Wool vs Down vs Fleece
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
- Spending time in the great outdoors not only will take away the stress of everyday life. But opens new doors to amazing experiences. One of the biggest challenges to enjoying that new experience is the weather. The unpredictable changes that it brings can make a great adventure. And turn it into a miserable day. And the best way to combat Mother Nature when she is not being so nice. Is wearing good clothing. This is a game-changer. In this episode. We are going to look at what I believe to be the best clothing. Wool, Down, and Fleece. to see how each one excels in the many different situations and conditions that you may face.
Jackets Used:
WOOL:
Lester River 100% Wool Boreal Anorak: ( lrbushcraft.com )
DOWN:
Columbia ( amzn.to/467fQ0O )
Patagonia
FLEECE:
Mountbell
Thanks for presenting the benefits of wool. I am a professional handspinner. I take issue with your description of wool. Merino is one breed of sheep. There are 200 sheep breeds who also produce wool. Merino like cashmere is soft but very fragile. Will snap, break, get holes quite easily. It the wool's equivalent to silk. Now, I am sure silk is not the first choice for rugged outdoors. Merino has marketed itself as a stand out in the wool world. However, other breeds of sheep that produce wool are often dumped into a generalize 'wool pool' where the good, bad and ugly get blended. Ergo, why wool is 'scratchy'. Think burlap. I spin distinct breeds to benefit from their unique properties. I spin, knit, weave wool (and many other fibers). Only sheep produce wool. Wool defines a particular hair structure unique to sheep. Whereas, cashmere is as you say the undercoat of cashmere goats. But mohair is also a goat hair. Mohair is very strong but it is not called wool. It is called 'fiber'. Same with qiviut (yes have spun that), again that is not wool but the undercoat of musk ox and is called 'fiber'. Softer is luxury but weak and impractical esp for hard outerwear. Layering with the softer base layers but as you go out get stronger wools is desirable. And in order of wind resistance from most to least: boiled wool (felt), woven wool, knitted wool. As one who has lived in Russia, at a certain low temp people switched from wools yarns to furs and pelts. A sheep's skin coat will keep you warm, dry, and wind protected. But you are interested in the wool yarns used to make fabrics. Please contact me if you have other questions.
WOW! Lots of great info…Thanks!
Wow, I loved your input. Thanks for taking the time with your comment.
*5 YEARS AGO I TOOK UP TAILORING* of men's historical suits and clothing for the aesthetic - I quickly discovered that WOOL is a literal wonder material.
Personally, I like an oily wool with good texture and a sturdy feel to it.
@@piccalillipit9211 oily wool was for outer oats or sailors. And you could never dye oily wool as oil repels the dyes . Maybe you mean the coarser wools?
@@suem6004 No, I literally mean the oily undyed wools woven in their natural colours - or knitted in their natural colours. I have a wonderful tweed jacket where the base colour is naturally brown and the over checks are dyed, I absolutely love it. Its vintage, they are so hard to get these days. Dougdale Brothers in Huddersfield do black and white but I cant find brown.
After that I like vintage cloth woven on the old mechanical looms, it has a different hand and drapes better. I now live in Bulgaria and lots is still available here, Im not a fan of the modern thin highly finished cloth.
Here in Norway wool clothing is always the way to go. A couple of layers of wool combined with a Gore-Tex jacket can save your life.
I'm in the Rocky Mountains of Colorado in the US and I couldn't agree with you more.
I'd like to hear your opinion on gortex, I just saw a fortnine video kinda disputing it's claims. Might be worth checking out.
I have used Gore-Tex for years as an environmental (outer layer), jackets and pants. It's fantastic in rain and wind and it breathes pretty well. The downsides are it's a bit heavy and noisy if you are hunting. To save money, buy military surplus gear. Hope that helps. @@ryanwightman9590
@@ryanwightman9590 In my experience Gore-Tex is a great product, if you take care of it. It needs to be cleaned and treated correctly for it benefits to really shine. But the good stuff is really expensive.
It is however not very good for the environment, and more sustainable products are being rolled out by companies like Patagonia.
I haven’t had a chance to test them yet, but my next jacket will be one made with more sustainable materials.
I live on the west coast of Norway, with the North Sea, mountains, fjords and forests, so it’s a very wet and windy place. It can go from sunshine to rain to snow in the space of 5 minutes . We have a saying that if you don’t like the weather just wait 5 minutes and it will change. A breathable wind and water resistant jacket paired with layers of wool is a must.
@@dtaylor10chuckufarle Same here. Also have worked in Montana and N Dakota when it's 30 below with a 20 mph wind. Was the only person wearing wool , and the only one that didn't freeze my arse off. And yes, a shell is great when it rains. Wore merino wool underlayer(s), layered wool socks, wool shirt, and wool pants.
If you hang wool to dry, it will stretch from the weight of wet wool. It is far better to lay flat to dry, it will retain it's shape this way.
Yup, and it will not mildew if you'd made sure it's not sopping wet
Especially with knit wear.
A great tip for soaking wet wool is to lay it flat on a bath towel, roll up the towel into a log, and then walk up and down on that to press the water out of the wool and into the towel. The wool is much lighter afterwards and stretches less when hung up to dry.
I laid my expensive merino wool out on a log to dry in the wilderness. Got chewed up by squirrels or something when I was away from camp. I'm assuming whatever it was has a nice winter nest thanks to me lol. Just something to consider nothing else got chewed up.
Hanging your wool garments in the bathroom whilst you have a shower or bath will help clean them from any steam produced without it getting overly wet. Being a natural fiber, water will naturally move to the ends of the fiber cleaning them.
*5 YEARS AGO I TOOK UP TAILORING* of men's historical suits and clothing for the aesthetic - I quickly discovered that WOOL is a literal wonder material.
Wool is an amazing fiber! Thank you Piccalillipit for watching. I really appreciate it.
Why yes, yes it is!
Ever work with caribou furr?
@@kittywampusdrums4963 NO
When I was in high school and that was a while ago, I worked for an outfitting company. We were taught that wool kept 80% of its thermal property when wet, but took longer to dry than synthetic fleece. Synthetic fleece on the other hand, kept 20% of its thermal properties, but dried far faster than wool.
We were taught to preach this to customers and to advise them to always wear both, either a fleece undershirt with a wool sweater, or a wool undershirt with a fleece sweater. This way they got the best of both should they get wet.
Having plunged through a frozen creek on a night hike in 25f weather I can attest to that idea having some merit. I wore fleece underwear and a heavy wool sweater and was warm by the time we got a fire going. My rag wool socks in GoreTex boots had my feet warm within minutes.
Down on the other hand was the icing on the cake assuming you got the under-layers correct.
Later on Gore-Tex and thinsulate came on the scene and changed how we advised folks for cold weather gear.
We were also taught that keeping one’s core warm would help keep one’s extremities warm. That never worked for me, being long and spindly. For me keeping my head, neck and feet warm was and is primary, my core secondary and my arms and legs tertiary.
We are all built differently and some methods are counter intuitive so try stuff to see what works for you.
The best advice I ever got was to test out gear in one’s back yard on the coldest nights of the year to actually see how they do in the dark without the radiation of the sun helping things. If you can sleep outside on the coldest nights then you are in very good shape, but if you can’t then you start to understand the limitations of your gear and can head inside for some hot chocolate.
Thanks for the vid, you brought me back to simpler times and I learned something. I really need to get one of those nice down jackets to impress.
Be blessed and stay safe.
Thank you The_watcher_abc for sharing your knowledge and experiences over the years. Very good Stuff!
I will go for the wool,knowing different layers and what activity you will be doing
Exactly. Not core at all but neck head feet and hands
There are diverging opinions on core vs extremities and it is very application dependent.
Example: I keep getting shown clips of the 2018 Boston Marathon, which was 35 F with 30 mph winds and rain. The good cold weather runners tended to insulate their arms with compression sleeves (it's like cutting the sleeves off a baselayer and wearing them on your arms) and gloves, but their only other bit of non-summer gear was a hat. They were insulating the parts of their body with high surface area to volume and doing almost nothing to anything else.
Personally, I start losing a lot of heat through my hands once my gloves get saturated.
@@hypothalapotamus5293 everyone is built differently. Some folks bleed heat while others capture it. Body shape, fat deposits, weight, height, overall mass, muscle tone, circulatory system, hair density to name the obvious all have a part to play.
It’s not so much what’s the leading theory of the time but more what is the leading factors that work for you. The only way to know is to observe what works for you.
12:45 "My grandpappy told me that alpaca is fleece! Haven't you ever heard "Mary had a little lamb, it's fleece was white as snow"? COME ON, MAN!!!" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thank you Tokiponafan for watching. I really appreciate it.
Wool is naturally flame resistant and offers a greater level of fire safety than other fibres. In addition, wool does not melt, drip or stick to the skin when it burns. (IWTO International Wool Trade Organisation)
Thank you Susanl for sharing that. I really appreciate it.
The cotton polyester flamed up and melted the wool sweater saved me
I laughed when he said "is it warm?" and answered with "I don't know, but hey, I look good" hahaha and the body language saying that said it all haha.
Thank you Choomanfoo for watching. I really appreciate it.
Well being 71 years old and having been born and raised up in northern Minnesota I've always preferred 100% wool. Been hard to find 100 percent wool though for a lot of years.
It is becoming harder to find at the resale shops also. I have several Woolrich sweaters and some wool shirts I purchased from them. A sears field master is my best. I haven't seen any for sale for a few years though. (Wool blankets are also best)
I live only 10 miles from the village of Woolrich Pennsylvania ... Unfortunately they have stopped completely producing their amazing wool products...and sold out to some outfit in Italy...A sad day when that happened...
@@billfrederickfrederick2791 As a baby boomer , I grew up w/ & have always loved Woolrich ! I've a black turtleneck sweater that is about 30 yrs. old & other than a very slight color fade , in mint condition .
These days, I buy my wool sweaters from Aran Sweater Market in Ireland. They are better than anything I've found in the States. And sometimes my mother gives me a locally produced machine knitted "jumper" (aka sweater) when I go home to visit her in Australia. I've got a bunch of Pendleton wool shirts, which are very good. Usually layer them with a merino wool t-shirt by Wool & Prince or Woolx. I really wish that Woolrich could have kept going. One of these days, I'd like to try something from Duckworth, which is a Montana Merino wool company.
@@billfrederickfrederick2791 Damn, that is sad news. One of my favorite winter shirts is a plaid wool Woolrich. Probably 45 years old, still keeping me warm. :)
Wool is far superior to fleece. Better wind protection. Keeps you warm, even when wet. Much more durable. Also doesn't retain smell anywhere near as much as fleece.
Well said! Thank you TK-cl1jm for watching. I really appreciate it.
I’ve used both wool and fleece and found fleece dries much quicker and provides more warmth as it doesn’t retain water as well as wool. One thing I don’t like about fleece is how fast it melts if embers land on it, or if you ignite your pack stove and your sleeve is too close, it’s about as fire retardant as cotton candy.
The smell is bad with fleece too right? I guess it's not as much of aa problem since you wear an underlayer between the fleece, but when I wear a polyester t shirt, I stink within hours vs no smell with a cotton t shirt.
I agree
@@aerodicus It IS plastic after all
As a perpetually cold person stuck living in a country that is a frozen hell 2/3 of the year, I am a huge appreciator of wool. I basically live my life in it from late fall to spring. Wool sweaters, in layers, thick wool socks, big fat wool blankets.. Fleece is great too, but tends to not look as nice so I wear that at home and the wool at work. And though perhaps too heavy for woodland adventuring, but from my experience the warmest thing ever is sheepskin. My winter coat is thick heavy sheepskin. When standing around in the wind waiting for the bus in the morning and its -25 with wind chill, that wind blows right at me and I don't even feel it. I put that thing on it feels like it radiates heat. Unbeatable. I've had the obscenely expensive down jackets too. They're pretty good but sheepskin is still warmer.
That's really interesting! I've never worn sheepskin, but I'll keep an eye out. Thanks!
How about real fur coat? Isn't that what Inuit wears to keep warm?
Can confirm. I live in an incredibly cold and snowy area, and I have some mittens that are made of sheepskin. Most comfortable and warming things in my entire winter wear collection.
I've never had one, but I would assume that yes, the fur coat would also be equally warm. Especially if its beaver.@@walden6272
where do you get your sheepskin coats? bouta buy one rn
This is what we need- just facts, no BS, but with a good dose of humor. Thanks Marine!
Thank you Muchasgracias so much. I really appreciate that!
I grew up in Australia, where we wear a lot of wool. Best to hand-wash wool with very mild washing liquid. If you must put it in the machine, only use the delicates setting and only cold water. Lay it flat, on towels, to dry. These days, I live in Utah and spend a lot of time hiking in the Wasatch and Uinta mountains. When hiking, I wear a Merino wool base layer and carry a down jacket in my pack, along with a waterproof shell to put over the top of it. I find that I sweat too much if I'm wearing fleece while hiking, but I often start out the hike wearing one until I warm up. If I'm going to be standing around fishing, I wear a heavy wool sweater because nothing beats it - usually one from the Aran Sweater Market in Ireland.
Thank you Dangermandave for sharing that. Good stuff!
I taught mountaineering for years on month long expeditions. Wool was the way to go. Never used a rain jacket unless sitting in camp as it locks in the moisture. A wind proof parka over your wool will let you keep hiking in the rain and wind and let all your sweat evaporate out. Synthetic sleeping bags over down as if you take a swim by accident the synthetic will dry ,but the down will be two sheets of nylon with nothing in between,
You are so right. In a couple of weeks I will being talking about a shell over wool or fleece. Even for down around the fire. I am very careful keeping my down protected for water. Two sheets of nylon is worthless for warmth. Thank you Johnwood for sharing that. Good stuff!
Was that 30 years ago? Wool is totally out of mountaineering and has been out for decades! I have not seen anyone use wool (merino) for anything other than base layer.
Also for high altitude mountaineering all sleeping bags are down.
I just came back from 6 week expedition.
FYI the quality of a made-in-the-UK wool shirt of the 1950s was unbelievable, there is nothing of this quality in this era. double wool layered and silk lined. Sir Every and Sherpa Norguay climbed Everest in wool.
@@alexwyler4570 Yes they did and this is why it was much harder climb than climbing of today. I believe they still had leather boots as well and possibly wood ice axes.
Now no one or very few people climb 8000ers with wool as something other then base layer and socks. I did wear all wool socks on 8000er. But nothing else made of wool.
I would agree with all that for extreme conditions of intense cold.
But for most hiking and climbing in the relatively warm but persistently wet Pacific Northwest (Washington State), wool has huge advantages.
Still, I have down sleeping bags. Only on one week long Nordic ski trip did condensation dripping on my sleeping bag night after night greatly reduce it's effectiveness.
As always, you need the judgement and experience to choose wisely for the trips you make.
Should also mention linen, which was traditionally worn as a base layer and has great thermal properties so can be worn in the cold and heat with comfort. It gets stronger when wet, softer when well-worn. It has anti-bacterial properties and wicks better than cotton. Great to wear under scratchy wool.
You are so right. They use to always line the wool will linen. Thank you KatharineOsborne for sharing that. I really appreciate it.
Linen is very under-rated. Yes it can feel rougher on the skin but is superior to most spun cotton, especially anti-microbially.
Thanks for mentioning it, I'm a great believer in linen as well not to mention ita healing properties
It was mentioned in a video by Shadiversity covering medieval clothing.
I work a trade(electric ) , I'm often outside in bad weather. Grandpa was an army officer, I grew up with a wool army blanket in my bed. Nothing beats a good pair of wool socks on your feet. And a wool blanket is warm even when wet.
A lot of jackets are made out of those wool Army blankets. The one that I was wearing is one of them. Thank you DeadCat-42 for sharing that. much appreciated!
I work outside doing hard physical work often in the worst weather (Wet, around freezing and windy) 4 years ago i bought 2X wool British army surplus jumpers for £20 each online. I still own and wear them at work. Extremely thick, warm even in the wet, and tough. There's lots avaliable online.
Best outdoor clothing I've ever bought by a mile. I'll be buying again soon.
Can you give more specific info about the surplus jumpers? Where did you find them? TIA.
@kapapatence6423 Search "British army surplus green/navy wool jumper" there's loads of army surplus sites that sell them. It's the one with patches on the shoulders and elbows
Used be so much well-made and affordable wool surplus around. Harder to find now
I know you Marines are brave, but that guy that shaves the wool off the musk ox must be truely fearless!
I ended up with a lumps and cuts. But mission accomplished! It is always good to hear from you.
I was in a shop in Stillwater MN yesterday that had some items knit out of buffalo. They were beautiful - smokey brown and silky.
I live across the river. Five miles south. What store was that?
For sheer warmth, I raze you a sheep skin coat - suede on the outside and the wool on the inside. Nothing I've ever tried is so warm. I live in the UK, so it doesn't get very cold here but sometimes our winters at least try to flex a bit so it can get cold. On the coldest day I've ever had here I wore a sheep skin coat and I wound up having to open it up and take my hat off to cool down after an hour walk, it did the job too well (I even had an ice cream once I got to my destination, outside, in the snow, and it was fantastic, it felt remarkably appropriate). The outside of the coat is suede so it's as waterproof as that and could be further waterproofed by oiling and treating the seams. Down side is they are large, bulky, heavy, and can't be compressed - but oh wowza are they warm!
sounds good but it will cost an arm and leg
@@trollmcclure1884 Depends where you get it from. I got mine in a charity shop/thrift store for 15.
Thank you Shadowjewel for sharing that. Good stuff!
Merino wool socks are the bomb !
So comfortably thick and soft in boots.
So you get no blisters or calluses.
Naturally moisture wicking and antibacterial.
So your feet won’t stink when you take them off.
Well said! Thank you Colddeadhands for watching. I really appreciate it.
One thing you didn't mention with wool is the desire of bugs to eat it. If you're using it for in the woods, I would treat the outside with permitherin. Alternatively, when you come back from a trip, stick it in the freezer for a couple days, then warm it back up for a couple days (this will cause eggs to hatch), and then back in the freezer to kill whatever hatched. If it's not getting much use between trips, store in a cotton bag (so it breathes, because wool WILL mold) to keep bugs off. If you do get little holes, you can needle felt a patch in quite easily.
Thank you Tammyschilling for sharing that. Good info!
Hmmm needle felting a hole is brilliant!
I live in the UK, and carpet moths are native here (they like to eat wool and make these little cocoons for themselves, like little sleeping bags that they haul around to keep safe in), so even if you clear a house of them they inevitably get back in. One thing I've found that's amazing to kill off the carpet moths is cedar essential oil, a couple of drops on a bit of card or whatever, in the corner of a draw or box or something that can be closed to limit air flow (but not sealed for the sake of the clothes), will keep anything in there carpet moth free for months. I add another drop or two every 4 to 6 months or so, though that is likely overkill (better safe then sorry). I don't know if it will work for other wool-eaters but given cedar also works to deter fleas, a very unrelated creature, I think it's worth a try.
However, if you have pets you need to be careful about exposing them to the oil or it's scent, as many essential oils are toxic to animals, some more then others (likewise with many synthetic scents for that matter - beware are fresheners and room fragrances). I've read that some cedars are worse then others for pet toxicity, and some might even be tolerated fine in small doses, but I can't remember which (also check dog vs cats vs birds vs other, tolerances by species vary).
For an essential oil and chemical free method to help try and keep them under control in your home (aside from freezing methods and careful use of storage bags), you can use feathers as a decoy - feathers are the food carpet moths in particular originally evolved to eat and prefer, they go mad for it (it wouldn't surprise me if other wool eaters do too). Keep a bundle of feathers in a large jar with the sides covered so the inside is dark with easy access through the top. The feathers need to be densely packed enough that it feels cozy in there, sheltered from a moths POV, and I unusually leave the quills poking out the top. Every couple of weeks, go in and pick out any larvae that have hatched and either throw them out away from anything they can eat, or just crush them (that's why I leave the quills poking out the top, makes pulling the feathers out to pick out the larvae).
Do you mean permethrin?
Pyrethrin
I'm definitely a merino wool fan.
You can't go wrong there! Thank you Christophersmith for watching. I really appreciate it.
I think I was fleeced the last time I bought a down jacket.
I think someone pulled the wool over your eyes. Thank you OverlandOne for watching. I really appreciate it.
If you have scratchy wool or your wool clothes are not as water resistant as once was, then apply some Lanolin it is also from the sheep and is what helps keep the sheep warm and waterproof, also softens your skin.
Thank you Jimmyfisher for sharing that. Good stuff!
Excellnt advice. However, since I live in the Mojave Desert, keeping dry or warm isn't usually the issue. Bamboo clothing provieds good sun blocking, is very soft and is excellent for hot summer desert travel.
Wool is naturally UPF40
Which bamboo fibres? Natural, or hydrophobised? Most you can buy are the latter... I bet that you meant the prior though...
Linen would work well; so would a wool and linen blend. Wool and linen have historically been the fibers used to keep comfortable in various temperatures
When I backpacked the Blue Ridge mountains in late fall and early spring/late winter, I wore wool. It was warm even if wet and it rained a lot up there. A light windproof LL Bean anorak over it was great when needed.
I have had a couple of LL Bean anoraks and they have worked beautifully. Coupled with some wool as an insulator, I have been quite comfortable when hiking/mtn biking.
what a great tutorial on warm-weather gear!! thank you for identifying the differences, pros and cons!
My pleasure! Thank you Joycejudd for watching. I really appreciate it.
Thanks for the advice. Much appreciated!
Thank you Brncllhn for watching. I really appreciate it.
Well done. Thanks for bringing together little bits of information I've been hearing...and giving the thought behind each one. Each one has it's place.
Glad you enjoyed it. Thank you BreakingBarriers for watching. I really appreciate it.
Love it, ive been going in to the hills for years , im 67 and have allways gone for wool, no fleece, marino base, wool shirt , and when wet its still warm, i live in new zealand and home to plenty of sheep.
And also one of the best place on earth ( New Zealand ) to fly fish! Some day I will be visiting your beautiful country with a flyrod in hand. Thank you Graveebailey for watching. I really do appreciate it.
Nice breakdown on the jacket materials!! Thanks
Glad you liked it! Thank you Jansultan for watching. I really appreciate it.
Thanks for the video. The information you provided answered a lot of questions I had about the differences of the fibers and reliability in different climates.
Glad it was helpful! thank you Thomasbissette for watching. I really appreciate it.
I appreciate the comedic value here
Thank you Blondiejoe so much. I really appreciate that!
The layers thing was drilled into us as kids in Boy Scouts, and now that I've gotten a lot more active outside in all seasons and weather, I've found it to be so true. It's also good to get out and "practice" with different layers in different conditions. Sometimes, I'll carry fleece, down, and a shell with a base layer and also take two or three pairs of gloves on a winter hike. If I'm moving uphill, it has to be pretty cold for me to have more than an insulated base layer. If I stop, or it starts to snow, or even if I start hiking downhill, I sometimes need to layer up again. I also love the fleece layers for something like cycling in the cold - the wind cuts through and carries all of the sweat away, but it's enough of a layer to keep you from the total wind chill.
This is so true. Fleece on, fleece off and up the mountain minimal clothes unless there is a cold cutting wind then it can be that I change to the shell jackets with vents open and so on.
Exactly.
I camp ALoT and I LOVE my wool clothing for warmth and my down sleep gear for my hammock. I also have a down hood that I sleep in ( best $20 I ever spent). It’s nice to have options.
Thank you Kasondaleigh for sharing that. Good stuff!
This was very educational. Thanks!
Thank you Jasonhundley so much. Much appreciated!
if you want to avoid wool clothes from losing their form after washing you should dry them laying flat. and to be sure that nothing bad happens to them, wash with hand! great video!
Thank you Prosarosa for sharing that. I really appreciate it.
Lambs wool sweater’s are my go to in the winter, warm , light, and soft ! Great layer clothing 👌
Thank you Markrowley for sharing that. Much appreciated!
Thanks for the info. I appreciate your direct style. No fluff, just the facts.
Thank you E3ECO so much. I really appreciate it.
I recommend anyone interested in wool layers to frequent as many different thrift stores as you can and just sort through the sweaters just by feel. Eventually you’ll have as many different thicknesses and qualities as a man can use… the bonus is finding vintage woolrich flannels that weight a couple pounds of 100% wool!
Finding vintage Woolrich is like finding gold! Thank you Logantheninja for watching. I really appreciate it.
Cheers! Wool has always been my choice. For clothing and a sleep system. I live on the West Coast of Canada...doesn't really get cold but it does get wet. Appreciate your video - humour included. - Semper Fi - (Canadian Coast Guard. Retired)
That is the perfect place for wool. Thank you Gordaro for watching. And thank you also for your service. Semper Fi!
Here in New England, a base layer underneath my Icelandic wool sweater is a winning combo. Throw on a Bean packable down jacket and you’re good to go. Great video sir, subscribed!
Thank you Mattjohnson for watching and subscribing. I really appreciate it.
I had some vintage heavy wool pants once. Those things were great in the winter!
For extreme cold. They make a world of difference. Thank you Americafirst for watching. I really appreciate it.
Awesome comparison! I love anything wool. Especially my new alpaca wool socks.
Me too!! Nice and toasty warm feet. Thank you KitCreep for watching. I really appreciate it.
Well done, Marine. Thank you.
Thank you Victoriaburkhardt for watching. Very much appreciated!
I was hiking on a creek once in NW Ontario at -20F with a wind. I went through up to my waist. But everything, and I mean everything, I was wearing was wool. I hauled myself out, rolled in the snow, and my partner started a fire. I stripped, wrung everything out as best I could, put the clothes back on and headed back to the truck, a half hour away. I thought I would freeze solid before I got there, but only had a layer of frost on my heavy mackinaw pants. Nothing was frozen or stiff and I was warm. So, we drove up the road a bit and went snowshoeing for another two hours with no ill effects. As my dad used to say about wool, no matter how wet and cold you are, you’re always warm and dry.
That is a great story! Thank you Almeadows for sharing that. Good stuff.
Wow, great detail... Thank you for the explanation!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Awesome general information thank you from the mountains of Appalachia!
Glad you enjoyed it! Someday I will be hiking there. Soon I hope! thank you Sinnicide for watching. I really appreciate it.
During the viking age a heavy wool fabric called Vadmal was used as currency. Understating the importance of wool clothing in those days when most of a persons life was spent outdoors. The dwellings had little to no insulation so good clothes were life essential.
That is really interesting. Thank you Patrickhamilton for sharing that.
As always very informative ! thanks ! 🙂
Thank you Borealcamping so much. Very much appreciated!
I prefer layers then a traditional British wax jacket. Its always worked for me.
Warm , waterproof, tough and plenty pockets.
Layers is the way to go. Not only insulates better. But you can put on or take off to regulate the body heat. Thank you Fexalbion for watching. I really appreciate it.
Excellent video!
Thanks!
Thank you Kasondaleigh so much. I really appreciate it.
Thanks for covering this! If you ever do an update, I’d recommend another con for wool: moths. I lost several merino wool Ts and sweaters to these little buggers. Store your wool safely👍
Moth balls when wool is in storage works to repel them.
Great suggestion!
Store them in the freezer over summer. Wear them in winter!@skippyonatrail1170
Before going hiking it's a good idea to do (what I like to call) 'the doorway test'.
You have on your wool/woolmix base layer (or the singe layer clothes you are gonna hike in, in the summer) and test how warm you will be in them. You do that by simply opening the door and let the cold air and breeze do their effect. You stand there in 5-15 sec to see how fast and how cold you get and.
That way you can dress for the weather and activity level. Then you can feel the different stages of 'cold': the "I need a windproof layer" cold, "it will be okay if I'm active" cold, or "need another layer while active" cold.
If you are going to hike, you should feel a little cold, but never a 'biting' cold. You should always have more clothes with you for when you rest and cool down or for when the temperature drop. You can also do this in the car, though a little more tiresome to dress yourself.
It's also a good idea to only wear one layer of clothes in the car, since the inside of the car is warmer than the outside. That way you can dress yourself warm instead of "freezing" in all your layer for a good while. And have your base shirt tucked into your base pants. It's the most secure method to not get a cold leak around your stomach and butt area.
I agree with most of that but you’re better off taking a 5-15 MINUTE walk outside as opposed to a 5-15 SECOND “test” standing in your doorway.
It’s not just how cold you are when inactive but how warm you get and how much you perspire when active.
@@4strokes I might have not written it good enough, but yes, what matters is how warm you are while active.
That's why I do the doorway test to find the minimum amount of clothes I believe I can have on in the activity level I will do. In those 15 sec I can get an estimation if I have too much clothes on or too little clothes on. For instance I feel I am warm enough for a slow walk, but too toasty for a fast walk or run. Or the cold wind is so strong that I think I will have a problem staying warm enough even if I run, so I have to put on more clothes or put on windproof clothes.
Of course you can take a small walk too, but this is just a quick trick to do right before you actually leave the house/car. Of course it isn't fail proof.😬
@@lovemarsh8037 Ah, I understand.
I spy a Superior Hiking Trail patch on one of your fleece jackets! Love it! Loved the shout out to the Boundary Waters too! Gotta love MN!! Thanks for pointing out fleece wicks moisture. My husband sweats a lot when we hike-passing along the great information!!
My favorite two places in the world. The SHT and BWCA. Thank you Annwhite for watching. I really appreciate it.
Fascinating discussion on types of wool
Thank you Cheryls for watching. I really appreciate it.
For the December muzzleloader elk season, I use a silk/wool blend as my base. Followed by a poly fleece zip front turtleneck and fleece bottom and then heavy wool, button front shirt and wool bibs and a heavy weight wool parka. There’s too much snow to mess with keeping a fire, so it’s my layering that keeps me comfortable. It’s too cold to be concerned about rain so I don’t bother with any rain gear. A rip stop poncho is in my pack along with a 6 mil poly drum liner for any unexpected overnight that might happen. Wool may be heavy but it’s quiet, durable, wind resistant and not easily damaged by fire on early winter campfires. My parka can come off if I get too hot and the other layers allow lots of options for additional ventilation. I’ve tried the down stuff, it’s noisy, easily damaged, easily ruined by embers and sparks and stupid expensive for something so delicate. I absolutely agree that there’s definitely activities that favor the down and synthetic choices but it’s just too dang delicate and I don’t own any now. Loved it when I was a snow skier but not for anything else. I’m not into the “fashion” scene of quilted down, like the metro-sexual city dwellers. I have a similar fleece setup over silk/wool base layer for cool to cold weather, but for frigid weather…wool works best for bushwhacking through brush and forest. Hard to beat multiple layers of fleece for the appropriate weather conditions. But a rain jacket in the pack is a must . Super quiet, crazy warm, light weight, soft and fairly durable, and if you’re around a fire, less damage from sparks compared to down/synthetics. Lots of interesting comments on this video. Great overview 👍
Love that comment...
METRO CITY SEXUAL DWELLERS!...😂
Thank you Jason for sharing that. Much appreciated. Good stuff!
Good video Marine, thanks for taking the time to post.
Thank you Jerry for taking the time to watch. I really mean that.
This wa very helpful and informative. Thanks!
Glad it was helpful! Thank you Nicowest for watching. I really appreciate it.
Alpaca socks are great. I'd always worn thick acrylic socks - till my mother gave me a pair of alpaca work socks. They were a fair amount thinner than the ones I had been using. Worth every penny, and I'll never go back.
I have yet to use Alpaca on my feet. Thank you FrankBlissett for sharing that.
Wool, always and forever. Even when it gets wet, ring it out and it will still keep you warm.
Amen to that. Thank you Twoowls for watching. Much appreciated!
Thank you kindly...good to know!!! 🍀🙏🥇
You are so welcome! Thank you Oldpisces for watching. I really appreciate it.
Semper Fi. Great advice.
Thank you Danyerdon so much for watching. Semper Fi!
Well done mate! Cheers!!!
Thank you Jimbriggs so much. Much appreciaed!
Great comparison video! Some info I knew but most I didn’t and I think that was your point. It looks like it will be mostly wool for me and the other material will depend on the situation. Thanks for the video, loved it!
Thank you Turbohelix for watching. I really appreciate it.
Great video with useful info. I've always been a stalwart for wool because of its broad flexibility in differing environments.
Thank you Cf542 for watching. I really appreciate it.
Thank you. Just what I needed to hear!!!!
You are so welcome. Thank you Mortenrongsted for watching. Much appreciated!
That's great info. Thanks!
Thank you Shevok for watching. I really appreciate it.
This is a great topic. Thanks! I personally love merino wool. I've never heard of the one from the yak I think it was. I would like to try that out! Thanks for the information!
Wool from Yak is expensive. Unless you live in the far north. Thank you Jason for watching. I really appreciate it.
@BackpackingWithaHammock holy hell, you aren't wrong! I researched the prices. OMG they were ridiculous for lack of a better word!
Wool: Baselayer, get something with a bit of synthetic for longevity.
Fleece: active mid or top layer, good in humidity
Down: camp, very delicate in humidity
Synthetic puff: active in cold, tough
I never use down. 22 years in the military and it just isn't worth it. High cost + being fragile + horrible in rain = no go from me. And, tbh I hate that puffy look. I'm not getting paid to do Michelin tire commercials. I've used an M65 for decades (still do for most things) and never had an issue. I can throw a base layer, some "fleece" and the M65 and get 90% of what I need. If it is raining, I can swap the M65 for a Level6 ECWC top or a Gortex.
All about layering and using what works for you. My core is always warm, but my hands and feet are what get me every time.
Good advice!
Thank you Jim-do5pt for watching. I really appreciate it.
Thanks for sharing. What a vigorous presentation 🙂
Thank you BlueAlgon so much for watching. I really appreciate it.
Early mountaineers wore woollen tweed jackets and trousers then modern synthetic materials were adopted to save on weight. A fairly recent experiment was conducted comparing the two sets of clothing and it turned out that the wool actually outperformed the synthetic materials when it came to warmth and windproofing. So some form of breathable waterproof outer layer and two or three layers of wool will allow survival in even the harshest conditions.
I suggest nylon. Goretex AKA teflon is too bad for the environment. Not very breathable either. It There's a vid about this gimmick. People should spare their teflon footprint for shoes
Since I have a pretty rough time having to fight my own tendency to perspire heavily even under little load. The issue I have with wool is that though I Know it will probably wick well, that pretty much applies to 100% wool items which are getting Painfully hard to find. I have taken to wearing cotton under my wools and Always under a shell. If you have any thoughts for folks like myself who sweat mucho.... it would be much appreciated. 😊
no problem. I learned to use a thin pure polyester skin layer in the military. The second layer had 50% of cotton or it could be 100% cotton T-shirt. As long as it's touching some cotton it will wick and keep you dry and warm because it insulates you from the soaked cotton.@@BruceWSims
@@trollmcclure1884 Many thanks for the tip! 😀
Wool socks, for sure. But for jackets I went from wool to down and then to fleece. I found that it doesn't really matter if you have a windproof outer shell over your wool or fleece. I used to have a wool inner and then a down outer. Finally I settled on a cotton inner (for comfort, cos wool was too scratchy), then a fleece mid-jacket, and then an outer nylon windbreaker. The deal-breaker, which you didn't mention, is the wind-proof outer. In that respect, the down beats wool and fleece hands-down in windy conditions. More important than wool/down/fleece is the wind-proof outer shell.
Thank you Rxotmfrxotmf for watching. I really appreciate it.
@@AdventureswiththeMarine You're most welcome. Do continue with the very nice videos!
Wool is my choice, for sure. Love it.
Can't go wrong with wool. Thank you Bosse for watching. Much appreciated!
Thank you for your service sir. 🇺🇸
Thank you Joreynolds so much for watching. I really appreciate it.
When fleece gets wet it's pretty simple to dry. You hang it up and let it drip dry or spin it around your head for a minute or two. It won't be perfectly dry, but it sheds water better than either of the two others, and will still keep you warm.
Absolutely from a night sweat suffering woman.
I had a long sleeve wool-polypropylene blend shirt that I would wear snowboarding and also desert hiking. Initially I was surprised at how much cooler it kept me than a tshirt.
A lot of people think of wool only foe warmth. Thank you Johnb for sharing that. Much appreciated!
well done comparison, thank you
Thank you Tamiboelter for watching. I really appreciate it.
Icelandic traditional Wool sweater, everybody in the old days wore them to survive the harsh winters
Old clothing where made so much better. Heavy duty! Thank you A-Viking for watching. I really appreciate it.
I easily get cold when damp and especially in combination of wind, even in tropical heat. So when living in a tropical country I always slept in a 200 merino t-shirt, especially if we had a fan or AC. Worked like charm, kept me dry andeven teperature, even though many thought it weird 😂
Thank you Sirseigan for sharing that. I hope people seeing this will make the a believer!
Very informative. Didn't know that musk ox wool was commercial.
Very popular way up north. Thank you Michael for watching. I really do appreciate it.
Great info, thanks for sharing!
You bet! Thank you Jasondanner for watching. I really appreciate it.
Thanks, good day to you and peace.
Thank you Byronholmes for watching. I really appreciate it.
I wear a silk shirt under my wool. Avoids scratching from wool, dries super fast. Light. Many of the same properties of wool, but lighter. Not as durable though.
That's a great idea!
A little past my mid 50’s, I still ride a single speed mountain bike and wear wool. I reside in the coastal mountains of Oregon and love making fire! Wool prevails!
That is awesome! Thank you Jonathanhambleton for watching. I really appreciate it.
Very informative and fun presentation! Thank you.
Thank you so much. i really appreciate it.
Wool makes me itch and gives me hives. Down and fleece are good!
Sorry to hear that. Thank you Catseye for watching. Much appreciated!
Wearing a low loft vest near to your base layer instead of the outside goes a long way toward persevering core warmth. Deals with sweat much better than fleece in cold weather environments, and it’ll keep temperature sensitive items such as batteries nearer to your body heat. Great no-nonsense run down, by the way. Thanks again, Marine
I love wearing a vest under my shell. It always works well for me. Thank you Prof.badfellow for sharing that. Good info!
A low loft vest made of what ?
@@2SpritOne Arctic goose down would be ideal. Recycled polyester fiber also works well as a less costly option
Another informative video from our favorite Marine. Everything you said spot-on. However, you didn’t mention the other synthetic insulators that are frequently used in clothing and gear. I have expensive down top quilt and bottom quilts and they are fantastic. But I also synthetic insulated top quilt as well and they work great too. I have a down sleeping bag and, over time, it gets clumpy and requires time in the dryer with 2 tennis balls and no heat to refresh the down and get thorough coverage within the baffles. So down requires more care and maintenance than synthetic insulation. So down is great, for sure; but I don’t wear it while I’m hiking/working and I don’t wear it in the rain, and I don’t wear it around the campfire. So, I think you owe us another video discussing the synthetic insulators that challenge the natural fibers. Oh, and much of the fleece garments are not wind proof. The wind blows through fleece like water through a sieve. There is more expensive wind resistant fleece, but you better make sure before you buy.
Not a fan of down if it gets wet your screwed. If you do any real adventure it's highly likely you will get drenched or very dampened somehow
My next tutorial ( 2 weeks) will cover down vs synthetics. And as far as wind blowing through fleece like butter. Well, that is the next one. I like the way you are thinking. Thank you Elderhiker for watching. I really appreciate it.
You have to protect that down in waterproof bags. Otherwise like you said. You are screwed! Thank you Theharassedexpat for watching. Much appreciated.
That was so helpful thank you! I’ve not known the difference
Glad it was helpful! thank you Avocado for watching. I really appreciate it.
I'm reminded of the "30 Rock" wool episode with Victor Garber - "Very Wool"
Classic! Thank you Themr_wilson for watching. I really appreciate that.
Glad that you did not dis any of these options. They all have their place. And I liked the thrift store reminders.
I walk my dog about 1,100 miles year in Iowa. We are on the road year round. We've seen -15 with 25 mph wind but were warm. He's a big fuzz ball that loves the cold. Me, I have to dress for it. But in the summer I have to pour water into his fur to cool him sometimes.
Fleece, wool, down, polypropylene, polypropylene fleece, leather, nylon, polyester, even neoprene foam sometimes. And in layers. It does depend on thing like temperature, humidity, moisture and wind. Snow melting on overhead trees is not a day for down. -35 wind chill requires layers on your ears.
When hiking with my dog ( a Lab ) for the three seasons. I always will hike by water for him to cool off. Thank you Phild for watching. I really appreciate it.
@@AdventureswiththeMarine As an old man I carry his water, my water, snacks for us both, my ankle and knee wraps, spare socks, and this list adds up to 27 pounds when it is summer and we go through a lot of water. It is a great excuse for an old man to get out of the house. I enjoy your stuff.
Great timing on this with the first MN snow this morning! (In the cities at least)
First April Fools Day. Now Halloween. Come ON Man!
@BackpackingWithaHammock The glory of living in Minnesota! I'm glad we at least get to experience all the seasons, just wish winter was shorter and the rest were longer!
Hey just want to say thanks for the video, I was somewhat familiar but now feel a lot more comfortable, for nw missouri, cheers and keep moving!
Thank you TonchoBluegrass for watching. I really appreciate it.
Thanks for the video. Natural sustainable fibres for the win!
My favorite base layer is merino wool. I tend to pack and travel light and soon realised that the natural antimicrobial and temperature regulating properties of wool can mean one merino top can replave at least three synthetic tops. Besides as i'm always wearing it, it doesn't count towards pack weight. I can go five days easy without body smell (as confirmed by others. ;-). Full disclosure. We don't make woolen outdoor clothes (just duvets) but after seeing your video we feel like we should!
Thank you BaavetWoolDuvets for sharing that. I really appreciate it. Good stuff!
Great info! Like your sense of humor! First time viewing one of your videos. Wool actually heats up as it dries! And still retains up to 30% of its insulating capability when wet. I like a mix of synthetic base layer, light to medium thickness Merino wool mid layer with Down or synthetic insulation as major warmth layer with good wind/rain protection on the outer layer.
Sounds like you are and always will be toasty warm. Please share you experience with others. You are very wise. thank you Kivinlytle for sharing that. Good stuff!
My favorite wool experience was snowboarding. I had fallen a few times as one does & gone through some powder & gotten caked with snow on my wool army pants. Very toasty I went a while & started getting a bit chilly & after looking down realized I hadn't fallen in several runs & had lost my wind break layer of 'caked on' snow. After veering off into the powder again I got toasty again very quick with a fresh layer of wind breaking snow. Love those pants so much.
That is a great story. Thank you for Salimufari for sharing that. I really appreciate it.
Can’t beat wool! Mil-surp suppliers are a great source of wool clothing, as well.
Thank you Eugenemcgloin for sharing that!
Very educational
Thanks
Thank you so much. I really appreciate it.