ElleHistory
ElleHistory
  • 141
  • 479 701
Tudor Historian SHOCKED by Firebrand Movie Clip
Such a powerful scene...
Is this the most accurate portrayal of Henry VIII of England on screen?
I react to the clip and discuss all TRUE history around it.
zhlédnutí: 2 477

Video

The Horrific Treatment of Anne Askew
zhlédnutí 539Před 19 hodinami
Hello everyone, With the release of the new Firebrand movie, I thought it would be good to take a deeper look at the real HISTORY of Anne Askew. A true force to be reckoned with.
Tudor Historian Reacts to The White Princess Clip
zhlédnutí 1,5KPřed 14 dny
Hi everyone, In this History Police video, I react to the clip where The White Princess speaks Spanish. Let me know what you think. Book: Nathen Amin: www.amazon.co.uk/Henry-VII-Tudor-Pretenders-Warbeck/dp/1398112461/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2R60IMIF50X5J&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.tOR7Oo4ihTovinUgzi4AEeaE-nQBQGFLXnJgujKgJMmIZPz-97gprvBrzoFGEKdBDjS3TLP-kU5t8lB-gQWmFZGmGJD8IB_GEsmyl5SAjixphp2MiFQV4deNzKdk0glT.AZVr...
Tudor Historian Reacts to My Lady Jane Trailer
zhlédnutí 1,5KPřed 21 dnem
Watch the full Amazon Trailer on CZcams here: czcams.com/video/PwFty8yi1cU/video.html Let me know what you think of the trailer and if you will be watching the show.
The Untold Story of Claude of France
zhlédnutí 575Před 28 dny
Hello everyone, In this Once Upon a Woman video, I discuss a forgotten queen of France: Queen Claude. Daughter of Louis XII of France and of Anne of Brittany. Wife and Consort of Francis I of France. Mother of Henry II of France. I hope you enjoy this video.
French Historian Gives an Overview of Versailles Season 2
zhlédnutí 676Před měsícem
This is not a review as such but I cover two of the main story lines and the focus on two powerful women. Let me know what you think. Images: wikicommons Videos: from Versailles the show
Marie de Guise: Forgotten Queen of Scotland
zhlédnutí 950Před měsícem
Marie de Guise: Forgotten Queen of Scotland
Tudor Historian Reacts to Firebrand Trailer
zhlédnutí 12KPřed měsícem
God... You have to WATCH THIS! It's mind blowing!!!
Thorns Lust and Glory: Anne Boleyn & the French
zhlédnutí 787Před měsícem
Hello everyone, This is a video dedicated to my new book: Thorns Lust & Glory, The Betrayal of Anne Boleyn. Here I tell you what you can expect to find in this book... including Anne Boleyn's allegedly lost letters that she sent to England when she was in France... Images: Wikicommons and cover of my book.
Historian Reviews Shogun Season 1 Episode 2
zhlédnutí 451Před 2 měsíci
In this History Police video on Shogun Episode 2, I give a bit more historical background and even discuss a letter written by William Adams (The Anjin, John Blackthorne) in the show.
What IF Edward VI of England Had Ruled For Longer?
zhlédnutí 1KPřed 2 měsíci
In this, What IF in History video, I discuss what would have happened if Edward VI had lived and ruled longer. What would have been the political, diplomatic, religious repercussions for England. Images: wikicommons and Canva.
SNEAK PEAK: Tracy Borman on Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I
zhlédnutí 286Před 2 měsíci
Hello everyone, here is the sneak peak of my interview with the fantastic, generous, and gifted historian Dr Tracy Borman talking about two of our favourite queens: Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I. To watch the full interview, please consider joining my membership: ElleHistory Club, which will be released on the last Wednesday of the month for members only. Tracy Borman's books: www.amazon.co.uk/s?k=...
The Real History Around The King Arthur Legend
zhlédnutí 440Před 2 měsíci
In this What the Elle in History video, we discuss the legend of King Arthur and how it affected history itself and historical kings. Images: Wikicommons.
Historian Reviews Shogun Season 1 Episode 1
zhlédnutí 3,1KPřed 2 měsíci
Hello everyone, and thank you for being here. This is a History Police video reviewing the first episode of Shogun. I've been teaching European/Japanese history for the last seven years in my course Cross-Cultural Encounters so I was very excited to watch this show. I will discuss in each episode a historical character behind the fictional one, give you a brief account of the episode but will t...
French Historian Explains Versailles Season 1
zhlédnutí 928Před 3 měsíci
Hi, in this History Police video, I explain Versailles the TV show season 1. What works and what doesn't. Thank you so much for your support and for watching.
Mary I of England: Beyond the Myth of “Bloody Mary”
zhlédnutí 698Před 3 měsíci
Mary I of England: Beyond the Myth of “Bloody Mary”
SNEAK PEAK: Dr Eleanor Janega on Medieval Women and Work
zhlédnutí 204Před 3 měsíci
SNEAK PEAK: Dr Eleanor Janega on Medieval Women and Work
The Man Who Created the Plague Doctor Costume
zhlédnutí 430Před 3 měsíci
The Man Who Created the Plague Doctor Costume
Diane de Poitiers: A Queen In All But Name?
zhlédnutí 605Před 3 měsíci
Diane de Poitiers: A Queen In All But Name?
Historian Rates TOP 5 best Elizabeth I and Mary Stuart On Screen
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 3 měsíci
Historian Rates TOP 5 best Elizabeth I and Mary Stuart On Screen
The DISGUSTING treatment of Princess Mary (Mary I of England)
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 4 měsíci
The DISGUSTING treatment of Princess Mary (Mary I of England)
SNEAK PEAK: Dr Nicola Tallis and her newest book: Young Elizabeth
zhlédnutí 245Před 4 měsíci
SNEAK PEAK: Dr Nicola Tallis and her newest book: Young Elizabeth
The TRUTH about Elizabeth I and Leicester’s Relationship
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 4 měsíci
The TRUTH about Elizabeth I and Leicester’s Relationship
What if Charles I of England had successfully fled to France?
zhlédnutí 409Před 4 měsíci
What if Charles I of England had successfully fled to France?
Historian Rates TOP 5 Best Anne Boleyn on Screen
zhlédnutí 7KPřed 4 měsíci
Historian Rates TOP 5 Best Anne Boleyn on Screen
The Improbable Fate and Life of Eleanor of Aquitaine
zhlédnutí 753Před 5 měsíci
The Improbable Fate and Life of Eleanor of Aquitaine
Princes in the Tower: Historian Reveals 3 Theories
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 5 měsíci
Princes in the Tower: Historian Reveals 3 Theories
SNEAK PEAK: Liz Fremantle on Historical Women and Writing Historical Fiction
zhlédnutí 153Před 5 měsíci
SNEAK PEAK: Liz Fremantle on Historical Women and Writing Historical Fiction
What if Henry II of France HAD NOT DIED in 1559
zhlédnutí 661Před 5 měsíci
What if Henry II of France HAD NOT DIED in 1559
Tudor Historian Reacts to Wolf Hall
zhlédnutí 2,8KPřed 5 měsíci
Tudor Historian Reacts to Wolf Hall

Komentáře

  • @Elvertaw
    @Elvertaw Před 4 hodinami

    With Jude Law and Alicia V. I wasn’t sure they had the gravitas to carry it off. But the I thought of Alicia in Pure. 🤔 I can’t wait to see this film!!!

  • @SLOTHSRIDEUNICORNS
    @SLOTHSRIDEUNICORNS Před 4 hodinami

    *JUSTICE FOR MARK SMEATON*

  • @brandenallen4526
    @brandenallen4526 Před 7 hodinami

    I watched season 1 in 3 days. I loved it the costumes and and sets are so amazing. There's never been a show like this. It's so funny and Emily Bader is awesome. awesome.

  • @wednesdayschild3627
    @wednesdayschild3627 Před 8 hodinami

    Henry wanted a boy. I think Henry regretted the break with Rome. Henry was never going to tell the pope he was right. I cannot get past Katherine Parr's treatment of princess Elizabeth.

  • @imonherenow3673
    @imonherenow3673 Před 12 hodinami

    I can’t wait to see this in its entirety. I’m so pleased we finally got some spotlight on Katherine Parr. Jude and Alicia are phenomenal in this scene. The wave of emotions they both present in just those few minutes is incredible. Side note no I wouldn’t want to see Alicia as Anne we’ve had the story of Henry and Anne and the other wives are always sidelined. Let’s appreciate this actress for this body of work.

  • @lillyclark8504
    @lillyclark8504 Před 14 hodinami

    Thank you for your comments. I was disappointed in the movie clip because while Henry was reputed to slap around Cromwell, a "low born" aide, a bit when he was angry, there is no evidence or even accusation I have ever heard that he physically manhandled a wife. Based on this clip I'd say the film may be egging the pudding too much for my taste. There is a clip of a scene from the 1970s BBC show wherein Parr is terrified just by the suggestion Gardner was going to "question" her with the king's approval and is hiding out in her dark bedroom. That scene really stung - this one just seems unlikely. I will probably watch it anyway some day. :-)

  • @jude2839
    @jude2839 Před 15 hodinami

    I watched 2 episodes and its absolute SHIT, not even reign is that bad

  • @emocuta
    @emocuta Před 18 hodinami

    Thank you for reviewing this movie clip. Your perspective is spot-on. I simply CAN'T wait to see this film! <3 I missed it at the movie theatre now I must wait for streaming.

  • @lonesomevalkyrie
    @lonesomevalkyrie Před 20 hodinami

    I can't wait to see it.

  • @random666777
    @random666777 Před 22 hodinami

    This is within the timeframe of the Münster rebellion. Would that be on Henry's mind?

  • @laurieduerr4757
    @laurieduerr4757 Před dnem

    Yes fully agreed that the casting is really perfect, for both H8 and K Parr. It's definitely Jude and Alicia at their best!!

  • @irenepinsonneault2740

    I haven''t seen the film yet but I never miss Jude Law--he never disappoints (Michael Caine is another like that--it can be the worst excuse of a movie but they deliver and you can't look away when they have the camera.) Jude Law grips the audience in the scene, his poor falcon, and us beyond the fourth wall, while forcefully grabbing that woman FROM BEHIND the shot.!! WOW--we saw a bit of cheek and some part of a crown--what an amazing summons of the power of a king like Henry 8. I have to see the film now! You reflected on the speed and force in his grab and crush of his wife (and Queen). It got me thinking. This next part is long and includes my personal reflections after a decades long and never ending study of Henry 8 and the Tudors and the whole Tudor England Age. Inside the engine of the Renaissance the power of just three generations of this not particularly distinguished family was magnified to imbue an Age and transform a querulous small island country into a serious power capable of holding its own and beating a religious institution and two empires while all were similarly at their peak. How dangerous was Henry and why? I am reminded of what supposedly occurred when Thomas More first tried to warn Cromwell ( in a complicated and humble bragging kind of way) of the danger of getting into a cage with a lion. "He stares directly in your eyes and the sun is suddenly revealed in his smile; he pulls you in close--he has the common touch everyone is told--and he begins to dance with you and you feel the astonished stares of onlookers boring into your back with with jealous envy . But none of it matters because he is allowing you such a generous and true connection, speaking with favor and such confident affection that you are helpless to fight your own enjoyment in it. Still, somewhere deep inside a voice sharply warns you: "Look at his paws, look at his paws.." I felt that power coming from Jude Law's performance in just a snippet, but even more so from the actress (with whom I am not familiar) and her reaction of genuine terror. She apparently didn't hear the little voice until the paws were already around her head) I hope the writers stuck close to the truth of this part of the life of a king so gifted and inclined to the job and the moment in history. As it happened is a cautionary tale about the way that power even when smartly wielded to make positive changes still corrupts. It is like iron in open air--it's corruptibility is a defining characteristic. But in Henry's case, as to the question of whether a head injury changed him or any other construction, I draw from personal experience dealing with incurable and progressive damage to a pelvis shattered by a drunk driver. Old bones (mine passed 50 12 years ago -- wasn't Henry somewhere in that range for his 6th marriage?) hurt in a way that drains your powers of reflection, evaluation and even your wind to have a conversation. When I can't ignore or placate the bones, when I close my eyes and mind's eye can trace the red, glowing spider web of cracks, I have been known to snap at loved ones, sometimes I am shouting and do not realize or intend it. I have become a practiced and very abject apology writer. I think as Henry got old and trapped by his splintering femur, barely able to hold his tremendous weight on a leg that was rotting out from under him, --no NSAIDS, no TENS patches, no PT or aquatherapy-- pain alone could shorten his fuse, and make him less resistant to court gossip. And --sadly most for the lion of a king, pain could erode his command of faculties it had taken him ten hard years to develop in the crucible of his Great Matter, faculties that could see the self interest and political agendas of all his ministers and courtiers as they approached him with their flattery and fear mongering. Saddest for him, the injury robbed him of all the things he loved to do that helped to draw off stress, feel and maintain his strength, get some good feelings from the admiration his athletic prowess engendered in others . He was a caged lion. God bless the Queen for not tempting the fate of the claws too many times and managing to come out not only alive but respected by people on all sides for her care and duty to the king.

  • @medievalwolfgrrl
    @medievalwolfgrrl Před dnem

    Alicia Vikander is a wonderful actress. I wish Firebrand would have been released in more theaters in the US. I guess I'll have to wait until it comes out on streaming services.

  • @justinrussell9391
    @justinrussell9391 Před dnem

    Please review the show. I want to hear your thoughts

  • @justinrussell9391
    @justinrussell9391 Před dnem

    I’ve seen lots of people who don’t care if it’s true or not. It’s unfortunate

  • @justinrussell9391
    @justinrussell9391 Před dnem

    Looks like a comedy

  • @gogreen7794
    @gogreen7794 Před dnem

    I'm rolling my eyes because Henry VII and Queen Elizabeth never went to Spain and I can't imagine they'd bow/curtsy to another king and queen. It does appear, however, that the scene was filmed in either La Alhambra in Granada or the Alcázar in Seville. Or maybe it just looks like it.

  • @giraffequeen9437
    @giraffequeen9437 Před dnem

    That scene made me so uncomfortable....that's likely how he was with his wife. I understand Catherine's fear in this scene. Scary stuff

  • @emmacharlenedostal

    And Jude Law … love him but wow I had admittedly low expectations & he captured Henry’s codependency type of crazy in a way I never felt before & I’ve seen a lot of Tudor related content … you just have to see the film in its entirety when you can❣️

  • @emmacharlenedostal

    It was me … I’m a lover of Queen Katharine & Anne Boleyn but I was floored after seeing the movie here in Texas I sat in my car & processed how even if you were adored by the King that would not save you if someone else “got to him first”

  • @scarlettrhett1575
    @scarlettrhett1575 Před dnem

    Jonathan Rhys Meyers was totally miscast in this series, hands down Keith Michell played Henry brilliantly❤ back in the back, and for me Genevieve Bujold will always be Anne

  • @scarlettrhett1575
    @scarlettrhett1575 Před dnem

    I could barely get through the first episode😮 I guess I was comparing it to the 1986 Lady Jane with Helena Bonham Carter no comparison

  • @keiththorpe9571
    @keiththorpe9571 Před dnem

    Based on everything I've ever heard or read about Henry, I believe he had people around him who, over time, learned how to work him in order to get him moving in the direction they wanted him to go. Now, he certainly wasn't the type who walked through a room, spoke to five different people who wanted five different things, agreeing to them all and acting on the last thing he heard said to him. No, not a bit of it. However, I have no doubt there were those who could get Henry to do something he might not have done on his own, if they were able to convince him that it was to his advantage. One thing at which Henry seemed quite adept was convincing himself of anything which served his immediate convenience. The moment where Henry becomes enraged with Katherine, and the others assembled don't react. Yeah, by that point, they knew better than to stick their nose in. When the king gets that upset, people get their heads cut off. You don't want to bring his attention down on your head. That wouldn't be prudent. Just keep going with your conversation, take note of the frightful weather, hell, pretend you've gone blind for a moment...But just tighten up and hope it passes without a death warrant being signed.

  • @Carter-hx3nb
    @Carter-hx3nb Před dnem

    The reason she’s so bold and straightforward here is because she’s in shock. She’s much more subtle and cunning in the rest of the movie

  • @RobertoLorenzPianist

    I'd love it if you'd also take some clips from older movies like "Anne of the thousand days" and "A man for all seasons", commenting on their authenticity.. That would be Gold!

  • @deanedge5988
    @deanedge5988 Před dnem

    oh dear

  • @wanyatelborn
    @wanyatelborn Před dnem

    It’s a movie clip and you’re scared they have meds for that

  • @wanyatelborn
    @wanyatelborn Před dnem

    ‼️‼️‼️‼️um here’s the deal How many Tudor historians are there in the entire world? Yea not a lot Soooooo most NORMAL people do not know this is not historically accurate Get it

    • @emmacharlenedostal
      @emmacharlenedostal Před dnem

      Totally true I was shaken at the decision the director made to end it as he did but while total fiction there gosh I loved to think for minute that’s how it really went down 😆 and I normally do not care for the fiction I’m here to learn the truth & the truth was far more frightening than I realized just being a part of King Henry’s Court

  • @spinster9187
    @spinster9187 Před dnem

    I saw the movie as a whole bad bad bad except the costumes were perfect, the cinematography, and all of Jude Law’s scenes(but the last but even then it’s good). I don’t know how they chopped everything else up but damn. The writing outside of Henry, I think they robbed him of an Oscar. I also read the book and I think it’s better Than the movie but Henry isn’t portrayed as well.

    • @AngelaChase
      @AngelaChase Před dnem

      I’m so glad to see someone else who has seen the movie comment. I saw it a couple of weeks ago, and agree with you. Some of the more repulsive scenes began to feel gratuitous and I do like they tried to turn Catherine into a composite of several of his wives. Catherine’s actual story was so much more interesting and more accurately portrayed in the book. Also, I loved the costumes, I especially loved Henry’s costumes and it’s rare that male costumes outshine the female ones, but of course Henry’s clothes were the most exquisite!

  • @Chipoo88
    @Chipoo88 Před dnem

    The first clip about Anne Askew - I really don’t feel she would have challenged him like that as it would have not been well received :). But it is a good line to demonstrate his omnipotence. “Her blood is on your soul”. No chance!

    • @emmacharlenedostal
      @emmacharlenedostal Před dnem

      When you see the next 5 minutes in the film she basically loses her mind trying to convince him (and perhaps even herself) how she could have said that out loud! But when you cry for what Anne endured to not bring the Queen down with her knowing they were like minded now that is strength

  • @jonathanwilliams9697

    I genuinely believe Firebrand is one of the best Tudor series we've ever been given. Jude Law shows the perfect contradiction in Henry's views versus his actions. Showing his volatility and unbowing devotion in the same breathe. Extraordinary. Alicia demonstrates so well the strength and courage of Katherine Parr in not only challenging a Tyrant like Henry but also knowing exactly how and when to play him by being the "meek" and "humble" wife subservient to his bidding yet being the learned and intelligent woman of the world he adores - as shown in Katherine of Arragon and Anne Boylen. Absolutely fantastic.

  • @pattigibson4396
    @pattigibson4396 Před dnem

    Henry's double standard of labelling a woman as bad because she abandoned her children and husband, when he did the same to his own issue both with Mary and Elizabeth and their mothers. Also, he had greater care for the hawk than he did for Katherine. The man was a nuisance and a menace

    • @RobertoLorenzPianist
      @RobertoLorenzPianist Před dnem

      Back then those double standards were common ideas in people's minds though.

  • @sheilalambie5288
    @sheilalambie5288 Před dnem

    I can't find out if this is on at any cinema in the UK does anyone know when it will be released

    • @elizabethadebanjo8736
      @elizabethadebanjo8736 Před dnem

      I have been trying to find out

    • @octavianpopescu4776
      @octavianpopescu4776 Před dnem

      As far as I know, it was made for the Cannes festival last year and released worldwide something like 2 weeks ago. I'm also curious to see it.

    • @sheilalambie5288
      @sheilalambie5288 Před dnem

      @@octavianpopescu4776 can't find it at any cinemas in my area I know it was released in the us on 14 June if anyone know when it is out in the UK let us know

  • @jamiedianne6778
    @jamiedianne6778 Před dnem

    Wow! Yes, you’re right, Jude Law just might be the best Henry I’ve seen on screen! The acting in this clip is phenomenal.

  • @bocus20
    @bocus20 Před dnem

    I think that the moment she included Henry's soul in the conversation, he flipped, because this was a real fear of his. He couldn't and wouldn't stand anyone question his soul, because he couldn't and wouldn't allow himself to question it. The fear here is real, it is the fear for her life, the stakes are that high. I have high hopes for this movie.

    • @BP-yd9vn
      @BP-yd9vn Před 21 hodinou

      Yes, I had hoped to see the CZcams reviewer would catch that. Very interesting portrayal. Of course, based on some of rumored concerns on his deathbed. He was a tyrant, but he also made a lot of decisions that were end justifies the means - stability of the country and no one challenging the king.

  • @emocuta
    @emocuta Před 2 dny

    I can't wait until November!! Thank you <3

  • @peterthefox2076
    @peterthefox2076 Před 2 dny

    Ow the Woke strange people, you can change a lot but a black English king? Really? And they used humor from other movies like Crocodile Dundee. You call that a knive?

  • @bushraiman3035
    @bushraiman3035 Před 3 dny

    Hello elle !! I want to improve at public speaking but can't afford paid courses can u help

  • @Joey-hn5hm
    @Joey-hn5hm Před 3 dny

    Queen Elizabeth and Mary Queen of Scots in the 16 century were cousins? Interestingly I remembered this from my British literature course here in the states. That they were sisters but it was a rein that one protestant and the other Catholic.

  • @LisaHopewell-sb7ek
    @LisaHopewell-sb7ek Před 3 dny

    OMG!! Wash that greasy hair!!!

  • @heatherwaetzig2633
    @heatherwaetzig2633 Před 3 dny

    Beautiful telling of Anne Aschew's story Estelle. I believe the belief that got Anne into the most trouble was denying the Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation. The main reason she was executed. Along with her possible ties to Catherine Parr. As a Protestant Christian she is an inspiration to me. I saw the movie Firebrand recently and thought it did her and Catherine Parr justice. ❤

  • @Toltecgrl
    @Toltecgrl Před 3 dny

    When I saw you reviewed the trailer I was like oh my gosh I can’t wait to see your review of the whole movie !!! 🤗🤗👑

  • @h.l.asolomonov7674
    @h.l.asolomonov7674 Před 3 dny

    He met her at a brothel she didn't have a horse face she was a mistress of a king the hole thing was awful sure he fell for her she was 30 years his junior

  • @flowerfaeri
    @flowerfaeri Před 3 dny

    I first heard of Anne Askew several years ago and was horrified by her fate. Thank you for dedicating this broadcast to her. Most focus on the more well-known Tudor women such as Henry's unfortunate queens. Glad that Anne Askew's story is getting the attention in deserves.

  • @EarthlingAlex
    @EarthlingAlex Před 4 dny

    The show is an alternate version of history, it seems silly to expect historical accuracy.

  • @vmhutch
    @vmhutch Před 4 dny

    Great review, from what's available to see, I too think Henry VIII was a monster. Can't wait to see this movie.

  • @AngelaChase
    @AngelaChase Před 4 dny

    Anne Askew gets far more of a storyline in the movie than in the book. However, The Tudors took far more care with the true history of Catherine Parr than Firebrand (the movie, not the book). I was extremely disappointed.

  • @fabulouswomeninhistory

    Season 2 of the Serpent Queen is coming out July 12th. It will be interesting how they show her regarding the religious wars. Enjoy your channel! Glad I found you. (P.S. I sent you can email regarding my channel. (From Hart Ent)

  • @klowe377
    @klowe377 Před 5 dny

    Just a thought: I wonder if Maria Theresa didn't die from rabies. How her death was portrayed on the show it looked like rabies. From what I read about Louis and the Palace there were animals all over Versailles, from pets to hunting dogs, exotics, the wildlife of France and the zoo Louis built. With the medical practices then, It would have been easy to contract the disease and never know it.

  • @christinestudley3982

    I love this, I drive people crazy watching Tudors movies. Thanks, from the States!