Nurse Mistaken For Intruder - $400,000 Case (Full Episode) | Personal Injury Court
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- Patch v Miller - In this episode of "Personal Injury Court," a nurse is injured while being mistaken for an intruder and sues for $40,000 in damages. With his no nonsense approach, Judge M. Gino Brogdon, Sr., presides over the courtroom.
#PersonalInjuryCourt #InjuryCourt
Nurse Mistaken For Intruder - $400,000 Case (Full Episode) | Personal Injury Court
• Nurse Mistaken For Int...
Season 1, Episode 57 - Zábava
So she trespasses and wants to sue him for defending his own home???
There have been crazy ridiculous cases like this, I recall one where the burglar (actual thief with intention to steal) broke into a house through the roof, fell through the ceiling and on top of the kitchen where a knife injured the thief. He (the burglar) sued the owner and won. Now that’s ridiculous.
Literally..
So you are sayomg if you had kids and you hear someone yelling "dad I'm home" your first thoight is let me get my gun
Exactly how does that make sense
@@daviddoyle982 that didn't actually happen that's a story from the movie liar liar with Jim Carrey almost word for word
Finally a fair ruling cause 99% does be extremely unfair !
Well, stop watching him! Go watch Judge Judy !
if he didnt rule in favor of the home owner i was gunna go crazy
He goes with the law and always explains why..
may be u should be a judge
I am pleasantly shocked that this judge actually made the right decision. His rulings are usually extremely unfair & tends to rule in favor of the complainant whether or not they are in the wrong.
I was shocked too.
I was very surprised as well.
From the beginning, after the lady’s first testimony, it was obvious that there was no case. I watched till the end just to know whether the judge was going to be fair. Today, he was fair.
😭😭
First time he’s ever made the right decision
These scenarios are getting more and more
Ridiculous. I need to unsubscribe.
I’ve been a nurse over 20 years so I HAVE been this exhausted. But to blame this man for coming into HIS home?!? Never. Take Accountability Ms Nurse
I'm going to guess you are not a nurse, people lie on CZcams
using a fire arm when a stranger comes through your back door at 4am does NOT make you a "trigger happy maniac"
Umm phasing lol
i work 80 to 96 hours a week and i have NEVER once confused my house for someone house and i was living in a HOA like them XD
Agree 100%. I have been a Critical Care RN for 30 years and have worked likely 1000+ 16 hr shifts with a total of 2 hours driving time. If you work a double you best be sharp or you have NO business taking care of patients risking their lives. Bite off more than you can chew, see what happens.
She's an adult! She's responsible. I like how she tried to get sympathy, because she's a nurse.
Nurse, shnurse. That's no excuse for invading some else's home.
@@steveb1164 Absolutely
She had zero accounbility🤡🤡🤡 Such a clown.
Honestly the plaintiff was delusional for trying to blame someone for their mistake. I’d do the same as him especially if I was a parent like him. No matter what the person looks like. Remember looks are deceiving and home invaders often use this.
No kidding hey! It is sooo true! Oh send you in and get him to set his gun down, so HE is vulnerable. Then….BOOM….SHE now isn’t who she appeared to be! Those stories happen more than you would think.
They are crazy for wanting to make money from this man
i dont understand how she feels she needs to be compensated for trespassing
The father firmly grabbing his heavily injured daughter by her fractured shoulder in an attempt to console her is just ✨tru family luv✨
I would've been upset if he was fined for what he did. He had the right to use his weapon to protect himself and others, as well as he exercised caution by not shooting her, but instead fired a warning shot. I don't think he could've been fined for those two things. The law can be unfair at times, but it's the law and that's just how it is. I'm saddened by her injuries, but I didn't think he was responsible for them, especially when he used caution to fire a warning shot instead of shooting her. 👏
Best judgement ever 👌 he has every right to protect himself and property. Glad he only gave a warning shot
It’s rather interesting how the plaintiff was giving the whole nine yards details of tired she was, her mission in saving life, how she’s scared for her life; yet, she’s conveniently left out the detail of her went into the wrong house which made her becoming the intruder. Her telling the story likes the defendant just out of the blue decided to harm her.
I'm addicted watching all these crazy things people went thru some of them I just laugh because it's funny I just love it love the judge the things he says
The judge actually got this one right.
The plaintiff’s father shouldn’t have been the licensed surgeon to analyze the injury. He added so much emotion to his analysis.
It's because he wasn't presented to the court as a "specialist" . So in the eyes of the court he was just presenting evidence on behalf of his daughter
She’s basically saying “I ram into the woods past a no trespassing sign, tripped on a stick and I’m suing the owner of the land because there was a stick in my path” she and her father bout to get heated at the HOA meeting😂
Worst sin ever
The first time I've seen him judge without sentiment and pitty caused by pain and suffering.
Very happy the judge made the correct decision here.
It’s funny because she keeps on talking about how it was pitch black in the room and how he did not turn a light on, and that he could have easily shot her in the head. But then she states “I’m a 6 foot red head, I can be seen easily”. Naturally woman are not 6 foot so if I saw her shadow, I would think it’s a male. Which brings up more concern also, considering it is pitch black so there’s no way we could’ve seen that. She’s a redhead and 6 foot. The woman is ridiculous with her statements.
Thanks for this amazing judgment
That “doctor” was incorrect when he said that her pins and plates will set off Airport metal detectors because I have pins and plates in my jaw and face because they’re made of titanium they do not set off Airport metal detectors. And that’s been since 2004! Plus, he’s awfully shaky for a practicing “MD“.
I wonder if these are all scripted actors.
I read another comment on another video that they are paid actors but the circumstances are real.
For just this show, yes, they’re all actors recreating real trials, but changing some details. All the evidence is scripted.
They are. The end credits of most episodes say they're all actors.
I had plates, screws, and wires in my forearm and they set off metal detectors at the airport. Since then a lot of the equipment has been removed, two maybe 3-4" plates and screws which still set off the metal detectors.
It's about time this judge made the right decision.
The title states this is a $400,000 case, but it’s actually $40,000.
i thought i was the only one who noticed
@@MTlife-or3wr yeah me too i thought i was the only one who noticed. apparently there are only 3 of us who noticed.
@@HarryMcKenzieTV 4*
Yep
you put too many zeros in the title..
If you were that exhausted maybe dad should’ve just picked you up. Anyway, you were just 10 mins away
Happy Father’s Day judge
She fell asleep in a strangers car. Her judgment is off all the way around. Sometimes your mistakes, are all yours.
It’s his house 😂
The father should have stood outside in the front waiting for his daughter as she was being dropped off
She is wrong
The right decision was made. He has every right to forget to lock his door and every right to defend his home and himself. The plaintiff doesn’t have any rights to lecture him about not locking his door. It’s her mistake and she should be accountable for that.
Castle doctrine my guy...I don't give no warning shots, because it'd be a waste of bullets
I have not finished this but no judge should allow people to lie like this .
This girl literally said that the popping of her ankle was louder than the gunshot.
She entered someone else's home illegally and then hurt herself leaving.
He should be suing her for pain and suffering.
I'm glad he made the right verdict lol
Who else is surprised he judged fairly this time
🙋🏽♀️🙋🏽♀️🙋🏽♀️
It's crazy how the nurse thinks that she's not at fault. She did commit a home invasion. Lol
This fool should have to pay this man just for being wrong and strong. She feels entitled because she is a nurse!!!!. You broke into the man's home. Who doesn't know their own house?
Watched a few episodes, most of these injuries happened months before the people appeared in court. why are they all bandaged up like it happen a week ago?
It's her fault I can't believe she comes in house
If someone enters my home and I don’t know them they will get shot! How you think you’ll walk in someone’s home and not get shot? 😒 How do you not know where your dad lives! 😒
He had a right to protect his home
That is true but he should've protected himself with the door lock first, before using a weapon.
The defendant had a right to protect is property. He did tell her to leave but she wouldn't right away. She has to be lucky that he did not shoot her. He just fired a warning shot.
I woulda started dancing and clowning
After wacthing 3 episodes straight there is the first verdict I agree with the judge the guy acted in self defense of his home and she lucky she didn't get killed
Why didn’t the defendant lock his back door if he was so concerned for his safety. She didn’t deliberately trespass, next time lock your door.
It doesn't matter. She shouldn't have gone in the wrong door. Locked or not.
If the door was locked, she would've knocked because she didn't have a key
He said he fired a warning shot what about the neighbors around by the back door. where that bullet went where did that bullet go ??? that's another question I think should have been questioned and answered ...
🤣🤣🤣 I'm sure IF anyone was harmed, they would be there suing as well.
Eventhough I feel bad for her, I think defendent was 100 percent innocent.
Yeah I feel sorry for the lady but I love the decision made by the judge.
Even without the ruling it’s clear that she will not win.
If you don't know your own father's house you could have called him to to pick you up.. why blame others for your recklessness
Glad the right decision was made!
When she first walks into the house doesn't she know what the inside of her father's house looks like? Geez wouldn't want either of them to be my doctors.
Point of contention, only one of them is a Dr, the daughter is a nurse.
They are tract homes that all have the same layout. The taxi dropped her in front of the wrong door. Dad said it would be open for her and it was. She wasn't inside yet, still in garage area and it was dark. She was calling out to her dad that she was home....got it now?
THATS WHAT I WAS GONNA COMMENT!! If you’re so tired you cant even find your house, how can i trust you to find my veins?
@@MoNehNeh17 That's our medical system, work caregivers until they drop. Interns are known for their sleep deprivation, it's considered a rite of passage, but very dangerous.
we need more videos :)
Love this ruling
The guy should have locked his door. It’s 4 am. Then there’s no argument. if someone is trying to get in at that point it’s a criminal.
The father should of went and picked her up he kept going on protecting his family
Finally! I have watched quite a few episodes and this judge is so biased in favor of the injured party. At least this time her injuries were so clearly her own fault he couldn't rule in her favor.
I broke my ankle like that and have a steel plate and four bolts for life.
Funny how different the law is from country to country. In Britain they would both have been found guilty, while in France the defendant would have been solely deemed guilty.
THIS JUDGE REMINDS OF TERRY CRUZ
Difficult but right decision. I am a nurse myself, I know how the job is difficult, I have worked many double shifts. I have never ben a zombie to the point that I would walk into the wrong house as a result of fatigue, but I understand how such a mistake could happen. I understand the homeowner's point of view too though. If you are startled awake at 2 am you are not going to make calculated and rational decisions about what to do to the intruder. You are in survival mode. To her credit at least the nurse did not make excessive demands for money. She did ask for a reasonable amount, and was not trying to play the system.
She will NOT set off metal detection devices at the airport... DOH!!!
Defendant was in the right on this one for sure legally. I would of done the same as him.
she entered someone's home at 3 am,, the judge ruled right in this case,,
40,000 dollar turned into 400,000 dollar??!!
If she is that exhausted and dealing with patients, she could be giving medicine to the wrong person. That is serious!
She was in the wrong house...is she kidding smh.
Why do people still leave doors open? when crime is rampart allover!
If you are not invited Opening a closed door or window is a breaking, even if they are unlocked.
This is why you should keep your doors locked even if you're at home
I definitely keep my weapons ready
Dad loves his daughter
I do feel bad for her injury but I can't blame him for protecting himself and his home
I very nearly brained my brother-in-law once as I woke from a sound sleep to the noise of someone coming in the front door. I swung that golf club with the force of a mammy bear and stopped it about half an inch from his temple when I realized it was him and he was staying over. We both stared at each other for nearly a minute and then he laughed and said "well, as you're up, is there any chance of a cup of tea?"
It's **$40,000.00 NOT $400,00.00**
Right 👆
@@juvenaerenito3489 oh there are 4 of us now who noticed, i checked the comments. hahahah
Was he supposed to give her a big hug? Nice thinking intruder......
It’s pretty sad when a doctor and a nurse are so clueless, she’s lucky that he fired a warning shot, but then again, this case shows why they tell you not to fire warning shots,,,,
No it doesn't.
Here's a hint: LOOK AT THE ADRESS BEFORE ENTERING A HOME!
suddenly everyone is judge
Isn’t that a little bias to have her father give the expert testimony?
She was in the wrong period you don't come to someone else's home they have every right to defend your house
What does a rowdy intruder look like? What does her being blonde have to do with whether or not she is an intruder? 8:57 & 9:10
She payed the price for her mistake and then sues the guy for defending him self wow just becuse you are a nurse and did a dubble shift does not mean you can just trespass even if it is an accident
This was for $40,000, not $400,000
I am with Mr. Miller
She is in the wrong.
I had an extruding compound fracture in my left arm. It was not fun
I think her dad probably encouraged her to sue the man. The dad was really into defending her for her mistake but he didn’t realize it was her mistake that caused her injuries.
how can this case even came to court...she should b lucky she was alive....
If you're so tired that you can't even tell that a home is not your father's home then you are way too tired to be driving! That's what nuber is for if you gave the address to the Uber driver I guarantee you would have wound up at the right place
She did use a driver
The defendant should have been taking the responsibility for getting herself hurt by mistakenly entering the wrong house, and her father should’ve pointed out that fact for her. The plaintiff made a comment to the defendant how to protect himself he should have locked the door and turned on the light. Here my 2 cents advice for the plaintiff, how about keep your eyes opened so you don’t enter the wrong house which clearly have made you become the intruder.
10:20 that kinda looked like my broken ankle ouch!
What does it matter what the severity of her injuries were? Regardless, she is in the wrong.
trespassing is a crime
That crazy those two think they did nothing wrong 💀
I would do the same thing if someone came in my house at 4am in the morning
The man was afraid that is why brought the problem .