Ring Alarm vs SimpliSafe Security System Review
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- Buy SimpliSafe: www.security.o...
See the BEST systems: www.security.o...
Note: SimpliSafe now offers self-monitoring, although you’ll only get notifications with the Interactive Plan. They also added a Google Assistant integration, and cloud storage is available separately from monitoring. They’ve also added a professional installation option for $79. After a recent update, Ring now works with Google Assistant as well as Amazon Alexa. Cellular backup is only available with the Ring Protect Plus plan.
#Ring and #SimpliSafe are two of the most popular security companies around, but which one is right for you? This video will go over the differences in their installation, components, monitoring plans, and more, helping you to make your buying decision.
Timestamps:
0:22 Table of Contents
0:54 Key Similarities
1:12 Key Differences
1:40 Installation
4:25 Professional Monitoring
6:46 Customer Support
8:00 Mobile Application
9:38 Recap
Can’t choose between #RingAlarm and #SimpliSafe for your home’s security? You’ve come to the right place. Ring Alarm and SimpliSafe both have okay app ratings, flexibility, monthly contracting, and DIY installation. A key difference is professional monitoring. All SimpliSafe systems include 24/7 professional monitoring and cellular backup, while Ring Alarm gives you the option to self-monitor. Plus, their most expensive plan only costs $10 a month, $5 less than SimpliSafe’s least expensive plan. In this review, I’ll go over their system components, installation processes, professional monitoring options, customer support, and apps.
Subscribe: / @securitydotorg
Note: We receive free products and participate in affiliate programs.
A few points:
1. In case of the contact sensors, it doesn't matter whether the large unit or the magnet gets placed on the door. What matters is that an alert is generated once the connection is broken.
2. Simplisafe does come preconfigured but does not come by default with enough sensors to fully secure a home. Adding new sensors is the same as the process for Ring; scan the bar code and place in the desired location. It takes a negligible amount of time and is a non-issue, especially for DIYers.
3. Simplisafe uses 3M adhesive to attach its components, which makes it easy to replace or relocate without damaging the surface it is connected to. Ring uses a super-strong adhesive that removes the attached surface when trying to replace, but armed with that knowledge there is no reason the adhesive cannot be replaced with 3M prior to installation.
4. Simplisafe 2nd Generation system is not backward compatible with the 1st generation contact sensors. Since to upgrade I would have been required to buy a whole new system, I decided to try Ring. I have not been disappointed in the least.
5. Ring offers far more options in terms of indoor/outdoor cameras than Simplisafe. Since this is a wireless system you do need to be considerate of the distance from an access point and whether range extenders are required.
This reviewer gave the nod to Simplisafe in a couple of areas based on other reviews, which can't be considered reliable Those recommendations would carry a lot more weight if they were based on personal experience.
Simplisafe is a decent system that I would likely have stayed with had I not been required to purchase a whole new system when I decided to upgrade, but I am so happy that they did. Ring offers a greater degree of flexibility in its implementation.
Ring offers Neighbors app, which is intended to serve as a social media type Neighborhood watch where the user can post suspicious/criminal activity. You do not need to be a Ring subscriber and it is free. In theory, this app is an amazing concept. In practice, I think too many users see suspicious activity where there is none. If Ring established guidelines and moderated the post it would be phenomenal. The Neighbors app aside, for my money Ring, is a far superior offering.
vlthompson3 : well I prefer to mount the sensor on the panel instead of the window b/c when you shut the window hard it’s bad for the sensors with the components and battery, also it weighs more too. It might post a problem in the long run. So mounting the magnet on the actual window is the best.
Ring also sells your data to Facebook and google. Even had a problem where other people can see your cameras and had a data leak too.
Jack Sparrow this is such a idiotic comment. So you saying ring aka amazon sells information to google which is always at beef with amazon. Two companies who compete in everything and one of them still sells information to the other? 😂 look I am not disagreeing with everything but knowing amazon they would rather keep the information they collecting and use it to target more amazon products to you instead of giving it to the others..
nik maknojia Before you call someone’s comment “idiotic,” there are a couple of things in your comment that shows that you are not well-informed. First of all, they aren’t always at beef with each other. Sure they compete in certain niches in technology and services, but overall they help each other hand-in-hand, especially in marketing. In marketing, you need data, data can either be farmed with your own products/services or be bought by other businesses that do the same or are similar. After all, they are a for-profit business whose goal is to make more money which can be done by targeting people with products that they are interested in with the data they have. They may not be the best of friends, but they still make business deals that can make each other profitable. Secondly, the Electronic Frontier Foundation found that 5 companies were identified in receiving information: Facebook (user's time zone, device model and screen resolution and a unique identifier), Branch (unique identifiers, as well as each user's IP address, device model and screen resolution), AppsFlyer (a range of information, including sensor data related to the magnetometer, gyroscope and accelerometer on users' phones), MixPanel (users' full names, email addresses, device information and app settings), and Google’s Crashalytics (a variety of information, when users use the apps, online reviews) without user’s consent. Thirdly, don’t assume that you know what amazon or google is doing cuz you ain’t the one controlling it. Just state the facts instead of your opinion cuz someone’s gonna one-up you.
(Note: don’t even think about mentioning the time they were blocking each other’s services from each other’s products cuz that’s already resolved.)
Ring home security system is not flexible in configuration and customization V.S Simplisafe allows to include/exclude specific sensors in the Away or Home mode or both mode - I loved that feature plus the price cheaper that's why I went with Simplisafe - easy peasy - 2hr setup/installation and my Simplisafe security is up and operational!
This is the second home in which czcams.com/users/postUgkx0jZ_lGlDVJhDnmagEU8gn47cmfPNlLQU we've replaced our "regular" doorbell with a Ring video doorbell and we really enjoy it. It is very easy to install and it works very well, with a clear picture through the app and good in-home use (we added the chime, which is also easy to install and doesn't require another thought to use).
This is the perfect video for me since I am considering these 2 programs. From your video, I have come to the conclusion that the Simplisafe is the superior program, I still want the Ring doorbell cam.
Interesting! I agree that SimpliSafe's video doorbell is much more impressive than any of the Ring video doorbells in terms of it's person detection. What made you go with the Ring? BTW, I also do more detailed written reviews: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
If you haven’t ordered system everything half price until midnight today
@@EC-iu3yb Facts!! Here's a link to get their Black Friday deal: bit.ly/2UlMTgZ
Simply safe uses an unencrypted wireless frequency, so with a $25 radio off amazon, you can knock out the whole blocks simply safe. Ring uses zigbee, which is alot more secure
A really professional comparison video. Thanks. The hat and shirt were even color-coordinated. Right on cool!
Haha thanks so much for noticing and glad you liked the review! My written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe is even more detailed: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
We had SS for years and were never happy with it. Unless you pay 25 a month, which is really expensive, setting up the system is a huge pain. We got ring last year and are never looking back. Ring is very simple and is 3x less expensive for better service. The only complains I have is they charge extra for a yard sign and a extra stickers but that’s easy to deal with considering how much cheaper it is. I also like that rings new products are backward compatible while with SS, if you wanted new devices you’d have to start over.
Simplisafe now has that camera too. New and improved.
Not sure if anyone mentioned this in the comments, but my family really likes the customizations you can change on SimpliSafe. Most notably the option to close the privacy shutters on the cameras. Some people may feel uncomfortable with a camera in a living space or a high traffic area.
Yes, I like that too! See my full review of SimpliSafe to learn more about what your system can do: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
I am thinking of ditching simplisafe for Ring. Main reasons are:
1) I am paying $15 and as far as I know the app feature to disable or enable is not available for $15. Ring sells for $100 per year which is obviously cheaper
2) My old simplisfafe system needs to be updated anyway since it's old.
In so many years, after collecting extra $80 over the competition, Simlisafe should have offered me a complimentary upgrade of the system. They are no longer just competing with ADP. Their main income from me is the monthly payments.
This is such a bias review toward SimpliSafe. The points you are making against Ring and points for SimpliSafe are way off in my opinion. The Ring door/window contact components can easily be reversed and mounted either way. The only plus you are making for SimpliSafe is a possibly faster installation of maybe 10 minutes. Yet on Ring the hardware product is much less expensive, is compatible with so many more home security products which you don't even mention like locks, outdoor security light/cam, ability to integrate with home automation hubs, etc, monthly professional monitoring is optional for Ring not so with SimpliSafe but even so, it takes $10 per month for Ring vs $25 (to get an equivalent feature to Ring app) so the total cost of ownership with SimpliSafe is incredibly more expensive than Ring. Sorry if this is coming off a little harsh but I don't like it when an influencer that is perceived to be fair really isn't. You have lost credibility.
So true Dale and what I dont like about Simplisafe is they tell you its $14 a month to monitor but if you want full access its $25 a month Ring dosent do that
1000% agree with you 👍
@@Alec-Fast I went with the ring system its fine and its $10 a month for monitoring and thats it It works fine
agree, the review(er) very conveniently chose to not list simpli's flaws and ring's advantages. Biased!
I was about to buy Simpli until i watched other reviews and came to know about ring's advantages.
@@heysushant yep true
I just got my Simplisafe yesterday. And I love it. My only complaint is that the adhesive on the back doesn’t stick very well. My motion sensor, keypad, and siren fell off the wall so I had to screw them in.
Interesting! I had no issues with the adhesive. Is it humid where you live? Check out my full review of SimpliSafe if you want more info on how your system works: bit.ly/2UlMTgZ
You have to make sure you clean the area that you want to stick them to as well. I have two keypads, two motion sensors, two glass break and none of them has ever fallen off and this is with the simplisafe. #simplisafe4life #simplisafe4thewin
@@slance126 Great point! I'm a fan of SimpliSafe's peel-and-stick elements as well.
Did you clean the location first? I never had any problems with the adhesive
Try these.....www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07PFW5SXB/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o03_s01?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Thanks for the review I've pre ordered the Ring Alarm from Amazon out in the UK next month. Cheers
Awesome! Hope you like it.
And little to no mention of smart home integration... My Ring setup controls and monitors my door locks too, an invaluable feature!
Yep, Ring now works with Google Assistant in addition to Alexa, and SimpliSafe works with Alexa. I talk about it more in my individual reviews of each-
Ring Alarm- bit.ly/2NKQjUK
SimpliSafe- bit.ly/2XAi5ro
I love your videos, you were the reason we chose ring over simply safe
curious what the criteria were for ya... why one over the other?
@@Bane-l7h Well the mobile app was more user friendly and it gave notifications. I believe you have to pay for the mobile access on simplisafe. The last reason is the professional monitoring was cheaper.
Thank you for the detailed demonstration of the SimpliSafe vs. Ring, much appreciated. Purchased Simplisafe.
Awesome! Learn more about SimpliSafe in my full written review: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
great video, thx
Thank you for the review the differences help me to select a system.
Awesome! Which did you decide on?
Don't rely on one review. Do additional research before making a decision. What are you looking for in a security system?
My comments: I actually ordered a SimpliSafe kit which came to around $450 but returned it unopened as I changed my mind and got Ring. Setup is done; need to put up more door and window sensors. Waiting for some "Slim Magnets" to come. I should have known I needed those as ADT had used them when they installed 8 years ago. I cannot complete installation without Slim Magnets because of the way some of our doors are built.
SimpliSafe uses VERIZON whereas Ring uses AT&T. The signal with AT&T is only one bar at best at my home, and indeed on my app and online it shows just one red bar. But when I called customer service, they said not to worry, as in the event of a breakin when our power and WiFi are down, one bar even if showing in red, is adequate to send a signal by cellular. The Ring base station can run 24 hours on its own battery.
One other thing: Costco currently has the Ring Doorbell to purchase for $189, and that includes the one year of Plus monitoring for the doorbell and the security system! Nice! Costco only has the 10 piece system in the warehouse so I had to order 2 more motion detectors, 6 Slim Magnets, and likely I'll need 4 more contact sensors for doors/windows and oh, will need the smoke alarm "listener" sensor which relies on the scream from our existing smoke detectors. (I think).
Wow, this was a super helpful and in depth comparison. Thank you for making this video.
Glad you enjoyed it!
This was very informative. Thanks Gabe!
You're welcome, Greg! More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
I’ve had both and I prefer simply safe. Ring has been bought out and unfortunately it’s just not as good as it was before. It’s also not as good as SimpliSafe. I’ve had SimpliSafe for about five years now with the top-tier monitoring. I’m very happy with it. The integration between the cameras sensors etc. is seamless and customer support is top notch. Also SimpliSafe has excellent monitoring. Also, you do not have to pay anything for SimpliSafe if you want to use it as a non-monitored/local alarm. You can choose two different levels of monitoring service for $13/$24 or you can pay nothing and just use it as a local alarm. SimpliSafe is the way to go, in my experience with both.
Thanks for sharing your experience! For anyone else interested, here's my full written comparison of Ring vs. SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
I chose Ring for the overall package, flexibility and ecosystem. I have the doorbell and one Outdoor camera so far with more planned for the future. SimpliSafe, put simply, has less hardware options and is more expensive. Ring FTW.
👍have you see my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe? bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
wrong... if you look over the products and read Security Baron's written review, you'd see Simplisafe includes more products e.g. keyfobs, siren, and panic button which Ring does not. Simplisafe also has the video cam now and allows self monitoring so I'd say in terms of hardware, SImplisafe > Ring. I'm still debating on the subscription plan as to which would be better for 24/7 monitoring. The nice thing about Ring though is they have the outdoor cams, but they're ridiculously expensive which I feel you could get a much better deal just buying wired security cameras separately, save recordings on a hard drive, and use for self monitoring
aperkins07 : Ring has panic button too $35. Too bad they dont have a good siren like the Simplisafe.
So.. SimpliSafe does not require the professional monitoring... at least now in 2021. Perhaps that's changed since this Video 2 years ago, but luckily I didn't have to include that.
It should be noted that Simplisafe does now offer self monitoring.
Yep, updated the description and the written review: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Which doorbell should I choose if I want to use the Ring outdoor floodlight cameras and the Simplisafe indoor security system?
I talked to simplisafe customer support professional monitoring is no longer required
This is a confusing comment. Maybe professional monitoring isn't "required," but it is still the only way to achieve App control from your phone if I understand correctly. Right?
@@Irwhodunit there is a new "Basic App Control" plan for $0/month. You can switch to it after a free trial but you have to call their support to get it. It allows you to control the system, get alerts if triggered, and camera alerts. Just got it yesterday when cancelling monitoring plan because damn it's expensive
@@shaneblain Thank you. Is the "Basic App Control" for SimpliSafe or Ring? I went with Ring and set up for their live monitoring. But frankly, in nearly a year, I've never armed the alarm. I'm at home and personally armed about 23 hours a day.
@@Irwhodunit "Basic App Control" for $0 is with SimpliSafe. I've been able to arm/disarm from app, receive some notifications, and view the camera. I think the $10 SimpliSafe plan gives you additional camera features but I'm not sure.
With Ring you're paying $10/month to get Live Monitoring and police dispatch and all the awesome app features that come free anyway.
For simplisafe In order to get Live Monitoring/Police Dispatch AND upgraded app features, you have to pay $25/month.
Did a lot of research recently 😅
@@shaneblain Thanks for sharing your research. I know it will be helpful to many people who are shopping, as I was a year ago. With Ring hardware installed and the security set up properly, I won't make a change. But others who are on the fence, will find your comments very helpful. Actually, I usually glean more information from COMMENTS than from the original video that prompts them. Best wishes.
This is the one I needed to ma decision!
Excellent! What did you decide? More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
I am looking into these two exact systems and one thing I noticed is that you do not need monitoring with simplisafe. Their system will work without monitoring for self monitoring. From their site "We strongly recommend a monitoring plan. Without a plan, your system will still function as a siren, but we won't be able to dispatch police or call you to alert you to a break-in at home."
Wow, that is a new feature! I'll have to make some updates. Thanks for the tip!
As someone who bought a SimpliSafe system, dropped ~$500 for it, and then returned it for a full refund, you do need monitoring. Without it, you literally can't do anything with the system. It doesn't even give you app notifications on your phone. It's completely useless. To further annoy you, there are features of different monitoring devices that cannot be accessed without the subscription. People on their forums say stuff like, "you can just buy one month, modify the settings of the devices, and then cancel it." I don't mind not having someone call me when my alarm goes off but to not even get notifications, via the app, if the alarm is going off is absolutely ridiculous.
So yes, you don't NEED the monitoring plan but without it you have to be at home to know there was ever an event. Trust me, if you're on the fence with both, go with Ring. It's amazing and my wife and I have been loving it for the last few months!
@@matthelton6637 Would you still recommend Ring? I'm on the fence between Ring and SimpliSafe.
@@aprildonahoo8650 Yes, I would. With SimpliSafe, you don't get the full product, not even something that feels like a "demo," if you don't pay for the subscription service. That didn't sit right.
Ring has a subscription, also, but you don't NEED it to use the hardware. I still recommend Ring (even with their privacy stuff, ugh).
Hi, Dave! I discovered your channel and really appreciate your in-depth and well-produced videos. We had a break-in at our remote farm in Maine and now (closing the barn door after the horse is gone) we are looking for a security system. I like the Simplisafe overall. But, a few questions that seem to arise on all of these systems:
1. Do you get some kind of alert on your alarm panel or cellphone that one of the sensors needs to have its battery replaced?
2. Can you set up sensors to beep/send an alert, even if the system is in Home mode (or off). So, for example, a door that is rarely opened or back windows that are out of sight - if those open up during the day, an alert/alarm is sent? Meanwhile, the usual doors and window sensors stay quiet for normal daytime use? I guess that would be a "settings per sensor" adjustment?
3. Are panic buttons "always on/available?" I would think they would be.
4. Are there integrations with Alexa for IFTTT or something that might trigger all the lights to be turned on? Most of our lights are Alexa controlled.
I also just ordered the Eufy video camera system which looks similar to Arlo version. I also have an older IP camera. I wish there were a software that would be "one stop shopping" for these various cameras. One portal that could host all cameras. But, probably, for the hassle involved, I could just retire the old IP camera.
I guess the outside sirens are battery operated? Our farm is way out in the country and the neighbor is about a city-block distance away.
I appreciate all the help! Great videos and very professional!
Thanks!
Hi Charles! It's actually Gabe. Happy to answer your questions.
1. Yes, you will be alerted on your alarm panel and phone if one of your sensors has low battery.
2. Yes, on Home Mode all of the sensors are armed except the motion sensors, so you can still be alerted from your entry or glass break sensors.
3. Panic buttons are always on/ available regardless if the system is armed or not.
4. Yes, SimpliSafe has integrations with Nest Thermostats and August smart locks. Unfortunately it doesn't work with any smart light bulbs, but it does work with Alexa for voice commands.
I also wish there was one portal to host all cameras!
The SimpliSafe siren is battery-operated.
Glad to be of help and thanks for watching! Here's a link to learn more about SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
@@SecurityDotOrg Hi, Gabe! Sorry, I just got your reply. I appreciate the information.
The setup for Simplisafe looks good and I like all aspects of it except for the lack of zones. For example, we have doors/windows that are rarely opened and should be armed at all times except when the alarm is completely OFF.
On the other hand, we have doors that are in use during the day that should only be armed when AWAY.
Then, of course, there are glass breakage detectors that, IMHO, should be armed all the time, too, because they are in remote areas of the house.
I like the fob idea and the sirens and all that, but I think zones are needed. I also did not see a strobe light or external relay type of device. This is for a farm in Maine and the distances between houses are significant so noise and lights are a big deal.
We installed Eufy cameras and they works well! I did see another service, Deep Sentinel (www.deepsentinel.com/) which shows some promise for a particularly sensitive/high value area of our property. I will look into that.
Do you have any recommendations for a wireless alarm that includes zones?
Thanks for the great videos! I've watched several and told friends about them, as well.
Frankly, it's sad to see this uptick in a need for this level of security but that's the world we live in.
Hi again Charles,
SimpliSafe does allow you to arm some sensors and not others. You'll just need to customize your components using the SimpliSafe Easy Setup Wizard. Here are some instructions from SimpliSafe: simplisafe.com/help-center/result/can-i-customize-my-system-so-certain-sensors-are-enabled-or-disabled
You are right that SimpliSafe lacks a strobe light. However, they do have an 105 decibel siren available.
I haven't actually reviewed the Deep Sentinel system yet so I can't really comment, but glad you're liking your eufy cameras!
If I were you, I'd do SimpliSafe even though there's no strobe light. SimpliSafe works with Alexa so I'd get a camera with a strobe light that does too. For example, you can get the Ring Floodlight Cam: bit.ly/2Z0UXCa
Thanks for spreading the word! I am happy to help.
You do a great review, my friend.
The one major difference is, with simplisafe you have to subscribe in order to have app access. With ring you have the mobile app access without subscription.
I like ring I have it
Glad you like it! To learn more about Ring, read my written review here: bit.ly/2NKQjUK
Does Ring have water sensors and do they offer outside cameras? Please advise. Thanks in advance, as I look forward to hearing from you all. Blessings always, Mr. Pol
Quick question ... my ADT charges me extra for the communication that goes along with the monitoring (basically a separate cell signal). Do the monitoring costs for Ring and Simplisafe already take this into account? Seems like they would since they talk about no need for a landline, but I would like to be sure that when we talk about monitoring for $30/year or $15/month ... that that really is the cost. Thanks,
Yep, those costs for Ring and SimpliSafe include cellular backup.
Thank you! It helps a lot. Excellent video
I'm a homeowner and currently use SimpliSafe. I want to add comments to your video based on my experience that may offer more clarification not covered in your video.
1. Installation of SimpliSafe and Ring are equally easy, however, one doesn't use the SimpliSafe app to install and activate the sensors. You use the keypad to activate the sensors and it is very clunky and feels rather 1990's for a modern installation experience. Four doors, three motion sensors, two keypads and base station took about 45-60 minutes to install. Not bad and was easy but could have been a better, more confident experience with an app.
2. With SimpliSafe, you don't get to use the app at all unless you're paying for the interactive monitoring package at $25 ($24.99). The less expensive $15 ($14.99) doesn't give you the ability to use the app to arm and disarm the security system or check history of door and motion sensors, etc.
3. The door chime for when doors are opened an closed (can be disabled but I like knowing when doors are opened and also closed) when the alarm is disarmed only chimes once for when a door is opened. When a door is closed you don't get an additional chime which is a setback from other security systems. I've used three other security systems and they all give you confirmation chimes for when doors are also closed - it is a nice feature and I feel it is important, especially if you have children.
4. The keypads do not chime when the doors are opened. Only the base station chimes. Again, I've used three other security systems and the base station and keypads all chime. This is a setback if you have a larger home and especially if the base station is not centrally located in your home.
5. SimpliSafe and Ring cameras need to be plugged in for power to the cameras. I'm surprised (and disappointed) that Ring cameras are not wireless yet like Netgear Arlo cameras. I don't mention disappointment with a lack of wireless for SimpliSafe cameras only because they're strictly a traditional home security system and never started out with doorbells and security cameras before moving into home security monitoring. Maybe SimpliSafe should partner with Netgear Arlo so homeowners can link the cameras to their SimpliSafe home security system.
Great video and thank you for doing these reviews!
Which system would you recommend? Ring or SimpliSafe? I'm on the fence.
SimpliSafe’s outdoor camera is wireless- indoor camera is not.
@@aprildonahoo8650 Because Amazon has a history of sending video footage to police without permission or notification of the homeowner, I would not use Ring products in my home at all. I also would not use SimpliSafe cameras. I use SimpliSafe for security and Arlo cameras as a separate video surveillance.
You did not mention, glass break sensor are not available with ring alarm..
Good point! Unfortunately Ring doesn't make glass break sensors. More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
We currently have Comcast security. Moving and they do not service our new home (have to pay them to cancel). These are the two systems I'm looking at. Torn. Equipment price wise right now, they're about the same (SS having sale plus free camera). Monitoring price is obviously different. I want to be able to use my phone. The free camera is a plus.
These seem very very similar. Need help. SS tend to get better reviews and rankings in "top security system" reviews. Having cellular is also a must. We're moving somewhere where our internet could be suspect. Help!
There are a lot of similarities, but Ring is going to be cheaper on a monthly basis so I'd go with that. bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Great video this will really help me make a decesion on which security to pick.
Awesome, thanks! More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Have you dont a comparison between ADT Security Systems and Simplisafe? because im considering (after im out of my contract) switching from ADT to simplisafe
Yep, it's here- bit.ly/2GGzZ5B
The Ring system does not take an hour to set up. The base may take a lot of trouble shooting and ring support to get connected to WiFi. An Hour on the phone... The devices can take a few hours to sync with the base unit. I’ve been waiting for 6 hours now. Which I heard does happen. Then, while you wait for the devices to sync you cannot get any live feed from the camera or try to back space out if the app. It’s locked up while you wait for a few hours...
Well it may depend with each persons experience but it only took me a few minutes to set up base. Now it took several hours to set up devices but i have slanted trim on doors and 5 of them plus two motion detectors and 15 windows. I can only attest to my experience but I never had these issues.
Ring wins ...period.
I got both ring camera and SimpliSafe alarm trying see if I should go with ring alarm system
I got you Jay! See my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe here- bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Can I run SimpliSafe and Ring through my computer with internet? I do not have a smart phone, and don't want to buy another new phone if it is not required.
Hello,
For SimpliSafe, you'll need a smart phone for the SimpliCam or SimpliSafe Doorbell Pro. Ring has a Windows app that you can use on your computer although it'll require a Windows 10 device. For any of the security systems that I review, smartphones are preferred. Here's my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe for more info: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Thank you for the review
Interesting that you noted that the Ring Alarm does not come pre-programmed , I’ve had my system for over a year now and the kit that I bought had every single sensor programmed to the base station. All I had to do was pull the tab and it was already paired to the alarm system. Did they change something recently?
Hi. Thank you for this review. Ive never had a system so even all your great, easy explanations has me a little confused. I can't seem to figure out who has what i really want. On top of things here with these 2 companies, i REALLY want a couple outdoor cameras. It seems to me that it would be really smart to be alerted to and see some things BEFORE they happen. An indoor camera i don't really know what id need it for, unles wanting yo watch a sitter with children, but i want to see whose creeping around most! And not just who rings my doorbell. Any thoughts for me? Is there something out there for me? I love both of these you reviewed but i want more! Lol. Thank you!
If you're looking for an outdoor camera, Ring has a couple options while SimpliSafe does not. Check out my full written review for the Ring Stickup Cam Wired, an outdoor/ indoor camera: bit.ly/2XFeOae
I have Simplisafe and it's a nice system EXCEPT for the fact that you NEED to pay $25 monthly to use home integration AND use the mobile app. Honestly, that should be free. Most company's have free integration with Amazon, Google or the apple nerds as well as free mobile apps. I would rate them 5 stars but because of the extortion fee (24/7 home monitoring is a scam to get your $$$) I give it 3.
Agreed, their app privileges are pretty pricey, esp when compared to Ring. To learn more, read my full written comparison of Ring vs. SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
I think a very minor addition to the comparisons would be the aesthetic value of the systems. In this case, SimpliSafe is the more attractive version, but it is something people consider when buying new things, especially electronics that will sit out for people to see.
Just my two cents.
Good point! That's definitely something someone might want to consider when choosing a security system. For more pics of the systems, see our written review: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
To think of it though, differences in capability are objective, while preference for differences in appearance are subjective.
I had the Simplisafe set up for a couple of days. The base station is attractive and speaks in a crisp English female voice: "Your camera is ready to be set-up."
For someone who wanted to use outside of US, what do you recommend? Ring allows self-monitoring without requiring monthly subscribing. Does this make Ring is the only option for those who would like to use it outside of the country. Also someone who lives in a country where they use 220/240 VAC, 50Hz. Thank you very much in advance.
It's definitely not the only option but to make a recommendation, I just want to confirm that you live in Myanmar.
There's a CZcams video on Simplisafe vs Ring security systems a side by side comparison.
This is it! I also have a written version that's even more detailed: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
What about the cameras. How are they at night and clarity range
To learn more about the cameras, I'd check out my individual reviews of Ring Alarm and SimpliSafe:
Ring Alarm: bit.ly/2NKQjUK
SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
All Ring and SimpliSafe cameras passed the mark when it came to video and night vision.
Ring alarm (from what I read) when set off takes 30 seconds before the loud alarm sounds. How does this compare to Simplisafe? Thanks!
You can customize the amount of time with SimpliSafe in the app. More info on SimpliSafe in my written review: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
30 second delay is only for entry motion detector or entry door( this entry time is actually customized up to 3 min. and can be set differently for entry and exit.) You can customize which doors and motion detectors you want as entry. All windows, secondary doors and secondary motion detectors will alarm immediately when triggered. Response time from alarm trigger from monitoring site is around 30 seconds which is pretty standard from what i read to give you time to disarm if false alarm. I have done this a few times letting dogs out in morning lol.
I just called both for comparison and RING told me that if your wifi goes out they give you cellular cover for only 24 hours
Whoops, looks like I misunderstood that! I'll make a note of it. Thanks so much for pointing that out Margie!
That's actually really badass.
I had a Simpisafe for about 5 yrs and liked it for the most part...however, I now live off the grid and need a solution that works with WIFI only or using a hardline dialup as a backup as we have (zero) cell service where we live now. What would work best for this situation?
Hi Rod,
With both Ring and SimpliSafe, you can do Wi-Fi only- cellular backup costs extra and is not required. More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Great job Gabe.....thank you!😎👍
Hi Kevin, I'm glad you liked it!
Gabe what security system do you use for your daily driver??
1:15 That is not correct, SimpliSafe does not require professional monitoring. You can absolutely do local, no purchase required monitoring. You can absolutely self monitor with SimpliSafe.
Hi, this video was recorded before they offered the self-monitoring option. We updated the CZcams description and written review. Here's a full review of SimpliSafe for more info: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
It's great, but the volume on this video is very low!!!!!
Hi Connie! Thanks for watching. Maybe turn the volume up on your computer and make sure the volume on the video is turned up all the way...I haven't had anyone else say they had this issue. You can also read the written version if that's easier: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Security Baron : Yea the audio of this video is low. I dont usually turn up over half the volume on my iPad but this video I had to. You need a better mic
Can you add the Ring doorbell to either of these? I kinda like the doorbell and it seems like both would have had that as part of the package...
You can only add it to Ring. SimpliSafe has their own video doorbell: bit.ly/2IgCECm
And here's the reviews of Ring's video doorbells:
2: bit.ly/2WVhv6m
Pro: bit.ly/2Kp9Jin
good info -- well done. thanks!
Fantastic video!!
Thanks! More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Can you let us know on your reviews how each device sounds as well? I'm curious of the type of audible notifications come from the base station that alerts
Like your channel, What would be the best system if we have no internet at the farm ( one barn is 160 ft from house ) ?
SimpliSafe doesn't require Internet. See my written review here: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
Is there a security system that has facia recognition so it can identify the owner? Is there a system that turns on and off automatically when i leave the house ?
Hi Rich,
The only security system I've reviewed with geofencing is Alarm Grid: bit.ly/2TDGIUS
Their Qolsys IQ Panel 2 has facial recognition.
Hi do you have a Nest Alarm vs SimpliSafe Security System Review video?
Hi, shockingly I don't! But I will add that to the list. In the meantime, check out my individual reviews of each:
Nest Secure: bit.ly/2ESy50E
SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
Installation is once or maybe 2x I am more concerned with how good it is after it is up and running
Hi Patricia,
I wrote more about how well each system worked in my individual reviews:
Ring Alarm: bit.ly/2NKQjUK
SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
@@SecurityDotOrg thank you
I love it. Since you are not going to use it. Please send it to me. I have a great home for it.
Thanks! I still need it for future comparisons though. If you want the best offer for Ring Alarm, click here- bit.ly/2UpPNRD
all these wireless diy wifi alarm systems are dependent of you wifi network and if you are away or even at home and your router goes down you are not monitored so it is only as good as your router.
Very true! We actually reviewed some Wi-Fi routers as well like the Nest Wifi, if you're interested: bit.ly/2WAvBLq
Those simplisafe prices have gone way up. I simplisafe requires the monitoring yes, but with simplisafe not only is the devices, equipment better, you get good quality for cheap price, on the other hand ring, Jesus lord sky high prices, have always been that way, don't think they will ever change. Big differences, I would stay with simplisafe for me.. That's my top system.
Hey if you wanna pay a arm and a little leg for a ring device cool with me.
Does ring have a glass break sensor yet? Or will they rely on Home Guard on Echo?
Hi Chris,
Ring doesn't currently have a glass break sensor, but the motion sensor encompasses glass break assuming its within range. See my full written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Is it true that by disarming the Ring Security System it does not automatically disable motion detection on your internal cameras? With SimpliSafe when I disarm it, my indoor cameras stop potential recordings.
Hello,
Yes, to disable motion recording you'll have to use the Motion Record control in the Ring app. For more info, see my written review of Ring Alarm here: bit.ly/2NKQjUK
With SS, u don't need to get the monthly subscription, I called them and that is what their customer sales told me
So what time period do you pay in instead?
@@SecurityDotOrg
first: your reviews are EXCELLENT, i love the content, it is very HIGH QUALITY
second: regarding SS
apparently you just pay for the equipment and can self monitor, again this is what the sales rep told me on the phone. i am still researching different options.
third: need your advice!
im in the process of a new home construction 300 sqft. i want to have a good system which wont break the bank which i can do self monitoring.
here is what i am looking for:
1. wired cameras, with lights and motion, probably 4-8, for outdoor. ideally to not have to purchase a separate monitor . so if there is an app or free software which i can use on my laptop/android that would be great, free storage on a dvr is fine
2. no interior cameras
3. use cameras over the front entry to avoid purchasing a video doorbell
4. front entry lock which has keypad entry so i dont need a key
5. alarm system for motion detection and if this could integrate with the cameras or be the same system that would be great
got any ideas? thanks in advance, keep your good content coming!
@@amphindian That sounds like massive overkill for a 300 sqft. home. Did you leave out a zero on that? (It's disappointing that Security.org didn't bother to respond to your request for ideas.)
@@Irwhodunit lol yes it's 3000 . Ah well. He must be busy 🤷
I want to use the Simply Save system, but it has no doorbell system. Makes me want to get both and somehow link them.
SimpliSafe actually has a video doorbell now! bit.ly/2IgCECm
It came out after I posted this video.
I have the doorbell and Jesus it works like a charm. Literally send you alerts of motion on the spot!
It took me 45 minutes & finally a phone call to ask about a doorbell system, and they directed me to it through a different page, which was confusing because the doorbell didn't naturally come up when trying to 'build' a system. Their website could be a little more 'user-friendly'.
@@mimiashford5544 Agreed, it's really hard to find products on it. Here's my full review of the Simplisafe Video Doorbell: bit.ly/2IgCECm
Since simplisafe requires professional monitoring, does it mean their system cannot be used in countries outside the U.S where their professional monitoring doesn't work ?
You can technically use SimpliSafe outside of the U.S, but it'll only work as a local alarm so I wouldn't recommend it (no interactive monitoring features like notifications, livestreaming, etc). See our full review of SimpliSafe for more info: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
@@SecurityDotOrg thank you, I think the ring system will work best for those of us outside simplisafes professional monitoring scope. Ring already is present here in my country (Ghana, in Africa) and so far their gadgets are doing great.
@@MichaelJohnson-kl7rf Yes, that definitely makes more sense. Here's a link to get the best offer from Ring- bit.ly/2UpPNRD
Simplisafes monitoring isn't the best. At least for the system i installed about 4 years ago. I would purposely set the alarm off. Then wait for a call. But the calls mostly never came, so I stopped paying for remote monitoring. Plus like others have said, customer service was a joke, literally.
Simplisafe has come a long way. We have ther new system simplisafe 3 and they have a couple of call centers now so i never wait more than 3 minutes to get someone and when we set ours off i got a call with 10 seconds so i love simplisafe and will never go to anything else #simplisafe4life #simplisafe4thewin
I in need of a cellular connection all the time! What is the best system for me?
Any paid plan with SimpliSafe will have cellular backup while only the Protect Plus plan with Ring will have it. Ring is cheaper than SimpliSafe by a minimum of $5 a month. More info on Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
i already have the ring doorbell. might as well get the ring alarm just so everything is within the same app
Agreed! Here's a link to get the best offer- bit.ly/2UpPNRD
I have Ring and Simplisafe systems. Sometimes I get confused on which system my cameras are on.
Puellos _ I have had both and I disagree. I’ve had more problems with the ring. SimpliSafe is amazing with great customer service and again you do not have to pay for monitoring if you choose to use it locally i.e. without professional monitoring
@@postersm7141 I actually switched to nest alarm system and nest doorbell
can both the systems connect to google hub or tablets via app? I want to set up a tablet say on kitchen wall so when someone rings i can see.
While both Ring and SimpliSafe work with Google Assistant, only Ring lets you stream on the Google smart displays, unfortunately. More info in my written review- bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
How does motion sensor work w pets? Will it trigger the alarm?
Ring: won't detect pets under 50 pounds
SimpliSafe: if you mount upside down and 4-5 feet off ground, won't detect pets. Instructions here: simplisafe.com/blog/avoid-false-alarms-from-pets
And here's my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe for more info: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
@@SecurityDotOrg I just read your review noted here, revised August 2020. You indicated the Simplisafe tier 3 monitoring fee is $ 14.99/month. Other research indicates the fee is now $24.99. Did they increase the fee by 66% since August?
Hi Gabe, I have watched almost every review you made about Ring and Simplisafe. I don't live in the US so I want plan to install a security system that makes a very loud noise that will alert my neighbours since internet are not reliable. Would you suggest Simplisafe or Ring? I like the extra siren you can add to simplisafe but also like the backup battery in the Ring System. Which one would you suggest since I won't be able to use any of the monitoring offer by them? I need basically a noise maker.
I would definitely do Ring because you can self-monitor and livestream footage and receive notifications. With SimpliSafe self-monitoring, it basically becomes a local alarm system so you won't be able to use the app at all. See my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe here for more info: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
What about if your internet goes down?
If you do a paid monthly plan with either company, you'll get cellular backup which makes your system stay on. Check out my full written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe for detailed info about all the plans- bit.ly/2N2ner9
@@SecurityDotOrg I'm trying to decide between ring, simplysafe, and cove. I live in an area with alot of storms and hurricanes. If we evacuate i want to be able to monitor my home even if power is out or the wifi is down. Which one would be best? And which one is less susceptible to being hacked or easily disarmed by an intruder
Can you do a comparison between Simplisafe and Abode? It's a toss up between those two for me.
Hi Moe,
Yep, we did that a little while back. Here you go! bit.ly/2J6QeMx
simplisafe gives you self monitoring with no monthly fee
I’m so conflicted. I want Simplisafe for my house, however I’m seeing so many mixed reviews regarding the hardware crapping out or false alarms.
Personally I found SimpliSafe really easy to use and didn't get many false alarms but there does tend to be a variance with security systems in general. For more info, see my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Simplisafe, like all other alarm systems aren't foolproof when it comes to false alarms. I have one personally, we had our keypad replaced since it "thought" the panic button was being pressed, which means the cops are dispatched.
However, their warranty is top-notch and customer service is really sympathetic when it comes to these incidents. I've had few of my devices replaced with no pushy tactics.
I would strongly advise against SimpliSafe. My wife and I bought it before returning it (2-4 weeks later) for a full refund. If you don't pay for a subscription you have no idea if your alarm is going off. They have an app to manage the system but features, including specific device settings, are not available without a subscription. It's so frustrating. We went with Ring and have loved it. I wouldn't go back to SimpliSafe even if they paid me to.
I’ve been using Ring Alarm for a year now and I’ve been super happy with it. I’ve never once had a false alarm and all of the hardware that came with the kit is all still working perfectly. What’s nice about ring is when you pay for the ring protect plan at $10 a month, all of the hardware is included under a warranty. My ring doorbell started misbehaving a while back and ring replaced it no questions asked.
@@matthelton6637 Thank you for this comment. I purchased Simplisafe and have now packaged it for returning to the company. A Ring package is on the way. I liked the Simplisafe hardware and cameras, but the forced monitoring for app control and the fixed expense really got under my skin.
I would get simplisafe but they don’t have outside cameras I don’t want inside cameras
Yep, I hope they come out with an outdoor camera soon! In the meantime, you might be interested in my review of the best outdoor cameras of 2019: bit.ly/2JeoKlQ
Isnt the video doorbell the same thing? (As an outdoor camera)
@@cashcreators So a video doorbell is an outdoor camera plus a doorbell, so it can hook up to your existing doorbell or be battery-operated. Either way, you'll be notified via a mobile notification if someone rings your doorbell and from there you can livestream footage and speak to that person. To learn more, check out my list of the best video doorbells of 2019: bit.ly/31nBWw2
@@SecurityDotOrg error 404 Not Found
They recently came out with an outdoor camera - which is wireless and operates off of a battery - solar charging is an option.
Simplisafe isn't exactly self .monitored, unlike ring it wont let you access any features in the app to know when somethings up, so when your away from the home its useless without monitoring plans.
Agreed, it becomes a local alarm system if you don't sign up for professional monitoring. To learn more, read our full written review of SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
@@SecurityDotOrg but even a local alarm system could be a deterrent for burglaries as opposed to having a video monitoring system, yes, you see what's happening and are notified of it, may not do anything against the burglaries if they are not aware of it or don't see it as an issue. Compare this with a siren that can go off and get attention from neighbors. That's pretty much what guard dogs are. They make noise and deter people from entering or try to keep them out.
@@aperkins07 Agreed! A study from Rutgers actually found that just by having an alarm system, burglaries are prevented. More info in this article on my site: bit.ly/31PHYF8
I love our simplisafe system
Awesome! For more info, see my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe- bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Please clarity and day and night vision to be compared....
Smart home integration is a big deal for me I wish I had known before I bought SimpliSafe that the cameras do not work with Alexa Echo show
Both systems need to make some changes if you ask me,
Can you do a comparison between ring and ADT security? If you have, someone drop the link!
I went back and looked and I have done so many iterations of comparisons. But did not find that one! I'll try this summer!
Gabe I have been reading tons of reviews as current as November 2019 and according to them they have all said simplisafe customer service is the worst as far as waiting times and returning equipment and trying to cancel service. So how in gods name do you go to simplisafe for customer support. Please explain unless your getting something from simplisafe lol. What’s up with that
I felt he was a bit biased towards them. Based on my research
Over all your video helped me decide but you missed hardware costs, quality.
Which one are you going with if you don't mind me asking I still can choose
Hi Steve,
Valid criticism! I would say SimpliSafe's system is of higher quality than Ring's, the hardware I bought cost around the same price- $547 for Ring and $559 for SimpliSafe (although SimpliSafe didn't include their video doorbell, which costs $199, so SimpliSafe is more expensive). More info here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
This info is wrong - SimpliSafe do a subscription free stand alone system. A monitoring plan is not a requirement.
This is an old review from before they offered self-monitoring. Here is the most updated review of SimpliSafe: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
Have you done any Wi-Fi extender reviews?
Yes, just did Nest Wifi: bit.ly/2WAvBLq
hi
Sorry for the thumbs down. But i don't think you went in depth into the truly important parts. Personal opinion. If i'm not at home, then i want to be able to see my home and what's going on. How many cameras can i view with either system? How well do the cameras work on the app for remote viewing? How loud is the alarm? How easy is it to set up with my router or internet? Mostly because you hate to buy a new alarm and can't get it to work. 👍👍🙏
Hi Shaka,
No problem! I'm happy to answer your additional questions.
1. You'll be able to livestream footage from as many cameras as you have with either system.
2. The ring Alarm base station is 104 decibels loud, about as loud as a table saw. SimpliSafe's base station isn't very loud at about 26 decibels, but they do have an 105-decibel siren you can add on.
3. Both companies have highly-rated apps allowing you to livestream easily, although SimpliSafe's app is a bit better.
4. Setup wasn't hard with either system.
My written reviews have a lot more detail than my video reviews- check out the one for Ring vs. SimpliSafe here: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
The new simplisafe base station has a built in siren that is 95 decibels and you can get the additional siren that is 105 decibels but ours is loud enough dont need the extra siren plus we have there video doorbell, interior camera as well and we get notifications as soon as someone walks up our sidewalk. These guys are awesome
@@SecurityDotOrg Thank you. Young man you have an amazing and awesome channel. And more importantly you respond to your viewers. So again thank you so much. 👍👍🙏
But does Ring offer Cell Connection as a part of their $10 plan or is it extra.. that would be the thing I care most about....o and SimpliSafe does let you self monitor
Yep, I made this video before SimpliSafe added the self-monitoring option but you won't be able to use the mobile app, so it basically turns your system in just local alarms. Ring's $10 plan includes cellular backup but so does the $3/ month plan. See my full written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe for more details: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n
Do you have to pay the 24.99 a month to have the features for the simplisafe app? Or is it free to see cameras and alerts like ring is? If not that is a big factor in rings favor, in my opinion.
Yes, you'll need to do the Interactive Plan to get the mobile app features and alerts. See the written review of SimpliSafe for more info: bit.ly/2XAi5ro
@@SecurityDotOrg I feel like that should have played into the mobile app section. Yes the mobile app is better, but only if you pay. To me that is a big con for simplysafe :/
@@markvanarsdale918 Agreed, I talked more about it in the monitoring section. For more info, see my written review of SimpliSafe here- bit.ly/2XAi5ro
I heard Ring got hacked, and someone was talking to a kid in his room. It was on the news.. How do these two compare in THAT category. Making a decision soon.
Hi Vicki. That is mostly because the users who got hacked did not set up 2 way authentication, which would've alerted the Ring owners that someone was trying to access their cameras and prevented the hackers from gaining access.
@Vicki Mori You could also do more research on how to further secure not only your ring or SimpliSafe security system but your wireless router that they connect to. Like ensuring your wireless router is secured with a WPA password and if somebody was to work their way in your network are you’re router password settings changed from the default? All things you could do to further secure your network and security system. Studying cyber security one of the basics is that not a single network or computer is ever completely secure. That’s just a chance you take when using network based security systems.
Thanks Gabe. Seems like cost of the system would be important.
Agreed, but people have different priorities. Make sure you check out my written review of Ring vs. SimpliSafe for the full breakdown: bit.ly/2D2Mq9n