YT151 Why There are No Friday Sermons from Muhammad? Did they hide them? What else was hidden?
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 07. 2024
- In this segment, we revisit the issue of the Friday prayers, specifically asking: Where are Muhammad's Friday sermons? How come we have none of them in the books of Tradition?
We hope that these provide you clear warning signs regarding anti-Quran preachers you should avoid, and that you should guide your families to avoid.
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:09 In This Segment
2:11 Reminders
3:29 Muḥammed as a Nabiy and as a Rassool
10:37 Difference between “يا ايها الذين آمنوا” and “المؤمنون”
13:15 Reviewing YT135 Regarding Friday Prayers
22:17 Historical Proofs Against Friday Prayer and Sermon
25:06 More Evidence #1: Imam Mālik Ibn Anas
28:12 More Evidence #2: Another Janaaḥ (Evidence)
30:19 Conclusion
36:26 Advice: Take This Matter Seriously!
40:56 Outro
We provide a Quran-based understanding that shows the true meaning of this Aya 62:9-10 and we rebuke those in our tradition who were at best negligent, and at worse intentionally harmful to Muhammad's Sunnah.
For more than 2 years, we have demonstrated how wrong the traditional interpretations have been. We demonstrated that traditional ‘scholars’ regularly imported claims from Biblical sources and super-imposed them over the QurꜤān! What if the definition of al-Injeel as taught to us by the traditional Islamic scholarship is totally wrong?
To receive a pdf copy of the notes file for this segment, please subscribe to our Marvelous Quran Project website at
www.marvelousquran.org
To learn more about the organic Quranic methodology that we use, watch the playlist on Methodology on the channel page on CZcams
On this channel, we do NOT teach the (corrupted) Bible! We only teach the QurꜤan, using the Quranic methodology to extract knowledge from the Quran, exclusively!
We rely on the organic Quranic methodology, on the Abrahamic locution, and on the nested interpretation techniques to uncover the meanings and indications of the Quran verses.
The conclusion: When the Quran Tafseer scholars decided to bring their stories form corrupted versions of the earlier scriptures, they misled the Muslims from engaging the Quran in the way that Allahh had instructed us to do.
Why are we presenting these topics on this channel?
1. Our primary mission on this channel is to teach this divine 3ilm (of the organic Quranic methodology + the Abrahamic locution) after it has been undocumented for 14 centuries
2. Please resist the urge of learning JUST for the sake of curiosity
3. The ultimate goal of learning this 3ilm is to teach you Shukoor (practicing proper communication with Allahh)
4. This channel is NOT to AFFIRM what you were taught, but to apply the methodology to seek the truth about the Quran. Learn how to empty your cup before you can receive a fresh refill!
Facebook Marvelous Quran
Website www.marvelousquran.org
You may contact us via email MarvelousQuran@gmail.com
Quran Translation and Commentary by Dr. Hany Atchan
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:09 In This Segment
2:11 Reminders
3:29 Muḥammed as a Nabiy and as a Rassool
10:37 Difference between “يا ايها الذين آمنوا” and “المؤمنون”
13:15 Reviewing YT135 Regarding Friday Prayers
22:17 Historical Proofs Against Friday Prayer and Sermon
25:06 More Evidence #1: Imam Mālik Ibn Anas
28:12 More Evidence #2: Another Janaaḥ (Evidence)
30:19 Conclusion
36:26 Advice: Take This Matter Seriously!
40:56 Outro
Thank you very much. Uploaded.
Al hamdulillahil Rabbil alemin! Allahu akbar! Befor haveing found YOU my dear father Dr. Hany I did not attand friday prayers for a very long period... and now u are telling me this.... TABARAK ALLAH!
May Allah SWT bless u!!! I LOVE U!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Salaamun Alaikum. Thank for the reminder, this should make us ask questions.
Alhamdulillah
Al7amdoelillahh Al7amdoelillahh!
JazakaAllahu Khairan Dr.Hany.
Salaamun Alaikum
Alhamdulillah coherent and consistent with the rest part of the Qur'an.
I 'skipped' zohor more than 3000 times n prayed jumaat instead!!! And all because of my ignorance over the ONE- SYLLABLE word MIN before the airing of relevant YT!!! May we all continue be guided based on the Quranic methodology as embraced n elucidated by our dear Dr Hany insya Allah
just wait until he said that dzohor also a fraud.
Wait till he gets to 5 salah and Ramadan my friend 🤣
@@anggasugih5303 Yes...only Allah give us understanding of AlQuran. We can read all the tafseer by the scholars or the interpretation by this guy BUT the only guide is by Allah ONLY
Who cares, both are inovation AKA bi'dah😀
@@melissatheguru8306 top G
Salaamun 3alaykum!
Beautiful video!
"but wait, there is more!" is just one of my favourite things to hear from Dr.Hany in these segments :D
May Allah increase us all in evidence-based knowledge.
:)
Alhamdulillah
Salamun Alaykum. Thank you for the very enligthening & comprehensive revelation. Alhamdulillah.
Alhamdulillaahh that Allaahh has made this knowledge available for us, It is He also the one will guide us through implementing and sharing it to others.
No fear and no sadness
InshaaAllaahh
Alhamdulillah
الحمدالله الذي هدانا لهذا وماكنا لنهتدي لولا ان هدانا الله لقد جاءت رسل ربنا بالحق
Alhamdulillah!!! Beautiful segment! The words of Allahh are so comforting!
Salamun Alaykum Alhamdulillahh MaasyaAllahh thank you Dr Hany
I feel nothing short of awesome blessing from Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) for the opportunity of listening to the results of all your work, Dr. Hany! And I am sure I am just one among many...and I hope we will be always more and more, insha'Allah!
Where are the CZcams shiekhs please come out and refute the evidence that this channel is presenting for two years you guys are quiet i challenge any youtube sheikh to come out openly and defend the tradition because you're leaving your blind followers looking very ignorant with the type of argument they are they bringing up against this channel, so weak and lacks evident base knowledge.
@@man4sliding950 yes when someone can't even follow the instructions to watch the complete segment and other pre-requisites segments that are being referred to but only making some claims without evidence
Very good explanation about the absence of Jummah sermon by prophet.
I hv listen to this segment over and over again. Love it. Thanks again to Dr Hany. Your hard work is my syukur.
Alhamdulillah and thank you, Dr Hany
Alhamdulillah - Such a clear convincing nested interpretation of ayat of 62:9 and 62:10. Thank you so much Dr. Hany, keep up the good work. Eagerly Waiting for a segment of Salat as Allahh (STW) said in Quran for us. S.A.
Alhamdulillah! I was thinking about this topic for the past few weeks.
Imam in the masjid recited this surah just yesterday, I was like. Oh wait theres the proof of Jumuah. And the video drops. Wow.
Salamun Alaikum Dr Hany and the Priviledged blessed listeners...
What a mind blowing segment and presentation is outstanding and Stunning clarity! We are travelling with you dear Hany! Our Soul is Dancing out of Joy for the Truths Flowing like the fountains of Jannah!
Our prayers for You to be safe and be blessed with Ocean of True Ilm.,
Quran is Absolute Truth HAQQUL YAQQEEN!
Let them Criticize Let them Go..
We love you We love Quran.
Thank you for the tremendous effort you took to present this segment! All praise belongs to Allah!
The Unassailable!
Am Naseema,
From Tamilnadu, India
Alhamdulillah
Why do u think you will go to jannah . For denying all the prayers and rules of life set by islam. U will go to jannah Just reading quran and its translations..that is it. 😢
Subhanallah
This segment is going to stir lot of controversy. Surely for those who want to inject their own agendas
السلام علیکم
I am new in this channel, can anybody give me the link where Drm Hany explained how we can take Hidayah direct from ALLAH S.W.T. at night, Couldn't find that video , Dr. Hany refered in this or other video.
Jazak Allah khaira
@@obaidulhaque7687 جزاک اللہ
Salaamun Alaykum Dr Hany, thanks once again for clarifying about Friday salat; as well as explaining the difference between the two terms"al Mu'minoon" and "Al-Lazeena Aamanoo" and cautioning about its implication on other Ayats, particularly those relating to the subject of Halal and Haram. I was wondering that quite related to this specific distinction between these two terms, Ayat 6 in Surah Al-Ma'idah (Ayat on Wudoo) that also starts with the term "Al-Lazeena Aamanoo" therefore implies that Wudoo has not been prescribed for the "al Mu'minoon" while they offer their Salat (or toil on Qur'an)!
Alhamdulillah
The terms THose who believed and the believers are game changer for me. They are new zabur / bayyinat Alhamdulillah
Alhamdulillah!
Salaamun Alaykum Dr. Hany.
Just wondering, how negligent we are in engaging the ayas of the Qur'an!
It's very easy to say, "Alhamdulillahh for everything", but it takes much more courage to actually mean it!
Can't thank you enough for the motivation you always give us to take the words of Allahh SWT seriously...
Are you from Bangladesh Brother @chander gari
@@muazmahbub5251 Yes, I am. You too?
Yes brother. I am from dhaka. I thought i was the only majnoon from dhaka. Anyway nice to have you here in this channel. May Rabb help us..
@@muazmahbub5251 You're invited to Bandarban Sadar. 🙂
Currently i am in London. Hopefully in future when i will go to Bangladesh. Btw thanks brother...
Alhamdulillah ❤❤❤
Thanks very much Dr Hany for this enlightening segment which sealed what was stated in YT135 .
Salaamun Alaykum!!
Sir hope u are fine what if min is used as from the day will it not change the meaning otherwise just curious please advice thank u
That would not be acceptable Arabic grammar
🧡💙🤎
30:10 That means the original Sabbath was their opportunity to receive direct guidance? do we know their process?
May Allah Swt protect and have mercy on all believers. 🙏🤲
very interesting, you have other examples where you think we have deviated somewhat?
Salamunalikum.. Alhamdulillah... Malaysia is here
Alhamdulillah. Thank you Dr. Hany.
Salam Dr Hany, May I ask why in Surah Baqarah Verse 183, it is not a past tense?
Thank you, Dr. Hany..., As always, very convincing and insightful in your arguments. Our heartfelt wishes for you.
May Allah guide us!!!
Once i want to memorize some khutbah of jumaa prayer and i came to know that there is not a single khutba recorded in hadith given by muhammad saw and yet they claim it is part of our salah if you talk or miss it you missed your salah or else you destroyed it at that time one thing i more realise that there is no tafsir of quran in the hadith the one who did tafsir they just fit one story which happened or not in muhammad saw times allah knows and make it the tafsir of the aayah.
As the time is moving faster quran is also starting to disclosing all its beautiful revelation.
❤❤❤ Jazak Alahh alghair
Salaamun Alaykum people… it’s 3:28 am where am watching this great segment.
Alhamdulillahh
Alhamdulillah it's a baraka of Allah that we are able to get this detailed information that makes things clear.
Very thankful
Jazakallahu Khairan
Alhamdulillah.. MQ starting to discuss about salat, the very subject that is giving me the most anxiety since following this channel. Thank you Dr Hany
very well explained, that was much needed topic and also helpful for those who ask again and again about salah. Gold bless you Dr. Hani
Alhamdullillah. Keep it up, increase the volume Dr. Hany. The more disclosures the more I am getting closer to Allah.
Salaamun Alaykum
Alhamdulillah
As always
Every video segment has gold and gem pouring out.
Thank you Dr. Hany.
Thank you Allah swt for Your divine guidance.
Thank you for enlightening us Dr Hany. Allah made this knowledge available.
Since my teenager I asked about this back and forth. I was in doubt again since 2 years ago.
And now it's all clear by the Qur'an which revealing the truth.
Alhamdulillah, Salamun Alaykum
Dr I have a question, یَـٰۤأَیُّهَا ٱلَّذِینَ ءَامَنُوۤا۟ . The word ءَامَنُوۤا۟ has a “ َ “ above the ء. Doesn’t that change the past tense to present since ءَامَنُوۤا۟ is different from امنوا ؟
It is the way the Quran spells that word, just like "قُرْءَان": This is how it is spelled. It means those who believed
Alhamdulilah ❤
SubhanAllah! May Allah reward you abundantly . Thank you for sharing.
Alhamdulillah...
Alhamdulillah ❤❤, feeling More and More confident, segment after another
Alhamdulillah!!!
Dearest Brother Hany
Allah has allowed you to be used for the purpose of “Good” and I thank Allah for allowing any, and everyone who is searching for the truth to come across this channel and dress and themselves with the finest jewels made available to us in this life and that is understanding “The Quran.” May Allah continue to bless, protect, and reward you.
Thanks for that
Thank you Dr Hany for the clarification on Friday sermons.
ALHAMDULILLAH ... Many Thanks to you Dr. Hany. you are a great teacher. Jazaaka Allahu Khairon
Just started watching, the subject is great, i m lovin it.
Salaamun alaykum..Alhamdulillah.❤
Salaamun alaykum. Thank you for a most enlightening and clear presentation on the topics presented in this segment. What a mind blowing experience to receive evidence after evidence to prove the points. Alhamudulillah.
Alhamdulillah. Allahh promised us: "If you seek, I will help you."
Interesting question. Never thought about that.
جزاك الله خيرا ❤
Salatul Jumuah Friday Khutbah is similar to the Christian Sunday Sermon? and Jewish Sabath Saturday?
Though I am not a believer, yet this video has provided huge convincing information on Friday prayers Muslims offer around the world.
❤❤❤❤
Salaamun alaiykum, Alhamdulillahh, again and again Alhamdulillahh .Our beloved Dr.Hany...
I mostly saw the word من associated with "from" and never "after" because "after" means it has a point of event "from" the initial motion has began , in this case the "calling" to assembly are the point where motion starts from , Then "after" that assembly / gathering you spread out in the way of the scripture...
I've never seen ANY TRANSLATION that uses من as "after" but I do see some use it as "against" in surah Quraysh , but it still make sense to use "from".
I agree with you when you say that there were no friday prayers. Alhamdulillah.
And I think you recently stated in your livestream that "يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوٓا۟" applied also for us.
"من" is well understood by grammarians to mean "after" or "instead", sometimes. Surah Quraysh is a typical example doing that. Just because you have not seen it does not mean that our interpretation is wrong.
Min also means from. Call to prayer from the day of jumaah makes perfect sense. It is in sync with the traditional Friday prayers.
The traditional practice should be based on the sunnah of Muhammad pbuh.
Do you have a hadith of the actual Khutbah in salatl jumuah?
We explained this in the video. Just watch it.
According to the traditional (erroneous) interpretation of this Aya, the "min" would be extraneous... And thus their interpretation is wrong!
Alhumdullilah 🥲 words of appreciation don’t do you Justice.
I read by accident part 17 Ayat 44 .once heard that earth might be interpreted as shallow text interpretation in ur video then suddenly I was blown away by reading this very small verse. It made me more questions than answer and I am not expert but curious more. I suddenly thought about a future population that have been successful to age to over 100 and then almighty come? Don't know how but the purpose is to reduce or eliminate shallow meaning.....🤔 any other feedback?😮
Great info !
Salaamun Alaykum
Alhamdulillah
I love Ya Dr Hany! Not once did I have a doubt in all you saying because you bring proof from the Quraan and use only that as the source to confirm and verify.
You have enlightened the deen in me and made the Quraan a light and do give it it's due revenue. I have been following and watching all videos and still eager to learn more. May Allah Be with you every second and make all your ways easy and give you abundant Blessings. Amin ❤🙂 #AGambianFinnishFan
Alhamdulillah
WHEN IS JUMU'AH?
The anounce is made the night before:
62:9 -- ...when the announcement is made of the day of [(min) not on the day but of the day] the Jumu'ah salat.
Jumu'ah is neither an appointment for a sermon nor a weekly appointment, is a monthly appointment for a congregational salat on the day after the new moon has been seen, on the Ghuduwi salat (69:10- disperse after the salat and seek Allah's bounty. So the day is still young to go back to business) or what the sunni call duha or the salat of sunrise (technically when the sun is high enough for one to cast a shadow, 13:15) :
2:189 --- they ask you about the new moons, say:"they are appointments for gathering of the people (jumu'ah) and for hajj (Arafat)."
Plus, the week doesn't exist in the Qur'an. The week is a jew thing copied from babylon for the lunar calendar.
Allah made an exception for them on the seventh day (16:124); for us the muslims the Sabbath is every night to rest and worship Allah (SWA):
Rest: 25:47/78:9-11.
Worship: 73:20/76:26.
I came upon channel that tells that solat Jumaat prayer was started in 6xx AD during Malik Marwan time, after seeing the Orthodox Christians have their gatherings on the first Friday of every month.
Now I am confused. Help me.
The traditional quirks by the Mullas hv played havoc with the discipline of innocent populace in general and progressive peace loving pakhtuns in particular. I recall iconic nonviolent protagonist Bacha khan and poet philosopher Ghani khan used to enlighten common man on nefarious designs of such information but were proclaimed as wayfarers by conformists. Thank you v much sir for spreading truth and I pray militancy hit pakhtuns find peace . Regards
Salamun Alaikum Dr Hany. Alhamdulillah.
Alhamdulillahh!
What a relief!
Thank you Dr Hany
I pray Allahh continue to increase you in ilm for providing us with water after long time of drought.
Salaamun Alaykum!
Barak Allah 🤲
I agree with Dr Hani in totality.
On the same subject, I asked the same to several local sheikhs or scholars and the answer becomes null and void.
I told them that if Jum’ a prayer prayer was obligatory then why not pray four than two Raka’s . If it’s obligatory then why not pray four Raka’s as noon or Dhuhr prayers.
No body has an answer for this update.
No one can produce an evidence when were we are told not to pray four but two on Jum’a or Friday prayer .
Friday has only 2 rakaa because it has 2 part of khutbah. So 2 + 2 = 4. Which is the same rakaa in zhuhur prayer. This mean the 2 rakaa of the zhuhur's is replace with 2 parts of the khutbah.
@@yulakasim4591
Can you back yourself with authentic Hadith .
Who told you 2+2 makes up dhuhr prayers for Friday.
Our prayers are built on the foundation that dhuhr is 4, Asir 4, Maghreb 3, isha 4, Fajr 2. These are the formats of our prayers. However, can you confirm that the Allah messenger has changed this pattern during his lifetime.
You cannot come up with a figure without collaborating evidences.
Beautiful!
Alhamdulillah thanks Dr. Hany, by the way missing the long 2.5 to 3 hrs videos..
Wat about sura 2 ajet 183 the same amenu its menshen
Alhamdulillah, thank you Mr. Hany for your presentation. 👍
OMG
Thank you Dr
You responded my question.
for way imam Malik did not attend the Friday pray in the last 25 years of his life
ALHAMDULILLAH.
Salaamun alaikum
Can someone clarify about 5 daily prayers?
Alhamdulillah. Idhaa zulzilat Ardhu zilzaalaha.
Salaamun Alaikum, Alhamdulillah
Salaamun 3alaykum.
Thank you for reminding us!
Brilliant explanation!
Following traditional religion is like buying a store cake mix - you're following someone else's recipe, but hoping it turns out as good as theirs.
BUT using Organic Quranic Methodlogy is like being a master chef - you trust your own instincts and create truly unique connection with Allahh
Alhudulillah!
جزاك الله خيرا Dr Hany for the great work, looking forward to see more and more
irrefutable evidences from the Quran:)
If i may ask, i have a question about the ayah (O you who believed) so you are saying that Amenu is the past tense. But how should we understand surat al Asr then? After the verse:” Verily Man is in loss” except those who (believed?) and (did good works?) so not those who believes right now and do good works right now? It confuses me.
بارك الله فيك
@E S
The aya includes allazeena aamanoo but continues with 3 more conditions: Those who toil in accordance with the divine lexicon, and then remind each other about the truth and about being patient.
Those who do this become Mu'minoon (believers)
Regards
From ayat 62:9 - 10 it's clear that salat for us in Qur'an is not the ritual prayer we do five times a day but "engaging the zikir of Allah" i.e. Learning the Qur'an. A shocking truth but makes sense.
My question for is, did prophet perform.ritual prayer Or Not??
Don’t listen to this, shaytaan wants us to stop making salah. Of course the Prophet saws prayed and showed us how to pray! Don’t be deceived. Most of these comments are non Muslims trying to deceive muslimeen.
@@AFAMFUN good we & we are alart
Salamun alaikum Dr Hany, I just realized that 'subatan' in ayat 25:47 and 78:9 does not mean 'rest'. Thank you for pointing this out among a lot more other hidden messages that you've uncovered in this channel.
Salamun alaykum, Alhamdulillah so is there any daily fard salah or not?
alhamdulillah
Salamun Alaikum!!!
Salaam,
I came across regarding the word “ O you who have believed “ .. Surah Al Maidah ayat 2 . Clearly talks to people of Makkah . Who already enter Islam .. believed in Allah and messenger Muhammad SAW. This in relation to your explanation of Surah Jummah regarding the word believed !