Fact: The Star Wars are ALL Jar Jar’s Fault! | Gnoggin
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 12. 2015
- You’ve never heard it like this before! Here we’ll explore every detail found in the Star Wars trilogies and find out just how much blame Jar Jar Binks can account for! Everything from the death of the Jedi, to the destruction of Alderaan can be traced back to his nefarious deeds! But what gets crazy, is that they aren’t his fault by mistake! Let’s look at the evidence and see how Jar Jar was initially planned to be a Sith Lord! AND why it was all changed! - - - This video is chapter based, so you can come back and watch other parts later by clicking on these links:
Part 0: Intro and Canon: 0:01
Part 1: Jar Jar's Character 5:10
Part 2: Use of the Force 12:17
Part 3: Episode I Plot Points 21:54
Part 4: Foreshadowing & Tidbits 27:06
Part 5: The Big "Why?" 32:12
Part 6: The Future of Star Wars: 41:17
Curious about what games I recommend? Click here: bit.ly/1OQVQo2
Support Gnoggin on Patreon!
/ gnoggin
Facebook: tinyurl.com/lmqr4zm
Tumblr: / gnoggin
Twitter: / lockstin
Music:
"Echoes of Time v2" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Egmont Overture" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Minima" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Impact Lento" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Hero Down" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Orion 300XB" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Our Story Begins" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Private Reflection" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
“Also Sprach Zarathustra” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Tempting Secrets" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Discovery Hit" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Are all licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
CGI Snake by Chris Zabriskie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
Source: chriszabriskie.com/divider/
Artist: chriszabriskie.com/
Video Game OST used under Fair Use:
“Phendrana Drifts” - Metroid Prime - Nintendo
“Title Theme” - Metroid Fusion - Nintendo
“Sans” - Undertale - Toby Fox
Outro Music by Kubbi:
goo.gl/GxFXFA
www.kubbimusic.com
No copyright infringement was intended, if I have used something of yours and missed the credit, please contact me through the Facebook link above and I can add your credit.
...
...
...
Can you really believe it?
Jar Jar is a Sith!
Jar Jar is an evil Sith Mastermind!
Jar Jar is Snoke! (well not that one)
Jar Jar is on the Dark Side!
So how was my explanation of the Jar Jar Theory?
Is it believable?
Or is it just a crazy fan theory?
A conspiracy theory even.
Did George Lucas abandon the Jar Jar plot twist?
Tell me what you think down below! You’ve read this far into the description so you must be dedicated! - Hry
![tattoo printer tutorial[제품단순선물]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g40_GwEJak0/mqdefault.jpg)
when I think of jar jar revealing himself as sith I imagine him starting out saying "me'sa had you" in his happy voice then continues in a smooth intellgent deep voice "fooled the whole time"
Yes. All my yes.
Yeah, kind of like Tobi in Naruto Shippuuden :D Would have been awesome
And then he draws two lightsabers , his face stern yet his eyes filled with sickening humour. He raises his hand and clenches his fist. Yoda is throw back with such force he had never encountered.
Obi Wan saw the jedi master slam into the wall and was filled with anger. He swings a strike to the left with his lightsaber, but it is stabbed with an iron wall of force.
"Weak. Pitiful." He says as he slashed Obi- Wans hand off. He cried out in pain and sank to his knees, eyes glazed over as he beheld the charred stump of where his hand once was.
Jar Jar laughed as he advanced on the prone figure of Yoda, lightsabers moving in menacing circles towards the ancient jedi...
Sir BigBeard holy crap that would be awesome
:P I'm a bit of a writer, just busted that out last night
Meesa been discovered! Yousa will suffer the wrath of Darth Jar Jar!
Oh holy bantha poo
I am willingly applying for the position of your right hand bodyguard
I will serve you my Lord
I shall follow you as your humble servant my master.
Darth is too low rank, i suggest emperor
I can’t believe this didn’t go through. This could have genuinely been the greatest plot twist in cinema history.
Jimmy Kudou would be like, "Why didn't I see it before?", in his head, lmao!
Aoi not to mention this would have been the first set of trilogies to go straight to VHS and other home media outlets. Meaning by the time the third one came out many people would have owned the first one.
Imagine the excitement of fans to receive that twist and anxiously running home to watch the 1st and 2nd movies like “OMG THE SIGNS WERE THERE THE WHOLE TIME!!!”
There would have been analysis of every hint, the films honestly would have been praised as the movies that fooled the world.
But we got this... and idk, it’s just sad tbh
Huh. I just saw your comment on am IHE video. We meet again!
Declan Kirby ooh nice! Which one?
@@killerkitten7534 "I hate the rise of skywalker" i think? Or it could have been I hate deviantart.
You left off: that anytime someone insults him, they tend to die or find themselves in peril, he is present during every major event and assassination, people constantly mistake him as a force user, he controls creatures, he is introduced in a scene very reminiscent of where the bio-weapon lab was on Naboo, he is almost never questioned about his activities, he was "banished" and now he's back, and when the Chancellor is doing his astronaut walk, Jar Jar is right next to him.
I mean there was an episode in the clone wars where they thought he was a Jedi and pretty much saved padme from the federation
@@sml2k186 still remember that and the fact he can climb buildings.
You get a like for the "astronaut walk" .
The best part about him being "banished" is how the Gungans don't act like they're bothered that a clumsy idiot came back, but rather get absolutely terrified.
And this isn't because of Qui-Gon or Obi-Wan (As the Gungans simply considered themselves superior to the Naboo, they didn't exactly fear them). So, what were they scared of?
So long since watched prequels. Care to give examples of guys that insulted him and later died?
I personally think that if they kept Jar Jar Binks being a Sith Lord would of redeemed his character!
It would of repainted him as a bumbling idiot to be a cold calculating lord of evil. Fixing the issues people had with him.
+Matthew Smith How Jar Jar Binks was in the actual movie: generic dumb unfunny comic relief that's arguably a racist black guy stereotype.
How he was originally: actually badass character, and for the that matter, an actual character
Racist depiction of a black guy? Being a black guy, no. I'd say he's a Jewish stereotype.
Joe Olson Exactly! Lucas should of fallowed through with his original vision!
If he did the Prequels would of been way better!
... Well at least a little bit better.
hedgehogsonic11 read somewhere that he was apparently that.....
hedgehogsonic11 His actor, a black male, was shown several times in the video. I would assume that is where the "Racist depictions of a black guy" stemmed from.
Just imagined Jar Jar suddenly standing up completely straight, starts talking in his sith voice without any weird grammar, while some sort of menacing music stats playing. This could have easily rivaled the Yoda scene in Ep V, where he instantly switched from goofy to wise in the blink of an eye...
There's a scene where Jar Jar listens to Anakin and Qui Gon's conversation on coruscant.
Imagine you hear a very deep voice by a hooded person with a red lightsaber saying "you will die" and he takes the hood off and its jar jar
@@thebestfreakingamer4316 Apparently the whole threat behind Armidale life in Episode 2 was going to be Darth Jar Jar and Jango Fett was working for him. Obi-Wan would spy on Darth Jar Jar not Dooku and he’d get captured and he’d reveal himself and his plan I guess and what he’s actually doing in the Phantom Menace. Lkie fooling hem all starting the war, manipulating people’s words or minds searching for the chosen one that he and Palpatine created, and bringing him back to Coruscant.
@@knightwarrioranimations9656 I knew some of that
Don't forget to play Lego Star wars the Skywalker saga in the character customization you can make jar jar Binks real as a sith Lord everybody knows it's true they just don't say it because they're intimidated by his presence.
Darth jar jar is here he is going to get us developers we're working on fixing the bug in the game but unfortunately we can't delete the code for Darth jar jar in the character customization files I'm telling you don't play the game with this character please.
This message is brought to you by a developer from Tt games™
Remember don't play as Darth jar jar he is a fake character he is not real if you encounter him please contact our Devs.
Jar Jar returning in Episode 9 as the big bag would've unironically been a bigger and better twist than Palpatine surviving a death star explosion.
A twist needs foreshadowing, Palpatines survival was just extremely bad writing, a lack of ideas and uncertainty how to even wrap up things after the last jedi. If you watch ep 7 and 8 nothing even remotely hinds to the idea that Palpatine is still alive, not to mention that they revealed it months earlier in a fortnite event of all things.
@@brotbrotsen1100 Its not like Star Wars has ever had particularly good writing. It's sort of all about the visuals.
@@Space_Ghost_Hunter the bad writing is only bad if you don't understand writing
@Stvy14 Ehhh, that's kind of a cop-out. I understand the writing just fine, (again it's not exactly deep or complex.) Not to mention the entire thing is pretty much a ripoff of Logans Run. I'm not sure what there is to misunderstand about space knights fighting really uninteresting wars that constantly recycle the same 4 villains over the span of like 9 movies?
That unironically would've made me love Episode 9.
Jar jar is responsible for the original trilogy too.
He was also the one who made Anakin start to have feelings for Padme.
Not to mention the whole reason they landed on Tattoine.
He and Palpatine both from the same planet.
If that was part of the plan,it means he purposely breaks the rule of two...But i could see it,cuz he is the master.Sidious constanly sets up competition for his aprentice and only punishes violation of that rule as soon as they start teaching their own students.A spark of reality after all,rules usually rn't binding for rulers.
@@phorz85 the sith broke the rule of two all the time. Especially during Palpatines time.
Jar jar is a scapegoat too.
Sith constantly break the rule of two in all cannon lore. Mostly to attempt to kill their master 😂 with the help of their apprentice.
And in legends, after all the rule existed not in the old republic...
so that's why he can double jump in LEGO Star Wars: the complete saga
But so can other gungans
TheTTVCrew like today species natural gifted in light side of the force maybe gungans naturally are dark force users
@@HeWhoDaresEhDel But it's just a gungan thing that they programmed in the game
TheTTVCrew not saying it's not most most of Star Wars after the originals were poorly planned therefore the execution was bodged. But it would make sense if jar jar was meant to be the big bad and I'm pretty convinced he was thought about to be by Lucas. It would make sense that gunguns were naturally soaked in the dark side of the force a ying to the yang of yodas species we know gunguns were described to be a warrior race and it's my guarantee that yodas were in Lucas head to be pacifist type species
@@HeWhoDaresEhDel I never said that was wrong bro. I just said that the reason he can double jumpe in the Complete Saga isn't because he can use the dark side
He's even smiling during Qui-Gonn's funeral. You have to look very closely.
And remember every little movement is animated ergo on purpose.
The first fully-computer generated character in a live-action film,[1]
What u mean by smiling
Meesa smiled because when heesa died meesa no longer served himsa a life debt.
@@wattobinks5785 yousa failed then!
He’s not smiling
There is also a comic where jar jar expertly uses a light saber and immediately acts like it was an accident
Ohh I remember that comic! That was awesome
29:29 that definition of "Phantom" seems to suit Jar Jar in a more literal sense, in that he's a CGI character, with no "physical reality or material substance"........
HOLY SHI----
That is even scary...!
That’s false
He does have physical reality and material substance
now you gone n make ahmed best cry again
His eyes are red and yellow. Theres only 4 characters with eyes like that and 3 of them have names beginning with Darth
Jon Luther Darth Michael Jackson
Darth jar jar
Palpatine, Maul, Vader, and Greivious right
Well, most other gungans have yellow eyes, right?
Are all gungans sith lords, then?
Darth Boss Nass is my favourite sith lord.
Jon Luther no they don’t my eyes are purple
Vader: I am your father!
Jar Jar (appearing behind Vader's back): That's what YOU think...
Vader: NoooooooooooooO!
Wait so luke is the son of a
whatever jar jar is
Mesa sorry! Mesa didn’t pull out!
@@funnyandclevername5599 this made my day🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. Aftwr a long stress filled day, this laugh was needed. Thank you for brightning up my day. ROTFL.
@@funnyandclevername5599 Noice!
Star Wars Fans: **complain for changes**
Also Star Wars Fans: **Complain about changes**
George Lucas: “Hold on... this whole operation was your idea”
I get it
Ahhhh, I see what you did there XD
My problem is, if they _were_ going to do this, the whole point would be that we'd find him annoying and stupid, then be blown away that was on _purpose,_ so...I mean you cant change a character because fans complain they're annoying if being annoying is the point. I mean, of course we were going to hate him if that was the _point._ Just ride the hate out and wait till we all feel like idiots for not figuring out what was going on
@@bloodyneptune Fans have to remember that because Jar Jar got so much hate, his actor almost killed himself. I mean, yeah, you don't like the character, that's fine, but Ahmed Best still got the worst of the backlash.
@@AkiraStrix94 I never hated jar jar binks.
Who else looked at Xanth and thought “That’s goddamn Florida!”
Brian Foote that’s the gag of the book series
Bink = Florida Man
To me it was italy
A Sith for Chameleon
Everyone
The Jar-Jar hate was all the MORE reason to keep the Dark Jar-Jar storyline. Most of the complaints were that he was annoying and a irrelevant distraction, this reveal would have demonstrated that the annoying idiocy and seemingly ridiculous luck were both tricks and that he was anything BUT irrelevant as the Big Reveal brought the anti-Jar Jar rage to a screeching halt. If they'd kept this storyline there probably would have been a lot less hate for the trilogy overall.
I don't know who I should blame. The fans for hating him so much or Lucas for chickening out because of the backlash.
I'm going with Lucas because if he had gone through with the Jar Jar plot twist it would have made for one of the best reveals since "I am your father".
Lucas is to blame. Mostly that he tryed to write this all himself look at the bad edits in the originals with people to stop him mess like the prequels happen.
He could have written him funny and lovable instead.
Is it possible that George Lucas was forced to change the Jar Jar plot by executives who demanded less Jar Jar after seeing the backlash? Lucas's hand may have been forced from above rather than him willingly backing down on it. If executives see Jar Jar's name to be mud they're not going to let him be plastered all over the next two movies in fear of them bombing.
Jar Jar would me many people's favorite character for the same reason almost everyone likes thrawn.
My master has been exposed :(
Darnet
Stupid People do it
sad just sad
aw shet
Emperor Palpatine LOL
I’m surprised you didn’t mention the theory that Jar Jar deliberately made them all go to Tatooinie to retrieve Anakin and bring him to Coruscant. After all, it’s been established that Palpatine was the one who manipulated the Force to create Anakin, so if Jar Jar was working for/with Palpatine, getting Anakin to Coruscant was necessary to their plan.
This is why fans need to stop b*tching about things so much. We could have gotten something awesome out of Jar Jar and a twist that surpassed Vader being Luke’s father. But because they complained so much, Lucas had to change things, and we got what we got. Imagine how amazing it would have been if Jar Jar suddenly dropped his dopey act and revealed he was a sinister master manipulator and Sith Lord.
Yeah, it's quite sad that fans screams about things. But I would have loved if Lucas had stuck with his original idea like: "Oh boy do I got a twist for you fans!"
Actually, Anakin's father was Darth Plagueis. He manipulated the midi-chlorians inside Shmi Skywalker's womb and created life, as Palpatine implies. So Palpatine and Plagueis were responsible for Anakin's existence. There is no other way Anakin could have fallen to the Dark Side so easily. Luke also had attachments, but he didn't fall, like his father did.
In the comics it's revealed that jar jar's buffoonish behavior is literally just a act just to gain political power without doing any work and is fast to gain it
@@mrnukes797 Are these comic even Canon?
@@mrnukes797
Which is why the theory of him being Darth Plagueis makes sense, but we never got that awesome twist because fans complained about him so much, so instead he remained an annoying comic relief.
I personally think this theory is just far too solid to be dismissed. As you said, it ALL wraps together by the end. I think they should have kept him as the main villain, especially because he was hiding in plain sight from the very BEGINNING before Sidious was even introduced.
Should've have toned down the dorkiness
Episode 9: No one is ever really gone
Jar jar binks: exactly
If they reveal something about Jar Jar in Star Wars IX, the theory is completely truth for me. I'm 99% believing in that but if we see something about him I'll be 100%, no doubt
meesa baaaaaack
No one:
Everyone: Yo what's up man!
Someone needs to edit the trailer and replace the emperor’s laugh with Jar Jar saying something
Meesa Back!!!
Looking at Jar Jar past his comedy, he seems pretty creepy. The way he looks at people almost with hatred.
i know created like that on purpose since he was animatedcreepy
Unfortunately the fact it took 15 odd years for this to come out means either Lucas and co had no intention of Darth Jar Jar or they hid the evidence too well. I think it would have been better if they cut out Jar Jar's goofiness in 3 or 4 scenes and had a questionable or mysterious ending with Jar Jar and Palpatine in episode 1. Imagine seeing Jar Jar's "Sith" eyes but him not stepping in animal poo and knowing Jar Jar can do a standing 20ft jump but not electricuted by the pod racer. Some simple tweaks and i think the character becomes much less hated and gets the audience questioning some of things he said and did.
Dark side is chaos. An "unpleasant break or conflict in rhythm, flow, or transition" - is chaos. Jar Jar is not clumsy - he's chaotic. He's not not lucky - he's spreading chaos around. He's sewed of chaos, he's pure chaos himself, he irradiates it all around and all his actions and behavior emphasize that. He's the master of chaos.
That's why he says stay away. Dark side is just a pov and he is literally saying just stay away , from the [insert quote here(dark side of the force) ]as a quote "stay away" and from being me ie dark side so what is water is the darker form of the force and light is the 'good' side of force meaning bigger fish and whatever yoda is fighting for supremancy
He was 100% animated, this means all his subtle movements hand motions were all done on purpose. I'm so sad they didnt go through with this. Him being dumb was all planned. Him and Palpatine are even from the same planet!
Jar Jar supersedes Palpatine. Even he was manipulated by Jar Jar without even knowing it. This wouldve been the greatest storyline ever.
The first fully-computer generated character in a live-action film,[1]. I don't think they spent the cash required for that on a useless character. Also he's in a lot of important scenes, and the more you watch his scenes the more obvious it becomes. He uses different levels of stupid to trick certain people.
@Edmond Schwab No Jar Jar is Plagueis. Think about it, in Star Wars NO Sith has ever turned on their master alone, it's always the Master, The Apprentice and the New Apprentice, but Palpatine doesn't seem to have a concrete apprentice, even Maul was fairly new in Episode I. That is because Palpatine was not ready to betray Plagueis. But as we would have seen at the end of Episode III, he would have, or perhaps Yoda and Plagueis dueled and Yoda defeated the Master but not the Apprentice.
However, Lucas got bullied by people calling themselves "fans" out of using Jar Jar and changed his story to exclude Jar Jar, so he changed Plagueis' species and had Palpy kill him in his sleep.
@@Illusionistical822 After i saw The Rise of Skywalker yesterday and watched this it would somehow make sense to see him in Future
Blaze Escamilla
Go read the books then...
If that was his original intent for jar jar it would be in the episode 1-2-3 books.
That we had almost 2 decades before a movie.
I love this theory-
However here's where I bury all continuity of sense within it.
Ben Skywalker was originally the name of Luke's son.
(Via books)
Han Solo's child never killed him
But did turn to the Darkside.
Now Chewy did die saving the children of Han.
The new trilogy is heavily changed from it's source material.
Boba Fett lives- in the books timed after Return of the Jedi.
If Jar Jar is important----
He will be portrayed in text the same way.
the prequels would have been so amazing if Jar Jar was the bad guy. Imagine Obi-Wan's reaction to finding out that his longtime friend was a sith that he completely missed.
now, imagine the teaser for The Force Awakens. Vader's burned helmet appears on screen. A wizened amphibious hand rests atop it. A goofy, but aged voice croaks from the darkness as yellow eyes appear. "Meesa gonna avenge you, Ani...."
Goggles Tigerkhan well, they killed snoke in the last jedi killed snoke, so there is room...
lol
Goggles Tigerkhan just imagine.
Jar Jar was behind the Empire/First Order all along. MIND BLOWN
Dude, I would quit the series. I hate Jar Jar.
That would be creepy
I’m thoroughly disappointed that this didn’t play out
It feels like we were robbed
I've unironically believed this to be the real story since I first heard the theory. Not even conspiratorially, this is the story in my mind, period.
If everyone hates jarjar that would make him a better bad guy lol.
Yea
I agree but they hate them for all the wrong reasons
Agreed
Villains aren’t supposed to be annoying. They can be threatening, funny or terrifying not annoying
@@lennonrush7705 All villains are meant to be annoying, yet perfected, by changing through their personalities. You never hear the heroes say, 'oh, hey, would you like some tea?'
No, they say, 'you again, I'll just defeat you, again.' They're meant to be entertaining in their annoyance, by being the annoyance to the heroes. I mean, sometimes people are annoyed by the heroes, yeah?
It's an effect, of character. We love The Joker, for his amazing annoyance towards Batman, cuz he's always changing his jokes of crime, to pester 'Bats', why we enjoy it. I typed too much, but, I feel it's worth the debate.
i wish every educator, teacher, and professor put this kind of effort and passion into their work. you really got down to the content while also making it fun for us viewers. !! thnx
Yes because a theory that works was somehow debunked.
+Quin Skew What?
Meesa gonna kill yousa!
Lol. You tried.
+Dom Cruise I wish every student put this kind of effort and attention into their instructor's teaching. Thx!
Sounds like they chickened out due to nerd rage. He might have been pressured by 20th Century FOX to change it too, since the hate for JJB was so bad, and they wouldn't want the trilogy to be a flop. (It's all about the bottom line for those guys).
Just a casual SW viewer here, but it would've made the theme of the prequel had they stuck to the original plan of JJB being Yoda's 'yang'.
Yup , i think it to , i might , and this is just a theory , that the moment he created the whole trilogy was even before realising the first movie , and that in his sketches , he put as the ultimate sith lord as snoke(carnivorous fish being jar jar ) that was being suposed to ve instead of plagueis , and the mame plagueis was just a name that he created after Fox told him ti recreate the trilogy
What kills me about this is if they _were_ planning on this, but changed it because everyone hated Jar Jar...come on, cutting his role down wasn't going to make him not exist in Phantom Menace or make people hate him less. But if it had turned out that everything we felt about the character was _on purpose,_ and George _hadn't_ lost his mind and thought 'Star Wars fans will def love this character', like...he _knew_ we'd hate him and think he was stupid and that was the _point,_ that was the same in-universe reason _they_ didn't suspect him?
_Nobody_ would have hated Jar Jar anymore. People would go back and watch them again to pick out foreshadowing and clues. Now its just "god...if i watch Phantom Menace I have to watch so much _Jar Jar"._ I mean, maybe we're all crazy and they weren't at all going to do Darth Jar Jar, but if they were and cut it? Now Jar Jar just sucks and the fallout is probably how Kathleen Kennedy ended up being able to chuck Star Wars in a dumpster, set it on fire, and then film said dumpster fire and call it a movie trilogy.
Yet that's exactly what happened. Jar Jar's role was cut because of the hate from fans, but Lucas clearly had a much more important role for him, a role that would eventually see Count Dooku introduced for the same purpose, while Jar Jar's involvement in Palpatine's plot would appear random.
I personally think that George should've 'ignored' the backlash and just went along with his initial plan.
I saw in other comment that Jar Jar could've actually been Sideus' master, Darth Plagius, the entire time.
Another theory I saw said that Darth Plagius was actually alive during Phantom Menace, for a time, orchestrating things from the shadows.
You’re telling me Jar Jar was supposed to be in Count Dooku’s place!?!?
*mindblown*
That means Jar Jar cut Anakin's arm off, knocked Obi Wan out, and made Yoda run off.
The general theory is that he would have been palpatines master and would have been the villain of the sequel trilogy. George had planned the original, prequel and sequel trilogy before he even finished the original trilogy.
@@akeelbrown7675 i really wish there were a way to read the original scripts that lucas wrote for the 9 episodes.
Klaustrophobia yeah, but unfortunately Disney wanted to do their own thing, and look at how fans are receiving it so far
@warrcc c well then why give power to paplatine and why doesn't his people jump high like him or can do what he can do in fighting doesn't that show evil intent
did i really just watch 50 minutes of jar jar binks, wtf am i doing with my life
Learning the truth.
Technically the clones would still exist because they were around/ ordered to be made before so yeah I love clones anyways so that means clones would be around forever
2x Speed.. 25 minutes.. xD
Zuto40 Lol. That's what happens when u don't pay attention to time.
wtf even is this it was an hour of a f*#$ING idiot who is extremely stupid
That awkward moment six years later when I would have rather had another Jar Jar than the new trilogy.
And if you use basic physics homework technology, for Jar Jar's Force jump, he doesn't accelerate with a constant velocity downwards, like he turned off gravity for a second at the top. Definitely the Force.
You forgot to mention that he smiles at qui-gon jinns funeral
He is also a bit delusional
f
He had a grin
Off
Oof
Hot damn dude! Now that was a well done video! I was like "48 minutes?? There's no way I'm going to watch this whole thing." And yet here I am, very impressed. You've done well Padawan.
Hey, I'm subscribed to you.
+Treesicle Hey treesicle, how are you doing man?
hey dude
I completely agree man
that's how I was
Two things:
Star wars 4, 5 & 6 clearly have Palatine as the Emperor. Jar Jar would be a lesser sith or maybe Palatine made a move. Maybe Jar Jar is connected to Dooku somehow.
Second, here l am sourcing KOTOR: The life cycle of jedi masters is 1, 000 years. That's the very strongest jedi. Yoda trained jedi for 8 or 9 centuries?
Factor time for Yoda's own training (forget that disney nonsense) and you Yoda fits the bill, almost. Not quite 1,000 years but close. And Yoda was exceptionally powerful as a jedi. If Darth Jar Jar was as strong as the theory suggests, he is MUCH older than we suspect.
Mutski1579 but that’s how Palpatine is still alive in The Rise Of Skywalker
Jar Jar not being present in 4, 5 or 6 doesn't mean he is a lesser character. It could mean he was meant to die in 2 or 3 or between 3 and 4. But it could mean he was to be in the background pulling strings. He often wasn't dong stuff himself but helping push others along. Palpatine wasn't the main bad guy who was shown in 4, 5 and 6 but rather it was Darth Vader the audience was made to focus on. And with so little effort being spent on Jar Jar's story we dont know if he was 30 years old or 1k years.
The Sith had a plan to take over the Republic for like a 1,000 years. Plaegus knew that to take control of the republic in an effort to destroy the Jedi, they needed a human, that ended up being palpatine.
"or maybe Palpatine made a move"
I would be 100% down for this. We already know that Palpatine killed Plageus. What's the death of one more master in pursuit of ultimate power?
Imagine that Jar Jar replaces Count Dooku in basically every scene. Obiwan is investigating on Geonosis and he sees Jar Jar negotiating with the trade federation, techno union, etc. Jar Jar faces off with Obiwan, Anakin, and Yoda at the end. Anakin saying "no I'm taking him now!" and charging forward only to be casually disarmed.
And then, at the start of Episode III, it is Jar Jar instead of Count Dooku. Anakin, the chosen one, an extremely powerful force user, defeats Jar Jar in combat. And there we have the iconic scene as Palpatine says "Kill him. Kill him now."
DEW IT.
I think dooku was basically shoved in there to fill the void of not having jar jar there due to the backlash, i believe yoda was set to duel jar jar as theyre basically a mirror of eachother especially the way they were introduced to us when we first met them.
Imagine having your grand story ruined by fans being blind and not rewatching the details - as so-called fans should.
When in the Gungan city, after talking to Boss Nass and the jedi are walking away, Jar Jar says to Qui Gon just as he passes in front of him "Any help here would be hot". BUT at the moment he says it, he waves his shackled hands in front of Qui Gon. And what does Qui Gon do? He turns right around and asks Boss Nass to let him go! THAT is my favorite use of the mind trick through out the trilogy.
But mindtricks don't work on other force users right
@@dearjohn7328 you are right but if Jar jar was more strong minded he could of mind tricked the weak minded qui gon but overall you cant mind trick other force users
@@dearjohn7328 As long as the power disparity is great enough, it can be. If Jar Jar was intended to be the ultimate dark side user, it's possible that he was powerful enough to use it on Qui-Gon. After all, Qui-Gon AND Obi Won together couldn't even figure out that Padme was the real queen, so they couldn't of been overly powerful.
@@knubswak I don't think Jar-Jar knew either.
Is Qui Gon not a top notch Jedi? I think you're lowballing his power and inflating Darth Binks
"Everyone leave for this scene filming, nobody is leaking this."
Meanwhile at Marvel: "Lol let's destroy mjollnir in the trailer."
Welcome to modern cinema where seeing a trailer is the same as seeing a movie with the exception that you save the money and a trip to the cinema
@@adamwilson2117 well, at least it stops people using illegal platforms, if you see everything relevant in the trailer. Lol 1/0 for the internet \o/
The trooper cracking his head on the door supports Luke's claim "I can't see a thing in this helmet".
He knows beforehand Padme is Queen, than he says she is hot.
czcams.com/video/980sRSeiBeM/video.html
Fun Fact:that line was not scripted
It makes more sense when you think that Palatine was able to hide his connection to the force. Jaja may have the same ability or even use it with out detection even among jedi.
Bink's reveal would have been the "I am your father moment" of the prequels
I wasn't on board with this whole theory until you started waving your hands at 17:42. Now, it all makes sense.
Good joke
@@escanorlionsinofpride6147 Well that was uncalled for.
@@escanorlionsinofpride6147 quit talking to yourself in public, people will think you're crazy
@@vd6070 Shut up, I was in a bad mood when I wrote that, so I took it to literal sense
@@gonhunter3994 mmmhm
18:01 Jar Jar tells Padme the Gungans have a “grand army.”
Then the “grand army” appears and not one gungan is holding a blaster. All they have is blue water balloons to throw by hand at the droids.
"We both know that there is no luck. There is only the Force." -Master Zhar Lestin.
Mike Or a fellow kotor fan
@Musical Matt Kreia: But as one trained in the Force, you know that true coincidences are rare.
How about the scene where a giant fish is about to swallow their ship. Jar Jar "falls asleep" and then suddenly a much larger fish eats the attacker. Then Jar Jar wakes up and they're saved! Jar Jar possessed the larger fish to prevent their destruction.
Nice bro!
Bully Hunter Over 9000 I misremembered. I meant the second monster attack once the power is restored. Jar Jar sort of "faints" and another monster with "red eyes" eats their attacker czcams.com/video/IIQVAShJzLo/video.html
@@astralclub5964 Jar Jar seems indeed recovering from something difficult when he "aweakens"
theres 2 problems with that, one its inconsistent, normally the person attacking or the threat itself is possessed, not another innocent character possessed to hurt the threat thats jus not how they did it and the other problem and probably nail in the coffin, is they never went anywhere with the jar jar theory.. so in the end its jus a theory
Travis Miller Lucas cut back on Jar Jar's part in the trilogy due to the overwhelming hatred the audience showed toward the character. His later reaction to this disapproval doesn't impact upon the attractiveness of this Jar Jar secret sith theory and the compelling evidence that supports it.
I never got the sense that Darth Maul was the Phantom Menace, I always thought it was Palpatine.
The Phantom Menace was Anakin.
Of course it was Palpatine it wasn't never supposed to be Maul he was just an apprentice
Darth maul was not his apprentice he was a dark side assasin at that time darth sidious was still apprentice to Darth plagueis ,keep in mind the rule of two
But wasn't Plageuis killed before the end of Episode 1, off screen? And since it's always 2, maybe Jar Jar and Maul were both contenders to become the new apprentice once Sidious took out his master, and Jar Jar won because he succeeded as a dark side spy, whereas Maul failed as the dark side assassin
@@a.jgamingclan398 But what if the "rule of two" was a lie to keep the Jedi confused?
I'm sold. The prequels could have been so much better if they had gone through with this
This theory is in my personal canon. I was never a fan of Count Dooku und Darth Jar Jar would have been a MUCH more emotional fight for Ani, being a former friend.
At this point, it's pretty much canon that this is the way George Lucas originally wanted it to be. We're all kicking ourselves for the hate we gave Jar Jar back in the day. This reveal would have been just as big as "No, I am your father."
you mean luke i am your father
@@smashergrilla954 The correct quote is "No, I am your father.".
@@Chloe-rj3nz not for me I remember luke i am your father fukin mendela effect
Hard to believe. Remember, this trilogy had a fixed end point. It had to end where the original trilogy started. Where’s Jar Jar in those? It would have had to be a huge plot point with a big reveal that went nowhere. Just a dead end. It’s much easier to believe that Jar Jar was put in the movie to appeal to/sell action figures to little kids.
Imagine if the original Star wars was released today?? People would be bitching about how much plot holes it has and how annoying yoda is and to have him removed lmao.
Didn't think I'd watch the whole vid, but I got hooked. I'm actually pretty mad that Lucas didn't go through with it. That twist would have been the biggest in awhile, and it would have been validation for all the hatred Jar Jar received earlier. It would have been a giant risk, though. Who knows how it really would have turned out.
George Lucas messed it up. Made Jar Jar TOO annoying and irritating, and then he thought he needed to get rid of him since people hated him so much.
He should have done it like Yoda's appearance in The Empire Strikes Back: only show him as annoying for long enough to disarm the suspicions of Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan, and the audience.
Then quietly move him into the background, like when Qui-Gon was talking to Boss Nass. In the transport they use to reach the capital, he should have been in the back: he's now where he needs to be, outside suspicion. But they slipped and made Jar Jar a "shock and awe" of annoyance, so everyone hated him.
@@grantkruger3689 100% Agreed, George Lucas pushed the thing a little bit too far with jar jar, even if personally I didn't really mind him when I watched the film for the first time when I was younger, I can understand why people hated him. But I guess that was a risky choice made on purpose, it didn't worked unfortunately.
@@apotaz3353 When Yoda first appeared, for two minutes he was much like Jar Jar: goofy, silly and annoying. But he was quickly revealed to be the Jedi master Luke was searching for.
They planned a later reveal for Jar Jar, so they should have moved him into the background. That reveal would have been epic.
@@grantkruger3689 Yes that's right, no one would have expected it and yet that would have made sense given the parallel with yoda. It's a shame, it could have been one of the most epic plot twist.
@@apotaz3353 It is a shame. I'm sad it flopped.
Just imagine: Yoda goes to confront Palpatine Palpatine, finds him standing menacingly over Senator Binks, and challenges him.
But then both Yoda and Palpatine are stunned to discover that Binks is far from helpless, and far from who they thought him to be...
I just realized the last episodes of the star wars trilogy -where Palaptine comes back-, could have been different BY JAR JAR BEING THE ONE TO REVEAL HIMSELF
Yo also when the gungans are scared as hell at Jar Jar coming back you can literally hear a gungan say “The Sith”
woah wait really?
PiousMoltar ye watch the scene a couple times and listen for closely
My favorite part is "the queen wishes it, she's curious about the planet". Why would the queen be curious about a planet covered in sand and why did Jar Jar come along to begin with??? Hmmmmm....
Also the way he says it. The pause in his words. Like he's in a sort of trance, being fed this information as he's speaking it, rather than communicating an idea he was told prior.
Jar jar has no redeeming qualities unless this is true. Then, he would be the greatest character ever set up.
And that's why it's such a tragedy that this was not used. Imagine how it would redeem his character and make the prequels improve, it would remove the single biggest issues fans have with that trilogy.
He could have been the single greatest and most interesting Star Wars character ever...
Did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Jar Jar the wise?
Sidious is a diminutive of insidious which means proceeding in a gradual, subtle way, but with very harmful effects... and Darth Sidious did just that
Vader is a diminutive of vater which means father, and Darth Vader turned out to be Luke's
Plagueis is a diminutive of Pelagianism which is a philosophy in which people can earn salvation through their own efforts (although assisted by God's Grace) and Darth Plagueis discovered a way to save people from death through his own Force assisted efforts
Tyranus, is a diminutive of tyrannosaurus which means "tyrannical lizard" which describes Darth Tyranus... not at all, it would have fit a lizard-like Gungan though. Could be just Tyrannical which still fails to describe Count Dooku. It is entirely possible that Darth Tyranus should have been Jar Jar, which would have been an amazing reveal.
"Jar Jar" is "Raj Raj" in backwards and check what "Raj" means.. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raj
Saying Raj Raj two times literally means ruler of rulers, king of kings, emperor of emperors. That Jar Jar for you being ruler of Sidious.
This aged so well, you were right on every point, especially about snoke
Shuddup plz
Personal theory: in the EU there are incarnations of the Force, Force gods for lack of a better term. The Whills, the Father, the Son, the Daughter are examples. What if Jar Jar was one of these 'Force Beings' and instead of representing the Light side, the Dark side, or balance in the Force; he represents Chaos? He did help Palpatine take power and exterminate the Jedi but he also helped bring Palpatine and Anakin together sealing Palpatine's fate.
Michael Driggers there actually is canon force deities in The Clone Wars
Nah I think Palpatine was hoping if he got Anakin on the dark side that he would kill him and take his place cementing himself as the dark overlord just as he did his former master. In the comics theres a story about this girl that got close to Vader and knew his plans. He started getting investigated so he decided to try and kill anyone that knew of his plans. She escaped him and was brought back by a bounty hunter I believe but she told the emperor of Vaders plan to overthrow him and that is the reason Vader wants her dead. He just laughed and was proud that Vader went through great lengths to try and cover up his plan to overthrow him. Basically Palpatine wanted Vader to kill him but Vader never really could find the perfect time which is where Luke comes in. He wanted Luke to kill the Emperor to fire up the dark side in him and take over the galaxy but seeing his son being killed and having his memories with Padme resurface changed him to where he didnt care about being some overlord. The love that him and Padme shared was literally dying by the hands of his master. Anakin never really could shy away from helping the people he truly loved could he?
this is really cool theory
Honestly, Jar Jar is very much a disruptive figure, a trickster, a sort of dangerous goblin.
is anyone else just randomly getting this 3 year old video pop up in their recommended all the time lmao. good video btw
Yeah
Same, lol
Yep and I had to watch all 48 min of it. Never heard of this before and was shocked.
Yeah dude I was wondering why he seemed so surprised by all this old info
Same
What's really ironic about all this is that the fans themselves ruined the Star Wars franchise. They disliked Jar Jar so bad, it made Mr. Lucas unable to release Jar Jar's movie and connect the entire thing about Jar Jar being the True Sith Lord. All the fans had to do was wait just a bit more on Jar Jar's movie release and everything would've been explained. Jar Jar revealing himself to be the Sith Lord would've been the biggest twist since Darth Vadar reveals to Luke that he's his father. BUT NOOO! Ya'll had to cry like little babies and now Disney has Star Wars!! I hope you're proud of yourselves.
you're kinda right.. this would have been an amazing aspect to the films. But every other problem with them still would have been there and they'd still be dogshit movies.. only with one more cool thing to reference when defending them. The main thing to keep in mind is that if Lucas had any remaining artistic integrity or ya know.. balls. He would have done it anyway. If he has any writing talent he wouldn't have put such a great plot in a shittily written movie and had us all dispise it in the first place. If anything.. the fact we all hated Jar Jar would have made him a better villain.. and his downfall more satisfying and the reveal more shocking. But instead, Lucas coward out in fear of not making as much money from the sequals and not getting critical acclaim. It's not our fault, it's his.
yeah but the other problems remained in the first two prequels with plot pacing and writing/acting direction so would it have turned out well if it had gone through? besides as he said Yoda was an annoying character too, perhaps the key to sucess with that was that audiences learned the truth shortly after meeting Yoda rather than waiting 3 years for an answer
am i the only person who actually liked Jar Jar?
+Zebraman437 14:21 says it
I'm so annoyed too... NO MORE TIME FOR THE HATERS
Well considering that Palpatine's plan relied heavily on them finding Anakin and Anakin falling in love with Padme, it isnt too far fetched that he had intended for them be stranded on Tatooine and Jar Jar wanting Padme to come along, interesting theory indeed. Also it's been a while since I've seen the movies, but did they ever say why Jar Jar was banished from Gungan City?Also now that I think about that whole scenario, he couldve intended on qui gon saving his life and be in "life debt" allowing him to tag along with them. I wont believe any of it though until Lucas comes out and says this was planned.
7 years later and I still bloody love this video. Thanks for the fun.
This makes so much sense.
No promises about the whole"staying away from the dark side" thing.
no it doesn't
CT-5597 Jesse yes it does.
Wildman Samurai yes it does.
KAT X Moron.
If your enemy thinks you a fool, you have already won.
If you think you have already won, your enemy is probably right.
@@deusexaethera believing is the first step to achieving.
@Ryan Palmer Congratulations. You.... have already lost.
NANI????
Unless you're actually a fool, then your enemy has already won. That's a really cute saying. However, the problem with your little saying is, most people think they are much more intelligent than they actually are making them in fact a fool. An intelligent person underestimates their own intelligence knowing they do not know everything. Making them a much bigger threat than the fool who thinks they know everything. When asked "how it felt to be the smartest man on the planet?" Einstein replied "I don't know, you'll have to ask Tesla" Proving that as smart as he was he realized Tesla was even smarter. A fool would have answered much differently.
@Ryan Palmer lol
I was kinda hoping he'd mention when Jar Jar force-threw a lightsaber in the comics
I just watched this after finishing Star Wars Jedi fallen order and I realized that dark moul and count doku could have been inquisitors while the two actual sithwould have been Sidieus and jar jar all along and when Anakin is brought into the picture he goes into hiding only to come back as snoke
If Jar Jar is revealed to be snoke I might cry tears of joy
More likely he is Snoke's master
Maybe Luke and Rey will make Kylo Join the light once again and they will kill Snoke together,but after that Jar Jar will come and kill one of them and make the other two flee.Disney said that there could be another final trilogy,and there Jar Jar may be the big enemy.Its gonna be cool for me
+Valerie Hoffman #youdontknowhowtousehashtags.
Obi-Wan left him to die
Jar Jar. The Drunken Master of the Dark Side.
"Oh heesa not the lord of tha Sith"
"MEESA THE LORD OF THE SITH, MEESA DARTH JAR JAR AND YOU ALL IN BIG DOO DOO THIS TIME"
How it should have ended.
HISHE!
*yousa
Proceeds to be cut down by Mace, Kit, Anakin, and pals.
I have had it with these nerfherding Sith Lords in this nerfherding senate!!!!!!!
You mentioned jar jar's lifespan... and possibly being able to extend it... it made me think of another possibility... could general grievous's body, be similar to Jar Jar bink's... like even general grievous' eyes are yellow with similar pupils... what if General grievous was "darth Jar jar's" ultimately menacing final sith form
Love revisiting this video every once in a while
Same bro
George Lucas said Vader being Dutch for Father was a coincidence. Darth Vader is supposed to come from Dark Invader.
+GamingFanatic Okay, so it's still a play on words. lOL
+Joseph DiSalvo He was also in school with someone called Vader.
+GamingFanatic Vater is German for father. Just one letter off.
+Darkness Pizza When you run into your brother on CZcams...
+GamingFanatic Yep Vader is Father in Dutch (I'm dutch)
I feel like if this is true.. than george maybe should have doubled down. Sure you would have hated jar jar... until he made his reveal and then you would have retroactively watched all the scenes and learned to love him.
Yup, same thing goes for Itachi. We all used to hate him until Obito revealed Itachi biggest deeds for The Leaf
@@graciasvito8067 Please, even with the reveal, Itachi is a complete and utter idiot. Like he honestly couldn't have found some other way to protect Konoha without committing mass murder of civilians and ninja alike, all of whom were family?
We wouldn’t hate jar jar due
Doubling down is a culture Hollywood only picked up on in the 2010s. If Phantom Menace had come out in 2009 instead of 1999, George Lucas would have probably used the fan backlash to make a Jar Jar series just to piss fans off.
@@DavidbarZeus1 better examnple for gracias in my experience is sasuke. In one instant sasuke went from the most hated character for me for one of the most liked.
Because it made sense and his idiocy was eventually realized by sasuke as wrong.
Just re-watched this. The replay value is good.
I always liked jar jar and wish they went through with the reveal, would of thrown people off their rockers and got him to be liked more after o-o
What crazy, is that this isn't even all of the evidence for the Jar Jar's original plan theory. I just put in what I find to be the most convincing and obvious, but you can go waay deeper into cast interviews and even some Star Wars books to see it.
Im my opinion Jar Jar isnt a bad Charakter or was bad for the story hes just another Charakter that is in the story nothing more
+Gnoggin Gotta say, this video sold me on the theory. Awesome work!
+Gnoggin Excuse me sir, but from where in the deep recesses of your ass did you pull *2* other planets that have life on them from? The drake equation may be complicated to get into, but it does NOT simplify to *two*.
+ENDERSLAYER2002 That's true, but many Sith apprentices had a secret apprentices of their own, and also Sith use other non-sith Force users as special soldiers, eg: the Dark Guards
So while the Only Two Sith makes Jar Jar being a Sith kind of non likely, he could be a force user serving the Sith
31:30 ominous jar jar music?
You forgot to mention jar jar smiled at qui gon's funeral but other then that you covered everything so great video
tyler wagner Just bad cgi smh
Or was it Sb E.T. or was intentional
Sb E.T Jar Jar is a completely animated character so every movement and motion has been animated perfectly and specifically.
DJ L3GEND he does
Yep. It's been shown in some other videos.
I’ve been a big believer in this theory since it first made its way around the inter-webs, but you’ve turned this fun theory into irrefutable fact! Never seen so much evidence, nor put together so completely and compellingly
This still keeps me up at night. Nothing can ever convince me that this WASNT exactly how jar jar was supposed to play out
you sse this is wat most people dont get. jar jar binks is both things at the same time.. its a very long story but basicly jar jar has been possed by Darth Tenebrous. so he has two states darth jar jar and jar jar binks. its dificalt to work out were one ends and one begins this is how the legand goes ''''well they say darth plagueis visits tatooine. and darth sidious visits naboo. so it's entirely possible that they crossed paths with jar jar binks' plus we know Darth Tenebrous possed plagueis in hopes he would get bought to anakin after his death. plus Tenebrous forsaw the death of plagueis. so this is strait from law Before Tenebrous' death, he had infected himself with the retrovirus and he lost his foresight ability. In his dying state, he transfers his essence into the maxi-chlorians and enters Plagueis' body through his eyes, mouth, skin and a wound on his back. ? possesion right? czcams.com/video/PlyRLtAngxo/video.html&ab_channel=SuperCarlinBrothers
girlfriend: "how was your day?"
me: "watched a 48 minute expose on how Jar Jar Binks was secretly a Sith Lord, wbu?"
girlfriend: "we're breaking up"
me: "I have no regrets"
lol
That's a nice cover to explain how you don't and have never had a girlfriend. Good try, though.
if this is true you dodged a bullet, any girl who dumps you for something so small isn't worth your time
"Why are you so afraid of the truth, Jennifer ?"
If she was trash, I wouldn't have any regrets either.
If she was actually a good girl on the other hand....
I think I would have some to be honest.
Anyone else wish this was the actual plot 🤣
Me
Everyone
Anyone with a brain cell would
Who doesn't?
Script should have never changed duspite the hate.
“Snoke is Jar Jar Binks” is an INFINITELY better idea than what they actually did with Snoke’s plot twist.
"Jar Jar is the key to all of this."
Huh, George really wasn't kidding.
did u forget to mention that JarJar SMILES on Qui Gon's funeral
Litten
IT IS CONFIRMED
That mixed with the whole "every bit of animation is on purpose" argument is probably the most compelling evidence for this theory.
I’m crying at the missed potential
Meesa too
@@wattobinks5785 damm it i was gonna do that :(
I've literally watched this at least 5 times every year since this dropped. I just love it
I would say if this were all true then Lucas should not had abandoned the plans because it would have made the prequel trilogy acceptable. If he started to uncover the Jar Jar thing in the second episode fans like me would have said damn WTF. It would have made the series watchable
It's this sort of reactionary response that may have been why the prequels were such a failure in comparison to the original trilogy. Even if Episode 1 received the same level of disappointment, if they stuck with developing Jar Jar as this hidden Sith-aligned mastermind as opposed to trying to retcon his involvement by adding in Dooku instead, it could have redeemed the entire trilogy and possibly make people retroactively appreciate the minute details established in Episode 1. Maybe 2 and 3 end up being more cohesive, and thus Episode 1, even if left unchanged, would still be plagued by the bad acting and odd pacing but will have been the building blocks for the rest of a potentially more enjoyable series.
I don't think Dooku was a mistake. They could have had both. Dooku to start the Wars, Jar Jar as the inside guy giving Palpatine power.
Besides, Dooku is cool.
I would have hit like buttom if not for the "sad acting" huehasuhuesahe the acting was exactly what it meant to be...
@@inseerlink3511 Everything in prequels was exactly how as ment to be. But its different from the OT, so it's bad.
Hollywood hates Lucas, I wouldn't be surprised if review sites and the like weren't paid off to influence online popular culture at the time. Wouldn't be the first time the media has targetted some one and tried to destroy their work or lives.
Same Thing happened with Episode 9. After the backlash of Episode 8 they tried to "fix" it, leaving us with a incoherseve story.
I can't believe I watch an almost hour long video-
-about Jar Jar Binks....
mcspence I think you mean supreme chancellor and dictator of the sith Binks
Oh yeah! Yes ur right.
an almost hour long video that was making the case that Jar Jar could have been amazing
Same
Yousa need new vids.
That's probably my favorite video on CZcams. I come back here every year before watching Star Wars
Also, I can't wait to see what they'll do with jar jar in episode 7... Whenever that will come out ;)
I think the jar jar theory is true. that's coming from someone in 2020 who's seen the rise of skywalker
Disney doesn’t own Star Wars. Not for me.
Yes, He smiles at Qui Gon Jinns funeral, and Palpatine was next to him, and he says ''sith'' while hes giving palpatine emergency powers, and what even happened to jar jar? its like he survived everything.
I think there's a lot more to Rise of Skywalker than people have allowed- I've watched those new films carefully- they are well structured, & all the 'mistakes' the nay-sayers moaned about actually make perfect sense by the end. It's clear the old guard had decided to condemn the new films before they even saw them- & so they didn't see what was right in front of them. I know- i'm a voice in the wilderness here.. but in 20 years people will be ready to understand.
@@ashmilliard6889 please share!
@@ashmilliard6889 Explain the absolutely horrid character decisions in TLJ then. It's not in Luke's character to murder a boy for only listening to something, and every decision Holdo makes is utterly horrible
Another example of fan reactions potentially ruining great plans. The prequels would have been a lot better if they'd just stuck with it
It makes me sad of what could have been. I wish they kept it too
I mean the main problem though is that Phantom Menace is still really really bad. It would've been better if it turned out that Jar Jar was a sith lord and such, but it wouldn't have made any of the other scenes any better. So even without Fan Reactions about Jar Jar specifically, they were bound to still try and course correct and make more changes and such.
Same here. To me this is as big of a disappointment as the cancellation of Silent Hills. Truly, the fans have ruined Star Wars. It no longer has that magic it once had.
Kurt Crockenberg We need a Darth Jar Jar Spin off movie by Disney to fix the prequels.
They still could have made him less annoying. There’s a difference between a tolerably annoying character for movie sake and “annoys the audience to death”.
I thought it was a joke, untill I actually heard it, I'm convinced jar jar evil was the original intended idea.
43:20 I thought he was going to say something the lines of: "Well, have you ever heard the tale of Darth Plagueis the Wise?" Really loved the video. It's ovious that you took a long time on it. Thanks! :D
Obi saying that as an old man is quite telling, since he witnessed Jar Jar first hand
Near the end, you say Jar Jar uses tech to extend his life. But if Jar Jar was so powerful, there is a good chance that he knew something about Darth Plagus the Wise, and his ability to manipulate life. Is it possible that Jar Jar was using this method of staying alive?
Shane Loranger Plagueis was first mentioned in Revenge of the Sith. It’s possible that Plagueis would’ve still been a Star Wars character. In the Plagueis book Sidious and Plagueis conspired to make Palpatine chancellor and rule together. That part could’ve easily been Binks. People strong in the force I would also think could live far longer than non force users. Sith alchemy could extend a life force beyond anything natural. Darth Krayt lived an unnaturally long life.
Dr P1bb, very good point! That makes sense.
teslagod2003, that is a very good point.
teslagod2003 The rule of 2 pretty much ended with Plagueis & Sidious. Palpatine had no intentions of helping Anakin save his wife. He knew she would die because he would pursue the dark side to save her(vicious circle right?). Sidious’ plan was to use Sith alchemy to live forever. Prior to this Disney takeover Palpatine came back from the dead, had many clone bodies of himself to keep coming back and even had Luke as his apprentice for a little bit.
The only person he was interested in helping was himself lol!
teslagod2003 then why did you reply to me if I’m on a wrong comment???
And no. The point was that the rule of 2 ended with them. They pursued eternal life.
Why do you keep calling him plageius the wise? He also wasn’t killed in his sleep.
He was killed while celebrating with Palpatine.
So Jar Jar messed with the hyperdrive in The Phantom Menace so they would find Anakin, wich actually made the grand scale killing of Jedi masters & more important jung padawans possible??
I’m totally on board with Binks being Darth Plagueis
Pablo Forstner One problem: Palpatine killed Plagueis, or at least thought he did.
@@nunkatsu Hes in Padme's funeral
DJEdg10 Well theoretically his speech could have been written after scrapping the Darth Jar Jar plot...
Binks is Plagueis's apprentice, and got sidious to kill him. He then took over sidious's training.
Pablo Forstner he is not plaugius he is Lord Vitite
Good old days when we thought the Sequel trilogy would make sense or that it was planned at all.
When they first met Jar Jar, he could have put himself in harms way on purpose and acted panicked and helpless, so Obi Wan had to body tackle him and save him. Why would he do this? He was banished from the Gungan society "for being clumsy" which could actually have been because of some scheme trouble he caused. He then insisted he owed Obi Wan a life debt, insisted he stay with him. While trying to convince Obi Wan he needed to stay and owed them a life debt, he was also waving his hands around a lot in casual conversation gestures, which, as you said, could be force mind tricks disguised as casual conversation gestures. They were also attacked again and after Jar Jar freaked out waving his hands and said "Oh no!" and as Obi Wan told him to get down, right as the ship on the far right of the screen is turning, Jar Jar was glancing around, then looked suddenly pretty much right at the ship, and waved his left hand and drew it towards himself, mirroring the exact motion turn of the ship, which then fired right at Obi Wan and Jar Jar. He ducked as Obi Wan told him to and Obi Wan blocked the bolt of course. Why would he do this? He explicitly said that Obi Wan saved his life again, further ensuring his life debt to them, and so that they'd need to find hidden shelter more urgently. He then followed them and told them that the Gungan society was safe, then specifically mentioned that it was a hidden city. Keyword: hidden, meaning they'd NEED HIM to lead them there, so he'd have an excuse to stay with them and go back. Basically, he could've subtly suggested the idea to them of asking him to lead them there, then act as if he'd said it without thinking and pretend to not want to lead them back there, when in reality the opposite of that could've been exactly what he wanted. When he was saying, "No, not really, no," he was waving and gesturing with his hands again in casual conversation gestures again, and Obi Wan immediately repeated after Jar Jar, "No?" and his demeanor completely changed from calm to quietly angry, threatening kind of Jar Jar then mentions that he was banished and that he "mighta forgotten." You don't just forget that you were banished from your home civilization, then remember seconds after having told someone about the hidden city, which they'd NEED YOU to lead them to. And he mentions that they'd do terrible things to him if he returned, giving him a reasonable reason to his (potentially fake) refusal to take them there, so it wouldn't be suspicious. Furthermore, at the end of this sentence, he nods his head to the left, the same direction side that Obi Wan turns his head before they hear more ships and explosions and Obi Wan asks if he heard that, similar to how Jar Jar body puppet controlled other people's movements as shown in your video, via similar body movements, hand gestures directions, gazes, lip movements, etc. Jar Jar then waves his hand up to his ear flap-fin-hair thing and immediately after he does that Obi Wan turns back to him in the same time and motion as the hand moves up, and as he wave puts his hand back down down, Qui Gon turns his head back towards Jar Jar as well, and then Obi Wan proceeds to tell him somewhat threateningly or intensely about the thousands of terrible things heading their way. He looks at Obi Wan and then turns his head and Obi Wan advances forward towards him in the same time and direction as the head turn, and Qui Gon also starts advancing once Jar Jar looked at him as well. Jar Jar then glances back and forth between Qui Gon and Obi Wan as the both advance towards him, but then Obi Wan stops advancing right as Jar Jar holds his hand up a "Stop" or "Stay There" gesture at him, and Jar Jar keeps his gaze and body direction mostly focused on Qui Gon as he advances, including having his other hand gesture extended out towards him as well to control-you can see that the arm is extended out-, to maintain the mind trick focus-perhaps he has difficulty controlling two people simultanously-, only breaking the gaze to glance at Obi Wan enough to keep him still and mind trick focused, all disguised as passive peaceful gestures and timid fearful expressions and reactions to being threatened. Why again would he do all of this? Why would him leading them there be suspicious? Why would he tell them about the hidden city and then refuse to lead them there, and how could he make that not suspicous? Why have them threaten/intimidate him into leading them to the hidden city? Why not just implant the idea into their heads and take them there? Because he needed it to seem like he'd been forced or threatened (either by them or the situation with the ships, and his twice life debt to them) to take them to the hidden city since he knew he couldn't just go back of his own accord, or else he risk those terrible things happening to him. Furthermore, Gungans don't like outsiders, as he mentions later, and he is a gungan as well, so why would he be any different, and so why would he-a gungan- lead outsiders to their hidden city, banished or not? The only acceptable reason for a banished Gungan to lead outsiders to their hidden city that wouldn't be suspicious to the gungan's or Obi Wan and Qui Gon would be that he was obligated by life debt, or forced threatened by them or the situation with the attacking ships. Everyone’s reaction to Jar Jar upon his arrival was definitely weird suspicious, fearful whispers and exclamations, fleeing away from him, electrocuting and handcuffing him. During the meeting, Jar Jar tried to use his little hand movements for mind tricks on the council, but I don’t think it worked. When Obi Wan and Qui Gon were leaving, he mentioned that they were being set up, going through the core was bad, and outright said that some help here would be great-with casual hand gestures again that could be a mind trick-and Obi Wan turned right around and asked for him to be released to come with them due to the life debt he owed. In the underwater submarine, he said he was banished because he was clumsy, he was all “eeeehhhh you could say that.” and they were surprised and disbelief about him being banished because he was clumsy. Jar Jar saw the goober fish before he explained the story. When Jar Jar is explaining why he got banished, if you watch his hand movements and the giant goober fish/creature in the background, it follows his hand movement patterns after a second or two delay, and what he says about causing an accident and crash could also mean that he intended using the mind trick for the creature to attack. Then the bigger creature came and ate the giant goober fish, they were caught then released-when he did the hand movements before, he closed his hand then released afterwards, just like what happened to them. He waves his hand at them and tells them, “Okay We go back now.” But the possible mind trick didn’t work. When they broke down in the cave and he said, “What yet? Monsters out there” he thumb pointed out the front, directly at the monster that’d attack them once the power came back on. When they were talking about how there might be something behind things, Jar Jar did this little eye close twitch flinch thing, as if that unnerved or bothered him, and he was literally standing behind them. Why did he do everything? He first needed to avoid being punished once he returned to his home, then he needed to prove himself with the Jedi to his people, so then he could manipulate Ness to promote him to general. If I notice anything else that wasn’t covered, I’ll update this. If anyone actually read this whole long analysis comment, I am astonished and impressed and salute you.
I have read this amazing scientific paper of yours and I find myself being beyond impressed.
@@iwonderwhy9681 Thanks. I didn’t mean for it to be so long as to be a scientific paper, but I just kept noticing more and more little things JarJar did that could possibly have been evil Sith Jedi mind tricks.
@@EverythingAndAnythingGoes24 I didn't so much call it a scientific paper because of the length, although that too played a role, but rather because of how well it showed that dark intentions of the greatest Sith Lord of all
@@iwonderwhy9681 Oh well, thanks. I wasn’t taking the Darth JarJar theory seriously until I saw the above video, and a lot of things in the movie started making sense when looking at it from the view of the Darth JarJar theory and then I noticed all the little things I typed about in my analysis. I’m glad someone read the whole thing and liked it. Most people would probably run out of patience before they get to the end.
@@EverythingAndAnythingGoes24 I wasn't taking it seriously before either, but now I am quite confident that Darth Jar Jar is indeed "behind everything, including the war".
Although I still have one question, how does the Rule of Two work in this case ("Always two there are, no more, no less, a master and an apprentice")? Since Darh Sidious (Palpatine) trains Darth Maul, but they are both under Jar Jar, that would mean that there are 3 Sith at the same time.
But maybe Jar Jar is not actually a Sith, but rather an independent force user, who controls the Sith, and in that case, the rule is always followed.
What do you think?