Do All Muslims Think The Same? | Spectrum
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 07. 2019
- Follow us on INSTAGRAM: / jubileemedia
Ien: / ienthekorean
Michael: / michaeldonte_
SUBSCRIBE for more! 👉bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEjubilee 👈
Be in a Jubilee video: bit.ly/JubileeCasting
Join our company! bit.ly/JubileeCareers
Are you a loyal Jubilee fan? Join our Facebook group: / 407942859721012
| ABOUT |
Jubilee exists to bridge people together and inspire love through compelling stories. We create shareable human-centric videos that create connection, challenge assumptions, and touch the soul.
Ultimately, we aim to inspire people to LIVE DEEPER.
| SOCIAL |
Jubilee Facebook: / jubileemedia
Jubilee Instagram: / jubileemedia
Jubilee Twitter: / jubileemedia
Jubilee Website: www.jubileemedia.com
FEATURING:
Nabeel - / best_beelieve
Nia - / itsaudaztv
Husna - / _weepingrose_
Freshta - / splendidly_misguided
Dania - / lady_narrator
For brands interested in partnering with Jubilee, email us:
hello@jubileemedia.com
Help us caption & translate this video!
amara.org/v/prQI/ - Zábava
Hey Everyone! Thank you for giving Spectrum a lot of love. This episode in particular was highly requested & we are excited to bring it to you. We are aware that this show & these 6 individuals don’t represent the whole Muslim community, but we hope this episode sparks dialogue amongst the good human fam.
Our team is working on ways to include you (yes, you!) in the prompt building process for Spectrum episodes, so stay connected with us on instagram.com/jubileemedia. We want to make sure everyone is heard & we’re asking the right things.
Let us know what prompts taught you the most below!
Jubilee thank you for making this video
The video was really good.
hey could you guys do voiceovers for the question portion its so hard to hear the questions with the echo and the caption for it goes by so quickly
Do all vegans think the same
Bring them
Please do change the intro - you missrepresent the guy with the broken arm!
Next : do all atheists think the same?
Jubilee promote anti male propaganda. Paid by feminist controlled media!
Obviously not. I used to be a big mouther atheist like Gervais 20 years ago and I since shut my mouth. I keep my beliefs for myself. I was made a godfather yesterday in a catholic church and played along with it and I'm happy. My rule is to not just shove your beliefs in other people mouths.
big balls uh they don’t? They made a whole video about on how they’re not a liberal propaganda platform
They don't... Atheism isn't an ideology nor relegion... It's simply a lack of belief.
I’d love that!!!! But there are so many people in that group I don’t know how they’ll be able to do that.
fact : reading the quran everyday doesn't mean understand it very well .
@leedee22 x science is included in the quran
I wish someone said this to purple scarf lady
@@denaier579 ''liberal muslim'' which doesnt make any sense
@@doha2939 well.... I think that is a Evoultion of religion, much like The idea of Libral Christianity use to be such a Drastic idea. But now its quite comon. It will just take time, but it will seam normal.
@@JesusChrist-sm4bm islam is available for every era and every place.
“I read Quran a lot of times and I understand it”
Her skipping the part about what happened to Lut(alaesalam) people👀
@🏴 Ebû Bekir Es-Siddîk🏴 she is one of the biggest liberals 🤦🏽♂️
@🏴 Ebû Bekir Es-Siddîk🏴 It’s true tho 🤷🏽♂️
LITERALLY
What happend??
@🏴 Ebû Bekir Es-Siddîk🏴 we can judge what is obvious. If the brother was to say she is a bad Muslim because of this than I would say he is wrong, but he is simply stating the fact that Muslims in America are struggling with coming to terms with true religion.
Im a Christian but I very much respect the guy in the white shirt because he’s actually using his source material and not making stuff up, a lot of my fellow Christian’s could learn from that bc half of us don’t even read scripture
As a former devout christian, I'd argue 95% or more of y'all don't, if not higher.
It is embarrassing how much christians don't know about the bible.
@@yingyang7448 it is embarrassing but the Bible warns Christian’s about this
wh ydoes it matter ur a christians u could of just said wha tu needed to say about broken arm guy
@@alehlete830
Proof read before you post.
@@alehlete830 English please
they confused the question “are women and men equal” with “are women and men the same”
That's a good point
randomm that’s true
so true
If they're not the same then why should they be equal.
@@FaaduProductions Tehy don't have the same body and stuff but they should be treated equally
Wrong title it should be "do all American muslims think the same"
@@Elijah666 That's great the world needs more progressive muslims, hope you're safe from the war in syria
@@Elijah666 I agree, Western media projects Islam and some parts of the world with Muslims as the majority of the population so differently to validate their political aims that some people think "Muslims from other countries are not as tolerant". I mean faith is about the person and their interpretation of the book as well as their experiences and relationship with God. It is not about any country. People seen on media are usually extremists and radicalized which does not, in any way, represent any population. There are a lot of Muslims in Europe and Asia but we always HAVE to think of the Middle East when speaking of Islam. This is a channel that casts speakers of English. Why don't we name other videos as "Do All American Feminists Think the Same" or "Do All American Atheists Think the Same" but this one? (I don't mean to aggravate but to form a conversation)
That's definitely not the case. Tolerence in Islam goes with the scriptures. Anything that contradicts with that is unacceptable. I am a proud muslim and I am happy with my spriptures that are from Allah.
True
MY DAD TRAVELED TO SAUDI ARABIA LIKE 20 YEARS AGO AND SAY A GROUP OF MEN BEATING UP A WOMAN BECAUSE SHE WASN'T WEARING HER HIJAB CORRECTLY
that purple hijab lady seems super “holier-than-thou” and wouldn’t even let the white shirt dude talk. he seemed really, really aware and as someone who’s considering reverting to Islam, I find myself curious with the values of Islam that he follows. he makes so much sense and sounds very intelligent. i’m also super impressed because it’s hard to stand up for a conflicting value in a room full of, well… conflict!
choices
🥩🏇
I personally wouldn't listen to any of them since they're nobodies, they're not Mufti's or anyone even near that level. As he mentioned, even he sins, we all do, we're not perfect. So the best thing would be to follow the Quran and the Hadiths of the Prophet PBUH
don't take our Islam values from this video search for scholars, Like Mufti menk and Zakr naik
Your gonna join a cult?
I think this challenge would be way different in an Arab country or an Arab society , because a lot of those questions were answered from a morale standpoint and not necessarily from religious view
the problem is most of the people force their opinions on Islam
“I read the Quran you cannot tell me anything” ignorance is bliss.
Yes
Yes
I disagree
@@ozurking4748 go home kid.
@@FollowPrincess no u
*white shirt guy gets ignored for 12 minutes and 58 seconds*
*STRAIGHT UP FACTS*
He was never, not once, ignored. They disagreed and had healthy conversation. They hugged and the one lady who also disagreed with him once or gave him a different perspective said at the end "I love how you brought a different perspective" to him.
Zeidan Reza he's not fully muslim so he doesn't understand islam that well, and he thinks he does, that's why they don't share his view . I personally don't believe he was ignored ,but he should learn more ,and then speak what's on his mind ,that confidently.
No
Zeidan Reza 😂😂😂😂
I grew up as a foreigner in a Muslim country. There is no way that you can argue that women and men are treated equal in the religion practice.
where did you grow up??
Definitely not. In islamic countries men and woman have different rules and expectations
Being equal doesn't mean that they should be treated in the same way
@@Fatemeh-qo4jy Women and men don't have free will to be either gender, so why treat them differently? Women should not be responsible for man's mistakes. Men are more promiscuous, they should cover not women.
Equality is bad, equity is what people should strive for.
they picked the wrong people
Fr, these people have little to no knowledge about Islam
There's always that *one person* in these videos
that one person is the person who always thinks outside the box. Those people are needed
Kenni Mac isnt true in this case.
@@paulvhs The guy was needed in this video. He brought up good arguments and the only thing the woman said was "well i've read the quran"
@@moneym3 she actually meant the woman in the purple headscarf... xD
Kenni Mac Exactly
I think Muslims vs ex Muslims would be very interesting to watch too
Same with Christian vs ex Christian.
Sana vs Yousef - Skam
Its no safe for the apostate to appear in public. Its just painting a target on them.
Yes I would watch that
@@Goudlock wow you're so edgy
White: actually read quran, purple: reads live laugh love quotes from social media
Now i think i'm better Muslim than they all are even tho i'm not actually Muslim. She even said that she read the Qur'an daily but she hugged that guy at the end of the video girl u can't even give him a handshake if he's not your husband.
Dont learn islam from these sourses plz
Islam is a beautiful relig9n and a peaceful too
It welcomes every race, color skin , language
Thank u very much
she also thinks that supportin LGBTQ is okay, hijab is not mandatory and denied all the intimidation in the Quraan💀.
She is probably Quran-only muslim.
Rejecting hadith and the orthodox sunni scholar tradition.
@@tasnimeow ikr nobody is talking about that💀☠️
@@tasnimeow everybody sins. you cannot say LGBTQ people cannot be part of the religion if you are, as you commit sins as well. islam does not support LGBTQ but it supports sinners, as everyone is a sinner
Whiteshirt guy:*breathes*
Purple scarf woman:"but i read the Quran everyday so you're wrong"
111th like
@@LIFEACADEMYindia proud of you
Lol
True
😂😂
"Do all suicide survivors think the same?" PLEASE like so jubilee can see this (attempt 2)
Omg I need this
I NEED THIS ASAP
Yes!!
I’m going to need a whole damn tissue box if this becomes an episode, please do it Jubilee!!
but how are they going to find them. and this is a really sensitive topic so..
Purple lady may have read the book well but she kinda failed to learn the basic life lessons through it
wtf how they are muslims and they say you can be LGBT and muslim?!
Agreed in islam its a sin
believe it or not, lgbt people sometimes are drawn to islam
@@motherknowsbest1192 Doesn't matter
Reading the Quran every day doesn't automatically mean you truly understand it. You might be reading it passively/on a surface level and not in-depth.
This is what usually happens with most muslims.
But u never know
Wut
Wut happenz. With most Muslim
@@khalidmohamud1537 they don't go in depth
*White Shirt Man* : disagree
*Purple woman* : I’m about to end this whole man career
3.3k likes ❤️
To be honest he was wrong on quiet few things but the purple women. Doesn't have much knowledge to answer him on the spot I made a comment and answered his questions
@@ThinkForward0 yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
True white shirt dude was right tho
He was and purple woman was annoying af
“Purple woman” I’m dead
Would love to see a middle ground of Muslims vs non Muslim middle easterns. As a Christian Iranian, I think that would be very interesting
bro these muslims are denying the quran in some parts.
yeah specially about LBGQ staff
like what ?? they didn't read the quran
this lady in the purple scarf ... let people talk 🤦🏾♀️
olivia rivera but she reads the quran, only she is right 😶😂
She wasn’t even that bad. Seriously people in the comments are so dramatic lol
Ik ppl like her. When they study and know so much they wanna share it. And sometimes they forget to let others chip in
You'r Mom she could have waited a little for the guy with the white shirt to finish his complete sentence but the way the comments and you guys make it seem is as if she was this super annoying rude person. People exaggerating to the max it’s hilarious lol
You'r Mom in the clips I’ve seen of him talking so far he was able to finish his thought. There was only one or two clips when he got cut off.
"I Read The Quran you cant tell me anything" how do you expect to have a conversation and learn if you aren't going to listen.
JTTV fr tho that lady was buggin😒
sowsow cool well unfortunately she was she was incorrect, 29 years of reading it and you haven't read the verse; she's masking her ignorance by showing here 'knowledge'. Just goes to show, time doesn't give you knowledge nor wisdom
It would be good to know what she means by read, is it just reading the text as in recitation, reading the arabic/english text with understanding of what the mean such as in reading a translation or reading with an understanding of the explanation of the verses and their context.
G Clowne Good point. But she meant read, not recite. She said she hasn't came across the verse within the years she 'read' it, her point was used to dismiss the guys claim of the verse existing, so if the read was used as recitation: it would be absurd.
She also pronounced it wrong
Wow. loved it!!!! Need more such videos it has evrything it shows us thinking also helps alot more people to clear their misconceptions .
Naoshad literally the most mature one here. Not only this he's honest as well. Both Naoshad and Nia have read Qur'an but but the way Nia debunked him when he disagreed on the equality point literally tells how many (not all) muslims says otherwise of the reality.
**Do all adopted (people) think the same?**
That's a good one.
oof. The internet is not ready for that one. Too many wet keyboards from the tears.
Omg I want this one
yeah
Viktor Björner yees that’s good
Next: do all the psychologists think the same?
Nice one.
That woulf be really interesting
YES
Oh yeas yes yesss
Stacey from dance moms would be funny for this one 😂
How string is the guy standing up against all of them about violence!! ❤️
Kudos to the guy who was brave enough to play devils advocate and force a more realistic and challenging discussion ♥️
-broken arm guy : I think...
-purple lady : *hold my Hijab*
green weaKnesseu wrong hijab*
Omg 😂
omgaad hhhhhh that was good
😂😂😂😂
green weaKnesseu are you muslim
"I READ THE QURAN YOU CAN'T TELL ME ANYTHING"
Muslim scholars memorize the book and still have discussions, this is not how you should act if you read the Qur'an daily.
The white t-shirts guy have a good point, but the purple scraf lady keep interrupt him.
If I were a non-moslem I would like to talk about Islam with the white t-shirts guy rather than a purple lady, he seems reasonable person and never "sugar coating" something within his religion.
what
@@dewaayodhyaa.9694 true, the Quran does say what he is talking about, and her way of response is why so many muslim kids grow up not understanding these points about their religion the right way.
The majority of muslims are ignorant to any kind of criticism of their religion.
Black girl needs to...stfu. she's ghetto proud go figure mannerisms match her anxiety and mentality ill tick. Someone must abused ther sht out her and her brain to b so unlikable
This video should be title as "American Muslim Liberal".
no single one of those women was covered properly
Not a single one of those were muslim
This spectrum episode did not have a healthy debate. Every time the guy with the white shirt disagreed and tried to argue back, they would shut him down. Disappointing.
Yes that is kind of true but it also shows that most questions that are asked about islam have an answers
it’s sad :( but good for him for not being scared to state his opinion no matter what
Exactlyyyyy
but he wasn’t exactly invested or fully educated about the main points of islam e.g he doesn’t understand the quran and alot of the questions he asked were answered soo
Even the video cut him off. Really sad.
‘I rEaD tHe qUraN dAilY’
So just because you do, which I respect, does not mean you’re always right with argument...
Well honey it's her opinion and these videos have diverse opinions if you find her wrong , educate yourself that there is no right or wrong there is just your opinion. Learn to widen your perspective 💙
Yep. That woman was condescending.
@@manishgunnala2881 the point is everyone is educated, but have different points to make. That's what makes the discourse so hard to have
And the question is, in wich language and do you understand the language. A lot of Muslims read it in Arabic and don't understand it.
TheAwkwardGuy Yes and that‘s our opinion. Learn to widen your perspective 💛
i love how proudly they are to be an american, i feel like thats so rare now, made me honestly tear up. Im ethiopian christain, but im truly american at heart, i've always loved america. murica baby
❤🇺🇸
The glazing is too much stop-
the "I read the quran" woman ... is the worst kind of people. I'm a muslim and I hate having to deal with those kind of people. and her info is wrong as well which is so bad.
I'm surprised they haven't done "do all atheists think the same"
maybe in the future.
they might be worried all the religious comments will get heated lol
Yes
Bruh they can only do one at a time be patient 😂
i've made so many comments that they should do that video but i'm still waiting on it
she switched hella fast when she saw that everyone prayed
Maybe she thought it was the opposite side?
Hahahahah
Dylan Baptist that’s most likely what it is. She was probably at first like “damn all you non praying heathen-oh wait I’m on the wrong side”
@@Dog3D that's probably gonna be me if I'm on the show 😂😂😂
she kept on switching in the other questions haha
My mom is protestant, my dad is taoïste, my mother in law is christian , my father in law is bouddhiste and my husband and I are atheist. Welcome to America! Open mind means also understanding that our believe is not the same for the person in front of us. Religion is personal matter and maintaining a neutral religious environment is also a kind way to welcome the other one.
Even though I'm somehow an ex-Muslim, I really like the guy with the broken hand. He's not afraid of discussing the contradictions between his mind and his religion. It can be seen very clearly on the "I believe men and women are equal" part.
Yeah exactly
I believe he will someday leave islam
He is so smart and intelligent
White shirt guy: breathes
Nia: that’s not Muslim
HAAHAHAHA! 😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Looks like we've got another Erin on our hands
Yours Truly 😭
At least she had her facts right 😭😭
White t-shirt guy: I believ...
lady in the purple hijab: I'm about to end this man's whole career.
Eissa Abd yeah so ignorant „reads the quran everyday“
Well the quran teaches to respect opinions and to discuss in kindness, looks like she is skipping many pages, she should cover her neck first.
anywasy i know what claims he his making... the problem is instead of clarifying the doubts he kept it within himself
But did she if she was willfully ignorant?
Eissa Abd I personally loved her😂😂😂 like YOU GO GURL
@@ochneeoder9252 RIGHT!
I am Indian,and we usually have so many conflicts with our neighbouring muslim country pakistan, so we always have a mindset that muslim religion is all about making women conservative ,just discouraging other religions,but i am very glad to see this side of muslim religion ❤️,and i so happy to discover its like every other religion,i think ideologies of muslim comunity should be spread by person who really knows ,what does muslim religion means,like 2 womens with black and purple hijab,not by the men who are always discouraging other religions ❤️after this video i definitely feel sorry muslim community,beacuse i am very accepting person,but interviews of muslim mulna's have set very diffrent narration in my mind
The 2 women doesn't know anything they are Americans who are not ready to gulp the truth about their religion or it will shake their beliefs
youre compassionate i respect that but you do not understand how diff. religions operate. muhammadism is completely dogma based not ritual or tradition based and just like any ancient dogma theyre backward and crappy. individuals may or may not believe certain things but it doesnt matter when state is ruled by sharia.
The white shirt guy was the kind of Muslim whom Islam needs
While the purple hijab lady is the one who had the mindset that escalates to the negatives. Just imagine her reactions and actions to others if she was so intolerant to the perspectives of someone who is a muslim himself but differs in opinion slightly.
Let alone listening or thinking, she did not even let him speak.
broken arm guy: i-
purple head scarf: I READ THE QURAN EVERY DAY
Yeah hahaha all the time. Ok you read that but just listen what he is saying and try to understand his point of view xD
Hijab not head scarf.
z z that’s not really a hijab but I don’t want to disguss✌️
@@HyPNoTiCMaN1 scarfs have a complety different look and I have that hijab so✌
z z 👌 If you say so
You did the guy with the broken arm dirty. You made it seem like he was against women's rights from the very first clip of him.
If you're a Deaf person you would think that. He's arguing that Islam says men and women aren't equal.
@@dontignorewatchme5851 What does being deaf have anything to do with it? From the first clip it seemed like he was against women's rights, and I'm hearing.
@@dontignorewatchme5851 but from the first clip alone it looked like he was against women's rights. I recognise that his actual argument is that Islam doesn't think women are equal to men and thag doesn't agree with that. However the first clip doesn't portray that view correctly to a viewer who leaves the video early before watching for context.
His arguments and contreversies are completely false and useless because everything prohibited and allowed has been mentioned and explained in the Quoran and anyone whos against it or tries to dive deeper into it is not a muslim or a beleiver at all
As someone who despises religions , i agree.
Husna's speech was just beautiful!!!
All of these people are so beautiful and I adore them all!!
"I pray with one hand and commit sin with the other" is that why your wrist is broken my guy
what a intelligent post
LOL
😂😂💯💯
💀💀
Pumpkin Spice Bleach lmao
The title should've said "Do all AMERICAN muslims think the same"
These are hired actor
@@ahmadhiyyastudentchannel8232 no they're just local professionals, likely with moderate social media presence. Likely paid yes, but not paid to give certain input
Yeah cuz Im from Turkey and I dont think the same with them. It RLLY should be that kind of a title you said.
I shouldn't watch this video mainly they have such modern- "westernized" perspectives and not following the kitab and sunnah.
Yeah. LGBTQ+ is strongly prohibited in the religion of Islam. Anybody that disagrees with me go look at the teaching of prophet lut.
No, it's not you can't be a Muslim and LGBT,
Blessings be upon you
It would also be nice to have muslims from places like Indonesia, Singapore and central Asia, theres an abismal diference between midle estern muslims and every other muslims.
White Shirt Guy: *exists
Purple Woman: Ummmm, excuse me, I read the Qu’ran soooo, you’re wrong
She's the Muslim Karen
it really be like that
And what did you expect? Quran is like google who has every single fact to Muslims
feminist
@@zainraad7862 false... if there is a modern problem.. it require modern solutions and keep in mind what is the purpose of quran. You cant always rely and seek for answers from evety single problems you face with quran.
White Tee guy: “thats ok but i-“
Purple scarf: *”nO. Quran All DAY BrO!”*
"I read in the Quran everyday, not once has I gotten to a verse about violence."
*/ignore*
Seriously, it's fine to highlight all the positive things about your religion, but violence is a part of every one of them and oh boy is there a lot of it in the Quran. That comment really proved how ignorant she is...
Octrox I think she meant in the terms on being aggressive towards people for no reason which the other women did explain why those verses were mentioned but the women in the purple Hijab was trying to be ignorant or dodge the questions which as a Muslim is annoying
@@Octrox Yeah. Some people choose to be blind
Octrox My mind is baffled on how she walked in and expected everyone to have the same opinion. Did she not think someone was going to go against hers? Even when they did, they weren’t bias or anything. It’s just plain arrogance.
Vaporwave what’s annoying was that she claims to read the Quran a lot but ignores the others you can’t do that it’s wrong it’s an open discussion
There are way more differences between muslims and that's mainly because of the language of the Quran even for me
a native Arabic speaker and an Exmuslim who further studied and learned more about Arabic
There are alot of verses in Quran that can be interberted in different ways
And others that is impossible to understand or conflict with science and reality there is even verses that conflict with other verses.
which ones conflict with science or conflict with eachother?
You can't do your own interpretation of Quran no matter how much you learn Arabic if the interpretation going against the interpretation of prophet Muhammad sallalahu alaihi wasallam, hes our teacher and he taught us the explanations!
@@voiceforpalastinerohingyau2507 Yeh islam is not a religion of peace though, agreed? Please stop bringing your values to western countries, you don't see me try to enforce my westerns beliefs on your country when I go there on vacation either.
As a Muslim who sins more than not, I struggle everyday with considering myself a “bad Muslim” I fear gods punishment every single day because I know I deserve it
The lady in the purple hijab was extremely defensive and closed minded to the ideas of others and listening. I wanted to hear the guy in the white talk more but I felt he was under attack. I wish this dove deeper.
Agreed, this is a form of censorship, not good at all. This happens when you put your feelings above facts
UH for GOOD reason, he was totally misconstruing Islam.
@@fleabag6477 He was quoting the Quran verbatim, how was he misconstruing it?
why don't you get that this is a religion with rules not opinions
curly I feel he was bringing up criticism of Islam to raise the question, not necessarily disagreeing with everything the group was saying. I would have liked to hear him finish his thought process before I judge.
The girl with the black hair is always changing her mind 😂
True lol, but I liked her. She made some good points.
Yeah I think she's a bit of a conformist.
Ikr idk if she was thinking about it or basing her opinion of the others... 🤔🤔🙄
Lol I noticed that 😂
TeoGPanda :3 they all have black hair lol
I'm a Muslim ummah, Alhamdullilah, i come back to this, particularly where husna said what she said during the prompt LGBT just so i keep living life but it's hard
Please do this but with Muslims in the UK, I can't - like I literally can't - with American Muslims.
Muslims in the UK, especially young ones are more tolerant and compariable with American Muslims. If you get a salt-and-peppered beard Mullah, yeah, those guys are wanting to see heads roll. Please do not harm people.
ikr. Go do this in speakers corner in London...
Wow dude could not speak without getting interrupted
Ikr let him speak, he was basing his answers off specific quran verses unlike them females
@@gracee6979 lol, them females
@@gracee6979 exactly
@@aaronlee6361 hahahha idk why I wrote that but it felt right 😂
Because he was being a realist and had critical thinking skills of actually criticising the wrongs in the religion. That's why he got shut.
that girl changing lines every 2 seconds is a MOOD
Woman*
@@javiercrespo4939 that Woman* Girl* Female* Human* is still a Mood tho
Marry* me*
WTF???*
i think she just forgot which side is agree and which is disagree cause "our" agree is on our right side and her left side yknow what i mean
islam doesnt promote violence, the people of islam do. dont blame Islam.
Do you know , what's really funny is that no one of those girls is wearing the hijab properly
And we should all understand that it doesn't matter what Muslims think what matters is what Islam realty teaches
@@voxlinou Why don't you read the Quran and find out for yourself what Islam teaches?
@@voxlinou You really need to read the book before critiquing it as if you know what is in it lol.
Next: Do All Atheists Think the Same?
Madelyn Huntington I’d love to this conversation too!
Yesssse
Do all non-stamp collectors think the same?
Yes please do this!!
Yee
purple scarf girl needs to learn that not everyone out there is trying to make her think differently. very close minded, needs to listen more and talk less.
Heather Rasmussen okay youtube comment reply girl
Heather Rasmussen calling you youtube comment reply girl is a strong talk? Hahaha, no, I’m not a satanist, but I’m pretty dure they wouldn’t have assumed my whole beliefs because of a profile picture
True
That’s what religion does to people a lot of the times.
That's exactly what I was thinking of too.. People like her are the ones who starts fights in debates.
I love to see this spectrum bc i can see perspectives from other people. Im not that religious but it's a little bit dissapointing how clash some of their opinions are from what our prophet taught us
imo, the broken arm guy and the girl with the black hijab with the red outfit made sense the most. they were respectful and self aware of everything that was happening.
Suggestion:
Do all atheists think the same?
DJW 2014 I thought they’d done that one! Sorry if I’m wrong xx
@@rhyanashah128 I don't think they have.
DJW 2014 oh sorry! I think I was thinking of their series Middle Ground instead
@@rhyanashah128 lol it's okay :)
I want to be on that one haha
Bro don’t clickbait White T-shirt guy, that’s not fuckin fair man! I hated him in the first seconds then I realized he’s the most level-headed logical one out of all of them
Edit: this is the first comment I’ve ever made that has gotten this big and I’m so ready for all the incoming hate and misinterpretations heheh
succ me off same 😂😂😂
So you just admitted to hating him without knowing him?
@@ibraheem9492 that's how people are nowadays
cheeto we all do that at some point . At least he admits it lol
succ me off yes I loved what he said a lot and how he was trying to understand others and how he was able to dissect stuff
"It's really comforting to know that you don't have to support a lifestyle to support a human being, to love a human being." A delusional mindset, especially when that lifestyle is a part of the person's identity and a fact of their existence. Love and tolerance aren't the same thing.
the hijab question has always had me curious. i know that we should dress modest but i dont recall ever hearing anything about the hijab. ive been told i have to but im not sure
yes it is in the quran
Guy in white: I believe that-
Lady in purple hijab: But I read the Quran EVERYDAY
And it’s obvious that she doesn’t lmao
Ser Kraus ikr
what she meant was that he cannot state something about the Quran that is incorrect, she reads it everyday therefore she has knowledge, she didnt mean any harm, calm down
@@sowsowcool2586 She was actually the one who was incorrect though. The Qur'an directly contradicts what she said. Maybe she reads the Qur'an everyday but only started a couple weeks ago so has only read the start?
The lady in the purple hijab doesn't give proper educated answers.
I agree to an extant. I agree with a lot of her sentiments but she needs to provide more evidence for her claims. Red sweater girl was awesome though, she provided the context, information, and Islamic scholarly interpretation. She really knew what she was talking about no doubt became she had a proper education in understanding Islam!
She reads the quran ugh she was so annoying I think shes a revert
She keeps using the quraan to prop herself up
Chantaya no, she wasn’t being cut off, LMAO. she cut people off the most.
Education vs religion...thats where it gets weird....fact vs myth
Real cool vid just hoped that when people disagreed they'd have more time to speak, specifically in that section about being in equal in Islam.
those muslims are considered very liberal and open minded actually, if they bought some strictly religious ppl, the entire conversation would be filled with sexism and homophobia
if you brought strict anyone to anything he would be strict... why are muslims special case there?
there is no strict religious people, only believers and non believers, it is the bare minimum that they must follow
Canmot agree more 💯
"I'm a contradictory human being, I pray with one hand and commit sin with an other" best lines
Ironic that one of his arms was broken LOL
@@whitneytan2330 lol yeah
That’s actually a verse from the Bible
@@maryelizabethparker2106 Well in Islam, they do believe that Christianity was the predecessor to Islam so they're likely to share beliefs.
He's genuine and honest and kinda holds himself accountable which is a great sign of maturity I find
No offence, but I was kinda feeling bad that the white shirt one didn't get to express his opinions openly without getting interrupted just because they were different.
Mainly the women in the purple
heights of abnormality that’s what they do.
He seems to have been the smartest and most through and unemotional in his responses.
Women in purple was and acting like she is the only one that reads quran
heights of abnormality muslims like the other ppl are like that they think that they’re always right and god was at their home giving them private tutoring telling them what’s wrong and what’s right
the woman in purple is such an american 🙄
I am not Muslim but have read the Quran because I am interested in understanding religions and looking for the similarities. As an outsider that strictly knows the words of the Quran and not someone who follows the teachings/interpretations the guy in the white shirt was most representative and the others focused more on interpretation vs written word.
So you're fluent in Arabic?
Nia is kinda annoying with her "I read the quran so stfu dont argue with me" attitude, especially when the other guys brings up correct verses from the quran.
I'm muslim btw and I agree with her on some points but ffs let the others speak.
And then she goes ahead and says you can be part of LGBT community and be muslim at the same time. That makes 0 sense it's like saying you can be hindu and eat cow meat..
@@yugandamirai6422 I agree with the fact that she just give the " I READ THE QURAN" argument
She doesn't know anything about Islam. That's the problem that reverts have. And she sounds like a radical feminist and she talks like every black Muslim is an American revert
@@yugandamirai6422 But You can i mean it is a Sin but it doesn't make you a Non Muslim?? Plz lighten me up if im wrong
_
broken arm guy, you da real mvp for bringing up different sides to basically all the prompts
Khaled Ryaz he basically did what no one else wanted to do.
Agreed!
He was the only one with the balls to face facts all the others wanted to make it out to be the perfect peaceful religion and its not I know that first hand I read the Quran I looked into its details the dark parts that everyone ignores like the purple lady I grew up in a Muslim country and I agree with everything he said am very sure that he renounced his faith or will in the near future once you reality you can't ignore it
poor opinion
@@imensalhie1128 correct
I really enjoyed this segment. Honestly, I'd have to say that I'm not too fond of Nia's disposition. You come to something where people have the opportunity to hear each other out, and you keep saying "...and nobody's going to change my thoughts, or talk me out of it." I am not saying leave there and change your whole, but listen...we're on this planet together to learn from each other.
The guy with glasses is the one making the most sense if you actually grow up muslim and studied Islam
The rest just wanna try to show a perfect image of islam but this guy isn't afraid to talk about questionable and unfair parts
The lady in the purple hijab saying “I read the Quran” reminds me of the lady from the previous video saying “That’s not vegan” 😂
Omg, that lady is Erin 😂
So in a way every community has an Erin :D
Monique Desireé ERIN AHHHH 😂😂
ahaha Erin 💀
Same😂🔫
white shirt guy: i-
purple lady: *YOU’RE WRONG*
She was so closed minded 😂
Lmao
Huh
all of them : same thots
white shirt guy : i have disagree for no reason
@@Hi-lg1lz wow thanks for this comment
It maaaaade my day
بارك الله فيك
8:35 makes me really sad to see strongly agree because they must not know the stories of the prophets (Story of LUT) obviously you can be but it’s incredibly contradicting
Wonderful! Learned a lot!
“i pray with one hand and commit sin with the other”
me- is that why u have a cast on one hand and the other one is fine😂😂😂
Hahaha good one
navya vadlamudi I thought the same thing 😱😂😂😂
In my opinion that's not funny to joke about.
OMG LOL
@@tulay4530 no I disagree the core of humor it's being about dark stuff and it's alright unless it contains alot of hating
You can tell which ones you wouldn’t be able to have a genuine conversation with
Purple scarf...
Hehe she is from Afghanistan and i am too :)
*cough* *cough* purple scarf lady
Shout out to my sister FRESHTA, whenever we are, coming from or going to, we are Afghan first. I love it... but one thing though HUSNA is like a typical afghan woman maybe she´s not but she´s a lot like it!
Muslim men can marry outside their religion and women cant lol
Very big point
No
i will reply to this quickly. can a non muslim husband ensure her the same values that islam ensures to women?
Religions are not the problem, people are the problem(closed minded people).
Agree 👍
agree😔👍
Purple girl: strongly disagree
@The Wondering Angler yea but the concept itself isn't evil,it's how it's used as a tool really. You can use religion to build a loving community and you can use it to put fear onto others it's all about which one u choose
agree 💜👍
The white shirt guy : (anything )
Purple scarf: That is not true I read the Quran
Hahah true
problem is with both. white shirt guy would state things he knows the context but wouldnt label the context with it to show how it can be miss understood by outsiders and then the women is saying basically she knows the context but all the white shirt dude was saying is that without the context this is how ppl miss understand it lol
White shirt guy:wait can we stop recording I need to go to the bathroom
Purple scarf:that’s not true I read the Quran 34 times in my life
I am a proud Muslim myself. And what yes the guy in the white has an opinion but the women in purple is just telling him what is right and wrong. And you shouldn’t be hating on her and being disrespectful towards her for correcting him! I personally don’t read the Quran as much as I wish and hope I would but many of my Islamic elders and teachers have guided me and I basically live on what the Quran says. As a Muslim we must be there to correct and guide our brothers and sisters and TEACH them what god has sent down to us! And the guy in the white shirt HAD his say and as u saw a lot of them agreed with him but again she just wanted to make sure he understood what he was saying and to correct him! Now stop hating and being disrespectful to someone who you wouldn’t understand. xoxo
Masroor Zaidi it’s true. Most of what he’s saying is incorrect
I think the lady with the purple scarf turns a blind eye to the verses she doesnt like to stay confortable but when we believe in a religion like islam we must believe in it whole heartedly.
There is only a miniscule portion discussing violance in the quran but it is all in self defense. But self defense and war is still violance, but the only kind that can be justifiable and is needed.