The Psychology of an Isolated Russia | The New Yorker
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2024
- David Remnick and the historian Steve Kotkin discuss Vladimir Putin and how authoritarian regimes are pushed into misguided foreign wars.
Still haven’t subscribed to The New Yorker on CZcams ►►
bit.ly/newyorkeryoutubesub
The Psychology of an Isolated Russia | The New Yorker
It’s a rare pleasure to listen to someone so well versed on the topic
Yes yes yes
EXCELLENT EXPLANATION! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Concerning russia Mr. Kotkin is a coryphaeus. He has forgotten more about russia than other people will ever learn.
absolutely
@@fjames208 0
I could listen to this bloke all day. He uses terms that everyone can understand without feeling like a child in a classroom.
A very clever man who wants to educate, without saying, "Look at at me 'I'm so intelligent."
Simple way of describing complex situations in a way that is totally digestible. This solved a few questions I had about motives and now the situation is clearer. Not great, but clearer.
Well put
This is an absolute gem of an interview. This gentleman speaks with clarity and precision. It's very good to have terms like " the west" explained so well. You kind of already think you know it, but he clouds the definition superbly. " The west is not a geographical place". Marvellous.
It is and it isn't IMO, the West is European, it's former colonies, former British Empire nations and a few others like Japan etc, but yeah also rule of law and all that stuff mentioned in the interview.
@@bob-zi1eb is China even a real threat?
If the west moved all their low end production out of China to other countries and back to the west....what would China be?
WOW!! First time I have listened to Steve Kotkin and now I could listen to him all night. Brilliant guy.
This man's intellect is towering and so broad that it's almost intimidating. Remnick is no slouch himself, as he's lived and studied Russia early in his career. I enjoyed this talk very much - very well done!
Stephen's analysis is brilliant, he clarifies where most tend to obfuscate behind ambiguity.
Yep, and as Kotkin points out, this uniquely Russian 'POV' precedes the formation of NATO and goes all the way back to the Czars. Though such rapid expansion of territory also arguably almost _demands_ some kinda uber-authoritarian strong man figure, just to keep in line the growing list of accumulated territories and disparate cultures, most with separate identities going back for hundreds of years,
You know he’s read all those books too.
I am shocked at the intellectual insight of this man. but why he couldn't say anything about the west being the trouble maker around the world. Noam chomsky said the US is the world's biggest terrorist, and what NATO did around the Muslim world is shocking. A man like himself should be neutral and honest that West is also at fault here.
@@LowenKM so Russians have always been this way! Russians are not like us. Let's eat em!
Incredibly penetrative interview. I am impressed by the intellects involved and the precise use of language, no ers, ums, ahs and hesitations. Thank you
It’s a shame that people of this caliber do not involve themselves in politics. His kind is needed…
@@67275gtb4 Agreed!
We agree all the way in southern Africa
@@67275gtb4 Kotkin is an academic at Princeton, and a very good one. Politics is a different game. Navigating political parties, finding donors, etc. I'm not sure he would like to be involved in that.
@@67275gtb4 Better that people like him advise the politicians who need different skill sets.
Great interview! I was glued to every question and every answer. And Every word! Nineteen minutes and 8 seconds of pure gold.
Thank you gentlemen.
And thank you to the New Yorker for sponsoring this.
Paul
I agree 100 percent!
I was totally engrossed thinking, wow, this pure gold, then I scrolled down the comments and exactly what you said.
Always amazing to listen to Stephen Kotkin. He puts it in simple and clear terms. He cuts through the fog of daily news to deliver the big picture. Thank you for this interview.
'Fer sure, and also nice to hear reminders that Russia's aggressive 'expansionist' tendencies long pre-date the formation of NATO, contrary to claims by John Mearsheimer and other 'Putin-apologists'.
Off course “ he puts it in simple and clear terms” !Will be a problem spreading lies if are not in a clear and simple terms!
He's clueless.
@@ScumbagKonflict I think he’s very,very well informed about everything. I don’t think secret service will employ clueless people. It is pretty amazing dose off hypocrisy, with not even a single moment off shame when he talk about lies he presents as a truth!
@@dezurniprovokator373 oh I didn't even know he's employed by the Secret Service. That puts his lies in perspective. They're doing everything they can to push these lies.
Kotkin is hands down the clearest head on this subject.
This was fantastic. Steve provided the ultimate clinic on the psychology of Russia, filled with historical references.
If you came here looking to have the agitprop on cable reinforced, you got it. They opened by naming John Mearsheimer, then they never named or refuted one point of Mearsheimer's position on this crisis, and he is the expert. I've read Kotkin's books and watched his lectures, I have a section in my CZcams library titled Kotkin, but this was an awful conversation.
You go to character assassination when you got nothing. It is ironic, Kotkin supports every US NATO escalation and move against all sorts of nations including Russia for the last 30 years, but when Russia pulls an Iraq in Ukraine, Kotkin says Putin must be mad.
@@johnsmith1474 can you share that video link..
@@johnsmith1474 mmk
@allgood what?... he din't compare Zelensky to Hussein at all...? he compared Russia's invasion of Ukraine with the US invasion of Iraq.
@@ScumfuckMcDoucheface Yes he did. He is comparing both and I agree.
I’m not familiar with the guest, but he’s extremely impressive. He puts the information and his view across in a very succinct manner. I wish we had more experts of his caliber on radio and TV.
Agree, I learned more in that 20 minutes than I have in following the war for six months!!! THANKS
Just amazing to hear Kotkin's take on the current circumstances. His depth of knowledge and ability to "distill" the complex nuances of Russian perspective so that we can get a better understanding is just incredible. Great, great, great segment.
His clarity is just stunning.
What you call "distilling" I call "oversimplifying"
Do you actually understand what he is saying? are you in favour of imperialism, puppet governments? Cause according to Kotkin that is the west "doing it properly" via EU and NATO and Ukraine is happening because Putin is just a bad guy. Also there are literally videos of Gorbachev talking about the consequences of NATO expansion in the 90s! there was no Putin. Kotkin is for people who seek confirmation bias.
@@MajinXarris
That’s some twisted logic you have.
@@MajinXarris
No, no… your original comment does not translate that cleanly. You said that because this dude has never lived in Russia, he can’t know anything about it and he’s a fool. Meanwhile, a quick search shows you that Stephen has been to Russia multiple times starting in 1986 and is very highly regarded in the scholarly community. What exactly does someone need to do to be an expert in your opinion?
One of the best and most succinct analysis I’ve heard. Thank you
I became familiar with Kotkin during my doctoral study that included Soviet and modern Russia. In a world in which commentators seems to struggle to explain, Kotkin weilds his mastery of history to hit every point on the head. This is why we study history. This is why students of Russian history study Kotkin.
Врун он! Story teller 🤔🤯
WOW!
This interview must be heard. Thanks to all involved.
This interview sheds so much light on the history and nuances of what we are dealing with and the difference between the eastern and western mindset that need to be bridged.
I think if you find the evaluation of Russia by a Finnish Intelligence officer, you will see how bridging it is unlikely.
Power and strength is key. Russia is fundamentally weak
Oh, really? Bul he's talking about not reality at all. 😵🤯 Что-то дядька напридумал?...? 😲
@@user-hv9vn4fi4wit is you who don't know reality. The Russian economy was seventh largest in the nineteenth century, now it's twelth. It has to spend 30% of its budget to hold in Ukraine.
I would love to see Kotkin and Mearsheimer together, with a good moderator, for about 90-120 minutes or so, discussing all this.
And he is correct, we need to stop the insane propaganda and find a path to a negotiated settlement.
Hear hear!
Not under current circumstances, Kotkin in this discussion is the same as all the media narratives that are Putin is crazy psychotic evil who will self destruct. Professor Mearsheimer is in the camp of 'realpolitik' which is a minority if not on his own.
Mearsheimer is stupidly naive and his theories are on the level of highschool kids theres nothing to discuss about
Mearsheimer can go and live in Ukraine after it is under Russian oppression.
Putin's Russia has a terrible record on respecting treaties. They angle shoot constantly and simply use implausible deniability rather than address issues.
This includes massacres after agreeing truces in 2014, as well as the recent humanitarian corridor breaches.
I could listen to this guy all day, please have him on more if you can. He has a way that the regular person can understand and it makes so much sense.
I have been watched this interviewed three times. I love how he explained all the questions in a very basic English that I understand. His knowledge is so incredible and the way he explain in the very simple term that any body can understand. "The West is not "geographical place"... Wow. Love it... Thank you
Не's big..... liar. Дядька сочиняет на ходу! 🤯🤔
I can watch and listen to this guy over and over! he just makes me feel that we have hope in the world.
Cant give up on Hope thats how the Russians try to win by saying hope is a weakness, not if thats some peoples only way of getting out of bed or not burried in a bottle of Vodka. As they say their Ruissa is doing great & all! Anything even stuff that a normal brain knows cant be possible Russia will point fingers until someone takes the bait ! I hope 🇺🇦 Ukraine built this Scum a Golden Bridge now, sadly 😥
@@darrenlord2468 I hope so, I just can't get my head around Putin who has thousands of nuclear weapons and he's waging war against the free world. Every day I woke up and look at the face of my kids and think what if there is a miss calculation on both sides? I just can't fathom what will happen.
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
This was fascinating, nice description of the Russian state of affairs and the current situation. I've read quite a few books about Stalin and it makes me want to read his book as well.
Me too.
He was wrong on every count . His BS is towering not his intellect
He's incredibly wrong on nearly everything.
@@ScumbagKonflict Interesting. What is he wrong about?
@@georgesimon1760 doesn't even mention the Minsk Agreement and Ukraine's failure or refusal to implement it for starters. Talks about sanctions as if its Russia that needs europe whereas its the other way around, just yesterday the rolled back scanctions on about 10 Russian banks. Doesn't mention NATO and the fact that Putin wrote a letter to Washington on December 16 pleading with the US for diplomacy on the border issue. These are things you can research if you aren't lazy looking to be spoonfed by so called experts.
Both these guys are so intelligent but I love the guy being interviewed, he’s just so darn smart with all his books piled up behind him, he has quick concise answers for question thrown at him. It’s just a privilege to listen to.
6 months later- this at the front of the situation, Steve Kotkin is amazing!
This was by far the deepest understanding for me of the ongoing chrisis in Ukraine. Most knolegable, like two men just chewing the facts, it was amazing. Thank you.
Always enjoy listening to brilliant people, and Stephen is certainly one of them. Thank you Stephen and David. Years ago I heard someone say "the sign of a genius is everything is simple". Stephen makes the complicated easily understandable.
STEVE KOTKIN FAILS TO REMIND THAT PUTIN AND THE WEST THAT "GOD" ULTIMATELY WILL DECIDE PUTINS FATE.
HIS
PERSPECTIVES AND INSIGHTS ARE JUST FLIMSY ASSUMPTIONS IMAGINED BUT CLOUDIES AS TO THE REAL OUTCOME OF THE RUSSIAN ILLEGAL INVASION OF UKURAINE.
I THINK
PUTIN WILL BE FORCED BY THE WEST TO GIVE UP HIS IMPERIAL ASPIRATIONS MAINLY DUE HIS LACKING OF TOP LEVEL TECHNOLOGIES TO MODERNIZE HIS WEAPON SYSTEMS, LIKE CHEMICAL, NUCLEAR OR CYBERATTACK RESOURCES.
What a great joy to listen to such an informative and understandable historical explanation of how Russia came to be in the position it is today. Thank you Mr. Kotkin, great presentation.
Stephen Kotkin....So profound. Thank you for sharing!
Gem of an interview. Penetrating cogent insights into Russia and the current Ukraine situation.
🤡
Superbly interesting interview. Thank you Mr. Kotkin and David Remnick for enlightenment of the best type.
Impressive interview. You let the interviewee talk, which is rare with mainstream egos. Questions were thought-provoking and intelligent. Thank you.
Gives one hope listening to this conversation. Thank you both.
Without doubt, Cotkin is the most informative, accessible & above all sound, commentator upon Russia we have today.
This was an excellent interview! So informative and clearly explained. I also appreciated the historical references. Thank you.
I really appreciate how Mr Kotkin can communicate his knowledge in such a clear, concise and articulate way for ordinary people. Very interesting interview.
That was mindblowing...what a great insight into not only russia but also his explanation of what is the West was sensational
The countries that belong to USSR and experienced iron curtain, made a decision to be independent democracies. NATO welcoming them to democracy was the right thing to do. It matters very little what fireside intellectual think of it. They have no clue what real life is.
A deep Thankyou Mr Cotkin
for sharing , in terms we can understand, the clarity and depth of your knowledge, during this unbelievable time.
Thank you so much for making this free to watch on YT.
I've never heard of this Guy before,he's unbelievable.His knowledge and depth of the Mad Dog state is unparalleled.
Fabulous interview! Helped me clarify several things. Thank you!
Grateful for one of the most clear pieces on Putins Russia and this debacle our world finds us in. Perfection.
Wow, so informative and intellectually precise. I can listen to this guy all day! 🤓
Rare these days to see such an intelligent and coherent discussion presented in such direct and clear terms. Decided immediately to get the audiobook version (volume I) of Kotkin’s book on Stalin. Anything this man produces is likely to be of high quality.
The final message of this interview was the most significant. We NEED to find a diplomatic off ramp for Russia that avoids the possibilities of the much less pleasant measures that Russia has at its disposal as it becomes more isolated and cornered.
You need to review your views mate. Two months on and we are the ones who are isolated . Russia is doing just fine . This interview was rubbish
Lolol as times goes on it's the west that's isolated and collapsing.
@@trevorcrook5753 You're whistling past the graveyard, comrades "Crook" & "buzuxi".
Wow! An amazingly well researched, logical, and reasoned presentation.
It was a pleasure, and owesome, to hear someone so smart, and knowledgeable about politics.
Absolutely brilliant reporting and very informative content, one of the best I have experienced.
What? It is not real story and history. О чём он рассуждает??? 🤔😵
Fantastic. Would love to see more of these two .
Clear ,concise and informative.👍
This is a great conversation! Thank you
Kotkin is brilliant. A very rewarding interview!
Thank you for this insightful talk.
Mearsheimer's West-blaming myopia destroyed much of my respect for his analyses.
I absolutely agree.
yes. the West is a unicorn really.
Why is it that it wasn’t (and wouldn’t be even today) acceptable when Russia was in Cuba but is for NATO (ie the US) to be Ukraine? Putting aside the issue of anti-West rhetoric, isn’t it provocative to park NATO/US on Russia’s border? Given Russia’s arsenal and its repeated warnings stretching back decades, isn’t this injudicious? The idea of spheres of influence is basic to foreign policy but the US seems to believe it applies only to itself. It can put a sphere of influence on Russia’s border (Ukraine) just as it can maintain one in China (Taiwan). Ukraine has demonstrated the costly folly of such thinking - a debt we Americans don’t have to pay; we just let Ukrainians take the hit. So far we have learned nothing. If anything, we are emboldened. Let’s see how these false beliefs play out in Taiwan.
@@Ephilates2024 That tired, stupid question again. You Russian trolls need to learn both current military realities and logic. Goodbye.
@@Ephilates2024 This interview rebutted every point you're trying to make. Did you even watch it?
"Spheres of influence" is nonsense. What about the spheres of influence of Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Finland, Sweden, Germany, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Ukraine, Moldova, Georgia, Romania, Turkey, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan, Kazakstan etc.? Your Mearshimerist claims completely ignore all of their concerns.
Russia is the economy of Italy or California with pretensions of being an America, a China, a Japan, an EU.
And besides Putin's funhouse mirror of a worldview there's the fact that Ukraine's gas reserves in the Donbas are a threat to Russian gas profits.
Every time I listen to Steve, he just blows my mind!! It’s a lot to process. His Lex Freedman interview is well worth listening too ✊🏻
Blaming the countries that were victims of the USSR for defending themselves in NATO, is at best stupidity; at worst, betrayal.
Yes, totally agree, we don't want to live under Russia never again.
Correct. No one should have been more afraid of Putin than Finland, as it was unprovokedly attacked by Stalin. But for years Finland appeased the USSR and Russia. But Putin opened many eyes. The new midget with Napoleon complex must be stopped and brought to trial. Hopefully, one of his humiliated generals or a simple private will take care of the problem. Those who blame the west are appeasing cowards.
Highly recommend watching this a brief yet detailed history of Russia
'Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake'..Napoléon.
Yes, love the quote, but people are dying, a country is being destroyed.
If the US is strategic (an attribute the US has lacked for decades) about this war, it will enable it to drag on for years into a war of attrition even at a toll of hundreds of thousands of deaths. The war can only hurt Putin and Russia.
Kotkin is a treasure. A great example of what a smart, open minded and above all, intensely curious person can accomplish with perseverance. Never even thought he’d “study Russian” when he first entered college, or even grad school.
One of the best talks about Russia I have seen. Well done Steve Kotkin.
Thank you so much for this video. Thank you for the Historian's way of explaining things so clear and simple.
Thank you so much for this. Very, very interesting and concise.
What an excellent interview- so clear and well presented. Thanks
Informed, enlightened, insightful, and communication clear as a bell. Brilliant interview, Q's and Ans.
First time seeing both men. Excellent production, very informative. Thank you.
Fascinating and very eye opening. Thank you.
Thank you for this jewel of an interview.
Perfect.
Thank you.
I lose patience with a lot of similar interviews on CZcams - but this was great, on both sides 👌
Stephen Kotkin is a gift to the world. I wonder if Mr. Putkin listens to this man or reads his books. The situation is bad if even 'my friend' Kotkin says it's this bad, with few options available to Ukraine and the west.
One of the most lucid and correct assessments I have heard in a while. Thank you!
Brilliant discussion, thanks for sharing
Best analysis I've heard.
No one mentions that Zelensky that before he was an actor he studied law so he's a clever man
Clever? You mean you think leading your country to destruction is clever? Maybe he is Mickey mouse.
@@ginnyazcona8529 He is leading his people back to the freedom they treasure. Putin is the one causing the destruction
@@ginnyazcona8529 Don't let them pay you in rubles
@@ginnyazcona8529 If My Country is under attack amd invaded, I will stay and stand my grohnd and fight all I can sith all my might till my last breath. Now go F yourself if You Think Staying back Defending oan Country is stupid.. YOU are A BLardy Coward.
So, lawyers are clever. Actors, not clever. Is that how it goes?
This guy's knowledge is very impressive. Amazed at how well he understands all the various aspects of history and life in Russia.
🤡
The person who is interviewed has good sense of the issue.
Reading this 2 weeks later. Unfortunately, the deescalation hasn't happened. Very wise and studied man on this subject. Thank you.
Steve Kotkin is not just a brilliant man; he is a wise man. Listening to the end of this presentation - knowing it was spoken early on in the conflict - is richly rewarded....jt
an excellent in depth interview! should help many understand the situation.
This was Excellent!!! Thank you
This Psychologist is so smart all of his answers to the questions about Putin is True I agree…I’m just a regular person but I understand pretty much…God bless you all!Keep safe!!!
Superb interviewee whose analysis was truly outstanding, subscribed.
I learned a lot. Thank you.
Wow, what a fantastic discussion this is! I am not a politically oriented person, but Steve Kotkin had me taking notes. I will seek out more of his stuff.
I read Catherine the Great and when she came to Russia she found great contradictions in the people, great ability and lawlessness as well...So it seems ingrained.
at least she knew how to hire competent military leaders to run the army without grifters
When Catherine the Great was ruling Russia, USA was printing their laws allowing slavery. Is racism ingrained in USA?
@@leaselmary_sims2189 She also allowed slavery, as serfdom, in Russia. Serfdom lasted until 1861 in Russia.
@@leaselmary_sims2189 I think racism is not inherent to US culture, but it is constitutive to Russian identity.
"Russia is a great culture with a tragic Achilles’ heel: For some reason or tangle of reasons, it cannot produce and embrace wise leaders. The death of Mikhail Gorbachev at age 91 is a sad reminder of Moscow’s inability to bring the old Soviet Union peacefully into the modern age. The chaos that followed the empire’s collapse fostered the rise of Putin, who set his sights not on building a prosperous future but on recovering a corrupt, repressive past." David von Drehle, WashPost. Thank you, New Yorker. Highly intelligent discussion prompted by excellent, laconic questions, all with a NY accent. Love it.
Excellent interview , GR8 questions and space given for Prof Kotkin to reply
Simply . . THANKS
Best discussion on Russia Ukraine war to date. Outstanding. Thank you.
Because of his clear and concise presentations, I learn so much every time I listen to Steven Kotkin. So grateful for these interviews. NOTE: 0:24 "sick of fans" = pychophant ;)
you probably meant sycophant
Fantastic interview !
Thank you 🙏🏼
Great analysis, Steve Kotkin!!
My big fear is that Kotkin will publish the third volume before I manage to get some understanding on the other two. I was brought up in western education and culture in Canada.For 2 years I have been reading Stalin volumes 1 and 2 a few pages each night so I have some hope of digesting it.At the start when this was going to be a short read I was impatient for the third volume.Now I am dreading it.This dystopia known as Communism surpasses all my understanding. One good thing.
Putin's invasion, the lies deceit the refugees the shelling, doesn't surprise me in the least.How it ends is why I looked up this interview.
Excellent information ❗
Such a brilliant interview! Accurate and insightful
This is The Best interview I have seen since the start of the invasion.
Brilliant.
I’m so unlearned and unsophisticated. Talks like these make my ignorance self evident. But boy, the deft and subtle way in which information is disseminated in these interviews leave me feeling both informed and educated. Bravo, gentlemen?! Thank you.
Kotkin is so spot on with his analogy right up until the last couple of minutes. Obviously the situation on the ground has very recently changed so dramatically and no one including Kotkin could have imagined the spectacular successes of the Ukrainian counter thrust, not only taking back Ukrainian territory but huge amounts of captured Russian soldiers and munitions. Morale within the Russian army is falling off a cliff. There is now a totally different possibility, an end game to this outrageous war that would have seemed impossible just a few weeks ago. My only fear is the use of tactical Nuclear weapons on the battlefield Putin is now a desperate man in a desperate situation
Mike, I see your point, but what do you recommend as an "out" for Putin?
His analysis remains relevant in spite of Ukraine's new advances. As Kotkin said Putin would not stop - he would completely destroy Ukraine if he is not offered some tangible deal that allows him to save face .. so this recent development is great.. but it would not stop Putin
How's Ukraine looking right now?
Hey bro, is prZel panhanding within the train?
Great interview and commentary on how the conflict could be resolved. wishing more people would listen to this.
Extremely insightful, what a fountain of knowledge.