Why are Japan and Korea in a trade war? | CNBC Explains
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 11. 2019
- Amid an escalating trade dispute between Japan and Korea, many people are asking why the two Asian powerhouses are fighting. CNBC’s Grace Shao explains the reasons behind the feud and how it affects you.
-----
Subscribe to us on CZcams: cnb.cx/2wuoARM
Subscribe to CNBC International TV on CZcams: cnb.cx/2NGytpz
Like our Facebook page:
/ cnbcinternational
Follow us on Instagram:
/ cnbcinternational
Follow us on Twitter:
/ cnbci
#CNBC #Japan #Korea
Title of video : “why are Japan and Korea in a trade war”
Reporter at start of video : “it’s not the one you’re thinking of”
I think she is referring to China and us
@@shoueda6566 Ok
Gotta remember this was played on cable news
She is just want to say “Only Japan is a bad country.” Korea work hard when they attack Japan. They hate Japan with no reason. Almost all history issues were made by Korea or some newspaper companies. They are believing only good things for Korea
@Mehedi Hasan Hey poor Korean ! Why you always hate innocent Japan. lol By your actions makes all over the world to hate Korea.
The camera guy be like “let’s unnecessarily zoom to add drama”
Internet commenter be like "let's nitpick stupid shit to raise our low self esteem"
ROFL
John Yeh he learned it with the koreans cuz ooooo boi
they do it
Da Da but we weren’t even talking about the merits of japan past with korea tho?
also please don’t act like the brutality of the old korean ruling class justifies they picking women up (as young as 14 year olds) and allowing multiple men to RAPE THEM
one crime doesn’t justify another and Japan need to acknowledge they also fucked up by ever doing this to multiple innocent people
@Da Da Since when did "never fought" equal to "did not invade".
"The world was in a trade war since its inception".
Nobody gives anything for free and nobody wants to miss out trade.
Not in OUR land KKomrade
south korea has trade relationship north korea. yes north korea.
if you dont belive me google "Kaesong Industrial Region".
south korean companies are using north Koreans slave workers to make cheap goods.
many industrial equipments were shipped to north korea for nuclear bomb development.
@@atmark666 Kaesong Industrial Complex, to my understanding, has been defunct since 2016. What are your news sources for your statements?
@@claylover9845
They still exist. if you disagree, show me picture of the demolished industrial region.
the facilities are still there. they can reopen in full capacity anytime. as South korean government announced it was "temporarily" closed.
"On 10 February 2016, the South Korean Ministry of Unification announced that the industrial park would be "temporarily" closed down and all staff recalled, partly in protest over continued North Korean provocations, including a satellite launch and a claimed hydrogen bomb test in January 2016."
@@atmark666 Right. There seems to be a big difference in meaning on your previous statement. You made it sound like they're still in operation and now, you're agreeing with me. The physical building exists but all the businesses are gone.
According to a newspaper article, On 2 November(←sorry it’s October is correct), export of hydrogen fluoride to SK Hynix was already permitted.
According to the news reporting this export license, it seems that it is taking time because Korean importers struggle with submiting all the required documents that were not necessary when South Korea was on the white list.
Similar to this declaration, I think that export declaration of hydrogen fluoride to South Korea that can be confirmed as import for semiconductor manufacturing purposes etc. will be allowed.
Japan is not restricting on export hydrogen fluoride, but only strictly controls strategic materials under the international law.
I love Korea as a Korean.
I like neighboring Japan, too.
But I hate the Korean government, which has anti-Japanese sentiment for political reasons, and the Japanese government, which has anti-Korean sentiment.
Korea needs Japan, and Japan needs Korea.
Stay close. 🇰🇷❤🇯🇵
Your data references are so poor. Stop using the phrase”Analysis says” if u tryna keep your video quality on track.
Ciaran XU soooo true
this comment on point
At least she doesn't use information from "Anonymous source" like Western medias does when they are about to lie.
Common lol. cnbc is just a media with bunch of "reporters" they dont care about truths, only popularity lol
As long as experts say it, it's valid. And many of these sources are from each country so even if they tell you the organisation and names of the experts, it will take up excessive amounts of time and you won't know them to make a difference.
This is just scratching the surface and missing details and have wrong informations. Feels like only reading the headlines from both sids
You seem to know more than they mentioned in this video. I was curious what chemicals the trade restrictions were put on by Japan?
@@CockatooDude ① hydrogen fluoride ② Fluorinated polyimide ③ Resist (semiconductor fabrication)
These products are not something you can find in any market around the world. Only Japan can make them with HIGH purity.
*Important* These are also key chemicals to produce nuclear weapons. Due to the recent North Korean missile activities, Japan made any countries to import these 3 chemicals have clear certifications and registrations, but they did not ban any of chemicals to export.
Japan did what they have to do, but Koreans took this something personal.
Lots of bull shits going on here.
@@peacelights7092 I mean come on. We don't like having nukes above our heads ffs. Why the hell would we export these chemicals to nkorea? Take a look at our military budget spent because of our north friend. We skoreans are sick of that.
@@SeongeunHyun-qs8fs Why? No one knows why. Only "The Moon" knows... Never explained, ever
video 8 mins and 54 secs long is not enough to fully explain and cover background information and causes of this issue at all.
It is simple. Don't break your agreement.
@@singlefather01 I'm talking about length of the video. what the heck are you talking about?
@P I'm saying it should be.
This is not a documentary, but a short summary. If you are looking for a documentary look elsewhere
It does very well in the time given, but should be a more in-depth piece
Good work. A very good summary of the relationship on an economic and political scale of the basic disputes.
My only problem with this video is that it was released on 13th of Nov and yet the content is outdated by roughly two months. CNBC, you will begin to lose credibility if you post outdated news packaging it as something new...
Can you do Vietnamese subtitles?
hoat giap No
@@Stoneface_bored
why ?
Now I could see if South Korea where to be self reliant, then let’s look at electric shavers as Panasonic is from Japan then, I have also seen a bunch of products made by Philips that are made in Korea and if Philips Korea where to manufacture shavers for the South Korean market and for export then Philips will sell more shavers than Panasonic in South Korea; that way is a lost for Panasonic for electric shavers.
That means it’s a huge win for a Dutch company to sell more electric shavers being manufactured in South Korea in South Korea and a huge lost for Panasonic.
You taught me more about the global economy than in one video than years worth of news.
I look forward to the quick recovery of the relationship between Korea and Japan. 🇰🇷🤝🇯🇵
토착왜구들이나 원하는 거지...화해? 장난하나😠
@@limelight777 아뇨 그뜻이 아니고 일종의 속임수같은겁니다.
@@limelight777 bro you have full right to hate Japan
Forget that... Korea needs to invade war and treat them how they treated Korea for 35 years. I am sure China will join Korea but Japan is hiding behind U.S.
Thanks for an informative video :)
I don't know how you guys gathered these information, but god damn it really sounds like u guys only gathered up infos like only from headlines of this issue related articles and etc. Lacking so much crucial infos
I Ike how this video glosses over the fact that the official reason for removing South Korea from the whitelist is completely unfounded and that Poland is still on the list despite having actually traded with North Korea.
No, Poland is not on the list. The list is maintained according to an international treaty among U.S allies controlling strategic substance only produced in Japan, U.S and western Europe.
jawedz last time I checked, Poland is on the list.
jawedz check out Aljazeera (I’m assuming it’s neutral) and you’ll see Poland on the list: www.aljazeera.com/ajimpact/south-korea-longer-japans-approved-export-list-190828081040875.html
@@absentminded7230 I stand corrected. Poland is on the list. The list is a result of rigorous evaluation, mostly of the designated country's government. Poland's government must have created a rigorous regime that satisfied Japan's Ministry of Industry, Trade & Economy.
On the other hand, South Korean government had not replied to the Japanese Ministry's enquirer for a year and did not answer details of South Korean companies suspected of shipping banned chemicals to non-listed countries.
@Demetrius Karavasilis That sounds like your fantasy, because that is not I read on news here.
If India try to do so than Britain now UK will have to give us trillions and trillions of dollars
Yes!
Disputes are not necessarily a trade war.
Stop spouting bullshit lies every single figure you are "quoting" is overexaggerated or straight up lies. . Also, your argument is like "Hey that woman wanted to have a child. So I raped her and now she has a kid. She should be grateful to me." Garbage like you spreading lies is the problem with japan.
Da Da I'm Korean and think half your comments are pretty solid. But damn. How much of a weeb do you have to be to comment crazy lengthy stuff on youtube just to show your obsession with Japan tho. I mean it's crazy bc you don't get paid or praised by any Japanese for doing this stuff, yet you be so obsessed and passionate. Gotta admire the effort tho lmao.
@Da Da NOW I TELL YOU THE TRUE. Japan gov is justifying its colonization and the war.
@@yuilchoi2799 조선족 어서오고
@Da Da bruh its already 2020 don't bring up almost 100 years of history it doesn't matter anymore.
so basicaly koreans are still salty about wwii? give me a break korea.
Oh so we should ignore the victim who were forced to work in terrible conditions ah i see makes sense.
This video is missing so many major and minor details, not even giving the right picture of the whole situation
can you give us some important infos in brief?
@@AMabud-lv7hy since I'm not an expert, I will leave a link to CNN page and Washington post written on this issue. ( www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2019/08/12/business/south-korea-japan-trade-war/index.html ) , ( www.washingtonpost.com/business/why-japan-and-south-korea-have-their-own-trade-war/2019/09/11/82b64246-d4fb-11e9-8924-1db7dac797fb_story.html )
However, I can tell you this much. This video is mentioning the main cause of the trade war is because south Korea's "inadequate management" of the chemicals. That is NOT the cause, rather is merely an excuse Japanese government gave after trade war started. The real issue that started the trade war is when Korean Supreme Court ruled that two of Japanese companies need to compensate several South Korean citizens for the forced labors during the years Japan imperialized South Korea. Japanese government did not like this decision, and tried to force South Korean government to alter the supreme court decision by restricting major components of semi-conductors - which Korea's major companies (such as Samsong) need for making cell phones. Since using this as a reason for trade restriction is against the rule under WTO trade agreement, they had to come up with different reasons why they are starting the trade war. That's where their made-up reason of South Korean government's "inadequate management" of chemicals comes in. South Korean government has already openly talked about this matter and asked the Japanese government about in what standard the management was inadequate. Until today, Japanese government still has not given an straight answer to that question, despite the fact that they are using that reason as a main cause of trade restriction. If whomever made this video looked up just a little bit more in to the subject, they cannot be making this major mistake in their summary.
@@AMabud-lv7hy so this is a news from Korean broadcasting company. I’m afraid that you may not be able to read Korean but I am quite sure google translate can sufficiently help you to get the idea what they were saying in the article. PLEASE NOTE that this issued in 5/17/2019. And we want to redefine what “made up reason” means. Critical thinking doesn’t require much words and eloquence to convince.
@Little birds can remember we reject that money we just wants "LITTE APOLOGY CAN REMEMBER" for all victims from japan
@@user-nt2tz4sy5r
History of truth.
czcams.com/video/GwXj74aj1cY/video.html
Great summary, I have learned a lot! Thank you! Keep the good work!
So in essence, SK took money from Japan twice, promising to settle the contentious issues between two countries once and for all, and then went back on its words without returning the money. Interesting.
Read the details of agreements, that does not include settlements of individule damage the japanese government and companies made to Korean..
SK said it will return the money but J refused. Money isn't the problem here. SK wants J to recognize illegal and forced labor of men and women during colonial era. J has been saying it was volunteer, which is not true. During the agreement where the news think Abe was sorry, he actually said sorry for the pain, but imply that government will never apologize....
Lol clearly only read the titles of headlines this is wht japan is good at "oh were sorry" goes back to japan* : so all ihave said in korea is bullshit the japanese obviously cant do anything wrong and we'll continue teaching our youth bullshit history 😃
If Korea replace Japan materials with China, then I have to consider changing a brand. I think, almost all chinese product I bought are with poor quality. I may sounded bias but my reason is based on experience.
Understandable.
I too have bad experience with materials from china because they don’t last that long.
You don't have to worry about that, we built our own chip manufacturer and we are using those
"Japan and South Korea are Asia's biggest economy after China and India". Last time I checked, Japan's GDP is still way ahead of India. Get your facts straight please.
True though sadly only as of now....India is estimated to surpass Japan soon or later.
Its true japan's GDP is more than 2 times of India's GDP
Could be in terms of PPP where India is bigger than Japan
China's data are not reliable.The second GDP is not unclear, India is rapidly growing.
India is bigger in GDP PPP maybe that's what they meant
surprisingly good impartial commentary
日本人はなぜこんなに韓国に関心が多いのだろうか？
lol sweet video
These videos are great
Excellent piece👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Always good to wake up to a well documented video.
Would be good IF NOT FOR THE WRONG VIDEO TITLE.
There are two koreas. There is no "Korea" as a country. There is NORTH KOREA and SOUTH KOREA. NOT KOREA.
The country mentioned is SOUTH KOREA.
@@KneeJerkReactor south koreans identify themselves with their supreme leader from the north.
Kyco MC It’s true... but it’s not Kim jung un
It’s Santa
@@christopherkim4747 north korea is best korea
czcams.com/video/PmWHHjuOMog/video.html
Where was this filmed?! I need to go there and get some pics!
My guess is Singapore lol. Their previous report on India was also conveniently shot in Singapore
@@cy9987 Guess I won't be getting those pictures then
@@cy9987 it's a story on a Indian in Singapore
As the economy is shifting you need have a legitimate and creative source of extra income. There are opportunities available that people have been using for years now.
The rich see's economic crisis as a garage sale, that's why investing right now will be the best decision
Consistency is the key, I've been investing with him for months now and I've made a lot of profit from him.
Who's this professional everyone keeps talking about and how do I contact him?
Good to know you all earn coin too
Bitcoin is pointing at the moon and everyone is staring at it's finger
4:29 am I the only one who finds it interesting that aside from South Korea who was recently removed from the whitelist no other asian country is on that whitelist?
AFP Modernization Program Updates,
You are one in the billion "Am I the Only One" clan.
To be on the whitelist you have to agree with USA too. You knownthat
Maybe the whitelist, is only mostly white people country list...lol
@@jon-unicorn-doxxer so koreans are sad because they use lots of whitening creams.
@@kiyoshim9593 lol...maybe...I said mostly tho...
Do. More. Videos.
Probably should specify which Korea
I think the first history lecture doesn't really explain the contemporary issues on this matter...
The reporter explained lunatic Korean grudge against Japan. But, everybody knows South Korea wants to be a part of China, so let it be.
North Korea: ha ha ha ha ha told ya peasant
Japan is suck😂
@The One LOL Japan sucks
enigma0165 korea sucks
@The One poor japanese
Please stop that dudes. We should be rational
I'm Chinese I like Japan but don't like south korean.
Thank you for your warming opinion. Lol ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
This was not nearly enough information to cover anything except small things, not even the information was absolutely correct, the reporters just kept quoting analysis.
Do tell more....?
and you have all the details i'm assuming? the purpose of the video isn't to span the entire history of their feud, that would take hours. Does no one read anymore, go forth and research if you want more details
@@gemelwalters2942
I didn't say cover all, I just said "This was not nearly enough information to cover anything except small things". So I'm just saying, they should have a little more information that is more reliable to create a better understanding. The story almost sounded if it was one sided.
Illusion67 I guess you are thinking in one side
Is there a way to get the sources for this please?
Just go and research both Korean and Japan media. I recommend you not to use Asahi and Mai nich article as for Japan media. You can't know the fact from those 2. As for Korean article, whatever. What they write is almost same.
So much missing information. However, it is good to see CNBC has interested in these complicated issue.
This video fails to cover the fact that none of the treaties between the two country settled the individual claims from the war victims. The court ruling covered exactly that issue; individuals claiming compensation from the Japanese companies.
South Korea didn't want to settle compensation claims individually, the government asked for more economic grants instead and said they would handle it themselves. They had the money but the state chose to do other things with it. The matter was officially settled in 1965. The Japanese government doesn't agree the SK Supreme Court has the right to rule on this issue and extract money for war crimes through a back door, its a matter between governments. SK will never forgive Japan no matter what is paid, its always looking for a fight. Its just stupidity at this point.
@@iihh517 lol the war crime victims are not asking for financial compensation, but sincere apologies from the Japanese government which was never done for once so far.
전쟁피해에서 개인의 피해에 대한부분은
국제법적으로 국가간 합의가 있어도
개인부분은 국가에서 권한 자체가 없다는 사실을 모르시는군요..
2년전 그말에서 한국이 어리석다했지만
2021년 한국이 일본에 승리했습니다.
I now some of you see well, (my?) a point, why do we have to keep paying suffering, labeled WC. Japan did what it can, and that should be enough there is also proof Japan did. Idk if CF is true or not prb Labor is true... But there are documents of Imperial Japan that sends to brothels "Not" to force ppl into this trade... You cant just ignore that. Japan is not SK, we dont Just make up lies and unfaithful. That is why we are able to develop, all develop country live under the rule of its own "principles" and its ingrained in their society and personality.
Meanwhile India and Vietnam : Business is about to pick-up
Vietnam maybe coz I trust the Confucianism circle. But India needs to understand what SOP means first before it actually picks up.
Vietnam's economy is dependent on Korea
Should pick up and I'll be more than happy to buy them.
@General Luise Martinbanger But you forgot to mention that India was the ONLY nation that had quitted the recent RCEP negotiations while others including Japan, the old adversary of China had joined this trade zone. If countries that are not friendly to China like Japan, Vietnam, Australia all joined this same agreement, why not India? Because India was too nationalistic just like the US under Trump. In the situation that every nation should make a certain degree of concessions, India chose not to. That's how India quitted, but not China asked it to do so.
Vietnam has maxxed out production with backlogs for the next 2-3 years. Mostly Chinese businesses too moving manufacturing into Vietnam.
North Korea:😶😐🙂😀😆😂🤭🤫
+ China
+Communist
No they are too exhausted to laugh because of starvation
@IMxYOURxDADDY so South Korea has a lot to loose in a war 😂😂😂
@Little birds can remember what a stupid saying lol zzz
This is not a trade war. This is generation shift that Korean's new generation no longer inherits the economic and technological inferiority underlying Koreans through the Japanese colonial period and modernization. If the pro-Japanese conservative government had continued to take power in Korea, this kind of overcoming could've been difficult to take place. In this perspective, this is also huge political issue.
@Der Schwindel Japan didn't modernise Korea you ill-informed cretin. Japan's colonial legacy: leaving South Korea as one of the poorest countries in the world! Thanks Japan!
Samsung is not Sam”son”.
President of South Korea is Moon “Jae” In, not Moon “Ja” In.
I think pronunciation and delivery are as important as good content.
You guys should’ve googled or asked a couple Koreans how you pronounce Korean names.
To be fair, we do it too.
The reason why Samsung overtook Intel a few years ago was the illegal export of strategic materials imported from Japan.
Samsung derived benefit from acts that disrupt international peace.
Before the Japanese goverment managed exports to S.Korea, in recent years, South Korea's imports of high-purity hydrogen fluoride from Japan have increased rapidly. At the same time, Iran's nuclear development has greatly advanced.
No one:
Comments from South Korea and Japan: Begins war at 3 in the morning
Does this mean that RAM prices will finally start dropping again?
will go up more likely
no ways memory price drops on Japanese GOV's silly act.
PaniniStealer Japan started the trade war first by restricting resources for semiconductor exports
KIX_LOVE it is japan’s fault. Japan restricted trade just because korean court judged that japanese war crime companies should pay back to the victims of forced labour. For example, if your poeple were kid - napped for forced labour, and you want compensation, but the bullies say it’s ur fualt. Would u be happy?
KIX_LOVE Japan js war crime country during ww2 which is same as nazis. I don’t think Japan has any rights to blame korea.
Very well explained Grace!! Impressive work.
Jonas Ekblom this video is pretty poor explanation. Only described one side of view.
@DR NO 9 minutes
Is annexation and colonization equivalent? Even if it is, Japanese colonial settlement is entirely different from those of European examples in history. Any objection?
Japanese annexation of Korean peninsula was similar treatments as the British annexation of Scotland. They built infrastructure, universities, railroads, dams, etc. during the era, and that they gave Koreans a full-fledged Japanese citizenship with equal rights.
@@colnagoboy I do appreciate your knowledge in history. You are great.
ほんとに。日本は韓国が良き隣人となると思って近代化したのにね。
Guys,can you just forgive each other and move forward?World War 2 ended wayback decades ago.We Filipinos even hated Japanese soldiers wayback,but we moved forward because we wanted growth for our future children and peace of mind.Hope both nations heal in their own pace. 😔😔😔
As a Japanese, we wanted to move forward. That’s why japanese government gave so much money to Korea. But they kept asking more and more money and spreading the bad thing about Japan to other countries. How do we feel? I’m from Hiroshima. Even my grandparents never said any bad thing against America. My mon told me that they were friends with an American family right after the war. They met some Americans who taught English. And when they moved back to their home, they gave my grandparents furniture. So even at that time my moms house had Western style furniture.
@@luvpuppy9564 dont bullshit 10 million dollars aint jacksht for both korea and japan and were only accepted by pro japanese officials in korea if u guys wanted to "move forward" u wouldnt try to keep the koreas fighting begging god for a 2nd korean war to revive ur dead economy
Historically the relationship and mutual feelings between Korea and Japan are much older and deeper than you know.
As a Japanese, I'm disappointed every time there is a boycott of Japanese products in South Korea. Japanese do not boycott Korean products. Because they think boycott is a nonsense act.
Certainly, Japanese do not go out of their way to declare a boycott or exert sympathetic pressure like Koreans do.
They just avoid Korean products without saying anything.
One thing to make it correct. Japan claims wartime forced labor compensation is all over with the 1965 treaty between S.Korea and Japan.
However, S.Korea claims “governmental compensation” is over with the treaty but “individual private compensation” is not over with private or public Japanese companies according to the International law of human rights in support of the United Nations.
There was no war between Japan and Korea. Korea got money from Japan in 1965. And they require more money.
There was a terrible war between Korea and Vietnam. Vietnam doesn't require money from Korea.
What does that mean?
@@Ultrasonicmolester
Most of asian hate that flag but you are using it?
Lol what the hell dose that mean?
@@user-tg2pb8ld2i it's only Korean obsessed with that flag and other Asians don't even care.
@@user-tg2pb8ld2i The actual victim of WW2 China welcomed Japanese navy ship with the Rising Sun Flag. Non-victim Korea rejects Japanese navy ships with the Rising Sun Flag. Only Koreans protest against the Rising Sun Flag. Don't say most of Asians.
@@Ultrasonicmolester That's true，as a Chinese I dont hate the Rising sun flag : -)
Sometimes I wonder if India and Pakistan were not partitioned the world would have been different same goes as if Korea were not divided by 38 parallel line they would been a global powerhouse
time to go back to flip phones..
Yes... Galaxy Z Flip :)
Keep the one you got unlike the sheep that have to upgrade every year cause marketing told them ....
Flip phones just like in anime
How nostalgic
Amazing overview! Congratulations to all of those who were involved!
Guilherme Chinen but it lacks facts. It merely says Korea’s actions are based on public sentiments. They failed to do detailed research on the areas not covered under two nations’ agreements as well as for the reason for discontinuance of GSOMIa
Seems like this animosity will go on for a long while... Almost a century and still on fuel
it will probably last another century.
Lmao it has been like this for centuries
Egos are involved. Both sides will have to suffer severely or see a huge gain before fixing there issues.
Asians are just as good at holding grudges as they are at math
@@cbcluckyii4042 This isn't really about grudges. It's about people who rightfully should be paid apology and compensation.
Sounds like a mashup of iffy secondary and tertiary sources.
Why are China and Unitedstate ?
At war, each side are to blame for not maintaining peace.
@jappie jappo 😅
@@zinc_trioxide that guy kinda definitely sounds like a Japanese liar lol
@@5tw3b45tcf or drunk 😂
this wouldnt have happened, if Japan didnt invade and colonize korea. Also, shinzo abe said sincere apology???? he never apologized. it would anger his political fan base.
@@screen6712 Says a brainwashed korean
Sohee Y Look who's speaking, fuckorean. But in my opinion, I want Abe and Moon to get disappear together for good. They're not for both Japan and S.Korea.
@Little birds can remember Japan copied the US. XD
@@songes3058 The Japanese system is completely different in many ways.
The compensation from Japan(in 1965 treaty) is only valid for nation-to-nation case. Individual compensation is not made yet.
Because individual compensation is very hard to verify.
@@kiyoshim9593 I understand that, but all the pains and wounds are remaining on the individual victims, not on the nation which likes to hide the embarrassing history and moves on. I am sure that the nation shouldn't rule the peoples, but the nation should rule by peoples. So right peoples can get the proper treatment for their scars till its heals up, not just externally but also internally.
@@huijunchoi Yes people should heal. But how are they going to heal with an apology from a politician? politicians are actors. And how are they going to heal with an apology from someone that was not even alive back then? these sincere apologies are long gone.
But the money can be achieved. Yes that can happen. in 1965 and 2015 Japan gave money., but if they want money directly. its different.
So I actually Believe that Korea should solve their internal affairs first before asking for something. not that each year someone say. "Oh I was in a labor camp too". Something that is very difficult to prove in 2019
@@kiyoshim9593 That's right, the real people who raised the bloody war and made innocent victims, they are gone. So it's hard too get the proper apology, i understood. However, the nation, Japan is still there with responsibility of what they did. So... i am not the brightest man or wise man who knows every things but i think Japanese government can start with stop worshiping the war criminals as hero at Yasukuni Shrine. And as you said korean government can solve the internal problem about why the 2015 agreement between korea and japan was completed without talking with the actual victims, so they can put them in a court.
I am not doing this for Korean to take a money from Japan. I am doing this so Japanese can have better understand the WWII was a horrible crime which we shouldn't repeat that in world history.
@@huijunchoi Yasukuni Shrine has 2.5 million people, Shinzo abe has family enshrined there so He always sends a present but he avoids to go there. Many Japanese don't even know about the existence of that. Japanese people in 2019 are kind, they hate war and they Do know that the emperor is not really a descendant of Amaterasu, They will never allow war again. That's why Article 9 Could not be changed. But they got internet, Wikipedia is not censored in Japan, if they wish to know better they will. But I do know. Every society has some people that has hate in their hearts. we just have to take it out. and maybe find peace because not a single of us is perfect.
The living from the same source of ,,food" so not a surprise. There both export economic system nations so they will fight for the same market. If one will want to get bigger the other will need to be smaller.
This is a sad result of governments interfering civil lawsuits. Things wouldn't have gotten this far if they let their judicial branches handle the issues.
Japan announced its export curbs without any prior notice and executed the curbs just three days after the announcement. It has not only ignored procedural justification, but also lacks consideration for its neighboring country.
@Harry Porter
Talk about lacks of consideration for its neighboring country...Obviously Korea thinks Japan doesn’t even deserve their consideration and it’s okay to demand money and apologizes endlessly.
@@mauricegatito6523 World press freedom index ranks Japan in 66th position, far below other developed countries such as South Korea, Germany etc. I would stop informing myself with Japanese propaganda before you start embarrassing yourself rsf.org/en/japan
They might use Ning-Bong currency instead.
6:45 For anyone curious, one of the signs say, "Japan Yes. Abe Out" meaning the general public of Korea wants a good relationship with Japan or supports the Japanese people but not Abe and his politics. I just wanted to point this out as supporters of Abe often decry Korea as simply Japan bashing or hating when it's far more nuanced than that. Considering the terrible things Japan did to Korea, to show any signal that Korea still supports the Japanese people is a sign of humility in my opinion. In fact, far more Koreans visit Japan than Japanese visit Korea and this should be telling of the perceptions of the general public from both sides.
good translation!
Abe and his party are the animals left alive right after ww2 until today. Their existence in their political spot is simply just a tragedy to humanity, as a fact.
@Proggo Bonskey woah dude u got a reason?
@Proggo Bonskey Studies on history can be differently taught depending on nations and communities. Reflecting on myself can lead to different answers against reflecting to our history since I definetly wasn't on the event, just like you and your history. Anyways we just lead to believe on the written history remaining since they were the past. Although I am believing the history that I've learned, there is no reason for me to blame you learning the history from your community. I wish there could be a better way to find out the truth, so our people and your people could be more caring and helping, loving each other. Both of us need to be MORE honest for ourselves and each other no matter what for the people who knows the truth for sure. I wish the real truth pops out, the inflicted apologizes, and to be cool to each other and live on with smooth relationship.
@@jym-i491 nice phrasing bro
Don't just say "three chemicals". I want to know what they are
Ultra- pure Hydrogen Fluoric Acid(HF), Fluorine Polyimide, and photoresist.
www.reuters.com/article/us-southkorea-japan-laborers/japan-to-tighten-export-rules-for-high-tech-materials-to-south-korea-media-idUSKCN1TV089
This world is going to shit. Looks like I'll be keeping my phones for longer before a upgrade
lol ur so funny
This world is actually becoming better and better
Consumer Electronics Industry is either going to fall, or its going to boom - all depends on these two powerhouses.
Hahaha the Sum of Profit of top20 Japanese electronics is less than that of Samsung. More Japan has no future in Electronics, look at Sharp and Toshiba. They were sold to Taiwan and Korea lol Only left industry is Car making. Toyota only for Japan
3:35 the predecessor president is nationally considered a tax money thief in Korea, and is currently in prison lol
Tell me at least past 10 korean presidents who didn't go to prison.
Eventdash01 There are only 12 presidents in Korean history. 5 of them didn’t go to jail. Roh Moohyeon(killed himself), Kim Daejoong, Kim Yeongsam, Choi Kyuha, Yoon Bosun are those.
@Eventdash01 but this one was *impeached* and went to prison.
@@hanul0023 5 out of 12? lol
That's why they say presidency in S.Korea is the most dangerous job.
@@moochoopr9551 some of them devoted their lives for democracy and serving the country, while others served just their own bank account maliciously
People on this comments don't have knowledge about the relationship btw S.Korea and Japan. This is a quite neutral report and seems to know a lot about the current situation as well as the history between us
2:44 That's a poor way to cover Prime Minister Abe's attitude towards the issue. He does a decent job at appearing as if he has "sincerely apologised" but his action prove otherwise. He's a self identified nationalist who has admitted that he wants to further revise Japan's already bias history textbooks in schools to make Japan's youth more "proud" of their history. You can't blame Korean citizens for remaining upset when the government of the country that committed the crime refuses to even admit what their country did in the past was wrong.
Shinzo Abe Attitude? it was him that made the last agreement only todismissed again by South Korea. Hes done with korea. Buy your chemicals somewhere else if you want.
The next time Korea want a sincere apology then ask the perpetrators. Oh wait they are all dead long ago.
Do you actually believe that a Japanese First minister has free time to spend with south korea.
A country that is even trying to change the name "Sea of Japan" to East sea just because Korean Nationalists dislike Japan.
When are the Koreans gonna acknowledge their comfort women in Vietnam?
@@thatleftyjames2893
Ask on the streets of Korea Koreans know and feel ashamed that Korean troops have done some wrong in Vietnam. And the Korean government tried to solve the problem several times, but the Vietnamese government seems to be not interested in war because it is a winning country and is only interested in economic cooperation now. Korea is not avoiding it.
This is what the Korean foreign minister referred to in questions and answers with students at the university last year. Even if Korea wants to resolve the issue, it is difficult if the Vietnamese government does not want to do so.
And the victim of Vietnam has also visited the Korean National Assembly, and civic groups and lawyers are trying to solve this problem in Korea. I heard that a Korean lawyer recently filed a lawsuit with a Korean court over this matter.
The difference between Japan and Korea is that most Koreans know and admit that Korean troops did wrong in the Vietnam War.
However, the Japanese do not understand well because they do not learn enough to distort history or to reduce the fact that they have done wrong, only to think of it as an old story.
The reason for this is that Prime Minister Abe's father was a war criminal and the Japanese government now has a long history revisionist rule, including the education minister.
And Japanese government does not recognize the Japanese military sexual slavery, forced labor. So the Japanese tv South Korean World War II victims often distorted and so the Internet, many Japanese people are only as a prostitute and the Japanese military sexual slavery.Forced labor that workers simply think.
If you look at the comments of Yahoo News, a famous Japanese website, or 5ch, you will know what the Japanese think.
Korea does not avoid at least that problem in the Vietnam War and all the more so because there are problems in Korea and Japan.
The problem is that material compensation is important, but most of all, they have to admit that they have done something wrong without rejecting it. The reason this problem isn't solved is because they just pay and don't admit it at all.
That's why the victim is a liar and does not recover his human rights.
It is difficult to say much because Korea also did wrong in Vietnam.
However, Koreans may not think about the human rights of Korean victims.
Victims of Vietnam are important, but it cannot cover up the problems of Japan and Korea.
It is a matter of Korea and Vietnam.
Koreans do not want to fight this problem because they want to get along with Japan. Koreans are also distressed. In this matter, Koreans have no choice but to think about the Korean victims' position. Money is not important. It is not that the Korean government has no money.
This problem must be acknowledged by the Japanese government. That way, the victim will not be insulted as a liar, but will be able to restore the honor of human rights
@Cumulus Humilis Why are you lying to yourself. The last apology was accepted by the Diet in Japan lead by the first minister.
@Cumulus Humilis 100% of world countries have 2 faced people. racist people. But not everybody. Most people only try to live their lives.
They got inspired by USA and China
Apparently our dearest neighbor, Pakistan has also declared a similiar war on us
Apparently they don't want to use our products unless it's stamped by Dubai
As made in Dubai
So I think similiarly in Japan Korea conflict....maybe Vietnam or Cambodia can play a huge middleman role and earn nicely
Japan was inspired by China, not br america. That's why japanese character is made of chinese character.
@@user-qv9lx1zc8p That's histotically, but from economic perspective Japan has been developed since long...South Korea almost rose from ashes after Korean war to a tremendously developed nation...similiar to China
@@Tysongranger47 What i meant was that japan adopted chinese tactics to regulate exporting material like china did to japan about rare material 10 years back.
Tokyo is not located there.
I rather watch Japan 🇯🇵 and South
Korea 🇰🇷 in a trade war than a hot
war 🔥
Greetings from Germany...🍺🇩🇪
What is Japan aiming for about Korea? Once the drunken Japanese policymakers have advocated to take Dokdo as a military. Recent news on South Korea's weapons development and third-party assessments of South Korea are favorable. In addition to Japan, Japan is the only country in the world that has an anti-Korean book section if it has a high level of popularity. As such, it is the hope of the Japanese to imagine that Japan is a favorable assessment globally. These things are similar to the people of any country who are selfish. It is not a government that teaches objective truth in Japan, but only Asahi Shimbun is in the media. As long as Japan has a Japanese government or media that has given up objective evaluation of Korea, it is difficult for Japan to become an internationally moral country. Self-satisfaction can always be there, but the political use of the country is not high in popular is not high. Only the Japanese don't know. The Japanese say they helped Korea, but Koreans don't think so at all. Technology was also introduced, but the price was paid. Japan has stolen technology from the United States or Germany. The Japanese government's colonial compensation was around $300 million and there was no compensation for individuals for "crime against humanity". On the other hand, Chinese civilians were reimbursed and duplicated. Tsushima citing the San Francisco Peace Treaty, but with Japan, Dokdo issue be as Korean school books compiled by the state of the official documents or later. Maps around the world of the Dokdo as Korean map to about 185. Of course, changing the color of the map and manipulating it into Japanese territory is the skill of the Japanese media. It was also the Japanese media that omitted Korean donations from statistics during the Great East Japan Earthquake. This has played a major role even now in the novel-like history of giving benefits to Korea and the manipulation of public opinion by the sham media that joined it. Prime Minister Abe's regulation of exports, not imports, is also the result of learning the wrong history. In the past, Japan has copied many technologies from the U.S. and Germany. I can say that I stole this mole. Then, is there any technology that Korea stole from Japan? If pollack sauce, pollack sauce, and pollack have moved from Korea to Japan, the Japanese say it is their traditional food. Far from acknowledging this fact, the South should sever diplomatic ties with South Korea on a trivial pretext. It is Korean who knows Japanese bad deeds and habits best. It would be in his favor to Japan to stop its foolish incitement. Therefore, some politicians and the media instigated the slandering of Koreans by all means. It is important to know that Japan can never be a beautiful advanced country and it is not. Isn't Japan fighting the glory of the past? Cruel history needs to be stopped immediately. Sengaku is Chinese and Kuril Islands is Russian. Dokdo is without saying. Will Japan be able to handle the fight?
Japan makes opportunities a crisis, and Korea uses crises as opportunities. Of course China spreads the crisis to the world. The average Korean is not very interested in Japanese slander. Japan only waits for Korea's mistakes. That's how they make headlines. The illusion that war crimes countries without reflection are recognized worldwide is their own sleep talking.
What are those 3 chemicals?
① hydrogen fluoride ② Fluorinated polyimide ③ Resist (semiconductor fabrication)
These products are not something you can find easily in any market around the world.
Only Japan can make them with HIGH purity.
*Important*
These are also key chemicals to produce nuclear weapons. Due to the recent North Korean missile activities, Japan made any countries to import these 3 chemicals have clear certifications and registrations, but they did not ban any of those chemicals to export.
Japan did what they have to do, but Koreans took this as something personal.
@Jinha Choi Maybe a capitalist country wants to earn more by secretly selling those chemicals?? Profit > Values
@@peacelights7092 funny cause south korea can now produce those chemicals by themselves thanks to japan
Why does CZcams not tell me how cnbc is funded with a watermark from Wikipedia under every one of their videos like it does with RT?
Cause you tube suck on CNBC's cock. You realized they bend over to media corporations nowadays. They even allow CNBC to monetized their video and demonetized non corporate you tube channel with impunity.
Thanks for the great summary Grace
i know japan is bad and all during the war but you cant just keep using that to get what you want you cant say its settled and then a decade later resume the demands i say japan have already paid the price for the war massive reparation to Korea even when it was coming out from the devastation of war famine 2 atomic bombs and basically being a us lap dog as these point.
The fundamental problem is South Korea's " Liberal-Socialist" News media and Government Moon. At first, I blame the Japanese Government for not doing their part. But now I blame President Moon for not doing his part. Both Party is to blame for the chiaotic Historical mess.
At south korean they had their 1st "female" president. In the north if big brother disappear for a while little "sister" takes control, family only.
Japan :Please show me what you use HF.
South Korea :No document.
Japan suspects that South Korea uses to military purpose.This is violation of terms.
(from japan)
Hello Grace Shao! hmm this is quite interesting.
Actually Japan's economy is larger than India, but India has a larger economy PPP wise! Next time please be more specific
Dude it is much x100 more developed than india it's a western country in East in terms of economic prosperity . It has a bigger economy by a long shot . Iam saying this as a indian . The discipline the Japanese have is way better than ours .
@@bloodwargaming3662 India having a larger GDP PPP is due to the shear population alone. However note that it’s not only discipline, but also the fact that India had a left leaning semi isolationist position regarding the economy (thus inhibiting growth for most of it’s history), if she adopted capitalism before China did, she would have definitely been richer than Japan by now
@@bloodwargaming3662 not really in "east asia" its econo.y handt grown for the last 30 years.. unless... its compared to north korea XD
@@bloodwargaming3662 Japan was on it's way to become the world's biggest economy but he Americans slowed their economy in the 80's with the Plaza Accord and it hasn't been able to recover from it ever, US will always do anything in their power to slow down or contain other countries from taking their place and now they are trying to do that to China and if they are successful India is next on the list, that's why China and India need to put their differences to the side and create an alliance, this will be more beneficial for both countries
@@Senpai-nc2js left leaning semi isolationist postion was their till the 70's. From the emergency times we have slowly progressed towards capitalism by 1991 we implemented it to a large extent . And China if you think is so developed only due to capitalism and privatization iam sorry to say you are dreaming . China's spending on healthcare education and other social programs have helped it grow equally .
CNBC you might want to check your facts, Japan is the worlds 3rd largest economy and India is the worlds 5th largest...
Gun is dangerous. When people buy guns, they need to show license. And to get a license, you need to pass a thing or two. If you don't have a license, you don't get to buy one. Chemicals they talk here is way more dangerous than guns. And re-selling the product that need license got them burned. What is so hard about this.
This is irrelevant comment but to reply that. Gun license ownership should be re-evaluate in USA. Only those with big properties allowed to carry gun to protect themselves. For now, those who pass gun license are those who pass at shooting things and can afford "cheap" guns. This created problems when almost everyone can carry a gun, including those who shouldnt in the first place. Answer this question, Why we own a weapon? It is to protect our properties. But some will answer, we get weapon because we want to attack. Those with who lined up with the latter answer is the reason why gun license should be re evaluated.
@@KazeKumo Chemicals they talk about here is used to manufacture high-tech weapons like nuke and Sarin. It is as dangerous as guns if not more, and I was putting things in simple term for folks to understand. They were re-selling those chemicals they buy from Japan to country in South East Asia, China, Middle East. Therefore, Japan start restricting those chemical exports. There is no conflict, just following the rules.
Looks like this lady copied the news from a month prior...
Is there any reason the south Koria removed from White list?
There is evidence that shows that Japan illegally sent material which is used in nuke and missile manufacturing. So South Korea thought that they cannot trust Japan.
It's because Korea started badgering Japan about wartime atrocities and started being vocal about Japan's past.
@@bariforever3611 which site or information can I look up. I need to see the evidence.
@@minekomendenhall5033 Korea's national assembly member Ha Tae-Gyung said that. You can use Google.
@@bariforever3611 lol.. this is the biggest joke I've ever heard. Nice one..
Japanese government offered to pay compensation money directly towards those females on 1965 agreed treaty but it was Korean government who rejected the idea and instead they said it's Korean government job to distribute those money to those femals. after all they agreed and signed on treaty on 1965 and (Korean government)took money from Japan. you cannot keep asking money after agreeing already. this is an essential rules internationally.
Who is doing this? Behind the scene.
Jews?
@@jeanbethencourt1506 100% correct lol.
The agreement between Japan and Korea regarding the human atrocity and damages from colonial era were both made by Park Jung-hee and his daughter Park Guen-he. Park junghee was a devout japanese colonial officers who used to hunt down korea’s resistants. He even had japanese name, as a japanese citizen! Therefore he and his daughter’s deal with japan doesn’t count, even as the leader of the nation. That’s why there’s so much resentment about between two nations. Japan has been infiltrating their political and economic influences in South korea, leaching off korea’s success in economy by selling the crucial parts for the major industries. Park junghee, who is a traitor and essentially a japanese designed the industrial structure of korea to profit japan for decades.
I am Japanese. I'm not good at English, but I'll explain briefly
First of all, Japan has a system called "White Country" that gives preferential treatment to trading partners.
Please understand based on that
Japan "Korea, exports of materials that can be used for weapons have tripled,
but they have not been resold to other countries, right?"
South Korea "I don't say how I used it"
Japan “Korea has an obligation to manage and report properly. If it cannot do it, it must be excluded from White country.”
South Korea "It doesn't matter what you do, export it."
Japan "There is no explanation so I will exclude it from White Country. Please explain it from now on before importing."
South Korea “Japan is harassing”
Japan"????????"
I don't think reselling weapons is a good idea. And South Korea says, "It's a declaration of war on the Korean economy!" but we just quit the preferential treatment. From now on, we will trade like any other country in the world.
actually Korean government made adjustments on the issues, the weapon, and showed them to Japan but, Japanese government do not response still at the moment. It just revenge sanction against Korean Supreme court' verdiction regarding comfort women
Korea and Japan are fighting for the past while China is reaping benefits in the present . Look, Indians have forgiven the British for their deeds in the past and we have a good trade with them these days . We know how it feels but this trade war will neither benefit Korea nor Japan just the bystanders.
Past belongs in the books not in our hearts .
The present generation shouldn't suffer the deeds of the predecessor, that's not what justice looks like and will neither benefit the victim nor the convict .
🇯🇵☮🇰🇷
As a Korean, Japan started this war first. and we will win.
Don't you guys still have grudges with Pakistan over a lot of things like Kashimir, terrorism, etc?
Was there an Indian soldier in the British army? Was there an Indian general in the British army? Are Indian Maharaja and British royal family married?
As soon as the Koreans who fought as the center of the Japanese army lost the war, they began asking Japan for an apology. Korea and Japan have different circumstances from other Asian countries.
Do you think that sex slave or forced labor occurred between the two countries that had this relationship?
This is a fake report like Asian Boss. Japan's Public security authorities say that over the years, some ship has been used to illegally export missile parts from Japan to North Korea and to give instructions to Pyongyang's spies in Japan and It's turned out the owner of this ship was South Korean company. Around the same time, It's turned out South Korea company illegally exported Japanese-made hydrogen fluoride to all over the world. Japanese government asked Korea to explain to which country Japanese hydrofluoric acid was illegally exported from Korea but South Korea only got angry with Japan and did not give a clear answer. Therefore, Japan controlled the export of Japanese hydrofluoric acid to Korea.
That is not the true. Can u name that korean company? And that happen what you talking about was getting issued after the jp start to regulate the trade so call trade war. I think u read some novels from japanese made. The true is japan they trade with north korea illegally like resources but usa and korea later realized they done this.
So korea ask them whats going on that "japan, u just said cant trust korea cuz of the n.korea thats why regulate the trade but u trade the resources to n.korea in behind?, then who is the most untruthful country now?"
Fmi, japan now they try to cancel the and try negotiating again to korea cuz of they economy getting falling. Most of European countries like uk they cancel the trade with jp then new contract to korea for vehicle parts.
Also the resources for cellphones, now korea invented the new materials and got from other countries( i think i heard was Israel and cn) so korea is getting no needs from jp. and cuz of that jp co are getting negative effects sp they try to renew the trade code.
Plz read the news from korea and jp then u can see real things
@@user-nt2tz4sy5r"In December 2018, Korean authorities prosecuted 4 Koreans and 5 Korean companies for illegally procuring North Korean coal via Russia. " The South Korean government has also made this true to the public. and The South Korean government also announced, "There were 156 cases of illegal exporting of strategic goods from S.Korea to the world. this included Japanese-made hydrofluoric acids." Then why doesn't the Korean government answer to which country Japanese hydrofluoric acid was illegally exported?
@@taitaichi4184 i love jp and my jp friend even me, i am 1/4japanese. But when you see the things doing korea and japan. i am for sure jpgv is regulating alot to ppl to hind what they done in past and now. Korea itself has lots of issue but in this case jp triggered first.
'Emotional diplomacy revenge'
'Make japan(Abe) great again'
Thank you for saying "semi" the correct way, instead of "sem...i"
lol, I heard both pronunciations.
When you met the person who likes to say "I am a Canadian. I don't like Japan. Because Japan is the war-criminal country.", you'd better talk with him/her about the surveillance operation against North Korea according to the UNSCR sanction. Although Canadian Forces are participating in the surveillance operation, their surveillance activity is based not on South Korea's ports but on Japan's ones.
And you'd better ask that "Canadian person" why Canadian Forces don't trust South Korea.
I guess that "Canadian person" will easily show his/her true colour.
What does the logical relation between the fact that ‘Canadian surveillance activity is based on Japan nowadays’ and the fact that ‘Japan was the war-criminal country in the past’?
Do you want to say ‘Surveillance operation against North Korea’ can erase or offset the fact that ‘Japan was the war-criminal country’?
🇯🇵🤝🇩🇪🤝🇮🇹
@@user-sq4xm4pb1d
History of truth.
czcams.com/video/GwXj74aj1cY/video.html
If this was a college report, I would give B for trying. I can see they spent 5 hours in the internet. Very superficial and amature. Would be okay for college report but I expect more professionalism especially in a very intense and sensitive topic. I wonder they even consulted people from both sides. I think the major problem is they dont care about what is actually happening. They only need to make the story to the depth that looks okay. Why bother.
You misspelled amateur.
The conflict is not only economic, historical, and national, it is also ethnic. Many Japanese consider Koreans as inferior to the “Yamato” race. There are many racial slurs in the Japanese language for Koreans.
Just look up Kanto Massacre.
Honestly “Export regulation/controlr” has nothing to do with history or national or ethnic.
Those who are stupid just tryna respond to an argument by changing the subject to focus on someone else’s misconduct, implying that all criticism is invalid because no one is completely blameless. Bunch of whataboutism nonsense makes me wanna laugh.
Nah its bigotry. Though in terms of Chinese people I did get a Japanese salary women mad by telling her I was learning Chinese and how I was learning it, she exploded told me Chinese are subhuman and when I told her thats matomo ja nai in America (that was her favorite phrase and she used it for people dying their hair and going to work) and she went nuts. She recorded the interaction, and I can give you a link to it if you want.