Dietitian Reacts to Ex Biggest Loser Trainer Jillian Michaels' Condescending Diet Tips
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 10. 2021
- Thanks Aura for sponsoring! To bring some calm into your life click here aurahealth.io/abbeysharp21 to get a seven day FREE trial to Aura AND 25% off your first year!
Hi everyone, I’m Abbey Sharp and welcome to Abbey’s Kitchen. In today's video we will be reviewing Jillian Michaels' What I Eat in a Day.
A FEW DISCLAIMERS
1) The information in this video is for education and entertainment purposes only, so you should always speak to a health care provider about your unique health needs.
2) Please use this video (as with all of my review videos) as educational, not as unique recommendations.
3) Please be kind in the comments.
4) Trigger warning to those with disordered eating tendencies.
5) Don’t forget to subscribe to this channel and ring the little bell so you never miss out!
RESEARCH LINKS
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21343...
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15866...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17490...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20463...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20219...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20807...
Follow me on Instagram and TikTok! @abbeyskitchen
/ abbeyskitchen
/ abbeyskitchen
Don't forget to check out my brand new product line ✨ 𝙎𝙚𝙧𝙫𝙚𝙙 ✨ to get your hands on our new no-slip nesting bowls!
servedshop.com/products/no-sl...
Dress by Ba&Sh
Anorexia & Restrictive Dieting Freedom E-Course
(Use promo code Abbey20 for 20% off)
grace-s-school-b818.thinkific...
Check out my clothing MERCH line in support of Sick Kids Hospital
abbeyskitchenshop.com/
Some important links:
My book, The Mindful Glow Cookbook affiliate link: amzn.to/2nev0lf
The best baby feeding & eating gear (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/36h1r4a
My favourite supplements (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/39pGV3j
My favourite kitchen appliances and tools (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/2ubQnXV
My favourite healthy snacks (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/2ucC6dD
My favourite healthy breakfast foods (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/2SK8b6s
My favourite intuitive eating books (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/3wYX9uw
My favourite healthy meal ideas and snacks (amazon #affiliate) amzn.to/39oA3mC
Check out my blog for healthy recipes, parenting tips and tricks and busting nutrition myths and diets: www.abbeyskitchen.com
If you liked this video, please leave me a comment below with your thoughts and let me know who you want me to review next!
With Science & Sass,
Xoxo Abbey
Contribution by: Giselle Segovia RD MHSc
as an italian girl, hearing someone referring to pasta (refined grains) as 'all that crap' gives me chills
same!! im not italian, but i literally eat pasta every day 😭
@@iheartspookyszn same !! 😓
I know 😫
Pasta is delicious, I’m not Italian I just love bread and pasta
Bahaha
She comes across as so joyless and overly intense when she talks about food. When I think of all the people you’ve spoken about on your channel, I like the ones who enthuse about and really savour what they eat.
I enjoy that too!
I like Katherine Zeta J's way of describing the food she eats.
Crazy, healthy cool describes food so well!
@@melodybroome6203 "healthy crazy cool" lol ; I love him ; he prevented be from becoming a fat-phobic vegan haha (speaking about dietary fat not "fat" people of course)
to be honest, food isnt the center of everyones world, for some it is like breathing, you just dont think about it, you do it so survive. why would that be wrong?
Jillian has always come across to me as an angry person. Unhappy and frustrated. I don’t respond well to being bullied and that seems to be her motivation when training.
She's HANGRY
if someone starts trying to bully me into doing something i will become a fortress of resolve to NOT do the thing. it really doesn't work for me either.
I completely understand
I love her training style on workout dvds. Never watched the loser show but I like her
I once read an article in which Jillian Michaels stated she had been put in a martial arts class run by an abusive teacher in which, when she cried, the teacher cornered and attacked her and wouldn't stop attacking her until she fought her way out. That must have been a huge contributor to her current issues - she even basically admitted it, but framed it in a way that suggested she thought that martial arts class was "character-building" when in reality it fostered a permanent cornered-animal mentality that she now turns aggressively on everyone else (you know, the kind of "anger issues" that are normally associated with toxic masculinity except in this case the person inculcated with those values was a girl).
You don't do that, especially to kids - and when it comes to practicing defensive fighting, there should be consent involved - and no cornering. From what I hear, anyway, drilling some of the more difficult self-defense moves means that those will be more effective even if you are cornered at some point, and that's why normal martial arts - the non-abusive kind - is taught that way.
I didn’t even realize that I had disordered eating until I started watching you. You’re fixing me and I didn’t even know I had to be fixed. I am so glad I found you and your cookbook!
Abbey Sharp is life! 🙌🏼 her videos have taught me how to both look for ways to make more satisfying meals and also how NOT to shame myself. She’s helping me unlock years of disordered binge eating and I feel like a new me!
There is a cookbook as well? Uu, nice 👌 need to check it out
@@workwithme. amzn.to/2YTW78k
Yank you so much, I’m so glad my videos and cookbook are helpful for you ❤️
Same!
The information from Jillian is fine, general in fact, the problem is that she serves it up dripping in a " come on people this is basic information". To me, hearing Abby with zero judgement is much more conducive to learning info about trying a healthier choice. I love how Abby helps us learn to tailor our nutrition around living our lives instead of the opposite. Thank you Abby.
Jillian reeks of ego. Not a good personality trait.
i don't get it people get mad at jillian for telling the truth EVEN YOU ADMIT IT why do people prefer it buttered up instead of straight forward
@@grandiose5720 I don't get it either. I mean, I guess she has a bad rep for The Biggest Loser, but I really felt this video was just reading way too hard into it. Jillian seems like she's achieved a heathy balance for herself.
Part 2 please!!! I feel that this needs more time to fully unpack Jillian’s condescending ways of fitness and nutrition that are in actuality promoting over exercising and anorexic behaviors. Even in her older workout videos she is always talking about “gross fat” in the abdomen and “if you don’t want to be fat then don’t stop”. Hearing that while working out to her videos when I was in highschool was what fueled my ED and “revenge body” mentality. I’m so glad that you Abbey are calling out all the diet culture bs and being a fresh voice of reason!
I’m so sorry for your experience. It is definitely on my list to make a part 2! So glad you enjoyed the video 😊
I’m so sorry Alyssa that you had that experience but you’re not alone… I would literally kill myself doing her workouts in my younger days as well shedding fat I didn’t have but “saw”… she’s low-key just awful and I’m hoping for a part 2 as well
Ditto to part 2!
I agree--part two, Abbey, PLEASE! It was such a relief to hear your practical, kind, reasonable but firmly critical response to Gillian, whose face and voice absolutely terrorize me even on video after growing up watching her berate so many people. You are right on the mark with everything you pointed out here, and for those of us whose anxieties and food issues have only been exacerbated by Gillian and her impact on popular culture, you offer a healing voice. Thank you!
Agreed! I got hooked on Team Body Project workout because of their inclusivity and positivity. Daniel and Alex feature people of all different sizes in their workouts and never use negative language about weight as motivation in their workouts. Prior to that I was used to CZcams fitness instructors using fat shaming terminology to motivate people during a workout. It just made me feel too uncomfortable to enjoy a workout. Jillian Michaels has helped normalise a lot of toxic language about weight and food. It’s not helpful for anyone on a fitness and/or wellness journey.
“Just spend your family’s monthly food budget on one week of organic food for yourself and tell your infant to put his own damn self to bed because mama needs that 8 hours of sleep. Easy.” - Jillian, if I was her client
😂😫 true!
She adds the “organic” modifier to foods some might consider “bad”, like it’s a holy incantation. She doesn’t feel the need to specify whether the fruits and vegetables are organic.
Good spot! I didn't notice this at first
Jillian Michaels seems scary, if she was my trainer or dietitian , i’d probably go once start crying and never go back. And the fitness plan on biggest looser did not seem beginners friendly. They should have started with light weights, walking, yoga , strench and work there way up.
Jillian is the stereotypical “tough” trainer. Which is disappointing because that’s been shown to be less effective than a trainer that listens and respects their clients. It’s an outdated strategy and luckily I see the industry becoming more understanding that being understanding and encouraging maintainable fitness behaviors is better in the long run.
I'd get mad, cry, yell at her, and never ever go back. I'd probably buy way too much food and stress eat at home. I can't stand her.
I agree all that did was humiliate them and made working out so unenjoyable, but hey it made good tv… 😕
I hated that show so much… the utter abuse made me want to 🤛 her through my TV… she’s just the worst
I know 😫😫
As an Irish person (from a farming family), I find it so unbelievably weird that in North America you've to define dairy/beef products as 'grass fed' because it's not the norm there. So weird that you don't allow cattle to eat their natural food source which their stomachs have evolved to digest...
Yeah, it is weird.
I know 😫
It's so weird that you refer to cows as beef, instead of cows. They are beautiful animals. So vulnerable and deserving of living out their lives and dying of natural causes.
It's certainly weird and sad. The Irish standards for meat are much higher than in America. The norm in America is the grain fed where grass fed is much more expensive.
And the milk and butter taste so much better in Ireland. You can really tell the difference.
I ate Halloween Oreos for a snack with tea 10 minutes ago. Complete with orange food coloring. They were delicious 10/10 would do again
This sounds amazing
Kinda random, but Oreos has a Carmel brownie Oreo with a little of salt on the top… 100% recommend if you can find them!
I just had vanilla bourbon's, string cheese, and vanilla coke. No regrets.
The Carrot Cake Oreos are spectacular too :P
@@mayprohaska3234 I SOOO agree! They're like a slightly *elevated* Oreo.
but also raise your hand if you’ve been personally victimized by Jillian Michaels 30 Day Shred 😩
I tried it once and my knees said no thanks 😩🤣
😫😫
I tore the meniscus in my left knee doing her 30 day shred. Weeks of pain, steroid injections in my knee, and walking on crutches were my “reward” for her training techniques.
I never got past the first week because I couldn't walk after the second day. I don't have time for that lol.
Oh man, 🙋♀️ 😮💨
I think people need to move to a farm or raise a garden and only eat seasonal produce if they are going to keep worrying a about every little ingredient. Once I went on a blind date with a guy who was happy enough to order pizza, but then gave the waitress a lecture about the chemicals in soda. When we left the restaurant he started asking whether I used organic shampoo. Since he “forgot” his wallet and I had to pay for the date, I forgot to call him back.
Oh no! 😫
I’m sorry about your date and I hope now you’re having pizza with nicer people
@@TheRightersblock It was a long time ago, and I laugh at the experience now. It’s just an example about how obsessive organic people cherry pick what they can consume.
I can easily sum him up in 2 words.....EWWWW and the 2nd word...YUCK!!!!.... I'm sure you agree, nice escape Hun👍👍👍🏆👑
@@mollybrolly4717 Yes he probably is still scoring free meals while pretending to be a purist :)
As a university student studying ecology, who's taken some courses discussing agriculture and ecoculture I feel the need to say (that at least in the US) the reason to eat organic has absolutely everything to do with sustainable agriculture practices and nothing to do with organic foods being any "healthier" for you. For my personal sustainability goals, this means I try to buy organic versions of the food I don't already grow myself. That being said, I fully recognize that organic foods are often times more expensive and therefore less accessible. If you can't afford organic, or even if you just don't want to eat it- you do you! I would also loooove to see Abbey do a deep dive into this, even though I know agricultural practices aren't exactly your forte!
Thank you for sharing this information! I can definitely put it on my list to do a video about this 😊
Yes!!! If I could afford organic food, I would totally buy it solely for the reason of it potentially being better for the environment because I'm all for that! Unfortunately where I live organic food is easily double the price of conventional so it's not really an option 😭
Thanks for pointing this out. I tend to skip organic because I'm cheap and figure non-organic is good enough for me. Reframing it as a bit of extra money to contribute to a healthier local ecology, well I am 100% down to pay for that. I'm lucky to live in a farming area, time to make some organic farmer buddies.
Also, buying from local small-scale farmers allows you to be familiar with their practices, so even if you aren't getting a USDA label, you know you are getting a good product. Or yeah, growing your own, even if your outdoor space is limited to a balcony.
I feel so dumb right now - I thought that organic meant that the food has less pesticides sprayed onto them? 🤦🏻♀️
I used to do one of her workout videos all the time about ten years ago. My mom kept it, so I decided to try it again about a year ago. I couldn't get through it. And it wasn't because I was in worse shape than before. My mindset and the way I think about my body had just changed so drastically that I couldn't stand her yelling and demeaning comments.
Wow! I completely understand
Omg, I thought it was just me. I could not get through her workouts. My mind is in such a different place that listening to her annoys me.
@@lavenderteal8485 I have only one old hiit workout that I still do, but she's quite joyful there lol
Some people do respond this tough love but it isn’t for everyone. Thank goodness there are so many options today.
@@stanislavaivanova6967 lol. I need to donate my old dvd's of her. Maybe some people like her more aggressive approach. It just doesn't work for me in this place in my life.
I can’t watch this one because Jillian is a huge trigger for me. Watching the biggest loser fed into my bulimia and anorexia in a huge way. Super glad you’re unpacking her! Thanks for everything you do, Abbey!
I totally understand, I’m sorry this is triggering for you! So glad you find my videos helpful 😊
Same! I used to be a huge Jillian Michaels fanatic. For years, I read her books, did all her workout videos, and listened to her podcast. It only led to me sobbing on the bathroom floor because I couldn't get under 117 lbs and then cutting out my "treat" (a sugar-free egg protein smoothie, FFS), and adding an extra hour of exercise onto each workout. Took a looooooooot of therapy to undo the damage I let that woman do to me.
@@megreads824 sorry you had to go through this
Ugh it’s horrible…I watched the biggest loser from when I was maybe 5 years old because I’ve been obese since I was 3. I never really thought to label it that way, but you’re right, she is a trigger. The biggest loser and just dieticians in general are that for me as well simply because seeing one always meant being shamed or not being able to enjoy food or eat when I was hungry for months afterwards. Um…is this what a trigger is? Sorry if I’m using it incorrectly.
@@megreads824how did she do that to you just by sharing nutrition and fitness advice that you chose to follow?
It's hard to break the "good food bad food" language when that's something that's instilled in us at such a young age
I completely understand. I hope my videos are helpful for you at all for unlearning this!
Jillian Michaels aided in my anorexia in high school. Now I am in no way blaming her for my choices, as I was solely responsible for my actions, but I was much less knowledgeable and so easily susceptible to molding. I watched her on Biggest Loser and followed her on all her talk show appearances, and "learned" a lot from her. Again, not her responsibility, and gossip magazines were a giant part of my "education" as well. But her name, face and voice will forever be embedded in my mind.
Really really proud of myself for moving so far away from her, as well as my former lifestyle.
In terms of making shorter videos, Abbey please don't! I love the longer length videos!
When I was heavily overweight in university and wanted a good quick workout, I read great things about 30-day shred and bought it to use. The shaming rhetoric and constant toxicity were enough to turn me off of fitness until I was 26 when I started my continued health journey. Shame does nothing for anyone, and the fact that Gillian monetized her cruelty speaks a lot about our society’s judgment on bodies that’s very unfortunate.
just comments about your own body and feeling ugly, gross does not help you stop binge-eating. I stopped hanging out with few friends who made disparaging comments about my body. I already have a mirror at home, I don’t need people reminding me how gross I am. And I feel better alone
Abbey: "and not the good big O we really like"
Me, clueless: "......Oreos?"
I get it now though 🤣
Love this!!
And that Abbey said that.
Your comment killed me! 😂😂😂 I love that your mind went to Oreos! But like... I'll accept the big o as Oreos! 😂
@@perfectlyimperfect2368 it definitely says a lot about me as a person lol To be fair, I experience the Oreos "O" more often 🤣
I can assure you if a person in a ‘larger body’ ate a bite of their child’s Mac &Cheese a lot of people would be critical and would be happy to tell them. Jillian knows this because she is critical of anyone in a larger body.
Wild salmon mean loads of other fish getting killed, either accidentally caught in the net or tiny fish who get scared and hide in the salmon's gills. Farmed salmon are fed wild caught fish.
If you live on this planet, the ecosystem's health has to be taken into account when you think about the health risks of eating a food, right?
Aquaculture is the way to go
If you dive even deeper, those companies she mentioned that promote sustainability for wild caught fish, none of them are doing anything to actually SUSTAIN the salmon population. It’s sad.
@@rebw5937 They are fed wild caught fish, they still deplete fish in the ocean and contribute to overfishing
As a personal trainer, we dont claim her.
😂
Samee!
We don't claim her 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Good for you. Fat people get shamed and or in difficulty. Adding shame. How is that sane, healthy or helpful?
The sad part is that the show is entirely based on that. Making fitness a competition filled with taking a lot of supplements, starving oneself, and working out until you're so sore that you cannot do much else. They have reached out to many of the other fitness people I follow, and their practices are completely shady. The key to lasting fitness that goes beyond a year or more is to receive proper nutrition (supplements are to SUPPLEMENT not replace regular food), exercise that helps you be consistent in reaching your goals, and your calorie intake should reflect your current goals
For sure. It is very upsetting
As a trainer, I don’t claim this behaviour
Okayyyy the edits!!😂😂 I’m a doctor and you’re helping me understand nutrition so much. Thank you!
I’m so glad my videos are helpful, thank you!
Seriously whoever you have adding in the memes… the references in this WERE SO GOOD.
Thank you, so glad you enjoyed them!
Generally they are, but I felt so sad for that person passing out in the supermarket. was really surprised that she put that person's suffering in for a cheap laugh.
Thank you for mentioning her attitude towards those of us in larger bodies. Her "just do this" attitude reminds me of when I went to the doctor and his tip for me was to stop drinking soda, and then was condescending and didn't believe me when I said I don't drink soda regularly.
I'm glad that part was helpful
Same thing for me. 😭 One day, I had to see a gynaecologist for an emergency appointment. At the end of the appointment, the gynaecologist took my by the shoulders and told me how much to eat, what I should eat and how to eat in a condescending tone while saying I shouldn’t eat too much. I literally hadn’t had anything in 24hrs that day prior to the morning appointment and ate less that 500 calories 7 days before the appointment itself. My depression and trauma related anxiety disorder were high-functioning at that time and I couldn’t eat more than one meal a day. I physically and emotionally couldn’t. Cooking was a hassle. And to top it off, he made me think I shouldn’t eat anything at all that day, too. I had a cup noodles portion a day for a week. I was like: “He’s right… I shouldn’t be eating bad food.” It was a time when the strength in my body would leave me, my blood pressure would be terrible and my heart started acting up. I drank water whenever I could and had little food. But, even drinking wouldn’t work often times and I’d be dehydrated. I’d become nauseous and got frequent headaches. This psychological low lasted for a month (started roughly two months before that but I “functioned”) and I tried to eat at least two meals a day, but that one week was especially horrible and exhausting. I already had trauma from a previous gynaecologist I’ve visited a few years back and that gynaecologist I’m talking about triggered me. I couldn’t even eat for 8hrs after the appointment was finished. So, I hadn’t had food in literal 36 hours at this point. My body was breaking down and I had to sleep after the appointment. I cried because the female gynaecologist I’ve seen before in the same practice was on vacation and I saw a substitute male doctor. I should’ve waited for the other doctor to come back but I was scared since I have PCOS and my period wouldn’t come although I’m on hormonal therapy… But now, I realise my abdominal pain and lack of period was due to insufficient nutrients and lack of movement. I wasn’t taking care of myself. Don’t let other people belittle you. Diet and physical exercise are individual processes for everyone.
@@anjie3871 I'm so sorry to hear that you experienced this 🙈😢
How are you now? It sounds like you may have had REDS (relative energy deficiency syndrome)
May I also suggest looking into keto and intermittent fasting. Processed carbs and sugar (even a little) cause a lot of trouble for some people. Have a look dr Jason Fung and his videos. And redefining strength on YT - Cori is a lovely instructor that actually cares about people's progress
@@mb8219 I’m doing all right, thanks for asking. I’m eating when I feel hungry and eat whatever I like (given it’s something that doesn’t mess up my hormones or elevates my IBS and PCOS). I don’t wanna restrict or find any problem with my diet as it is right now. As I said, my psychological disorders were high functioning. As aforementioned in my text, I didn’t specify a time frame. It was a few months ago, it isn’t recent. I try to balance out my meals as much as I can. Keto and intermittent fasting does not work for me given my natural metabolism, IBS, PCOS, hunger cues and intake of daily prescribed medicine. If you’d read the text I wrote again, I was only eating like this for a week. It isn’t my usual diet. I don’t want to do any self-diagnose myself on the internet if a doctor hasn’t said mentioned anything like this to me in real life.
Genuinely doctors don’t believe you when you say you don’t drink soda or fruit juices or diluting juice or add sugar to anything. I literally only keep granulated sugar in the house to add to maybe twice a year baking or sour tomato-based sauces, I buy a 1kg bag every couple of years.
I don’t drink my calories, I only drink black coffee, tea & water, don’t eat sugary cereals etc. & guess what? I still have insulin resistance & am still “fat”.
I’m so over demonizing food and that’s why I love your videos. It makes me want to make healthier choices while still eating what I love. What could be better for mind and body? Thank you!
Totally! So glad you enjoy the videos 😊
Thank you for calling out the economically privileged viewpoint of Jillian's video. Organic this, organic that is just not economically possible for a significant percentage of the population. The inability to afford a certain kind of food should not be a moral failing. A bite of mac and cheese is just that. The shame faced admission that she likes peanut butter seems to come from the idea that almond butter is more sophisticated--only kids and 'plebs' would like peanut butter! There's an underlying tone of classism in this "common sense " that bothers me.
Absolutely! I’m glad this point was helpful
Good points, but both Walmart and Costco sell cheap organic food. A week's worth of organic greens from Costco costs less than a Whopper. Heck, it costs less than an egg, cheese, and "protein" ( your choice of) bagel sandwich at any place I can find in my city. If I had to eat on practically nothing, I'd be down to organic veggies, beans, rice, pasta, and pasta sauce from Costco. I'd be miserable, mind, because I'd miss, well, tons of flavors and foods, but I wouldn't starve.
Well, except for the bread. They have cheap organic flour and sugar, too. Not the healthiest, because it's just plain unbleached white all purpose, but it's amazing how tasty your own bread can be. Especially fresh.
Eggs, meat, dairy, though, that does get mad expensive. Especially if you add in grass-fed. That said, everything I read says the planet needs us to eat less meat. And I do know lots of pretty awful stuff about the three big meat industries.
@@kobaltkween The fuck are you talking about. I went to a Walmart and shopped organically before. It cost almost a hundred dollars just to keep the house stalked for a week. Either something is off with your numbers are the people at McDonald’s are ripping you off.
Plus you aren’t counting in food desert where people don’t have Walmart’s or cosco. Or any sort of grocery stores to go too. They have to live on fast food or any place close enough to keep family fed. This is very much a classism thing.
@@kobaltkween Bringing Costco as an example…yup, you’re privileged.
@@LylyHec How so? Membership is about $50 a year. Even Cricket costs more per month. If by privileged you mean I'm not unhoused and have a vehicle that runs, sure. And I'm very thankful for that. But if I had to eat on $50 a week or less, I could do it at Costco. That's not privilege. And just to be clear, I've lived off dollar store food before. It's more expensive. _Much_ more expensive.
I will forever love Jillian for changing my attitude about exercise and I think she has the right idea about how to approach it. Her dvds definitely got me in great shape. Her food plans always seemed dogmatic though so I never really did them. I’m found it funny she doesn’t like almond butter either since I tried it for her 😂. Her making the cut book is a lot more respectful of how difficult it is to lose the last 10. I’m curious as to what approach you actually recommend
I love you so much. My relationship with food has changed SO much since watching you. I don’t binge much anymore because I’m getting over the guilt of eating “bad” foods. I just remind myself to grab something WITH it to balance it out.
I’m so glad my videos have been helpful for you ❤️
As someone who had anorexia nervosa as a teenager... Jillian's approach has A LOT of red flags. If I go out to eat (if ever because yay for the pandemic and anxiety because of it), I personally never really spend a long time thinking about what I'll order any more. When I did have anorexia, I would spend hours upon hours pondering over what to eat, and if it was a chain, I'd be sure to Google the establishment, scan through their menu, calories, and macros.
It's debilitating. And it must be super debilitating for Jillian herself, her family, everyone involved. Always having to be in control is not freeing in the least, not at all. You'd think you'd be free because you're at the wheel (or so you think) but it's the polar opposite. It's like making your own prison cell, locking it, keeping the key with you, and refusing to get out.
It's so much more freeing when you can just live in the moment, enjoy the company of those around you and mindfully savour every bite of a meal you love because it brings you happiness. It's things like that that make life worth living.
Absolutely. Thank you so much for sharing your experience with this
Condescending. Condescension. That is the perfect description of what I've always felt this woman epitomizes.
😫😫
I absolutely can't stand her. She comes across as so arrogant. The fact that she was part of The biggest loser worry about people who put on severely restricted calorie intake and exercise just about to death weighing as much as they did. And from what I've seen most of those people put the weight back on again.
I actually watched Jillian’s video on menopause. She made it seem so easy to lose weight and keep it off while going through it. My first thought after watching “um obviously she hasn’t gone through it yet”. When it’s her time, I got a feeling 1. She may disappear from social media for a minute or 2. She may change her tune and become more Empathetic to us struggling to gain control.
@@FitforFiftyish I totally agree. Menopause totally sucks. I feel like I just smell food and I gain weight I have had to make some big changes in my diet to just maintain my weight let alone losing any. I find going higher protein low carb medium healthy fats works well. And I do a little bit of intermittent fasting so I eat my breakfast late and my dinner is finished at 6:00 p.m. . I cycle most days and if I don't the wait will not move one centimeter. I have noticed a menopause means you also have a longer recovery time after doing exercise. Some woman experience muscle weakness which comes with age I've always been very strong physically but I can't say I have lost some of that strength purely due to menopause. I gain weight on my tummy which used to be as flat as a pancake. Menopause also triggered an autoimmune condition in me. Yeah so I don't take advice from women or men who have never been through menopause. I follow a nice lady on CZcams who's at the age of menopause who looks fantastic and she does promote more of a low carb lifestyle because she's realized that's what happens as you age you don't metabolize the carbs as efficiently. In fact she stated that when your estrogen drops you automatically get a little bit more insulin resistant. So you need to adjust the carbs which sucks cuz I like them. Best of luck to you please excuse my typing I'm actually speaking and with an accent and it does not always recognize what I'm saying.
@@sylviaking8866 thank you for that. I need all the help and info I can get then, sort it out, experiment and do what works for me. I’ve binged Paula B she has great menopause help.
I went low carb zero sugar for 30 days. One thing is for sure sugarless coffee is disgusting to me. And I need oatmeal potatoes and rice in my life.
I’ve been exercising regularly for over 20 years distance running, biking weight training etc but lately I may walk 3-4x a week for 40 mins. Some weeks I’m on my couch. Abbey’s channel is teaching me…”and that’s ok” 🤗 Chill.
something I do want to point out about the whole "organic" thing. If you can afford to buy organic, you should, because conventional pesticides in runoff water (along with fertilizers) are making marine mammals like sea lions and elephant seals very sick. I volunteer at a marine mammal rescue that is contracted with state and federal governments to conduct research; when an animal dies in our care, we perform an autopsy, and pesticides from farming are causing diseases in these mammals. we tell the public it's one of the ways you can help preserve marine life, buying organic. The other thing you can do is to reduce your use of single-use plastic as much as possible because the marine mammals can swallow it and it makes them sick.
The problem with “organic” is that unless you know the individual farms very well, they could still be using loads of pesticides that aren’t on the banned list. Many of the pesticides that organic farms are able to use while still calling themselves organic, are studied less well and have the potential to be more harmful than banned ones. I agree with you though, that it’s good if you can find farms that are actually using more natural methods rather than polluting. But then we have the other problem regarding yield and cost. I’m really hoping that in the future we can find sustainable ways to produce food at scale that is healthy for the environment and economically viable to feed everyone on the planet.
Thank you for sharing this information!
Thanks for clarifying too that "organic" refers to pesticide use and not nutrition. So many people are confused when I try to talk to them about the "dirty dozen" and "clean fifteen" in this context when asking if organic is "better" than regular produce.
Her obsession with everything being “organic and grass-fed” strikes me as pretty orthorexic
It is definitely concerning
Especially as she is so often using it to justify choices that feel shameful to her. Like the mac and cheese.
I think, though, it's important not to classify others' behavior as pathological just because it may seem more rigid than average. If it is not distressing and/or dysfunctional (e.g., doesn't have negative impacts on health or quality of life), even though it may be less "normal" doesn't deem it pathological.
Jillian also needs to concern how portraying this food this way makes it seem very privileged. Not everyone can afford grass fed and organic produce or meat.
Just because someone has different food preferences than you do, it doesn't mean they have a "disroder." Some people are just really invested in their health.
She helped me lose about 70 pounds !! I loved her workouts, but I ignored her diet advice ! I ate less treats (but still enjoyed them now and then), ate far more fruits and vegetables, and just tried to eat healthier overall.
Same! I lost over 80 pounds doing her workouts and eating healthier. I personally love her for her harshness but I understand she's not for everyone!
"Are you gonna tell her or am I?" Hahah, made me actually chuckle out loud. Lets all tell her 😄
😂😂
This is my favorite video yet! You just took so much of what has made me feel like a failure and put it into perspective. I really needed to hear all of this! Thank you!
the editing on this is cracking me up 😂 I lost it at peanut butter baby
Peanut butter is good. I don't even like almond butter, not sure what the big hype--unless you're allergic of course.
“Not the big O we really like- Abbey Sharp 2021 😂
😂😂
I remember meeting her unexpectedly in New York probably over 5 years ago now, she was actually really approachable and down to earth. Thought I’d be super awkward but she’s easy to have a chat with. She’s also way smaller than I thought she would be in stature haha.
That’s nice to hear bc she looks like she’s miserable and seems like she wouldn’t be nice. I’m glad my first impression of her from curated videos isn’t necessarily true.
I’ve heard she’s a sweetheart people read her wrong in her videos because she’s got a strong front I really like her tbh and I can tell id like her in person regardless of peoples negative view of her
@@skylerpresley8223 Yeah I think people have a lot of preconceived ideas of who she is.
She was just very sweet and very funny actually haha.
@@MurisaD1412 Definitely not a miserable person in my experience, far from it :)
The editing and clips in this are so good, what a classic! Abbey - love your work as always!
I’m soo impressed with how much research and thought you put into your videos! They are incredible and can be really eye opening for people who struggle with their eating, you’re changing the narrative!
I used to do her workouts and really liked them, but there was one dvd I had where she said “after you do this workout don’t go ruin it by eating pizza!” It always annoyed me because I’m like, ok so if I go eat pizza after this all the muscles I worked will reverse their work? The endurance I built will up and leave? She talked like life was all about calories in vs calories out but exercise is SO much more than that!
Oh wow, I wouldn’t like that either! Absolutely
Well if you do go binge on a pizza or fast-food afterwards, because working out makes you hungry it's definitely not putting your mindset at the right place to loose weight... I don't see anything wrong with that.
@@1000OtherFoxes the point is that there are other reason to exercise besides losing weight. FFFFs
@@brandywillis3998 lol...of course but just be honest with yourself, majority of us want to get in shape and that include weight loss most of the time. When people bought her best seller workout called "30 days shred" it's not to just workout for nothing
I can’t wait to hear more on of your expertise and perspective on this video. Your advice and insight have been incredibly helpful for me to learn more about nutrition.
Thank you, I hope you found it helpful!
I would love to see a full video breaking down the difference between organic and non when it comes to things outside of nutrition like the treatment of animals, the planet, and workers! 💕
Abbey, you are the best! I’ve changed my internal dialogue about food a lot since watching you. Instead of focusing on what I can take away from my diet, I think about what can I add that is nutritionally dense. I’ve tried a lot of new to me foods as well. I have lost over 100 pounds with an entire medical multidisciplinary team helping me but I find your content to be more helpful. This RN thanks you!
When you're a millionaire like Jillian Michaels, grass fed, grass finished beef is just a home delivery (or personal assistant trip to the store) away. But I know her style appeals to all the wanna be rich on social media.
Love your channel! This is where it’s important to understand everyone’s expertise area. Jillian is a fitness person.. I think everything for her comes down to the aesthetic goal… while all good dieticians including Abby (and my sister 😊) will always focus on eating well-balanced meals and understanding that people need to have a good relationship with food that fits into a HAPPY lifestyle.
Thank you for sharing your perspective!
I suffered with orthorexia through my teens and early 20s, and in the years since, my strategy to avoid falling back into those habits have pretty much been "do not think about my diet or regular exercise at all" lol. I've been struggling with knowing that I want to live a healthier lifestyle but being afraid to make changes and potentially fall back into old disordered eating and exercise habits. Your channel has really helped me learn about nutrition and health in a way that feels good and safe to me, and while I'm not all the way there yet, the new knowledge I have from watching your channel makes thinking about my own health and diet feel a lot less scary :) Thanks Abbey!
Thank you for sharing. I'm so glad my channel has been helpful for you ❤
“Elitist flex” 🤣
Love you you’re the best! The knowledge, edits, and observations are amazing. Thankyou :)
Hey Abbey... I'm sure you know that I reached out to have you on my podcast to discuss? But you dodged. Why don't you come on and we can debate all this?
Team Jillian rocks, you go girl!
When people say “food has less chemicals” and all food is chemicals 😂
😂 yup!
As an actual chemist, this bs enrages me. Water is a chemical, it doesn’t mean it’s poison (although it also can be if you over-drink it! Water toxicity is real.)
There’s a saying that ‘the dose equals the poison’ & that’s true of almost anything. Foods by themselves are not “poison”.
Also, I used to love her. I am healthier mentally now & I don’t want to be like her, I don’t want to think like her or look like her if it means having this food fear mentality & “cheat food” mindset.
ugh, i mean I know this isn't specific to Jillian Michaels, but i hate the way people demonise farmed fish
It is a sustained controlled way to ensure our oceans maintian biodiversity and stops over fishing!
-Australia has some pretty awesome sustainable fish farms and has contributed to the global studies on this
Thank you Abbey for being sensible and showing research/institutions that back up the sustainability of farmed fish
Thank you for the information!
Lots of downsides for the environment when it comes to fish farms. They are breeding grounds for disease. If they are based in a natural source of water it can ruin ecosystems. The ones in the tanks have their downside in that the fish themselves are even more diseased and therefore treated with a ton of medicine and chemicals. Find out the true source of your fish and meat and reduce the amount you consume. But there is no perfect way to farm or harvest animals that leaves no damage on the scale of the population we have now.
If you want to eat fish that swim around in their own feces and bacteria thats on you....I'll stick with wild caught
@@TheRolexseller it is true that you have to be careful about where the fish farms are located but Australia is leading the way in sustainable tuna farming and a massive part of that is def being responsible for the ecosystems and the health of the farmed fish as well so i totally agree with you about doing careful research as irresponsible farms can do so much damage so its def a careful balance that needs to be maintained
@@jasontaylor8283 lmao wild catch swim in their own waste too
You have changed my opinion and relationship with food for the better. I never realized that I had disordered eating until I started watching your videos. I finally realized why my unrealistic diets never worked. Thank you for helping me change my thought process when it comes to food. I no longer feel guilty for eating foods I used to categorize as bad. I honestly feel like I’m finally nourishing my body and intuitively eating. So happy to rid myself of that all or nothing dieting mentality!
Abby, just wanted to pop in and say your editing is really nice, light hearted and fun. I like the change :)
If in those clips it was her screaming to people in order to work out more, yes we need a part two to establish maybe with a psychologist that WE DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE RUDE TO PEOPLE WHO HAPPEN TO WEIGH MORE THAN US. Jeez...there are dangerous trainers out there!
I know right 😫
YASSSS!!! I have been waiting a video on Jillian Michaels… I remember when I used to do her workouts and thought how great she looked, except she pushed her BS “diets” and “detoxes”… not to mention her abuse on the Biggest Loser, her fatphobic rhetoric, and her ableism…
I’m here for it…
I hope you found the review helpful!
@@AbbeysKitchen super helpful… she’s just as vapid and shallow as ever 😪😪
I've been watching your videos for weeks now and I feel so much smarter about food!! I've been able to make better changes to my own diet to better suit my goals! Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and making it so entertaining and fun to watch! You're awesome Abbey!!!
I’m so glad my videos have been helpful for you! ❤️
Good review!! Lots to unpack. I particularly love your little video clip inserts!! They make me laugh out loud! Keep the content coming.
whoaaaa I totally forgot about Jillian Michaels!! I used to follow her advice religiously and then I realized it was so so unhealthy for my mindset and affected my progress in ED recovery
Same here, she triggered my ED big time 🤕
@@justinec1707 I hope you’re doing well now!!!
Abbey you've helped me alot. I was always trying to lose weight until I learnt the difference between weight loss and fat loss. Your whole approach on healthy food habits is amazing... not me fangirling ferociously 😂🤭
Your videos had been truly eye opening to me, I didn't realize my relationship with food was that bad until a couple years ago and that how I look physically was that important to me. Which is not a bad thing but sometime it can come at the price of neglecting it. The thing about this video is that everything you said I knew yet never really put that much thought. I grew up watching the biggest loser and the time where I watch it like there was no tomorrow was when I had cancer. The quote of "If you haven't puked or fainted means that your body can still go". I followed it , I tell myself that once I was done I was going to recuperate my body back and be healthy. And although at one point it helped me, once I started therapy almost 5 years later I realize how toxic that behavior was because I didn't allowed myself to rest nor to feel ill. And the fact that during chemo was the healthiest I ever been yet I still needed to excuse my weight gained is so sad. Even now because of my stretch mark at doctor appointment that haven't read my medical history always thinks I was pregnant because of them and makes me feel so self conscious.
Anyway, just here to remind everybody who need it that your body weight doesn't necessarily goes hand in hand with your health. And that it's okay to take a break.
I love the funny clips you mix into your videos!! I look forward to watching more! Thanks for your sensible take on food!
Having salmon for dinner. it’s not organic, raised by woodland elves or blessed with pixie dust but it’s going to be delicious.
I hope you enjoyed it!
Haha!! I’ve been loving salmon lately too, with a sweet potato with butter and a big salad!
The editing - chef's kiss 💘
😊❤️
I love you, Abbey! Haha 😂 your videos always make me laugh but are also very educational. I enjoy your long videos 🙋🏻♀️ because every time you post one, I grab my headphones and my dog and we walk while we watch it!
Yes please give us a part 2! This was so validating!
On my list to do a part 2!
it's really scary to see Jillian shouting. if my trainer was like her, I would've changed my trainer to someone else
Thank you for posting this. I was really turned off by Jillian when she stated that she didn't want to get pregnant because she was scared that she would get fat and not be able to get her body back. I know that she has kids now so at least she gave herself 'permission' to have a baby but it was such a problematic and harmful statement to make.
She didn’t give birth I think her “partner” did...?
I recently started watching you and I love the fact that you talk about still being able to eat "processed foods" or "bad foods" as some people call it! I myself have made a big change in our diets here (the hubby, 2 kids and me). We eat fast food occasionally, we eat treats, we eat healthy ... so we eat balanced! I myself am on a weight loss journey and lost since the changes (4 months ago) 27 lbs. With keeping a balance I don't feel I'm missing out on anything. Between you, Greg Doucette and Nicole Collet's channel I have learned a lot about making the right food choices without depriving yourself! And the thing is ... my hubby and kids don't need to lose weight whatsoever and we all choose to eat the same things, which makes things so much easier. Thank you for the great advise you give out without judging the snot out of people! Love and respect Liz
Every time I feel myself slipping back into my ED habits, I come back and catch up on your vids and i don’t wanna say it fixes it buuuut, it certainly does put me back on track so thank you
I do not care for her at all! I saw a show where she was dragging a mom for her son being overweight. She had that poor mom in tears yelling at her instead of educating her. Ugh 🙄
I really think we need to move away from calling fat-shaming rhetoric "tough love." There is nothing loving about making statements that are not just unsupported by science, but are KNOWN to negatively impact people's health. Jillian has loudly and frequently bashed celebrities based solely on their size, regardless of their health habits.
Didn't know I needed this video in my life, but I am LIVING for it!
I would love a Part 2! I would love to see reaction videos on some of the Beachbody trainers. Autumn Calabrese, Shawn T, Joel Freeman, Sagi Kalev, etc. I really love your content and your ability to steer the district towards a healthier relationship with food.
I will put these people on my list to discuss! And I’m so glad my videos are helpful for you 😊
@@AbbeysKitchen a reply! Thank you! You made my day! 🙂
She really seemed anxious when she admitted she had a couple bites of Mac and cheese and pb 😓 I remember feeling upset over minor things like this and I highly empathize. It's a miserable place to be.
I recently discovered your channel, and you are so refreshing to watch. I wish I had someone lik you to listen to growing up. I feel like those of us who grew up in the 90's and early 2000's have such a distorted view of food and health, and it's so sad. Unfortunately, I watched The Biggest Loser growing up and I didn't realize until recently how much that show and the trainers distorted my thinking on the whole subject matter. Thank you for your videos and being informative, while also being respectful.
Great video!
I love Jillian for a lot of reasons, but you definitely nailed it about the condescending diet cutlery talk in this video.
I would love to see a part 2 related to supplements. She has a pretty intense supplement routine.
Definitely on my list to do a part 2!
Me watching this while happily eating my inorganic sweet chilli doritos with inorganic double cream plain yogurt and just being happy that I crushed my hunger with something I enjoy 🤗 all the best to Jillian!
Thanks to Aura for supporting me and my channel, and helping me to keep my calm and focus. I’d love for you to support Aura, Click aurahealth.io/abbeysharp21 started with Aura today for FREE and get 25% off your Aura membership.
Yes... to shorter videos😊
Review Breatharians! They cray cray
E: not sure how many are left due to their only lining on Light & Air starting back in the 80's . Fascinating dietary faction
I love your videos. You are so calming and non-judgmental. Wish I heard you when I was younger and all of my eating habits became so ingrained in my head.
I really value the realistic and down-to-earth information you give.
I can really overthink what I'm eating, and if I'm the most healthy I can be. It becomes joyless and exhausting.
Thank you Abbie 💜
Apologies - Abbey* 😊
Omg that little clip you stuck in when talking about the peanut butter 😂
😂😂
I used to LOVE Jillian. I had been able to make peace with her hard line diet talk because a lot of what she says has some evidence to back it up. The thing that made me give her less time is the fact that when it comes to other ways to maintain your health, she dances the line between science and pseudoscience and I can’t get behind that.
You make me smile with your little “clips” in between. I really love your blog!🙌👏👍
I’m so glad! ❤️
I am also a dietitian and new to your videos but I love them! Your approach to nutrition is similar to mine and these videos are really informative. I am hopeful for a future where food is not so stigmatized and divisive in society
Thank you! So glad you enjoy the videos 😊
This pain pill I took may have made me a little loopy, but these clips are on point today!!!
Thank you!
I so heard that as organic breastfed yogurt. I was like WTF??? :) Not everyone is in the social economic position to either have access to these things or be able to afford the extra expense.
Totally
I think it was *grassfed* not *breastfed* haha. But your point still stands. Not everyone can afford this. If you can afford fine, but recommending...
I haven’t watched the whole video, but isn’t it normal to recommend more humane products with often more nutrients? Like if you can afford it , you should! But you can’t force people to spend their monthly budget on food for a week. (If that is what she does further in the video, I’m sorry and your point stands)
I’m glad there are comments here with positive reviews of her workouts, because I’ve had the same experience. And her commentary in her more recent videos isn’t as problematic as the older ones. She’s getting better!
I have always liked her and her workouts have stood the test of time
I love you so much Abbey. you are just so amazing to listen to and have taught me so much and are really the realist nutrition youtuber ever
Thank you so much ❤️
Jillian has a really odd vibe. This felt like she was talking about her time in war not food. No joy, no fun.
😫😫
Right now, the biggest issue is that many people find *too* much joy in foods.
I know this video had a lot of important info but The video of Elon Musk smoking and then Abbey saying chain smoking was so unexpected and funny - it had me on the floor 😂😂 I just had to say something. Okay back to learning!
😂😂
I love seeing that other people feel the same way about Jillian that I do. I think it's also worth noting that Jillian's weight loss methods don't work! The majority of the contestants on The Biggest Loser, her claim to fame, gained all the weight back and then some and had permanently altered their metabolisms.
love this! and editing on point!
I've been waiting for this! A friend of mine adores her and I never got why. Her condescending tone and the fatphobic, ableist stuff she says make me so angry.
I totally understand!
I think there is a lot of self hate seeping through.
This was a hard one to watch, especially with all the "O" flexes--but super helpful at the same time!
I’m sorry if it was triggering for you!
Call me crazy but I like Jillian's no nonsense approach. She is not the one to coddle you. Some of us need that.
I've been neglecting my health and eating so much junk food. I've been watching your videos to get my brain into a better mindset with food. Listening to your tips
Peanut butter is great and perfectly healthy. Like if she's worried about it, she should get the "all natural" kind that doesn't have added sugar or stabilizers in it. (Which is what I get because it's just more satisfying for me personally.)
Anyway, I love watching your videos around mealtimes especially when I'm beating myself up about my food choices. Today I was torturing myself about whether I wanted to eat lunchable pizza or something healthier like fruit and yogurt for lunch, and your video came up and reminded me that... one lunchable PLUS a bowl of fruit yogurt is a valid meal.
that sounds Yum! I sometimes feel the same but it comes down to: If i dont eat it now I will eat it tomorrow so why deny myself?
I also love the 100% peanut butter. It tastes nuttier than the other really smooth kind that doesn't separate!
Unfortunately, peanut butter is full of mould and highly inflammatory omega-6s. It’s a killer but I love it. 🤷🏻♀️
Love love peanut butter! Well done on the lunch, I’m eating yoghurt and fruit now for an afternoon snack ☺️🙌