Hamid Ansari-Secularism Critical for India; I’m Worried About Our Future; Muslims Hurt by Prejudice
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 08. 2022
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
#karanthapar #hamidansari #interview #75yearsofindependence
Note: We have made a mistake in writing the name of former Vice President Hamid Ansari.
In an interview where he speaks his mind without recourse to euphemism, India’s former Vice President has said secularism is critical to the integrity of the country and its steady weakening is endangering India’s future. Mr. Hamid Ansari has also said India’s 15% muslim population is hurt by the prejudice they face and feel they are being ill-treated. He says he is worried about India’s future but he hopes that things will change.
Join The Wire's CZcams Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Karan, You are interviewing him or discussing with him 😂😂? Where are your hard questions and counter questions which you put to your guests who are opposed to your point of view?
I agree with you.
Karan is obnoxious
Those people you mentioned don't want to give interview to him.🤣🤣
@@yam2050 yes we don’t want to talk such Hippocrates with secular drama face
@@yam2050 those who are proud of their nation.
Secularism for Hamid Ansari means ‘I WILL EAT MY CAKE AND HAVE IT TOO”
Whats ur point?
@@ZakirHussain-oz9suread quran 5:33
9:25
That's fine, but please do ask all Indian Muslim politicians one question- "What steps did they take to give worldly education to their community, and how come the second largest community in the country is still in a miserable condition, even after more than 70 years of freedom?"
Most of them have been miserably failing to do anything constructive as far as the upliftment (worldly progress) is concerned.
Wake up, accept the reality, show love for this world, equip your kids with worldly education, get emerged in the society you're a member of and contribute to the growth and development of the nation, the society and yourself.
sad to see such personalities talking like this after getting that much. he has the blame not to clear bills in parliament for no valid reason.
Classic Hindutva of tactics of blaming the victims? What has YOUR community done to diseminate "wordly education"? You have disenfranchised, exploited, subverted, and replaced science, reason and secular rationality with jingoism, and supernatural claims to exceptionalism. Who are you to decide if they are in a miserable condition? How many muslims do you hear lynching other people because they are from a different caste? "Wordly education" is not a concept that any serious academic ever discusses, at least none that I have heard through ten years at various graduate schools across three continents. Pick up a book by an actual academic -- Noam Chomsky, Amartya Sen, Irfan Habib -- and then come back with some actual, verifiable arguments that show awareness of the basic principles of political economy.
90% Indian Muslims r RADICALISED. Hijab, burkha, halala, j!had and kaf!r used by M is danger to world.
MOST oppose UCC and want 4 wives even in 2022. Most want to live in HADITH rule
@@jaysahup6563 Apne bilkul hi sahi bola.
Earlier centuries ago Muslims were also Hindus mostly from lower castes. They were mistreated by upper caste Hindus. That's why they took up Islam. Some Hindu Rajas were also converted into Islam. By giving proper education and healthcare country will progress. Fertility rate is same Hindus and Muslims in UP and Bihar .
If enemies are in worries then believe me King is doing something good. Chanakya.
Exactly 👍
Islam will take over India and you either be a Muslim or pay jizziya
So according to you Muslims are enemies
Yes yes
Secularism ...
It gives a perfect cover ..
Till one day ..
Everything is open ...
These people of a particular religion do use it but not tge people of other religion.
@@TheMalllu Exactly 👍
Even the name of Hindu is given to your Religion by Arabs and British. Before that you never had a name for your Animist, superstitious and Brainless Religion where you used to push your women folk in the funeral pyre of their dead husband and burn them alive. Such an evil religion is yours. That's why many Hindu women are converting to Islam and Christianity.
Yes yes it is better than the saffron country with no employment.
@@nvaravind5394
Yes ..
All unemployed say that ...
More than 15 minutes of this debate was too much for me. He did not provide ANY specific examples in response to any question. As opposed to intelligence, such people should be grateful to India for rewarding their type.
Blame it on English...15 minutes...KT is not for everyone...
You using the phrase "their type" is in itself an example of what he is saying.
@@ateeqshahid5712 "Their type" is a very good reference for such types of people. These are nothing but propagandists who run an islamic agenda behind the covers of democracy. These people should be exposed for what they are - Hate mongering islamists.
Yeh apne Mukhtar Ansari ko samjha leta pehle , jo govt ke sheh se crime karta raha aur bachta raha , yahi log hindi belt mein rehne wale sabse jayada pakistan banana chahte the par phir pakistan kyun nahi gye
@@asmirann3636 I am confident that the "Propagandists" will face the same resistance from the Civil society and Citizens of Indian for running their "Islamic Agenda" that the BJP is facing for its Hindutva.
The only thing that is from Ladak to Kanyakumari is the Dharmic Civilization! Invaders tried to corrupt it but failed but they succeeded elsewhere! The one from Kanyakumari knows and travels to Ketaranath for his Dharma and the Kashmiri Pundit travels to Rameswaram for the same reason! They may speak many different languages but they had Sanskrit to communicate, the language that was deracinated by the invaders! What is prevailing is a civilizational conflict of survival by the natives over the imported and foreign and their complicit! It is bound to lead to conflict of ideology on account of it and it is a fight worth fighting for! This is the last standing native civilization on the planet that was the civilizational leader before colonizers subjugated them.
Is the discussion about Muslim or minorities... ? if it is abt minorities, then why other minority segments other than Muslim is not part of the discussion.....
Good question.👍
Muslims are second majority and inching closer year after year
@@bw8026 👍
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 The discussion is about India. If it is about India thenWhyDoWeNeedToHaveTheaRSSeBhhdddwaaadaariGbrrrrMtrrrrChhhhddddzzzzzAskingQuestions??😂🤣😂😂
As we can clearly feel and see all other minorities have been performing much better due to their excellent leadership and modern thinking
There was no prejudice when he served for Vice President two terms . It was a privilege and many like him get and have got privileges since 1947. The more you do for them the more they demand.
True
You're not doing any favours to them.
@@shrutichaturvedi2410 not favours. It is called saanp palana in hindi
Because he was a VICE PRESIDENT their was most definitely prejudice against him when he was in the bottom of the ladder.
@@shrutichaturvedi2410 I am not supporting anyone but as long as we follow our Constitution it's WE THE PEOPLE..
The hospital I work with has muslim doctors and lower staff, haven't seen discrimination of any sort.
I believe in secularism and don't get provoked by any wings' agenda.
But i haven't forgotten Moplah genocide of hindus, noakhali, Kerala , kashmir massacre by Muslims. Seriously, the great culcutta killings shook the very secular Mr. Ambedkar, he wrote that the genocide of hindus was undescribable in Kerala, culcutta in his book: Pakistan Or india's division. Don't forget that yes khilafat's radical Muslims' blind support by Gandhi, congress at that time was described pathetic by Anne basent in her book, too.
@@PalShivkumar Apne bilkul hi sahi bola.
@@PalShivkumar true. pani sar se upar ja chuka hai
This guy Thapar put words in the mouth of the interviewee.
shame on journalism, see his past interview with modi. now modi is out of his aukaat.
@@jaysahup6563 Karan Thapar is communist propogandist
Jai Lalita nai he iski baand Baja di thi
Jo khud fake news fake propoganda fhalata h wo dusro ko Gyan de rhai h
The wire ka record h fake news fhalana
Achi patrakarita
Aacha mazak kerta ho bahi
Tabhi na 2 bhk se bhar nahi nikalti h madam
Good joke
Leftists Islaamist communist propoganda media outlets journalist is not real journalism
Just because it's suit ur narrative it's doesn't mean it's true
What about Hindu moblyunching and anti hindu riots blasphemy against hindu god
Which have been supported by this blasphemy
What about pashmanda muslim
Dalti hindu target by Islaamist
U the wire as white washed many dalti riots by Islaamist just because it's doesn't suit their Islaamist communist agenda
Hypocriste
@@shamshararajput4205 i know if pfi only talks to ndtv, bbc and wire, that says all !
It's called staged interview, a propaganda
@@jaysahup6563 Bilkul sahi
The question we, Indians should ask ourselves is do we deserve this beautiful, dynamic, well-prepared constitution ?
The answer from me would be a comprehensive no. But that doesn't mean we don't need it. We need it but we don't even know we need it- that's the irony. Once we realise we need it we'll start fighting for what the constitution stands because the constitution stands for one and everyone.
He should become secular and start a movement to instill secular values in his fellow religionists
He can advise bangaladesh and Pakistan to become secular
But does islam allow secular values
Yes actually it does allow secular values.
@@Awk_potats 😂
@@Awk_potats how much Jizya? How much for $€ x $Iave®y
The problem is two-fold:
1. Many Indian Muslims still live in the zamindari hangover. They aren't skilled and capable enough to do a good job and they consider themselves too much better for the lowly jobs. The reason behind the fact that a large chunk of Muslim population still remains unskilled can be discussed.
2. Muslims are expected to be loyal to the constitution but the majority community has very cleverly converted loyalty towards their religion equivalent to loyalty towards the constitution. We are often faced with the question asking us to choose between our religion and the constitution. This question in itself is foolish. But how come never ever has anyone from the majority community been asked this question? Inspite of the fact that many leaders of the ruling BJP can openly spew venom against Muslims and call them outsiders and yet get the votes clearly explains the fact how muchwho is loyal towards the constitution.
There will not be a smoke without fire ...
That constitution is a fraud on the Hindu. It will be changed shortly.
Sir, ur interviews with prominent people, gives opportunities to learn more, of a wideer and indepeth land, of our sub -- continent.
sir , I'm surprised when I compare karan Thapar of 30 years ago & karan Thapar of today. (in the meantime I was so busy trying to understand this mysterious world both scientifically & philosophically). Today's karan Thapar compares very badly with the Thapur of old .
It's a fact that the majority of Indian Muslims in British India supported partition. They stayed and we still embraced them. We still do. But this victimhood of "we feel prejudiced" is awful, especially from a man of privilege like Ansari.
This man talks like this only. He wants everything on this earth for him.
Apne bilkul hi sahi bola.👍
@@raveetr8730 This is common mentality of the peaceful community.
So off from reality... keyboard bigotry warrior lol learn your geography smh😆
What stupid logic.. criticism should originate from privilege as the underprivileged would be busy surviving
Thanks Karanji, excellent interview. Very knowledgeable, the present truth of parliament is noticeable.
Chutiye interview nahi jugalbandi hain.
Questions asked 00.00.00
He remembered 2002 but not 1990s kashmir genocide kudooooss to Indian secularism
How is secularism in consonance with umma and khilafat?
Exactly 👍
how is secularism in consonance of sanghis and lunduvta followers like you?
How can a Muslim be Secular when their allegiance is to ummah
@@varunsriniwasan6561 Exactly 👍
😂🤣The consonance is thousand times more than withTheaRSSeBhhdddwaaadaariHndtvChhhdddzzzzAttnnnkkwaaad🤣😂🤣
Constitution never jelled with us for the reason because our history shows that majority is backward so far as pure Scientific temper is concerned. Plural society cannot be united without education to the effect that religion is rather personal affair and its values are not meant to be amplified as universal. Pinde Pinde Matirbhimnaah Munde kunde Nvam Payah ………..This first Line of a subhashit is an example of Scientific temper of Hindus far back when western science had arrived but we never followed it in a organised manner. We failed to realise as a nation that our polity should cater to needs of all rather than that of majority for the simple reason the majority itself is divided. Politicians have invented Hindutva as an ideology which never existed at ground level.Perhaps it rested on the lack of political icon for the Hindus in near past . But Muslims had several ikons. The only way was to sully their images in the eyes of Hindu majority. It was like breaking the idols which was the way of the victor in past regimes against the defeated.Murtibhanjak of past are now Hindus who took pleasure in destroying a dilapidated structure called Babri Masjid. It is interesting to note that the structure was not destroyed even when the Moghul power declined and Maratha power ruled up to Delhi. Ram mandir shall become a national monument with false glamour feeding the majority that true Ramrajya had arrived.
Mr Vice President has been trying to maintain a balance but Mr Thapar constantly putting his word in to Mr Ansari's mouth. He even was forcing Mr Ansari to reach a conclusion which he was not necessarily in agreement. This is not the first time. It is Mr Thapar's misciviousness.
Karan Thaparsir isa Mirror of Journalism and CHANAKYA Of Patrakarita
@@meharbansingh5544 You may think so but I don't agree with you.
@@meharbansingh5544 your chanakya is doing job in a sasta CZcams channel ,this is the actual worth of this vampanthi shit
Sir I am looking forward to view an interview a great nationalist Indian Who speaks for India,works for India,think of India, greatness of India and all of good of India.my expectations prove otherwise with every interview passed away
We Indians unfortunately had this pro pakistan man as vice President of India..
Today in Hindu india resides the second largest Muslim population of the world.like it or not the two communities have to live together.Peacefull coexistence is the only sane optoin
Well said. This can not be altered. Good Muslim's should help build harmony
@@raveetr8730
why only good Muslim and why not good Hindu too
If Musalman want to peaceful co-existence they should not only return all those properties originally belonging to Hindus but forcefully acquired by Musalmans in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Kashmir but also agreed to give Hindus special privileges as discriminated community .
@@indianfirst5169 Because Hindus already proved their goodness many times. Now Musalman should say that what they did for peaceful co-existence .
Co existence Is impossible Mr Seth. You should have realised by now….
There is time to debate but are not willing to debate.
Hindu is born secular.a Hindu is free to choose any god or be spiritual and find god by him self.no body is required to impose upon us which is deep rooted in other religions.we have largest democracy in the world so let us not allow one community to take advantage for wrong deeds. This is the high time and respect the people s mandate.let us all live peacefully.
A magnificient presentation of Secularism and how it ought to be manifested in terms of Implementation of Policies . It is relevant not only to India but also all Democracies which has Secularism as the Basis of Governance in the Constitution. Thank You Mr. Karan Tharpar and His Exellency the Former President of India.
The intelligent Host throws the Right questions and where the Guest , His Excellency erudites the following:
How "Hindutva" plays itself in its implementation - esp. in the erosion of the very Principles laid out [ in resepect of ] "Fraternity" as spelt out in the Constitution. What is the Rule of Law. What are Rights spelt out in the Constitution . How manifestation of Prejudice of the Minorities present itself. And lastly, and more prominantly how Majoritarianism based on religion, language and social class asserts itself in reality.
66
2022 is a different India to him. He calls 1947 a different world. There was a minority communalism problem they which led to Hindu majorityism now.
Exactly. 👍
Minority communalism? How?
@@Dendronish Heard of Pakistan?
@@Mjjjyyy Yeah. I have heard of Pakistan. This is the state created out of fear of majority communalism.
@@Dendronish If you are Pakistani, you can pursue your nationalism. I am nobody who can help. If you are Indian, just think about it a million people die just because of some people saying "Hum alag hai aur Hinduon ke saath nahi reh sakte".
Dosti bane rahe😁
Thappar sir dosti kaisi rahi🤣?? Ab bhi bani hui ya toot gai?? 😔
This guy a sleeper cell member of ISI was Vice President of India. We should be careful what kind of people are being given what kind of positions. Never it should happen again.
Exactly.👍
Karan Thapar and Hamid Ansari:
Repeated open and diabolical mass chanting of one community against another “Sar Tan se Juda” chanting and then committing that declared crime against innocent people: was NOT “a war” against India ( itself ) ?
Mr Ansari himself went against India ( during his tenure in Iran ) communication picked up my Mosad of Israel 🇮🇱. He is lucky that BJP Govt has not thrown him into life long prison for treason against India 🇮🇳.
He does not know hindutva lol , lies , gave no example whenever asked , said in 1947 people were not that divided but somehow pakistan came into existence and people asking for it were ???? The thing is in 1947 they were having it easy in comparison to today that why he liked that era better, why don’t he go ask Muktar Ansari to stop his crimes stop giving him patronage . These types of people resulted in formation of pakistan but didn’t leave when the time came because it’s tough to leave behind the property.
Exactly 👍
EXCELLENT INTERVIEW . SALUTE TO THE EX VICE PRESIDENT OF INDIA FOR SPEAKING OUT HONESTLY & FRANKLY . INDIA HAS DIVIDED DUE TO CASTE & RELIGION
Election Time , Politician Time .
Power is everything,values and principles does not matter much in India.Targeting opponents is bread and butter in today’s society.We Indians needs to step up the game and change our mentality in order to bring change in our country.
I always enjoy this program.
Because it is pro Muslim channel. Anti Hindu is always liked by muslims
Problem lies in ourselves, as a nation we have ignored the English education in our personal life, Liberty, fraternity and democracy is a western or a European ideology, if we have to remain integrated we have to follow and learn the western ideology of democracy. Otherwise we will call ourselves northindian,southindian, northeastern and so on.
Chal ticket book kar
Then can you acknowledge us the ideology better than liberty, fraternity and democracy...
You are a worried man, you are a worried man...alag hi level hain..
He is like those women who spoke about me too years after building a successful career. Speak only when you get cozy.
Mr. Thapar's attempt to twist and sensationalize the responses =0
Mr. Ansari's informed, intelligent, cogent, precise yet safe responses = 1
Mr. Karan Thapar you are one of the best few existing journalists in India.
You are joking.........right???🤣🤣🤣🤣
He is being asked easy and comfortable questions
I enjoy listening to Karanji of today.Mild voice, polite and intellectual.Choose your guests , please dont bring antinationals
Secularism allows the people of various religions live peacefully without any fear. Unity and secularism will be the motto of the Government, we can't afford divisive polity in India, As far as the public is concerned, India is Amazingly secular
Secularism is dead in 57 muslim countries. How ?
@@prasun2024 sorry ..they cnt say anything about them🤔
@@prasun2024 because Secularism is a F word for Islam
@@bw8026 Well said.👍
Pl get securalism practiced in any of the 57 islaaaamic pigsty.
Pro ISI
Exactly. 👍
@@krishanuadityapandey4414
Lage raho sanghi chadhi chintu IT cell ka dalla
See the difference !
In the interview with KT Modi confessed to be passimistic, wheras, Hamid Ansari is still an optimistic !
Hello karan.. Its no surprise that you are not in mainstream media.. Those days of setting narratives against national interest is past now... You.. Shekar.. Barka are all bygones now..you dont even have a bjp spokesperson to discuss about the future... U r still in history with this old man..
Exactly 👍
i am not able to comprehend that so much time is spent discussing muslims
The genesis of the indian problem is exploitation of Indians through the caste system
No , not at all.
Genesis of all most all problems in present India is only because of exploitation of Hindus by Muslims and Congress .
It's the BJP/RSS all the time talking about muslims. They are the one all the time focusing on muslims and creating problems.
They are not worried about the country and it's well being. It's all the time Hindu/ muslim debates on TV since 2014.
Bro, every program has a topic of discussion, you should watch other programs if you want to watch on cast exploitation, there are many by the way. Don’t mix things.
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 Hello Pandit Pandey jee ......do not get offended with title i use, we both know that it is a title of entitlement not some great learning. 3 % of this entitled population is enjoying 75 % of national resources. Look at the list SC Judges you will understand better ..here not referring to other area. That is why a caste census is absolutely necessary.
Let us see how long this communal card will hold the aspirations of the 75 % of the population. Check again now not many sarpanch we can call pandit surpanch ......
@@redmoad955 these are my critical view after watching a program........i know somehow you prefer that the focus remains communal.....
Great intellectual interview.
Karan Thapar is communist propogandist
Jai Lalita nai he iski baand Baja di thi
Jo khud fake news fake propoganda fhalata h wo dusro ko Gyan de rhai h
The wire ka record h fake news fhalana
Achi patrakarita
Aacha mazak kerta ho bahi
Tabhi na 2 bhk se bhar nahi nikalti h madam
Good joke
Leftists Islaamist communist propoganda media outlets journalist is not real journalism
Just because it's suit ur narrative it's doesn't mean it's true
What about Hindu moblyunching and anti hindu riots blasphemy against hindu god
Which have been supported by this blasphemy
What about pashmanda muslim
Dalti hindu target by Islaamist
U the wire as white washed many dalti riots by Islaamist just because it's doesn't suit their Islaamist communist agenda
Hypocriste
Secularism is never critical for Muslim majority societies. For Muslims only Sharia is critical!
Madrasse me pade ga to ye hi intellectuals lage ge .
arabon ka gulam
Hindu is the term developed by some miscreants, the actual word is Hindi in which everyone bindes either he be a Muslim Sikh or Christian he is hindi not hindu..
Karan must ask the right question to whoever wants India to be secular.
Same interview can be trace in 1930s. One religion is always insecure. As Hasan Nissar says traitors are exclusive to subcontinent Muslims.
Yes traitor to their own community, but faithful to others
@@syedusaidhasan As Mohandas Karmachand Gandhi
@@jagdishkumar-hg8og Exactly. These are only technics for islamisetion of India.
They are not happy until they get jannat. That is the carrot what is shown to them in 6th century
@@bw8026 Exactly. 👍
Ridiculous attempt for trying to portray India as intolerant.
You are asking a person about secularism who is involved in religious fanatism - was involved in sabotaging RAW while he was ambassador to Iran and again calling specially a Pakistani journalist to address a seminar on Terrorism, in both cases he prefered religion over nation.
You are joking Karan Thapar.
Apne bilkul hi sahi bola.👍
Jha u do have little knowledge about the personality in question.
@@NurulIslam-kc2jl Keep your Sky-fall knowledge with you . We have no need of your Sky-fall knowledge.
Thapar Sir great YOU are but I subscribe to your show since I am an outsider to your show
Huge respect for A.P.J ABDUL KALAM
Ansariji is a THOROUGH GENTLEMAN!
Thanks 🙏
Huhh WTF
He want sariya Court in india
And he talk about constitution
How samefull is it
Iran me is gaddar ne raw agents ko pakadwaya tha
And a thorough @nti national
@@mrworldwide1119 This is the real truth about the peaceful community.
Great..
Karan, why don't you get Modi on the interview?
Because Modi speak the truth.
Forthright & outspoken, Yes. Not rude & overbearing.
gaddar, aman chopra ka interview chord kar bhag gaya tha...traitor
ahsaan faramoosh. complains after getting so much.
Exactly 👍
Aman Chopra ko gaddar kyu bol rahe ho...nafrati chintu bolo
@@sudeepmenon17 Gaddar to Hamid Ansari hai .
@@krishanuadityapandey4414
Mera 🤞yeh le le
Beautiful analysis of existing realty in India of different religious groups. Thank you.
Hamid Ansari,
Is desh ki 6aand ki bimaari.
Kide waali.
Everything what is said here very well be true but real question what is the root cause of it. Just telling the result is not called analysis but finding the root cause is important.
57 muslim countries - secularism dead. Why?.
Good question.👍
If secular is not fit for him,what than ISLAMISATION. HE remained 2nd head of country,what fear he has now.
A great interview by a great journalist and answers by a great nationalist bureucrat and former VP of our country and his views about so.many dofferent aspect of our polity and governance is really of political and judicial wisdom. hats off to both of you amy Allah bless with his bounties and hpnours which yoy deserve .Ameen
great interview skills 👍
I thought I am listening to Ex- VP of India.
For larger part I mistook him as EX - VP of our most peaceful, secular, developed and human right champion country PAKISTAN.🙄
Apne bahut badhiya bola.👍
From Pakistan 😂
Disgusting ,why these media channels are so polarized .Muslim , muslim everywhere .I am fed up of it
because minority haters are ruling now
because they're paid for it, simple
@@arindamkoner854 Exactly 👍
Those channels are created and funded only for spreading anti-hindu and anti-India propaganda.
You are right..because they dont have anything else to discuss like Employment/Progress etc..they purely living on this issue only.
आप लोगो ने कभी judge लोया पे एखादी documentary क्यू नही बनायि
डरपोक हो आप
Worried and to be worried are not only minority but majority dalits and every weaker sections of the society! But scenario will soon change that's the nature of this great nation, jai hind 🇮🇳
i am a dalit and have no problem with my religion but i am afraid of terrorism.
Let democracy survive.
When your mind is full of assumptions, conclusions, and beliefs, it has no penetration. It just repeats past impression.
Deradicalise Muslim population.
Most are radicalised
Block veins and mind have no place. For penetration..
👏
Secularism is never critical for Muslim majority societies. For Muslims only Sharia is critical!
@@1008apocalypse1008 Kaum is eternal for them. Burkha, hijab, hal@la, kufra, jih@d will keep them backwards. Who cares?
You work on an agenda and you are with the right person who enjoyed the benefits of office and many of his actions are worth investigation on national security angle.
Exactly
Secularism allow people to respect each other religion. But mulla don't allow to sing a bhazan by singer .
Exactly 👍
Thanks
In coming time when will be written
History
The wire will In Written in Golden
🤣
@@AbhinayJain90 Haha Ghanta
@@drake71000
Rotey haho aur burnol lagao IT cell ka sanghi troll with a Christian name this usual
@@drake71000 👍
Not golden. Yellowish brown 💩
Wow, Karan! You asked "did that happen in the last 8 years?" so many times, and Ansari only had to nod. What an interview!
Ansari accuses the majority (Hindu) population of being unfair to Muslims. But we can put up a counterargument that it's the Muslims who are othering Hindus! How many Hindu MLAs and MPs get elected from Muslim pockets? Why are Muslims _officially_ barred from greeting Hindus on their festivals, or eating prasad/sweets? Why are there so many incidents of stone-pelting and arson after Friday prayers? Why do Muslims insist on disrupting life by blocking public spaces for _namaz_ (blocking of public roads, malls, railway stations, etc)?
And worst of all, why are there horrific incidents of throat-slitting by Muslims, which is celebrated by many other Muslims?
Can you blame Hindus for being traumatized by this??
Islamophobia is just like the fear of shark attacks. Both fears are emotional trauma caused by *availability bias,* which is inbuilt in humans. These fears are developed because of real-life gory incidents.
You cannot blame a victim for being traumatized! You cannot drive away the fear by pointing out that such incidents are rare, and we are unlikely to encounter them in our own life.
Therefore, we have to accept Islamophobia as a ground reality. The onus of eliminating Islamophobia lies with the Muslim leaders and clergy, who must work hard to create a very kind image of Muslims.
As regards LS/RS being dysfunctional, I would submit that it is ridiculous to put 250/545 people under one roof to have any meaningful discussion among them. The debate must be designed to address each point separately, and it would take a lot of to-and-fro discussion to settle each point.
But the current practice is to take turns to give winding speeches! That method cannot find a solution for each objectionable point in a bill. In fact, the TV footage of LS/RS clearly shows that the MPs only waste time by jeering and heckling while someone is giving a speech.
Thus, the LS/RS process was never good, right from the beginning!
The solution is to use modern technology, and carry out all debating online. During COVID times, many people worked from home, and their productivity actually increased. Likewise, the MPs also can be effective without attending the LS/RS sessions!
There are many effective online tools such as Debategraph, Kiallo, Arguman, etc., which can be used by all MPs. Let the public see the entire debate graph! The most critical advantage is that every individual MP can raise any number of points, all of which must be rebutted; and no point can be ignored.
That means even a tiny opposition is reassured that their objections would have to be fairly dealt with. The bills cannot be pushed through with a brute majority or with rhetorical speeches.
There won't be any demonstrations, disruptions or walk-outs!
Any people that suppress and hurt their minorities ….,are immoral as a society …., that is the bottom line …it shld make any decent person squirm …
@@sehbakhan1814 This is a generic statement, with no examples.
What rights are being denied, and how? There are many much smaller minorities (Christians, Sikhs, Parsis, Jains, Buddhists, etc.) How come the largest minority is always complaining, but not the others?
@@nagesharas5136 see how much u have to validate and defend …?! My statement is just that and it stands as just that … a majority that ill treats its minorities has no moral ground and shld be ashamed .., not just in india , everywhere in the world …
@@sehbakhan1814 Your statement is universally valid. So how is that relevant here?
If anyone wants to argue that Hindus are treating Muslims unfairly, then such arguments must be done with facts. Also, the counterarguments I raised must also be answered. It cannot be just a one-sided barrage of unsubstantiated accusations.
Just wow! Can't get better than this 😊🙏
I love the discussion and there should be more of these so that the people get sensitised to these issues.
FYI ..there are minorities like parsis, buddhist, jains, sikhs do exist in india apart from 2 majorities .. when will talk start for those ?
ya muslim-muslim .. hindu muslim he chalta rahega !
@@jaysahup6563 Exactly 👍
😂😂😂 hi I can't stop laugh
I also
Muslim enblock must support the INC to get rid of communal agenda of BJP/RSS.
And Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains should vote for BJP!! Good suggestion!!
@@emrao7732 Exactly 👍
This is one programme that I look forward to.
best combination of antinationals on one platform.
Thanks wire mattear
Well spoken Hamid 👌 And thanks for another brilliant session, Karan 🙏
Secularism is critical to India, until it is declared an Islamic state.
Apne bahut achchha bola 👍
@@krishanuadityapandey4414
Sabhi jagah same thumb and likes a single jija both are from IT cell and they're paid Sanghi chadhi chintu
Tripathi ji please call all your relatives and friends working in gulf, Indonesia, Malaysia and all other countries and drawing huge amounts then you vomit your venom
@@indianfirst5169 They will come back when your relatives from Middle East invite you to stay there.
@@indianfirst5169 Mirchi lagi kya ?
Ja ke barnol laga le .
Excellent discussion.
Secular idot spotted ...
Karan should asked him his act of blown cover of R&AW officials in Iran.
There is no such order to Karan from Pakistan.
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 It isn’t true that he is working payroll of pak.
But karan is like other left liberal who think promoting people like Hamid Ansari with beneficial for India.
Haz subsidy, Personal laws, Madrasha education system are the greatest deviations from secularism in India .
RSS, mob lynching, raping and all are the basic education for other community
Haj subsidy or amaranth Yatra...should govt invest is debatable I agree...personal laws a touchy section for all religions, India should have had more and more education for the masses regarding these ....madrassa education is like having some Hindu educational institution like a gurukul...but secularism is very important....which BJP and RSS has to learn...
secularism in india means pro muslim, in actuality should be politics separate from religion. so much appease for decades that they think it is normal.
@@sudeepmenon17 Hindus should be as tolerant as Musalmans . India should be as secular as Pakistan, Afghanistan and Saudi Arabia. Muslim should be treated in India as they treat with Hindus in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan.
@@sudeepmenon17 BJP-RSS is following true secularism. Congress was converting India to an islamic country in the name of secularism.
Good dialogue with good information... Thank you.... Sir
This ex VP got everything in his career. Wht contribution he gave to uplift the community first and then society. Muslim's lack credible leadership to take them on right path. Hence mostly mullas or ulemas provide leadership. In India they should not say khafir to other faith people. Words like Khafir , jihad spreading mistrust and fear among non muslims. This man says he don't know the meaning of Hinduism. Wht an arrogant answer he gives.
Exactly.👍
@@krishanuadityapandey4414
everywhere same thumb this the teaching of IT cell appointed more than 5 lakhs to spread venom
I am still finding tough question 🤦
Karan, you always and relentlessly discuss and rant on Muslims, secularism, and minority's rights. Have you ever discussed upon the Hindu psyche and insecurities. Muslims taken away 1/3 of this country with 23% Muslim population. Now they are again going to be 23%. So are the Indian Muslims have become more secular and liberal than they were in 1947?
I expect you to debate these issues with some competent personalities honestly.
These channels are created and funded only for hindufobic jehadi propaganda.
You mean someone from RSS...they will not appear here else have to ask for water glass.
Very true. He will not take such issues because it doesn't fit in his propaganda
@@bw8026 Exactly 👍
@@abdullahalfaruquemullick9048 You mean supporter of ISIS should be kicked to Middle East.
Prejudice what a joke:-😂 hindustan made all peace lovers Education minister, foreign minister, president, vice president, everything still but still victim of prejudice
You should apologise for situation of your sect
this traitor enjoyed his tenure and lo! on retirement complains
@@jaysahup6563 Exactly 👍
Absolutely not
@@jaysahup6563 u r a foolish and he is an intellectual.
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 "chor chor mausere bhai"
Very qualified discussion…Critical to we the people of the nation. We have given up our lives….blindly electing and not questioning the elected . We think the elected are our Mai-baap. This is not freedom ,this is like electing the jailor to control our homes…our children’s…our parents/wife/siblings/future… I.e.crumble our rights n freedom.
All ; specifically Muslim should OR must get educated . Study First social science and humanities and then whatever for their careers. Understanding society we live in is as important as we breathe oxygen , freely from environment. We have lost to cherish the sacrifices and freedom struggle. We and most of the lot of ruling people ( I don’t call them leaders) ,just want to propel themselves on the countries resources ( incl. corruption of money ; power; religious bigotry, manpower).. Too late!!!!? Not sure…!!? Can I commit ?Seems complacent ..no spine?!! Just words….!. It’s all easy to b blind n njoy, and let the future pay d price for being born on the earth.. :(
GOOD INTERVIEW WITH BOLD QUESTION, ANSWER
Han ch***, kaun sa question books laga retired politician se... Bold dekhna hai to Kerala ka Governor dekho
@@thevagabond85yt Kerala ka governor means
Wonder if this Hamid was a VP of India or only for muslims?
Exactly. This shows the level of ideological bankruptcy of Congress.
A Pakistani agent is saying about constitutional values of India !!!!
BJP IT cell spotted
@@justlove2126 exactly 😂
@@justlove2126 It is not Pakistan . BJP IT cell not only allowed in India but also BJP is the rulling party. Who don't like this they may go to Pakistan.
sangi is vomiting
@@sharuk98ala Jihadi, go to Pakistan.
Did you ever think of Indians who are minority in USA and many times victim of systematic discrimination. But we take this on our stride and work so hard that makes us the most educated community. If you are discriminated then work hard. Rather than asking alms from majority. खुदी को कर बुलंद इतना कि हर तक़दीर से पहले खुदा बंदे से ये पूछे बता तेरी रज़ा क्या है
Karan- can you ask this question.
Why must India be secular.
Muslim countries can be Muslim.
White man can be Christian. India is a Hindu rashtra. We are Dharmic . .