Twinkle Khanna, Amish Tripathi full session at HTLS 2018
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 10. 2018
- Actor, author and film producer Twinkle Khanna and author Amish were in conversation with Anuradha SenGupta, Consulting Editor, CNN-NEWS18, at the HTLS 2018, in a session on Reimagining Fiction. Speaking at the 16th Hindustan Times Leadership Summit, they talked about what is being defined as India’s Me Too moment. Twinkle said that it is happening all across the country.
Hindustan Times, owned by HT Media Ltd, is one of India’s largest publications that provides unbiased news, analysis and features on politics, sports, entertainment, lifestyle and more. Hindustan Times delivers the news across all social media platforms, on the web, and at your doorstep.
Subscribe to our channel: read.ht/fLZ
Follow us on Twitter: / httweets
Like us on Facebook: / hindustantimes
iOS:- m.onelink.me/bcae8b2d
Android:- m.onelink.me/986f584a
Watch more videos at: www.hindustantimes.com/video
hindustantimes.com © 2016
My goodness! How can you consider Twinkle Khanna and Amish Tripathi at the same level?
She bitched about Amish about his male privilege in an interview with Anupama Chopra.
Liberals can match anyone with anyone
If PR agency work seriously then some miracle happen like that 😊
*Amish is way more intelligent than Twinkle Khanna*
@@sharathananth2058 she's such a bitch, 🤮
This conversation is like insulting Amish but he handled this gracefully.
Anchor is very uncomfortable when Amish talks about Hindu scriptures and wisdom.
Is not she ugly inside out. Left Liberal women are ugly.
If she shows interest and comfort then her Masters will not like it.
Anchor is not intelligent enough to understand scriptures. Omg movie also said many truths in all the religious books. Gita. Bible. Quran.we need to explore few or more. Also twinkle twisted it to 'hindutva'and alarming etc.which was so not needed.
I was about to make same comment. Thanks buddy.
I noticed it. This exactly brings up the bias Amish was standing against
To Hindustan Times,
Why does your host cut Amish Tripathi so often, disrupting the flow of conversation. She did this 4 times, unless I am missing more such occasions. Audience didn't get the true wisdom of the guest you invited!!
I am totally agree with you, It's not fair Hindustan Times.
They want to project Twinkle more. Paisa Jo diya hua hai.
Prejudice against him was clearly visible, I just don't get it!
He is so wise and always felt like he deserved a seperate interview ❤️
Twinkle khanna tried to counter....
But Amish tripathi nailed it ❤️
"More educated we are ..less indians we become" So true..👌👌
"More western education we get less ......"
Correction
Agree white tiger
@@Krishna_8298 exactly
When we are more educated than we became less Indian best line by Amish and suit on anchor.
abhay yadav time changes people change knowledge develops we are now getting lost in the past and fail to see the exciting future
So stop educating urself n read only religious books
what are you getting with becoming more Indian?
just here for Amish Tripathi
More educated we are less indian we become wow 😍😍😍
He is gold
He is sitting with morons and calling them morons on their face
What an insult for such a great author amish tripathi!
hats off to amish ..here, he is really doing a great work by reviving our vedic wisdom, i am stunned how he qouted section 377 and "lord Rama's" words that' shloka' .He is really a proud indian & being a law student it really encouraged me that how we can quote our own examples of our own land by great leaders before putting any foreign judgments or examples, after all we Indians are born leaders.
Huge difference between 2..Amish is way far better writer
Good balanced talk but at a few points looked like the anchor just wanted to talk to Twinkle and is more affirmative of her and is shutting off Amish when he discloses relevant facts from ancient India's past.
Ruchira Agarwal - agree looks like it's all about twinkle ! Amish is a great writer !!!
This anchor is irritating and also disrespectful towards amish 😠
She knows if she tries being a smart ass around Twinkle. Bollywood will ass rape her. So Amish ko berate karo!!!
@Priyanka Gupta Liberal is someone who may disagree with you, but still respects your opinion. This lady is just posing as a liberal and imposing her own secret agendas and completely demeaning someone who she can. Yeah wahi hain jo Feminism ko ek ghatiya naam deta hain!!!!!!
Clearly!
Because he is a fool
7:19 Arundhati Roy is the highest selling female author of India! Her God of Small Things sold over 9 million copies world wide which is more than Amish who's sold around 4.5 million. So the highest selling authors, when they are scaled this is what we legitimately infer
1. Chetan Bagat over 10million in sales
2. Arundhati Roy over 9 million
3. Amish over four million
Following close would be stalwarts like Salman Rushdie and Rudyard Kipling. Not mentioning Tagore. You wouldn't even be in the top 10 list.
Twinkle, you NEED to calm down.
Loved that. So true
Really true descriptions
How can hindutva be alarming? I didn't get what she said? And why is the anchor asking twinkle all the time? Even twinkle seems to notice this and points to Amish so that he is also made involved. Change such anchors!!
Sorry ! How can u even compare Amish & Twinkle ?? Man he is way ahead with his class and dignity of writing ! I have nothing against twinkle but can he she a comparison to him ????
No ..not yet.
This is the tragedy of India. All channels are filled with pseudo-left-liberals and the people who possess the Vedik wisdom don't involve in the society. The lady anchor is very reluctant to hear Amish speaking Vedika wisdom and cuts short the conversation of him. She put a weird face when Amish mentioned manuscripts had not preserved and translated and while saying how the govt of India and Ramdev baba doing it.
rajesh chinthakindi exactly, as if she just then started to have an unbearable onslaught of piles!
Yess you are right
Peolp lik that anchore cannot digest
Indian ancient scripture to be promoted
All Tim she was interrupting
Amish is a excellent person
Amish is more knowledgeable than twinkle . I wish we could hear him more . He was telling such great things about our culture.
Knowledgeble in what sense
@@aaronwarner2379 Every
The difference in levels of knowledge among the three is very much visible.
1)Who is extremely uncomfortable to speak and talk about Vedas.
2)Who does not have enough knowledge and is very much westernised (Not modernised, merely westernised)
3)A person who has bachelor's in mathematics, Masters from finest management institute and even after all that the sheer knowledge about the work he does. Vedas etc is amazing.
I actually do not like twinkle so I may be biased here.
Do you know about twinkle's academia
@@aaronwarner2379 yes she may have been born with a silver spoon and got the best education.
Unlike her , Amish is from a humble background and might not have the money to attend fancy universities.
He was a banker and writing is his practical choice to earn a living.
This lady plays the victim card of being a woman and chooses to tell the audience that she fails to be as good as Ameesh coz of her gender.Heck how can she take the financial background out of consideration.
Ashamed of women like her.
The anchor seems lost. HT please make sure to get someone better next time.
journalist or anti Hindu librandu.
The anchor is only interested in what twinkle has to tell
I was sad to see the interview but very happy after reading comments.
Who people have understood speaking English does not makes u intectual.
Amish you beauty ❤️
Likes only for amish👍, anchor is absurdly out of the topic trying to cut out Amish whenever he is above her score.
Anuradha Sengupta please let Amish finish.
Never bring this host back again please
I agree. She is not "listening". Its insulting when she does not even make eyecontact and is so engrossed in her own questions. She even completely ignored what Amish said and just took it to Hindutva contradictory to what he was trying to say.
The host was unfriendly to put it mildly. Twinkle Khanna answered calmly and gracefully and chose not to react to provocative questions. Amish Tripathi was the perfect gentleman giving a balanced view.
Agreed!!!!
Yes..exactly...being a Bengali...I can say she is a disgrace..😡
Such a Bad Host😡
I have been watching HTLS for quite some time but I will definitely put this conversation as the most idiotic one.. Thanks Amish for being the perfect gentleman!
Wow...That is Educated Indian Class...Wah wah..👏👏
Invite Amish to Insult😡😡
Brown English people..
They way anchor introduce Amish and twinkle. It's like you campare Sachin with Afridi.
As a writer she isn't even Afridi.
When did Twinkle Khanna become a Best selling Writer ?
Which Book did she write ?
HT when you call two guests, talk to both and let both of them speak equally on topics.
It looked as the host wanted to make discussion about feminism. No problem but be honest.
Come on, you should've given more time to Amish, I was here just for him.
She is in denial mode. Deliberately blind and acting oversmart.
Both have left there earlier professions but Amish is here cuz of his great successful books & his knowledge about ancient wisdom, mean while Twinke is here only cuz she is popular, still she is getting more attention.
I am totally agree with him when he said if we want to talk about on some issue with the help of our mythology it will create more impact, I have also an example for that Raja Rammohan roy does that to abolish the sati pratha by giving the examples of mythology to end the sati pratha.
TWINKLE YOU NEVER HEARD ABOUT GARGI SANMHITA AND MAITREIYI SANMHITA,THAT WHY YOU NEVER COME OUT OF SO CALLED FEMINISM APPROACH.
Great speakers, pathetic host. They have some amazing insights but this women is not allowing them to speak!
I wonder, when did Twinkle become bestselling writer 😅 I think either she buys herself lot many books or people are in bad habit.
I would say Twinkle write just to be called as writer. By writing this comment, I am also feeling that I have become a good writer.😄
If I may I add the anchor is really dumb and stupid
Amish man ! you are outstanding👌
And to think of it Akshay chose Twinkle over Raveena
Bilkul sahi bola Bhai Akshay Kumar sabhi kitaben kharidta hoga
I fully agree. She must be buying all her books and then arranged a platform like this to come and declare her success. Aren’t there better women writers than her.....
I'm not sure if Anuradha had enough time to prepare for the interview. There is a flow when Twinkle and Amit are talking. Anuradha is the flow killer in this video.
No one have question for Amish or the interviewer doesn't want to put it there this shows the intellect of indian people or the interviewers
Arguably the most talented and knowledgable Indian authors of our generation in an interview is such a treat! Wish the host had been more interactive tho.
So true
oh my god why the hell is twinkle khanna equated with amish tripathi?!?!?!?!? have you even read the difference in their quality of work!! Amish is a literary genius and Twinkle's book is really basic and very very ordinary. my god.
Comments on the moon and the black tread by Twinkle is uncalled for, could somebody educate Twinkle on this rituals. I mean some Sanskrit scholar, if it is of any importance.
it is well acknowledge fact about plastic surgey and "susruta " and how it was exported to Europe but still left gang uses sleazy face and never mention this fact . another point is sheldon pollack putra are translating sanskrit collection with sub -altern lens . everyone knows about sheldon Pollock and his orientalist way of looking at sanskrit work . but still our sold out intellectual bet for such western lens .
Twinkle khana is looking fool in front of Amish😂
Including Host of the show .
"The more educated we are the less Indian we become".
Anuradha u sound so mean with amish tripathi....I guess why??well v know👍but amish u r fantastic human being and author....tooooooo goood
The anchor sounded so condescending when Amish was talking about India's vedic past and its liberal aspects.
Edit: This is really dissapointing. Not beacause of the guests but because of the anchor. I want to dislike this video because of the anchor but I really liked the guests.
i really did not like the Anchor , she is really not able to grasp and respond , she is disgraceful in the approach of asking and responding.
no body cares what you think
@@gatech5190 exactly, but why to respond when you don't care
@@Sri-Hari just to give you a reality check and let you get off your high horses
@@gatech5190 people who says nobody cares and then are worried about giving reality check , really!!!
Twinkle is no where near Amish!!!! It's a strange thing to bring them on same stage!!!
Agar twinkle khanna author hai to mai newton hu
Loved that
Being a full time working mom myself, I completely understand the challenges that women go through managing work and home. But to attribute someone’s true success to the ‘privelege’ that they get is just not done!
If I compare the two here, Twinkle got a platform and audience on a platter whereas from what I know Amish got rejected by more than 10 publishers and finally had to self publish his first book!
So let’s not get fooled by the fundamental attribution error here. Twinkle you are a strong, independent woman and a role model, who also is truly privileged in the purest form of the word- please show some magnanimity in your praise and acknowledgment of the other person who has achieved great success, ofcourse with the support from his family as is true for many of us!
The anchor is so disrespectful to Amish....not even she is paying attention when he speaks, looking at her papers and intentionally ignoring....
Twinkle says shes the best selling female author in India. Well her writing is good & witty. But then she has a brigade of Bollywood actors launching her book. Saying "maybe my chromosomes defines my success" is the most absurd statement. 🤦
"I want your sales, not your compliments"- well, she has to be more creative to make her work more-happening than hogwash!
I agree...i hv watched her otjer interviewas well n it seems like she wants to earn more miney thn working on content writing
some lady rishi .....u bloody anchor give some respect to the speaker
Bizarre comment by Anuradha when she said 'some rishi lady' was involved in writing the Vedas. If she wants to know about the women who have been involved in writing some of our spiritual texts why have a dismissive and casual tone about it. Am sure Anuradha would be the first to genuflect in front of any supposed Western feminist without really knowing how relevant that person was/is. As an Indian woman i was deeply offended by her dismissive tone. The same Anuradha was very proud of her home as a feminist home in her interview with the Jain monk Tarun Sagar as if all that was forward thinking emanated from her home. Very egoistic i must say !
anuradha is a ugly person both from the inside & the outside , ironic she hosted a show called "beautiful people"
@ pvnag ....I totally agree with your statement 👍
Biased anchor :((
Its so shocking to learn that the anchor, most of the audience, Twinkle-these guys are imbeciles. Uncannily obsequious to the prevalent dammed tradition.
Needless to say, Amish Sir, he's one of a kind
The anchor is taking this conversation to totally different dimension.
13:14 - 17:00
Wonderful👌👌
You can see that conspicuous restlessness in this anchor, as she finds it difficult to focus on her agenda or get the panelists to say what she wants to hear. Her panelists, at least Amish Tripati, is not toeing the line she wants him to. This is the sad story of modern India, as Amish alluded to, that "more educated you are, less connected with this civilization you are." It is appalling to hear when Twinkle Khanna says our two greatest kavyas were authored by men, so the narrative is from a man's perspective! How does it matter what the source of wisdom is, when it is meant to elevate the humanity to its highest consciousness? Why this relentless focus on gender binary even when the discussion is about the spiritual nectar flowing from really ancient times that is meant to eliminate all multiplicities and melt into oneness? To add to that, she had to be schooled by Amish about women scholars of our ancient past, and I am sure she will not be rid of her bias even after this schooling! These two women need to embrace Dharmic wisdom and rid their intellects' of Aristotelian logic (a Western trait) and stop seeing conflicts in everything they see as binaries. Dharma traditions have always celebrated women as the creative energy without which purusha has no way of expressing himself. Of course, our society got hammered with lot of invasions, and lot of corruptions and oppressive tendencies have crept into the system, as the society went into survival mode and survivors imbibed the alien cultural traits in order to survive. Hope these "modern" thinkers/writers get their lenses cleaned and seek the wisdom of our traditions before they start "educating" the masses. And, finally, "mythology" is a western epistemic category; in our tradition, it is "itihAsa."
this is the problem with western abrahmic education system. their religion, culture and ideologies see man and women different , by this thinking , there exist a man , women issues and discrimination in their society but radical western slave feminist are importing western problem in India or see Indian society through western abrahmic lenses. they people will destroy Indian culture, society and family structure.
Bang on.
Well said Praveen...👍
I think the anchor tried to impress Twinkle so that she could influence her husband in future for a role in the next movie.
The anchor is not just unprepared. She is UNDERPREPARED. ..👎👎👎👎
Joker audience ko Amish sir indian culture bata rahe .Jo sex aur beauty par hi tike hai.
Sahi baaat
Sahi bola
Some lady rishi is still remembered today after 1000's of years and what is the name of that anchor who..! Fake Feminist..!
calling twinkle khanna a writer is disrespectful to the author writers
@@ananyalal7950 exactly
@@ananyalal7950 self-proclaimed writer 😂 having zero knowledge about India and Indian history. Remember the part where 'tripathi' asked to guess who said this.....and she instantly reacted "it can't be many". This shows her narrow minded thoughts.
Manu**
@@sudhakar3653 The biggest question is who buys her Books ?
@@rahulray9983 Akshay Kumar; that's why he does 3-4 movies every year 😂😂
Host is stupid! She isn't giving much significance on Amish. I think she is star struck!! Amish and Twinkle make a great pair for interviews
They didn't seem ready for the kind of wisdom and knowledge that Amish was bringing on the table.
This is just AWKWARD!!
Twinkle's only achievement is that she was privileged to be born as Rajesh Khannas daughter.
anchor is left..
Twinkle, extremely well put! More power to you.
An idiot who decides to play the victim card of being a woman isnt really impressive to a lot of people.
By trying to lower Ameesh through her words, she gains less respect from us.
She had a sound financial background and doesnt know what a banker like Ameesh has to go through in order to become a full time writer.
Heck to even write a book with a full time job is tedious task.
All that twinkle could see was the gender difference.
Man she needs to up her content and knowledge not blabber like idiots to put men down.
what is anchor doing yar..taking so long to respond and asking questions... she has to be quick and spontaneous
@4:06 min, the anchor just cut Amish short
Who reads an author as a woman? Equality or superiority that's the question.
The anchor 😂😂😂😂😂😂
It was so nice to listen to Twinkle Khanna.
Mrs funnybones is one of the most multitalented girls I have ever seen in my life.l always follow her through social media . I think debating with her is one of the most difficult things especially infront of live audience.
Amish is d best author ever i see. Twinkle is just not comparable to his writings.
Feminist always angry, always complaining, always playing victim, always blaming...
Twinkle said politicians are terrible poet...c'mon , Atal Bihari ji was one of the best poet ever lived
She said these days
The person who gave those questions is Ms Gitanjali Iyer I think. She was one of the best
Ooo come on HT u need do a separate session with AMISH SIR..
Mrs. Twinkle khanna is 3rd best seller?
Reason why I chose science in life.
Edit: A waste of time. Amish barely spoke for 12 mins combined.
Question should be is our society and Judicial system ready and capable to do of what took place in Hollywood.
twinkle khanna is an author😂😂no thanks
why is she interrupting so much. I would have lost it. Amish is really humble and calm as well.
Only for Amish.
Amish ❤️❤️
Writing book on any topic of life is very good thing the people who are writer they are very creative and sensible people I am also creative person I write stories of English movies I think the name of movie by my own mind the society in which we are living there are different kinds of people we should write books on these different people I especially admire twinkle khanna that she is a very good book writer
I haven't read twinkles khanna single book.....
Can anybody Tel me which book is best ? So that I can read one ...
Amish has sold almost 6 million at this stage in 2022. She has sold less than 250,000. huge difference and she is definitely not the 3rd highest selling female in india!
We r among d crowd, we respect writings of Amish, number of sell of his book explained everything about his acceptance by mass. About Twinkle , just a big laugh
Was that Rini Simon in the background?
Amish tripathi is the icon our new generation shd follow it's not about Hindu ideology or hindutva it's about knowing our lost culture
True i noticed amish statements were blocked many times by anchor n her assistants. Purposely questioners were on twinkl which is strange. Amish is a seasoned writer not like twinkle. Here again you will see starry eyed audience.
The anchor should respect Amish sir.
I am a woman. I think there is too much importance being given to women’s identities.
If chetan bhagat is the sachin tendulkar of nonsense on the account of being author, the twinkle is the bradman of this art!