Inspiring Philosophy DEBUNKED Again!
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 02. 2024
- BEST WAY TO SUPPORT MY WORK: www.gofundme.com/f/yyt3r-supp...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @themuslimmetaphysician
Consider hitting the like, subscribe, and share buttons if you enjoyed this video and wish to see more content like it on this channel in the future.
Consider supporting The Muslim Metaphysician
Kindly donate to contribute to ongoing expenses:
Patreon: www.patreon.com/themuslimmeta...
CZcams Channel: / @themuslimmetaphysician
Twitter: / mmetaphysician
/ themuslimmetaphysician
Facebook: / themuslimmetaphysician
Website:
TAP CZcams channel: / @thoughtadventurepodcast
Email: themuslimmetaphysician@gmail.com
*He's becoming Uninspiring as he speaks.*
Imagine being a self proclaimed expert (enough to have an authoritative styled channel) and constantly being schooled by a member of another faith on your own religion
@@OriginalAndroidPhoneyea that inspiring philosophy guy looks dumb too
Lmao, maybe watch his response if you want any real facts without the misleading.
@@RIS3N1who's response bruh the Uninspiring Philosophy dude?
@@raymonddarhk20 don't take these ppl seriously, the scholar this uninspring christian mike quoted himself said Jake knows christianity more than mike who is a dishonest actor. Thats was seen in a later video by jake.
Keep smashing it out the park Jake! Alhamdulillah
This is great. Keep up the good work. 👍🏻
@@Justin-ShalaJC what and where was it misquoted? You just made a statement with no context.
جزاك الله خيرا يا أخينا جيك ويزيدك علما لقد أوضحت لقد أمثال مايكل وغيره من المدلسين على عامة النصارى.
أسأل الله أن ينصر اخواننا في فلسطين غزة و المرابطين في الأقصى وإدلب والسودان نصرا مبيناً
Ameen Yaah Rabbul alamen
Thank for your dedication to the truth
All respect and love for your videos and efforts brother 🌹🇸🇦🇵🇸
Inspiring philosophy doesn’t even know what the trinity is.
He was complete clueless when Jake interviewed him on the trinity.
He doesn’t even know what the trinity is. But he claims the trinity can be found in the writings of the churchfathers.🥴
He think you can still be a trinitarian if you affirm that the Son is begotten by the free will of the father.😂
Yes it can
@@borsalinokizaru9862Holy was unknown until the council of Nicaea.
@@borsalinokizaru9862 nicia was about whether Jesus was fully God or a demi god like, you know like hercules. There was a even later council in constantinople which added the Holy spirit as fully God aswell. Literally making it up as they go along
@@Orthosaur7532
Jesus isn't even a necessary being then. It was in the hands of the father to bring Jesus into existence, not Jesus being eternally uncreated, welcome to heresey club!
@@theactualuser No? Jesus is eternal
Your arguments are very advanced and precise and you have collected all the relevant details from diverse sources. May Allah keep you humble and sincere and save you from showing off.
Brother, please write a book, or a website to store your knowledge and references.
Jay Dyer prays to an Arian type of Christian.
Justin Martyr is an Arian type of Christian.
I'm not an expert but I follow these debates alot and understand many concepts. When I started the video and Brother Jake shared what Michael Jones said I was like "wow that sounds explicit, Justin did believe Jesus was God.",
When Jake started responding I was like "Wow!".
We have to learn never to give for granted what words like "God" meant to the early Christians. It's a big mistake to presume that they thought of the concept of God like Christians do today.
Masters in Philosophy and Theology. Nice job.
Can I read your paper that you submitted in college?
Jazak Allah khair brother Jake.
The only reason I like Jake here is simply on the basis compared to christian CZcamsrs. He provides actual sources and citations. Examines them, explains them without monologue and or attempting to place a seed in your mind as he drags on the topic to give you the allusion of legitimacy like Jay Dyer. He provides secondary, third sources as well.
rhetoric is only for falsehoods after all
Do a Debate with Him on Pre Nicean Christology
He's unwilling.
my comment was deleted by only God knows who
but
he will debate William Albrecht
in a meanwhile, IP invited William Albrecht on St Justin Martyr in response to Jake, you should watch it
He doesn't care and if he stops peddling lies that's the end of his channel
I ve caught this guy lying about bible verses too, commented on his video, he responded to me until I brought out the Hebrew. Then he went quiet like a mouse.
Lol. Which video was it?
@@lithium8847-er2oj a video on prophet yunus as and the belly of the whale !
There more than one video. It's amazing how quickly he goes quiet when presented with things which go against his version.
I've previously asked hie some straight forward questions and he instantly goes quiet. Same thing when I explain why he's wrong.
Examples of his videos:
1) His "cherry picking" video is perhaps the most ironic as he has repeatedly shown that he does exactly the same things as he accuses other people of doing.
2) On his "conversation" with Linguas Amo about Amenhotep II not being the Pharaoh of the exodus (in which they both appear childish), I have left some questions for him. His silence has been deafening.
3) "Ask them to provide evidence" - guess what happened? I provided evidence to support my statement and both he and the other person suddenly went silent.
4) Indoctrination - no explanation received on why he uses the arguments he does.
@@gordondetotth9302 yep I ve had this experience too
@@lithium8847-er2oj something about ayub in the belly of the whale, he claimed it was in the belly of hellfire...
Thank you
Excellent
while watching this I happened to open the Facebook Page of a friend who's birthday is today, he quoted 2 Corinthians 1: 3-4
"3 Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of compassion and the God of all comfort,..."
...the God and Father of Jesus, 😀😊
get prepeared for the biggest debate if they accept , not that youre not but to break their decadent ideology at the smallest.pieces great job dont stop growing ❤
Wow ❤
@The Muslim Metaphysician salam alaykum you know Inspiring philosophy made a livestream in response to your previous video
Youre right...again.
Its super weird that an entire faith is built upon the ambiguous and ignoring the Explicit like (john 17:3)
This is Explicit (Crystal Clear-cut) not implicit.
@raymonddarhk20
ah i meant explicit* thank you
you mean, the entire faith is built upon somebody taking a bath in the pool of his own blood?
@@aiya5777 yea.
Look at my reply under alonzo harris for verse citation step by step.
Alhamdulillah
Nah bro that guy is becoming irritating. U gotta have a debate with him. And finish it once and for all
You should address RedPenLogic videos and claims too.
He has a book called Deconstruction Of Christianity.
He seems quite popular nowadays.
Think about arranging a debate please
They plan. And Allah plans. And Allah is the best of planners ~ Qur’an 8:30
Christians in the end they will pray to allah the god of jesus and god of jabrel . and all prophets .
Why not tackle orthodox shahada channel?
He’s friends with them. That’s probably why he’s not as willing to make call out videos like this but I’m fairly sure he’s been on their channel and vice versa.
Why on earth will he give attention to some random dude on the internet
Jake is taking out the teachers of orthodox Shahada.
He is taking out Beau Branson and Jay Dyer.
They are both the teachers of Qai the polytheist.
Jake schooled both of them.
Christianity should be renamed as Hinduism 2.0
Why?
Why don’t you guys set up a debate instead of these “response” videos
He's unwilling.
William albrecht said it he will
jake got dunked so hard by him
Inspiring Hipocrisy
I am a subdeacon in Byzantine Catholic Church and I agree with Jake Brancatella that St Justin Martyr didn't teach post Nicene Trinitarianism. I can go with the details but I will cut the chase and refer people to read from the editor of New Advent who summarized that St Justin Martyr didn't teach post Nicene Trinitarianism. This is similar with St Theophilus of Antioch who originated the word Trinity. St Theophilus distinguished impersonal Logos innate in God's mind as endiathetos versus personal Logos caused by God to create the world as prophorikos before time began. What I would recommend to Jake is to avoid calling the Logos as created. While I understand why but this word would make him ignored by Christians. Instead I recommend use patristic word namely caused. Both the Logos and the Holy Spirit are caused and have their beginning in God who alone the one true God or the sole divine monarchy and origin. Arianism spread fast not because Arians converting people. These people already subordinationists before Protopresbyter Arius. I recommend Anatolios Khalid Way to Nicaea. He wrote a dissertation on subordinationism in pre Nicene Christians. Even St Athanasius still call the man assumed by the Logos as a creature. I hope we can have in depth discussion on pre Nicene Christianity and why subordinationism predated Arianism. Do you plan to review your debate with Jay Dyer? Can I request you debating Ubi Petrus or Erick Ybarra?
Hey,
Is the Logos of God, God himself? Because this video shows a quote from John behr which discusses that the tradition was that the word was an intermediary for God because God was too transcendent to the created reality. Wouldn't that mean that the word ISN'T God but God's supernatural-divine intermediary (a super messenger of God) since the word can go into the creation but as he states that God can't go in his creation as he is too transcendent? If the word was God in the very same sense as the God that John behr talks about, then the word wouldn't have been able to enter the created reality too, right? I wanna know your position on this. When the tradition clearly implies that the word was NOT God in the same sense as THE GOD OF ISRAEL but an intermediary which enters creation on his behalf. Wouldn't that just make Jesus a super-divine agent of God rather than THE God himself?
@@theactualuser I recommend you to Luther's anathema against Calvin on the original Formula of Concord. Melanchton later removed the anathema but Luther condemned Calvin for polytheism. I'm a subdeacon in Byzantine Catholic Church. Both Catholic and Orthodox deny the Aseity of the Son. The Son is God by participation not by identity. If by identity then Trinity would be tritheism. Exactly Jake Brancatella argument. That's why Lutherans, Catholics, and Eastern Orthodox condemned Extracalvinisticum heresy. I do hope Jake Brancatella would be open to have zoom call with me. I believe I can help him nailing Trinity better. God the Father is inaccessible. No one has seen the Father except the Son. The Son here is analogical. Similar to how human mind conceived and begat idea. Just as idea can be metaphorically said begotten similarly the Word was begotten by God and not God by Himself. I hope this help. I can help Jake Brancatella with more references on subordinationism in the early Church. Protestantism deny any form of subordinationism. Catholic and Orthodox profess subordinationism.
@@AdithiaKusno
When you say 'The son is God by participation' what do you exactly mean? Does that mean the son can be worshipped as if he is God himself? Or is the worship of the son not needed in your belief system?
@@theactualuser is Kalimatullah a creature or participate in Allah's divinity? If Allah created His Mind then prior to that Allah would be mindless. Allah and His Mind are not two separate gods but rather His Mind participate. Let me know if this helps.
@@AdithiaKusno
Oh alright, so you just believe the word of God has its own will and consciousness as well as the true God has the consciousness too. Though, we don't believe the word of God (Allah's speech) has a character or personality on its own.
We should change his name to Inspiring Apostasy.
Assalam Alaikum