‘Infrastructure is crumbling’: Peter Dutton ‘a lot clearer’ on migration than Labor
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 05. 2024
- Sky News host Paul Murray says Opposition Leader Peter Dutton is “a lot clearer” in his budget response to lowering migration.
“Peter Dutton, a lot clearer, a lot easier to understand … he believes one of the main things we have to do in this country is stop the number of people coming in,” Mr Murray said.
“This is because we know when you have got already record waiting for ambulances … infrastructure that is crumbling, when you have got lines around the block for a house, adding more people to that is not very clever.”
Cut immigration by 75% is needed.
100% would be a hell of a lot better!
100
Zero Net immigration as per One Nation and other smaller parties is the way to go.
TRY 100%
NO CUT IT TO ZERO WE DO NOT NEED ANYMORE MIGRANT INVADERS SPENDING THEIR MONEY BUYING AUSTRALIAN PROPERTIES AND PUSHING AUSSIES OUT OF THE MARKET
BOTH INBUYING A HOME AND RENTING A HOME
HOUSING FOR AUSSIES FIRST
AUSTRALIA IS ALL OUT OF CHARITY NOW FOR MIGRANTS
PLEASE STAY HOME OR GO BACK HOME
We need Pauline Hanson
Please explain
Ok. So the chant is out. We want One Nation to run the country.
Consider this.
I'm not going to take anything away from Pauline Hanson or One Nation. But does Pauline have any experience with foreign affairs? Now, let me put forward a scenario. Let's say we have an election, One Nation wins in a landslide, and Pauline Hanson becomes our new PM. Next minute, the Chinese decide to launch an attack on Australia. How would One Nation handle this situation?
The point I'm making is this. If Pauline Hanson and One Nation are good enough to win this next election I will personally congratulate her, and I think it is fairly safe to assume that she and One Nation, with a good team, could manage the economy. But if we were to come under attack, is Pauline going to be able to make tough decisions where it counts? I say this because you overlook the fact that if go to war with China we will have a leader that will be under enormous pressure and will have to have daily meetings with a war cabinet. Now if this was to eventuate, would we have the right person in the hotseat steering us through a war?
Just think about that.
Home grown issues are our main focus. But foreign affairs are very important too.
We need to stop emigration full stop we need to be like Hungarians
Immigration is where they come into the country, emigration is where they leave the country, which are you actually against?
@@haruchai I think he means immigration. But is it OK to say "stop emmigration to Australia from other countries"?
I interpret a Javier style policy would be the preference. Which is fine to say. 😎👊👍🇦🇺
And Denmark and now the Dutch
Poland and Japan, although rumours have it Japan is being pressured to change their policy, also Switzerland have just banned the Bur ka and ruled that izz-lamb is no longer recognised as a religion.
We don’t need anymore people coming we don’t have jobs for our selves
You are mistaken unemployment is extremly low at the moment. Meaning we don't have enough workers for what needs to be done. When you factor in disability etc. But don't disagree that it needs to be lowered.
@@kirnl
Would that have anything to do with people working 2/3 jobs to make ends meet?
@kirnl yes, you're right. Immigration needs to be lowered ( not stopped as the ABC loving lefties are trying to criticize Dutton of). Dutton's plan lowering Immigration plus a two ban on foreign purchasing of Australian properties to sustainable levels will find the right balance between management of our economy and giving Aussies a chance of finding rental properties as well as buying their own properties.
@@ricochet2977Or an hour a week and they say employed.
Get rid of DIGITAL ID
💯
Digital ID is good. Foreigners are exploiting our social services.
You cant send them to the REGIONS. WeJust Spent 7 HOURS in Emergency WAITING. People Will and HAVE DIED. Its Shocking. The System is BROKEN.
Completely broken 😞
I agree, don't send them to the country towns. Why ruin regional Australia with mass immigration like it has ruined Sydney and other capital cities.
That's funny. Really sad and funny. It is not an accident that systems are broken and infrastructure is crumbling - where plebs live. Canberra has only the best of everything. The elites look after themselves and we slave class just have to pay for it all. A lot more peole will die. It's part of their plan. Agenda 2030 and the WEF's great reset are real. Wake up and get out while you still can.
@@glennkenny9810Yep
They don't want to go to the regional areas
The alp are a destructive force.
They both are.
@@k20t30pl
NO, Just the ALP 💩👉🤯
@@k20t30plrubbish. The ALP spends; the LNP mends.
@@derekmottley3656 I just saw Dutton preach about censoring the internet. They both are for social control. Labor is more violently extreme with their Maoist agendas, but the Liberal Party never change any laws the Labor puts in, and when it comes to censorship, they join in without missing a beat. As far as I am concerned, they work together. One in the same.
@@wrongtracksuit I just saw Dutton preach about censoring the internet. They both are for social control. Labor is more violently extreme with their Maoist agendas, but the Liberal Party never change any laws the Labor puts in, and when it comes to censorship, they join in without missing a beat. As far as I am concerned, they work together. One in the same.
They both work for somebody else other than the people.
Islam out 🇦🇺
English out
His lamb is sick
politicians out! public servants out!
@@user-fz3ey3ug3o That's never happening get over it
@@earthangel7253 will who are use to say no islam no Christian no no Jews no no Buddhism no religion remember Australia had no religion till who ????
Paul you have hit the nail on the head our hospitals are broken in Victoria don’t get sick
Yet hospitals are funded etc.. with our “ royalties “ being our resources eg minerals etc… in which is BILLIONS, so NO excuse, period !! Maybe put that to yr “ representative’s “
Oh worse than people have any idea of if you don't know they are full of Indians and Asians who don't know much about health.
We are already- Indian State. Australians are homeless living on the streets.
An Indian State? Are you sure mate? Most foreign buyers are from China and Europe. You are focusing on the wrong nationality. Maybe you just don’t like them.
- English (36.1%)
• Australian (33.5%)
• Irish (11.0%)
• Scottish (9.3%)
• Chinese (5.6%)
• Italian (4.6%)
• German (4.5%)
• Indian (2.8%)
• Greek (1.8%)
• Dutch (1.6%).
@@rajnanda1867You missed a few. Italians were and are what we need, not Asian or Indian
Indians are part of Asia as well and so is Australia.
On what basis do you say that? Coz you don’t like Asians?
FYI, Asians pay a lot more tax, which pays for the welfare and pensions that is enjoyed by Europeans and the white population. We give more than we take from the system.
Even if you don’t like us, you need us whether you fail to see it or not.
@@rajnanda1867 Don't need you or want you. Nobody does.
Lol.. I guess that’s what the natives said when your p**sy ancestor’s plundered their land cowardly.
I am a citizen of Aus since 2003. You are free to leave My Country.
cut it more and stop non Citizen from buying a home/house and let them invest only in rental units
How do we know where that overseas money to buy houses/property comes from? money laundering? gangsters? drug money? crime gangs? etc etc
Ok boomer
Stop duel citizenship and house ownership to non Australian
Labor economics, eyes wide shut. Liberal economics, on a clear day you can see forever.
Liebor economics - big govt, big spending, big taxes, big Australia (by bringing in more liebor voters), more laws, more govt restrictions, less freedom of speech, more wokeness and on and on and on it goes.
Actually Australian labor is rated consistently as one of the top OECD economic managers while libs are rated poorly.
Things like carbon tax and the way we handled GFC were seen as world leading and have been used by other countries.
Liberal backed anti freedom reforms and spy reforms.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Labor is just hanging around now.
Just like a bad smell
Doing as much damage as possible before being booted out.
@@ricochet2977 Absolutely 💯
Plus watch those migrants crash...drive trucks.
Yup
They don't give a rats.....
It would help if they had a good grasp on English. So they could read the signs.
@@ricochet2977
They can read until they are caught...
Then it's NO HABLA ENGRIT.
Reduce by 25% means 75% would come still
25% is not enough. I think it should be stopped completely for a couple of years.
@@carbine5378For good
25% from the normal rate which is still a high 140k but will be compared to albo's current 450k and next years 250k lol
Add to the numbers of people coming into the country as a problem, better vetting of WHO is coming into the country is needed. We have to raise our standards.
Never in my life have I seen such a train wreck of a government !! If you're lucky enough to get an ambulance then you will probably still die in it waiting to be unloaded at the hospital
O boy. Got some news for you. Liberal cut spending on hospitals and health care and has been gutting Medicare since the Howard days. So that doesn't fall out Labor at all.
@@kirnlHospitals are full of immigrants who know nothing. They don't have the skills and people are being done in.
You aren't very smart.
So $300 after 2 yrs of Govt, two record surpluses?? FFS are they for real ??? 😮
How is national debt paid off?
So true..its happening here in the US also
Skilled immigration? How about not slashing TAFE courses and helping these kids into apprenticeships.
Exactly !!!! We need Australian trained and qualified apprentices - not some third world trained immigrant that doesn't even know the basics safety measures !!!!!!!!!!
Too late for that.
Look to their mummies & daddies working overtime to send their darlings to university to protest.
The $300 rebate is approximately 82 cents per day. What can you buy for 82 cents, zip.
Sweet F all!
You don’t get it in your hand company takes it off 😜
To give $300, the government will take $600 off each of us... and the government will grow and do very well while we all suffer and have to beg for crumbs from our own table.
@@user-kr1zi7ck9g Right so they get to use the money first .
Cost of living is being driven by corporate greed. You are pointing fingers in the wrong direction quick google search shows all major supermarkets in the country are boasting record profits right now.
Dutton is pointing in the right direction BUT that's all he's doing...... pointing.
He's Not in Charge.....Yet !
About time he started acting then. @KT-bb1tb
He is in opposition.
Are you really that jilted that your beloved ALP/GREENS kicked you under the bus ?
@@derekmottley3656 left and right wings are attached to the same bird, time to realise we're dealing with a two headed snake here and figure out a different way forward.
TLDR; time to stop swinging Labor/Liberal forever and try something new, they've done nothing but drive the nation into the dirt since the 1970s and probably earlier.
Dutton gave cash hand outs to his mates muscle car company's during covid. They were never locked down or under financial stress. Dutton was part of the group that gave harveynorman hand outs that they didn't need and didn't pay back.
Islam out.
No more phones in parliament. Vote one nation
It’s too late Australia has fallen to 🇨🇳 I lost my job my home 39 and have nothing
This is the Real Australia 😢
Jesus mate!!
I'm with you my friend, just 10 years older and apparently to old for employers.
And yet I'm 35 with 3 propertys to my name own all my cars and toys outright. Sounds like poor choices got the best of you not the government.
Our hospitals are in a disastrous state thanks to you Chalmers.
Maintenance staff/ tradespeople are leaving public health system jobs due to ALP in NSW removing incentives.
The Irish get to keep their 5 figure pa incentives though.
Half of Ireland must have migrated into port macquarie for guaranteed jobs in NSW health.
Libs been gutting Medicare and health since the Howard days. This isn't on Labor.
De port and Sho w no Mer cy ✝️ 🇦🇺
Albo the drongo
Shut up Chalmers!
The LNP need to be a lot clearer on basic freedoms - freedom of speech, freedom of association, freedom of movement, freedom of religion - the ALP are pushing ever more draconian legislation both at state and federal level - restricting, movement, access, speech etc. Dutton is not clear on these basic items and should commit to rolling back the invasive policies of the ALP - if the LNP can't do this they are not fit to govern and Dutton is not a fit and proper person to be a leader of a Australia.
He has to take off his training gloves put on fighting gloves Labor always fight dirty 😡
Don't trust Dutton either. He voted for the digital I D. and WHO and the misinformation policy. He's not to be trusted. He's also a WEF PUPPET. WATCH HOM CAREFULLY.
The aboriginal industry has restricted movement around this country.
Look at what they do at The Spit in QLD on Australia Day !
Left and Right are wings on the same bird, time to open our eyes and realise the twin headed snake for what it is.
Bla bla blah
Jilted ALP/ Geens voter ....
😭😭😭😭
I have waited over 2 years to see a specialist in our public system. How on earth are we going to treat more people.
Thank the libs for that. Been gutting health and Medicare since the Howard days.
The $300 to my power company is of zero use to me . I’m an invalid pensioner and over the past 5yrs to purchase a solar system. My power bills are now ZERO$$
and I’m in credit. Is the $300 a BRIBE and buying off the Power companies.. Ron
Then give your neighbours the $300.
They have been paying your bill while you enjoy zero Mr pensioner !
@derekmottley3656
Why should he give it away, he's paid taxes all his life. He's stating an obvious point that not everyone needs that money and it's obviously a vote bribe .
I’ve heard a lot of discussion about immigration, but why has the media started thinking migration is a problem? The terms are not interchangeable, and mean different things. There is no such thing as a migration problem. The problem is immigration. Could journalists and politicians refer to dictionaries on occasions, please?
Labor said it themselves right there on the telly,”but who is going to deliver your parcels”.
The DARK PEOPLE
😂😂😂😂
This is like your two kids arguing about who messed up the toilet last week😂😂😂😂
The international students don’t want to do it as it’s a backdoor into the country and for them being able to apply for a skilled graduate visa that’s why they don’t want to study online from overseas then apply for a skilled visa.
Not to forget the cost to Centrelink as emigrate family's arrival in Coountry.
Labour is a joke.
Labor*
My poor daughter who moved to Victoria to do her degree at Monash did the bulk of it locked up in her house doing it on line
Good enough for Aussies good enough for overseas students that want our education without putting pressure on housing etc!!!!!
140k too many. Skill up our own people, you certainly are not going to make the situation any worse.
As a hiring manager gen z Australians are lazy and useless and want everything handed to them not wanting to work. You can't up skill someone who isn't interested.
@@kirnlI agree, parents have let their children down, can't even manage a child having a phone that they should not have, but it's everyone's else's fault they died.
Hmm where did my comment go o.O
Peter Dutton hit the nail on the head.
The education delivered by an Australian University is not the selling point. It is the access that this provides to a job in Australia and thereby a path towards living in Australia that is the real attractor.
Let them eat cake
Dutton / LNP policy does not go far enough! There needs to be zero net immigration intake until infrastructure catches up! There needs to be a complete ban on any foreigners owning Australian properties forever, and existing foreigners need to sell their properties in 2 years.
It's a show they might as well sit side by side and kiss each other on the cheek. You are delusional if you think they are opposing sides.
Exactly. If anyone thinks voting for majors will fix anything they are sorely mistaken.
Albo represents Labors radical left faction that don’t know how to count or actually run a county’s infrastructure.
Dutton represents the more conservative faction of the Liberal party that are less caught up in divisive racial and gender ideologies,
And can run an economy better.
One nation doesn’t pander to radical left wing ideologies at all. Vote One nation first, Liberal/national coalition second.
No. Voting minors all the way down the slip with liberal and Labor last. Dutton supports censorship laws he's no better than Labor. There are better party's to put above them freedom loving ones.
Yeah study from home 🏠 it’s a sham
Labor tells what people want to hear, (suck them in). Liberal tell what’s needed to be prosperous.
Strange false view on how it actually works. Liberal spends 9 years making a mess. Labor wins and election liberal points fingers and blames Labor for their mess.
Poor Jimbo been out played his pea and thimble budget has been found out an no way will the rba cop the bs
New jets. what when the next Gov. sells them, depreciation. another tax payer cost.
Unbelievable arrogance 😡😡
If Australia was a corner store...
Would you flood the shelves with stock nobody wants?
Would you serve only a certain breed of customer?
Would you lie to your customers and be deceitful?
Would you give all your profits to the local chain supermarket and keep borrowing $ to keep your doors open?
I could go on.
Absolutely brain curdling to think this or these fools are who we have to choose from.
Where are the smart intelligent ppl to vote for?
Love you Pauline but i think they have built walls around you.
If Australia were a corner store, 4% of the population would still steal from it !
There's a ship load of people on unemployment benefits. Maybe there's something there. Get the ones that had jobs before the Governments locked everyone in back to work.
What ever we do, vote ONE NATION
DV crisis? According to the latest data released by the AIC there is no ‘crisis’. In fact DV has been dropping significantly over the past 40 years. Of course it needs to continue but it’s not a crisis nor does it need a billion dollars thrown at it!
Keep doing what they’re doing (all governments), and let’s see it continue to improve.
Filter the dv stats by ethnicity. That's where theres a dv problem with 40 billion a year thrown at it for 3% of the population.
4:23 - Clearly he has not seen any of the BAD AND SHONKY BUILDING PRACTICES and BREACHES OF BUILDING CODES, as a result of immigrants moving into the building sector. They just want ALL THE BENEFITS AUSTRALIA CAN GIVE THEM, BUT THEY ARE NOT SKILLED IN WHAT THEY DO!
Yes, totally shocking.
Once you leave the South east in Queensland, you can't get a Dr.
Sure you can !
They are just hard to interpret.
Why Australia vote for labor in first place ? How also get in chair ? That’s question
If labour was serious about skilked immigration the numbers of immigrants would be much lower. Labor needs unskilled migration to bolster union memberships who are scamming low paid workers out of extra income.
Thank you Paul
I wonder what the budget would look like and where we'd be if the funding wasn't focused on 0 emissions. So much of the budget is getting sunk into just this field while it drives prices up and reduces energy security.
That's the WEF plan. Everything fails when it collapses. Nobody really asks the tough question, why the lies of climate change when it's a WEF lie. He would be not able to answer it. Nuclear isn't going to happen.
Well promise austerity and stick me in a bubble.
Paul Murray for PM!!! 🤩
It is so difficult to house the people already in the country. unless more accommodation is made available at a realistic price all the immigrants will be homeless. When is the Gov. going to stop exports of building materials to sustain our own building industry.
Maybe the politicians can sell off their spare houses and investment properties to the Australian people so there's enough homes?
Immigrants will never be homeless that's the point because fuck us
It won't be immigrants that are homeless. It will be the real Australians.
Not them, have a good look who it is, they always get homes
I love this channel always speaks the truth 💯 love it
Smoke and mirrors
Has the infrstructure had its 18th booster pauly? If yes its obviously tough enough.
Dutton might be clearer, but his ideas are still enormously short of what is required.
A population target AND an infrastructure plan to enable this target!
Meanwhile we need to build the seriously lacking shortfall of infrastructure to even get us to the starting line.
Infrastructure is bad because libs spend 9 years giving cash to their mates instead of building infrastructure.
As if, bunch of BS artists both Labor and liberal
There needs to be a massive CUT to IRRELEVANT public service departments and deadwood public servants and the savings need to go straight back into tax cuts. That alone would probably results in many thousands of dollars of less tax paid to the average worker.
And dutton talks with forked tongue.vote ONE NATION OUR ONLY HOPE
we need to stop this power energy ankar, a ankar around every Australians leg and business. The only way to brake the chain is nuclear power. A nuclear power station out in the desert in the middle of Australia that can feed power to Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide and Perth. Oh no you cant do that a nuclear power station needs water there is no water in the desert!!! . Well the water can be piped down from northern Australia.
You are deluded and don't know what is going on.
Well every other country has one , its only the small minded austraians that dont have one.. We are so lucky that we can put one in the center of australia where there is no pupulation and feed out too all of the big cities...
Whent to go for a simple blood test the other day, 9 migrants waiting in front of me! I left.
"Peter Dutton" in the feminine voice of Airbus
Always wondered how some of these Uni "students" ever managed to pass any courses especially with limited English skills.
They are not really students at all, they are illegals in the country
Happy fathers' day! Just a thought ..to build millions of houses, a massive project to implement, how many months will a house be completed if there is lack of workers to do the job?
Labor, gives us no choice on mass immigration!
Its easy to say just "study online" but international students wont want to pay incredibly high fees in exchange for a few downloadable lectures every week.
It’s obvious the LNP will never win an election against labor/green/teals because they support labor what party supports the LNP ?
Good they shouldn't be allowed to win after trashing the country for 9 years straight only to lose then blame Labor for their poor management of the country. Liberal dug the hole the country's in.
@@kirnlBut Labor have always been a terrible overspend Government, and are not for any worker and have not been for a long time. They both stink
@@vivrowe2763 except that's just a lie anti Labor media outlets spit out. It's false. One of the most wasteful governments in Australian history was the Howard government. Sold a heap of government owned assets had a massive surplus handed it out to buy votes and still lost instead of spending it on Australian infrastructure investments.
Charming super dork?
Skills base, thats a joke, look at most that finish Uni, they dont use their degrees. Help the homeless, they're everywhere, now thats Unaustralian Jimmy.
Agree totally with immigration cuts, forget about all the so called benefits of more people bring to the economy for a few years and concentrate on real issues of housing and everyone stop being so dam greedy.. It's shameful in a rich nation like Australia that we should be having people without a home.. Absolutely shameful..
PETER DUTTON !! What a worry they must be having sleepless nights ???
Build duplex houses. Front unit for the owner, back unit for rent and the rent will add on to the easy payment of mortgage. It's financial management, practical and crisis on housing can easily be solved? Just an idea
Dan Andrews was building a million houses imagine howmuch money in loans that is.
Probably majority going bust and money in his pocket afterwards.
First, focus on healthcare. Second, major infra projects. Third, immigration relevant to economy and on migrants who can work on healthcare and infrastructure, etc
Dutton wont undo Howard policies. . .
Hilarious watching you lot argue the budget is inflationary and arguing that it’s not doing enough. Maybe the current economic conditions are tight and there’s… shock… nuance?
Basic macroeconomics, I would have thought, nuance. This government, nuance, needs a more contractionary fiscal policy, nuance. It has relied too much on monetary policy, nuance. It also needs to consider the impact, nuance, of too high an immigration rate, nuance, on aggregate demand, nuance.
36 does. It even fill up a tank of fuel especially when you live in rural areas and there is no alternative transport except your vehicle.
Labor need to go as they are the most inept government we have ever seen and incompetent in most portfolios.
How about we get those off the dole working and skill this lot up and having skilled migrants is no excuse as we have so many sitting in their backsides taking from the tax payer and yet so nothing for themselves let alone for the country.
What about single mothers and starting to stop those younger ones having kids and then living off the tax payer.
Aboriginal affairs need a full audit on the 40 billion and making this money more accountable.
Until there is accountability on the tax payers money being used by governments then those trying to say LNP is going to do when In fact Labor have failed all Australians since taking power two years ago has cost this country and out us into more and more debt that children will be paying for years to come if they can get a job and a home to live in once they leave home.
Immigration needs to slow down and until there is more infrastructure and dams being built this country cannot sustain the growth as the numbers outdo what we have at the moment.
Get it stopped and deport what Dutton didn't do. Kick out all the illegals immediately.
One nation all the way
Can you report and investigate on the power companies since budget have announced they'll be charging people to put power into grid, who invested their hard earned money into solar systems
Not me, knew it was crap
The skill basis should be going to Aussies first
Homes should be going to Aussies first
Rents need to go to Aussies first
You can’t go to Bali and buy homes Willy Nilly
Always who can pay the most
Labour 'Woke' up with Fleas because of who they let sleep in the party room
Labor*
Is there volume for this video?
I never thought they would show racism directly in tv ..
The ABC has done it for years.
When the liberal party gets in at the next election their first priority is to get rid of the ABC and then get us out of the shit we are in at the moment
@@cozofcat9170Don't know how, he is not manly enough and still lying about climate. They signed up for this.
Skills based immigration?… All I see are more Petrol Station attendants, Uber Drivers etc. These are jobs where wages are down so how is immigration helping Australia.
It helps. When we were locked during covid I couldn't get staff at all ran on a skeleton crew with everyone exhausted. We have a case of its to much now but some is definitely needed as no Australian wants to work in service stations. And other forms of retail.
Cut the benefit of negative gearing and capital gain tax benefit as well!
Please ask chalmers as i cannot reach to him on any other news or youtube channel as they are closed for comments..... if the government invest in housing problem, do we need to apply and leave in social housing or he has to do better for us to afford house !!!¡! Please ask him if you have a chance better than us ... community
Can we have an election NOW please
Too many Labor people in the country. All have a bed and roof.
Decades too late Asia owns most homes here and like being our slum lords
Lol Tas power prices about to go up by another 10%
I hear there is some free money for power companies about to become available.
Infrastucture is going to crumble more.
CV,s are too heavy and break up roads
Also inertia on tyres makes them wear out fast😊
Be wary taking a CV over a speed hump!