Joe Rogan Experience

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 21. 08. 2024

Komentáře • 4,5K

  • @davidcartwright3097
    @davidcartwright3097 Před 18 dny +495

    To think there are people in this world who would argue that an 18 year old didn't understand student loans and can't possibly be trusted with a beer, but a 5 year old can determine their gender.

    • @Aireck174
      @Aireck174 Před 11 dny

      I think this is all working up to democrats arguing 5 year olds should be able to vote.

    • @robertpirtle7642
      @robertpirtle7642 Před 3 dny

      My personal opinion is that it's a cult of people who have been brainwashed by pedophiles and other kinds of sexual predators. I believe it's people doing the devil's work intentionally or unintentionally, either way it's evil. They've taken advantage of weak-minded people and it slowly affected the intelligent ones over a few decades until this point. There's a lot more I'd like to say about it but I don't want to make too long of a comment. Again it's just my personal opinion.

    • @unclemikescomedy
      @unclemikescomedy Před dnem

      I feel less uncomfortable hearing that a child is being put on medication or is smoking cigarettes than I do about a child choosing their gender through medical intervention.

    • @taylorrichard3770
      @taylorrichard3770 Před dnem

      @@unclemikescomedy You're an abomination. Or, you're just a comedian, per your handle.

  • @jessicahexhibits
    @jessicahexhibits Před měsícem +2022

    My Psychiatrist said that she went form ZERO cases where kids thought they were meant to be the opposite sex to 8/10 children she sees. We are putting this in our kids heads. These are things that should be dealt with organically

    • @user-tn6lx4tr8c
      @user-tn6lx4tr8c Před měsícem +136

      Strange thing, Jessica - I am a white South African, and honestly the only places here where this is becoming prevalent, is in Liberal white communities. Most black people would think you are crazy if you mention such a thing. It is interesting how Africans are liberal/leftist when it comes to economics, but extremely conservative on topics such as family.

    • @PickupsAreNotTrucks
      @PickupsAreNotTrucks Před měsícem

      It’s sick. Our kids are being brainwashed by a communist party in the US. I live in ND which is super red and I also live out in the boonies and there’s a kid in our children’s small school that claims to be “trans.” This nonsense has spread everywhere. I don’t care what anyone does as an adult but, I draw a line at kids and I cannot believe we are not all in agreement on this.

    • @keinegotter573
      @keinegotter573 Před měsícem +62

      My therapist said the same. 100% social contagion.

    • @cuppycakey5013
      @cuppycakey5013 Před měsícem +37

      That’s terrible but not surprising. It’s all about attention now. Btw, WE aren’t doing this, THEY are.

    • @sue8344
      @sue8344 Před měsícem

      Becky Weiss did a great video on IG where she says if she was a few years younger she might have gotten sucked into the trans ideology . She’s always been a tomboy and if someone had said to her ‘you’re really a boy’ at a vulnerable time in her development , she might have believed it. It’s so unfortunate that young girls are now questioning their gender just because they don’t fit into the stereotype of Barbie loving girls.

  • @cherylg9074
    @cherylg9074 Před 19 dny +120

    Great conversation about marriage. I converted to Catholicism to be married in my fiance's church. 15 years and 3 children later, he wanted a divorce. We got pregnant by choice, and one of the reasons for that choice is that we could afford 3 children with both of us raising them, and we could parent them together. When he divorced me, he left me to raise those 3 children alone. All 3 children are now grown and have mental health issues, both from their abandonment by their father, and because I needed to leave them home alone to work because my income was now all we had to pay housing costs, food, clothing, etc. It was too much for me to provide for them alone. I never wanted the divorce, but was forced to accept this life he chose for me when he decided to leave us. I 100% agree with Matt that divorce is too easy. Both parties should want it. If he was going to have to be unhappy in our marriage, maybe his unhappiness would have been much better than the damage done to these children who had to be raised in a single family household with the economic struggles and lack of supervision that single parent families have.

    • @MelissaDisha
      @MelissaDisha Před 16 dny +8

      Well, a according to Jesus. Divorce is not recognized. So if your ex sleeps with anyone else he's an adulterer. He can't marry again either. However YOU can marry again because he broke the covenant of Marriage which frees you.

    • @thefinaldispatch
      @thefinaldispatch Před 15 dny +7

      Did you stay intimate with him? If not, time to look in the mirror. Always two sides to every story

    • @furiousg3orge
      @furiousg3orge Před 14 dny +33

      @@thefinaldispatch It’s disturbing that this is your knee-jerk response to this woman’s comment.

    • @rayflores9854
      @rayflores9854 Před 13 dny +3

      Afford lol
      Having children should not be about what you can afford. This is "boss girl" mentality and exactly why we are declining in replacement rate.

    • @MercuryRisingFast
      @MercuryRisingFast Před 13 dny

      @@cherylg9074 get childsupport

  • @allwaystherebel
    @allwaystherebel Před 23 dny +187

    What I think Matt failed to say: marriage was initially intended to be within the confines of the Church. The government adopted it legally to monopolize and incentivize with tax breaks. More government intervention.
    As far as everything else, moral relativism leads to a “freedom” of chaos and hedonism.

    • @OffGridInvestor
      @OffGridInvestor Před 14 dny +5

      Actually it was religious in general. The first Christians were converted pagans who were married under their pagan religion and then had a second Christian marriage to the same people once they converted to Christianity.

    • @scootmcgoot570
      @scootmcgoot570 Před 14 dny

      Well unfortunately the govt has 💩 all over marriage and incentivized single motherhood. The more children you have out of wedlock the more taxpayer funded benefits you can receive......but NOT if you are married

    • @christiansoldier77
      @christiansoldier77 Před 11 dny +11

      ​@OffGridInvestor Wrong. The first Christians were Jews and it was God who created marriage from the very beginning with Adam and Eve

    • @athenametzger9269
      @athenametzger9269 Před 11 dny +8

      I was surprised by Matt not hitting that home. To me that’s an unforced error on his part in the dialogue. He’s too smart to leave that out-maybe there’s another reason, like an agreement with Rogan??
      The Biblical framework/covenant for marriage and family is, to me, irrefutably the best design, but flawed humans mess it up through sin, selfishness, abuse, etc.
      When God is left out of the marriage, and divorce becomes rampant, you end up with the trainwreck American society faces today.

    • @DarinTWright
      @DarinTWright Před 8 dny +18

      @@athenametzger9269 Matt didn't push the Christian perspective on the subject because he knew in Joe's eyes that would immediately discredit his argument in it's entirety. While marriage is an extremely important tenant of Christianity, it is not JUST a Christian and/or religious issue. Marriage exists in virtually every culture and religion on Earth. Focusing solely on the Christian point of view would lead to Joe, and thousands of others who hold his same perspective, not even considering the points Matt was trying to articulate about the importance of traditional marriage to society as a whole. Coming from a Christian Conservative, we have to learn to argue on subjects such as this without even bringing theology into it. In the eyes of many people who are on the fence about certain hot topic issues such as abortion, the moment we bring our personal religious beliefs into it they feel that we aren't thinking logically, and are simply spouting religious rhetoric at them.

  • @ThinkTink21
    @ThinkTink21 Před měsícem +3083

    Please Matt, we need a sequel "What is a baby?"

    • @kookpatrol7490
      @kookpatrol7490 Před měsícem +35

      Yes!

    • @thinkitthrough8000
      @thinkitthrough8000 Před měsícem +24

      Cool. Let’s test that. What’s a baby?

    • @roadkingthor8421
      @roadkingthor8421 Před měsícem +66

      ​@@thinkitthrough8000 Human offspring.

    • @Consconservative
      @Consconservative Před měsícem +31

      @@thinkitthrough8000 a baby is a stage of animal development in which the animal is highly dependent upon its parent or parents for survival.

    • @jaydonaldson3410
      @jaydonaldson3410 Před měsícem +12

      @@Consconservative so a baby puppy?

  • @annoythedonkey
    @annoythedonkey Před měsícem +185

    I was put on lupron as a kid for precocious puberty, I’m fighting my second rare cancer diagnosis in the last 16 years. I’m not likely to survive this time around and partly blame the lupron for my current situation. I really wish I could scream it from the rooftops and talk to people about this risk, I vividly remember how that drug made me feel, it made me feel so terrible both physically and emotionally. Please if you are a parent who has a kid who’s transgender and is considering “treatment” I beg you to consider what the drug can do to your child in the future.

    • @curlsncoilsnwaves7324
      @curlsncoilsnwaves7324 Před 24 dny +15

      Interesting, this is why we won't treat our daughter with medication for precocious puberty. I'm so sorry for your experience!

    • @OwenHarris-dq6pw
      @OwenHarris-dq6pw Před 19 dny +13

      You will make it! God bless you for telling your story!

    • @sabiaottley5318
      @sabiaottley5318 Před 15 dny

      I think gender is targeted because there’s an attack on the nuclear family.

    • @loormaria
      @loormaria Před 13 dny +5

      I pray you will beat the cancer this time around. God bless you abundantly!

    • @sr.bootsnpants664
      @sr.bootsnpants664 Před 10 dny

      I'm sorry you went through this. I hope you can stay longer to warn others. Thank you for your sentiments..

  • @maddieburke317
    @maddieburke317 Před 8 dny +25

    Joe I’ve been a nurse and NP for over 40 years. Among the saddest times I have seen are childless couples that lose their spouse. It is heartbreaking! I am now a widow and so thankful for my children and grandchildren. It is the way of nature

    • @Chongfjongdong
      @Chongfjongdong Před dnem +2

      Very selfish thought pattern you have

    • @stormfath3r754
      @stormfath3r754 Před dnem +1

      @@ChongfjongdongShe is literally expressing empathy for widows, and her gratitude for her situation. Who hurt you my guy?

    • @Nellsbells79
      @Nellsbells79 Před 18 hodinami

      ❤ I agree

    • @Nellsbells79
      @Nellsbells79 Před 18 hodinami

      ⁠that’s selfish? It is heartbreaking and if you have a heart you’d agree.

  • @DougWilkerson-uy1mh
    @DougWilkerson-uy1mh Před měsícem +478

    This is why Joe is the king. They agree for 70% of the interview and disagree on 30% yet the conversation goes on. People get to listen and decide for themselves.

    • @humantwotwentyone641
      @humantwotwentyone641 Před 20 dny +6

      And Matt bruh.

    • @kyrrilcrepeele1353
      @kyrrilcrepeele1353 Před 18 dny +17

      They were really dancing around the conversation. Matt's position was marriage is a religious union to create offspring and people who want to be together and 1 arent man and woman or/and 2 dont want kids can have that same legal union without calling it marriage. Law stole the name marriage.

    • @New_Age_Drifter
      @New_Age_Drifter Před 18 dny +23

      Did you check the video after the 2 hour mark? Joe spends a good half hour building a straw man on Matt Walsh's conservative view on marriage vs gay marriage. It's pathetic.
      Joe can't argue for shit without relying on logical fallacies or exceptional hypotheticals for a general argument; it's like listening to a 90s teenager point of view. I don't think Joe has challenged his views since then, it's embarrassing to hear a grown man like him argue purely from emotional outrage. Dude is a Karen for any liberal views he holds.

    • @pablohiteshew2457
      @pablohiteshew2457 Před 17 dny +13

      Matt kicked his ass.

    • @MercuryRisingFast
      @MercuryRisingFast Před 15 dny +16

      meh... he kept cutting off Matt. Marriage is between a man and a woman. Gay marriage isn't marriage. It's something else, but it's not marriage. What does the state have to do with marriage at all?? Does it make you more in love? What rights? No one is stopping gay people from doing anything. We just don't care.

  • @MiindGames
    @MiindGames Před měsícem +276

    Matt exposing this issue absolutely helped me snap out of the Bay Area/LA liberal brainwashing. I came back to Conservatism thanks to this nonsense. God bless.

    • @crunchywashere3513
      @crunchywashere3513 Před měsícem +2

      The very god you can't prove exist and has these views, sure buddy

    • @tippsish
      @tippsish Před měsícem +18

      ​@crunchywashere3513 It's basic English terminology. It's basic biology. It has nothing to do with religion. Nice try though

    • @crunchywashere3513
      @crunchywashere3513 Před měsícem

      @@tippsish Well, if it was that simple, why would gay people exiat ? Let alone trans ans everything that is "abnormal" ? And the fact that they exist is fine by me, and not by Matt. Why ? Because of the Bible

    • @knowthycell
      @knowthycell Před 26 dny

      @@crunchywashere3513you can’t disprove it. But It can be proven that a person with certain chromosomes is a man.

    • @rt19187
      @rt19187 Před 25 dny +4

      Respect.

  • @Damudean
    @Damudean Před 14 dny +45

    What other people do in a marriage to you doesn’t directly affect you. But it does diminish what marriage is and it’s importance overall

    • @beanybabyrabie
      @beanybabyrabie Před 8 dny +7

      It DIRECTLY impacts society

    • @scesfizia
      @scesfizia Před 4 dny +5

      @@beanybabyrabieIt really doesn’t, I think the disgusting things done in the name of Christianity have impacted society

    • @scousiered3124
      @scousiered3124 Před 2 dny +1

      @@scesfizia One does not negate the other.
      A marriage confers benefits. The reason for those benefits was an assumption that the marriage would result in a family (when nearly all had families if they could). If that is not now the assumption, why are we conferring benefits? Because people are in love: so people not in love should be punished..?
      So I get it. It's a status that the church and state allow marriage for the benefit of the children. Easy divorce does devalue marriage: no-one goes in thinking they are in this for life anymore and will jump ship when it becomes not worth it.
      So it has been eroded from all sides.

    • @scesfizia
      @scesfizia Před 2 dny +1

      @@scousiered3124 What are you babbling on about? No relevance whatsoever.

    • @jameseverett4976
      @jameseverett4976 Před dnem

      @@scesfizia "in the name of"? what does that even mean?
      Oh, right.... it means you can throw an infinite chain of blame at something or someone you have a bone to pick with, because somehow or some way there's a connection that can bemade with literally any 2 entities, organizations, names, institutions, or ideas. Like all white people were born "in the name of" slavery?
      Or all mice are killed "in the name of" Sylvester the cat. The funnest ones though are whenever good intentions go awry, [as they always do sooner or later] then Christianity - a set of general beliefs that revolutionized society & brought us out of the dark ages, and is the foundation of modern legal philosophy - is to blame. How do you blame a vast set of ideas, though? Are all the doncrines of Christianity to blame for marriage problems? Would it be better to not have marriage in the first place, no families, just let all women who get pregnant abort their kids or fend for themselves?
      Which brings us to the final and inevitable question: If Christianity is to blame for X problem, do you have a better solution? Can you teach us your solution, so that the situation you're blaming on Christianity, can be eradicated and prevented from happening? Have you thought out your solution sufficiently, so that it is actually practical and works consistently, without causing other problems that are even worse? Like, have you tested it out, and proved it's efficiency in both solving the problem, and not creating other, more severe problems?

  • @charlaporter7773
    @charlaporter7773 Před 22 dny +14

    2 men I love to listen to and respect...and this is another reason to respect them!!
    This is how 2 people who disagree sit and have a discussion

  • @clownfishcanjuggle
    @clownfishcanjuggle Před měsícem +918

    They need to redo this interview in the current political climate. It has only gotten crazier.

    • @nifftycat
      @nifftycat Před měsícem +13

      Totally!

    • @charaznable8072
      @charaznable8072 Před měsícem +7

      What is a Banana?

    • @brettmuir5679
      @brettmuir5679 Před měsícem

      Obama Identifies as a black man even though he is half white. Who says you cannot self identify your race? Rachel Dolezal got beef for it and she had to be cancelled

    • @brettmuir5679
      @brettmuir5679 Před měsícem +21

      Isn't this episode 11 days old?

    • @clownfishcanjuggle
      @clownfishcanjuggle Před měsícem +46

      @@brettmuir5679 na, it is an old one uploaded to the library. Look at the show number versus his current show number.

  • @kdLsmarckee
    @kdLsmarckee Před měsícem +921

    The original air date should be in the description

    • @trickhealey
      @trickhealey Před měsícem +96

      I clicked “more” and scrolled down to the bottom and saw the release date of nov 6, 2022

    • @justanotherhuman2961
      @justanotherhuman2961 Před měsícem +2

      total control

    • @user-gq2vo6ci9n
      @user-gq2vo6ci9n Před měsícem +30

      This is still incredibly relevant.

    • @MrXxsoulessniperxx
      @MrXxsoulessniperxx Před měsícem +5

      It is. Maybe it's time to put the m3th pipe down.

    • @ccampbell7214
      @ccampbell7214 Před měsícem +2

      I think it's some hack reposting these podcasts to CZcams off Spotify... They do it to Mr Ballen as well ..

  • @ginger7098
    @ginger7098 Před 14 dny +8

    OMG! Joe Rogan, giving new meaning to the word obtuse. I don’t even agree with Matt Walsh on this issue, but how can you not see that he is talking about the cultural impact, not how it affects his own marriage?!?!

    • @FlorentinaBray
      @FlorentinaBray Před 2 hodinami

      Yea obviously, but Rogan is arguing the point that not everyone has to see everything the same.. because how how people that get married but cannot conceive.. so their marriage then also becomes pointless? Even Abraham in the bible had a hard time conceiving with his wife.. but their marriage wasn’t irrelevant…

  • @joshuawells1808
    @joshuawells1808 Před 12 dny +9

    I like both of these guys. And I enjoy how they don’t get super emotional, or enraged. It’s more focused and thought out.

  • @kevincquesnel
    @kevincquesnel Před měsícem +64

    We need more people speaking up like Mr Walsh. You should be proud of the work you’ve done sir and your family should be too. Keep fighting the good fight. God fearing, hard working, law abiding citizens are on your side. Period

    • @Heartwing37
      @Heartwing37 Před 18 dny +1

      💯

    • @Cannibalizee
      @Cannibalizee Před 17 dny +1

      Matt should stick to what he knows, which is politics and religion, and leave psychology and psychiatry alone. He doesn't really believe in either and that's just dumb. Even catholic church exorcists believe in mental illness.

    • @boblinux370
      @boblinux370 Před 4 hodinami

      @@Cannibalizee You don't need to understand psychology to understand reality. Also, the reality is, no one understands psychology, even the pharma companies don't fully understand how their medications like anti-depressants work. Don't allow credentialism to rule your thought patterns.

  • @bobbrown200
    @bobbrown200 Před měsícem +251

    I think joe is speaking about individual people. Matt is speaking for the society as a whole.
    Individuals are allow to not have children. But for society not having children is a detriment to society.

    • @mgband
      @mgband Před měsícem +10

      Some would argue that having fewer children would actually be better for society as a whole.

    • @casmatori
      @casmatori Před měsícem +47

      @@mgband Well no, because that is slowly eliminating the society.

    • @Nathanaelelliott
      @Nathanaelelliott Před měsícem +23

      ​We actually need to start having more kids otherwise our societies are going to collapse. Replacement rate has went down all over the world and some think part of the open border crap is to ensure we still hit replacement rate but idk it seems like a lot more than that.

    • @gorgo4910
      @gorgo4910 Před měsícem +14

      @@mgbandyeah Japan is doing great…

    • @theantitheist1
      @theantitheist1 Před 27 dny +2

      ​@casmatori it's what we need. This is why we are fighting for resources, why there's so much crime, and so on. To many people to keep any type of control of.

  • @badshodi
    @badshodi Před 21 dnem +10

    This country is getting worse by the minute. Thank goodness for people like Matt that fights this craziness

  • @cainfrittswallace7895
    @cainfrittswallace7895 Před 20 dny +21

    Got to give Joe and Matt credit for being able to have a reasonable discussion on points that they very firmly disagrees with and be able to come out at the end disagree and be civil about it, the world needs more of this we're allowed to disagree and still be civil!

  • @markemilyshepherd7981
    @markemilyshepherd7981 Před 17 dny +17

    I’m sure CZcams is throttling this video. It should have millions of views.

    • @patrickbateman1660
      @patrickbateman1660 Před 9 dny +1

      You guys say this about EVERYTHING. SHUT UP. This is from a 2 year old podcast that reuploaded. Not everything is conspiracy

  • @ryu210gonzales9
    @ryu210gonzales9 Před měsícem +597

    I left this on when i ran to the store and now my cat is a conservative and has been telling me the benefits of converting to Christianity for the last hour.

  • @jasonpopielarczyk7511
    @jasonpopielarczyk7511 Před měsícem +526

    I love the fact that as much as Joe pushed, Matt never really backed down.

    • @pr7765
      @pr7765 Před měsícem +40

      Joe "Whatabout" Rogan

    • @EDUAROSOLAS
      @EDUAROSOLAS Před měsícem

      You mean when Matt Walsh pulled a random number out of his ass and Jamie had to correct millions down to a few thousand? If you are that far off with basic facts, you have zero business being anywhere close to this conversation. What a fucking dunce.

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před měsícem +12

      @jasonpopielarczyk7511 did you love when Matt thought that millions had been on therapy when it was thousands? He did a documentary and was off by many orders of magnitude. You failed your sanity check.

    • @BPoweredLove
      @BPoweredLove Před měsícem +9

      While I don't agree with Matt on THAT subject, I admired Matt's patience. Very impressive indeed.

    • @pepefrog7456
      @pepefrog7456 Před měsícem +4

      @@TheFloridaBro BRO (my b) i dont think the average joe checks the numbers, why do u think people say shit with so much confidence lmao. they just hope they are right.

  • @Jfidelis1
    @Jfidelis1 Před 16 dny +8

    Marriage is not primarily for the couple's personal fulfillment (as Joe seems to believe). It's to maintain a stable family of a father and mother for their offspring. In other words, it's about the kids.

    • @petesmitt
      @petesmitt Před 2 dny

      Those on the left try to muddy the water by stating not everybody is fertile or want to have children in a marriage; the key issue with a man and woman joining in marriage is that there is the potential for children; this potential is of course impossible with gay unions.

    • @linnforfreedom
      @linnforfreedom Před 6 hodinami

      Yes! Thank you! It's about creating a safe space for children where both partners are required to put in the effort necessary to sustain and maintain the family.

  • @julielaraenelson5173
    @julielaraenelson5173 Před 21 dnem +5

    I truly appreciate when a conversation can be exactly that, a conversation even when the views are different. No one is screaming. Open to a variety dialog. This is how people should discuss issues. If only.

  • @mynamejeff4883
    @mynamejeff4883 Před měsícem +355

    Glad to see that they are uploading all of these back onto CZcams.

    • @nik07nik
      @nik07nik Před měsícem +1

      Back? they were never here.

    • @mynamejeff4883
      @mynamejeff4883 Před měsícem +22

      @@nik07nik Yes they were. Before the Spotify deal. Maybe not this specific one, and there are several that were done while Joe was only really on Spotify but all you could usually find on CZcams were things on the clips channel. It is nice to see Joe's podcasts back on CZcams.

    • @yobabybubba
      @yobabybubba Před měsícem

      ​@@mynamejeff4883This one was originally on CZcams. I've reached a point at hour and a 1/2 in realizing I heard this before and I can't believe I stumbled upon your conversation here By the way, I just googled it a little while ago and yes, this was from 2022.

    • @Kayrunningandcoffeeaddict
      @Kayrunningandcoffeeaddict Před 27 dny

      @@mynamejeff4883 Yes!!!!!!

  • @imaginedmountains2311
    @imaginedmountains2311 Před měsícem +257

    Originally aired November 6th, 2022.

    • @denisea.9033
      @denisea.9033 Před 20 dny +3

      Thank you!

    • @lyt48
      @lyt48 Před 19 dny +3

      Damn! Why haven’t they put that in the description! This is so confusing!!
      Thanks for sharing though!!

    • @karihouke974
      @karihouke974 Před 18 dny +8

      Yes. Today Matt has 6 kids.

    • @adammustafa3330
      @adammustafa3330 Před 14 dny

      @@karihouke974 Fuck sake. That's too many kids. Everyone and their goddamn kids.

    • @karihouke974
      @karihouke974 Před 14 dny

      @@adammustafa3330 yep. The more the merrier.

  • @northshore1000
    @northshore1000 Před 24 dny +25

    Joe: A gay marriage doesn’t hurt a straight marriage or straight marriages. It hurts society at large. Marriage expanded to people of the same sex then opens marriage up to whatever anyone wants. And a critical, historical institution loses its foundational purpose. The institution is a whole different thing.

    • @myriamsy7
      @myriamsy7 Před 4 dny

      Parfaitement résumé
      👍👏🙏

    • @KaronaG
      @KaronaG Před 3 dny

      Very small minded thinkers flooding this podcast's comments, eh? lol

  • @titoramos5766
    @titoramos5766 Před 10 dny +5

    I totally agree with Matt Walsh also on the Marriage aspect.
    The main goal of a Marriage should be to create and raise a Family.

  • @mhedden033
    @mhedden033 Před měsícem +189

    I didn't realize this was from 2022 until Matt said he only had 4 kids.

    • @shinkablack
      @shinkablack Před 29 dny +4

      Haha

    • @JAMONCT
      @JAMONCT Před 24 dny +11

      Back when Joe did not care about the woke mob…. Cant remember the last time he had a figure like Matt

    • @dr.dawna.lancaster638
      @dr.dawna.lancaster638 Před 24 dny

      😁

    • @YujiroHanmaaaa
      @YujiroHanmaaaa Před 10 dny

      Joe doesnt give a shit about " woke mob" and anti woke warriors + maga cult ​@@JAMONCT

  • @davidolyott5503
    @davidolyott5503 Před měsícem +232

    Very interesting commentary on marriage. Thanks Joe for having the courage to host these type of discussions. Props to Matt for being able to so clearly explain his position.

    • @davidtomkins4242
      @davidtomkins4242 Před měsícem

      Shame his arguments didn’t follow logic and joe exposed the gaping holes in his backwards, religiously dogmatic thinking

    • @jeffhatmaker817
      @jeffhatmaker817 Před měsícem +12

      Although I understand your sentiment, what kind of world are we in whe we have to "thank" someone for stating obvious facts?

    • @aaronflynndevereux1832
      @aaronflynndevereux1832 Před měsícem +7

      They seem to have a disagreement on what the fundamental purpose of marriage is. Joe seems to think it's about individual happiness and matt seems to think it's about the way individual relationships and society interact to make a stable environment to raise kids. Both are right in their own sense

    • @adamfuller5640
      @adamfuller5640 Před měsícem

      @@aaronflynndevereux1832it’s the liberal worldview (individual Liberty, personal happiness) vs the conservative worldview (societal stability and cohesion, tradition and connection).

    • @davidtomkins4242
      @davidtomkins4242 Před měsícem +2

      @@aaronflynndevereux1832 agree, it's the order in which they view it. Joe thinks a marriage solidifies a loving bond between 2 people, who are then in a position to have a baby. Matt thinks you decide to reproduce and so get married to provide a stable environment in which to raise a baby. Joe doesn't regard the desire for baby-producing as a pre-requisite for marriage.

  • @NinjaScorpio
    @NinjaScorpio Před 3 dny +4

    The marriage and the gay marriage is not the same, thats why we say "gay" before the word marriage.

  • @Factrillion
    @Factrillion Před dnem

    This is the first ever JRE episode I have seen whole. Both were calm and respectful despite having a major disagreement. Well done.

  • @theironforce3000
    @theironforce3000 Před měsícem +338

    For anyone wondering why this got uploaded now? this is an old episode? Etc.
    They are uploading the great majority of the back-catalog on CZcams again.
    Prob has to do with signing the new Spotify deal Joe did several months ago.

    • @hdca18
      @hdca18 Před měsícem +11

      ok thanks. This is what i was thinking.

    • @SVW1976
      @SVW1976 Před měsícem +22

      Spotify exclusivity is over. It's that simple.

    • @slapppp815
      @slapppp815 Před měsícem +1

      Thanks

    • @Lemonbonbon
      @Lemonbonbon Před měsícem +14

      Yes Spotify wouldn't upload the more "controversial" episodes. More censorship.

    • @edgar9651
      @edgar9651 Před měsícem +11

      Good that they release the episodes. But I think it should be clear in the title that this was from years ago.

  • @deligeorgieva8535
    @deligeorgieva8535 Před měsícem +58

    nice to see a friendly calm debate between two respectable men

    • @goon6932
      @goon6932 Před 20 dny +3

      So who do you think won?

    • @chef7658
      @chef7658 Před 16 dny +5

      does that matter actually? i think this was a good conversation on its own and good points are made.
      maybe judge the video on that fact instead of a winner/loser situation. ​@goon6932

    • @deligeorgieva8535
      @deligeorgieva8535 Před 16 dny +3

      @@goon6932 i actually don't have a bias. I'm a longtime Matt Walsh fan and although I agree with lots of his opinions, i also agreed with Joe most of the time here so. There's no winner, just a really good podcast

  • @jaredkelly930
    @jaredkelly930 Před 18 dny +5

    My oldest daughter starts Kindergarten this month and I’m absolutely terrified about the brain washing she might get. I’m thinking we should have opted for private school.

    • @user-mi5dt1js6f
      @user-mi5dt1js6f Před 15 dny

      Just go into the classroom. Those loons don't hide, they will have signs and flags posted, making it easy to identify.

    • @TwrZon-4all
      @TwrZon-4all Před 12 dny

      You should do some research on what is being taught with the teachers, ask your neighbors, etc. good luck to you and your kids.

    • @beanybabyrabie
      @beanybabyrabie Před 8 dny

      @@user-mi5dt1js6fthey won’t LET you in the classroom today. They used COVID and then obsessed about gun control and now parents have never re-entered the schools…….

    • @beanybabyrabie
      @beanybabyrabie Před 8 dny

      Yep. I’m terrified. My child is older now (still not in middle school) but I’m highly suspicious and we’ve have multiple conversations about him hearing key words and immediately telling me.
      They’re actively keeping us parents out of the schools and out of the class rooms…. #1 career that donates to democrats I believe

  • @10onpump5
    @10onpump5 Před 17 dny +2

    It’s about time to bring Mr. Walsh back (he has a new film coming out!)

  • @Majinblaze
    @Majinblaze Před měsícem +153

    The definition of "marriage" that Joe proposes here is actually the definition of "Civil Union." The two are not interchangeable because they have different origins and purposes. Matt is 100% correct on this - even if he couldn't quite articulate it in this session.
    Marriage is the recognition of spiritual AND legal union - coupled with the expectation and opportunity to form a new family unit.
    A civil union is the recognition of two individuals who love eachother and want to dedicate themselves legally to that coupling.
    There is a REASON that gay people want "mariage" and not "civil union" - and that's the connotation that the term brings -- To set out on a journey of building a family together and becoming parents for the next generation is such a big deal to human beings (since time immemorial) that we have always gone out of the way to celebrate these unions in a big way.
    A civil union doesn't get the same treatment societally because it is, literally, just designed for the happiness of those involved. It brings with it no such glorification, because it's not a proclamation of one's willingness to further the species and/or participate in societal customs. It's just two people saying "this one's mine."
    The problem, as Matt tried to explain, is that modern society has completely lost touch with this fact - and is treating them interchangeably. The result is that marriage as an institution has been degraded of all of it's value and is treated identically to civil unions - The only noteable difference now is that mariage comes with a few extra legal benefits.
    More and more young people are so disillusioned / removed from greater society and no longer see the value of marriage. Young men especially, since signing those papers essentially gives the women absolute control over their lives - with the opportunity to ruin them entirely and walk away scot-free.
    When marriage is degraded to "just a legal document" that "says you love eachother," more and more young people are asking "well...why is that needed then? Why sign my life away unnecessarily?"

    • @GaelynCunningham
      @GaelynCunningham Před měsícem +9

      Yeah, I was little bummed at Matt's response here. Definitely lacking. I thought he'd have a better grasp and response than that.

    • @kaitlynhope1268
      @kaitlynhope1268 Před měsícem +6

      You articulated this very well! I agreed with Matt Walsh on every point he made but it seemed like there was a bigger point that he was trying to get across that he just couldn’t find the words for.

    • @Leo4gzs
      @Leo4gzs Před měsícem +2

      Excellent. I was thinking about this while watching the episode.

    • @cayceesmith2650
      @cayceesmith2650 Před měsícem +2

      Wow! That last part was a little rough. I was married for 16 years, was narcissistically abused, and when I finally escaped, left 3 business that we had built together, a new house on an acreage, boat, cars, trucks, RV's, etc. I got no cash, no alimony, no child support. Our daughter and I were homeless for two years while I dug us out of the hole. So no, marriage is not a contract that allows a woman to ruin a man and take all his stuff.

    • @Sweaty_Grandpa
      @Sweaty_Grandpa Před měsícem +4

      @@cayceesmith2650 yes it is.

  • @Joyloulou
    @Joyloulou Před měsícem +156

    This was such a DEEP AND POWERFUL conversation. I love Matt Walsh and Joe Rogan. I am a Catholic Convert ex feminist

    • @TommyGunz327
      @TommyGunz327 Před měsícem +11

      Matt is 100% correct about the marriage issue. Joe is clueless like usual

    • @Joyloulou
      @Joyloulou Před měsícem +3

      @@TommyGunz327 is not Catholic yet but I did include him in my Rosary Prayer today with Father Rocky on Relevant Radio❤️🙏 I am asking Our Lady’s Intercession for his conversion. He is a good hearted man and seems just on the edge of realizing that he has a desire for a Faith Life. God changes hearts…I WAS a liberal and in my conversion to Catholicism I truly understand the disorder a mysogyny underneath homosexuality (I was bisexual and through conversion as well as Jungian type work I totally have been healed of same sex attraction)…see Mario Bergner’s book “Setting Love in Order” and Leanne Paynes book “The Broken Image”. Gay men were either molested/ or absent father/ overbearing mother…there is always a deep family of origin issue or molestation (even with Lesbians). In Lesbians there is some mother hunger absence of maternal love absence of father too.

    • @sebastiangaraycocheagomezd473
      @sebastiangaraycocheagomezd473 Před měsícem

      ​@@TommyGunz327really? How so?

    • @RallyTheTally
      @RallyTheTally Před měsícem +3

      Based. I'm a Baptist but I agree with that.

    • @aljan5047
      @aljan5047 Před měsícem +1

      @@TommyGunz327 Joe took the pride month to heart 🤣

  • @kevinmclaughlin3088
    @kevinmclaughlin3088 Před 3 dny +1

    I had no idea what Joe was doing in the beginning there. Like, are you telling Matt to slouch down? Telling Jaime to turn down the volume?
    Oh, no, you're just making coffee with a french press. What a nice host.

  • @DrDavenstein
    @DrDavenstein Před 14 dny +1

    This is absolutely heartbreaking. I have a 5 month old son, and if they do this to him, I am going to become a monster. 😢

  • @lizevandeven7904
    @lizevandeven7904 Před měsícem +129

    Thank you Matt for graciously standing firm.

  • @1000sister
    @1000sister Před měsícem +64

    I think Joe doesn’t really buy that the family unit is the basic building block for society to be good. Having a high quality society is not valued these days maybe because we have not experienced it recently.

    • @woodandwandco
      @woodandwandco Před měsícem

      The family is the fundamental building block of the society. Society is the larger family. If the society is not a single family, it is low-quality. A fractured society is a larger, fractured family. Families are a form of social embedding as old as evolution itself. Social embedding is a prerequisite for a high-quality society of any lifeform we are familiar with. Unfortunately, the enemies of all-human potentiation figured out a simple trick: convince children their parents are ignorant perpetually by embedding subtext in family-focused media (cartoons, children's edutainment films, holiday films, social dramas, etc.), by redirecting their interests away from the norm perpetually by funding novel socio-political constructs (feudalism, industrialism, communism, capitalism, techno-feudalism, etc.) The modes of governance are shifted generationally and intentionally to perpetuate the permanent disabling of families emerging from poverty or providing legitimate socio-economic instruction across generations. It is an old technique, as old as society itself, but the majority are too plugged in to the constructs to figure the totality of the system out.

  • @adamdrives365
    @adamdrives365 Před 14 dny +11

    Gotta give it to Matt for being so patient under constant pressure from Joe. Personally I feel that he’s missing the point.

    • @joanneboty4882
      @joanneboty4882 Před 5 dny +3

      I agree, he was insisting on his own personal level and missing the opportunity to understand the wider meaning.

  • @victor_bueno_br
    @victor_bueno_br Před 19 dny +6

    I feel like Matt lost himself a bit trying to explain the whole marriage thing, but I think I got what he meant. It's all about definition of the marriage institution. One could say it's a "loving union between a man and a woman in order to stablish a family by having children". So having children is recommended, because that's what marriage is for, but you can opt to have it without doing it. It's like buying a knife. A knife is for cutting. You can opt not to cut with it, but cutting is it's function. Now, if you call any sharp metal object a knife, soon you will be trying to cut your food with a hoe, and weed your yard with an axe.

    • @Edi1107
      @Edi1107 Před 10 dny

      If it works better for you, why not cut food with a hoe

  • @alexandertrossen5561
    @alexandertrossen5561 Před měsícem +235

    I love how intelligent and pragmatic MEN speak with eachother. There is a certain type of respect and accountability that makes the conversations blossom and become very contemplative. Each participant is evolving mentaly right in front of your eyes

    • @lisareiter5368
      @lisareiter5368 Před měsícem +14

      That’s what I was just thinking. I sent this to my son as an example of good conversation.

    • @rgCA_01123
      @rgCA_01123 Před měsícem +2

    • @christopherrobbin847
      @christopherrobbin847 Před měsícem

      Men remain civilized with other men because with every interaction there is a threat of violence, so typically they will both maintain their composure

    • @nik07nik
      @nik07nik Před měsícem +16

      Except when Joe expects Matt to answer for an entire religion. He have never treated a Muslim this way on the show.

    • @austinfonk8945
      @austinfonk8945 Před měsícem +1

      ​@@lisareiter5368great idea 🙏🏻

  • @nonosays
    @nonosays Před měsícem +218

    Marriage has never been looked upon in any society throughout history as merely a construct of Man, it has always been seen as a creation of God and Nature and merely recognized as such by Man.
    This is so fundamental it defies any disagreement.
    It is because man and woman alone carry the procreative potential that marriage has been seen as the building block of society.
    It is a new thing to say now Marriage is a lifestyle choice based on individual feelings.
    A formal acknowledgement of a gay union might be a good thing, but it can never replace the purpose of Marriage for society.
    This is a fundamental change in the way society has been ordered since recorded time.
    We will, as Matt suggests, see in time what this change has yielded for society and our civilization.

    • @user-rs6vc1xe5s
      @user-rs6vc1xe5s Před měsícem

      The whole second half of this podcast really put on display how joe is only able to see reality through a hedonic lens.. from devorce, to the choìce of childless union, to people prefering same sex relations... everything he said was on wants and feels... total hedonism. Marriage is duty not choice. Sex for pleasure is an immoral selfish act. No one is born gay, some kids just never have their narcissism checked by a strong father and a loving mother in a proper marriage and so they come up with warped perceptions of sexuality and self to societies detriment.

    • @chloesanders3631
      @chloesanders3631 Před měsícem +2

      Once it gets to that point though, the source of degradation will likely be skewed and/or ignored completely by the majority. Not trying to be a negative nelly, it's been a pattern of human history to twist said history for one's own personal gains

    • @snu3877
      @snu3877 Před měsícem

      Conservatives were laughed at/derided for saying the legalization of gay marriage was the beginning of a slippery slope. And here we are. Once gay people achieved their goal, they had to figure out where to turn their attention and funds. They chose trans rights, although many gays are either unaware of that or furiously backpedaling away from that.

    • @CipherDiaz
      @CipherDiaz Před měsícem +12

      Its not that clear cut. The idea of marriage that we have today came in through christianity. Roman law, greek law, asian law, ancient egyptian law -- they were all different. Marriage in roman and greek terms had nothing to do with love. In fact, up until the middle-ages the very idea that you married for love was regarded as absurd. Your parents picked for you, often in a strategic way to join families and obtain wealth. So the idea of romantic or "love" based marriage is a relatively new notion. Christianity did not care about the love aspect either until the age of the chivalry. People really need to read history, including the darker aspects

    • @MsJom123
      @MsJom123 Před měsícem

      @@CipherDiazindeed. That is the individual level it affects. The societal is less children. We are living that out heavily at this point. The west is well below replacement level at this point. The need in a society to at minimum keep replacement rate cannot be understated. This is why couples that marry and don’t have children actually do hurt other people. The economy suffers, the social programs become more burdened, the next generation of workers disappear and on and on. Then amplify those problems even further by saying anyone can get married and it doesn’t matter at all. The two same sex cannot naturally have children and that won’t help. Then if they do decide they want children they will have to use surrogacy or something. In this method they are intentionally depriving the child of either the actual mother or father. In some cases both. (This is especially egregious as a child has a right to be raised by their biological mother and father. Does that always play out, unfortunately not. In cases where the parents did something to lose those rights for the safety of the child or something. However as a society we shouldn’t start with that.) And that is all to fulfill their desire to have kids. A good thing in it itself but done in the most selfish way possible. Certainly marriage as it has historically been defined is better for everyone it impacts.

  • @Alex-dx1lq
    @Alex-dx1lq Před 13 dny +4

    This is why i love JR podcast ! It is very clear that Joe disagrees with Matt on the subject of gay marriage. And i do too. But instead of insulting Matt.... he is asking questions, laying out his point of view and just trying to understand why Matt is thinking the way he does. To have a civil conversation with someone that has a different point of view, is a trade that is getting lost with this generation

  • @MattF433
    @MattF433 Před 4 dny

    Great job to both.
    Intense back and forth between the two and both were able to have the time and space to flush their points out without a single name call, character assault, straw man, fake stat, etc. So rare.

  • @jfuriouse1234
    @jfuriouse1234 Před měsícem +53

    Official Rogan quote “people shouldn’t be expected to stay married for life” lol Joe, that’s what he’s talking about.. Marriage doesn’t matter anymore, he’s explaining why that’s happened.. And yea, if you make a contracted commitment to a marriage, it should be hard to get out of..

    • @davidtomkins4242
      @davidtomkins4242 Před měsícem +3

      It used to be hard to get out of as recently as the 50s and 60s. You were shunned by your close society. It caused misery for everyone involved - those who stayed in loveless cohabitation, kids growing up with parents who hate each other or live in fear of their parent, and those who were ostracised by their church and village/society. We changed divorce laws for the better

    • @jesseryan3256
      @jesseryan3256 Před měsícem +2

      Gay marriage has only been legal in the US for less than 20 years so explain the increasing divorce rate and other things they discussed before it was legalized. Marriage may not mean as much as it used to but I highly doubt gay marriage caused as much of that problem as Matt is saying. Realistically it’s the lack of thought before actually getting married and then the easiness of modern day divorce.

    • @gurugru5958
      @gurugru5958 Před měsícem +3

      People sometimes get into marriages that turn out to be incredible abusive... at the very least, it should be easy for people to get away from that.

    • @sameash3153
      @sameash3153 Před měsícem +8

      ​@@gurugru5958 I don't know why people say this like it's some kind of own. Most hardcore stay-married-for-life advocates acknowledge the "Three As" as acceptable reasons for divorce: abuse, addiction, adultery. What is being criticized is no-fault divorce, where neither of the above are present.

    • @gurugru5958
      @gurugru5958 Před měsícem

      @@sameash3153 Yeah, I can agree with that.

  • @ambersolomon7942
    @ambersolomon7942 Před měsícem +231

    Matt Walsh is a true inspiration and love his work with the Daily Wire. Fantastic episode!

    • @crunchywashere3513
      @crunchywashere3513 Před měsícem +7

      Matt is a clown at best

    • @xandyrwlkyr2563
      @xandyrwlkyr2563 Před měsícem +17

      @@crunchywashere3513 No, I don't always agree with him. But, he is very serious about his convictions and for the most part they are based on sound reason and data. Clown is the last descriptor you could append to such a person.

    • @amostlyreasonableguy
      @amostlyreasonableguy Před měsícem +9

      @@crunchywashere3513yes, when I think of clown I think calm, rational person with consistent values who can articulate them well in an even tone of voice

    • @adrianharry5336
      @adrianharry5336 Před měsícem

      Quite interestingly EVERYTHING Joe Rogan said to defend homosexuality is what Trans advocates use to defend transgenderism. It’s quite remarkable that each generation is swept up by something new with the EXACT SAME SENTIMENT, P3dophilia 🔜

    • @adrianharry5336
      @adrianharry5336 Před měsícem

      @@crunchywashere3513how so?

  • @GabrielSantos-dm5pm
    @GabrielSantos-dm5pm Před 12 dny +2

    People who have much deeper voices than you expect

  • @06Adrianne
    @06Adrianne Před 17 dny +1

    Amazing conversation … made me query my own perspective and that is never a bad thing. I applaud you both for the platform and space you gave each other to discuss a delicate and nuanced subject 👏👏

  • @jedicodm4341
    @jedicodm4341 Před měsícem +28

    Matt Walshes documentary should be put into school systems

    • @noless
      @noless Před měsícem +1

      It was better than I thought it would be. Funny, tragic, scary

  • @TheTexasBoys
    @TheTexasBoys Před měsícem +33

    Noah Webster's 1884 dictionary defines marriage as "the act of uniting a man and woman for life; wedlock; the legal union of a man and woman for life." It emphasizes the legal and lifelong union between a man and woman.

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před měsícem +1

      @@TheTexasBoys great for 1884, what's that matter now?

    • @mepatton
      @mepatton Před 22 dny +5

      @@TheFloridaBro There is no justification for changing it now, and no authority to do so. Unlike the approach taken today where a cabal of ideological nitwits changes the definitions of words in online dictionaries on a whim, to suite their ideological predilections, the original compilers of dictionaries worked diligently to clarify definitions that expressed the observable and documented meaning of the word as used in society. They took their role seriously.

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před 22 dny +1

      @mepatton an appeal to definition for a cultural construct like marriage is the lowest form of argument you could make, if it can even be called an argument. That was the definition in 1884 for those particular, very serious men. Their definition doesn't extend to the infinite future.

    • @mepatton
      @mepatton Před 22 dny

      @@TheFloridaBro You're entirely wrong. The definition laid down in 1884 was mostly definitely NOT "the defition for those particular, very serious men," it was the OBSERVABLE RECOGNIZED DEFINITION of society as far back as they could document it. You demonstrate no comprehension of how dictionaries came to be, and no awareness that the English speaking world is not the only society which has recognized what marriage is. You will not find any significant different in the understanding of what marriage is in any society in the history of the world, regardless of the language they spoke. Marriage isn't a "cutural construct" as you #RegressiveleftistDipshits use the term. It is an observed action ("to marry") and an observed state of being ("marriage"). No one sat down one day and made up what they thought it should be at the time; both the act and the state of being predate written history and are present in all civilizations.

    • @justinhill2378
      @justinhill2378 Před 22 dny +1

      ​@@mepattonin 1884 the word gay meant something totally different also.

  • @MrRavenArrowz
    @MrRavenArrowz Před 4 dny

    I saw the bootleg copy of "what is a woman" and i'm glad I did. You are doing good work, Matt Walsh, and you have a good sense of humor.

  • @beanybabyrabie
    @beanybabyrabie Před 8 dny +3

    Bring Matt back!

  • @joefrank3439
    @joefrank3439 Před měsícem +24

    I don’t agree with Walsh in all subjects, but he is a great man fighting for a great cause! He speaks for all the people who can’t for fear of losing one’s livelihood

    • @lisareiter5368
      @lisareiter5368 Před měsícem

      Matt is pretty smart on most topics…except for saying fat people are gluttons and food can’t be addictive. I have seen too many CZcams videos of people who lost weight once they gave up carbs.

    • @doid4354
      @doid4354 Před 20 dny

      @@lisareiter5368 well fat people a lot of the time are gluttons. if people are able to stop at some point then it means it's a choice

  • @deadfall0324
    @deadfall0324 Před měsícem +17

    My father would always tell me “silence can make a man speak” just nod and listen when someone talks and they will tell you a lot, maybe more than they intend

  • @seanlara
    @seanlara Před 24 dny +6

    Crazy how quickly this episode turned from both Matt and Joe seemingly being 100% on the same page, to having completely opposing viewpoints. While I don't agree with Matt's position on marriage, I can certainly appreciate the respectful dialogue and maturity between the two of them. Props to them both.

  • @LectioDivina33
    @LectioDivina33 Před 18 dny +2

    Joe shows through his questioning that he doesn't understand the Catholic doctrine. Matt held back and was very careful with his answers. I would not have held back. Joe needs to interview Bishop Robert Barron, Exorcist Fr Chad Ripperger & Exorcist Carlos Martins and Joe will get the answers he is looking for!

  • @patrichohl-uv7be
    @patrichohl-uv7be Před měsícem +128

    My favorite episode. Matt Walsh speaks the truth. Every parent in Portland needs to watch "what is a woman"

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před měsícem

      How do you know what he's saying is "truth"? Because you agree with him?

    • @patrichohl-uv7be
      @patrichohl-uv7be Před měsícem +4

      Yes

    • @thzzzt
      @thzzzt Před měsícem +1

      Especially those parents than don't understand that Portlandia is intended as a comedy.

    • @johnv6806
      @johnv6806 Před měsícem +8

      ​@@TheFloridaBroit's biological fact. How do you know you're human?

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před měsícem

      @@johnv6806 I understand the principle, but there is more of a social element to how people choose to present themselves. There is such thing as a biological woman, and there is such thing as a trans woman. Trans species might not be too far behind, depending on how technology/biological sciences advance.

  • @williamconn1259
    @williamconn1259 Před měsícem +75

    I'm on Matt Walsh's side.

  • @Damudean
    @Damudean Před 14 dny +1

    Wow, Rogan and Matt for 3 hours I wonder how this goes

  • @jcrcreations4515
    @jcrcreations4515 Před 15 dny +1

    The stat at 54:50 about 4,780 kids getting puberty blockers is only kids that have already been diagnosed with gender dysphoria, which I imagine they no longer diagnose and I don’t even think it’s in the DSM 5 anymore (the standard list of diagnoses and their requirements), so the number of kids who have received puberty blockers is probably a lot higher.

  • @dudedarkness
    @dudedarkness Před 27 dny +23

    I absolutely love that there was a debate on a sensitive topic and both men remained gentmanly (not a word) and cordial. This is something we need to see more of in the political and professional arenas. Great work!

    • @Absrod
      @Absrod Před 12 dny +4

      Agreed. Gentlemanly is a word btw

  • @chrisgunther109
    @chrisgunther109 Před měsícem +339

    On marriage I don't get why Joe keeps going back to "well it's their choice." Matt's whole point is "it's not good for society." There are a whole lot of personal choices that everyone can make which will lead society to absolute ruin, and the vast majority of them would not effect you personally in the immediate.

    • @fredricks8701
      @fredricks8701 Před měsícem

      Gay marriave will lead t0 "societal ruin"? 🙄

    • @ExpertContrarian
      @ExpertContrarian Před měsícem +30

      Because it’s their choice. You have no actual proof that is bad for society. Most marriages could be argued as bad for society. So should the government evaluate each and every single potential marriage to see whether we will be harmful and be the ones to decide whether it can happen? Why do you want more government oversight and tyranny?

    • @tashavdlinde6260
      @tashavdlinde6260 Před měsícem +26

      No, I don't have a problem with gay marriage, but I do believe that's where the slippery slope began and that there wasn't a line drawn ever since.

    • @Empoweringhistory
      @Empoweringhistory Před měsícem +17

      100% agree jow ruined the conversation on the topic

    • @cynthiag1557
      @cynthiag1557 Před měsícem +16

      That's the beauty of your personal political beliefs. I"m a centrist, libertarian but right leaning libertarian and while I think it's wrong to teach this gendered confusion to children, if you are an adult in a same sex relationship, and want to get married, then you should be able to get married. I"m all for people being treated respectfully and equally unless they give me, or society as a whole a reason not to treat them respectfully or equally.

  • @michaelcowdrey4494
    @michaelcowdrey4494 Před 13 dny +1

    They should call it hormone conditioning not therapy

  • @Silversoon78910
    @Silversoon78910 Před 24 dny +1

    Two people that are so amazing and kind.

  • @Cacuofa
    @Cacuofa Před měsícem +25

    Saying you are 5 when you are 38 is less crazy than a man saying he is a woman. At least sometime he was 5 and knows what being 5 feels like. You can’t say you feel you are a woman’s because you like the color pink and fashion shows. I don’t understand women who are in favor of this.
    Doing this only serves to demean and diminish the real significance of being a woman to frivolous, material ideas.

    • @beanybabyrabie
      @beanybabyrabie Před 8 dny +1

      This is SUCH a good point.
      At some point all these males had a moment where they though “well I feel this way which is different than some of the guys I’ve observed, women must feel this way too therefore I am a woman”
      SMH

  • @johnnunn8688
    @johnnunn8688 Před měsícem +102

    Hate to see Joe using ‘she/her’ for a man. Matt has it right.

    • @Whyexes
      @Whyexes Před 23 dny +7

      Weird how he can acknowledge how the movie shows the insanity of the position but then Joe also plays ball.

  • @NancySwass
    @NancySwass Před 2 dny +1

    AND, IF YOU ARE MARRIED, Joe, and Matt, send my gratitude home to them, please. Behind good men, there are good wives.

  • @jakes.5591
    @jakes.5591 Před 12 dny +3

    Gay marriage was the first step toward the gender confusion.
    It was the first thing to say "man and woman isn't a significant thing."

    • @oliver556
      @oliver556 Před 3 dny

      This makes no sense at all. It's just allowing 2 people of the same sex get married. In what way does that negate or reduce marriage between a man and a woman?

    • @petesmitt
      @petesmitt Před 2 dny

      @@oliver556 Marriage between a man and a woman has a potential for having children; this is not possible with unions of the same sex; for society to allow gay marriage pollutes and degrades the meaning of marriage and it does make sense that society moves further to pervert the clear separation of what it means to be male and female.

  • @harloss9839
    @harloss9839 Před měsícem +40

    Joe keeps asking "what's the damage to a straight relationship because of a gay relationship" Matt Keeps answering "the damage I'm talking about is to society and the safe and best environment for child rearing NOT to my existing marriage or any other individual relationship" then Joe obviously doesn't listen and just asks the same question again...

    • @ThePossumone
      @ThePossumone Před 23 dny +2

      Yes - Matt looks Big Picture not his own personal inconvenience

    • @nedhill1242
      @nedhill1242 Před 20 dny +1

      @@ThePossumone Exactly and if you look at countries and cultures doing better than America they are all traditional, homogenous, and in so many ways, if not completely, culturally opposite of America. And as America has become more secular and progressive we have declined. The irony is every country progressives point to as superior to America, their cultures are the exact opposite of America and often Catholic. And they love brown and/or Muslim cultures that are radically traditional, which is what they despise about America. Their cognitive dissonance is epic.

    • @ThePossumone
      @ThePossumone Před 20 dny

      @@nedhill1242 interesting isnt it how deceived people can be

    • @nedhill1242
      @nedhill1242 Před 20 dny

      @@ThePossumone
      It proves how easy it is to brainwash people. I’m 58 years old. People I went to college with back in the 80s would never ever have been on board with today’s radical agenda back then. But now whatever the Democrats tell them to think they rabidly defend. They love to mock conservatives and libertarians as being brainwashed, but we actually believe in objective truth, science, reality, data, science. They are the ones that believe things that are objectively false. We can prove what they believe is factually incorrect. But they still will not change their mind. It’s literally 1984 and precisely as Yuri Bezmenov described.
      During pride I I got into fights on Instagram with very radical & privileged very attractive white women in their 20s and 30s. They loved saying go away old white man. And of course they arrogantly thought they were being funny and profound. I would immediately point out that they have a soft privileged life thanks to old white men. Everything they use and enjoy daily and take for granted was invented by an old white man. They have the right to vote because of old white men. They have freedom thanks to old white men. The reason they can even have a pride parade and the rights enjoyed by homosexuals today is because of old white men. So show some respect & appreciation.
      The combination of the media selling out to the far left and the radicalization of the public school system by way of teachers union is what got us to where we are today.

  • @angelodimas1962
    @angelodimas1962 Před měsícem +69

    Dude I'm getting chills listening to this... So glad we have people like Matt big fan had to catch this episode.

  • @flaviolofaro
    @flaviolofaro Před dnem

    MATT IS A LEGEND, PLEASE HAVE HIM AGAIN….FASCINATING TO LISTEN TO HIM 😊

  • @MichaeMichaelMichael
    @MichaeMichaelMichael Před 16 dny +1

    Kudos for having him on.

  • @ericshaunfield9304
    @ericshaunfield9304 Před měsícem +94

    Statute of limitations for medical malpractice in most states is 2 years. The high being 5 years. If the statute of limitations was raised. Especially for minors so they have a solid decade after they turn 18… and absolutely NO doctors would do hormones, puberty blockers, or surgery on minors.

    • @ericsmith1508
      @ericsmith1508 Před měsícem +9

      The problem is that it isn't "malpractice" to do a transition surgery or medications. These are procedures that are fully legal for the doctor to do, and as long as the end results are technically correct, then it isn't "malpractice." If the puberty blockers blocked puberty exactly as intended, if the surgery went as expected and was performed correctly, then it isn't "malpractice." From a legal standpoint, that is.
      From a moral standpoint, it is evil, ritual mutilation in the name of Satan, and should absolutely be stopped, not just in minors but in adults as well!!
      I said what I said. 🤨

    • @oliviatiller1088
      @oliviatiller1088 Před měsícem

      THIS!

    • @niceyoutubehandle
      @niceyoutubehandle Před měsícem +2

      @@ericsmith1508 let’s make it malpractice then 😎

    • @terryfinley4979
      @terryfinley4979 Před měsícem

      That’s a great point.

    • @akboyz1
      @akboyz1 Před měsícem

      ​@@ericsmith1508That is factually incorrect. When treating a patient you have to have to determine: the right patient, right medication/procedure, the right dose, the right time right route. This is typically used for medication administration but is true for any aspect of the medical system. Deviation from it does constitute malpractice. You can't suggest that A: a child can consent to any of this, or B: that a practitioner is not liable for their actions that have long term harm so long as they did their buchery well.

  • @jakobiner6083
    @jakobiner6083 Před měsícem +48

    Matt walsh is great!

  • @joyvellema6799
    @joyvellema6799 Před 22 dny +2

    Matt is saying marriage, by definition, is not necessarily legal but spiritual, religious. Sacred. 50%divorce rate says marriage is not being taken seriously. It is viewed as a legal document so somebody can have money. That's not what marriage is about. That's a civil union

  • @mmartin8877
    @mmartin8877 Před 25 dny +2

    Wait until they see the Olympics opening..

  • @blueninja87
    @blueninja87 Před měsícem +24

    Bring Matt back for a another conversation Joe!

    • @ShimonFrankel
      @ShimonFrankel Před 20 dny

      What more is there to talk about?

    • @blueninja87
      @blueninja87 Před 20 dny +4

      @@ShimonFrankel Updates. Plenty of things. Cmon now. That's what makes joe Rogan podcast #1. He brings people back for more conversations.

    • @johnnyfreespeech5815
      @johnnyfreespeech5815 Před 19 dny +1

      @@ShimonFrankelThe usual stuff of course. UFOs, conspiracies and cults etc... it would be great to see Matt and Joe discuss the legitimacy of Bigfoot identifying as non binary.

  • @darkerthanblack6413
    @darkerthanblack6413 Před měsícem +116

    I love how honest matt walsh is

    • @jessm8696
      @jessm8696 Před měsícem +10

      It’s so refreshing

    • @bradgilbert6718
      @bradgilbert6718 Před měsícem +11

      Just a few minutes in and I love that he calls him Bruce.

    • @celebritarian
      @celebritarian Před měsícem +1

      @@bradgilbert6718did Matt call Joe Bruce, or the other way around? I didn’t catch that.

    • @AlexStein-q3d
      @AlexStein-q3d Před měsícem +10

      @@celebritarianhe called caytlin Jenner Bruce 😂

    • @niceyoutubehandle
      @niceyoutubehandle Před měsícem +6

      @@AlexStein-q3dbased Matt

  • @seasidesue816
    @seasidesue816 Před 17 dny +5

    Joe!!! You’re NOT listening!

  • @RMD-uw5np
    @RMD-uw5np Před 20 dny +1

    I have a patient that is a corrections officer in NY and she told me at the women’s prison she works at they estimate the population is almost 20% men. She was in an altercation with a male trans pretender and durning the confrontation words were exchanged and she told me afterwards she was pulled aside by her supervisors and scolded for misgendering the inmate.

  • @dewindae3059
    @dewindae3059 Před měsícem +125

    What Joe calls marriage and what Matt calls marriage are two different things.

    • @drunknluv78
      @drunknluv78 Před měsícem +31

      I understand both sides. Matt is explaining the reason marriage exists while Joe is explaining why people want to marry. Both correct in their own way.

    • @mitchc3569
      @mitchc3569 Před měsícem +11

      Joe Is NOT a Texan.

    • @edjackson4389
      @edjackson4389 Před měsícem +1

      That's because the true definition of marriage isn't clear. Unless you're speaking of the legal aspects

    • @DarkLawify
      @DarkLawify Před měsícem +26

      @@edjackson4389 No it is perfectly clear. It is just people outside of the religious context in which it should remain, don't believe the sacramental value of it.
      Have your civil unions, I have nothing against that, but to call them marriage... is pushing it.

    • @dino_spamonie
      @dino_spamonie Před měsícem +20

      ​@@mitchc3569I was slamming my head against the wall listening to Joe explain what he thinks marriage is

  • @swampypolitics9574
    @swampypolitics9574 Před měsícem +97

    Kids and humans have never before in history had so much access to " mental health care".. and yet it's getting worse. This should scream volumes

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před měsícem +3

      @swampypolitics9574 kids and humans? What a strange set of categories lol.

    • @swampypolitics9574
      @swampypolitics9574 Před měsícem +5

      @@TheFloridaBro as in kids, the main point. And humanity in general.

    • @AlCapwnd-tb5ow
      @AlCapwnd-tb5ow Před měsícem +1

      Did you forget how expensive healthcare is in the USA? If you don’t have insurance good luck getting help you need.

    • @TheFloridaBro
      @TheFloridaBro Před měsícem

      @@AlCapwnd-tb5ow Obama care bro

    • @AlCapwnd-tb5ow
      @AlCapwnd-tb5ow Před měsícem +2

      @@TheFloridaBro just because you qualify for Obama care doesn't mean we all do

  • @kevinmorris7722
    @kevinmorris7722 Před 8 dny +7

    A minor can't sign a contract. Medical services included signatures. That alone makes it illegal.

  • @Anthony-ov8jq
    @Anthony-ov8jq Před 20 dny +1

    I can assure that as a therapist I do not push such narratives nor was I trained to do so....

  • @Local_Shark_Enthusiast7462
    @Local_Shark_Enthusiast7462 Před měsícem +14

    I wish the film was on public places for those extremely misinformed people this film is aimed for. Love your work Matt 🫶

    • @patrickboyle932
      @patrickboyle932 Před 18 dny

      Matts not in the business of informing people. He's in the business of making money by talking about things that he is entirely unqualified to talk about.

  • @macngeeseyt6029
    @macngeeseyt6029 Před měsícem +1691

    Sweet baby gang come on!

    • @jflesh8673
      @jflesh8673 Před měsícem +47

      GAAAYYY…

    • @guitardadsinc
      @guitardadsinc Před měsícem +54

      @@jflesh8673how … dare you… insult thy sweet baby gang!? We will find you. 😢

    • @jflesh8673
      @jflesh8673 Před měsícem +10

      @@Ohgreatitsthisfreakinguyagain it’s the gayest thing you can refer to yourself as and it’s Matt Walsh..

    • @robertfrancois6064
      @robertfrancois6064 Před měsícem +20

      😆is Matt the sweet daddy? Who came up with that? I’m not here to tease anyone but that’s awfully gay

    • @JenniferMiller-sx1xn
      @JenniferMiller-sx1xn Před měsícem +17

      @@robertfrancois6064it’s just an awesome troll

  • @jasonmills8592
    @jasonmills8592 Před 10 dny +1

    Boxes have corners.

  • @glxracer337
    @glxracer337 Před 21 hodinou +1

    Joe gave Matt a cigar and then tried to put him on the ropes about his views on Gay marriage. Joe will not understand Matt's religious beliefs, And shaming him for them or trying to force him to defend himself changes this from a conversation to a conflict.

  • @garrett892
    @garrett892 Před měsícem +15

    Marriage has become more of a legal status for taxes and protections under the law than a sacred union between two people. Society is slowly devolving.

    • @jimbob9407
      @jimbob9407 Před měsícem

      Do you know why the tax incentive is there?

    • @musemuser777
      @musemuser777 Před měsícem +1

      Orwellian nightmare now...

    • @DeadEyedTye
      @DeadEyedTye Před 24 dny +5

      Genuine marriage stopped existing well over 30 years ago if you didn't notice.

  • @frankperdue6585
    @frankperdue6585 Před měsícem +18

    I know they always switch around, but the Matt Walsh ARMS AGAPE is the greatest thumbnail EVER

  • @brianmitchell8680
    @brianmitchell8680 Před 20 dny

    What a fantastic conversation between two people with different belief structure. I love it. Society needs more of this!

  • @jasonmills8592
    @jasonmills8592 Před 10 dny +1

    Good faith isn't a tool to be used to do bad things, Joe.

  • @SancLunatic
    @SancLunatic Před měsícem +27

    The debate on marriage was really good. Its one of the rare debates where even though I may agree a little more with one side, both Joe and Matt articulated their arguments well.

    • @ccoddington
      @ccoddington Před 13 dny

      Seemed like Joe tried to steamroll him at certain points but Matt showed great patience.

  • @billmara7215
    @billmara7215 Před měsícem +9

    This is a great conversation by two thoughtful people and no hatred. Thank you both.

  • @toaster3822
    @toaster3822 Před 16 dny

    Adding to the other comments asking for a second interview! Hopefully they can set this up after Matts new movie in september.

  • @jennifermommy9373
    @jennifermommy9373 Před 24 dny +1

    The french language is also gendered. It uses masculine and feminine the same as the latin language