i've never seen a tally hall full ranking before, i'm pretty glad we share the same opinions overall, including DSISM on top, it's my absolute all time favorite. Please do more Tally hall content, I really need more lol
a FULL tally hall ranking would include Tally hall, Tally hall (demos) , Miracle Musical, Joe Hawley Joe Hawley, Not a Trampoline, Edu / Sketches 3D Cojum dip, Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum, Good & Evil, And also some Casey related stuff, don't know much about him😭
Personally, I don’t like mind electric I don’t think the voice effects were weird. Some parts in the song were reversed. Not talking about the first three minutes. I’m talking about the parts in the song so when you listen to it reverse it sounds a little normal and I just think that was a stupid decision.
It's kinda cheating but listening to a version of The Mind Electric with the reverse half skipped makes it MUCH easier to listen to and enjoy. Especially if demo 4's added. The transition gives me chills. I'd definitely recommend sitting through it that way as a casual listener but there's so much more when looking at it as an art piece The lyrics are very poetic, pretty much every line has multiple meanings, and it's hauntingly beautiful and just really impressive honestly The instrumentals also do a lot to show how the singer was already powerless and mentally unstable, desperate for what he has left in his life. His voice getting reversed mid-sentence when he says "insane" and stuttering makes his state feel wrong and out of his control. Then he gets drowned out by louder singers sentencing him to the infirmary and he breaks down even further. The pleading and energy of the court sentencing section reminds me a lot of Bohemian Rhapsody The lyrics and instrumentals both show his desperation and his reality being forcefully torn apart by the shocks and abuse in the mental hospital but the lyrics and background working together make each other even more terrifying. Not to mention that the ending "see how the serfs work the ground" section just sounds amazing on its own Remembering that The Mind Electric and the rest of Hawaii: Part II all had to be envisioned, written, performed, and produced by real people feels... almost unbelievable Basically if The Mind Electric has a million fans, then I'm one of them. If The Mind Electric has one fan, I'm that one. If The Mind Electric has no fans, that means I'm dead
I agree. Had the reverse part not been included, I would probably have put TME somewhere in between #20-#15. However, when a discography is almost perfect, even the slightest imperfections can send a song far down the ranking.
6:28 I think the whole world and you is about someone always feeling in their friends shadow and it’s kinda a sarcastic, bitter song about how everyone sees them as the main character and no one pays attention to the singer
Fucking sobbing cause mind electric was ranked second to last- its such an amazing, powerful, intense experience of a song, the most glorious climax to an album I’ve ever heard. It’s definitely not for easy listening but like- cmon it’s a song about grief and trauma and fucking electric shock therapy and institutionalized abuse where the poor guy literally straight up loses his marbles, it would be entirely reductive to take all those themes and make a song about them easy to listen to. Plus, even with the noise, when you break it down into its parts, it’s recurring motifs and all the other leitmotifs from the rest of the album, how warped and distorted and unapologetically creepy they are, it’s a music theory masterpiece, even in the non-musical segments. It’s reversed at the beginning because it’s the characters life literally flashing before their eyes. It’s an entirely genius piece, and while I respect your opinion, and agree that it is definitely not an easy listen for someone not into more experimental music, I disagree in your ranking of it.
i respect your opinion @@apauljuice , and although the album does i believe have a fair amount of backmasking on it, i understand that it's a difference of priority and taste, and ultimately entirely respect that. More power to you
kramba
i've never seen a tally hall full ranking before, i'm pretty glad we share the same opinions overall, including DSISM on top, it's my absolute all time favorite. Please do more Tally hall content, I really need more lol
wat is dsism
@@AutZeroOneGotBanned dream sweet in sea major, hawaii part II's finale
@@KanyeOeste911 that's not technically tally hall
a FULL tally hall ranking would include Tally hall, Tally hall (demos) , Miracle Musical, Joe Hawley Joe Hawley, Not a Trampoline, Edu / Sketches 3D Cojum dip, Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum, Good & Evil, And also some Casey related stuff, don't know much about him😭
you look like Justin Bieber pre-weed era
Lol
No. No. Just no. I cant believe you put the best song of all time the mind electric at last. Bro fast forward to the non reverse part. I just can't.
Personally, I don’t like mind electric I don’t think the voice effects were weird. Some parts in the song were reversed. Not talking about the first three minutes. I’m talking about the parts in the song so when you listen to it reverse it sounds a little normal and I just think that was a stupid decision.
Dude you can’t say a song is good if you have to fast forward half of it to get to a good part.
@@lahbandueve ☝🤓
@@ActionPulse_Alt that’s like if you were gonna watch a movie but the beginning is so unbelievably bad you have to skip it to get to the good part
Nah it’s just not enjoyable either way
every person on earth can agree that dream sweet in sea major is the best song to ever exist, it is just perfect
Fax
Frrr
I feel depressed listening to it, but I love it so much
It's kinda cheating but listening to a version of The Mind Electric with the reverse half skipped makes it MUCH easier to listen to and enjoy. Especially if demo 4's added. The transition gives me chills. I'd definitely recommend sitting through it that way as a casual listener but there's so much more when looking at it as an art piece
The lyrics are very poetic, pretty much every line has multiple meanings, and it's hauntingly beautiful and just really impressive honestly
The instrumentals also do a lot to show how the singer was already powerless and mentally unstable, desperate for what he has left in his life. His voice getting reversed mid-sentence when he says "insane" and stuttering makes his state feel wrong and out of his control. Then he gets drowned out by louder singers sentencing him to the infirmary and he breaks down even further. The pleading and energy of the court sentencing section reminds me a lot of Bohemian Rhapsody
The lyrics and instrumentals both show his desperation and his reality being forcefully torn apart by the shocks and abuse in the mental hospital but the lyrics and background working together make each other even more terrifying.
Not to mention that the ending "see how the serfs work the ground" section just sounds amazing on its own
Remembering that The Mind Electric and the rest of Hawaii: Part II all had to be envisioned, written, performed, and produced by real people feels... almost unbelievable
Basically if The Mind Electric has a million fans, then I'm one of them. If The Mind Electric has one fan, I'm that one. If The Mind Electric has no fans, that means I'm dead
I agree. Had the reverse part not been included, I would probably have put TME somewhere in between #20-#15. However, when a discography is almost perfect, even the slightest imperfections can send a song far down the ranking.
Yes someone who actually explains why they don't like Be Born! Most people chalk it up to "It's weird" or "It's country."
Nice video, really deserves more views
i was laughing throughout this entire vid, nice ranking dude
Glad you enjoyed it!
6:28 I think the whole world and you is about someone always feeling in their friends shadow and it’s kinda a sarcastic, bitter song about how everyone sees them as the main character and no one pays attention to the singer
Interesting take
NAH HIDDEN IN THE SAND IN 40?! OTHERWISE THE TIERLIST IS ALMOST PERFECT BUT DUDE THATS ONE OF MY FAVORITE SONGS EVER
Why does “You” always get so much hate.. I love it :((
Because Andrew Horowitz's vocal delivery leaves much to be desired
banana man was one of the first songs i know and it is literally in my top 3. i love it so much.
Yk i was kinda annoyed by the personality but i realized you were being sarcastic at spring & a storm
This hurts because I wasn't being sarcastic
Dude I love spring and the storm 😭
I absolutelycried when you ranked time machine number 31.
Yeah my opinion has changed with most of my spots now (like how I put Greener at #22)
Why does this only have 107 views?
Spring and Storm>>>>>>>>all
No thanks
You are correct sir
Is there even a bad song in good & evil?
"You" is not that good.
Fucking sobbing cause mind electric was ranked second to last- its such an amazing, powerful, intense experience of a song, the most glorious climax to an album I’ve ever heard. It’s definitely not for easy listening but like- cmon it’s a song about grief and trauma and fucking electric shock therapy and institutionalized abuse where the poor guy literally straight up loses his marbles, it would be entirely reductive to take all those themes and make a song about them easy to listen to. Plus, even with the noise, when you break it down into its parts, it’s recurring motifs and all the other leitmotifs from the rest of the album, how warped and distorted and unapologetically creepy they are, it’s a music theory masterpiece, even in the non-musical segments. It’s reversed at the beginning because it’s the characters life literally flashing before their eyes. It’s an entirely genius piece, and while I respect your opinion, and agree that it is definitely not an easy listen for someone not into more experimental music, I disagree in your ranking of it.
I have it that low because I don't like reversed music, none of the other songs have reversed music
The story does not help the execution for me
i respect your opinion @@apauljuice , and although the album does i believe have a fair amount of backmasking on it, i understand that it's a difference of priority and taste, and ultimately entirely respect that. More power to you
@@spookyjosh158Some people don’t want to listen to the music to “understand the story” some people actually listen to enjoy it not enjoy a plot 🥶
is your greenscreen behind glass why can i see windows
yes, there were windows behind my green screen
bro thought he ate
Am I the only one that actually likes Be Born??
I have been reformed, Be Born goes hard
I agree on turn the lights off its pretty overrated in my opinion