SK-II PITERA™ Essence Deep Dive: What's the Science? Hate it or Love it? | Dr. Shereene Idriss
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 07. 2024
- FTC: Thank you to SK-II for sponsoring this video! I took the deep dive after asking you guys! Let’s get into the ingredient story and technology of this iconic essence, and my very own PITERA™ Story!
0:00 my journey
0:33 intro
2:04 about my skin
2:26 toner vs. essence
3:30 how to apply
4:30 ingredient deep dive
5:26 origin of PITERA™
7:00 benefits of fermented ingredients
8:21 technology
10:28 my review (feel, scent, package, results)
17:03 recap
SK-II PITERA™ Essence: bdb.agency/shereeneskii
FOLLOW ME 💬 ✨
Instagram (@shereeneidriss): / shereeneidriss
TikTok: (@shereeneidriss): vm.tiktok.com/ZMJ47sUeG/
Facebook Group: / 328289008475775
Newsletter: www.pillowtalkderm.com/
FTC: Video is sponsored. I am not receiving any commission from the product sales provided on the link above.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
#shereeneidriss #pillowtalkderm #dermatologist #sponsored #skiipartner #piteraessence #MyPITERAStory
I was a beauty consultant at SK-II for 10 years…also winning top global consultant for my country in 2013. I can honestly say I am and will always be in love with this brand and product. The integrity and the science behind this brand won me over. I am turning 45 soon and my skin is still looking and feeling smooth, hydrated, firm and plump. I’m so proud to have represented SK-II. I assisted so many loyal customers in their journey of improving their skincare and seeing their amazing results. It’s a time I will truly treasure.
Thanks so much for your great representation of the facial treatment essence! It’s so easy to become so passionate about it by the unique way it is produced and all of its unbelievable benefits.
❤❤❤
Hi dear. Is it possible to layer the essence with retinol? I'd love to try this essence but i'm affraid it might not work well with retinol since i cant live without my retinol serum
Thank you for your comment
@@yasintaf8050 - yes, u can layer them. Start from thinnest to thickest.
@@yasintaf8050 so what did you end up doing first ? Did your retin-a still penetrate?
@@MsLipsxLikeSugarI just used it with retinol… also can’t live without it. If my face falls off I’ll let everyone know 😅
One question not answered. Would you purchase this again with your own money?
Good question
She still uses it to this day and recommended it in one of her latest videos to pick up during the Sephora sale !
This is a pretty significant departure from your usual tone... it's borderline QVC 😬
Anywho, it's nice to witness a potential preferential transition from purely Western to being open to Eastern.
I'm disappointed that you didn't say anything more informative than their advertisements.
And a lot of stuff you mentioned was a bit confusing. I thought NMF consists of squalane, cholesterols, ceramides, etc.
How are minerals, vitamins, amino acids NMF? Also, what kinds of minerals, vitamins are you talking about? And how exactly do they work?
This whole video is just an ad for skii, I didn't see any scientific facts or research like the title promised.
Yep...I'm feeling the same. Thank you for exercising critical thinking here, and 'asking the hard questions'.
After reading just a few of the comments here - have to say, I am SO impressed with Dr. Idriss' audience and their knowledge on the subject AND the fact that everyone is speaking up here. She definitely doesn't have a slavering, hero worshipping audience here - like so many influencers do. So many YT influencers have subs who just hang on every word they say as 'Gospel', and they can literally do no wrong.
What a hard bunch, here, to try to slip anything past! Speaking of 'dupes'...looks like this group cannot be duped (no pun intended)....
and not saying that Dr. Idriss is trying to dupe anyone - she gave an honest review on a good & effective (but WAY overpriced) product. I am a little disappointed that she didn't bring up that there are reasonably priced dupes out there.
OTOH, I can see where bc this was a paid promotion, doing so may have been disrespectful of the company. Surely she knows about these dupes - she doesn't live under a rock - but I do think that given the nature of this video, probably best for her not to go there...
All skincare youtubers hey paid for promoting products,Even without trying them,so...
*get
@@EspadasYCopas is this your opinion, or factual information...? Pretty bold statement to declare, 'All CZcamsrs are....'
Care to back that statement up with factual data?
@@barbarafairbanks4578 At least she was up front from the beginning that she was given the product and that the video was sponsored. I've seen other"skinfluencers" make obviously sponsored (and scripted!) videos with no disclosure.
I'm hoping that in an upcoming video, Dr Sherene will do a true deep dive into fermented ingredients and show a range of product. I don't mind that she didn't do so here.
Would I use this? If someone gave me a bottle, I'd add it to my regular routine - but not replace my retinoid, vitamin C and acids. It looks nice, but at my age, I'm looking for anti-aging, not merely smooth, soft skin.
CosRX's Galactomyces Essence and Toner have about 90% of the same ingredients of SK-II for anyone looking for a cheaper alternative.
Thank you
love this!
I believe that CosRx has a lesser concentration
It does not have the same texture though, find it a little sticky too...
Thank you. My bank account does not support SK II lol
I don’t mind derms doing sponsorships, but I have to say I’m pretty disappointed by this video. If you’re going to title the video “deep dive” and prompt the question “what’s the science?” then actually do a deep dive…and attempt to answer that question by drawing upon your own knowledge and academic literature. I understand that SKII isn’t going to describe in great detail how their secret fermentation process works; however, I would have expected - especially being in touch with someone from HQ - a general idea of what makes this ingredient/process unique to them. This video is also lacking general information that could have been researched independent of SKII, like how skincare actives across the industry are typically fermented, what galactomyces are (chemical structure, function, etc), how and why yeast enzymes make an active “more potent” - I could go on.
Again, I have no issue with sponsored videos, but the title is so misleading for what’s essentially a retelling of SKII’s oft-repeated origin story and a surface level skimming of what the company adverts already say 😕
🎻 🎻 🎻
@@jt8142 "oh no, it's legitimate, respectfully-worded constructive criticism! better drag out the overused tiny violin meme"
BECAUSE THERE IS NOTHING TO TELL. IT'S JUST WATER AND USELESS PITERA CRAP THAT DOESN'T PROVE ANYTHING. LOL
She has always been very thorough and is always good about doing her own research. Obviously since this is sponsored, the brand is going to send her more detailed scientific info than what the release to the public and its reasonable for her to be in touch with them. What’s good is that she didn’t make assumptions and did want to speak to the head scientist herself. I think it’s unfair to assume that she didn’t do her own research to supplement the information she was given by the brand.
When u accept sponsorship, u have the duty to promote the product especially under money compensation. Do not expect unbiased opinion. Her tone has been different on this video if u noticed:)
Aside from the review of the product itself, I really appreciate you talking about glass recycling and carbon footprint!
I am so happy you are giving this the green light. So may people insist there's no way it can do anything but I have always found it does worlds for my skin!!!
I’m hoping you try out some more affordable dupes and report back on how they compare. Would love to try pitera but not at this price point 😊
Missha Time Revolution The First Treatment Essence is somewhat considered a dupe, or a discount dupe. I use it and will likely repurchase (I might see what happens when I discontinue it for a bit), but I’ve never used SK-II.
Secret Key and Missha both have the same product but with extra goodie ingredients, making them arguably better.
A bottle lasts me six months using it once a day. I love it and would rather go cheaper on cleansers or moisturisers to keep it in my routine.
Purito glacto niacin 97 power essence is a great dupe for it.
It’s better not to try it then, same ingredients doesn’t mean same quality, especially since it’s a natural and fermented ingredient.
I am using this for last 6 years and it worth it. It did wonder to my skin and it one of the best products I ever used. Just love, love and love it.
“Who is this sustainable for?” Someone with a big skincare budget.
I have tried some of the dupes … and I’ve tried this brand… and I have to say… many of them perform the same, a few perform even better.
@@MsAntigonaki please do list those that you mention, could help some people. the replacements didn't really work for me
@@adhuna1009 CosRx, secret key, innisfree and NEOGEN - I also like the Missha fist essence but it doesn’t have the galactomyces - it has other firmented ingredients- and I do the 7 skins method every other night, so I feel a bit less guilty about “wasting” such expensive product.
So much of the price of this stuff is marketing - the more expensive it is, the better it has to be. Right? I’ve fallen for that time and time again, nope… not today
Dr. Idriss, if you liked that one, you might also like the I'm From Rice Toner. It's super hydrating (and by your definition, technically an essence) with 77.78% rice extract, and the price point is way cheaper!
It’s great too.
I have used both, Pitera is superior compare to rice toner
So is the Missha the first essence
@@MsAntigonaki I hate to have to say this, but I've used the Missha and the other Korean dupes and unfortunately they do not hold up against SK-II. SK-II has the patent on the particular type of yeast that they use (hence you don't see other companies using the name Pitera in their products because SK-II has trademarked it)
@@s_shaleh agreed, i have tried to use "alternatives" but nothing compares to the real deal. its too expensive now though, the price increased exponentially a few years back.
Thank you Dr. Idriss, you have helped this 67 year old man who previously suffered from hyperpigmentation, to dramatically transform his facial, and forearm skin. As someone who has 38 years digital imaging expertise, what I have experienced first hand has been nothing short of amazing. Science is a wondrous thing, and you Dr. Idriss have greatly deepened my understanding of what is now possible. P.S. your facial skin has never, ever looked better!
What did u use ?
LOVE YOU DR! your knowledge and humor is so appreciated. You look absolutely glowing. Have an amazing weekend!
Love your review! Been using SK-II for almost a decade. You’re right it varies on what skin type. I have oily skin, I only use it during night time. I still get its max benefit. LOVE SK-II!
There is no amount of lore, legend, patent or proprietorship that will convince me that this is not a MEGA cash grab. If you're looking for a galactomyces ferment filtrate essence with a price tag that isn't an affront to humankind, I recommend the Missha 5X Treatment Essence or the NeoGen Real Ferment Micro Essence. Don't buy into the theatre that these companies partake in to convince you that their exorbitant prices are even remotely justified.
Thank you so much for listing these! I got a free ounce of SKII Essence and I really like it but there's no way I'd pay $100 for the same ounce.
Fermented ingredients are very common in Korean skincare products and therefore, much more affordable than this SKII stuff.
Hi hi! I have sensitive eczema prone skin and have used both the SKII Essence and Missha Essence (the latter because SKII IS EXPENSIVE 120%!) and sadly I will say that Missha didn't have the same softening and moisturizing effects as SKII. Missha actually started to irritate my skin over time so I had to stop using it. Everyone's skin is different and mine unfortunately didnt work well with Missha so my search for a wallet friendly and still effective Essence 😔.
I hear you, @@funcake22 Everyone's skin is different. They very recently did a reformulation of the classic 'The First Treatment Essence' which is now called 'The First Essence 5X'. If you're still in the market for a more affordable pitera essence, it might be worth giving it a second try! Or if you know what ingredient irritated your skin when you previously used it, it might be worth checking if it's omitted from the new formulation.
@@alliecinder Ooo! Thanks for this information, this sounds promising ❤!! I'll definitely give the company another try! LoL sometimes the skin journey to find the right products is just so tiring 😑
I have been using SKII essence for more than 8 years. 230 ml last for 10-12 months using without cotton pad. Whoever says the same ingredients with any alternative products, thank you and I can’t replace it. I have tried almost 10 different essences and I can’t compare it.
Cost per month really worth it. If you can find in Asian countries, there is with airless pump and plastic bottle with 330ml which is the biggest size.
How many drops a day did you use to make it last 10 months?
Not one hand clap, no slap of the desk, not one 'wtf?' look into camera ...bring back unsponsored content!!! haha...no hate to sponsored stuff, but we all enjoy the real T from Dr Idriss and seeing her on her best behaviour for a sponsor was cute, yet not her usual 'brand'. But if a successful Doctor will not spend that much for a product every month, what hope do the rest of us have, LOL... Thank you, love from Bermuda!!!
I agree. Wear yellow if SK-II are holding you hostage next week
Don't you have to say at the beginning of the video that it is sponsored. Did I miss it?
Fermentation is huge in the Japanese and Korean Skincare industry! I have not used any of these products yet, but am planning to. For now I'm just researching products first. I believe they are good because I know for myself including fermented foods in my diet ( like kefir, yogurt, sauerkraut, kim chi etc) has been truly life changing.
Jalilah Lorraine Zamora -
Fully agree👍
(Intriguing name, btw)😀
This is going to be a long one, apologies in advance.
I voted for her to do a paid promotion review not a sell out review.
There is a difference between a paid promotion review & a sell out review, this unfortunately was a total sell out review.
I mean the "scientist from Japan" was in touch with her, what a golden opportunity for her to ask him where are the papers on the study on Galactomyces Ferment Filtrate? Why are there studies done by P&G only which owns sk2? if studies indicate there're vitamins, amino acids, nutrients in them what vitamins what amino acids & what nutrients Mr. "scientist from Japan"? Nothing & these are rational & obvious questions mostly everyone who knows the brand sk2 wants to know.
If you look at all the other reviews there is always a science based evidence factor to it for eg her vitamin c video she saying ascorbyl glucoside didn't have much research behind it despite its been used by Estée lauder, Clinique etc. so if they would have paid her to review the product, would that vitamin c derivative become more potent?
The best part & the most cringeworthy (apart from the whole review) was that (she adhered to the golden rule of reviews) well I cannot be 100% positive of sk2 it wont look "genuine" so let me bitch about the stopper on the bottle, you cannot be more obvious.
Look I respect women like Dr. Idriss, Dr. Dray, these people on CZcams are in a class of its own. no question.
Remember Dr. Drays paid review of i think Paula's choice 20% niacinamide & 15% vitamin c booster how she mopped the floor with it even if it was paid?
I did not of course except that form her but a flat out advertisement of sk2 with bs bickering of the stopper on the bottle was not expected from someone who always talks about science backed evidence, even after getting a call from the "scientist from Japan", paid promotion or not.
If this wasn't paid by sk2 we all know what sort of questions she would've asked.
Please understand because she may put it this way I don't know, that Its not that she liked the product & people are angry, that's not the case at all but the person who has built her channel on and always questions the science backed evidence (despite the "scientist from Japan" calling her) couldn't even ask a simple, basic & obvious questions based on science about sk2's star ingredient was just amazing & fantastic to watch. Worst review on this channel by far & I sure hope its the last.
So well said !
I was one of the people who voted no because a paid promotion is just another term for an advertisement. Companies don’t pay people to say negative things about their products.
I too hope that this is her one and only.
To be fair the entire thing is “proprietary” therefore they weren’t going to tell her anything more than what’s publicized.
Then don’t watch for free anymore! My god!
I think you’re comparing apples to oranges. I watch the Dr. Dray video, she did not use the product. She just commented on ingredients. This essence was used twice a day for 30 days before the review was given. So in my opinion this is a little bit better because not only were the ingredients discussed but so was the experience of using the product for 30 days twice a day. I’ve reached out to companies before and gotten in touch with people who were responsible for creating the item. So I don’t think it’s outlandis that she was able to get in touch with one of the people responsible for formulating the product, especially since they sent it to her. 🤷🏽♀️
I love the SK-II essence. I do love some alternatives but the feel of SK-II for me is different. I also am surprised some of you are bothered by this. Not all products people like are cheap. Not all products are cheap, just the way it is. I sometimes get cheaper alternatives and sometimes I get the bougie expensive stuff. If you don’t wan’t/can’t fathom the price tag, that is ok!! Some good alternatives are out there (coughs, the neogen one)
I am 0ⁿ0
Agree. I tried other brands, Korean brands, dupes, Caudalie, etc. But, SK-II is different. Use it for a long time, we can see the different
Hey! Can you please drop the names of some it's alternatives? That you know of
@@prerna1839 yes! The Neogen ferment Essence Donginbi 1899 Single Essence
@@derekcarboni861Thank youu
So this video is sponsored by SKII, :) no wonder the tone is so different.
Naurr get her jade
I received a bottle of SK-II essence as a bday gift. Though I did enjoy using it and noticed some skin improvement but I don’t think it’s worth spending $200 a bottle. Just think in a year, you are out $2400, which I rather use that towards a cosmetic procedure instead. Honestly, there are too many good kbeauty dupes that can give you the same effect. I am curious if you would spend your own money to buy this again ?
Exactly. If you got that kind of money save for a chemical peel, laser treatment, etc.
I get a big bottle and it lasts me six months. That’s $400 a year. Worth it.
I have to say that I tried it years ago and unfortunately for my wallet loved it. It helped to balance out my dehydrated oily combination skin who became normal and no more dehydrated. Not everyone need, want or can do laser , peel etc... and your done with those treatments you still need to maintain with good skincare. Is it necessary? No. But if you have that money to spend on skincare at least it's good skincare and it's much worth it than any La Mer or Lancome products.
You use 2-3 drops, and it covers your face. 2k$. What are you planning to use it on your entire body? 😂
There are couple dupes for this toner like the CosRX and Purito, would you try them and compare results?
She is sponsored, that s why do not expect unbiased opinion, sponsored means it's her duty to promote the brand!!
I tried both of those, and I only got to use half of the bottle before trashing them. As much as I want to like cheaper dupes, I haven't found one like sk2.
I have a few questions.
1) can I apply this before applying Tretinoin in my nighttime routine?
2)does this replace something like a vitamin C?, for my morning routine since I use it to protect from free radicals?
just asking to make sure it would be worth it for me.
1) Yes. It goes on after cleansing but before moisturizer/tretinoin.
2) It does not replace any kind of active ingredient like acids or vitamin C. Essences are just another layer of hydration.
If you're considering trying a fermented essence you might want to try one of the many dupes before spending the money on SKII. The Missha First Treatment Essence is a good one. CosRx Galactomyces is good but has a thicker more serum like texture. There are others suggested in the comments too
@@Allenro711 good advice! I was about to comment the same way, but saw that you already had. 👍
Information for other viewers, I have extremely sensitive skin ( perfume, alcohol, essential oils, tap water, honey...) but my skin reacted very well to that product !
So apart from this commercial, where is the deep dive and the actual independently researched science? I began to follow this channel due to Shereene’s scholarship voiced with facts and rationality, excellent scientific explanations and no-nonsense attitude, burning through the ridiculous marketing tactics of skincare brands and the beauty industry as a whole as a beacon of reason and critical thinking - and how disappointing to see her yield to sponsored ads and sell out to a cash-and-grab ad culture that promotes mindlessly purchasing overpriced products. No, I am not interested in dermatologists doing advertisements.
Just over a month ago, she passionately claimed ‘toners are an absolutely unnecessary part of your routine’ so how come now this abrupt change of mind once SK-II approached her for what essentially is a paid promotion?
Pitera is a trade name for saccharomycopsis ferment filtrate, thus essentially a fancy name for liquefied, fermented yeast. There is no substantiated research published in peer-reviewed medical journals proving it has any benefit on skin. Further, there is not one magical ingredient to cure all - skin requires a blend of antioxidants to thrive and this product is just pitera with a few water-binding texture enhancers, water and preservatives. Don’t fall for the marketing gimmick of ‘proprietary’ terms, save your money and opt for superior formulations for much less.
have to agree, saw the paid promo in the video and im not even going to give this my time.
Thanks for making me aware. Shut down the video instantly.
It's an essence and the review is based on her 30 days experience of the product and what the result is.
I have the same feeling, very disappointed by her.. Even though she said she asked on her instagram whether she should do a review if this..
@@rulahydon1301 which is why as a professionally trained data analyst and marketing researcher I hate Instagram polls with a passion LOL
Why does this feel like an infomercial?
It's sponsored you can see it in the description drop down
@@bashmeesh well I'm disappointed in our girl
Are there any contra-indications with using this essence? Can it be used with retinoids? Did you keep using a chemical exfoliator or did this replace it?
Essences are just an extra layer of hydration. They don't have (at least this one) any acids that could potentially interfiere with other acids.
My biggest question is: will this be incorporated in her daily skincare routine? If it is, then she really liked it and was 100% transparent. If not, then most likely she was being really nice in her sponsored ad.
In this specific case if she doesn't incorporate it into her daily routine I would not hold it against her because of the price. She may really love it but unable to justify or afford the expense.
@@DMMNCO You have a valid point, but I do not think price is a concern for her especially since she really saw a difference. Other products she has recommended are also on the pricey end, especially some of the makeup.
I agree
@@DMMNCO If youre familiar with her videos youd know she buys very expensive skincare if she loves it.
@@ninalou4629 im aware she is willing to spend money on what she loves. Thats why I said maybe she enjoys it but not worth the price to her. That it was a fine product, but not one she cares to spend the money on. That varies for all of us based on budget, needs of our skin and if there are other products we prefer more.
I know it says paid review but this video in comparison to all of her other videos just felt like a paid review even though it says that.
The fact that there’s no study showing pitera works for your skin & the only study which exists are from P&G scientists which owns Sk2. this point wasn’t brought up which I thought was very important to highlight.
All of this aside products like this one, Estée Lauder ANR which I splurge on every time have stood the test of time since some of us were even born & companies like this can afford to charge us at this price point because they sell like crazy & that is an undeniable fact. Dupes will be dupes better use product that will suit your skin needs than copycat products. If you cannot afford sk2 just don’t use it. The ordinary vitamin c & arbutin will do a better job of brightening your skin than these dupes.
Apologies for the long one but this review did not feel like it was her reviewing the product but she has the right to rake in that sk2 mullah.
I was giving this as a gift a year ago. I liked it. I didn't feel it added or took anything away from my skincare. Sometimes using a moisturizer after, my product would pill. If someone gave it to me again, I would use it, but I feel my money is better spent on actives and treatments.
I tried out the Facial Treatment Essence for two reasons: this video from Dr. Idriss (whom I trust 10000%) and my wedding was coming up and I felt like splurging on my skin prep for it :) I used the product once every night for two months, all over my face and neck until my wedding came and went...and saw no noticeable difference in my skin or its texture, which was a bummer. Obviously, some people love and swear by this product and that's awesome, but for me it was definitely not worth it.
Yes! The video I was waiting for! Thank you for the deep dive. I've been considering getting this so your video is helpful in making a decision. 😊
Ooooh Dr Shereene trying an essence and on top the gold standard one 😂😍
Can you talk about if the Missha,/Time Revolution, First Treatment Essence Rx is a good dupe? Their description is "Contains yeast ferment extract specialized in skin protection and Hot & Cold Double Fermentation Process maintains a healthy balance of your skin". I know the sk2 one has their own proprietary blend, but it resembles the missha one.
Yes! I want to know also!
She was payed to promote this on Instagram so go for the dupes they will work just as good don’t worry
@@run4508 ya know...just bc she was 'paid to promote' SKII (your wording, not mine)...does not AT ALL mean that dupes of this product are 'just as good' as SKII. Maybe they are, maybe they aren't, idk. But you are usng irrational 'logic' here - to declare for a fact the dupes are just as good BECAUSE this was a sponsored video.
What kind of 'science' is this?...or even rational thinking...i.e., because of THIS
(factor), it must mean that THAT (factor) is true? WHA???
The two (factors) are completely unrelated!...except in your own mind.
Just sayin...
@@barbarafairbanks4578 the main ingredient in SKII is pitera or galactomyces same as the dupes so yeah it’s not the exact same but you’ll get the same results , paid promotion is not a problem at all she is promoting something she believes in but not everyone can afford it
Just saying
This is why I mostly listen to dr. Dray first and foremost, and the others for entertainment.
The one where Dr Idress does an infomercial.
Maybe it’s because I had terrible skin in my teen years but now at 31 skincare is the one area of my life I will spare no expense. Monthly facials, Derm appointments, preventative care, the best of the best. I can attest SK-II is totally worth the money (but obviously don’t go into debt over it)! Their masks are the BEST - and if you want to save them just use before a big event (after a test patch of course).
SKII is great! I'm 32 and live in Singapore, a humid country, and this really helped with my pores. This is means it overall smoothens out my skin. Doesn't seem to have an effect on evening out pigmentation but i only used it for 6 mths. I evenly stopped using it because i have very sensitive skin and have eczema on certain small areas of my cheek. When my skin is more sensitive than usual, this tends to cause some itch (i think mild irritation) my those eczema prone areas.
oh no...I was expecting Dr. Shereene to put Sk2 on blast but turns out it was a sponsored video!!!...
I think SK2 is unnecessary and extravagant, both as a product and as a brand
Thanks so much for this video. I have been curious about this product FOR YEARS. Just to make sure I understood correctly, it goes on in the morning before the CE Ferulic and at night after the glycolic acid? Thanks so much again!
Thank you for your honest thoughts on this. I've been waiting for this after seeing your post in Instagram. It's good to know this actually lives up to it's hype!!!
Hey Dr. Shereene, I would really love if you would do a video on eye wrinkles, how to improve their look.
I love your range. One week you talk about $9 Vanicream cleanser and the next it's a $100 essence! While this type of product isn't for me, I appreciate the variety of products that you review or dive into! It's always so well done and informative :)
I’ve tried an entire bottle of the SK II Essence, but I still prefer the Neogen Real Ferment Micro Essence. Glad I tried it though.
Am using the Neogen right now but not sure what the benefits are as of yet. How did you get on with it?
@@humamumtaz2719 I also don’t use cotton pad, I simply pad it on my skin after cleansing while my skin is still damp. Neogen is hydrating & brightening. I have tried other essences before such as SK II, Missha Time Revolution The First Treatment Essence, Primera Miracle Seed Essence, Innisfree Soybean Energy Essence…etc. But I keep circling back to Neogen.
Have you tried the secret key rose edition essence?
@@tnadg9521 🤣...she's tried at least SIX different fermented essences, and you found the ONE essence she didn't mention🤔 (I am astounded at how astute and well educated on skincare DR. Idriss's subs are! I'm learning a whole encyclopedia's worth of skincare gems here just by reading the comments section!
You guys are amazing😃
@@humamumtaz2719 Neogene did absolutely nothing for me. It's just like a regular hydrating toner, nothing special...
I’ve used this product for years. Even in my 20’s, I felt like it soothed my skin and calmed my breakouts. When I had too much sun, it just helped to feel more soothed. In my 30’s if I’m stressed, it shows up on my face and SKII helps it feel more plump and hydrated. I will always keep this in my routine but I only buy it during the Sephora 20% events or Costco stocks it 1x/year
Do you know when Costco generally stocks it? Thanks
It’s never consistent but I’ve seen it around September or December. They almost always sell out in under a week
Yes water does the same thing...
This was my first essence and I love it. But because it's too expensive, I use the Cosrx Galactomyces Tone Balancing Essence now. I think my face really love fermented rice extract to help me get more hydration and evening out my skin.
OMG same! The Cosrx Galactomyces95 is the better dupe for this!
Thanks for sharing the great dupe
Do we still need to apply serum after using this skii essence?
MIsha has a " dupe " the First essence... not the same... but also worth while...their formula is reformulated almost every year!!
I also like the missha Artemisia first essence…worth trying!
I have this one as well. I really enjoy using this essence. I have used both and say that they seem very similar when using them.
I really like this one too; have even repurchased. Secret Key had a really good one as well
I’ve tried both and actually prefer the Missha one. It’s so good!
@@jenniferstratton7880 thanks for that! I'll have to put that on my list as I really like the Secret Key - I'm excited 😊
Do you think you'll continue using it? Did you use it at night before retinol or Glycolic Acid? Or in the morning before serum?
Another great video. Ive always passed it up because of the price, but i may try it. I would also love to hear your thoughts about red light therapy! Thanks!
I used an entire bottle, and it did nothing. Now the Fresh Kombucha Essence is the truth!
I LOVE the Fresh Kombucha Essence. I'm on like my 5th bottle it's so good.
Yes 👍🏼 it’s soooo good.
That is TRU!
The main fermented ingredient can also be found in Numbuzin no.3 toner essence.😉 And it’s far more cheaper 😛
I have been using Numbuzin essence toner and the No. 3 serum, and so far, my skin has been LOVING it so far. Missha’s Time Revolution is also great.
@@filomiir87 I definitely testify to Missha's, my skin loved it and ppl even noticed it!
Thanks for sharing the dupe
Thank you very much Dr, Shereene it’s always a pleasure to listen to you.
Your way of speaking clearly and calmly allows those who do not have English as their mother tongue to clearly understand your content.
You're charming.
Now that their patent expired From Nature makes a 95.7 % galaxtamyte essence.
So does Missha I think. I have the Age Intensive Ttratment Essence and it's just like SK 11
Also Cosrx and Iunik have very similar products in essence and serums! It seems that It is the star ingredient in Asia right now!
The Age essence and secret key rose edition essence are for me the only ones that gave me that "glow" , they are comparable or better than SKII
The larger sizes of SK II essence 11.5oz does come in a plastic bottle and with a pump!
Dr Shereene, do u think why they use glass bottle could have been the fact that galactomyces may interact with plastic? IDK and although bottle most often not recycled, will it not become sand after all once broken into pieces. Just my thoughts. Thank you for sharing 💐
It comes in plastic as well. The one I got in the airport was plastic.
I have been using SK II since 2015 when i moved to Asia.it does wonders to my skin - helps with acne, dehydration and fine lines. When i dont use it, i can tell almost immediately. I know is $$ but i dont have to use additional products besides my 6-1 IT foundation, so it helped me save $$$. I use a mist but keep it close to my face to avoid waste. A bottle lasts me 2 months actually, and i usually buy when they have a special offer. I am so happy you liked it Doc.
I have used it and it burns my face causing me small bumps all over my face! Skincare is not magic, let alone its difinitely for all skin formular just sayin
ppl don't have many to buy $ 100 cosmetic product each two month 🙄 ofcourse, if someone hazs money and wants to spend it for cosmetic product - go ahead. but it's not a miracle ;) and if yes, everybody with cystic acne and other skin problems would buy it instead of tretinoin
Costco has this SK II Facial Essence in a pump 11 oz. for a great price. Just for you! Thank you for all your great information - You are real and so much FUN! Other reviewers have stated the same outcome for this essence - the "Dupes" may have the same ingredients but not the same quality.
Like driving a FORD or a BMW. Both are a car -one is more economical one is luxury! Costco makes this luxury a great deal.
Ok. If you’re using a retinol which is applied first. This essence or the retinol? Or does this negate the need for a retinol?
what about the dupe's like secret key that contain the exact same ingredients including galactomyces? what sets this apart?
This is a ridiculous price point. Could you please review The Ordinary brand, making routines for mature skin (using the Ascorbic Acid 8% + Alpha Arbutin? Thanks.
The best dupes that I found for this are the From Nature Age Essence and the Purito Galacto Niacin 97 Power Essence! Both have more Galactomyces filtrate and have the similar light watery texture ❤️
Great. I know this comment is two years old but I picked up the from nature one at Marshall’s for 7.99 and now looking at videos to see if it’s even good, if I should use or return before I open so your comment helped me a lot in deciding to try it.
Missha time revolution and secret key also have great dupes!
This product is irreplaceable for me. Actually the facial treatment cleanser, clear lotion and essence all are. People always say, omg it's so expensive you can get a much cheaper option but I'm convinced the people saying that are the people who have never even used the SK-II essence or haven't used it long term because no other "dupe" produces the same results and I've tried many.
I am interested in this but the price tag scares me. Would you mind sharing the changes you saw on your skin??
@@anamikaaudra2868 I’ve bought the full size one and I love how bright my skin looks after but I also got the same effect from cosrx and missha essences. My conclusion is its the cumulative effects of all my skincare not the 1 individual product.
I agree! I have been using the essence for over 10 years and I gotta say, it works. I've tried cheaper k-beauty (Missha, Cos-RX) dupes over the years but nothing compares. It's my one skincare splurge. Yeah, it's expensive, but not La Mer level expensive and there's actual science behind it. It's so much cheaper than needing injectables!
Right
I started with sk ii facial treatment essence. Amazing result (brown asian prone to hyperpigmentation and melasma). I was convinced to try the dupes. So far I tried 2 dupes - cosrx and time revolutions. I have higher irritation (redness) with the dupes so hard to see any result when your skin is reacting. I am now back to the real stuff - sk ii
Would LOVE to see a deep dive on NuFace or Ziip technology!!! I have no idea in between what steps I should incorporate it into my routine (especially since the gel has has hyaluronic acid in it - like should I wash it off afterwards?!?!) Thank you and can't wait to see your own line!!
You slapped the hell out of the toner fakeness a few video's back and now it's like: "blah blah my skin feel luminescent". I mean come on!
We are very happy to hear your review about this hype essence as you always do with popular products. We encourage you to share your expertise.It is always welcome!. We love you,!
This was the biggest waste of money for me. No benefits or improvement. Happy if it works for others. But, I’ve used other, more affordable and effective, essences.
Me too! I love the Neogen real ferment micro essence :)
Same here
I always wanted to ask about the best way to apply skin products, some recommend a massage to increase blood flow and absorption and other just to tap lightly, your thoughts??
Thanks for reviewing this product!! As a Japanese, I was always curious about this product with the most beautiful celebrities had done the commercials for decades, at it was always onf TV!! Considering the cost of living, the price doesn't seem overly expensive in Australia, but if you lived and worked in Japan, this was definitely an extremely high-end product that normal company workers in their 20s wouldn't be able to afford and sustain. Now I'm reaching 40, I might be able to try it considering how potent it seems as you described. Thanks again!!
Thanks for the video! Would you use this before a niacinamide serum in the morning as well? And after a retinoid at night?
well the reason why we always love essences 😍
Would like a comparison on major essences out there and what to look for in one.
I love this product, been using it for years on and off. I got a big bottle back then and it came with a pump, the best. 👌 do you know how long of shelf life does this product has?
Love it too. I believe the shelf life is 3 years.
Hi doctor Shereene! Thank you for your videos, you're always very informative, funny and witty! I'm a medical student in Italy, but I am no expert in dermatology. I was wondering if you have any tips for pregnant women and stretch marks, did you experience any and if so, how did you treat them? what can we do to avoid them? Is there any prescription cream that we can use to avoid them? Also, what can I use instead of retinoids on the face during pregnancy? thank you!
She has an entire video on CZcams that includes all products safe for pregnancy! Hope this helps
Dr. Idriss, how would you layer this with other actives in the skincare routine? Would you use it before or after applying vitamin C serum? Or is it better to use at night, before applying retinol? Also, I am curious about the SK-II LXP Ultimate Revival Cream. It supposedly has a really high concentration of Pitera, as well, but b/c it’s a moisturizer, when would that be applied?
Can i use this in conjunction with CE Ferulic? Can I use it around the eyes?
These are the questions that are never answered!
I love your content Dr.! What's your opinion on copper peptides for the skin??
I buy the giant bottle. That comes with the pump. At Costco.
It’s worth every penny. I love the delivery of the pump. The giant bottle is in my humble opinion. The way to go.
Thank you for doing such a deep dive. Into my favorite essence.
How long does it last?
If fermentation helps in the case of this product, is that the same situation with fermented rice water?
Hii Shereene why do use camera filters? Wanna see your real skin. With filters it looks perfect which is misleading.
Very interesting - THX. I think adding a pump or anything else will add to the material needing to be disposed of in the environment. I use some products with little plastic stoppers like this and they work for me. I do shake the product out on my closed fingers and tap it on my face rather than my palm so I use less product.
Can i use together with retinol / retinal on night ?
I totally agree! I definitely prefer applying toners and essences directly to my skin with my 👋
Do any of the ingredients help keep skin clear? What about causing breakouts?
This has helped me a lot. And I've only used it for the last couple months
Do you know how this compares to the tatcha essence?
THANKS for another great deep-dive! QUESTION - How to fit this SK-II into my AM Routine without it getting "canceled" out by other products?? Current AM: (1) CeraVe Hydrating Cleanser (2) BR LOTION P50-1970 - to prep skin for better absorption of (3) SkinCeuticals Vitamin C E Ferulic (4) SKIN1004 Hyalu-CICA Blue Serum (5) Sunscreen (brand varies). Or should I just use the SK-II at night after my double cleanse, but before my night serum? TIA!!!😅🙏
Could you please do a comparison of this and the missha galactomyces ferment essence? The missha seems similar but much more affordable!
You can use the essence before the tetrinoina at night? If so... Better after or before....
korean brand have cheaper dupes
Expensive skincare have like that in South Korean brand like Sulwhasoo
@@visualbeauty3427 yes but cheap brands have better ingredients. highly recommend etude house, innisfree, be plain, round lab, nature republic, zeroid, illiyoon, isntree, goodal, etc
Hi Dr, thanks for posting the video! I have a question, can I use Skinceutical CE ferulic along with SK2? If yes, in what order?
There is the neogen micro ferment essence as well and they have a serum to go with it and it's cheaper
Doesn't do anything, go for secret key rose edition instead you will notice a difference
Thank you for this review. I love this essence. Of course, there are more cheaper brands are also not bad. But, still the overall performance is different. There is nothing wrong about cheaper brands. Just like there is difference between a Ph.D and a high school diploma. Anything wrong about a high school diploma? Of course No!! But, there are still some difference. Thank you again. You are one of my favorite doctors. 👍
the 11oz version comes in a plastic container with pump delivery. i always buy the largest one when i travel at duty free (and i think skii may be cheaper is asia)
What AHA /BHA are you using. Tia
It has been one of those products that your skin will miss when you take a break from it. Undoubtably a great product. After hearing about your conversation with the brand’s chemist and your explanation of what the ingredients do, I feel a tiny bit less guilty spending the money. Just a tiny tiny bit… so expensive.. 😭
true
And there it is. Every good channel turns into an ad and cash channel by the video saying "you know that thing I never liked? Well they gave me free stuff and money so.....I LOVE that thing now!"
Exactly!! Thank you!!!
R8versong86 - unfortunately, your cancel culture reaction to a sponsored product review is unfair & unreasonable, IMO. You've decided because of 'this', 'this' and 'this', it MUST MEAN - THAT!
( i.e., that, given this is a sponsored review, Dr. Idriss must be lying about her experience with this product, for the sole purpose of selling it? Really?...you know how her mind works?
You can't fathom that Dr. Idriss, with all the integrity she's demonstrated, over time, in past videos- might just be giving an honest review of a product she's tried for 30 days?
It never ceases to amaze me how so many people in comments sections in this and other SM sites, think they have crystal ball insight to someone else's thought processes.
In truth, when someone declares, "I have figured out WHY you are doing, or saying this or that!'...they only have access to their OWN thought processes & agenda, no one else's. Their projections of their own thought processes onto someone else - whom they believe they have all figured out - only gives us a glimpse into their own thinking and what makes THEM tick, not anyone else.
😿 🎻