How I would have loved if radiohead was on this too but I think the world would have exploded from too much musical greatness lol. Still one of the most beautiful song from the pumpkins.
He doesn't hate them, he just said that he dislikes the culture which puts them on a pedestal and that they make art music nowadays not pop or rock music
Me2. Pulled it from Limewire around 1999/2000 and have loved it ever since. Thanks to those who've put me right about the non-Radiohead connection - I can now relabel it myself!! :)
PLEASE rename this track (you can click 'edit video'). It's Billy Corgan performing the song with the help of Mike Garson on the piano, who was the touring keyboardist for the Pumpkins at the time. Myself and others pointed this out a year ago. I understand it was an honest mistake, likely to due to mislabeling but others may be confused because they aren't familiar with this track.
Thanks, I second that, especially because this is the best version I have found, so fix the title so we can share it, without confusing people. Well said Act4.
As an aside, the only band from the UK that Billy performed with during the KROQ Almost Acoustic Xmas in 1998 was Depeche Mode--when he came on stage to perform "Never Let Me Down Again" with them. Radiohead didn't even perform during the show in 1998, they played in 1995, while Smashing Pumpkins or Billy Corgan had not
@jimmychauv Yep. Radiohead has never performed with SP or Billy Corgan in any fashion. I'm guessing this was found on a peer-to-peer program or something. I've seen plenty of mp3s that have been improperly labeled this, claiming Radiohead performed it. I think this was mislabeled (not necessarily by the person who happened to post it here) because people assume that only Thom Yorke from Radiohead can play piano lol
hi Billy, I've been having a really bad time, Marilyn Manson was the best I could come up with to at least move things forward a little...anyhow there's no such thing as God, but if you need one look to Courtney Love, she killed me so softly, if only I had let her finish the job...love, peace, empathy - a boy named blue
Obviously it wasnt radiohead. You know that a black hole appears if Radiohead and the pumpkins perform together. And well, we still here :D
How I would have loved if radiohead was on this too but I think the world would have exploded from too much musical greatness lol. Still one of the most beautiful song from the pumpkins.
"Radiohead & Billy Corgan" must be a hangover from the early file sharing days when this track was erroneously titled.
I remember I discovered that song after I downloaded from Napster back in the day and it was the same error in the title!
I love you Billy Corgan.
Between this song, rhinoceros and love to love...very emotional
i was waiting for this version on utube for years....thank you!it s awsome!!!
He doesn't hate them, he just said that he dislikes the culture which puts them on a pedestal and that they make art music nowadays not pop or rock music
as a former Radiohead fan , I now side with Billy on that one.
Me2. Pulled it from Limewire around 1999/2000 and have loved it ever since. Thanks to those who've put me right about the non-Radiohead connection - I can now relabel it myself!! :)
PLEASE rename this track (you can click 'edit video'). It's Billy Corgan performing the song with the help of Mike Garson on the piano, who was the touring keyboardist for the Pumpkins at the time. Myself and others pointed this out a year ago. I understand it was an honest mistake, likely to due to mislabeling but others may be confused because they aren't familiar with this track.
*7 years later*
Nope. He did it for the clicks.
Thanks, I second that, especially because this is the best version I have found, so fix the title so we can share it, without confusing people. Well said Act4.
I have been looking for this forever. God I miss mistitled files from Bearshare.
The BEST version, with the WRONG title. 'BILLY CORGAN feat.MIKE GARSON - If There Is A God (live). Please FIX IT.
As an aside, the only band from the UK that Billy performed with during the KROQ Almost Acoustic Xmas in 1998 was Depeche Mode--when he came on stage to perform "Never Let Me Down Again" with them. Radiohead didn't even perform during the show in 1998, they played in 1995, while Smashing Pumpkins or Billy Corgan had not
as much as i dislike misleading false titles, the pureness of this song prevents more from pressing the dislike button...
greatest bands ever
more of this
@jimmychauv Yep. Radiohead has never performed with SP or Billy Corgan in any fashion. I'm guessing this was found on a peer-to-peer program or something. I've seen plenty of mp3s that have been improperly labeled this, claiming Radiohead performed it. I think this was mislabeled (not necessarily by the person who happened to post it here) because people assume that only Thom Yorke from Radiohead can play piano lol
This was recorded from 1998 KROQ Almost Acoustic Christmas. It has nothing to do with Radiohead.
Uh.... No radiohead in here. Im a fan of smashing pumpkins though, so its chilled.
it's not RADIOHEAD, it's just RADIO + BILLY
Thom Yorke não canta ! O nome do vídeo deve estar errado.
RADIOHAED LOL
.
didnt billy hate on radiohead?
No he said they’re one of the greatest bands of all time
I don't hear any Radiohead.
I want to dislike this because the Radiohead part is a complete lie, but the song is amazing. It's Mike Garson and Billy Corgan.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but Radiohead has nothing to do with this :)
hi Billy, I've been having a really bad time, Marilyn Manson was the best I could come up with to at least move things forward a little...anyhow there's no such thing as God, but if you need one look to Courtney Love, she killed me so softly, if only I had let her finish the job...love, peace, empathy - a boy named blue
romans 1 god shows himself in nature accept gods general revelation and he will show himself to you more intimately www.equip.org
yes he hate them now and he is right this band overated
John leclair dumb
He doesn’t hate them. He said they’re one of the greatest bands of all time!