@Millie Wharton Year 11 Clifton omg I don't understand why cancer has anything to do with her actual talent. We get it she had a cancer and recovered and that is amazing but it has nothing to do with her actual voice. Why give people false hope out of feeling sorry for them because they had cancer.
she has too much tension in her jaw when singing. it’s very nasally. yes, having cancer is incredibly difficult but that doesn’t mean she can use it as a sob story to get a part. it’s not fair to the people who have worked their whole lives to get there.
Christian Borle no one said she was using it as a sob story. They treat her like everyone else and I don’t think she got the part anyway, but it’s a big part of her and her story so that’s why she told it.
Lauren Mcintyre but she also shouldn’t mention it like 20 seconds being in the room. It’s not the x-factor. you just go in and show them what you’ve got. that’s incredibly sad if you’ve had cancer but there’s no need to tell the judge table. she was obviously saying it as a sob story to make up for the horrendous singing.
the fact that she was diagnosed on press night and continued to go through with the show amazes me. she is very strong
Honestly her singing isn’t bad I just don’t really think this song suits her voice.
shes got a good voice, the style of the song is hard
The fact that she can come out and sing like that after three years out is phenomenal.
That’s so sad, so glad she’s better now!
Idk what person in their right mind sings this for such a big audition especially if it’s gonna be that shaky
Everyone’s saying she was a bad singer I thought she was good
Her voice was kind of weak
yes she had cancer thats sad but also her singing was pretty bad
im sure you can't do any better
Howard Barlow actually a lot of people could do better: I could name some people now if you want
Amazing vocie horrible song choice
it was shaky and abit nasal
Beauty! ❤️.
Just because you had cancer doesn’t mean you should get a job
Just because you're alive doesn't mean that you're smart.
Beck Styles i agree
@@laurenjcoates Exactly so go to school and maybe you wont be so stupid.
@@beckstyles3467 calm down
@@Lucy-bs4xh ironic
She wasn’t that bad
Poor audition choice.
This was kind of awful sis
Better than you hun
I mean this is actually one of the songs in my repertoire and I’ve had a couple successful auditions with it but go off I guess
You keep believing that
Charlie Oliver - Cound believing?? I don’t believe those things, those are facts. Like actual things that have happened in real life.
@Millie Wharton Year 11 Clifton omg I don't understand why cancer has anything to do with her actual talent. We get it she had a cancer and recovered and that is amazing but it has nothing to do with her actual voice. Why give people false hope out of feeling sorry for them because they had cancer.
I thought she was a good singer 🎤
Well she just beat cancer so obviously she’s gonna be shaky and do you really have to comment that
Sadie Maya it wasn’t sarcastic, I really liked her 😊 x
Sadie Maya well then if you aren’t fully recovered then do you really think you should be doing a broadway musical?
@@aurqias3190 well I mean cancer doesn't affect your voice and why come back if you're not ready.
she has too much tension in her jaw when singing. it’s very nasally.
yes, having cancer is incredibly difficult but that doesn’t mean she can use it as a sob story to get a part. it’s not fair to the people who have worked their whole lives to get there.
Christian Borle no one said she was using it as a sob story. They treat her like everyone else and I don’t think she got the part anyway, but it’s a big part of her and her story so that’s why she told it.
Lauren Mcintyre but she also shouldn’t mention it like 20 seconds being in the room. It’s not the x-factor. you just go in and show them what you’ve got.
that’s incredibly sad if you’ve had cancer but there’s no need to tell the judge table. she was obviously saying it as a sob story to make up for the horrendous singing.
Christian Borle it’s a reality tv show, they’re told if not forced to do this. Doubt it was really her choice to mention it.
Dunno why everyone freaked out. It really wasn't that bad.
i thought her wasn’t bad but this song is awful for her voice