Comparison Review: Nissan Rogue Platinum vs Mazda CX-5 Signature / Oldest vs Newest Compact SUVs
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 07. 2024
- For the longest time, I have always recommended the Mazda CX-5 because it’s spacious, drives very well, and has a cabin full of high quality materials. However, it is now 5 years old so can it still keep its crown against the updated Nissan Rogue? The Rogue has more interior space, bold new looks, and packed with more technology than its predecessor. So how do these SUVs stack up?
The Mazda CX-5 is available with two engines. A naturally aspirated 2.5L 4-cylinder and a turbocharged version of the engine. This Signature CX-5 has the latter and this turbo engine can produce up to 250 hp & 320 lb-ft (186 kW / 434 Nm). However this engine is not comparable to the engine under the hood of the Nissan Rogue. Instead, a more comparable engine would be the base 2.5L naturally aspirated 4-cylinder that produces 187 hp and 186 lb-ft of torque (139 kW / 252 Nm).
By comparison, the Nissan Rogue comes equipped with just one engine for the 2021 model year. A naturally aspirated 2.5L 4-cylinder engine that produces 181 hp and 181 lb-ft of torque (135 kW / 245 Nm). The 2022 Nissan Rogue is available with an optional 1.5L turbocharged 3-cylinder engine on all trim levels except for the base S FWD trim. This new engine produces 201 hp and 225 lb-ft of torque (150 kW / 305 Nm).
The 2021 Nissan Rogue starts at $28,498 CAD ($26,050 USD). This 2021 Nissan Rogue Platinum starts at $39,998 CAD ($35,830 USD) with the Platinum trim of the Nissan Rogue 2022 receiving a $2,000 CAD price jump. The 2021.5 Mazda CX-5 starts at $29,200 CAD ($25,370 USD) for the base GX trim (Sport in USA) with this top spec Signature Mazda CX-5 costing $42,950 CAD ($37,505 USD). The Mazda CX-5 2022 also receives a price hike but it is only $400 CAD for the top spec Signature trim.
-----
➡️➡️ 𝗗𝗲𝘁𝗮𝗶𝗹𝗲𝗱 𝗡𝗶𝘀𝘀𝗮𝗻 𝗥𝗼𝗴𝘂𝗲 𝘃𝘀 𝗠𝗮𝘇𝗱𝗮 𝗖𝗫-𝟱 𝗖𝗼𝗺𝗽𝗮𝗿𝗶𝘀𝗼𝗻 𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄: mgreviews.com/comparison-2021...
👉👉 𝗦𝘂𝗯𝘀𝗰𝗿𝗶𝗯𝗲: / mgreviewsblog
-----
#NissanRogue #MazdaCX5 #Comparison #Nissan #Rogue #Mazda #CX5 #Review #TestDrives
-----
Vehicles provided by @MazdaCanada & @nissancanada
-----
𝗙𝗼𝗹𝗹𝗼𝘄 𝗠.𝗚.𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄𝘀 𝗼𝗻 𝗦𝗼𝗰𝗶𝗮𝗹 𝗠𝗲𝗱𝗶𝗮
Facebook: / mgreviews
Instagram: / mgreviews
Twitter: / mg_reviews
Pinterest: www.pinterest.ca/mgreviews/
-----
𝗩𝗶𝗱𝗲𝗼 𝗻𝗮𝘃𝗶𝗴𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻
0:00 Intro - Don't Forget to Subscribe :)
1:24 Performance - Which one drives better?
7:35 Comfort - Which one is more spacious?
13:01 Odds and Ends - Which one has more gadgets?
15:41 Conclusion - Which one should you buy? - Auta a dopravní prostředky
Rogue's interior is just wow
I own a 2018 CX5 and if I were in the market for a SUV, I will still go for the CX5.
As would I. How has your ownership experience been? Any major unforeseen maintenance issues?
Don't' understand why you don't have more subs. Very good production values (better than Doug's 😅) and compete reviews. Hang in there you'll break through. It's all about the algorithms.
Thanks! Haha, I doubt that Doug cares about production values.
I test drove both and bought the Rogue. I'm old enough now and drive short distances only when I have to, so I'd rather have the comfort, better view, bigger touch screen, and more space than the 'driving experience'. And honestly, the driving experience is still fun in the Rogue. The engine is more than willing and it's very light on it's feet, so it's not that big a sacrifice. Like going from a 9 to an 8... etc.
As far as the CVT, they've completely re-engineered it, the consumer complaints since 2017 have dropped off, and you get a great warranty.
As far as the 1.5L-T... Nissan has been putting reliable turbos on reliable small engines for decades now. The grandfather of this engine began it's life in the early 2010s, and ended up in a Le Mans race car producing 400hp.
I'll be getting the 2022 Rogue a bit later this summer so I'll be re-doing this review with the 2022 version of these cars.
Test drove both and bought the Cx5 kuro. Red leather interior is fantastic, 6 gears are plenty.
Excellent thanks
Thanks for watching!
Both look good! I’m awaiting the release of the 2022 Qashqai (Rogue Sport) as I want a smaller well equipped vehicle.
Yea it looks very funky. Looking forward to getting my hands on one later in the year.
Mazda in general is FAR ahead of the competition in technology, luxury, and styling. The CX-5 has had the same design language for years and it still looks better than even these redesigned updated competition.
I'm astonished at how well Mazda's vehicles stand up against the updated competition. Even in my CX-9 vs Avura MDX video, I still preferred the Mazda.
@@MGReviewsBlog Just helped my aunt buy a 2022 Mazda CX-5 yesterday. She was choosing from a 2021 Nissan Rogue and 2022 Subaru Outback. I recommended we stop by the Mazda so she could test drive the CX-5. She loved it so much that she bought the car right there.
@@Malkav Doesn't surprised me. I've never seen heterosexual male drive cx5. Women love this girly looking crossover
Just bought a 2021 CX5 GT..Love it ..I just don't trust the CVT in the Rogue and I think the Mazda over time will be more reliable
Congrats on your purchase! That's the jist I keep hearing from a few Nissan owners who comment on my videos. They've had a few issues here and there with the transmission but all good responses from the Mazda owners. Even some who put over 200,000 km on their Mazdas.
@@MGReviewsBlog I had a 2013 Nissan Rogue with 60k miles on it when purchased, in 2017. The 2nd day I had it, I took it for a hundred mile drive and the transmission went into limp mode. Couldn't get over 3k rpms, changed the tranny fluid with Nissan TF, and didn't have many issues for over a year, besides the whiney noise and a little jumpy at times....Then things got worse over time. Not reliable, didn't have the confidence in it to take it more then 50 miles at a time. Purchased a 2022 C50 carbon, today and love it so far. I don't plan on having a CVT transmission in the future, but Nissan has seemed to have gotten some kinks out... But- Im a Mazda guy now Thanks for your video.
@@aaronburns2387 thanks for the feedback of your ownership!
I will buy the Mazda CX-5
A good choice 👌
It seemed you did not mention the Rogue came with a new VC-turbo engine, a real breakthrough in turbo engine technology.
No, I did. Around the 4:30 mark. I can't comment too much about it because I have not yet driven a Rogue with the new 1.5L turbo engine. So for now, all I can provide are the basic stats.
Love my Mazda cx5 grand Turing reserve
Any problems with it? Any unforseen issues?
Need your 2022 Nissan Rogue review or comparison
As soon as it gets put in the Nissan press fleet, I'll be all over it.
I thought they aren't using CVT no more !! I'm surprised this one still has that trans !! thanks for the review .. the Mazda in this case is a winner for the long run that for sure .
Yep, Nissan is still using it for some models. A few newer ones, like the Pathfinder, are switching to 9-speed automatics.
Most manufacturers use a CVT, including Honda and Toyota
Wish you could have compared the 2022 Rogue with the 1.5L turbo. Mazda's design has always been my favorite and I like the way it drives. The new rogue is a big improvement and with the new turbo engine the choice between the two is more difficult. Personally, I'm waiting for the new CX-70 to be introduced, hopefully in 2024.
I will be redoing this review with the 2022 cars. I have the 2022 CX-5 booked and now am just waiting to get the Rogue booked. So expect to see and updated version of this review in a couple of months.
@@MGReviewsBlog Looking forward to that review.....
How will the Rogue age vs CX-5? Have a 2014 CX-5 (175k), fun to drive, reliable, feels like a car with another 100k+ miles to run.
That's quite a bit of mileage on your CX-5. Any major issues with it?
I have 175k on a 2016 and have had no maintenance issues. Still feels the same way it did when i first bought it. Follow the scheduled maintenance and this SUV just keeps going without worry.
Nissan rides excellent and feels like they will last forever without any issues when riding in their new cars. But annoying problem(s) magically arise after paid off, 7 years or 70K miles, whichever come first 😃People buy Nissan because they give you more for the money compare to competitions.
I tested drove the cx5 I liked it but the interior was too tight I'm a tall guy that's why I went with the 2021 rogue s loved how it drove and the larger interior can't beat the price for what your getting I wish I went with the Platinum version all wheel drive when my lease is up in 2024 I'll probably get the platinum version
Ok let’s peal back some skin on this Apple vs orange comparison. I gather the Mazda feels sportier not just because of what makes it so but that turbo vs the Rogue’s naturally aspirated engine makes a huge driving difference!
Now, if I read it correctly the Rogue gets 4 miles per gallon better fuel economy than this Mazda. This stands out as does a review I just read on the 22 new Rogue’s engine the 1.5 l turbo 3 cylinder.
It apparently gets 4 miles per gallon fuel economy better than it’s iteration year 2021 Rogue!
If my math is correct that 2022 Rogue out does the 2021 turbo Mazda by 8 miles per Imperial Canadian gallon!
Young man I hope you can afford that gap and I wasn’t even thinking of the resent gas increases we’re having.
Apparently the 21 and 22 Rogue’s CVTS are better operating but will they be more reliable than the “similar” older ones that were crapping out?
Time will tell. You mentioned the Mazda had enough leg room for your six-4 frame. Did the bottom cushion extend far enough to bolster your under thighs? Just wondering.
Unless Mazda has lengthened the front seat lower portion I think the answer is a resounding no.
Other than those points a very good review. A breath of fresh air review actually.
Keep it up young man!
Go Ni.
Thanks for the feedback! I did say that the 2.5 Turbo engine isn't really comparable against the Rogue which is why I included and talked about the naturally aspirated version of the 2.5L engine. I'll be getting my hands on the 2022 Rogue with the new turbo 3-cylinder so I'll do a video on that one too.
Never will I ever trust a cvt. It’s like trusting cylinder deactivation. Just waiting for it to break something expensive. It’s why I went 2022 Mazda CX-5 turbo signature. Other than that Nissan also feels cheap and feels like I could break stuff very easily. Let alone when you squeeze on some panels on the Mazda it doesn’t move an inch, in the Nissan Rogue premium it sounds like your squeezing a console controller. Just makes lots of noise. Also highway sound dampening was a very big thing for me. Nissan let’s in way more ambient noise than the cx-5 or rav 4 I tested out before making my decision. Personally I’d you want best bang for you buck go base rav 4 hybrid best for MPG also some states give you tax rebate for plug in hybrids and some offer regular hybrid rebates. The 2021+ CX-5 gas tank has another hole that I’m positive is designed for a future plug in hybrid model. Ohh also cx-5 has the better infotainment. I hate touch screens. They get full of finger prints. I love the non touch screen design. It’s what sold me on the signature over the best rav 4 hybrid model. I believe it’s either prime or something like that. Anyway I’ll stick with CX-5 reliability and constantly being one of the best compacts (imo it’s the best). I’ve had a 2014 Mazda sport touring. (Has features from both) the 2022 model blew it out of the water. My wife dislikes the HUD but you can disable it. Therefore making her sole complaint irrelevant. Ohh she also hates the safety features because if someone break checks you the CX-5 applies full force to breaks. Even if you’re already applying more than enough to stop in time. I believe I can also change this to be less responsive but I don’t trust the wife driving. Very scary.
The extra hole you're referring to next to the fuel fill hole is for the DEF (diesel exhaust fluid) hole. In some markets (and even briefly in North America) the CX-5 was available with a diesel engine. I wrote a review about it a while back: mgreviews.com/review-2019-mazda-cx-5-diesel/
This generation of CX-5 probably won't get a hybrid powertrian but the new CX-50 is rumored to be getting one in the near future.
I checked all the suv's on sale and ended up buying the Rogue platinum I would never buy a vehicle with a turbo engine turbos will break sooner than later as well the gas mileage is much worse in a turbo car I find the Rogue to be to my liking the cvt transmission is great
What year is your Rogue? The 2022 and newer have a turbocharged 3-cylinder on all but the base trim level.
@@MGReviewsBlog 2021 platinum model
you bought a car with a Jatco cvt and are worried about a turbo??? sorry
@@fakebrake mine was perfected and it is a dream to drive it it is the first time i could drive 90 miles and hour and still be below 3000 rpm with a 4 cyl
Why do you compare CX-5 of 2021? It is 2022 now and CX-5 of 2022 is available.
Because I receive these cars directly from the manufacturer in their media press fleets. They get to decide what cars are available or not. So far, they don't have the 2022 models but once they do, of course I'll be doing reviews of them.
@@MGReviewsBlog Does not sound convincing. Instead, it seems like a staged misleading.
@@View_from_Australia I told you the truth. Believe what you want. But that's why I included a few 2022 specs for the cars.
Cx5
This reaction makes no sense. The Rouge will soon have a new engine and not even use the one in this review in a month or so .
2.5L engine is still available for the Canadian market (which is where I am) on the base S trim of the Rogue. I did mention the new engine in the video and I did say that this was a 2021 Rogue and a 2021 CX-5. If I had access to the 2022 cars, of course I would've compared the two. But neither manufacturers have them in the media fleets yet. They will eventually and when they do, I can make an updated video which you can check out.
Mazda CX5
Being that I bought one, the CX-5 all day.
Congrats! Did you get the 2022?
@@MGReviewsBlog yes, I did get a 2022.
Why are you posting just 2 months ago with an old model when the new one has been know for a while? Makes 0 sense, specially the comments about engine power which actually is more powerful than the standard engine of the cx-5 (not the turbo)
Because that's how my timing just ended up. I'll have the 2022 models in a couple of months so I'll make an updated video then.
Comparing a Rogue (SUV) with CX-5 (Its more like a sedan than an SUV) is like comparing Oranges with Lemons. CX-5 can only take 4 people comfortably when compared to Rogue.
- For 2022 CX-5 top trim when one divides 43,350 CAD by 4 people it comes to 10,837.50 CAD per person
- For 2022 Rogue top trim when one divides 41,998 CAD by 5 people it comes to 8,399.60 CAD per person.
- That means every person sitting in Mazda is paying 2,437.90 CAD more becoz CX-5 couldn't fit in that 5th person which means CX-5 is 9,751.60 CAD more expensive than Rogue.
- I wouldn't pay so much if the only thing Mazda has is 49 bhp more than Rogue. Driving is not black n white whereas interior space is. Mazda might be good in driving but so is 2022 Rogue especially with the punch of new Turbo engine and more refined CVT than 2021 Rogue itself.
- we shouldn't forget the 8 miles more mileage that 2022 Rogue gives compared to 2022 Mazda CX-5 especially when gas prices are hiking which makes CX-5 more expensive.
- Few people complained about the cabin noise ... CX-5 doesn't give Panoramic Moonroof and the reason is becoz its affects cabin noise. We should wait till CX-5 comes out with Panoramic moonroof without increasing the weight of the car.
That is a very interesting way to look at things. I've never heard anyone compare cars like that before or call a CX-5 as more of a sedan than a CUV.
@@MGReviewsBlog I think CX-5 is more like a sedan becoz other than sitting height ... it has all the features a Sedan can give with comparable very less price. The example of 4 people with 5 people was mainly becoz if I have a family or friends of 20 people travelling for a long trip ... we will have to buy 5 Mazda CX-5 compared to 4 Nissan Rogues. That's 1 extra Mazda in price :) ... I feel its a good point of comparison too.
Muy buen razonamiento, muy inteligente su opinion.
Nissan rogue es superior.
We regularly haul 5 people in our cx5 with no issues.
@Martin Farrell well I said 4 people comfortably. If u can take 3 people in the 2nd row, then u r definitely squeezing them in.
Nissan wows you with the tech but their cars and suv are garbage.
Bad experience with them? I can't really comment on their reliability because I only get these cars for one week at a time. But their new generation of cars (Rogue & Pathfinder) feel better to drive than their respective previous generations.
@@MGReviewsBlog I only wish they made them like the Nissans of the 90’s but sadly they are not.