened to the other 4,000 Gods.. and who says a one God is right ??? because some human told you so ?
@Fiona's Life and Challenges why not take another step and learn about the history of religion and mythology ?
Incredible clarity, art, graphics, and production quality. This video is a cut above - liked!
Thanks for creating this great video. I love how at the end you have asked people for any feedback and you have allowed for corrections if any.
Congratulations. This is such a difficult subject matter, yet you gave an excellent, informative rundown in fifteen minutes.
As someone who likes studying Islamic history. It was a great video. You really did put together everything well.
WHY DID NOT GOD TELL THEM WHAT TO DO
kalki avatar (beast of the earth) (christ on the white horse) (son of man on clouds) is the biggest enemy of dajjal/antichrist/kali 😏
Kalki Avatar (Murtaza) cousin of Moula mahdhi a.s. (muhammad) 😎
Moula mahdhi is raja shashidhuvj (the mighty one) 😎
Prophet Moula Isa a.s. will kill dajjal cause dajjal is going to kill Kalki Avatar 😏
Kalki Avatar will follow orders from 2 religious king Moula mahdhi a.s. and Moula Isa a.s. 😎
Kalki Avatar going to have 2 swords and ring of moula sulaiman a.s. and staff of moula musa a.s. (iron rod) Staff of moula musa a.s. is like omintrix can transform into anything and can transform others into anything And stone in the ring of moula sulaiman a.s. is also known as kastav mani and it's more powerful than all 6 infinite stones combined 😇
This staff will transforms into white horses with wings,weapons,iron-man,cloud etc or can do imagination into reality 😎
*Ratn sru sword of lord shiva (miri)😇
*Ratn varu (zulfakar) sword of Moula Ali (piri) 😇
miri piri 😇
Satyug (sunrise from West) 01.aug.38 😏
Sambal is hospital 😏
Gzwa e hind 2029 😎
@@Ironcammandoo are u out of ur mind? Are u mad?
@seek mogol jews call it eloh or elohim and muslim call it allah
@seek mogol hey. Please if a well educated person see your comment will laugh. Deleted it. I don't even want to argue with you. No point to...
This is so interesting because Im from morocco and we are sunnite and celebrate ashoura as well, but for us its a joyfull celebration. I never knew that the shiaa were mourning that day
Been through 40 or so videos looking for a breakdown like this… thank you
“Conflict of succession” is a common theme among any groups, religion and politics.
Im sunni and respectful to my shia brothers we one ummat 💙🇮🇩☪️
Can you respect me if I say all the bad words in the world to your mother father and family???
@@mohammedkamilshaikh8406 yes. Because we are taught to always show love and no hate because thats not how our prophet dint represent himself. He was always kind and respectful
@@eyazulul can I show you some proof regarding this?? Will you believe??. man you need to read seerat of our sahabis.. (RADIALLAHU ANHUM).. you can't be kind to gustakhs of rasool صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم Or their beloved sahabis..... That's called iman.. Otherwise I'm the name of tolerance you may receive love from kafirs in world but after death you need to face Allah... Keep that in mind...
@@eyazulul the prophet ﷺ fought in wars. He wasn’t always this kind and love person. ﷺ
@@sev9139 ah yes comparing war and normal interaction in normal life. Very high intellectual
I am English and i am 38 years old Muslim
What an effort! Great job I'm really enjoying your videos 💞
Well, if there are people born to Sunni-Shia (Sushi) couples, there are also people born to Safavid-Hashemite (Sashimi) couples.
Brilliant! Lmao 🤣😆
Well done
🤣🤣🤣
😂🤣
In reality they actually can't
From your prior videos, I knew that I needed to see this. You are so humble and I never see you pass judgment and you are so fair. Well done as always, my friend.
Wow. I'm impressed. You presented this in a way that makes it easier to understand somehow. I'm impressed. Thanks for the information
your pronounciation is absolutely incredible, it's like you can speak the language (this is my first video of you so idk but it seems that you do have a second language- you definitely have more range than the average english speaker)
This is a high quality video and the best I’ve seen on the subject so far, thank you for your time sir, it benefited me greatly. Reading a book called political tribes and it talks about these two groups without defining them. This helped a bit with that
I am very impressed with not only your in-depth analysis of this subject but the clear and concise articulation and presentation. You sir are a true scholar in my opinion and make a fantastic teacher. It is clear from the beginning how intelligent you are and how much preparation you invested in this video, for that I am most very thankful. Great job! and thank you.
This is a lot of information crammed into 15 min. Very well presented and I learned a lot about the Muslim Sunni and Shia groups!
It is good to watch someone without any biases talk about sects in Islam
One difference is Shia have continuity of leadership to carry responsibility of guidance in every aspects.
😂
Their so called imams are infallible. i mean they call upon them like some demigods
@@MegaBaddog from what I can tell they don’t look up to them as “demi gods” but they remember the bloodshed of the grandchildren of Prophet Muhammad
@@bakerzane3055 he didn’t say look up to them as demigods. He said call upon them as demigods
@@ibrahimyilmaz4861 my point still stands
Nice video. Just a note. Shia believe in Imam Ali (A.S.) being the successor because of the event at Ghadeer Khumm where the Prophet (S.) said that "Whoever I am his master (Mawla) then Ali is his master (Mawla)" along with other events.
Also, Twelver Shias (the main group of Shias) still have a living Imam, Imam Mehdi (AJ.), who is in occultation and will return. This is similar to how Muslims believe Prophet Jesus (A.S.) will return.
This is just a general note and more details can be found at the appropriate sources.
That sum up better
What do you mean by alive but in occultation? Is there a living person who carries that title but lives in hiding, or is it purely eschatological figure?
Well said
@Pedro Cruz yes Imam Mahdi who is the 12th and last Imam is still living until these days but in hiding and he will only appear again before a certain number of years before yawm al kiyamah
Well said👏 I thought of this too when watching the video. We didn’t just make up from our own minds that Imam Ali should be the successor, he was literally appointed by the Prophet (pbuh)
Very helpful and informative.
Most appreciated as we have only been confused by modern conflicts as mass media worsened the divides lot worse than I ever known personally.
Peace and stability may come from knowing that we are more similar than different. Regards.
I'm glad to have discovered your site and pleased to know about your well researched video which one can listen and learn, do provide more to us.
This was a wonderful video! You shed light on the issue in a very objective way. I adored this video!
You did a great job in research and in explanations.
I went through your videos by chance and i’m amazed!
What a well presented and thoughtful explanation!
I think this is best round up introduction in limited time capsule presentation
Very well done
I had this ultimate hate toward shia, was so ready to slap one on the face if I met any, up to the point where I couldn't stand it anymore and looked for any shia community. People kept telling me not to go alone, to bring any smarter guy along. When I finally found a shia community, nobody wanted to come along, so I went there by myself.
I sat down among shi'is that were listening to their ulama preaching. Somehow my fast-beating heart gradually settled down when I heard the guy preaching about the 2nd verse of surah al-Baqarah, the verse of the Holy Quran that I firmly believe. When it was about to end he mentioned Husayn ibn Ali, then I heard the guy next to me sobbing softly, also the one next to him, also the one in front of me, it was like almost everybody there was crying. Only by then I remembered that I was surrounded by shi'is. For almost an hour I completely forgot that I'd been listening to a shia preaching all along.
I was told that shia has a different Quran. No, they don't. I didn't join shia, I never will, as how I've never even also consider myself a sunni. I'm a muslim, that's it.
That power of hate was just unbelievable, I still can't believe that I could hate that much against something I never knew about. The more I think about any justified reason to hate, the more I felt like being ordered to hate. I'm pretty sure the only reason to bring someone along was to keep burning that hate, or at least to prevent one from joining instead.
@@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx curse of Allah on Muawiah & who defends him.
@Dark_Lord Imagine still being mad over something that has happened 1400 years ago. That'S ridicilious and y'all should focus on what makes islam, islam. And then it becomes apparent who is more deviant than the other
@@ThexXxXxOLOxXxXx Guys no point spreading misinformation and hatred, Shias have always been a part of Islam. They believe in the six articles of faith, so do most Sufis and Ibadi, you are not the Judge, Allah is.
@@majorblazer9055 Peace be upon the Prophet Muahammad (SAW), may Allah bless his wives, his children, all his companions and his nation. Ameen
Indeed there is no difference between Shia and Sunni. The division was created by the prophet's family. Ali took the side of those who later gave intellectual and scriptural leadership and was the vanguard to a scientific revolution, unknown at the time. The Umayyads of Damascus, for political reasons sowed the rift. Today Saudi Arabia pretends to be Umayyads while Iraq and Iran represents the Shia, who leads the Islamic attempt to unity and fight the common enemy. One day they will be united and the spark will rekindle. The Sunnis embarked on military domination while the Shia led the scientific revolution (Mutazila-question everything), it was the Sunni fundamentalism that did the most harm. I am a Sunni.
Salaam, I want to thank you for making these videos, but also for including my Maser, Sheikh Ahmadou Bamba, in the introduction!
I think it's good to show that the "Muslim World" doesn't just consist of Arabs & Persians, but has a much broader and inclusive range. Also, I think Ahmadou Bamba is especially inspirational and should be highlighted more.
Thank you for such a clear, concise and unbiased explanation. I never understood the differences between Shia and Sunni Islam so thank you for the explanation.
Thanks for this video. I have looked for this answer for a long time but usually people only talk about the succession issue. Glad I saw this video where you have really gone beyond the obvious.
An amazing video! Very well presented and explained, thank you
🙏🏽
Appreciate your work, I learned a lot, and enjoyed your deep understanding and unbiased analysis of the subject. 👏🏻
Brief,concise,precise
Simplified
Wonderfully presented and explained
Very few have been able to explain this distinction so clearly
Incredibly articulate and well explained. I’m so much smarter now than i was 15 minutes ago. Thank You
Thank you for sharing, and promoting knowledge and understanding!
Your clarity in thought and expression on matters within the realm of inquiry into religious and philosophy is very remarkable and thus commendable, for you serve to enlarge the visions of the common masses having very little time and energy for pursuing these matters and you thus contribute to the peace of tgis strife-ridden world. Congratulations to you...
Im not religious, i grew up in an atheist household but i love learning about religion thank you for this videos ❤️
I love learning how disliked I am for my beliefs also 😉 . and yes I agree with you too
I am neither Atheist nor a believer, i am just not interested to do or take part in any religious things. And i do not follow any kind of groups. I just live my life. Also sometimes i think the whole world is just a plaything for God. He knows i am sinning, he also knows if i go to hell or not 😅 We are basically like a Puppet doing what the divine entity want us to do. Maybe i am more like the iblees who knows God is the one yet do things that god has forbidden. I do not care if i die right now or i live another 30 years, i do not care if i go to hell nor i want to go to heaven.
So what am I actually? 😊
But I hope you figure things out before you check out of this world. Don't believe that you came from monkeys and therefore you owe to yourself to find the answer
@@Lightbringer11.11 strong. I feel similar
the whole point of this world is, it is your choice and decisions that will affect your afterlife. It’s not prewritten, you have your own will.
You do a much better job at explaining this sensitive topic than most Western news media organizations and documentary productions.
Thank You for your time in explaining this issue.
American here let me say it mainstream western media is trash and not to be trusted
Why point at Western media on a topic they have no clue about
I love the little girl who declares herself “Sushi.” Adorable and a hope for the future. Blessings be.
I'm sorry for the poor Sushi who is bound to be molested by temporary marriage (mutu'a).
@@surajoafakamuhammad700 ; Oh God I hope not. That is just awful.
Ther,s only on god
Wat is this terminology SUSHI ?? I didnt agree with this ??? We are born muslims and we have religion in our BLOOD specially blood gp Apositives have qualities of Hazrat ALI because he was cousin of OUR Nabi MOHAMMAD,Hazrat Adam,hazrat Ibrahim,mohd,ALI,Hssan,Hussain all r Imams of their ERA quality of conqueror, Leadership,Itellectuals,beautiful,Aerogant,Sensitive related to religions are blood gp A positives true descendents of Hazrat ALI
@@dr.farehasaleem5061 "SUSHI" is a light-hearted joke to resolve a serious problem. Since her mother is SUNNI and her father is SHIA, if you combine the first two letters of SUNNI and the first three letters of SHIA, you get SU-SHI, that is SUSHI. At 14:48 in video, the young child is a combination of her mother and father, hence SUSHI which is not an actual faction of Muslims. To make matters more hilarious (or serious, depending on how you look at it), sushi is a Japanese food based on raw fish.
On a more serious note, though, did you say that Muslim religion is based on blood grouping? And that A+ is more common among Muslims of the decedents of Hazrat Ali? Could you please share a link/URL to show at least one such study done under strict scientific conditions with relevant statistical analyses? Thank you!
I look forward to videos that go into specific details about (at least) the major branches.
Gee, I love the opening music! Great stuff!
🎶
I like the way you present facts in a very objective manner; a great scholar in the making :). I can say that you said it all correct, at least for the part on Shi’ism.
... and also for the part of Sunni.
@seek mogol both Sunni and shia believe Muhammad died a natural death. Where are you getting your information from?
@seek mogol Where from you got this bullshit?
Both shia and sunni accept that there was natural death of prophet Muhammad (pbuh)
Umm did he? He didn't even mention Ghadeer. Prophet Muhammad already told the Muslims multiple times who is gonna lead them after his death. The Sunnis rejected it after his death, which led THEM to deviate, not us.
@@bhatfirdous1081 he did die naturally but he was injured in khaiber which lead to his death
I got out of mainstream religion. I simply go to the corner of my room and pray to God directly. It's free, it's peaceful, it's not complicated.
.. and not useful either.
You will grow old, grow sick, and die .. like the animals, bugs, birds, fish, bacteria, etc, etc, none of whom EVER pray.
@@AjayKumar-dv4pq Yes , you are right, PRAYER WITHOUT ACTION IS DEAD, OR FAITH WITHOUT ACTION IS DEAD,, About man is superior to insects and animals because we were created in the image and likeness of YHWH. ,, But man sometimes goes down to the level of animals and insects when he starts carrying bombs strapped to his body and blows away innocent people, or practices idolatry, sexual fornication, murder and so on..Let us keep this world a better place. Shall we..
@@albertmalcampo9784 : I can see you are intelligent, but not passionate. To discover truth (any truth) passion is required, otherwise intelligence is a waste.
If you are really interested (passionate), you should analyze deeply what is prayer. Don't make a rocket science out of it. It is fairly simple.
Also, why do you think your life is more meaningful than animals? Because you study mathematics?? You are born, grow old, look for food, shelter, have sex, entertainment, are violent, hoard wealth (walnuts like squirrels), then grow sick and die, exactly like animals.
@@AjayKumar-dv4pq Yes, you've got a point there, but for me, Fear in God and putting God in the middle of your life is most important. When we fear God, we achieve wisdom, more than all the knowledge of this material world, more than the traditions and cultures of this material world. ,,My God is the God of Abraham , Isaac and Jacob, ,,, Any other is man made..WELL, NICE TEXTING WITH YOU,, PEACE BE IN YOUR SIDE OF THIS WORLD....
@@albertmalcampo9784 : I understand if you say you fear snakes or tigers or dictators. How can you fear something you (and everyone else) has never seen ?? Think deeply before giving an answer.
You are not afraid of God my friend, but of something else.
"Because things insist on always being complicated" --- This is the universal explanation for everything that's going on on Earth :)
Thanks for the video, mate. I am not a muslim, but one of my passions if the study of religions. I'll check your other videos for sure.
Well, you've definitely cleared up my initial misconceptions by explaining that it is all WAAAY more complex than I ever imagined....
Thank you for enlightening me(us) in the very intricate and complex history of the Islamic religion. The more we know the better it helps us understand humans that have religious views and tenets than we as individuals.
I'm a Shia Muslim, and honestly I'm amazed by your knowledge and clarity in this matter. You actually know things that even most of the Muslims don't know. This video is a job well done.
Question to the non Muslim.
Which side are you supporting and why? Which group makes more sense to you?
This was very interesting and informative, thank you.
Wow. I did not think a 15 minute video could deliver a concise but clear and mostly accurate explanation of this divide in the Islamic world to the rest of the human population. Usually a college level course delivers this amount of data. Kudos to you for making it simple and concise
THANK YOU
I like the video as well, but if you take a college course and only learn what can fit into a 15 minute video on CZcams... find another school.
Excellent video and narrator, thank you
Always remarkably enlightening!
Fairly deep understanding and study of the subject material is appreciated.
Always learn something new from this channel.
This was very interesting and highly informative video. I was aware of the Sunni and Shia split within Islam and the associated reasons but was not aware of the extent of the disparate factions. Well done! 🇨🇦
🍁 O Canada 🍁
well described. I really like your tone and clarity
Islam is the antithesis of the British weather. Islam is mostly Sunni and a little bit Shi’ite, whereas the British weather is a little bit sunny but mostly shite.
Great video by the way. Very informative 😊
You are now my new favorite YT channel. :)
Oh this is gold XD
Luckily its a little sunni right now though it was quite shi'ite this morning
@@hpsauce1078 British weather is a bipolar racist.
Ngl i like british depresing weathers
this is so high quality its crazy man, love the effort you put into this!
Excellent source of information 👏. I have friends of all different sects and respect them all. This clarify even more than before. Shukran !
Sushmita: extremely well presented Philip. Thank You 🙏
You are talking history but your content is so convincing, as if you lived it all, your language so precise, pronunciation of words so clear, that's amazing
As a muslim who follow Quran, I actually dont really care about sunni and shia thing. First, there is no sunni or shia in prophet era. Secondly, it is not part of iman or islam requirement. Some stupid people usually say "shia is not islam". But I appreciate this video because you make some effort to bring this informative stories. After studying each group, I come up with conclusion: whatever you are sunni or shia, you can go to heaven if you are sincere, honest, do good deeds, etc as explain in Quran.
When asked “Are you Sunni or Shia” respond by saying “I’m Muslim”.
totally agree with you!
Then answer me this, do you believe the descendants of Muhammad as divinely inspired? That's the problem with not claiming to be sunni nor shia. If you're a muslim who believe that the Imams are not infallible/maksum, then you're a sunni.
@@originalsun5206 it just your claim with simple logic, black and white, "if he is not shia then he must be sunni". 😄
@@gondala lol what? Only because it is that simple. Every Muslim has the basic faith that Muhammad is the last prophet of God and there is no god but *the* God. The majority of Muslims are sunni (this is why I assume and said "you're a sunni" ) and they probably wouldn't know or even call themselves sunnis if not for shia's distinct principles.
By all means I'm not against Shias existing nor am I saying that they aren't Muslims but the small theological differences unfortunately happened to be the most substantial in deciding how the religion works and progress. This is why I bring up about the Imams because they are the deal breaker.
According to Shias, the hadith of the Imams are *weighted almost the same as prophet Muhammad SAW himself* . This is a problem as being infallible/maksum is a quality that's usually reserved only for the great Prophets and especially problematic that in their belief it can be passed through bloodline inheritance.
I know what you're trying to say with the kumbaya stuff but we have to bridge the gap between sect through mutual understanding of each others differences and throwing your hands up then say "we're all muslims" is quite lazy, doesn't add anything to the conversation and in your own words "simple logic, black and white".
I'm sorry if I offend you, no intention to just needed to share. And let me rephrase my statement - If you're a Muslim who believe that the Imams are not maksum, then you're not a Shia, and *probably* a Sunni based on majority.
Excellent..a far more complex division than I previously imagined
I watched your other episode about angels speaking Arabic language for eternity, and I have been hooked to your knowledge.
Very much appreciated.
It's true that when one looks for a difference between Sunni and Shia, one usually gets a short answer of a split happening after the death of Muhammad. This is why I made an effort to find a vid like this.
As pointed out, it would be like looking into different branches of Christianity, finding out about the Great Schism and thinking you have it all figured out.
Very interesting, learned a lot. As a history teacher, I try to tell the story of Islam, but have always struggled with the real difference between Suni and Shia. I knew about the succession story if course, but nothing mire than this. This will help educate my students.
Excellent video! Thanks for sharing.
Wow the amount of research and the content you presented to us.. Thanks for that! 😁
Thank you for this video. I learned a lot about our muslim brothers and sisters. More power to you!
@Who taught You To Hate Yourself One is all and all is One my friend.
@Who taught You To Hate Yourself Do what you must
Sunni and Shia are like that of protestant and holly Roman Catholic church.. like that of branches of Hinduism, Bohdism.. .😂😂
Religious beliefs systems are are out dated and out of modern touch..😊
Therefore it must be slowly phase out and neutralize.. because it is out live it's usefulness.. it have become a liability in terms of ideology..🦀🤳
@Who taught You To Hate Yourself I don't just hate Muslim..😊 I hate all religious freedom and beliefs systems.. because it is a pointless opium high and whor of elites few that control a culture a group of people a pocket of economy and I call them the 1%ners that benefit from independence sovereignty of nations and it's Tailored made jurisdiction that dominates our species of humanity social structure.. another word.. I hate all independent sovereign nations of the world.. because it is a feudal system and structure..🦀🤳🤓
@Who taught You To Hate Yourself why would I want to destroy my beautiful species of humanity social structure.. I just want to protect preserve it and evolve it for the better because being a live in a time line is what I wanted..😊
Who wouldn't love the first kiss, the warm sunshine in a cool morning the breeze brushing against your sensory hair, the flavors of food and the different fragrance of flowers and lots of colorful women..😊..
Yeah I love reality of life, the very essence of it..😊 that is why preserving our species and reasonably equality for all mankind is logical and worthy for the conversation..🦀🤳🤓
I don’t remember the last time I read such a sane and reasonable comment section. Watched, like subbed
Wonderful explanation on this interesting topic. Thank you 🌷🙏
Imam jaffer is actually common in all Sunni and Shia paths, however both think he had different teaching. Infact Hanfi which is largest school of thought either in Sunnis or Shia, imam Abu Hanifa was student of Imam Jaffer. So clearly the division is not so old as today's historians say so.
Generally it is very good video I learned a lot.
Imam Abu Hanifa and Imam Jaffar were contemporaries .www.ilmgate.org/regarding-imam-Abu-Hanifah-studying-under-imam-jafar/. Further, one of the main differences between sunism and shism is sunis for the most part believe the Quran is complete, and anyone can study it and try to understand it. Shias have the concept of immamt, spiritual leaders from the decent of Ali (RZ), who are better suited to understand the Quran.
there were shias who used to be hanafi and yet a shia before safavid empire
He was not a student of Imam Jafer As Sadiq.This is a rumour.Imam abu hanifa Lived in other place and time and Imam Jafer in other time.This is totaly fake
@@muhammadbilalimran818 he was, you don't know
The demarcation between Sunni and Shia has historically been really blurry and the clearer line we have now is only like 40 years old and is a reaction to the idea that Imam Khomenei would lead a pan-Islamic global revolution.
If you are a Zoroastrian or a Jew or a Christian or a Muslim you should know that you all worship one God.
We disagree on minor issues and we care about them very much. We forgot that the main issue is monotheism and living healthy together.
The time for unity has come.
Peace be upon humanity
Excellent video. I will have to watch it several times in order to get all of the factions down as I am not Muslim. But I would like to suggest a video that does a time lapse by map of the growth and populations of the different factions. Fascinating video. Very well done.
Thanks for the great content. It was a very good account on the divisions of Islam. I would, however, also mention the significant similarities between the two main sects. For example, many of the hadiths, although from different sources (eg Sahabah vs Imams) they convey the same meaning, or even are identical. Or the the backbone of most rituals, despite differences in details, are more or less the same (5 time prayers, Ramadan fasting, Hajj, etc.).
you know what u did an excellent job.
i'm impressed with ur deep research.
hope to see more good works.
btw thank you
I have been impressed by some of your previous videos but you have not dealt with the origin of this issue with well researched analysis. But over all thank you for your informative video.