Gnostic Informant
Gnostic Informant
  • 611
  • 14 256 238
Bible Scholars are WRONG about the New Testament
Richard C. Miller, Ph.D
Resurrection and Reception in Early Christianity (Routledge Studies in Religion)
www.amazon.com/Resurrection-Reception-Christianity-Routledge-Religion-ebook/dp/B0CQPZ9RK2?ref_=ast_author_mpb
independent.academia.edu/RichardMiller140
www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant
Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons.
2nd Channel:
www.youtube.com/@UCMfDzHVSPdGcYOshWG35EgA
Follow me on Twitter:
gnosticinforman
Discord:
discord.com/invite/uWBZkxd4UX
#gnosticinformant #richardcmiller #bible
zhlédnutí: 38 829

Video

Unblemished Lamb: They Lied about Easter | Documentary
zhlédnutí 111KPřed měsícem
www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons. Easter. The Celebration of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. The story we are told is that Jesus of Nazareth, around the age of 33, went down to Jerusalem with his disciples during the Pesach Festival, also known as the Passover, which is a J...
Dr. Jennifer Bird Debunks Bible Misconceptions
zhlédnutí 9KPřed 2 měsíci
Jennifer Grace Bird, Ph.D www.jennifergracebird.com/ Subscribe to her channel: @JenniferBirdPhD Get the Book: www.amazon.com/Marriage-Bible-What-Texts-Say/dp/1538121050/ref=sr_1_1?crid=VDAGQM5332ZM&keywords=marriage in the bible&qid=1696448498&sprefix=marriage in the bible,aps,150&sr=8-1 An East Coaster by upbringing, undergrad, and graduate schools, Dr. Bird has taught in New Jersey, Texas, Te...
Oldest Religion of Stone Age Eurasia | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 121KPřed 2 měsíci
www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons. 2nd Channel: @gnosticinformantTV Follow me on Twitter: NealSendlak1 The Proto-Indo-European (PIE) language & its spread across the world from the Stone Age through the Copper Age and into the Bronze Age represent a fascinating per...
Heated Discussion w/ Rabbi about Torah
zhlédnutí 24KPřed 2 měsíci
www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons. Subscribe to Rabbi Tovia Singer @ToviaSinger1 2nd Channel: @gnosticinformantTV Follow me on Twitter: NealSendlak1 Discord: discord.com/invite/uWBZkxd4UX #gnosticinformant #toviasinger #torah
Jesus & Dionysus Links: Deeper Than You Think | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 40KPřed 2 měsíci
www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons. 2nd Channel: @gnosticinformantTV Follow me on Twitter: NealSendlak1 Discord: discord.com/invite/uWBZkxd4UX Jesus and Dionysus (also called Bacchus, Zagreus, Sabazius & Liber) both are the Son of God. But not just any of the sons o...
What NOBODY Says about Christmas & Saturnalia | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 86KPřed 4 měsíci
Grab Atlas VPN for just $1.70/mo 6 months extra before the Christmas Special deal expires: get.atlasvpn.com/GnosticInformant 😍🥰 (Use my code to get 86% OFF!!!) www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons. 2nd Channel: @gnosticinformantTV Follow me on Twitter: NealSendlak1 Th...
They will NEVER teach this about the Old Testament
zhlédnutí 64KPřed 5 měsíci
Grab Atlas VPN for just $1.70/mo 6 months extra before the BLACK FRIDAY deal expires: get.atlasvpn.com/GnosticInformant (Use my code to get 86% off!) Subscribe to Derek Lambert: @MythVisionPodcast Please consider supporting me through Patreon: www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Thank you for all the support. 2nd Channel: @GnosticInformantTV Follow me on Twitter: NealSendlak1 Discord: ...
They Lied about the First 100 Years of Christianity | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 656KPřed 5 měsíci
Grab Atlas VPN for just $1.70/mo 6 months extra before the BLACK FRIDAY deal expires: get.atlasvpn.com/GnosticInformant (Use my code to get 86% off!) Please consider supporting me through Patreon: www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Thank you for all the support. 2nd Channel: @GnosticInformantTV The first century of Christianity is shrouded in mystery. What we know for sure, compared to what we ar...
Dionysus: Most Influential God of ALL Time | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 92KPřed 6 měsíci
www.patreon.com/GnosticInformant Please Consider joining my Patreon to help finding scholars to bring on. Any amount helps me. Thank you existing Patrons. Dionysus, alternatively named Bacchus, Iacchus, Zagreus, Sabazius, or Liber Pater (as well as dozens of Titles in the traditions of Greco-Roman mythology, is a deity representing the natural elements of fertility and plant life, but is most r...
Surprising links between Virgin Mary & Artemis
zhlédnutí 12KPřed 7 měsíci
Dr. Carla Ionescu @goddessproject Dr. Carla Ionescu is a Romanian refugee who escaped the Communist regime with her family when she was 10 years old. She is also an adrenaline junkie, an animal lover, and a natural born storyteller. She likes to ride motorcycles real fast, and research through archival documents very carefully. Carla’s research centers on the influential nature of Artemis both ...
The TRUTH about MARTYRS will surprise you | Candida Moss
zhlédnutí 13KPřed 7 měsíci
The TRUTH about MARTYRS will surprise you | Candida Moss
Oldest Origins of Biblical Yahweh are Shocking
zhlédnutí 495KPřed 8 měsíci
Oldest Origins of Biblical Yahweh are Shocking
The Origins of Roman Religion Are MIND-BLOWING
zhlédnutí 186KPřed 8 měsíci
The Origins of Roman Religion Are MIND-BLOWING
MIND-BLOWING Anunnaki & Nephilim | 4K DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 1,4MPřed 9 měsíci
MIND-BLOWING Anunnaki & Nephilim | 4K DOCUMENTARY
Pre-Historic Cyprus Religion is MIND BLOWING
zhlédnutí 218KPřed 9 měsíci
Pre-Historic Cyprus Religion is MIND BLOWING
Ancient Creation Myths that Influence Genesis
zhlédnutí 28KPřed 9 měsíci
Ancient Creation Myths that Influence Genesis
Remarkable Origins of Ancient Greece | 4K DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 113KPřed 9 měsíci
Remarkable Origins of Ancient Greece | 4K DOCUMENTARY
What the Church doesn't tell you about PAUL
zhlédnutí 75KPřed 9 měsíci
What the Church doesn't tell you about PAUL
Pre-Historic African Religions are MIND BLOWING | 4K DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 1,3MPřed 10 měsíci
Pre-Historic African Religions are MIND BLOWING | 4K DOCUMENTARY
Oldest God in WRITTEN History STILL IMPACTS TODAY | 4K DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 732KPřed 10 měsíci
Oldest God in WRITTEN History STILL IMPACTS TODAY | 4K DOCUMENTARY
Oldest Sumerian DEVIL MYTHS are MIND BLOWING | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 466KPřed 10 měsíci
Oldest Sumerian DEVIL MYTHS are MIND BLOWING | DOCUMENTARY
Author of LUKE/ACTS used JOSEPHUS as Source
zhlédnutí 12KPřed 10 měsíci
Author of LUKE/ACTS used JOSEPHUS as Source
SHOCKING Sumerian Roots of the BIBLE | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 205KPřed 10 měsíci
SHOCKING Sumerian Roots of the BIBLE | DOCUMENTARY
The OLDEST Religion in the WORLD is INSANE | Documentary
zhlédnutí 1,5MPřed 10 měsíci
The OLDEST Religion in the WORLD is INSANE | Documentary
Science PROVES Marcion's Gospel PREDATES Luke
zhlédnutí 22KPřed 10 měsíci
Science PROVES Marcion's Gospel PREDATES Luke
CHRIST was INFLUENCED by these PAGAN GODS | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 12KPřed 11 měsíci
CHRIST was INFLUENCED by these PAGAN GODS | DOCUMENTARY
Oldest God EVER FOUND is MIND BLOWING | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 62KPřed 11 měsíci
Oldest God EVER FOUND is MIND BLOWING | DOCUMENTARY
SON OF GOD: Saviors BEFORE Jesus | DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 64KPřed 11 měsíci
SON OF GOD: Saviors BEFORE Jesus | DOCUMENTARY
Oldest Mention of DAVID & ISRAEL ever Discovered
zhlédnutí 17KPřed 11 měsíci
Oldest Mention of DAVID & ISRAEL ever Discovered

Komentáře

  • @MuktiArno
    @MuktiArno Před 19 minutami

    Zarat-hustra

  • @magickmagazine7675
    @magickmagazine7675 Před hodinou

    Thanks to both of you - I applaud your bravery -this is a dialogue that the world needs to have right now !

  • @MouradMazouz-db3tc
    @MouradMazouz-db3tc Před 2 hodinami

    You are trying to pass in the needle hole.You are insulting Jew without proof.whatever it is I do know only one creator who did send universal commandments through Noah and Moses and this is what Satan do hate.

  • @CALIBA88
    @CALIBA88 Před 2 hodinami

    yahwe and allah both the same filth

  • @matereo
    @matereo Před 2 hodinami

    BS

  • @rabbiyohanan6823
    @rabbiyohanan6823 Před 2 hodinami

    I unsubscribed you because this title is misleading, a follower of the One Truth will never mislead others, even if its to share knowledge. I am sorry but I can't support such behavior.

  • @julioortega9996
    @julioortega9996 Před 3 hodinami

    I knew Nic Cage was a vampire, he was even a pharaoh judging by the thumbnail lmao

  • @zacharceo4004
    @zacharceo4004 Před 3 hodinami

    Could it be that greeks descend from even ancient jews?

  • @Edits_Panic0
    @Edits_Panic0 Před 3 hodinami

    Why the Pharisim wanted to throw rocks at Jesus when he said before Abraham even existed "I am", then? Was he also the devil? Or this part of the Bible is also false?

  • @susanmcdonald9088
    @susanmcdonald9088 Před 3 hodinami

    Looking at your excellent visuals & interesting discussions, I just had to stop, and INSIST those interested in this field as well as those believing ancient & prehistoric art, is all ancient aliens; these narratives are using as their "proofs" , grossly misinterpreted symbols & beliefs of the ancients... All the current book writers & podcasters, such as Paul Wallis, Billy Carson, Graham Hancock, MythVision, but also all of academia including mythologists, historians, theologians, classicists, archeologists, and other specialized fields, ALL have a GLARING GAP in their understanding of ancient messages! Those dragons, serpents, encircling snakes, were actually PLASMA DISCHARGES that were witnessed in prehistoric skies! SATURN was the light shining, closer to earth, at the pole! VENUS was a comet, close to earth! She was both beautiful as a GREAT STAR, but at times, terrifying! These 2 planets at various times, devastated earth & early civilizations. EDEN with its 4 rivers, or ATLANTIS with its complex channels, information Plato got from Solon who got it from ancient Egyptian records, the priests, because these great events in the sky were remembered, recorded if we only "see", and interpreted in ways that guided the earliest cultural organizations. To control the masses, doesn't explain everything! And today, we're still killing each other over these earliest of interpretations! The proof is undeniable, explanatorially powerful, brain-expanding, eye opening, and wonderful! I would suggest anyone get a further idea going. It will revolutionize our understanding, thus SOPHIA. czcams.com/video/t7EAlTcZFwY/video.htmlsi=o3AlmyH7pRlKo1gb SYMBOLS OF AN ALIEN SKY, part 1, documentary on YT by The Thunderbolts Project, a group of interdisciplinary folks, plasma physicists, scientists, engineers, astronomers, and comparative mythologists among others. Part 2 is THUNDERBOLTS OF THE GODS. It is visually extraordinary as well. And you'll never look at the ancient's art & texts, ever the same way again But until modern writers & inquirers, understand the art, stories, traditions, metaphors, religions, and more regarding our most ancient ancestors, we are just lost in the maze of circular reasoning & speculations. It's time to understand! And the Gnostics would heartily agree, lol, I think! SATURN was a GOD. He was Cronos, An, Atum-Rah, EL & ELOHIM with other planets; he was Yahweh, Marduck, ... There's more. But I'll stop here. And say only, what an inspiring COSMIC story! But how is such a thing begun? Accident? Simulation? Coincidence? This thing that got humanity busy wondering & thinking. Or the sheer terror when all hell broke loose! Their prayers & hymns, and even sacrifices to appease such devastation, seems as natural as making tools & building monuments on a large scale, to say, we are here! And we honor you! Diffusion of these stories was probably less than we attribute to it! If the global planet was seeing THE SAME IMAGES & EVENTS IN THE SKY, of course there'd be SIMILAR ARCHETYPES, BATTLES IN THE HEAVENS, PETROGLYPHS especially! Etched in stone all over the world, yet great similarities, is ALL explained by plasma discharges aka "cosmic thunderbolts" found in art, cuneiform tablets, stone carvings, petroglyphs & paintings. OH! You did get around to Velikovsky! Yes! 👍 I think humanity's IMAGINATION & CREATIVENESS was absolutely present at this awe-inspiring cosmic messages! Perhaps in our DNA, like language, but I think it was the inspiration that motivated story-telling, which humans evolved beyond the animal world. Dr price needs to watch these! ;) Sorry, lol, SuperHero, Cosmic Hero, Super Cosmic Warrior... All the planet MARS!!! And cultures got their mythic clues from him, literally, lol. Whether Hercules, Gilgamesh, Jesus, they ALL tell us how to behave & act in this world, despite it all; the violence inherent in an evolutionary creature... A survival. And everyone on earth, 8 billion, are survivors of the most sublime. Palestinians come to mind. I weep every day for most of them, our participation, and tyrants with atomic weapons. Now I forgot what I had to say, getting old, but I think there's something missing in our discourses, especially politics, our numbers are declining thus, more babies needed to enlist. WE better start listening to them

  • @TIznus
    @TIznus Před 4 hodinami

    You shall know them by their fruit. The world is corrupted by those who live for themselves. I will stand by YHWH.

  • @twspma3549
    @twspma3549 Před 5 hodinami

    You are full of shit! You are about to find out as well. The lies you promote and the confusion you bring will gather you the worst kind of judgment. Repent for your ignorance and ask to be forgiven for the lies you promote as truth. Your cerebral gospel will always fail you. Seek Yahshua by the straight gate and down the narrow way. Otherwise the demons will come and gather you to he'll and then to the lake of fire.

    • @TheZodiacRipper
      @TheZodiacRipper Před 4 hodinami

      The lake of fire is only a second death, nothing to worry about there.

  • @MrRaposaum
    @MrRaposaum Před 5 hodinami

    Christ is King!

  • @kamarudinhj.dolmoin8578
    @kamarudinhj.dolmoin8578 Před 5 hodinami

    Just like Christian Prince; so dominantly verbos!

  • @scottgiannotti5480
    @scottgiannotti5480 Před 6 hodinami

    The Sybil sounds like the Symbol. Also Civil. To be Civil is to be Sybil

  • @zzeeeuuss11
    @zzeeeuuss11 Před 6 hodinami

    man you made all caucass region Iranian, where were Turks? :))))

  • @vvanderer
    @vvanderer Před 7 hodinami

    There were many texts which dealt witn religious topics and were treated with a certain reverence but they did not make it into the Canon.The wise men decided they were wisdom but not divine.

  • @farhadamon8389
    @farhadamon8389 Před 7 hodinami

    It is written, judge a tree by its fruit. have found the research of Clif-High. the translation of old text shows that they are nasty and love blood scarifies. In my logic the source dont need scarifies. Just do your research, by the way there is no mention of God in the bible.

  • @christianyoutubegaming
    @christianyoutubegaming Před 7 hodinami

    I disagree when you alleged that the Annunaki rule the underworld, why would beings of God give a fuck about being the devil. Lmfao c’mon on with that bullshit. The Annunaki did their best to monitor Earth but they all wanted to play a key role and control land. They conflicted with eachother at times but these beings aren’t greek mythology. Instead they are purely intelligent beings where 1 year to them is equivelent to 3,600 years/ 1 Shar.. These beings can live for Shars and Shars, Imagine that.

  • @tramberg1972
    @tramberg1972 Před 9 hodinami

    THE five loaves and the two fishes, fed about five thousand So 2+5=7 then multiply... 1x2x3x4x5x6x7=5040 triangle+square+pentagon+hexagon+heptagon+octagon+nonagon = 5040°. 180° + 360° + 540° + 720° + 900° + 1080° + 1260° = 5040° At it's root, it's about Squaring the Circle...IN YOUR BIBLE

  • @MrPINKFL0YD
    @MrPINKFL0YD Před 11 hodinami

    Title is misleading

  • @paulokas69
    @paulokas69 Před 11 hodinami

    13:14 Muhammed is not at the same game play as Jesus. Muhammed plays the role of an apostle like Paul. Jesus plays the role of the supernatural being like Gabriel

  • @MetatasticCreations
    @MetatasticCreations Před 11 hodinami

    So much to wonder about.

  • @hemi5.7awdpursuit5
    @hemi5.7awdpursuit5 Před 12 hodinami

    @GnosticInformant Not slick you almost had me with your lies. In Torah Jehovah battled eygptian gods with 10 plagues to free Israel from Egypt slavery.

  • @kbeautician
    @kbeautician Před 12 hodinami

    So what?

  • @Daniel-Tiger
    @Daniel-Tiger Před 14 hodinami

    yes I know the content of this secret teaching. It is the same content that Steiner speak about

  • @sideoutside
    @sideoutside Před 14 hodinami

    omg i hate the beard my dude, lol. sorry, i adore your channel, but damn..

  • @stevilkenevil9960
    @stevilkenevil9960 Před 14 hodinami

    And 4500 yrs later they're still fighting over sand

  • @fender97
    @fender97 Před 15 hodinami

    So YHWH parts the Red Sea, destroys Sodom and Gomorrah, guides Israel through the wilderness, causes water to sprong from rocks (all the sites of which you can visit!) and you are saying He's Satan. Amazing. If God is good, there must be a hell since there would be no justice. YHWH loves us so much He sent His only begotten Son to save us, that whosoever believeth in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life! Now is not the time for playing games, war is coming, Jesus saves.

  • @Vagabond824
    @Vagabond824 Před 15 hodinami

    CHRIST IS KING!

  • @Ami2902Ami
    @Ami2902Ami Před 15 hodinami

    information overload. Seeing stars

  • @cs9183
    @cs9183 Před 15 hodinami

    Neal - love Dr Ammon's depth of knowledge & delivery of ancient texts Please consider an episode (or ten) with John Lamb Lash - He can speak directly to the mysteries at Delphi, Elyuses and more. He can also tell you about kykeon and the Mystery Schools - from his direct shamanic experiences with the Organic Light - Goddess Sophia. Would make for a great show.

  • @legendnaveendelu7209
    @legendnaveendelu7209 Před 16 hodinami

    Ugh europeons want in on everything by writing fake history.

  • @jimmcconnell7328
    @jimmcconnell7328 Před 17 hodinami

    This is very interesting. When Jesus says in the New Testament that Jesus accuses the priests of being children of the devil this has always been understood that they were evil priests,liars and murderers. Never did I think that Jesus was literally naming their God. He was in fact pulling no punches. This discussion opens up your mind and scripture makes much more sense and explains why Jesus was so against the priests of the Jews.

  • @neoconsuck
    @neoconsuck Před 18 hodinami

    Day 2 of the Towering, Rumbling, Hidden Majesty of my Papa over MT. In Jesus name, Amen.

  • @GiantMechanicalFist
    @GiantMechanicalFist Před 19 hodinami

    Clickbait bullshit

  • @beckybrynjolfsson
    @beckybrynjolfsson Před 19 hodinami

    You don't know what Jesus said or any true apostle. The bible was constructed of pagan and Egyptian fables, embellishments and lies mixed with Jewish history. Paul and Constantine and other romans made the bible. None of them ever met Jesus or the apostles.

  • @JESUS.IS.GOD.777
    @JESUS.IS.GOD.777 Před 20 hodinami

    Jesus is the King of Heaven.

  • @INFINITY-im4fi
    @INFINITY-im4fi Před 21 hodinou

    Wtf is the skyrim ambiance soundtrack doing here😂

  • @neoconsuck
    @neoconsuck Před 21 hodinou

    Interesting Elcessaites believed The Holy Spirit was feminine. That's the As Below, Wo-Man, Divine Grace, Waters Below side of my own cosmology vision. El Shaddai (holy war)...

  • @davidhuffman4036
    @davidhuffman4036 Před 21 hodinou

    Stop to think why churches don't teach every story true and false stories. All religions came from 1. Cultures are self taught religion is our maker. Our races are our masters' mark of his workforce. Each race has blood of thier master and creator. ( Many Gods )

  • @neoconsuck
    @neoconsuck Před 21 hodinou

    Paul was a butt buddy...

    • @neoconsuck
      @neoconsuck Před 21 hodinou

      Upon this butt will I found my church...

    • @neoconsuck
      @neoconsuck Před 21 hodinou

      What is this, The Beatles? Never trust a guy named 'Saul.'

    • @neoconsuck
      @neoconsuck Před 21 hodinou

      Blood over intention. EEENK! Wrong Answer!

  • @dezertfox3681
    @dezertfox3681 Před 22 hodinami

    YAHWEH is not Heylel. This is one of the most ignorant and uneducated videos I have ever seen. However, it's from a gnostic, so should we be surprised? Ende.

  • @SomeRandomGuy777x
    @SomeRandomGuy777x Před 22 hodinami

    Hi Neal, I've been following your progress for some time now, and I'm wondering, Are you at some point considering to explore the fasets of mystical/magical practice that these symbols (not mainly in reference to this vid) point to? If not.. why? By this I mean the reality of what you can know internally vs what you'll have to speculate about historically. By this, I'm thinking in terms of the occult or esoteric strands of 'adept' magick/ritualistic/invocation practitioners. Not religion specific. But in terms of practitioners with paranormal bits of actual magickal/spiritual "Gnosis"? One good western example of this would be Josephine Mccarthy (founder of Quareia) but there are certainly more out there. I mean you have been getting bits and pieces here and there of these endeavors in your historical explorations. (The various rituals leading to "revelations" for ex) But those are and will always remain fragmentary as far as you don't have actual inner Gnosis of these powers. And by this I mean you could try to bridge the gap in knowledge by using mystical interpretation tools (such as "Pardes" it's great, look it up) to give multi perspective on cryptic texts. But those tools can only get you so far, without inner knowing and 'real' communication with the figures we may call "deity" or divine. By that I mean beyond any psychological framework may try to project unto it's reality. I'm not really expecting a reply, but I hope you take it into serious consideration and maybe check some interviews from Josephine if you don't know what value this would provide. If you do get her on the show, I'd become a member instantly.

  • @freedomthief8499
    @freedomthief8499 Před 23 hodinami

    Standing with PALESTINE 💯....

  • @homeskilit23
    @homeskilit23 Před dnem

    Sitchen didn't translate the tablets either, he just put the already translated texts together. They were translated BEFORE he was born.

  • @pattheitguy
    @pattheitguy Před dnem

    Sorry, oldest religion is Shamanism... by a LONG shot: eclinik.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/the-evolutionary-tree-of-religion.jpg

  • @NullStaticVoid
    @NullStaticVoid Před dnem

    there are a lot of holes in this guys logic.

  • @BanditGaming479
    @BanditGaming479 Před dnem

    Unless you have some newly discovered document you cannot fully disprove mythicism in my opinion.

  • @zipperpillow
    @zipperpillow Před dnem

    It all sounds so made up, and only about half-thought through. Old-timey people seem pretty gullible to hare-brained ideas.