She's your granddaughter? Fantastic - pretty much all hardcore gymnastics fans thought she should have been in the final. First session luck(or lack of).
5 years later : 2 times European champion UB ; 2 times World Champion UB and now Olympic Gold… no further comments 😜 My granddaughter: simply the best on bars ; my queen 👸 😘
Go learn to be a judge if you think you’re so much better at it. This angle doesn’t show what the judges actually see- such as handstand position and body line in releases and transitions. It’s very easy to armchair judge- so if you want to prove your claim get off your duff and go join the judges ranks!
She had flexed feet often during this routine. Some of the handstands may have been a bit short, but I think it was mostly the flexed feet that hurt her E-Score. She still does this now, but she's WAY better at keeping toes pointed now.
Oh, no I can't agree Scheder didn't deserve to be in the final. She's a lovely bars worker, long lines and flight on everything. I always thought she should have more recognition for her bars - and I was really happy to see her win the bronze. Derwael should have been in the final over Lopez or maybe even Shang.
she should have imo. But she as in the first subdivision of the day and bars was here first event... the judges didn't have anything to compare her routine with. Should she have been in a later subdivision, she would have make it
that's what this open ended scoring system is supposed to remedy. the difficulty is the difficulty and the execution is the execution. no need to "compare" it to anything. each routine stands on it's own and should be judged accordingly. so sad.
There were a multitude of reasons she didn’t. One, she had a couple of connections that were missed- just like Fan Yilin- and her D score reflected it. Two, she had really bad flexed feet several times- a deduction- and some missed handstands. Those all add up. (And before you start to say anything, yes- Aly received the same flexed feet deduction but HIT her handstands).
If Aly got an 8.733 execution, Fan Yilin and Nina should've had no problem getting into bar finals and having higher executions since they both had much better form. I'm usually not a fan of Chinese gymnastics, but Fan's UB QF and Shang Chunsong's AA BB scores were ridiculously low, and should have medalled in their respective events
Fan absolutely botched her UB qualification routine, missed a bunch of connections and had some insanely late handstands. Shang was hit for lack of artistry (justifiably so) just like Aly was, and would have medaled in the AA if not for her vault. A FTY at the Olympics in the AA will absolutely never win a medal, something she should have learned from the previous year’s world championships but didn’t. Aly’s qualification UB was the cleanest she’d ever put out and was rightly scored. In AA finals she had less clean form and got suitable deductions for it. Watch the routines with an unbiased eye and you’ll actually see it.
Aly actually hit her routine the best I’d ever seen her do- super clean and well executed handstands (for once). This had multiple form errors and some very missed handstands. Those add up quickly.
She has a beautiful body shape for the sport. Everything looks so elegant with her long legs. When women built like her do well, it looks so much more beautiful than the "power house" built gymnasts however, when a leg is bent or a foot is flexed, it is so much easier to see with tall gymnasts. Every mistake is easily seen while the short stalky gymnasts can hide mistakes better and get thru with no deduction.
Because other people performed higher difficulty and had cleaner execution- including Aly. This angle doesn’t show how much she missed a couple of handstands and her catches involved body line shape that incurred deduction.
Fue muy injusto dejarla fuera de la final Sabían que tal vez destronaria a Aliya Mustafina y por eso no la metieron a la final lo bueno es que hay Justicia Divina lleva dos campeonatos mundiales y tal vez un Olímpico 2021 Mustafina se retiró sin un solo título mundial
No hubiera podido ganarle pero fácilmente medalleaba, di lo que quieras de la participación de Mustafina en mundiales pero es un hecho que defendió bien su título de barras. Si quieres que te moleste algo ahí tienes a los jueces dejando pasar a Madison Kosian que tenía una ejecución cuestionable y le pusieron una notasa
@@marjoriegonzales4677 Se ve que no sabes absolutamente de gimnasia jaja o a Daría Spiridonova que clasifico con una nota De muy superior a su ejecución hoy en día Nina Derwael lleva dos oros en mundiales un bronce y un Oro olímpico y tal ves este año consiga su 3ro, mustafina está sobre valorada
@@lovepop4336 dale la burra al trigo, no le hubiera podido ganar en esta final en específico, hay un abismo entre la Nina que vemos ahora y la que vimos en 2016. Aquí aún tenía problemas que la hubieran alejado del oro si pasaba. Repito, si quieres rajar de alguien ahí está lo de Kosian que quién sabe cómo apareció con una notasa de ejecución teniendo errores técnicos
@@marjoriegonzales4677 si analizas la rutina del 2016 de Nina tiene elementos de sobra y Kosian tiene mejor ejecución que Mustafina de echo Mustafina en su rutina final tubo muchos errores simplemente separó el pie al aterrizar sus codos siempre flexionados en sus alemanas y en su Jaeguer Korkina si era más técnica y adelantada para su época tres finales olímpicas Ni Mustafina podía con las gimnastas nacionales de Rusia después de rio Pues tu sigue ahí Apasionandote con su actuación Jajajaa Fanatizate de Mustafina y adorarla jaja
way better than simone,than all us gymansts,actually anything about us mostly i hate,because its so buyers,us athletes wins without dignity,me no respect!even they did do good or amazing
It makes me very proud to see her win a gold medal today
So proud of my granddaughter ! She should have been in the UB finals with this performance !
She's your granddaughter? Fantastic - pretty much all hardcore gymnastics fans thought she should have been in the final. First session luck(or lack of).
She will be 20 at the Tokio Olympics ; Watch out for her to surprise the world of Gymnastics 👍💛💪
Benny Lammens Hoping she goes well at Worlds this year and makes the final for sure!!
Benny Lammens that bar routine was amazing!
Congratulations on her win at European Championships!
And 5 years later…. Olympic Uneven Bars Gold Medalist🥇 😍😍😍😍
This was my favorite bar routine of the Olympics. Pity it was so underscored and wasn't in the finals.
Well, she's Olympic Champ now. ;)
That underscore tho.
I really hated the judging in this year's Olympics. Truly terrible and at times heartbreaking.
Revenge Tokyo succeeded !
5 years later : 2 times European champion UB ; 2 times World Champion UB and now Olympic Gold… no further comments 😜
My granddaughter: simply the best on bars ; my queen 👸 😘
Go learn to be a judge if you think you’re so much better at it. This angle doesn’t show what the judges actually see- such as handstand position and body line in releases and transitions. It’s very easy to armchair judge- so if you want to prove your claim get off your duff and go join the judges ranks!
Her twisting in transitions is so nicely timed
She should be in the final
Roy Wilson.C absolutely what I had just thought
She had flexed feet often during this routine. Some of the handstands may have been a bit short, but I think it was mostly the flexed feet that hurt her E-Score. She still does this now, but she's WAY better at keeping toes pointed now.
Those leotards are fabulous, & so appropriate & festive for the location of these olympics!
Should've made the bars final over Seitz or Scheder, nothing against those two, but I feel this girl is much cleaner with the same difficulty.
Oh, no I can't agree Scheder didn't deserve to be in the final. She's a lovely bars worker, long lines and flight on everything. I always thought she should have more recognition for her bars - and I was really happy to see her win the bronze. Derwael should have been in the final over Lopez or maybe even Shang.
Rosalina 90 no Shang deserved her place in the final. She competed in the first subdivision as well and was also underscored.
I'm surprised this girl didn't make the Event Finals for UB
she should have imo. But she as in the first subdivision of the day and bars was here first event... the judges didn't have anything to compare her routine with. Should she have been in a later subdivision, she would have make it
that's what this open ended scoring system is supposed to remedy. the difficulty is the difficulty and the execution is the execution. no need to "compare" it to anything. each routine stands on it's own and should be judged accordingly. so sad.
@@KarlWarden i agree so much
There were a multitude of reasons she didn’t. One, she had a couple of connections that were missed- just like Fan Yilin- and her D score reflected it. Two, she had really bad flexed feet several times- a deduction- and some missed handstands. Those all add up. (And before you start to say anything, yes- Aly received the same flexed feet deduction but HIT her handstands).
Beautiful!
Judges on crack!!! Never forget that Raisman got a higher E than this! Lol
Albin Andersson Wait, are you Serious???
Alchamei Well yeah, Derwael got a 8.533 and raisman got a 8.733
The uneven bars judging in Rio were so so generous except for China
And Derwael :-((
Oh my god that's ridiculous!!!!!!!
Belgian queen on bars xx
If Aly got an 8.733 execution, Fan Yilin and Nina should've had no problem getting into bar finals and having higher executions since they both had much better form. I'm usually not a fan of Chinese gymnastics, but Fan's UB QF and Shang Chunsong's AA BB scores were ridiculously low, and should have medalled in their respective events
Fan absolutely botched her UB qualification routine, missed a bunch of connections and had some insanely late handstands. Shang was hit for lack of artistry (justifiably so) just like Aly was, and would have medaled in the AA if not for her vault. A FTY at the Olympics in the AA will absolutely never win a medal, something she should have learned from the previous year’s world championships but didn’t. Aly’s qualification UB was the cleanest she’d ever put out and was rightly scored. In AA finals she had less clean form and got suitable deductions for it. Watch the routines with an unbiased eye and you’ll actually see it.
Things like the fact that RAISMAN got a higher e score then this makes me want to stop watching gymnastics and I'm for team USA.
Aly actually hit her routine the best I’d ever seen her do- super clean and well executed handstands (for once). This had multiple form errors and some very missed handstands. Those add up quickly.
I love the carnival style leotard
Que gran rutina
She should’ve been in the finals. She could’ve easily medaled. Just two years later and she’s a Worlds bar final medalist.
Nina Derwael is a champ!
I agree that she should have been there in the finals. Her leo was amazing. I wish she could connect her Bhardwaj to a Van Leeuwen..
❤️
She has a beautiful body shape for the sport. Everything looks so elegant with her long legs. When women built like her do well, it looks so much more beautiful than the "power house" built gymnasts however, when a leg is bent or a foot is flexed, it is so much easier to see with tall gymnasts. Every mistake is easily seen while the short stalky gymnasts can hide mistakes better and get thru with no deduction.
See u in Tokyo
trop beau sont justaucorps
Ela merecia a final das paralelas assimétricas...
I don't know why a 15.133 wouldn't make it to an uneven bar final🙄
Because many others performed better and earned a place!
De brug is ook mijn favoriete toestel
Ik ben en meisje hoor
Why she wasn't in the UB finals?
She was underscore, even Raisman had a better E score, that's ridiculous.
Because other people performed higher difficulty and had cleaner execution- including Aly. This angle doesn’t show how much she missed a couple of handstands and her catches involved body line shape that incurred deduction.
Fue muy injusto dejarla fuera de la final
Sabían que tal vez destronaria a Aliya Mustafina y por eso no la metieron a la final lo bueno es que hay Justicia Divina lleva dos campeonatos mundiales y tal vez un Olímpico 2021
Mustafina se retiró sin un solo título mundial
Nina não tinha chance contra Mustafina em 2016
No hubiera podido ganarle pero fácilmente medalleaba, di lo que quieras de la participación de Mustafina en mundiales pero es un hecho que defendió bien su título de barras. Si quieres que te moleste algo ahí tienes a los jueces dejando pasar a Madison Kosian que tenía una ejecución cuestionable y le pusieron una notasa
@@marjoriegonzales4677 Se ve que no sabes absolutamente de gimnasia jaja o a Daría Spiridonova que clasifico con una nota De muy superior a su ejecución hoy en día Nina Derwael lleva dos oros en mundiales un bronce y un Oro olímpico y tal ves este año consiga su 3ro, mustafina está sobre valorada
@@lovepop4336 dale la burra al trigo, no le hubiera podido ganar en esta final en específico, hay un abismo entre la Nina que vemos ahora y la que vimos en 2016. Aquí aún tenía problemas que la hubieran alejado del oro si pasaba. Repito, si quieres rajar de alguien ahí está lo de Kosian que quién sabe cómo apareció con una notasa de ejecución teniendo errores técnicos
@@marjoriegonzales4677 si analizas la rutina del 2016 de Nina tiene elementos de sobra y Kosian tiene mejor ejecución que Mustafina de echo Mustafina en su rutina final tubo muchos errores simplemente separó el pie al aterrizar sus codos siempre flexionados en sus alemanas y en su Jaeguer
Korkina si era más técnica y adelantada para su época tres finales olímpicas
Ni Mustafina podía con las gimnastas nacionales de Rusia después de rio
Pues tu sigue ahí Apasionandote con su actuación
Jajajaa
Fanatizate de Mustafina y adorarla jaja
Gimme that leo NOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
It wasn't her time yet here in 2020 she's win 🏆 gold medal on UB and ➕ she's young she has time 🕒 people
Robbed
way better than simone,than all us gymansts,actually anything about us mostly i hate,because its so buyers,us athletes wins without dignity,me no respect!even they did do good or amazing
You hate the US and it's peoples. We get it. 😏
She should be in the final