A CONFUSED Conclusion - Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 12. 2019
- Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS: clcr.me/XqNPjP ✅ ANDROID: clcr.me/T2W7se Start with💰50K silver and get a Free Epic Champion 💥 on day 7 of “New Player Rewards” program
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is most definitely controversial, and this is my opinion on the film! Hope you enjoy! :O
The Browntable Patreon!
/ browntable
Browntable Discord! - / discord
Browntable Subreddit! - Send me stuff/ Ask me stuff
/ new
Browntable Merch!
teespring.com/stores/browntable
Follow on Twitter
/ browntable_ent
Follow on Instagram
browntable_... - Zábava
Thanks for watching my thoughts on the film! Big thank you to Raid Shadow Legends for sponsoring this video! Check em out, you support my channel in doing so! Install Raid for Free - IOS: clcr.me/XqNPjP | ANDROID: clcr.me/T2W7se You start with 50K silver and a Free Epic Champion on day 7 of “New Player Rewards” program!
No you
Y'all are missing out on Sir Thiccolas
Browntable that man is the only real chad
@@Browntable personally I love Raid. And this isnt an ad
Yeyeye get that ad money my man.
Palpatine: I am all the sith.
Rey: and?
Palpatine: I am the senate.
Rey: Better.....but not quite what I meant.
@@rexerator And... I am your father
DEW IT
Not having a thousand Jedi force ghosts appear behind Rey when she says "and I am all the Jedi" is one of the biggest wasted opportunities in film history. The line, and the moment is already dumb, just lean into it. Give me the father/son Kamehameha
Jedi spirit bomb is more like it, or Jedi avatar state lol
The line is already an Endgame ripoff
Yes but also what doesnt add up to me is that when i heard Anakin's voice call out to Rey saying bring balance like i did or something, i dont get why he doesnt call out to his grandson Ben Solo also? I mean Reys not even a Skywalker by blood.
I actually was afraid that Force Ghosts/manifestations/projections of former Sith Lords (Vader, Maul, Dooku) and Jedi Knights (Obi-Wan, Luke, Yoda) would appear at at that moment and start fighting each other.
@warystatue33 They ALREADY borked the concept of force ghosts in the previous films. May as well go full ham in the end.
this movie completely violates show don't tell.
the
entire
film
I thought quite the opposite. TFA more violates show don’t tell. This one follows the rule to the point where it collapses in on itself.
@@Gemnist98 I feel like I sort of understand where you're coming from, when we get a lot of information in scenes lasting only a few seconds to establish something (ie Ben getting his helmet repaired being visually shown to the audience)
But for me, show don't tell is important for character development. Characters shouldn't be explaining how they feel to the audience, we should be interpreting it through their actions, but this movie has no time for that. One of the worst cases of this that sticks out in my mind is when Rey out loud explains why she needs to confront palpatine. This is key information about character motivation that shouldn't just be blatantly spelled out to the audience. I feel like it was done in tfa because there was a lot to establish between rotj and tfa. That doesn't necessarily make it right, but I understand why they did it.
the
entire
trilogy
@@maxcovfefe nah. 8 is pretty much the opposite of this
@@felipea1399 huh, can't honestly disagree with that, but not in a good way. I wanted to like this whole series, but the final 2 felt very much like -homage- parody. 8 showed a lot but didn't tell me anything interesting or new, or maybe there was something more in the books, but I didn't read them. I still like the first 3 originals best. That said, I'm warming up to The Mandalorian. :)
I wonder how much money it took to get Harrison Ford to reprise his role lol
RIGHT?
@@Browntable Also, did you feel like that was actually supposed to be Leia? But they had to rewrite it, because she died before they could film it?
@@HolybasilYT That was exactly my thought...
@@HolybasilYT no because it was showing kylos regret about killing Han
@@alextherichardson Right after Leia used the remaining life force she had to zone Ben out for 30 seconds. Come on... It was supposed to be a force projection like Luke did to Ben in TLJ.
Honestly, my biggest issue with the Sequel Trilogy was the waste of some really great actors/characters. Take Finn for example, he had a really interesting back story, a good actor in the role, and so many cool possible pathways... could he be force sensitive? Could he be a spy? Is he really good or just scared? All these things were wasted and he was turned into a source for slapstick comedy and cheesy one liners. Kind of defines the whole trilogy for me, alot of wasted golden opportunities... heartbreaking.
I think Finn is a prime example of the disconnect between Abrams and Johnson. Clearly JJ had things set up for him. And Rian literally had him wasted in the second movie. Meanwhile, I think Abrams always had Finn becoming Force sensitive. Finn's arc in ROS feels like the halfway point of his story, not the end. I blame Johnson
Finn had no arc. It would have been so poignant if he died in Last Jedi sacrificing himself destroying the mini Death Star in the name of the rebels
Basically this type of character arc was done better when they did it with Agent Kallus.
I so wish they explored the mentality of being an ex stormtrooper and what that would do to a person and how he'd learn to live beyond that. I thought we might finally get something like that with Janna, but instead we were told that she and the others were all former troopers and then it was never addressed again
I agree, Maz was wasted how did she find Luke's father's lightsaber? A story that will never be told. Captain Phasma wasted, Hux wasted really, the Knights of Ren! Such cool and mysterious characters completely wasted. R2 D2 hardly did anything either, and D-0 what did he really do? I cant remember. The "Sith Storm Troopers" were just RED thats it, they did jack shit we hardly saw them. All those Star Destroyers with mini death star weapons attached to them and only one fired at a planet.
The whole movie is one big waste, this "Disney Trilogy" a wasted opportunity.
I actually laughed in the cinema when Rey took Iron Man's line.
Peter Frank I shouted out ‘Iron Man’ when she said that. Unfortunately, no one reacted 😢
InTheAirMC and Yoshu yeah that typically happens when you yell in a theater.
Ya they also copied endgame marketing revealing title with first trailer 😂
To me this movie was like the bow on a present. In some ways you can say that it ties everything together. In other ways it has no substance in comparison to the gift inside.
Brilliant
Or like putting a bow on a pile of shit
Panama more like putting a pile of shit on a half-decent present 😆
Yeah, if the gift is Baby Yoda. As for the final trilogy of the Skywalker saga, a bow woulda blended perfectly into everything else they tried to throw at it.
And to think, your car collection is that amazing, even with the Ferrari under wraps.
Imagine if Obi Wan said hello there when all the voices of the Jedi were talking. That would’ve been amazing. 😂
“Hello there! We’re with you Rey!” I would’ve died in the theater
I liked the movie but jeez when Rey and Ben kissed and then he immediatly died I wanted to leave
Killing Ben was a fatal mistake.
It got weirder for me because I always saw them as siblings.
😬
R2 Well, he did propose to her in TLJ 😂
When Rey started to force pull the friggin ship out of the sky, I almost wanted to leave, but I did sigh heavily.
@@KalCraig Why?....???
i would have loved that at the end she didn’t choose to be a skywalker, but instead she chooses to just be Rey
I feel u, but imagine if she was like “Rey Rey” lmaoooo
Browntable 😂😂 i was thinking more along the lines of “just rey” but that would be goofy too
I was like just accept you're papa palps' girl 🤦
Damn bro, I actually liked this movie
My favourite part was when Thanos said “I am all the Sith” and then Tony said “I am all the Jedi” then snaps his fingers.
Wait...
My favorite moment from The Rise Of Skywalker is that it ends thank God put a bullet in the sequel trilogy head.
Thanos: I am inevitable.
Iron-Man: And I... am-
Rey: About to steal this man’s whole quote.
If I could sum up this entire trilogy in two words, it’s this: Missed potential. Some fantastic ideas and characters, but a lack of planning ruined it.
Exactly! It really feels that they had NO plan. It’s ironic the the mcguffin of the last movie was a map because the entire sequel trilogy felt like there was no map
In my opinion force awakens is the best star wars movie
@@Whateveridksomething TFA was a great movie. People just hate it because of the other two, even though I like episode 9.
@@mcoates agreed and they will find any reason to hate it "it's a reboot of a new hope"
@wilson fisk It is though? Watch the movie again and just try to tell me it isn’t mostly a copy-paste of A New Hope.
“Rey, I have to tell you something because you are the last one alive” “what is it, Finn?” Her heart reaching out. “I-I Love Poe” “Oh..” they die..
The whole theme of lineage not mattering to be a hero in last jedi is something that I loved. Something original, and they could have built on it instead of undoing it, and undoing everything TLJ did. Really disappointing.
TLJ shouldn't ever have happened....
I didn't see the last jedi yet but seeing episode 7 and 9 i could understand why rey is a palpatine? Kind of cause in the first she is super powerful
fuck the last jedi 😂 rise of sw gets high praise from me just because they literally wiped out the piece of garbage that was the last jedi
@@mrz4227 yeah, people like you are the reason why RoS is the PoS that we ended up with.
I agree i mean i did like Rey being a Skywalker but also did not mind her being a nobody either, but i got to say about TLJ being undone by TROS, i can only say now you know exactly how many fans who didnt like TLJ feel; and this movie doesnt even sit well with them either.
Jj wanted to retcon TLJ so much that he turned ROS into a movie solely for the purpose of retconning instead of finishing the trilogy which is why the trilogy and movie seem so incoherent and inconsistent it sucks that jj didnt get to fulfill his vision for the trilogy buts hes got to live with what RJ gave him
If JJ had visions about the story, he should have handed that over to RJ. That didnt happen. Like it's addressed in the vid and in general: there was NO vision for this trilogy.
@@RandoSando jj had a script for the last Jedi and Rian ignored it
@@RandoSando yeah, jj already had a script that would act as a guide for Rian. Rian just threw it away and made his own
@@Ekircher5 If JJ actually had a script then that should have been the roadmap imposed by Disney to Rian from the start. Directors don't just get to do whatever they want. Look at MCU; Do you think Doctor Strange director can go on like, "Oh Time Stone is in this movie? I'm just gonna blow it up"
@Cypher I think you should read my comment again buddy, but slower and more carefully next time.
*_Look at the bright side, at least Baby Yoda is trying to cheer us up whenever we become disappointed. He's not just a baby, he's a pure art form._*
Werner Herzog called Baby Yoda cinema
Grogu actually
Wether you liked this movie or not, you gotta admit it gives you just a weird feeling lol.
Yea, it's weird to see Rey kissing the man who tortured her, I'll give you that.
Weird feeling is right. I actually get nauseous thinking about it sometimes. I’m not even exaggerating.
Lmao yeah. I know I don’t like the movie, but I also kind of like it? Hell maybe I love the movie but I definitely hate the movie.
@Shurryy Namegenerator also aside from the beautiful set design lol
Shurryy Namegenerator Boo Hoo.
Weird is... definitely one way to put it
Each movie seems like it's made from a different story bible and for a different audience. There's a lot of good to be found in pieces, but as a whole it's a gigantic waste and a perfect example of how not to handle a series.
Especially the biggest most beloved franchise in the world, and one of the longest running sagas in movie history.
It's as if the sequel trilogy was just a callous money grab by a soulless corporation made with little consideration and care for the source material and aimed at desperate fans who would buy tickets unquestioningly in the name of their nostalgia. Oh wait.
This movie felt more like a sequel to TFA than TLJ
This movie was JJ throwing a fit against RJ and completely forgetting that he had to conclude a trilogy rather just the one he made.
@@kaptenlemper i mean TLJ felt like Rian getting mad at how JJ set him up
To be fair TLJ felt like a stand alone film or even a conclusion.
@@siddaslothman2273 you still have a lot of potential to continue the story
This movie in a nutshell:
"A collection of weird decisions, empty story or themes, and pointless moments."
After bringing up the Beaumont Kin character doing what Rose could have, I am very annoyed. I wasn’t a fan of her character in The Last Jedi but they didn’t have to just ignore her in this film, the actor did nothing wrong just to be sidelined.
Only came here for the Shadow Legends ad, bye
Epic, I'm glad I actually put effort into it haha
Someone should make a playlist of every CZcams video with a Shadow Legends ad, so I can watch all of them.
That's completely fair
@@eeveeon4081 It'd be at least 80 hours long. I'm not sure CZcams can handle something that epic.
Diffently not a great movie but not a bad one either I personally liked it a lot with the action,cgi,easter eggs,and the emotional moments the film brought but the plot wasn’t really good
That's literally my opinion on the movie too. I liked more than the Last Jedi.
This movie just kinda ruined the whole trilogy for me . It's hard to watch knowing the movies lead to no where and kinda a muddled mess .
I walked out of the movie feeling no emotion other than "what" it that's even an emotion. After a day I just couldn't remember anything I liked about it because the negatives out way the positives wayyyyyy to much. Like there are things I liked about the movie, specifically Kylo and Rey's scenes together but that's really all that I liked. I swear to god WHY DOES PALPATINE NOT JUST STOP FUCKING SHOOTING LIGHTNING EVER LIKE DUDE YOUVE ALMOST DIED ONCE BECAUSE OF THIS AND YOU KEEP DOING IT
I just saw Rise of Skywalker for myself. And while I enjoyed it more than Last Jedi I think it's ultimately worse than that film despite being significantly more entertaining. It's chocked full of really dumb and easy cop-outs that destroy any sense of steaks or tension. And it also completely undermines the one thing I liked most about Last Jedi which was that Rey's lineage wasn't tied to any major character and it ultimately didn't matter where she came from. It's a straight-forward MacGuffin plot and nostalgia trip that weirdly feels inspired by Avengers: Endgame.
And although I'm nowhere near as invested in the characters of this trilogy as I was with the Avengers team this cast does a lot to keep me engaged. This movie feels like an apology for Last Jedi but it also feels like fan fiction that JJ wrote when he was 12. It's like JJ was trying to make the sequel to Force Awakens he would've made and a conclusion to the saga all in one movie. This is a mediocre movie for sure but it's certainly watchable. It's a fun time but ultimately a disappointing conclusion to the saga.
Maybe it would’ve been better if this third movie didn’t finish the saga and instead there was one final movie after this that tied all movies together
I hated it personally, seemed like they took someone's fan fiction of what to do next and made it into episode 9. But what I'm not going to do is hate on anyone who enjoyed it or attack anyone online that was involved in the film (actors writers or producers) that probably tried their best to make episode 9 as good as it could be. Whether we love it or hate it, we are all Star Wars fans and it has something for everyone and that's okay.
hi
@@tonybutweird3 hi?
Hello there
Orion Watson GENER-Wait, wrong film...
I'm just a bit confused as to why Ben didn't came back as a "force ghost" at the end, but maybe that's just me
Edit: maybe I should watch the complete video first before commenting! I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought that
Don’t worry. They put Palpatines words being heard around the universe in Fortnite so they didn’t need to in the film.
One of the critiques I heard for this was "Star Wars was never a franchise where you had to turn your brain off to enjoy it." I don't agree with this because there were alot of things in the original trilogy where you had to turn your brain off to enjoy (the Ewoks and rescue of Han in ROTJ and the incompetence of Stormtroopers). Also you should be allowed to not think about things to enjoy anything and I think that it has become lost in some parts of the Star Wars fanbase today.
What has become lost in the sw fanbase is a brain to turn on in the first place
Star wars was always stupid and silly and ridiculous but it was never this soulless and corporate
Ok but those things aren’t main plot points. Suspension of disbelief is just that. “Suspension” pull to tightly and the whole story snaps. To loose and it falls limp. The leaps this movie takes every other scene break the entire movies in world logic and thus any suspense.
Wtf the kiss between rey and Kylo came out of nowhere
For me it maked perfect sense He saved her life they have a thing for each other so normal
@@luma4902
he tried to kill her multiple times wtf
@@jovanym2931 maybe, but reylo shippers have been a thing since the beginning. Go online and you'll see how zealously passionate they are. You also can't deny there was a lot of sexual tension in the last jedi.
What’s funny is that if you think about it, they’re both related to Palpatine so it’s basically an incest relationship
@@trevordavis6830 Nah they ain't
Browntable, no one cared that Ben died because other than Rey he had literally no relationship with anyone. They all hated him besides Leia and Rey. By the end, it's only Rey who was left who really knew him
RedLightning17 man Ben really does have the saddest story in all these films man...
Reylo shippers cared and resistance people cared cause it ended the war.
Reylos cared, just go check out their videos
Rey should have died in the end, therefore, putting an end to the Palpatine legacy. Ben should have lived and be the one to place his mother's and uncle's lightsaber back on Tattooine, that way, he can carry on the Skywalker legacy. Hence the title, The Rise of Skywalker. Also, didn't buy the kiss for a second.
But wasn't Anakin's space daddy Palpatine? That's what was heavily hinted in the prequels, and google seems to agree.
@@floraposteschild4184 that wasn't considered a canon thing
@@mmdrawifi Tell that to google.
@@floraposteschild4184 kind of confusing to me. The writer says it's only Anakin's visions but some people told me it was canon until recently.
@@mmdrawifi Maybe they're thinking of when Disney bought out George Lucas, and all the Extended Universe books, etc. were officially tossed.
But I am thinking of the opera scene in Revenge of the Sith, in which Palpy heavily hints that some Sith lord or lords can hold off death and create life, while in front of them what looks like sperm are swimming around. And of course later Palpy reveals himself to be Darth Sidious. That was written by Lucas, and the prequels are canon.
They might as well have a blinking light around Palpatine's head saying "here's daddy!" I guess Anakin's father could be some other Sith lord who created Anakin for some reason or just 'cause, but do we want even more pointless complications in the SW universe?
*After The Last Jedi*
"You could not live with your own failure. Where did that bring you? Back to me." - J.J. Abrams
Failure = Whiny Fans
"Mystery box bullsh&t" - yes, pretty much summed it up. This is a mess.
Star Wars:The Rise of Raid Shadow Legends
only true Chads get sponsored by Raid Shadow Legends
#ChadNation
Only true chads sell out to Raid Shadow Legends
Huh. This review is interesting.
I skipped this movie because some critics I trust (who I don’t find to be needlessly critical and even liked The Last Jedi) said a lot of things I did not like about how it felt directionless and just a general mess at 120mph. This review is kinda making me wonder if I missed something by not seeing this film. Still think I’d have a lot of issues though.
Still very happy I decided to see Knives Out and I’m thinking of giving Uncut Gems a try. I’ve got a hunger for some smaller films I guess. Still bummed I missed out on Parasite though.
Save your time and money. It can be a fun action movie, you don't get bored, but it's a really REALLY dumb movie. The plot is a giant mess, that's not Star Wars for me. I want it so be something special, something unique and different from other action films
I thought the same way, but i still decided to watch it with friends. Its a really fun movie. Would reccomend. Yes its kind dumb, but its fun.
This is a great time of the year to check out smaller films. It's not like we didn't pay Disney all through the summer.
Find a way to watch Parasite ASAP! 😁
It’s fun. Not particularly memorable or good but a fun enough time at the movies while it’s going on (just don’t think too much about it afterwards).
As a movie it’s fine. It’s alright. But this is the final episode in the Skywalker saga. This should be the Endgame of Star Wars, and it just isn’t. What’s frustrating is that they had one shot at this, we won’t ever see the cast of the originals together again and they failed to take full advantage of that opportunity while they had the chance. The whole sequel trilogy is just a whole lotta nothing. A series of wasted opportunities. Whatever you think of the Last Jedi, it completely derailed the story of this trilogy. You could easily skip the entire thing and not miss out on anything imo.
Damn you should start a movie channel
Chicken With 1000 Subscribers with no videos not sure if you were being serious but I’ve actually been thinking about it.
Scarce Hyperion nah bro u definitely should you clearly know a lot about movies and stuff
Chicken With 1000 Subscribers with no videos thanks bro that’s nice to hear. When I’ve got a bit more time on my hands Ill see if I can get together some money for equipment and I’ll start a channel then. It’s funny you said that because like I said I’ve actually been thinking about starting a movie (and gaming) review and discussion channel for a while now.
Also: I think Palpatine's return would have been a good thing of there had been some breadcrumbs across the trilogy. I would like to live in a reality where the films had been 3 years apart from each other, there was an outline from the beginning, and Rian and JJ had collaborated closely from the start with both having some direct involvement in each film
Honestly my thoughts on Ben's file are exactly the same. Like the flip scene itself is fantastic, but the rest of the movie before it does not do the work it needs to get there.
The splices of Se7en were hilarious 😂
“I don’t hate it, I actually quite liked it”. Followed by over 10 minutes of analysis of all its problems LOL
That was presidential level misdirect
The thing with Rey “having to choose” her own destiny is we literally already saw it in the original trilogy with Luke and Vader. So I didn’t really care about it.
Doctor 1:The patient is dying quick hand me those scissors.
Doctor 2:Okay but first I want to talk about my favorite game Raid Shadow Legends.
Good commentary, I agree with most. The Ben ending was the most disappointing of all. Kylo Ren/Ben was such a good character, and he just gets offed and never mentioned again... Honestly I saw this whole movie as a spit in the face to TLJ in general, and I don't even know who at Disney is responsible (probably too many to name) but 100% yes, everything Disney makes is just a cash grab.
Surprised though that you didn't mention the force healing, and how that inclusion basically ruins everything that came before. This is beyond JK Rowling levels of "but I just invented this magic that I want to use and screw that it would have been useful before/after" , this is seriously like world shattering ramifications. Since apparently anyone can learn it (Rey learned without being taught, Ben knows how at the end for some reason) then we could assume that Anakin could use it? So, what exactly was it that the dark side was offering him to turn evil? Oh right, that whole saving Padme thing.
Anakin heals his mom= no Darth Vader. Anakin resurrects Padme = no Darth Vader.
But yeah, sure, let's just let Rey heal everyone because she's awesomesauce like that. And then Ben can know how too so we can kill him off at the end. Yup. Perfection.
This entire movie is just one long ??? meme.
I get Justice League vibes from TROS.
Like, completely reshot, playing it safe and an apology for the previous film.
Yes, but TROS is at least enjoyable
@@andreiefectivuatafac1966 nah it was awful
@@rorylennon4043 i can respect that, but I still had a good time
Șob Olverine It was mindless fun, but Star Wars should always be more than mindless fun. I loved TLJ and Force Awakens but TrOS actually made those films worse for me
@@rorylennon4043 I really love the TFA,it's my favourite since Empire. TLJ was great when it was focusing on Luke Rey and Kylo, and it was pretty mediocre when was focusing on Finn and Poe. TROS, as you said , is mindless fun , but I still enjoyed myself.
Edit: TROS being mindless is still better than TPM ,which is boring, and attack of the clones, which is stupid
Spoilers...
Don't forget that Lando basically did the "on your left" thing
I would've like that in the scene where kylo becomes good he would've instead of trowing his sword he would've gave his saber to han(similarly how he gave it to him in force awakens) and he would've just walked away with it and get swallowed by a wave
After much consideration, I found that I think it would've been much better if they had to bring Palpatine back it should have been at least 20 minutes in and they should have capitalized on his voice thing to trick everyone in-universe by broadcasting as Darth Vader, they also shouldn't have promoted him but let it be a surprise though we know it wouldn't be Vader so at least we're expecting something... But I really think they should have brought Anakin back... He talks to Rey at the end so he's still "force-active" it makes no sense he wouldn't have warned Kylo or helped at the end. We see that Yoda used lighting in TLJ and Luke caught the lightsaber so they can obviously touch physical stuff so there's no reason Anakin couldn't have played a bigger role. He should have been the Skywalker to rise but Rey just takes the last name (WHICH IS STUPID) she should embrace her last name or come up with something new idk but I didn't like the name thing.
Sidelining the Rose character was clearly done intentionally. Star Wars fans (me included) never took to her in The Last Jedi. Nothing against the actress who plays her (Kelly Tran), but Rose just isn't interesting or important enough to have that much screen time in Rise of Skywalker.
I get you, but it's pathetic of Disney to not include a character due to backlash when she is - regardless of our take on her - a main character in one of the movies. The movie feels pandering; to our gripes from TLJ and to our nostalgia (i'm looking at you Lando).
Bro you said Kylo turns abruptly? How about how Luke who was about to burn down the Jedi Tree gets talked to by Yoda, then all of a sudden wants to help out after 6 years being on the island. THATS abrupt.
yeah both films are bad
I think Luke's redemption arc had been slowly developing until that Yoda encounter, which ended up being the tipping point
Disney made three fatal errors when handing Star Wars:
1. Not having a plan from the get-go.
2. Giving the film to JJ Abrams.
3. Giving the film to Rian Johnson.
I think one of the biggest problems with the plot was how the entire time palpatine is hell bent on turning Rey to the dark side so she can strike him down or whatever and he can flow through her and blah blah blah then outta no where he’s like oh wait ! You and kylo are a dyad thingy? Oh well it’s a lot more convenient for me to just suck you guys energy and restore myself to keep going instead .... like shouldn’t that have been the plan from the start ? How would he not notice they are the dyad ? Or even if he did why would he choose his initial plan for her to replace him when he could just use her and kylo to keep living ?? None of it makes sense .... and he if can just die multiple times like he mentions “I have died before” then what’s to prevent him from coming back again ? Totally undermines all the entire arc anakin had and his purpose of being the chosen one ... and yes that ending was clearly a reshoot. That scene has zero dialogue... just an awkward forced kiss to make reylo fans Stan this movie because now it’s “cannon” they have a boner for one another. Not saying it’s the worst movie ever , but god was it a major let down. Kylo shoulda got more justice in the end as well. He deserved better. And THANK YOU FOR SAYING that bout Finn and his confession of love. Like it was SO clear that it was meant to be that and they just throw that whole plot away and replace it with the reylo ending.
When I think of this film, I think about how despite it sort of not following through with what the TLJ set it up (I like the TLJ and what it especially did with Rey, Luke and Kylo) it still had great potential in multiple areas if they were just changed a bit and if the movie slowed down and breathed more to let scenes resonate and characters develop more.
I didn’t hate it or love it, it’s a movie I can watch again and appreciate it in some ways, but ultimately I was a bit disappointed. Still overall really enjoyed the sequel trilogy (and I’m actually really looking forward to what Rian Johnson could put out with his trilogy)
I came out of the theatre, feeling intense anger and let down at the Corporate Hollowness that was The Rise of Skywalker, knowing that they had everything they needed and more to make the perfect end to the 42- year saga and they threw it out the window to do things that would "please the fans" when it's just plot and no scene, and no emotion, and no time to grieve or let the emotions settle in it's just action after action after action, even in the most emotional moment of the film, it was Adam Driver's parts that pulled it up, and even then, with the least lines possible, he is able to pull off some of the most phenomenal acting l've seen and it makes me so furious that they made this movie like that, it had the best potential and, now I'm just sad
Man this movie is controversial. I for one liked it.
Same I enjoyed it a lot actually
Same.
Did anybody else squeal when u heard Ewan McGregor's voice during the movie
A rather balanced take on the film. Great as always BT!
I'm with you. I enjoyed it to a degree, but I have a lot of issues
I feel that the last Jedi will be as romanticized as the prequels in the future. Not so sure about the rise of skywalker.
I liked the idea of Rey being related to Palpatine. It shows that anybody can be a hero, even the spawn of Space Hitler.
The biggest problem for me with the new movies is that we never see Anakin. This trilogy had so many great opportunities to include Anakin but they managed to fuck it up every single time.
Rey didn't struggle with anything and thats why its not believable that would would be tempted to the dark side.
i disagree she struggled in this movie and honestly its baffling how they give her an explanation of her abilities and yet you people still dont get it.
D'Angel Correa Soooooooo since they give an explanation of her abilities
How’d she get Force Healing?
I think if an extended cut of this film was created, it would fix quite a few of the issues. Chances are the slower scenes exist, but this film neded to fit a certain length for the theaters.
"I actually didn't really mind this film too much." -Browntable High praise, sir, high praise indeed.
I think my favorite "new" Star Wars movie is Jedi: the fallen order.
I really liked Last Jedi and Force Awakens.. But this however sucked
This movie didn't feel like an actual movie. Just a series of plot points and apology for the previous film
Same! I was just rewatching some scenes from TFA. That was such a good movie. How could they not have planned the rest of the story when they made it? How could the same people who made that film made the trainwreck that is _Rise of Skywalker?_
@@polyhymnia701 exactly, TFA was si great
'The Rise of Skywalker' actually strips the merits I once viewed on 'The Last Jedi' and 'The Force Awakens'.
Sure, Rian Johnson pretty much boxed Star Wars into a corner and his execution may be far from perfect but he brought some interesting ideas into it too.
Rey being a nobody was something fans protested, arguing as their proof that she's a Mary Sue, but isn't that the point? That the Force is no longer exclusive to some lineage? I mean, it did end on some Kid Nobody picking up his broom using the Force.
My opinion is that they should've brought someone new to write Star Wars out of that corner instead of undoing the previous film, which is what J.J. Abrams did. Bringing Palpatine back and making Rey his granddaughter is Fan-Fiction 101.
This film, at core, is hollow. I don't see much to discuss about it and I no longer see much reasons to discuss the previous films either.
I don't care what any visual dictionary has to say, the real name of Dominic Monaghan's character in The Rise of SkyWalker is Mr. Poopybutthole.
I want sir thiccalus to give me a present
;)))
those inserts from SE7EN lmaoooo
Really agree with all the points you mentioned man, it's definitely enjoyable, very well made video, would've been great with some A-Roll but damn the mic.
Also I definitely get some X-Men Apocalypse vibes from this film.
They kind of rip off Avatar: The Last Airbender too. Rey masters the Jedi state, gaining access to the collective knowledge and experiences of all previous Jedis, allowing her to bend all Force elements. She then used Uncle Windu's lightning redirection technique to turn Sidious' lightning back against him, destroying the Dark Avatar.
KingOfMadCows Did they ever imply that she learnt all of the Jedi powers from every Jedi?
Hzrds0 the line “and I am all the Jedi” should ring a bell to you
“I don’t hate any Star Wars movie”
Me:LIAR
This trilogy shouldve followed the story of Luke Skywalker forming the jedi council to fight off Darth Revan, Nihilus etc.
Maybe he couldve trained Revan in 7, and at the end of 7 Revan kills all the younglings, making Luke a darker, more depressed character.
In 8 Revan could get wrecked by Luke and Luke could chop his arm and legs off, but before leaving him to die he redeems him, seeing that he might end up creating the next Darth Vader
Then Anakin could return in 9 when they fail to prevent Nihilus' return to help stop him
When Luke is about to be killed suddenly a portal opens, and people walk through. When they open their lightsabers you see its Anakin, Obi Wan, Yoda, Qui Gon and Mace Windu.
Imagine Anakin, Obi Wan, Luke and Yoda alongside a redeemed Revan all taking on a full powered Darth Nihilus....
Palpatine is just like: i aM BaCK tHIs wAs mY PLan fRoM tHe BEgiNinG
To be honest, Palpatine being every voice Kylo heard in his head (i love this qoute) actually solves the plot hole of him talking to Vader's spirit, and kinda makes his redemption kinda justified. Imo.
Rise of Skywalker feels like everything i like and dislike about Star Wars
Felt like a fan fiction than a movie
"Have you heard of Raid: Shadow Legends?"
Every viewer: "Aw shit, here we go again..."
This is basically Harry Potter Part 1 and 2. If you smushed them together. There's so many scenes and shots that come straight from those movies, or visual cues and I'm like. Yeah they should've just done another movie. Don't think anyone would've gotten mad about that tbh. Also this movie made me appreciate Last Jedi a lot more lol
That's really interesting! Which scenes reminded you of Deathly Hallows?
Those "I am___" lines literally made me think: "what kind of dismal riff on Legend of Korra is this."
The thing about Rey coming from no one is that her power would be completely unexplainable
Thank you for at least talking about the pacing. I hated how fast everything went. I literally said out loud but silently SLOW DOWN
I like what you did at 5:45 with the titles.This video reminded me of why I like your channel, it was great... the editing, the review itself... :) _in Jason Mamoa voice_ " _muh _*_MAN_* " !
Great video, and seeing the image from Perfect Strangers around the 11:45 mark - classic!
At first I agreed that making her Palpatine’s granddaughter lessens the impact of her coming from nobody, causing her to forge her own destiny. Then after thinking about it, I realized that the Palpatine twist entails that Palpatine is her grandfather and that her parents were good people trying to protect her. This means that her destiny wasn’t necessarily to become evil, but it was to choose to be like her evil grandad Palpatine or to be like her good and sacrificial parents. Nothing was set in stone for her so she still had to choose who she wanted to be, which I still liked.
Rey being Palpatin’s daughter is almost the same as Luke being Vader’s son. But worse. Dunno what’s interesting there at this point.
I am in confusion about this fact most of all:
How old is Babu Frik?
For me I didn't grow up with starwars I heard about it but I never watched it before, so when I started watching it I wanted to watch everything in order so I watched the first 2 episodes of the prequels which got me interested then I watched all 6 seasons of the clone wars animation and in proper order then I watched the 3rd episode and I have to say watching the prequels in that order made me fall in love with them and with the starwars story in general I got so invested in the story and lore and so seeing the end of the Jedi order in Anakin turn to the dark side made me feel really sad and that last seen with obi wan while everyone was laughing at the memes I was crying waterfalls out of my eyes it was so heartwrenching sad seeing these two brothers in that scene and the amazing relationship they had between them which was fully explored in the clone wars, I watched the og trilogy afterwards and Loved them and I really wish we had a 6 season animated like the clone wars after ep 6 wich would fully explore what happens after and make us connect even more with characters then cam ep 7 which I liked fine enough not great but fine it setup really interesting ideas and themes which I was looking forward to , then the unthinkable happened Ryan Johnson came with his "subverting expectations " ideas and completely and absolutely destroyed everything we loved about star wars he did so many things wrong that not only did he ruin what 7 started he completely destroyed the enture sequel trilogy he didn't care about star wars he didn't care about the fans he didn't care about telling a good story what he cared about is subverting expectations he is the living embodiment of "subverting expectations" I hate him so much for what he did, that's why the sequel trilogy failed and that's why it feels so sad for me to see this great story so utterly destroyed just breaks my heart what Ryan did is just unforgivable.
I can't escape raid shadow legends it's like my sleep paralysis demon
Not a bromance, just two guys consoling each other for being to chained behind an incompetent Mary Sue. She is the protagonist, but for some reason that means no one is allowed to outshine her for a moment.
Way to review Rise of Skywalker-
As a Movie in its own right.
As a Star Wars movie.
As a conclusion to the Sequel Trilogy.
As a conclusion to the Main Star Wars 9 Movie Long Saga.
I felt bad for Abrams. You could see he was really trying to make the best of the situation since Rian Johnson wrote the story into a corner with TLJ.
Abrams was trying?
@@jeremybrown9611 The blame shouldn't be on Rian though. He made the best film of the saga since the original trilogy and he freed the story from being too similar to plotpoints from the originals which is what so many complained about in TFA.
I think more attention should be directed towards Terrio and Abrams for refusing the mold and new example to take form and insisting we just needed to set things back one movie and make a "bigger and better" RotJ. RotJ wasn't planned from the get go before ESB was released, and yet the crew of VI were still able to make a lovely film respecting the twist of Vader and Luke and concluding the trilogy in a decent manner. Even without a plan.
I wish in mid 2018 Disney removes tlj from canon and then jj had until December 2020 to make his own episode vii
For the most part, I've had a clear idea of how I felt about Star Wars movies. And this is the first one that really mindfucked me. Ik a lot of people that hate this movie with a passion. I also know a lot of people who fucking love it. I think hands down that this is the best threequel in the saga. Especially coming from someone who REALLY doesn't like Return Of The Jedi that much. At the end of the day, I went into this expecting to hate it (which is new for me). And this is helping me piece some things together for me. You have a knack for doing that to me lmao. At the end of the day, it still kills me that this movie wanted to kill the last movie so bad despite it's pros. And the JJ bullshit is galore still. But the performances (*cough* Leia *cough*) and the better aspects of the fan service saved it for me
This video is the only thing I need for Christmas. In all seriousness though I really enjoyed this film but it’s one of them movies where you agree with the people who say it’s bad and you agree with the people who say it’s good