Turkey: Afghan Refugees Not Welcome I ARTE.tv Documentary

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 08. 2024
  • Almost 10 years ago, Turkey opened its doors wide to more than 3 million Syrian refugees. But for those Afghans who fled the Taliban to power this summer and are trying to cross into Turkey, the welcome couldn't be more different.
    Turkey: Afghan Refugees Not Welcome I ARTE.tv Documentary
    🗓 Available until the 09/11/2091
    ARTE.tv Documentary is here to tell you more about what’s going on in the world of culture, news and current affairs with powerful, refreshing and entertaining docs subtitled in English for our international fans.
    Discover a whole world on #ARTE.tv
    Subscribe to our CZcams channel: / @artetvdocumentary
    #Turkey #AfghanRefugees #Documentary

Komentáře • 349

  • @artetvdocumentary
    @artetvdocumentary  Před rokem

    WATCH next: Albania: A Shepherd's Life - czcams.com/video/vq0YikeUxmM/video.html

  • @mikeylejan8849
    @mikeylejan8849 Před rokem +28

    Afghans have a different mentality with Turks, Afghans should stay in Afghanistan since it fits closer with their mentality and psyche, Afghanistan is currently under Pashtunwali and Sharia.

  • @hoponasu2471
    @hoponasu2471 Před 2 lety +203

    enough is enough. Agree with turkey on this one.

    • @pretty-micky3737
      @pretty-micky3737 Před 2 lety +7

      Thank you our Muslim brothers. Shame on you.

    • @pretty-micky3737
      @pretty-micky3737 Před 2 lety +9

      @Hikmet Madanoğlu I’m sure Allah will be proud of you.

    • @tttt9131
      @tttt9131 Před 2 lety

      @@pretty-micky3737 What a peasant you are

    • @tevrenus77
      @tevrenus77 Před 2 lety +46

      Send my regards to Allah: Read my lips: Don’t come to Turkey, my brothers are Turkic regardless of religion

    • @gergingorunusluadam3798
      @gergingorunusluadam3798 Před 2 lety

      @@pretty-micky3737 there is no muslim brotherhood in turkey. Turkish people are secular. I don't care about your religion and Turkish people don't want to see you in our country. We are losing everything. Erdogan make turkey hell. Look at grecee! They protected their country. We were should do the same. But Erdogan will be gone soon and the refugees as well.

  • @niccoarcadia4179
    @niccoarcadia4179 Před rokem +70

    I visited Turkey in 2006 and again in 2022. What a big difference. Back then the city was prosperous, many jobs pay good. All children in school. Now: The cities are full so much that food is hard to find. Apartments for smallest is 200+ euros and the streets at night are too dangerous for women and children. Many children not in school on streets collecting trash, the sight of family hungry in squalor is shame. And the gov is leaning far right again. I pray for Turkey solve & survive this mass immigration problem.

    • @lilo7741
      @lilo7741 Před rokem

      its the idiot at the topic. erdogan who cannot close the borders. hes an islamic moron and wanted to use the migrants to have more leverage in the elections. and he one. hes the type of person who considers everything legit as long as the goal is okay. neither turkey nor europe has to have a mass migration problem. we have a leadership problem. the government is the problem.

    • @history_repeats8201
      @history_repeats8201 Před rokem

      This is what happens when a Turko-jihadi plan to destabilize Europe backfires. The MIT plan was to allow millions of moslems to come to Turkey visa-free and then enrich the Turkish mafia with the money of all those who will need to pay to cross to Europe. The plan also had provisions to train enough of these to be immigrants to be the fith column in Europe (especially in Germany). This plan assumed that Europeans are stupid. Then EU closed the borders and Turkey found itself with 15 million immigrants. Add to that a devastating earthquake and you have a recipe for a total disaster.

    • @brotha5
      @brotha5 Před rokem +2

      As a turk he is spitting facts

    • @matrixtrollmarine
      @matrixtrollmarine Před 11 měsíci

      seconded@@brotha5

  • @sassimaus2
    @sassimaus2 Před 2 lety +79

    What I don’t understand is why there are only male afghan refugees? Where are the women?

    • @fehmieneskirazci8010
      @fehmieneskirazci8010 Před 2 lety +28

      They are coming invade Türkiye

    • @cemo3292
      @cemo3292 Před 2 lety

      the same groups only young male arabs and afghans they are fleeing letting their wifes at home no balls to fight their wars

    • @abrahamlincoln6704
      @abrahamlincoln6704 Před rokem

      They will breed with Turkish women to produce new form of Taliban

    • @misscoutts6193
      @misscoutts6193 Před rokem +4

      Fleeing from conscription.

    • @raafeyplayz7015
      @raafeyplayz7015 Před rokem

      @@misscoutts6193bro said conscription like he knows what’s happening in Afghanistan 😂

  • @mercow1242
    @mercow1242 Před 2 lety +78

    Afghans must save their own country. Get out! Let the sharia rule you.

    • @cemo3292
      @cemo3292 Před 2 lety +18

      same for the Syrians

    • @kabdul9208
      @kabdul9208 Před rokem +3

      @MassudNRWWhat about your countries were pay billion to Arab fighters in 1980s so come in Afghanistan so Soviet Union doesn’t get powerful! While Afghan people started accept them! In 1995 support Taliban and in 2000s killed millions of Afghans by bombing!

    • @ULASFLIX
      @ULASFLIX Před rokem

      @Massudno, we Turks don’t want them so they should go. To Europe or to Afghanistan. I don’t care. They must go

    • @livehealthy959
      @livehealthy959 Před rokem

      ​@Cemo you know nothing about what happened in syria, only syrians understand. Syrians tried fighting for their country, look at how many people died. Most governments supported assad regime and helped him stay in power against helpless with little to no support people

  • @letheravennest6789
    @letheravennest6789 Před 2 lety +40

    ohh germany can take them for human sake ^^

  • @terintiaflavius3349
    @terintiaflavius3349 Před 11 měsíci +5

    If he was a soldier he should go to the US and UK embassy and get the process going there. Turkey has taken in so many syrians they really can't take in a whole new group

  • @terintiaflavius3349
    @terintiaflavius3349 Před 11 měsíci +4

    All nations have the right to say who can live in their country.

  • @elizabethjarvie6077
    @elizabethjarvie6077 Před 11 měsíci +4

    Why don't they just stay in their own country Afghanistan?
    If they are beaten & not allowed asylum & told not to come across the border, I don't know ow why they're subjecting themselves to all that trouble and torture and grief

  • @g.m3399
    @g.m3399 Před 2 lety +35

    Stay home afhanensitan isn’t dangerous they just have a new government

    • @rahelmanijeh7767
      @rahelmanijeh7767 Před 2 lety

      Afghanistan is more then dangerous. The taliban let the people dying. They don't have food, no jobs, no freedom.

    • @kabdul9208
      @kabdul9208 Před rokem

      It’s the most dangerous in the whole world! Check it yourself just go online

  • @Nat-Con
    @Nat-Con Před rokem +5

    Considering how many afghans have arrived in turkey, in a few years everyone will look like genghis khan 😂

    • @yo2trader539
      @yo2trader539 Před rokem +5

      Original Turks are from the Mongolian Steppe.

    • @kimkardashiansdaddy2744
      @kimkardashiansdaddy2744 Před rokem +1

      no they are not, cringe refugee@@yo2trader539

    • @matrixtrollmarine
      @matrixtrollmarine Před 11 měsíci

      in mentality yes.. i long for those days where muslim blood will flow like river

    • @elhamhemat572
      @elhamhemat572 Před 8 měsíci +1

      lol, the majority of afghans are Iranic (Aryan) while Turks originated from east Asia and are Mongolian cousins lol.

    • @Nat-Con
      @Nat-Con Před 8 měsíci

      @@elhamhemat572 lol if they are Aryans why are they always begging for asylum?

  • @karazipkaKRZP
    @karazipkaKRZP Před 2 lety +62

    Germany and France always ready to host you dear Afghan brothers. Come here :)

    • @SadokiKojiro
      @SadokiKojiro Před 2 lety +25

      Bro u dont want this

    • @69socialmedia97
      @69socialmedia97 Před 2 lety +15

      Take it more and more.We can sent more and more.Take all of them

    • @dancercoffin6868
      @dancercoffin6868 Před 2 lety +39

      as a turk.
      Don't do it unless You want a small middle east in your capital

    • @bakermayfield6hunnitdan6er24
      @bakermayfield6hunnitdan6er24 Před 2 lety +5

      @@dancercoffin6868 people don’t understand that not “all middle eastern refugees are bad”. Afghan refugees (mostly military aged men) have caused exponentially more crime than any other ethnicity, even though the numbers are lower than most other countries by far. I feel bad for Syrians, as many have been able to integrate into their respective societies while Afghans and Pakistanis have caused immense anger, hatred, and nationalism. The govts of developed nations have failed to recognize this until the public demands that enough is enough.

    • @geishasahhak8055
      @geishasahhak8055 Před 2 lety +6

      @@dancercoffin6868 did u forget turkey is middle east too? Just becuz a part of turkey is in europe and yall are in nato doesnt meannur so european

  • @rahelmanijeh7767
    @rahelmanijeh7767 Před 2 lety +13

    Why they don't translate when the man is talking. He told that they were biding by Iranian police.

    • @user-bx2ku3ic4k
      @user-bx2ku3ic4k Před rokem +5

      Arte translates only what they want the european people should to hear. This is not first time.

  • @Sinner85
    @Sinner85 Před rokem +4

    A so ..rofl.. muslim brotherhood just hoax words 😂😂😂

  • @pgancedo9299
    @pgancedo9299 Před rokem +6

    Why do these people want to go to Turkey or other European countries? Why the not try to go to China or India?

    • @saymyname10
      @saymyname10 Před rokem

      China's borders are completely closed, India is already a bad country. They are trying to escape to Europe.

    • @Sinner85
      @Sinner85 Před rokem +1

      For Muslim brotherhood sake 😂😂

  • @karenmiller553
    @karenmiller553 Před měsícem

    Turkey is complaining that it's at maximum capacit of refugees,Europe is also. Where are these people to go?...America has over 9 million asylum seekers...that number is higher than some of our states populations.Americans are struggle with inflation, not enough housing, high cost of health care,homelessness and now are burdened with providing everything for refugees.

  • @kabdul9208
    @kabdul9208 Před rokem +7

    They are unarmed civilians and they are point guns at them!

    • @publicname
      @publicname Před rokem +2

      Don't be a Qaren, pointed the gun when checking at night if someone has anything that can harm, totally normal procedure.

    • @Mazamasan
      @Mazamasan Před rokem

      ​@@publicnametill they point the gun at ur mama or family then u cry like a shreikker😂😂😂

    • @matrixtrollmarine
      @matrixtrollmarine Před 11 měsíci +1

      be greateful they didn't gun them down on the spot

    • @rodyys
      @rodyys Před 2 měsíci

      They must feel lucky to be alive crossing the borders illegally, so you better stfu

  • @user-kb7vq7cp8g
    @user-kb7vq7cp8g Před 2 lety +3

    LOL!

  • @timurcan2210
    @timurcan2210 Před rokem +3

    GOOD JOB.

  • @rajmaity
    @rajmaity Před rokem +1

    Do people have to carry to the top

  • @tacocruiser4238
    @tacocruiser4238 Před rokem +11

    It's a shame the Byzantines didn't have these "smart towers" to stop the Turks from crossing their borders....

    • @berkay9888
      @berkay9888 Před rokem

      Well erdogan on his way to take every middle east people to turkiye without any hesitation syrians can even go to their country for holidays can you believe that?

    • @berkay9888
      @berkay9888 Před rokem

      @@TheBs9875 and are you actually turk?

    • @meralodem
      @meralodem Před rokem +1

      Well instead Byzantine had more Turkish soldiers in its army then greeks :))) They basically lost and important war against Seljuks because Türks in the Byzantine army switched sides during war ahahahha

    • @tacocruiser4238
      @tacocruiser4238 Před rokem +1

      @@meralodem It is true that the Byzantine used Turkish mercenaries in their army. The Turkish mercenaries did a good job for the Byzantines. It was the Turkish horse archers who helped Alexios I Komnenos defeat the Normans in 1085 ad.
      Actually it was the Normans who caused the Byzantines to lose to the Turks. The Byzantines might have been able to defeat the Turks if they weren't so busy fighting the Normans.

    • @lilo7741
      @lilo7741 Před rokem

      byzantines and turks had already been living together for 5 centuries before turks conquered constinople. they werent foreigners to each other. turks therefore didnt treat the greeks harshly. afghans are a threat to europe and turkey alike. they are culturally completely incompatible.

  • @Taha-dj4ly
    @Taha-dj4ly Před rokem +6

    Beautiful language

    • @faaaduma6876
      @faaaduma6876 Před rokem +3

      I hope you were referring to the Turkish language.

  • @reuterromain1054
    @reuterromain1054 Před rokem +2

    So leid mir diese unglücklichen Wanderer auch tun, das Boot Europa ist voll.

    • @lilo7741
      @lilo7741 Před rokem

      sie sollten dir nicht leid tun. sie sind opportunisten, die ihre familien zurück lassen und sich in unseren wohlstand hineinschmuggeln wollen. das recht und befürnisse des gastgebers sind denen scheißegal. außerdem betrachten sie europäer sowieso als ungläubige die es langfristig zu erobern gilt. lol. wie doof muss man sein, dass man leute ins land holt die absolut nix beitragen können.

    • @Mazamasan
      @Mazamasan Před rokem

      😂😂😂 stimmt das europa boot sänkt , lieber raus hir ab nach krypton

  • @mohamedbah532
    @mohamedbah532 Před 2 lety +6

    I thought it was us only blacks, but now I know that human beings are confused creatures.

  • @user-bx2ku3ic4k
    @user-bx2ku3ic4k Před rokem

    Arte is a provacative tv chanel.

  • @karazipkaKRZP
    @karazipkaKRZP Před 2 lety +44

    We Afgans should go to Germany. My family in Germany. I'll be there with my 8 brothers soon. Afghans should be in Germany. They love Afghans. I have more then 20 Afghan friends in Germany all got citizenship this year very easy to get german passport. I heard that german girls love afgans too. I am gonna marry one of them. Thanks Germany!!!!

    • @ramboram03
      @ramboram03 Před 2 lety +7

      You don't know the long history of Germany then, liberal Germans don't represent the mass population, Europe is going through a massive ideological shift and its been documented by Douglas Murray, in short they abhor and despise Muslims and they are in essence being turned into the position Jews held in Western Europe during the Medieval period and which culminated in the Holocaust. The White Man's lash always comes the question is when. You are sorely misguided if you feel Germans or any Europeans want a seismic demographic shift in their own land. Turks are Muslims and more culturally closer to Afghans and they feel this way, so you can imagine what the vast majority of Western Europeans who are genetically and culturally completely different feel. Just see the Draconian measures against Muslims in France and Austria taking place. Regardless my sympathies are with these people, everyone deserves to be happy but sadly life does not work this way.

    • @Kaan_is_myname97
      @Kaan_is_myname97 Před 2 lety +47

      @@ramboram03 He is obviously a troll with that comment .
      Hello from Turkey o/

    • @Hello-uk5xp
      @Hello-uk5xp Před 2 lety +27

      You obviously not a Afghan with that good English grammar

    • @MrDoenerliebhaber
      @MrDoenerliebhaber Před 2 lety

      @@Hello-uk5xp hahaha

    • @questionmark3219
      @questionmark3219 Před 2 lety +18

      I come from Germany and can only advise you not to come to Germany. Nobody there seriously wants to take in more migrants. Many do not integrate into Western society. Many think that they can carry on their lives and their social traditions as they did at home. This causes anger on the part of the local population. Please go to other countries and leave us alone in Germany. We are not a guarantee country for the reception of people. Stay in Turkey or Greece or go to Arab countries. In Germany you will always belong to the lower class anyway and in many cases you will also be exploited by companies as cheap labor. In addition, our state can guarantee aid payments that are becoming increasingly difficult.

  • @manumontana1425
    @manumontana1425 Před 2 lety +2

    Bitte generell für r alle Männer aus diesen Kulturen 🙏

  • @tonyzarif6124
    @tonyzarif6124 Před 2 lety +7

    I'm an Afghan/American living in Turkey and would like to offer my assistance to the family of Ferouz (the martial artist). How can I become in contact with him. Thank you

    • @artetvdocumentary
      @artetvdocumentary  Před 2 lety +2

      Unfortunately we cannot provide personal information via our CZcams channel but we very much appreciate the sentiment.

    • @meltem65
      @meltem65 Před 2 lety +51

      Ülkene dön

    • @tonyzarif6124
      @tonyzarif6124 Před 2 lety +1

      @@meltem65 Dinleyin ırkçı pislik, Alanya ekonomisinin büyük bir kısmı benim gibi gurbetçilerden ve batı ülkelerinden gelen turistlerden oluşuyor. California ve Alanya arasında gidip geliyorum ama sizin gibi ırkçı bir punk değilim ve Amerika'da veya Alanya'da herkese aynı şekilde davranıyorum.

    • @tonyzarif6124
      @tonyzarif6124 Před 2 lety +1

      @@meltem65 Aynı şeyi Türkiye'de yaşayan Avrupalılara mı söylüyorsunuz? Bir gün Allah bir ders verecek, ya da belki de senin ne kadar sert konuştuğunla seni cezalandırıyor. zihninizi ve kalbinizi açın ve insanlığı sınırsız sevmeyi öğrenin.

    • @tttt9131
      @tttt9131 Před 2 lety +35

      @@tonyzarif6124 ülkene dön. Burada istenmiyorsun.

  • @geishasahhak8055
    @geishasahhak8055 Před 2 lety +10

    Love how every turk is hating on afghans. Its like you all just forgot about the great history afghans and turks shared. You think now you are a part of europe and so much superior to other countries. I just remember when i visited turkey and how nice everyone was, but now its just some overly selfish people who think they are the best since they joined the nato

    • @profesorsnape5641
      @profesorsnape5641 Před 2 lety +18

      So u came turkey before 1952 lol turkey joined NATO in 1952 hahahsjajsh

    • @abrahamlincoln6704
      @abrahamlincoln6704 Před rokem +1

      Fuck your history
      Turks and Afghan are different

    • @geishasahhak8055
      @geishasahhak8055 Před rokem +3

      @AYSHIA wasRAPEDbyYOURPROPHETatnsix! But they try so much to be a part of them

    • @geishasahhak8055
      @geishasahhak8055 Před rokem

      @@abrahamlincoln6704 bro it's not like we give a fuck about u and ur people. Wannabe europeans

    • @abrahamlincoln6704
      @abrahamlincoln6704 Před rokem +1

      @@geishasahhak8055 are you Afghan??

  • @alex69elijah9yaki
    @alex69elijah9yaki Před rokem +6

    why Turks don't want to help their muslim brothers?

    • @tanrnnkuzusu1359
      @tanrnnkuzusu1359 Před rokem +23

      Why Turks wanna to help their muslim brothers

    • @thespinosaurus2972
      @thespinosaurus2972 Před rokem

      Because refugees work for a cheaper salary and companys hire them rather than turks so our own people are jobless because of that. They also reproduce in a fast rate because they get money per children.It is so dumb how a goverment lets some foreigners get their money rather than their people.Some also cause problems that are forbidden in islam and still say they are muslim. I am no racist. I am also a muslim.But this is getting out of hand !

    • @thespinosaurus2972
      @thespinosaurus2972 Před rokem +2

      @@tanrnnkuzusu1359 Müslüman’ın müslüman’a yardım etmesi güzel bir şeydir ama yardımın da bir sonu var.(çoğunluk müslüman olduğu için İslam’dan yola çıktım)

    • @tanrnnkuzusu1359
      @tanrnnkuzusu1359 Před rokem +12

      @@thespinosaurus2972 hiçbir alakamız olmayan afganlara yardım edelim ? Özellikle vatandaşların çoğu anca ayın sonunu geçirirken onlara yardım etmek bize mi kaldı? Sen istiyorsan SMS ile et ben etmem

    • @The_Burnedman
      @The_Burnedman Před rokem +31

      Bro why doesn't Germany/France help their Christian brothers from Africa?

  • @rajasekhare9573
    @rajasekhare9573 Před 2 lety +17

    Turkey should give Afgan refugees the same rights that Germany gives to Turkish refugees.

    • @tttt9131
      @tttt9131 Před 2 lety +17

      @@lsdaukul2945 did you really expect rationality from a surname as “sekhar” ?

    • @tevrenus77
      @tevrenus77 Před 2 lety +71

      Are you for real? The Turkish in Germany are mostly “Gastarbeiter” called by the German government. There is a huge difference. The government did not call for those, the Turkish people certainly did not..

    • @irem3133
      @irem3133 Před 2 lety +26

      No turks went to germany due to their propose. Turkey didnt proposed afghans to come.

    • @nomnom7697
      @nomnom7697 Před 2 lety

      Nope, we don’t have to. If you have problem with our people and country get the hell out of here.

    • @bb-mi5uq
      @bb-mi5uq Před 2 lety

      Turks are not ilegally refugee germany wanst them for work. Most turkish doctor in germany now. We are not equal. You are uneducated. We wont give u rights go back to your country.

  • @BogalaSawundiris
    @BogalaSawundiris Před rokem

    TURKEY ! You must remember that you are part of the Ummah ! You are not above Allah !

    • @lilo7741
      @lilo7741 Před rokem +18

      afghans = allah? ::DDD stop telling turkey what do to.

    • @hectorberlioz7350
      @hectorberlioz7350 Před rokem +9

      senin ben allahını

    • @lilo7741
      @lilo7741 Před rokem

      allah will fk the refugees.

    • @m.aydogmus5834
      @m.aydogmus5834 Před rokem

      Fu** off. We don't have to take people who have bacha bazi culture. If you want them, you can take them.

    • @Senler0
      @Senler0 Před rokem +7

      No.

  • @mukhumor
    @mukhumor Před rokem +5

    Assad was fighting Islamists like ISIS and Al Qaeda. There is nothing wrong with Assad. He is the leader the Syrians deserve. Go back to Syria.

    • @MA-qz1sd
      @MA-qz1sd Před rokem

      Very uninformed and ignorant

    • @Mazamasan
      @Mazamasan Před rokem

      Aww people like u are the reason our race is so vile and stoopitt
      Stuuppitttt boyy 😂😂😂😂
      Asad is a radical child killer u should join him and support him