0:52 Lunacy 4:14 Mother of the World 8:04 The Wolf 9:26 The Seer 16:53 The Seer Returns 19:48 93 Ave. Blues 21:24 The Daughter Brings the Water 23:33 Song For a Warrior (feat. Karen O) 25:40 Avatar 29:00 A Piece of the Sky 35:30 Apostate
@@ImmutableUniverse They're loosely connected in the sense that they feel like natural evolutions of one another, to my knowledge it's more of an unofficial trilogy, not something recognized by the band. Also these three albums represent a certain era for swans so people just say "The Trilogy" when they want to refer to that certain era, Michael Gira himself said that The Glowing Man was the end for that iteration of Swans so anything after that is considered a new incarnation of the band
@@ImmutableUniverse yes, they're all 2 hour double albums, they're thematically consistent and have similar song structures (their classic build up, climax and release)
Definitely do The Glowing Man next. It's the final album of the trilogy of The Seer -> To Be Kind -> The Glowing Man. Also very nice of Spotify to remove most of the lyrics from this album for no reason.
It's kind of head-cannon, but to me the trilogy of The Seer, To Be Kind, and The Glowing Man feels like the stages of Hell, Purgatory, and Ascension. Spiritual, cyclical, samsara. The Seer feels like rustic, ritualistic, and organic darkness; To Be Kind feels like nuclear fission; The Glowing Man feels like a supernova.
I actually wrote an essay about this exact connection in my “Evil in Literature” class, I basically connected the trilogy to Dante’s Divine Comedy (Inferno, Purgatory, Paradise)
Probably the scariest Swans album, to me anyway. I think all Swans albums carry a certain sense of dread, but this one definitely captures more of a downward spiral into malice and chaos. The album cover helps with that, a literal monstrous feel to the music. So glad you’re reacting to this
for me The Seer, Soundtracks for the Blind and also Greed/Holy Money are all pretty equally scary but for different reasons which i find interesting. The seer feels like the most simple, horror movie-like fear out of all of them. Soundtracks is a very psychological and surreal kind of fear, and greed/holy money are scary to me because their sound just feels so bleak and oppressive. I find it very cool that Swans is able to pull off so many subtly different kinds of fear so well
@@Qwertyuiopaz imo soundtracks just fucks you up in some song, but the seer has an overall goofy terrifying night in alaska vibes, but the scariness of something is subjective
@@zxr9291 that’s fair too. I haven’t listened to Greed/Holy Money yet, but from what I can understand The Seer is the most cohesive and “storytelling” of the 3, which personally works more for me. The seer makes me actively scared of what’s happening, while SFTB is more of a long lasting, subtle fear. Makes me excited to listen to Greed/Holy Money though
@@QwertyuiopazI think I could also say that SFTB had a more lasting fear and unsettling feeling on me while Seer was kinda more traditionally scary? idk how to explain it
Been waiting for this one!!! So glad you strapped in. After The Seer and To Be Kind, The Glowing Man completes the trilogy, and The Beggar acts like an epilogue. Both are essential Swans records, and you should hear them!-and if you’re wanting more afterwards, The Great Annihilator, Children of God, and White Light From the Mouth of Infinity are verified classics too 👌
A lot of people are telling you to do The Glowing Man next, but you should check out either The Great Annihilator or White Light From the Mouth of Infinity if you do more Swans. Pre-Soundtracks for the Blind albums are great and much different sounding. This band has a long and super interesting discography worth bouncing around in. Keep up the great work Smags!
My favourite band again! If you want to dive further into the catalogue I recomend Children of God. The glowing man is amazing too, but cog would give you a nice insight into their musical range, same goes for The Great Annihilator.
Smags, for some reason I stumbled upon your channel and, after watching some of your reviews, I gotta say that I'm totally invested in the channel and I really love you, man. Keep the reviews coming! (The Seer Returns is a banger, indeed. That song and Avatar are my favs off The Seer).
as someone with bipolar disorder i see this album as the story of someone’s struggle with mental illness, especially since “lunacy” originally specifically meant bipolar. this album has meant a lot to me and “song for a warrior” has lifted me up during some of my darkest moments, i love the power of swan’s music and the many different interpretations it leads to
So glad to see you get to this, it's definitely my favorite album of theirs. I saw them on this tour in San Francisco in 2012, easily one of the top musical experiences of my life. I really appreciated how much you got into A Piece of the Sky. It's my favorite song in their whole discography. Really really good stuff.
Swans is my close friend's favorite band, and has made his favorite album. You know what is also one of his absolute favorite albbums? That's right, my suggestion! Magnolia Electric Co. by Songs Ohia, you should reeally listen to it, you won't be dissapointed.
you should do how i loved you by angels of light if you want more sincerely beautiful music from gira ala song for a warrior & a piece of the sky. if that album had the swans name on the cover, it'd be considered one of their absolute best, i'm certain. you'd love it!
A lot of folks are suggesting The Glowing Man, and it is a wonderful record and I think the best of the trilogy, it's probably my favorite of all their records but I would love to hear your thoughts on Leaving Meaning or The Beggar, especially with your appreciation of Song for a Warrior and the beauty that Swans can have too. The Beggar especially has some of Swan's most beautiful gorgeous music on it but both are wonderful.
FILTH is their first album and it’s honestly my favorite. much more minimalistic, brutal, loud, etc, but i think it exemplifies Gira’s talent as a songwriter. also some political funness in there CHILDREN OF GOD is probably their 2nd best album. it’s the first Swans album you could call “beautiful,” and it has some of their best songs of all time. good stuff!
Thanks for reviewing this album and putting it on my radar what a good listen! Some Suggestions Arctic Monkeys - Whatever People Say I am That's What I'm Not Queens of the Stone Age - Like Clockwork... Glass Beach - Plastic Death Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway Moody Blue - Days of future passed Sonic Youth - Goo Queens of the Stone Age - Rated R Dinosaur Jr. - You're Living all over me
More Swans would be amazing, if I had to recommend just one of their albums it'd definitely be The Glowing Man. If I could rec more I'd say The Great Annihilator, other than SFTB, it's my favorite pre reunion album from them.
I know given your Swans journey so far, The Glowing Man does make the most sense for your next Swans album, and it is absolutely one of my favorites in their discography. But I would genuinely interested to see you explore other parts of their catalog too. The thing about Swans is that they have changed their sound pretty radically over the course of their career. Specifically I'd love to see you react to their album White Light From the Mouth of Infinity. Couldn't be more different from something like The Seer, but also among their better albums.
its very different stypistifally to the other swans youve heard, but i really enjoy children of god. really dark and brooding post punk and gorgeous vocals from both m. gira and jarboe
Eventually you should react to their live album “Swans Are Dead”. The first disc was recorded in 1997 on their final tour, while the second disc was recorded in 1995 for their Great Annihilator tour. The version of “Blood Promise” on that album is one of the best things I’ve ever heard.
Hooray, finally a new Swans reaction! They have so many high-quality albums that you should also get to at some point. I agree with the comments that the most logical choice for your next reaction is The Glowing Man which is kind of a continuation of this one and To Be Kind, although it's more ethereal and pretty, if I may say so. Hopefully it won't take as long! Also still patiently and eagerly waiting for your reactions to Third by Portishead and The Moon & Antarctica by Modest Mouse. I'm sure you'll like them! 😉
i fuck with the 𝓼𝓪𝓵𝓾𝓽𝓪𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷𝓼 heavy, dont stop doing that also speaking of the seer... if there was a nicer version... it could be called... the DEER!!!! (get it cuz the animal on the cover is BROWN?? like a deer!)
LOVE YOUR VIDEOS MY GUY a few recommendations: Process - Sampha (experimental r&b, great production) Nurture - Porter Robinson (light summer electric with fun production) Koi No Yokan - Deftones (very heavy, sexier and heavier radiohead imo) Hypochondriac - Brakence (very experimental emo rap, glitch pop) Reading Writing And Arithmetic - The Sundays (the smiths ish, with beautiful female vocals)
I might be the only one who feels this way but imo the Seer is the best of their new records , the atmosphere feels the thickest to me, to be kind sounds almost dry in comparison, i like swans at their most texturally rich, a piece of the sky might be my favorite modern swans track (also lowkey my least fav track on here is the seer returns and that's specifically the track that it seems like Michael was like "let's really focus in on that sound on the next couple records, i really wanna make post rock that sounds like it was made by those little furry aliens from star wars" shit like a little god in my hands makes me nauseous)
The funny thing is you definitely weren’t THE SEEing-ER the album, your were The Listening-er to it hahah. I have a big stand up performance in a week, wish me luck 😁
i crashed my car listening to apostate, good times
Lmao, what part?
@@damando6631 dont really remember honestly, i guess around the mid to end section
@newhillroad that parts where the song gets super hype so i understand
@@colloquially yeah the music made me want to destroy my car so i just did it
@@newhillroad understandable
the glowing man by swans is one of their best too
their best period
0:52 Lunacy
4:14 Mother of the World
8:04 The Wolf
9:26 The Seer
16:53 The Seer Returns
19:48 93 Ave. Blues
21:24 The Daughter Brings the Water
23:33 Song For a Warrior (feat. Karen O)
25:40 Avatar
29:00 A Piece of the Sky
35:30 Apostate
Bro, The Glowing Man and you complete The Trilogy.
What trilogy?
@@ImmutableUniverse
The Seer
To be Kind
The Glowing Man
@amireal5458 why is it considered a trilogy, are the three projects connected with each other?
@@ImmutableUniverse They're loosely connected in the sense that they feel like natural evolutions of one another, to my knowledge it's more of an unofficial trilogy, not something recognized by the band. Also these three albums represent a certain era for swans so people just say "The Trilogy" when they want to refer to that certain era, Michael Gira himself said that The Glowing Man was the end for that iteration of Swans so anything after that is considered a new incarnation of the band
@@ImmutableUniverse yes, they're all 2 hour double albums, they're thematically consistent and have similar song structures (their classic build up, climax and release)
Definitely do The Glowing Man next. It's the final album of the trilogy of The Seer -> To Be Kind -> The Glowing Man.
Also very nice of Spotify to remove most of the lyrics from this album for no reason.
It's kind of head-cannon, but to me the trilogy of The Seer, To Be Kind, and The Glowing Man feels like the stages of Hell, Purgatory, and Ascension. Spiritual, cyclical, samsara. The Seer feels like rustic, ritualistic, and organic darkness; To Be Kind feels like nuclear fission; The Glowing Man feels like a supernova.
I actually wrote an essay about this exact connection in my “Evil in Literature” class, I basically connected the trilogy to Dante’s Divine Comedy (Inferno, Purgatory, Paradise)
SMAGSSSSSS I LOVE YOU I LOVE SWANS LISTEN TO THE GREAT ANNIHILATOR OR WHITE LIGHT FROM THE MOUTH OF INFINITY YOUD FW THEM SOOOO MUCH
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
I SEE IT ALL
A Piece Of Sky its top 5 Swans song
Apostate might be their 2nd best closer
@@bbpoisonnwhat’s their best!?
@@bbpoisonnBest closer is To be king
@@euanpirt2594 Helpless Child
@@juda4568 Do Te Bing
Finally. Been waiting since your Soundtracks for the Blind reaction. This album feels like a cult initiation so you’re one of us now
What language do the Swans speak?
Portu-geese! 😭😩
Jail
@@M0UNDZZZstaight to it. no questions
god of the sun i'm taking you down on the inside
@@M0UNDZZZ*jailbird
Probably the scariest Swans album, to me anyway. I think all Swans albums carry a certain sense of dread, but this one definitely captures more of a downward spiral into malice and chaos. The album cover helps with that, a literal monstrous feel to the music. So glad you’re reacting to this
I'm curious why you think this is scarier than Soundtracks for the blind
for me The Seer, Soundtracks for the Blind and also Greed/Holy Money are all pretty equally scary but for different reasons which i find interesting. The seer feels like the most simple, horror movie-like fear out of all of them. Soundtracks is a very psychological and surreal kind of fear, and greed/holy money are scary to me because their sound just feels so bleak and oppressive. I find it very cool that Swans is able to pull off so many subtly different kinds of fear so well
@@Qwertyuiopaz imo soundtracks just fucks you up in some song, but the seer has an overall goofy terrifying night in alaska vibes, but the scariness of something is subjective
@@zxr9291 that’s fair too. I haven’t listened to Greed/Holy Money yet, but from what I can understand The Seer is the most cohesive and “storytelling” of the 3, which personally works more for me. The seer makes me actively scared of what’s happening, while SFTB is more of a long lasting, subtle fear. Makes me excited to listen to Greed/Holy Money though
@@QwertyuiopazI think I could also say that SFTB had a more lasting fear and unsettling feeling on me while Seer was kinda more traditionally scary? idk how to explain it
you NEED to react to lingua ignota
HEAVY AGREE!! Caligula will end up being the darkest album you’ve heard yet
i second caligula :)
third for caligula
fourth for caligula
fifth for Caligula please smags
Been waiting for this one!!! So glad you strapped in. After The Seer and To Be Kind, The Glowing Man completes the trilogy, and The Beggar acts like an epilogue. Both are essential Swans records, and you should hear them!-and if you’re wanting more afterwards, The Great Annihilator, Children of God, and White Light From the Mouth of Infinity are verified classics too 👌
and now i sit patiently for my fav record by swans - the glowing man :D
We are bububublessed
Check out the live album: Swans Are Dead.
A lot of people are telling you to do The Glowing Man next, but you should check out either The Great Annihilator or White Light From the Mouth of Infinity if you do more Swans. Pre-Soundtracks for the Blind albums are great and much different sounding. This band has a long and super interesting discography worth bouncing around in. Keep up the great work Smags!
a piece of the sky is one of my favorite songs ever it made me just sob the entire time not cause its sad but because its so beautiful
My favourite band again! If you want to dive further into the catalogue I recomend Children of God. The glowing man is amazing too, but cog would give you a nice insight into their musical range, same goes for The Great Annihilator.
Smags, for some reason I stumbled upon your channel and, after watching some of your reviews, I gotta say that I'm totally invested in the channel and I really love you, man. Keep the reviews coming! (The Seer Returns is a banger, indeed. That song and Avatar are my favs off The Seer).
as someone with bipolar disorder i see this album as the story of someone’s struggle with mental illness, especially since “lunacy” originally specifically meant bipolar. this album has meant a lot to me and “song for a warrior” has lifted me up during some of my darkest moments, i love the power of swan’s music and the many different interpretations it leads to
So glad to see you get to this, it's definitely my favorite album of theirs. I saw them on this tour in San Francisco in 2012, easily one of the top musical experiences of my life. I really appreciated how much you got into A Piece of the Sky. It's my favorite song in their whole discography. Really really good stuff.
the glowing man is incredible, you need to check it out!
White light from the mouth of infinity plzzz.....
Swans is my close friend's favorite band, and has made his favorite album. You know what is also one of his absolute favorite albbums?
That's right, my suggestion! Magnolia Electric Co. by Songs Ohia, you should reeally listen to it, you won't be dissapointed.
you should do how i loved you by angels of light if you want more sincerely beautiful music from gira ala song for a warrior & a piece of the sky. if that album had the swans name on the cover, it'd be considered one of their absolute best, i'm certain. you'd love it!
A lot of folks are suggesting The Glowing Man, and it is a wonderful record and I think the best of the trilogy, it's probably my favorite of all their records but I would love to hear your thoughts on Leaving Meaning or The Beggar, especially with your appreciation of Song for a Warrior and the beauty that Swans can have too. The Beggar especially has some of Swan's most beautiful gorgeous music on it but both are wonderful.
FILTH is their first album and it’s honestly my favorite. much more minimalistic, brutal, loud, etc, but i think it exemplifies Gira’s talent as a songwriter. also some political funness in there
CHILDREN OF GOD is probably their 2nd best album. it’s the first Swans album you could call “beautiful,” and it has some of their best songs of all time. good stuff!
You should react to Neu! Self titled album, its Krautrock and it’s awesome
The glowing man is NEEDED
NEW SWANS REACTION!! man of the people right here
terrifying album, now you need to complete the trilogy with the glowing man :)
ive watched this video 4 times please do more swans
Thanks for reviewing this album and putting it on my radar what a good listen!
Some Suggestions
Arctic Monkeys - Whatever People Say I am That's What I'm Not
Queens of the Stone Age - Like Clockwork...
Glass Beach - Plastic Death
Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Moody Blue - Days of future passed
Sonic Youth - Goo
Queens of the Stone Age - Rated R
Dinosaur Jr. - You're Living all over me
Yesss! This is the album that made me actually get their music lol
More Swans would be amazing, if I had to recommend just one of their albums it'd definitely be The Glowing Man.
If I could rec more I'd say The Great Annihilator, other than SFTB, it's my favorite pre reunion album from them.
How do you do these reactions so often, I get about 2 drop in my feed every day haha it's impressive
One of my fav from Swans
I know given your Swans journey so far, The Glowing Man does make the most sense for your next Swans album, and it is absolutely one of my favorites in their discography. But I would genuinely interested to see you explore other parts of their catalog too. The thing about Swans is that they have changed their sound pretty radically over the course of their career. Specifically I'd love to see you react to their album White Light From the Mouth of Infinity. Couldn't be more different from something like The Seer, but also among their better albums.
You should check out Yanqui U.X.O by Godspeed you! Black Emperor, its their most underrated album imo
Thank you, daddy smags. You do not disappoint
Do Children of God or White Light from the mouth of infinity next
you should check out The Great Annihilator
hey bro, when we getting the Flood by Boris reaction
fr
its very different stypistifally to the other swans youve heard, but i really enjoy children of god. really dark and brooding post punk and gorgeous vocals from both m. gira and jarboe
I recommend White Light From the Mouth of Infinity, an incredible swans album that is highly depressing so watch out
Definitely check out The Glowing Man next. A perfect end to a perfect trilogy
HALLELUJAH!
DONT BEND! ASCEND!
no freaking way. I've been excited for this for a while now. You have to do the glowing man as well at some point
I’d love to see you react to The Great Annihilator👍🏾
Eventually you should react to their live album “Swans Are Dead”. The first disc was recorded in 1997 on their final tour, while the second disc was recorded in 1995 for their Great Annihilator tour. The version of “Blood Promise” on that album is one of the best things I’ve ever heard.
Yo check out death ~ symbolic pls :)
you should check out Duck Stab by The Residents
this is literally my favorite album of all time i love it so much 😭😭😭
this trilogy is so epic , the glowing man might be peak swans
w review dude, The Seer is my favorite album of all time ❤
Literally almost had a panic attack to "A Piece of the Sky" and "Apostate". Amazing album.
yoo this is one of my favourite musics ever
Hooray, finally a new Swans reaction! They have so many high-quality albums that you should also get to at some point. I agree with the comments that the most logical choice for your next reaction is The Glowing Man which is kind of a continuation of this one and To Be Kind, although it's more ethereal and pretty, if I may say so. Hopefully it won't take as long!
Also still patiently and eagerly waiting for your reactions to Third by Portishead and The Moon & Antarctica by Modest Mouse. I'm sure you'll like them! 😉
A Piece of the Sky and Apostate together make one of the best album closers I've ever heard
The Glowing Man and Children of God are must hear albums. If you want something softer check out their album Leaving Meaning.
Please do The Fragile - Nine Inch Nails!
pretty pretty please do "from a basement on the hill" -elliott smith
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAHHHHHHH
great anhillator or the glowing man would also be great reactions. 👍
Now you have to do The Glowing Man (the best one) to finish the trilogy (The Seer, To Be Kind, The Glowing Man)
i fuck with the 𝓼𝓪𝓵𝓾𝓽𝓪𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷𝓼 heavy, dont stop doing that
also speaking of the seer... if there was a nicer version... it could be called... the DEER!!!! (get it cuz the animal on the cover is BROWN?? like a deer!)
freaky font...
@@gggreatness freaky bob.......
YESSSS THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!!!!! I LOVE YOUR CONTENT 🙏🙏
HELL YESS
Glowing Man next 💪
LOVE YOUR VIDEOS MY GUY
a few recommendations:
Process - Sampha (experimental r&b, great production)
Nurture - Porter Robinson (light summer electric with fun production)
Koi No Yokan - Deftones (very heavy, sexier and heavier radiohead imo)
Hypochondriac - Brakence (very experimental emo rap, glitch pop)
Reading Writing And Arithmetic - The Sundays (the smiths ish, with beautiful female vocals)
I have several spasm when I see u upload
would be really cool to see you react to "Hey What" or "I could live in hope" by Low. The members of Low sing on lunacy :)
It would be sick to see you hear mastodons crack the Skye. It’s a very emotional album and i think you would like it.
You'd probably more like their earlier stuff if you don't love their longer tracks, The Great Annihilator is amazing
Please react to the glowing man and the beggar
I might be the only one who feels this way but imo the Seer is the best of their new records , the atmosphere feels the thickest to me, to be kind sounds almost dry in comparison, i like swans at their most texturally rich, a piece of the sky might be my favorite modern swans track (also lowkey my least fav track on here is the seer returns and that's specifically the track that it seems like Michael was like "let's really focus in on that sound on the next couple records, i really wanna make post rock that sounds like it was made by those little furry aliens from star wars" shit like a little god in my hands makes me nauseous)
I see it all
Great review as always. Would love to see chocolate and cheese by ween within the next few months
Got scared that you were gonna recommend chocolate starfish
@@meatgrinder9506 what's that? Limp biscuit? 🤢
Listen to the glowing man pipsqueak
The funny thing is you definitely weren’t THE SEEing-ER the album, your were The Listening-er to it hahah.
I have a big stand up performance in a week, wish me luck 😁
Oh sick
👹 type beat
Can we get a reaction to xiu xiu- a promise
Yes yes yes
THANK YOU
Hell yeah, my favourite Swans album.
You should listen to Chocolate and Cheese by Ween
best part of this video is you can watch the sun set
Day 52 of asking Smags to listen to:
Portishead - Third
King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard - Polygondwanaland
You know man
Listen to low by david bowie
also do Daughters "You Won't Get What You Want"
complete the trilogy. fulfill the prophecy. the glowing man is calling you.
Hoorayy
What is up with bro reacting to birds? First we got Geese now Swans
Whats next? 🦆
YES!
YES YES YES SWANS RAAAHHHHHH❤
36:39 😂
xiu xiu reaction would be so cool
A request to react to Definitely Maybe by Oasis. I don’t think you have reacted to them yet.
(The Glowing Man) and (The Beggar).
You should do those next.
can't believe u didn't like Avatar bro it is my absolute favorite in the album 😭
bro h ates lou reed
you should totaly listen to filth